Yucca fern shaped CuO nanowires on Cu foam for remitting capacity fading of Li-ion battery anodes

To remit capacity fading of lithium ion battery (LIB) anodes, freestanding yucca fern shaped CuO nanowires (NWs) on Cu foams are fabricated as anodes by combining facile and scalable anodization of copper foams followed by calcination. The porous and radial configuration of the hierarchical CuO NWs on the Cu foam substrate guarantees the remarkably improved electrochemical performance with durable cycle stability and excellent rate capability compared with CuO NWs on Cu foils. The reversible capacity remains 461.5 mAh/g after 100 repeated cycles at a current density of 100 mA/g, and a capacity of 150.6 mAh/g even at a high rate of 1000 mA/g. By examining the surface morphology of the cycled samples, possible performance fading route is proposed. The 3D CuO NWs network with a porous architecture simutaneously reduces the ion diffusion distances, promotes the electrolyte permeation and electronic conductivity. This novel strategy might open a new window to develop durable CuO based composite anodes for LIBs.


Results
The typical preparation process of the 3D hierarchical porous CuO NWs on Cu foam is displayed in Fig. 1. The Cu(OH) 2 NWs clusters were first obtained through the electrochemical anodization of Cu foam in an alkaline aqueous solution. The Cu atoms at the surface were oxidized to Cu 2+ ions and immediately reacted with OH − from the alkaline solution to form Cu(OH) 2 and deposited on the surface. The thickness and morphology can be tuned by the optimizing electrolyte concentration, current density, reaction temperature and time 20,21 . During calcination, the dehydration reaction of Cu(OH) 2 NWs occurs at high temperature. Plenty of vacancies and pores were generated at dehydration sites of Cu(OH) 2 . As a result, CuO NWs with porous structure are finally obtained. The digital photographs of the bare Cu foam, anodized foam and heat treated sample are shown in Fig. S1. The red copper foam changed to navy blue after anodization and then to brownish black after calcination, which are corresponding to the formation of Cu(OH) 2 and CuO on the Cu foam substrates.
The surface morphology of the bare Cu foam and the as-obtained CuO NWs@Cu foam was characterized by SEM and TEM. As the substrate, Cu foam was first characterized by SEM as shown in Fig. 2a. A smooth surface and 3D interconnected network with 50-80 micrometers ligament size and 200-500 micrometers pore size has been confirmed. After the anodization and calcination, uniform CuO NWs with a high density have been fabricated as displayed in Fig. 2b. A higher magnification image of CuO in Fig. 2c shows that tens of CuO NWs construct a yucca fern shaped cluster, which induce a micron-sized porous superficial structure on Cu foam. The diameter of a single CuO wire is about 310 nm as shown in Fig. 3a. A further testing of Fig. 3b and c reveals a porous feature of the CuO NWs. The pore size ranges from 2 to 10 nm. Figure 3d presents a high resolution TEM image of a CuO nanowire. The measured lattice spacing is 0.251 nm, which corresponds to the (−111) lattice plane of monoclinic CuO 22 . The SAED pattern in Fig. 3e demonstrates that the CuO NWs are highly crystalline. Finally, a 3D hierarchical porous CuO structure, containing Cu foam framework in a few hundred micrometer scale, CuO wire cluster in a micron-size scale, as well as CuO NWs with mesopores and micropores, has been achieved.
The above 3D yucca fern shaped CuO structure is deliberately designed for remitting volume expansion during lithiation/delithiation process, but it is not easy to obtain. Although anodization is not a new technology to fabricate nanowires 21 , it is firstly reported in this study that such method can be used in the preparation of radial CuO nanowires in strict technological conditions. Figure S2 presents superficial morphologies of CuO@Cu foam anodes in different processing variables. It was found that electrolyte concentration and anodization time only change the size of the obtained nanowires, while temperature and current density are more likely to control the morphologies of the anodized products. By controlling a moderate growth and leaving proper room among adjacent nanowires, yucca fern shaped CuO structure with plentiful interspaces was obtained successfully.
The crystal structure of CuO was further investigated by XRD as shown in Fig. 4a. The main diffraction peaks located at 43.3° and 50.4° can be indexed to the (111) Fig. S3. These results indicate that the CuO, without any other impurities, has been successfully obtained. The porous feature of the 3D hierarchical CuO NWs was studied by N 2 adsorption-desorption measurements as displayed in Fig. 4b. The pore size ranges from 2 to 20 nm in the CuO NWs@Cu foam composites. Meanwhile, there are no obvious nanopores on the Cu foam substrate. The isotherm of the composites also exhibits a broad hysteresis as displayed inset of Fig. 4b, which is also the characteristic of porous structures 23 . The nanopores might greatly improve the electrolyte permeation and provide space for volume expansions during battery cycling. To further gain the surface information on the electronic state of the CuO NWs, the XPS analysis was performed as shown in Fig. 4c and d. For the bare Cu foam, the Cu 2p spectrum presents two sharp peaks located at 932.8 and 952.7 eV which are assigned to Cu 2p 3/2 and Cu 2p 1/2 , respectively. On the other hand, the Cu 2p 3  higher binding energy values are associated to OH groups and to water absorbed onto the surface of the CuO NWs, respectively 24 . For the bare Cu foam, only peaks at 531.7 and 533.5 eV, which may originate from oxygen and moisture in air adsorbed on the Cu foam surface 25 , have been observed. Thus, possible existence of CuO on the Cu foam surface can be ruled out.
The Li ions storage properties of the Cu NWs@Cu foam are carefully evaluated in coin-type cells. The cyclic voltammetry (CV) curves conducted between 0.01 and 3.0 V at a scan rate of 0.1 mV/s are displayed in Fig. 5a. It clearly exhibits that three electrochemical reduction steps accompany the lithiation process. During the first cathodic sweep, a broad but weak peak appears at about 2.1 V which belongs to the initial formation of Li x CuO 26 . Then, two succession reduction peaks are observed at 1.0 V and 0.7 V, which are associated with the further conversion reaction with deep lithiation. A solid electrolyte interphase (SEI) layer formed during the initial discharge process which results in the broaden reduction peaks. During the de-lithiation process, two main peaks at 1.5 V and 2.5 V, and a shoulder peak at 2.7 V can be observed, which corresponds to the oxidation of Cu to Cu 2 O and CuO. In the subsequent CV cycles, the reduction peaks show a positive shift and demonstrate super reproducibility, indicating the improved kinetics and good reversibility.
The representative galvanostatic discharge/charge curves of the as-fabricated CuO NWs@Cu foam anode are shown in Fig. 5b. There are three plateaus during the initial discharge process, which mainly involve the continuous formation of LiCu x O and Cu 2 O phase, as well as the completely conversion to Li 2 O and Cu, respectively 17 . It is also consistent with the results of CV curves. The first discharge and charge capacities are 996.2 and 719.3 mAh/g, which gives the initial Coulombic efficiency of 72.2%. The irreversible discharge capacity is associated with the formation of SEI layer. Two charging plateaus at 2.3 V and 2.6 V are observed during the first charging process. In the subsequent cycles, it shows well cycling reversibility and almost similar discharge/charge capacities at the same cycle. The calculated Coulombic efficiency remains 99.57% last to 100 cycles (Fig. 6a), which indicates the super reversibility. As shown in Fig. 6a, the cycle performance of CuO NWs@Cu foam and CuO NWs@Cu foil substrates were carefully compared. The CuO NWs@Cu foam electrode displayed good cyclic stability and a discharge capacity of 461.5 mAh/g even at the 100th cycle. In contrast, the CuO NWs@Cu foil electrode gave similar capacities during the initial 10 cycles. However, there is a gradually capacity fading in the following cycles. The capacity retention is only 19.5% at the 100th cycle for the CuO NWs@Cu foil. This comparison results indicate that the 3D structure can be better accommodation for the electrode volume expansions during discharge/charge cycles. The rate capability of the CuO NWs@Cu foam was further investigated at varied current densities (Fig. 6b). The first charge capacities are 792.6, 678.7, 532.2, 315.5 and 150.6 mAh/g at the current densities of 50, 100, 200, 500 and 1000 mA/g, respectively. There are two reasons for the excellent rate performance: firstly, the 3D structure features improve the electrolyte permeation and accommodate the volume expansion; secondly, the Cu foam substrate and the Cu components at the final discharge state obviously enhance the conductivity of the electrode composite. When the current density returned back to 50 mA/g, 77.9% of the initial charge capacity was regained. The slight performance fading was due to the formation of stable SEI interface layers. In order to clearly evaluate the performance of CuO NWs@Cu foam electrode, a detailed comparison between the present electrode and the reported CuO electrodes based on different synthesis methods and structures is shown in Table 1 15,17,25,[27][28][29][30][31][32] . The superiority of the freestanding hierarchical porous structure of the present electrode, which guaranteed excellent electrochemical properties, can be seen from the table.
To further understand the performance improvement from the Cu foil to the 3D Cu foam substrates, the electrode morphologies after discharge/charge 110 cycles were investigated by SEM as depicted in Fig. 7. The cycled samples were first disassembled in Ar-filled glove box and washed by electrolyte-free solvent. The surface of the CuO nanowires were coated by a solid layer and the surface became rough for both of the samples. This rough layer is mainly originated from the decomposition of the electrolyte during the initial discharge cycles. Obviously, some of the thick wires intertwined and merged together to form squid-shaped lumps, which resulted in the performance fading. It is much severe with a Cu foil substrate because of the inter-cross original architectural feature of the CuO NWs as shown in Fig. S4. It is nice to see that the 3D foam architecture and the yucca fern shaped CuO cluster alleviated this fading tendency and the morphology maintained better, although the nanowire seems to be expanded to some extents. The expansion is due to the unavoidable volume change of transition metal oxides during lithiation/delithiation process as well as the protective effects of stable SEI films. The nanowire grows up a little at every repeated cycle so that it cannot recover to its initial state. The accumulative effect of 110 repeated cycles finally leads to this clear expansion. A further observation on the macro-photograph of CuO NWs@Cu foam anode before and after 110 cycles is shown in Fig. S5. It revealed that there is a good binding force between CuO active material and the Cu foam substrate. Barely cracking-off problem is observed for the CuO NWs@Cu foam anode. These results are consistent with the electrochemical performance.
The internal resistance evolutions of the two samples with different Cu current collectors were also analyzed by electrochemical impedance spectrum (EIS). As shown in Fig. S6, the Nyquist plots are composed of a semicircle followed slope lines, which correspond to the charge-transfer resistance and the Warburg behaviors. It can be seen that two kinds of fresh electrodes exhibit almost the similar resistance (Fig. S6a). After 110 repeated cycles (Fig. S6b), both the resistance reduces to a certain extent as compared to the fresh ones. It can be found obviously that after cycles, the resistance of the electrode with Cu foam current collector is much lower than that of electrode with Cu foil current collector. The 3D Cu foam substrate dramatically reduced the resistance, which indicates the better electrochemical kinetics of the Cu NWs@Cu foam than that of CuO NWs@Cu foil.

Discussion
Formation mechanism of Yucca fern shaped CuO. The structure of CuO was mainly inherited from Yucca fern structural Cu(OH) 2 framework. So, the study on the formation mechanism of the Yucca fern shaped CuO is indeed an investigation on how Cu(OH) 2 framework created.
Every Yucca fern structural Cu(OH) 2 cluster is comprised by tens of nanowires. The microscopic formation mechanism of the nanowire is analyzed as follows. The nucleus shape of monoclinic Cu(OH) 2 crystal is usually a rod-like structure containing a tip. Under a moderate anodizing condition, most of Cu ions were transported to tips, resulting in a quick growth of crystals in vertical direction. Only a small part of crystals grow in diameter direction at the same time, so that the growth rate of crystals in vertical direction obviously higher than that in diameter direction. As a result, it is easy to form a wire-like structure under current conditions. If the experimental conditions are changed, the growth rate of crystals in different growth directions may change too. On this occasion, Cu(OH) 2 crystals with possible shape of nanoplate and nanosphere instead of nanowire may be generated.
The macroscopic formation mechanism of Yucca fern structural Cu(OH) 2 is analyzed as follows. Under suitable anodizing conditions, partial Cu atoms at the Cu foam surface were oxidized to Cu 2+ ions and immediately reacted with OH − from the alkaline solution to form Cu(OH) 2 crystals and deposited on the surface of Cu foam. With the increase of the anodizing time, Cu(OH) 2 kept growing in the solution and formed short nanorods. Cu(OH) 2 nanowires were then generated by further growing of these nanorods. Controlling the number of nucleation sites through adjusting anodizing parameters, Cu(OH) 2 nanowires were designed to nucleate and grow only at limited sites. Generally, a nucleation site develops into more than one nanowire. Similar to the human hair follicles, one nucleation site is easy to grow into a cluster of radial nanowires, which is named Yucca fern structural nanowires in this study. It needs to be emphasized that the anodizing parameters have an important influence on the formation of Yucca fern structural nanowires. Other morphologies of Cu(OH) 2 such as nanoplates, nanowire arrays instead of Yucca fern shape may be prepared by adopting improper experimental conditions. Importance of Yucca fern structure. The hierarchical CuO NWs with Yucca fern structure contains many advantages. Firstly, the 3D structure features can improve the electrolyte permeation and accommodate the volume expansion, which guarantee a good cycling stability. Secondly, the Cu foam substrate and the Cu components at the final discharge state greatly enhance the conductivity of the electrode composite, resulting in a good rate property. Based on the results of this work, the relatively stable Yucca fern structure before and after cycling is the key to maintain capacity stability, indicating the significance of this structure in restraining the capacity fading. In addition, in terms of preparation technology, the anodizing is a simple and rapid process to prepare low-cost anodes, which may facilitate the assembly line production.  If the structure cannot be remained, there must be a clear capacity fading. After 110 repeated cycles, a small part of nanowires had merged together and transformed into squid shape. So, we cannot rule out the possibility of a capacity fading even by utilizing the as-obtained Yucca fern structure during next hundreds of cycles. Anyway, the material has shown excellent performances compared to the existing reports (Table 1). In future work, graphene and other carbon materials were planned to coat on the surface of Yucca fern structural CuO for improving the long-term stability in both the structure and capacity.

Conclusions
In summary, a facile and scalable approach for the fabrication of freestanding 3D yucca fern shaped CuO nanowires with hierarchical porous structure has been introduced. The possible Cu source and substrates have been investigated. The obtained CuO NWs@Cu foam electrode demonstrated superior electrochemical properties, including stable cycle performance (461.5 mAh/g after 100 cycles) and high rate capability (150.6 mAh/g at current density of 1000 mA/g). The outstanding electrochemical could be attributed to hierarchical porous structured nanowires combined a 3D foam substrate. This unique structure feature guaranteed this Cu NWs@Cu foam a promising anode with a high performance for lithium ion batteries. In addition, the simple fabrication process involving mature anodization technology boosts prospects for scalable production.

Materials preparation.
The bare Cu foam with thickness of 0.8 mm was purchased from Kunshan Jiayisheng Electronics Co. Ltd., China. The anodization was carried out by DC Power Supply (TPR-12010D). Cu foam (2.0 cm × 4.0 cm) was successively washed with acetone, ethanol, 0.5 M HCl, and deionized water for 10 min under ultrasonic condition to remove organic contaminants and an oxide layer on surface. And then it was dried using a stream of a compressed air and before using as the working electrode. Another piece of Cu foam with a same size was selected as the counter electrode. The electrolyte was 1.0 M KOH solution, which was deaerated by bubbling with dry argon for at least 20 min before experimentation. The Cu foam was electrochemically anodized at a constant current density of 10 mA cm −2 with a typical reaction time of 10 min to form Cu(OH) 2 NWs. A thermostat was used to control cell temperature at 20 ± 1 °C. After anodization, samples were rinsed twice with deionized water and then carried out a calcination treatment. The calcination temperature was maintained at 185 ± 2 °C for 1.5 h to converted Cu(OH) 2 to CuO. Finally, a binder free CuO NWs@Cu foam anode was obtained. The total weight of an anode is about 55 mg, in which the weight of active materials is about 6 mg. A CuO NWs@Cu foil anode was also obtained through a same process for comparison. All the chemicals were of analytical grade and used as purchased without further purification.

Materials characterization.
The morphologies of the as-prepared CuO NWs and Cu substrates were observed by scanning electron microscopy (SEM, Nova nanoSEM 450, FEI) equipped with an X-ray energy dispersive spectroscope (EDS) and transmission electron microscopy (JEM-2100F, JEOL). X-ray diffraction (XRD) patterns were obtained using an X-ray diffractometer (D/Max-2500, Rigaku) with Cu K α radiation to confirm crystalline structures. X-ray photoelectron spectroscopy (XPS, Thermo Fisher Scientific) was employed to determine the chemical composition and valence state of the anodized products. Nitrogen adsorption/desorption isotherms were measured at 77.2 K with a physisorption analyzer (Micromeritics ASAP 2020). The specific surface area was calculated using the Brunauer-Emmett-Teller (BET) method. The pore size distribution was obtained by the Barrett-Joyner-Halenda (BJH) method.
Electrochemical testing. Electrochemical performances were examined using coin cells (CR2032) assembled in an argon-filled glove box. The cell was consisted of CuO NWs@Cu foam as a working electrode and Li foil as both counter and reference electrode. The electrodes were separated by a Celgard 2400 separator. The electrolyte is composed of a solution of 1 M LiPF 6 in a mixture of ethylene carbonate (EC)/dimethyl carbonate (DMC) (1:1, v/v) (Shanghai Xiaoyuan Energy Technology Ltd., China). The cyclic voltammetry (CV) test was carried out on an electrochemical workstation (CHI660B, China) from 0.01 to 3V. Electrochemical impedance spectroscopy