Interface-induced spin Hall magnetoresistance enhancement in Pt-based tri-layer structure

In this study, we integrated bilayer structure of covered Pt on nickel zinc ferrite (NZFO) and CoFe/Pt/NZFO tri-layer structure by pulsed laser deposition system for a spin Hall magnetoresistance (SMR) study. In the bilayer structure, the angular-dependent magnetoresistance (MR) results indicate that Pt/NZFO has a well-defined SMR behavior. Moreover, the spin Hall angle and the spin diffusion length, which were 0.0648 and 1.31 nm, respectively, can be fitted by changing the Pt thickness in the longitudinal SMR function. Particularly, the MR ratio of the bilayer structure (Pt/NZFO) has the highest changing ratio (about 0.135%), compared to the prototype structure Pt/Y3Fe5O12 (YIG) because the NZFO has higher magnetization. Meanwhile, the tri-layer samples (CoFe/Pt/NZFO) indicate that the MR behavior is related with CoFe thickness as revealed in angular-dependent MR measurement. Additionally, comparison between the tri-layer structure with Pt/NZFO and CoFe/Pt bilayer systems suggests that the SMR ratio can be enhanced by more than 70%, indicating that additional spin current should be injected into Pt layer.

FMI in the bilayer structure. Their results show that the SMR ratio of HM/FM bilayer structure is one order of magnitude higher than the HM/FMI bilayer [32][33][34] . These results have highly increased the application possibility of the SMR-related effect in spintronics. However, the main studies of the SMR behavior focus on the bilayer structure, particularly in the FMI/HM structure, while the SMR behavior itself is generated from the interface of the FM layer and HM. In general, increasing the number of interfaces may increase the total SMR ratios. However, very few studies 35 report on the SMR behavior of tri-layer or multilayer structures. Therefore, tri-layer structure behaviors are an essential topic of research for SMR-related studies.
In this study, we systemically investigate the SMR behaviors with bilayer and trilayer structures. The work is organized as follows: first, we grew Ni 0.3 Zn 0.7 Fe 2 O 4 (NZFO) on C-sapphire and identified their structure and magnetism behavior-NZFO is one of the ideal candidate for SMR studies due to its great insulation and high magnetization; after that, we grew Pt on NZFO because Pt is the most widely used material for generating SHE and ISHE due to its high spin orbit interaction. The field and angular-dependent MR results can help us to obtain the spin Hall angle and spin diffusion length by fitting the longitudinal SMR function in FMI/HM system. Furthermore, we grow another ferromagnetic layer CoFe on Pt/NZFO to build a tri-layer structure, which we compared with the Pt/NZFO and CoFe/Pt bilayer structure. The comparison results show that the SMR ratio of the tri-layer structure is higher than the Pt/NZFO and CoFe/Pt bilayer structures and is increased by more than 70%.

Results and Discussion
XRD patterns of NZFO and Pt illustrated a clean (111) orientation without any second phase, and the pattern of Pt/NZFO bilayer structure revealed that the sample had ideal layer structure condition, as shown in Fig. 2 Fig. 2(c),(e) show the RHEED patterns of single NZFO layer and Pt growth on NZFO layer, respectively. The patterns indicate that the NZFO and Pt growth on NZFO have smooth and ideal surface condition, which is also confirmed by the AFM result, and the surface roughness is 0.4 nm and 0.2 nm, as shown in Fig. 2(d),(f), respectively. The structure analysis results indicate that the PLD growth bilayer samples ensure high quality structure with smooth surface and appropriate structure for the SMR behaviors research.
After structure analysis, the magnetic-field-dependent longitudinal resistance (R xx ) of Pt/NZFO bilayer sample with 3-nm Pt thickness was measured, as shown in Fig. 3(b). The result showed that the bilayer samples had an MR-like behavior at H x and H y direction. Compared to NZFO in-plane hysteresis loop, as shown in Fig. 3(a), the coercive field of NZFO also matched with the observed MR. This suggests that the MR signal of the bilayer samples resulted from the interaction between NZFO and Pt. On the other hand, angular-dependent MR measurement can help identify the MR mechanism that results from SMR or anisotropic magnetoresistance (AMR). Therefore, in the Pt/NZFO bilayer structure, we elaborated three different rotation angles of longitudinal resistance, as shown in Fig. 3(d). The schematic diagrams of the different rotation angles, α, β, and γ, are also illustrated in Fig. 3(c), representing rotation in the x-y, y-z and x-z plane, respectively. The difference between the SMR and the AMR behaviors was revealed in angular-dependent MR results. For the AMR behavior, the resistance depends on the angle between the charge current and the magnetization direction (ρ . The MR curves of angles α and β were functions of θ cos 2 , while the angle γ was nearly constant. In addition, the marked purple line intersected with three MR curves, representing R x , R z , and R y for different rotation angles α, γ, and β, respectively, where R i (i = x, y and z) is the resistance measured with external magnetic fields. A clear SMR behavior was observed (R x ≈ R z > R y ), which differed from the AMR behavior (R x > R z ≈ R y ) 21,24 . As a result, the angular-dependent MR results revealed that the SMR behavior clearly dominated in the Pt/NZFO bilayer structure.
After that, the SMR change ratios of the Pt/NZFO bilayer structure were plotted as a function of Pt thickness from 0 nm to 6 nm, as shown in Fig. 4. Moreover, the red line in Fig. 4 is the fitting curve obtained by the longitudinal SMR function 21,22 as where ρ,σ,λ and d N represent the resistivity, conductivity, spin diffusion length, and thickness of the HM layer, respectively. G r is interface spin-mixing conductance, which is about 1.2×10 18 m −2 by ferromagnetic resonance (FMR). Moreover, θ SH (spin Hall angle) and λ pt (spin diffusion length) are the fitting parameters. The theoretical fitting results well matched the experimental data points, and the fitting result provided values for θ SH and λ pt as 0.0648 and 1.31 nm, respectively. Compared with literature, our calculations for θ SH and λ pt are in reasonable ranges. Particularly, the MR ratio of the bilayer structure (Pt = 3.04 nm /NZFO) had the highest changing ratio of about 0.135% and much higher than the Pt/YIG system in literature 27,28,36,37 , which is due to significant saturation magnetization of NZFO.
In the above studies, the Pt/NZFO bilayer structure samples exhibited typical SMR behavior with high performance change ratio. However, increasing the interfaces number is beneficial for increasing the SMR ratio. Therefore, we present an amorphous magnetic metal layer CoFe to cover our bilayer samples, thus forming a CoFe/Pt/NZFO tri-layer structure. The highest SMR ratio of Pt(3.04 nm)/NZFO bilayer was chosen for the fabrication of tri-layer device. The angular-dependent MR of CoFe/Pt/NZFO and CoFe/Pt is shown in Fig. 5(a) and (c) respectively. The results demonstrate that the SMR behavior dominates in the tri-layer structure, which is also confirmed by the intersection of the purple line (R x ≈ R z > R y ). Interestingly, in the tri-layer structure, the SMR ratio (around 0.72%) was much higher than the ratios of Pt(3 nm)/NZFO and CoFe(3 nm)/Pt(3 nm), which were only 0.135% and 0.259%, respectively. The result indicate that the tri-layer structure can significantly magnify the SMR effect, and also imply that the additional spin current may be injected into Pt layer.
Furthermore, to realize MR behaviors of the tri-layer structure, we prepared a group of tri-layer samples with varying CoFe layer thicknesses. CoFe thickness vs. angular-dependent MR ratios with different rotation angles, α, β, γ, and β + γ, is shown in Fig. 6. First, we observed that the MR ratios of α angle (black triangle) was very similar to the ratios of β+γ angle (green triangle), which represents the satisfied rotation experimental result. Furthermore, the MR ratios of β (blue square) and γ (red circle) were dominated by the SMR and AMR behavior, respectively, as per the abovementioned results of the bilayer structure. Particularly, the results of the γ angle with varying CoFe thickness showed that no AMR behavior arises when the CoFe thickness is below 3 nm; conversely, the AMR behavior arises when the CoFe thickness is above 3 nm. Comparing with literature of the FM/HM bilayer structure 34 , we suggest that the results of γ angle are due to the proportion of CoFe (9.9×10 −5 cm) and Pt (3.2×10 −5 cm) resistivity, where the driving current mostly flows in Pt when the CoFe thickness is below 3 nm. Moreover, the MR ratios of β angle with varying CoFe thickness increase at first, but then decrease with the increase of the CoFe thickness, until a maximum MR ratio is observed at 4 nm CoFe thickness. We suggest the following scenario: when the resistances of CoFe and Pt are significantly different, the electrons are mainly moving with simplified path, which means that the driving current prefer to transmit in low resistance layer, focusing on Pt. In contrast, when the resistances of CoFe and Pt layers are similar, the interface-induced multi-reflective electron should be generated 38 , leading to the injection of the additional spin current in the Pt layer. Therefore, the SMR behavior should arise at an intermediate CoFe thickness. Finally, we summarize the three types of structures (CoFe/PT/NZFO, CoFe/PT and PT/NZFO) of SMR changing ratio (β angle) for different CoFe layer thicknesses, as shown in Fig. 6(b), in which the y-axis is defined as the enhanced SMR ratio   . Spuriously, the result shows that the MR ratio can be enhanced and the highest enhancement SMR ratio is obtained at 3 nm CoFe thickness, which can be enhanced by over 70%. The tendency of enhancement SMR ratio may be correlated with our discussion of the current separation in CoFe and Pt. However, the mechanism of SMR ratio enhancement and the spin injection in tri-layer structure still remains unclear. Therefore, a further investigation of microscopic spin current motion in interface is needed to deeply understand the SMR mechanism. The SMR behavior is a fascinating concept in spintronics and offers exciting insights in related spin transport behavior. Our finding in CoFe/Pt/NZFO tri-layer structure not only significantly enlarge the SMR signal but also systemically study the SMR behavior and related phenomena in multi-layer structure.

Conclusion
We successfully grew three different arrangement samples, Pt/NZFO, CoFe/Pt and CoFe/Pt/NZFO by the PLD system, demonstrating that those films are high quality samples, as confirmed by RHEED, XRD, and AFM. Therefore, we quantitatively investigated the SMR effect in Pt/NZFO, CoFe/Pt and CoFe/Pt/NZFO heterostructures. In the Pt/NZFO bilayer system, we clearly observed a maximum SMR in our samples with a ratio of 0.135% at a Pt thickness of around 3 nm, and we obtained θ sh , λ pt and G r by fitting the longitudinal SMR function. In addition, we also showed that the AMR behavior can be ruled out in this study. Moreover, the tri-layer structure of CoFe/Pt/NZFO efficiently enhanced the SMR ratio, which is much larger than the bilayer system (Both Pt/ NZFO and CoFe/Pt), observing by ADMR measurement.
Experimental Procedures. In this experiment, two sets of heterostructure films, as shown in Fig. 2a (bilayer of Pt/NZFO/Sub. and tri-layer of CoFe/Pt/NZFO/Sub.), were in situ deposited on (0001) C-sapphire substrates by the pulse laser deposition (PLD) technique. The Hall bar shadow mask was used in situ to pattern the samples for transport measurement (the ratio of length and width being 1). The NZFO films were grown at 750 °C with laser energy 2 J/cm 2 . Pt and CoFe were grown at room temperature with different laser energies of 4 J/cm 2 and 3 J/cm 2 , respectively. After deposition, reflection high-energy electron diffraction (RHEED) in situ monitored the quality of the films, and the structural properties were investigated by X-ray diffraction (XRD) and  atomic force microscopy (AFM). The magnetic properties of NZFO were measured by a superconducting quantum interference device. The angular-dependent MR was measured by our lab-made rotation system and the DC voltage signal was detected by a nano-voltage meter, Keithley AC 2182 A, at room temperature, and all MR ratios are defined as (R max -R min )/R min in this paper.