Article | Open

Superconductivity in Ti4O7 and γ-Ti3O5 films

  • Scientific Reports 7, Article number: 12544 (2017)
  • doi:10.1038/s41598-017-12815-4
  • Download Citation
Published online:


Titanium dioxide is one of the most popular compounds among simple oxides. Except for the fully oxidized titanate, titanium oxides have partially filled d states and their exotic properties have captured attention. Here, we report on the discovery of superconductivity in Ti4O7 and γ-Ti3O5 in a thin film form. The epitaxial Ti4O7 and γ-Ti3O5 thin films were grown using pulsed-laser deposition on (LaAlO3)0.3–(SrAl0.5Ta0.5O3)0.7 and α-Al2O3 substrates, respectively. The highest superconducting transition temperatures are 3.0 K and 7.1 K for Ti4O7 and γ-Ti3O5, respectively. The mechanism behind the superconductivity is discussed on the basis of electrical measurements and previous theoretical predictions. We conclude that the superconductivity arises from unstabilized bipolaronic insulating states with the assistance of oxygen non-stoichiometry and epitaxial stabilization.


In the periodic table, titanates are the first group of simple oxides, which are defined as oxides consisted of a kind of the cation and oxygen ion(s), indicating metallicity, and all the simple oxides of scandium or much lighter elements are insulating. Therefore, the choice of titanates is favourable for large electron–phonon coupling. Figure 1(a) shows a schematic of the crystal structure for Ti4O7. Ti4O7 is the first member of Magnéli phase [a triclinic cell (a = 5.597 Å, b = 7.125 Å, c = 20.429 Å, α = 67.7°, β = 57.16°, γ = 108.76°)]1,2 that exhibits unique low-dimensional structures characterized by shear planes. These shear planes correspond to the rutile TiO2 (121) planes and amputate the edge-shared infinite TiO6 chains at every n TiO6 blocks with shifting by a half of the unit cell. In the nominal composition, a TiO6 tetramer has two electrons occupying the Ti 3d states. Trititanium pentoxide (Ti3O5) with polymorphisms (α-, β−, γ−, δ−, and λ-phases) is a neighbour of the Magnéli phase3,4,5,6,7. γ-Ti3O5 is one of them with a monoclinic cell (a = 5.0747 Å, b = 9.9701 Å, c = 7.1810 Å, α = 109.865°)4. In contrast to the Magnéli phase, there are no shear planes, as illustrated in Fig. 1(b). However, since the chemical formula is consistent with that of the Magnéli phase (Ti n O2n-1 at n = 3), it is sometimes designated as the first member of the Magnéli phase. Because of difficulty in the growth of a single crystal due to polymorphism, their physical properties are still under debate. Several studies have dealt with the structural phase transitions accompanying MIT, which are induced under the specific conditions (α ↔ β at 450 K3, δ ↔ γ at 240 K4,5,6,7, and β ↔ λ by irradiation using visible-light pulses6).

Figure 1
Figure 1

Crystal structures of titanates. Schematics of the crystal structures for (a) the first member of Magnéli-phase Ti4O7 and (b) γ-Ti3O5.

We find that Ti4O7 and γ-Ti3O5 films synthesized using epitaxial growth are superconductors with TCs 3.0 K and 7.1 K, respectively. The temperature dependence of resistivity strongly depended on the growth atmosphere. The Ti4O7 film grown under a more oxidation condition of oxygen atmosphere exhibited metal–insulator transition (MIT) accompanied by clear hysteresis at ~150 K. The insulating phase was suppressed in the films grown under a less oxidative condition of Ar atmosphere, and the superconducting phase appeared at low temperatures. These results and the previous theoretical prediction suggest that epitaxial stabilization and oxygen non-stoichiometry play key roles in the realization of superconductivity in these titanates.


Structural characterization

The formation of the Ti4O7 and γ-Ti3O5 phases was verified using x-ray diffraction (XRD). The out-of-plane XRD patterns showed intense reflections from the Ti4O7 films grown on (LaAlO3)0.3–(SrAl0.5Ta0.5O3)0.7(LSAT) (100) substrates and the γ-Ti3O5 film grown on α-Al2O3 (0001) substrates [Fig. 2(a) and (b), respectively]. These substrates are insulating, non-magnetic, and exhibit high reduction resistance, providing advantages in the growth and search of a superconducting sample. Irrespective of the growth condition, Ti4O7 202 reflection was detected at 2θ = 42.38°, corresponding to d202 = 2.13 Å. No other film reflections except for the 404 reflection at 2θ = 92.60° was detected in wide-range XRD patterns. The γ-Ti3O5 022 reflection was detected at 2θ = 37.83°, corresponding to d022 = 2.38 Å. The out-of-plane single orientation was verified using wide-range XRD patterns (not shown). Surface morphology of the films are shown in the inset of Fig. 2. The small grains were observed and the root mean square roughness was about 1 nm for both films. Their surface morphology was different from that of TiO and Ti2O3 (see Fig. S1 in Supplementary information)8.

Figure 2
Figure 2

Structural characterization of titanate films. (a) Out-of-plane XRD patterns for Ti4O7 films grown on LSAT (100) substrates under Ar gas at 1 × 10−3 Torr (top) and under oxygen gas at 1 × 10−7 Torr (bottom). (b) Out-of-plane XRD pattern for the γ-Ti3O5 film grown on α-Al2O3 (0001) substrates under oxygen gas at 1 × 10−7 Torr. The insets show AFM images (5 µm × 5 µm) taken for the same films. Colour codes are 13 nm and 8 nm in height for (a) and (b), respectively.

Because of various polymorphisms with different ratios of oxygen to titanium, their crystal structures must be carefully distinguished. Then, we used the tilt angle χ-dependence of 2θ-θ XRD profiles to survey the asymmetric film reflections (see Figs S2 and S6 in Supplementary Information). Reflections coming from the substrate and film were found at characteristic χ angles. Since the intensities of the film reflections were too weak to determine the d values of interplanar spacing precisely, synchrotron radiation XRD measurements were also performed (see Figs S3S5,S7 and S8 in Supplementary Information). From the d values and χ angles, we identified the Miller indices as those listed in Tables S2 and S3. In comparison to the previous structural analyses of titanates1,2,3,4,5,6,7, we concluded that the films grown on LSAT (100) and α-Al2O3 (0001) substrates were Ti4O7 and γ-Ti3O5, respectively. Furthermore, using the d values and Miller indices (Tables S1 and S3), we evaluated lattice parameters of our titanate films: Ti4O7 film grown under PO2 = 1 × 10−7 Torr (a = 5.52 Å, b = 7.12 Å, c = 20.43 Å, α = 67.5°, β = 57.3°, γ = 108.8°), Ti4O7 film grown under PAr = 1 × 10−7 Torr (a = 5.52 Å, b = 7.11 Å, c = 20.46 Å, α = 67.5°, β = 57.2°, γ = 108.8°), and γ-Ti3O5 film (a = 4.99 Å, b = 9.80 Å, c = 7.06 Å, α = 110.3°). The a-axis lattice constant of both Ti4O7 films is smaller than that of bulk. In contrast, b- and c-axes lattice constants of the former Ti4O7 films were in agreement with those of bulk. The b- (c-) axis lattice constant of the latter Ti4O7 film was smaller (larger) than that of bulk. We note that the c-axis length directly corresponds to the Ti–Ti bond length in the TiO6 tetramer [see Fig. 1(a)] and c-axis lattice constant of the former Ti4O7 film is larger than that of the latter Ti4O7 film. For the γ-Ti3O5 film, all of the lattice constants were smaller than those of bulk. The lattice parameters of the titanate films and bulk are listed in Tables S2 and S4 for comparison.

Formation of the different titanate phases under the identical growth condition suggests that epitaxial effects play an important role for stabilizing the Ti4O7 and γ-Ti3O5 films on each substrate (see Fig. S9 in Supplementary Information). In fact, we have grown neither γ-Ti3O5 films on LSAT (100) substrates nor Ti4O7 films on α-Al2O3 (0001) substrates. The in-plane epitaxial relationship between the substrates and films were also investigated and described in Supplementary Information.

Temperature dependence of resistivity

The electrical properties of the films were investigated using the temperature dependence of resistivity (Fig. 3). The resistivity curves strongly depended on the growth atmosphere for Ti4O7 films [Fig. 3(a)]. For the film grown under PO2 = 1 × 10−7 Torr, MIT accompanied by clear hysteresis was found at around 150 K, which is in agreement with the behaviour of a bipolaron insulator of bulk Ti4O79,10,11. In contrast, the insulating behaviours were strongly suppressed for the film grown under PAr = 1 × 10−3 Torr; the upturn in resistivity was weak. The different behaviour across MIT was in agreement with the difference in c-axis lattice constants of the Ti4O7 films: the larger c-axis length weakened the Ti3+–Ti3+ bond in the TiO6 tetramers for the Ti4O7 films grown under PAr = 1 × 10−3 Torr. The weak resistivity upturn was also reported on V-doped bulk Ti4O712. When V content exceeds 0.35 at%, the disordered bipolarons dominate the electronic properties in the insulating phase. If we account for the lower degree of oxidation at PAr = 1 × 10−3 Torr, oxygen deficiency would play a similar role to substitution of the Ti site with V and be responsible for the suppression of the insulating states. Furthermore, superconductivity was observed at low temperatures. The Ti4O7 film grown under an intermediate condition (PAr = 1 × 10−6 Torr) exhibited both hysteresis and superconducting characteristics in the resistivity curve (also see Fig. S10 in Supplementary Information). We will refer to the Ti4O7 films grown under PO2 = 1 × 10−7 Torr (PAr = 1 × 10−3 Torr) as insulating (superconducting) ones in the following discussion.

Figure 3
Figure 3

Temperature dependence of resistivity of titanate films. (a) Temperature dependence of resistivity for Ti4O7 films grown under three different conditions. The inset shows the temperature dependence of the Hall measurement. (b) Temperature dependence of resistivity for the γ-Ti3O5 film. The inset shows the temperature dependence of the Hall measurement.

The variation in the Hall coefficient (RH) during warming exhibited a tendency similar to that of resistivity. At 300 K (10 K), the inverse RH was 3.6 × 103 (1.5) and 1.2 × 104 (1.2 × 104) C/cm3 for the films grown under PO2 = 1 × 10−7 Torr and PAr = 1 × 10−3 Torr, respectively. For the insulating Ti4O7 film, the temperature dependence of the inverse RH [inset of Fig. 3(a)] suddenly decreased at around 150 K, suggesting that the MIT was induced by the depletion of hole carriers. The inverse RH at 10 K was four orders of magnitude smaller than that at 300 K. The MIT in the bulk is associated with the formation of bipolarons9,10,11, which remains robust in the insulating Ti4O7 film at low temperatures. In contrast, the inverse RH for the superconducting Ti4O7 film was almost independent of temperatures, and even the value at 10 K was comparable to that at 300 K, suggesting the suppression of a bipolaronic insulating state.

The temperature dependence of the resistivity for the γ-Ti3O5 film exhibited a complex curve along three electronic phase transitions: MIT around 350 K, insulator–insulator transition around 100 K, and superconducting transition [Fig. 3(b)]. The intermediate transition would be related to the MIT of Ti4O7 due to their similar transition temperatures. Nevertheless, the resistivity upturn was much weaker, suggesting the suppression of the insulating states, as with the case of the superconducting Ti4O7 film. The inverse RH almost [inset of Fig. 3(b)] remained the same (~103 cm3/C) over the entire temperature range. The sign and magnitude of the RH also reflected this correspondence.

Superconducting properties

The temperature dependence of resistivity around the temperature of liquid helium indicates further similarity between the superconducting Ti4O7 and γ-Ti3O5 films [Fig. 4(a) and (b), respectively]. The TC of Ti4O7 and γ-Ti3O5 were 3.0 K and 7.1 K for TC,onset, 2.7 K and 6.6 K for TC,mid, and 5.8 K and 2.5 K for TC,zero, respectively. Note that the TC of both films exceeded that of other simple-oxide superconductors in bulk [TiO (TC = 2.3 K), NbO (TC~1.4 K), and SnO (TC = 1.4 K under 9.3 GPa)]13,14,15,16. We also note that enhancement of TC = ~7 K in TiO films has been reported in recent17. The superconducting states were gradually degraded under applied magnetic fields. Here, the magnetic fields were applied perpendicular to the film surface. TC shifted toward a lower temperature under a higher magnetic field, and the superconducting phase finally disappeared for the Ti4O7 film at above 2 K. As for the γ-Ti3O5 films, superconductivity remained robust even under 9 T. In addition, from the temperature dependence of magnetization measurements, where magnetic field was applied parallel to the film surface, clear diamagnetic signals were observed [insets of Fig. 4(a) and (b)], respectively. The observation of diamagnetic signals in field-cooling curves indicates the Meissner effect of bulk superconductivity inTi4O7 and γ-Ti3O5 films, and roles out major influences arising from impurity, filament, and/or surface states.

Figure 4
Figure 4

Superconducting properties of titanate films. (a) Temperature dependence of resistivity of the Ti4O7 film grown under P Ar = 1 × 10−3 Torr at low temperatures. (b) Temperature dependence of resistivity of the γ-Ti3O5 film at low temperatures. The insets of (a) and (b) show temperature dependence of magnetization for (a) the superconducting Ti4O7 and (b) γ-Ti3O5 films at low temperatures, respectively. FC and ZFC denote field-cooling and zero-field cooling curves, respectively.


Chakraverty et al. proposed a theory to predict Superconductivity in Ti4O7 with the largest λep value18,19,20. Therefore, experimental verifications for superconductivity in bulk Ti4O7 were attempted by applying high pressures. However, no superconducting transition was observed under a hydrostatic pressure of up to 5.0 GPa, although the high-temperature metallic phase was extended down to 3 K9,10. Our first observation of superconductivity in a Ti4O7 film demonstrates the importance of the epitaxial thin film. Titanium-based simple oxides with various chemical formulae and polymorphisms easily transform from one to another, and subtle tuning of oxygen stoichiometry causes modulation of carrier density. Epitaxial growth on LSAT substrates enables us to stabilize the Magnéli phase. In fact, the γ-Ti3O5 and Ti4O7 films can also be grown on different substrates under the same growth conditions (Tg = 900 °C and PO2 = 1 × 10−7 Torr) (see Fig. S9 in Supplementary Information). The lack of these advantages would be inevitable for hidden superconducting phases in bulk specimens. The MIT of the stoichiometric Ti4O7 bulk is premised on the bipolaronic interaction9,10,11. Sharp increase in resistivity and hysteresis at the MIT are strong evidence for the bipolaron formation9,10,11. The insulating Ti4O7 film exhibiting such characteristics can be regarded as a bipolaronic insulator at low temperatures. For a bipolaronic system, the bipolaron density is a key parameter in the electronic phase diagram19. Our growth of Ti4O7 films under Ar atmosphere aims at inducing extra Ti 3d electrons by introducing oxygen vacancies which dilute the bipolaron density, resulting in the suppression of the insulating states. In fact, the inverse RH of the superconducting film suggests suppression of the bipolaron formation [Fig. 3(a)]. Ti4O7 films grown on MgAl2O4 (100) substrates also exhibited superconductivity (see Figs S11 and S12 in Supplementary Information). Thus, the observed superconductivity is intrinsic to the Ti4O7 phase. Furthermore, superconductors composed of Mg, Al, Ti, and O with TC of more than 3 K are not yet known, indicating that any elements from the substrates cannot induce the superconductivity in our samples.

For bulk γ-Ti3O5, the MIT occurs with the structural phase transition at ~240 K7. There was no sign of such a structural phase transition at the temperature in the resistivity curve of the γ-Ti3O5 film [Fig. 3(b)], suggesting that the metallic γ-phase was stabilized in an epitaxial thin film. The first-principle calculations revealed a one-dimensional conducting pathway along the c-axis arising from the density of states at the Fermi level7. The low-dimensional electronic structure would lead to the pairing of electrons at ~100 K where MIT occurred in γ-Ti3O5. On the other hand, the small number of studies on γ-Ti3O5 makes it difficult to discuss the strength of the electron–phonon interaction, the formation of bipolarons, and the density of states at the Fermi level. Further investigation will be necessary to reveal the origin of superconductivity as well as several electronic phase transitions.

In summary, we study new superconductors produced from Ti4O7 and γ-Ti3O5 films whose TC are 3.0 and 7.1 K, respectively. The latter is one of the highest known values among simple oxides. Our investigations on the electronic properties and the previous theoretical prediction suggest that epitaxial stabilization and oxygen non-stoichiometry play key roles in the realization of superconductivity in the titanates.


Thin-Film Preparation

A TiOx ceramic tablet was prepared using a conventional solid-state reaction method. Ti (3 N) and TiO2 (4 N) powders with a molar ratio of 1:3 were mixed and pressed into a pellet. This was sintered at 1000 °C for 12 h in vacuum. Prior to the film growth, LSAT and α-Al2O3 substrates were annealed in air to obtain a step-and-terrace surface. The annealing conditions were 1200 °C for 3 h for (LaAlO3)0.3–(SrAl0.5Ta0.5O3)0.7 (LSAT), and 1100 °C for 3 h for α-Al2O3. The films were grown using PLD in an ultra-high-vacuum chamber. KrF excimer laser pulses (5 Hz, 2.0 J/cm2) were focused on the TiOx ceramics tablets. The growth temperature was set at 900 °C. The chamber pressure was controlled with the continuous flow of oxygen or Ar gas (6 N purity for both). Ar atoms in the chamber tend to scatter with the lighter oxygen, especially when mean free path of the gaseous species exceeds the target-substrate distance21,22. Therefore, introduction of Ar (oxygen) gas during the growth corresponds to reduction (oxidation) of the films. In fact, we have also grown TiO and Ti2O3 films using PLD in Ar atmosphere (see Fig. S1 in Supplementary Information)8. After the growth, the gas flow was stopped immediately, and the samples were quenched to room temperature.

Characterization of the thin films

Thickness of all the films was ~120 nm, as measured by a stylus profiler. The crystal structures of the films were characterized using XRD with Cu Kα1 radiation (Rigaku, SmartLab) and synchrotron radiation at BL15XU in SPring-8. The photon energy of the synchrotron radiation was set at 15 keV (λ = 0.826 Å). The temperature dependence of resistivity was measured using a standard four-probe method with a physical properties measurement system (Quantum Design, PPMS). The temperature dependence of the Hall measurements was also measured using PPMS in a standard six-terminal geometry. The temperature dependence of magnetization was measured using magnetic properties measurement system (Quantum Design, MPMS).

Additional Information

Publisher's note: Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.


  1. 1.

    Marezio, M., Mcwhan, D.B., Dernier, P. D. & Remeika, J.P. Structural aspects of the metal-insulator transitions in Ti4O7. J. Sol. State Chem. 6, 213 (1973).

  2. 2.

    Lakkis, S., Schlenker, C., Chakraverty, B.K., Buder, R. & Marezio, M. Metal-insulator transition in Ti4O7 single crystals: Crystal characterization, specific heat, and electron paramagnetic resonance. Phys. Rev. B 14, 1429 (1976).

  3. 3.

    Åsbrink, S. & Magnéli, A. Crystal structure studies on Trititanium Pentoxide, Ti3O5. Acta Cryst. 12, 575 (1959).

  4. 4.

    Hong, S. –H. & Åsbrink, S. The structure of γ-Ti3O5 at 297 K. Acta. Cryst. B38, 2570 (1982).

  5. 5.

    Onoda, M. Phase transitions of Ti3O5. J. Sol. State Chem. 136, 67 (1998).

  6. 6.

    Ohkoshi, S. et al. Synthesis of a metal oxide with a room-temperature photoreversible phase transition. Nature Chem. 2, 539 (2010).

  7. 7.

    Tanaka, K. et al. Structural phase transition between γ-Ti3O5 and δ-Ti3O5 by breaking of one-dimensionally conducting pathway. Cryst. Growth Des. 15, 653 (2015).

  8. 8.

    Kurokawa, H., Yoshimatsu, K., Sakata, O. & Ohtomo, A. Effects of phase fraction on superconductivity of low-valence eutectic titanate films. J. Appl. Phys. 122, 055302 (2017).

  9. 9.

    Tonogai, T., Takagi, H., Murayama, C. & Mori, N. Metal-insulator transitions in Ti4O7: Pressure-induced melting of the electron pairs. Rev. High Pressure Sci. Technol. 7, 453 (1998).

  10. 10.

    Ueda, H., Kitazawa, K., Takagi, H. & Matsumoto, T. Strong carrier concentration dependence of pressure effects on bipolaronic transitions in Magnéli phase Ti n O2n-1 (n = 4, 5, 6). J. Phys. Soc. Jpn. 71, 1506 (2002).

  11. 11.

    Mareizo, M., Mcwhan, D. B., Dernier, P. D. & Remeika, J. P. Charge localization at metal-insulator transitions in Ti4O7 and V4O7. Phys. Rev. Lett. 28, 1390 (1972).

  12. 12.

    Schlenker, C., Ahmed, S., Buder, R. & Gourmala, M. Metal-insulator transitions and phase diagram of (Ti1-xV x )4O7: electrical, calorimetric, magnetic and EPRstudies. . J. Phys. C: Solid State Phys. 12, 3503 (1979).

  13. 13.

    Doyle, N. J., Hulm, J. K., Jones, C. K., Miller, R. C. & Taylor, A. Vacancies and superconductivity in titanium monoxide. Phys. Lett. 26A, 604 (1968).

  14. 14.

    Morin, F. J. Oxides which show a metal-to-insulator transition at the Neel temperature. Phys. Rev. Lett. 3, 34 (1959).

  15. 15.

    Hulm, J. K., Jones, C. K., Hein, R. A. & Gibson, J. W. Superconductivity in the TiO and NbO system. J. Low Temp. Phys. 7, 291 (1972).

  16. 16.

    Forthaus, M. K. et al. Superconductivity in SnO: a nonmagnetic analog to Fe-based superconductors? Phys. Rev. Lett. 105, 157001 (2010).

  17. 17.

    Zhang, C. et al. Enhanced superconductivity in TiO epitaxial thin films. npj Quantum Materials 2, 2 (2017).

  18. 18.

    Chakraverty, B. K. Possibility of insulator to superconductor phase transition. J. de Physique Lettres 40, 99 (1979).

  19. 19.

    Jongh, L. J. D. A comparative study of (bi)polaronic (super)conductivity in high- and low- T C superconducting oxides. Physica C 152, 171 (1988).

  20. 20.

    Micnas, R., Ranninger, J. & Robaszkiewicz, S. Superconductivity in narrow-band systems with local nonretarded attractive interactions. Rev. Mod. Phys. 62, 113 (1990).

  21. 21.

    Schou, J. Physical aspects of the pulsed laser deposition technique: the stoichiometric transfer of material from target to film. Appl. Surf. Sci. 255, 5191 (2009).

  22. 22.

    Ojeda-G-P, A., Schneider, C. W., Döbeli, M., Lippert, T. & Wokaun, A. The importance of pressure and mass ratios when depositing multi-element oxide thin films by pulsed laser deposition. Appl. Surf. Sci. 389, 126 (2016).

Download references


The authors greatly thank Prof. S. Saito, Dr. S. Okamoto, Dr. T. Koretsune, and Dr. R. Arita for their useful discussion. The authors also thank M. Azuma and H. Hojo for assistance of magnetization measurements. The Synchrotron XRD measurements were performed under the approval of the NIMS Synchrotron x-ray station at SPring-8 (Proposal No. 2015B4700). The authors are also grateful to K. Yokoyama, S. Takeda, K. Kagoshima, and J. Matsui, University of Hyogo, for their technical contribution and to Y. Shimada and Y. Katsuya for their technical support. This work was partly supported by MEXT Elements Strategy Initiative to Form Core Research Centre and a Grant-in-Aid for Scientific Research (Nos. 15H03881 and 16H05983) from the Japan Society for the Promotion of Science Foundation.

Author information


  1. Department of Chemical Science and Engineering, Tokyo Institute of Technology, 2-12-1 Ookayama, Meguro-ku, Tokyo, 152-8552, Japan

    • K. Yoshimatsu
    •  & A. Ohtomo
  2. Synchrotron X-ray Station at SPring-8, National Institute for Materials Science (NIMS), 1-1-1 Koto, Sayo-cho, Sayo-gun, Hyogo, 679-5148, Japan

    • O. Sakata
  3. Materials Research Center for Element Strategy (MCES), Tokyo Institute of Technology, 4259 Nagatsuta-cho, Midori-ku, Yokohama, 226-8503, Japan

    • O. Sakata
    •  & A. Ohtomo


  1. Search for K. Yoshimatsu in:

  2. Search for O. Sakata in:

  3. Search for A. Ohtomo in:


K.Y. performed the experiments and analysed experimental data. O.S. supervised the synchrotron X-ray diffraction measurements. All authors discussed the results and wrote the manuscript. A.O. supervised the project.

Competing Interests

The authors declare that they have no competing interests.

Corresponding author

Correspondence to K. Yoshimatsu.

Electronic supplementary material


By submitting a comment you agree to abide by our Terms and Community Guidelines. If you find something abusive or that does not comply with our terms or guidelines please flag it as inappropriate.

Creative Commons BY

Open Access This article is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License, which permits use, sharing, adaptation, distribution and reproduction in any medium or format, as long as you give appropriate credit to the original author(s) and the source, provide a link to the Creative Commons license, and indicate if changes were made. The images or other third party material in this article are included in the article’s Creative Commons license, unless indicated otherwise in a credit line to the material. If material is not included in the article’s Creative Commons license and your intended use is not permitted by statutory regulation or exceeds the permitted use, you will need to obtain permission directly from the copyright holder. To view a copy of this license, visit