# Compositionally Graded Multilayer Ceramic Capacitors

## Abstract

Multilayer ceramic capacitors (MLCC) are widely used in consumer electronics. Here, we provide a transformative method for achieving high dielectric response and tunability over a wide temperature range through design of compositionally graded multilayer (CGML) architecture. Compositionally graded MLCCs were found to exhibit enhanced dielectric tunability (70%) along with small dielectric losses (<2.5%) over the required temperature ranges specified in the standard industrial classifications. The compositional grading resulted in generation of internal bias field which enhanced the tunability due to increased nonlinearity. The electric field tunability of MLCCs provides an important avenue for design of miniature filters and power converters.

## Introduction

The temperature stability and electric field tunability of capacitance in multilayer ceramic capacitors (MLCCs) is highly desired to develop smaller and lighter power electronic devices. The tunability in capacitance over wide range of frequency and power provides opportunity to develop new circuit architectures. Increased temperature stability, miniaturization, and controlled capacitance tunability in ceramics also provides opportunity to develop new MLCC architecture. In the past, various dopant engineering based efforts have been made for improving the room temperature dielectric constant of ceramics1,2,3,4 via shifting the Curie temperature (T c) towards the room temperature. However, shifting of T c towards room temperature renders increased temperature dependent dielectric response. To improve temperature stability of the dielectric behavior, core-shell grain microstructure has been widely exploited5,6,7 where, for example, grain comprises of ferroelectric core and paraelectric shell with diffuse phase transition characteristics5. However, achieving high dielectric constant along with high temperature stability is challenging through these approaches8,9,10,11,12,13,14. Additionally, the core-shell structures exhibit strong frequency dispersion in dielectric constant15,16,17. The compositionally graded ferroelectric architectures have been investigated in literature illustrating the principles that govern the capacitive behavior18,19,20,21,22. Extensive theoretical studies on graded structures have predicted low loss, and high and temperature-stable dielectric constant23,24,25. Prior researches have demonstrated thermally strained26 and compositionally strained graded structures in Ba1−x Sr x TiO3 thin films27 for tunable antenna applications28,29,30 and wide band gap semiconductors using graded (Pb, Sr)TiO3 films31. Despite of interesting effect in the compositionally graded architecture, most of studies have been limited to thin film multilayer or hetero-structure not been actually applied in MLCCs. Previously, we also have predicted enhanced temperature stability in dielectric response through compositionally graded multilayer (CGML) laminate architecture32. However, fabrication of CGML co-fired capacitor resulting in enhanced temperature stability and tunability has not been reported.

Here, we report success in synthesizing and characterizing CGML ceramic capacitor structure with high dielectric constant over a wide temperature range and high tunability. Recently, lead-free materials such as BaZrO3 8, 0.7BaTiO3-0.3BiScO3 9, BiScO3-BaTiO3-Bi0.5K0.5TiO3 10, 0.9(Bi0.5Na0.5)TiO3-0.1KTaO3 11 and various other compositions12,13,14 have been investigated but most of these materials exhibited low permittivity, high losses, and strong temperature and frequency dependent dielectric properties. The volatile nature and high reactivity of alkali elements create processing challenges, which hampers their practical applications. In this paper, we report fabrication of functionally graded multilayer ceramic capacitors based on modified BaTiO3 based dielectric compositions. The dielectric response of CGML capacitor was simulated using phase field simulation33,34,35,36. The modeling and simulation provided relationship between microstructure and temperature stability of dielectric property, in particular, effect of grain structure and composition grading on the temperature-dependent dielectric properties.

## Results and Discussion

### Designing High Dielectric Constant Composition

0.975BaTi1-x Sn x O3-0.025Ba(Cu1/3Nb2/3)O3 (BTS-BCN) ceramics were selected for the compositionally graded multilayer ceramic capacitor because Curie temperature of this composition can be easily tuned by modulating Sn content while maintaining high permittivity and low loss in wide temperature range32,37. Addition of small content of Cu and Nb in the form of BCN allows further tailoring of the magnitude of permittivity of loss factor. Cu on Ti-site will act as acceptor suppressing the loss factor while Nb on Ti-site will act as donor and enhance the permittivity. Figure 1(a) shows room temperature X-ray diffraction (XRD) patterns of BTS-BCN ceramics with varying Sn concentration (0.01 ≤ x ≤ 0.08). These XRD patterns were recorded on the powders obtained after crushing the pellets sintered at 1300 °C for 2 h. All the compositions were found to exhibit perovskite phase. As shown in magnified view of the diffraction peaks in the vicinity of 2θ = 45°, the splitting of (0 02)/(2 0 0) peak gradually reduced and merged into a broad symmetrical peak with increasing Sn content (x). This suggests reduction in the tetragonal distortion and long range ordering in the system with increasing Sn content. For x ≤ 0.03, the XRD-spectra exhibited tetragonal structure, however, for increased Sn content (x ≥ 0.05), the average crystal symmetry is cubic. This phase transition from tetragonal to cubic structure was found to occur over the compositional range of 0.02 < x < 0.05. Therefore, both cubic and tetragonal phases may coexist in the range of 0.03 ≤ x ≤ 0.04 at room temperature.

Figure 1(b) and (c) shows the variation of dielectric constant (εr) and loss tangent (tan δ) of BT(1-x)S x -BCN ceramics (0.01 ≤ x ≤ 0.08) as a function of temperature at 1 kHz. The Curie peak (permittivity maximum, εmax) becomes broader and shifts towards lower temperatures with increasing Sn content indicating diffuse phase transition. The shifting of Curie temperature towards room temperature (RT) is in accordance with the reduced tetragonality with higher Sn content. A broad peak indicating the phase transition temperature (T T-O ) from tetragonal to orthorhombic structure was observed for x ≤ 0.03 compositions, as indicated by arrow in Fig. 1(b). This T TO peak was found to shift towards higher temperature with increasing Sn content. Subsequently, this T TO peak merged with the Curie peak to give rise to broader peak at x = 0.04 at RT suggesting the coexistence of tetragonal and cubic phases as indicated in Fig. 1(a). The value of the maximum dielectric permittivity (εmax) was found to be >5500 for all the compositions, while x = 0.08 exhibited the highest value of εmax ~ 7110. The loss tangent factor (tan δ) was found to be less than 3% over a wide temperature range of −50 °C to 125 °C for all the compositions. Moreover, some compositions exhibited very small value of the tan δ < 1% at RT, indicating their strong potential for MLCC technologies according to the EIA standard. The reduction in the values of tan δ after T c can be attributed to the absence of the domain walls in the paraelectric phase.

### Processing of the compositionally graded multilayer ceramic capacitor

Figure 2(a) shows the processing method for BT(1-x)S x -BCN ceramics with 0.01 ≤ x ≤ 0.08, and MLCC with the compositionally graded architecture. For graded architecture, each two layers of eight different compositions of BTS-BCN were stacked sequentially (Fig. 2(a)). Figure 2(b) shows the schematic representation of the inner electrodes with up- and down- termination. The Pt electrodes were formed using a screen printing for compatibility with a high temperature co-firing process. The dielectric layers with up- and down- terminated electrodes were alternately stacked for a series connection with outer and inner electrodes as illustrated in Fig. 2(a), it electrically corresponds to parallel connection of multiple single-layer capacitors. The active area of the electrodes was designed to be 16 mm2 (4 mm × 4 mm), as indicated by a red dotted square in Fig. 2(b). Total of 48 active layers (repeatedly stacking of the 16 layers in Fig. 2(a) three times) with eight different compositions of BT(1-x)S x -BCN (0.01 ≤ x ≤ 0.08) were stacked to achieve compositionally graded MLCC. Figure 2(c) shows optical image of the sliced green samples after hot pressing. After the binder burnout process, the green samples were sintered at 1300 °C for 2 h to achieve final MLCC samples. The sintered MLCCs were lapped and subjected to fabrication of the outer termination electrodes, as shown in Fig. 2(d). The width and thickness of the MLCCs were found to be about 4.5 mm and 2 mm, respectively.

Figure 3(a) shows cross-sectional SEM image of the graded MLCC co-fired at 1300 °C for 2 h. Despite containing hetero-composition layers with different thermal expansion coefficients and Pt electrodes, MLCCs did not exhibit any delamination or mechanical defects after sintering process. The thicknesses of each dielectric layer and electrode were found to be ~40 μm and ~3 μm, respectively. As shown in Fig. 3(b), the EDS elemental analysis on Pt and Ba elements did not show the evidence of interfacial elemental diffusion across the dielectric layer and Pt-electrode layers. Figure 3(c) shows the SEM image of the grain morphology of the dielectric layer indicating homogeneous distribution of the grain size and dense microstructure. This SEM micrograph is the representative of the several micrographs recorded on various positions of different dielectric layers. The grain size of BTS-BCN was found to be in the range of 50–200 nm, which is much smaller than that of typical BaTiO3 based dielectric materials under normal sintering conditions3. In the case of BTS-BCN ceramics, the occupancy of Nb5+ on Ti4+ site (B-site in perovskite) is expected to form metal vacancy for maintaining electroneutrality38. On the other hand, Cu2+ substitution on Ti4+ site will result in the formation of oxygen vacancy39. The segregation of these oxygen vacancies on grain boundaries is expected to hinder the grain growth process, resulting in fine BTS-BCN ceramics40. The small sized grains are advantageous for reducing the thickness of dielectric layers. Additionally, the smaller grain size provides a higher dielectric strength because grain boundaries act as barriers for the oxygen vacancies41. The SEM image of the boundary region of the Pt inner electrode and the dielectric layer is shown in Fig. 3(d). The Pt inner electrode was also found to have a dense microstructure without pinholes.

Figure 4(a) shows the capacitance as a function of temperature at different frequencies for the graded MLCC. The maximum capacitance peak (Cmax) was significantly broadened due to the compositional grading. The maximum capacitance of 348 nF (at 1 kHz) was obtained around RT (25 °C). The value of capacitance was found to decrease gradually with increasing temperature and was significantly reduced above 75 °C. On cooling below −15 °C, the capacitance value was also found to decrease. In order to further achieve enhanced temperature stability of the dielectric response, it is necessary to include more compositions having Curie temperatures above 75 °C and below −15 °C. As shown in Fig. 4(a), although the capacitance tends to decrease slightly with increasing frequency, the capacitance difference (ΔC) between 1 kHz and 40 kHz was less than 5% over entire temperature of operation. Unlike core-shell structure, the notable frequency dispersion for dielectric permittivity was not observed over a wide temperature range in BTS-BCN ceramics16,42. Figure 4(b) shows the temperature dependent dissipation factor of the graded MLCC at different frequencies. The tan δ of the MLCC was below 2.5% over a wide temperature range of −55 °C~125 °C. Interestingly, this functionally graded MLCC exhibited very low value of tanδ <1% at RT, which was found to reduce further with increasing temperature due to the absence of domain walls in the paraelectric phase43. The values of tan δ was found to increase with increasing frequency, which is typical behavior for ferroelectric material.

Figure 4(c) shows temperature dependent capacitance for the graded MLCC with and without 200 V DC bias at 1 kHz. The capacitance was found to considerably decrease over the entire temperature range (−55 °C to 125 °C) with 200 V DC bias. Interestingly, the Cmax peak [combined Curie peaks (εmax Peaks)] of different compositions disappeared under 200 V DC bias field. This phenomenon is indication of the suppressed ferroelectric-paraelectric (FE-PE) transitions in BTS-BCN compositions under the DC bias. Additionally, under 200 V DC bias, the reduction in the magnitude of the capacitance over the temperature regime of broad capacitance peak in MLCC (Fig. 4(a)) was more significant than that of other temperature regime. This phenomenon can be attributed to the enhanced structural instability and domain reorientation near the Curie peaks. Figure 4(d) shows the capacitance and dissipation factor as function of DC bias at 1 kHz for graded MLCC. A gradual decrease in the capacitance value with increasing DC bias can be attributed to domain reorientation. The tunability was calculated as:

$${Tunability}\,( \% )=\frac{{C}_{{E}_{0}}-{C}_{E}}{{C}_{{E}_{0}}}\times 100 \%$$
(1)

where $${C}_{{E}_{0}}$$ and $${C}_{E}$$ are capacitance values at 0 V and under DC bias field conditions, respectively. The tunability of the graded MLCC was obtained to be ~70% under 200 V (50 kV/cm) at room temperature. It can be seen that the dissipation factor was initially increased with DC bias up to 25 V (6.25 kV/cm) and then gradually reduced with increasing DC bias to become the value of 0.5% at 200 V (50 kV/cm).

In order to investigate frequency dependent characteristics of graded MLCC, the capacitance and the tan δ were measured as a function of frequency at RT, as shown in Fig. 4(e). The value of tan δ was found to be <1% up to 15 kHz. However, with increasing the frequency above 50 kHz, the value of tan δ was found to increase rapidly. On the other hand, the capacitance was found to slowly decrease with increasing frequency up to 50 kHz before dropping rapidly at higher frequencies. The compositionally graded architectures did not exhibit frequency dispersion over the phase transition temperature regime contrary to the core-shell architectures, as discussed before. These results indicate that the functionally graded architecture is a promising strategy to provide the high capacitance with enhanced temperature and frequency stability along with high tunability.

### Phase Field Simulation

In this work, we adopt the phase field model of ferroelectric polycrystals44 and carry out computer simulations to investigate the effects of grain microstructures and composition distributions on the temperature-dependent dielectric properties of Pb(Zr1-x Ti x )O3 (PZT), a model system of compositionally graded ferroelectric ceramic. PZT is chosen because it is the material system where all the composition- and temperature-dependent coefficients of the Landau-Ginzburg-Devonshire free energy function have been experimentally determined, as required by the phase field modeling. While quantitatively different, the simulation results are qualitatively applicable to the relationship between microstructure and temperature stability of dielectric property in compositionally graded multilayer BTS-BCN capacitors where the required complete set of material coefficients are not available. We first investigate layered composition distribution as shown in Fig. 5(a). Five layers of grains of respective compositions x = 0.40, 0.45, 0.50, 0.55 and 0.60 are arranged in series configuration, as illustrated by the electrode positions. To compare with parallel configuration, the polycrystalline structure of these five layers of grains shown in Fig. 5(a) is mirror-reflected around its diagonal to produce the parallel layered structure shown in Fig. 5(b). To investigate the effect of layer thickness, the polycrystalline structures of eight layers of grains arranged respectively in series and in parallel are also simulated, as shown in Fig. 5(c) and (d). To study the effect of connectivity of composition distributions, in addition to the continuous layered composition distributions shown in Fig. 5(a)~(d), randomly dispersed and well-separated distributions of grains of different compositions are further considered, as shown in Fig. 5(e) and (f), respectively.

Figure 6(a) shows the simulated dielectric constants of the polycrystals of five layered structures in series and parallel configurations shown in Fig. 5(a) and (b), respectively. For comparison, the dielectric constants of polycrystals of the same grain microstructures but different homogeneous compositions are also simulated and plotted in Fig. 6(a) (black curves). It is observed that in both layered cases the distribution of dielectric constants with temperature has been flattened, where the distribution peak is broadened with respect to the sharp peaks of individual homogeneous composition cases, which indicates enhanced temperature stability in functionally graded ferroelectric materials with composition gradient. The sharp peaks in the temperature-dependent dielectric constants of individual ferroelectric polycrystals with homogeneous composition follow the Curie-Weiss law as expected from the Landau-Ginzburg-Devonshire theory with experimentally derived composition- and temperature-dependent material coefficients. The composition gradient introduces a distribution of the Curie temperature which is a function of the local composition, leading to a broadened peak of the temperature-dependent dielectric constants while the peak height is reduced, providing enhanced temperature stability of the dielectric constants as desired. It is also observed that the layered structure in parallel configuration (green solid curve) provides slightly higher temperature stability while lower values of dielectric constants than the layered structure in series configuration (red solid curve). To understand this difference, the dielectric constants of compositionally graded polycrystals are theoretically calculated by using the rule of mixtures for series and parallel configurations, respectively, from the simulated dielectric constants of different compositionally homogeneous polycrystals (black curves) according to the volume fractions of individual compositions, as plotted in Fig. 6(a) (dotted curves). It can be seen that, while the parallel configurations (solid and dotted green curves) agree well with each other, the series configurations (solid and dotted red curves) deviate from each other quite significantly. Such behaviors are attributed to the different electrode structures in the parallel and series configurations: in parallel configuration there is no internal electrode between layers, thus the simulated and calculated dielectric constants agree with each other; on the other hand, in series configuration there is no internal electrode between layers in the phase field simulations, while the rule of series mixtures assumes internal electrodes to connect neighboring layers, and this difference leads to different dielectric constant values as shown by the solid and dotted red curves. The results presented in Fig. 6(a) shows that two design variables can effectively control the temperature stability of dielectric constants in compositionally graded ferroelectrics: (i) parallel or series configuration of layered structures, and (ii) if series configuration, internal electrodes between layers (or lack of internal electrodes). These two design variables allow choice of the dielectric constant value and its temperature stability for various application requirements. These theoretical results confirms that a good temperature stability with intermediate dielectric constant value can be obtained in compositionally graded layered architectures, which is in line with the experimentally observed behavior (Fig. 4(a)).

To investigate the effect of layer thickness, the polycrystalline structures of eight layers of grains of respective compositions x = 0.40, 0.45, 0.50, 0.55, 0.60, 0.55, 0.50, and 0.45 arranged in series and parallel configurations shown in Fig. 5(c) and (d) are also simulated and compared with the five-layered cases shown in Fig. 5(a) and (b). It is worth noting that, in addition to the different layer thicknesses between five-layered and eight-layered architectures, the gradient of heterogeneous composition distribution is also different This is because of the periodic boundary conditions adopted to numerically solve the long-range electrostatic and elastostatic interactions of inhomogeneous distributions of polarization and electrostriction strain using fast Fourier transform technique. The layers of composition x = 0.40 (blue) and x = 0.60 (red) are adjacent to each other in the five-layered architecture, while there is no such a large composition jump in the eight-layered architecture, as illustrated in Fig. 5(a)~(d). Despite such differences, it is observed in Fig. 6(b) that the temperature-dependent dielectric constants of the five-layered and eight-layered architectures are essentially the same in the respective series and parallel configurations. This comparison result shows that an abrupt composition change across layer interfaces does not significantly affect the dielectric constant, and it is the parallel and series configurations that are important design factor. In particular, this finding implies that, for given layers of selected compositions, the order of the layers of different compositions in the architecture is insignificant for the dielectric constant and its temperature stability.

To further illustrate the important role of connectivity (i.e., series and parallel configurations) of composition distributions, randomly dispersed and well-separated distributions of grains of different compositions shown respectively in Fig. 5(e) and (f) are simulated and compared with the five-layered series and parallel cases shown in Fig. 5(a) and (b). To eliminate other effects in this comparison study, the same polycrystalline grain structure is used in the simulations, and approximately the same volume fractions of individual different compositions are considered. It is observed in Fig. 6(c) that the polycrystals of randomly dispersed and well-separated grains of different compositions both exhibit isotropic properties and their dielectric constants are essentially the same at the same temperature, which fall between the values of series and parallel layered structures. This comparison result agrees with the well-established fact that the isotropic structures of randomly dispersed and well-separated grains produce isotropic properties, and the anisotropic layered structures produce anisotropic properties, where the series and parallel configurations respectively set the upper and lower bounds of the dielectric constants for a mixture of grains of different compositions. The trends of variations in the experimental dielectric response of the functionally graded MLCC architectures are successfully modeled delineating effect of the microstructure and connectivity of the layers.

## Conclusion

In this study, we fabricated the functionally graded multilayer ceramic capacitor (MLCC) with enhanced temperature stability in the dielectric response and high tunability. To fabricate the compositionally graded MLCC, various compositions given as BT(1-x)S x -BCN (0.01 ≤ x ≤ 0.08) were used. The compositionally graded MLCC exhibited enhanced temperature stability of the capacitance with small dielectric loss (<2.5%) over a wide temperature range. These MLCCs also exhibited enhanced tunability (70%) of the capacitance indicating their adaptability without reconfiguring the device. Additionally, we demonstrated good frequency stability (no dielectric dispersion) of the dielectric response. Phase field modeling was used to quantitatively simulate the effects of grain structures and composition distributions on the temperature-dependent dielectric properties.

## Methods

### MLCC Fabrication

The 0.975BaTi1-x Sn x O3-0.025Ba(Cu1/3Nb2/3)O3 ceramic powders with x = 0.01~0.08 were prepared from oxides of over 99% purity by the conventional solid state synthesis. The stoichiometric oxide compounds of CuO (Alfa Aesar, 99.0%), TiO2 (Alfa Aesar, 99.5%), Nb2O5 (Alfa Aesar, 99.5%), BaCO3 (Alfa Aesar, 99.8%), SnO2 (Alfa Aesar, 99.9%) were mixed for 24 h in a polyethylene jar with zirconia balls. This mixture was dried in an oven followed by calcination at 850 °C for 4 h. After calcination, the powders were again ball-milled for 48 h and dried in an oven. The resulting product was sieved through the screen with 200 μm holes to achieve homogeneous powder. These prepared powders were mixed with 37.5 wt% of the binder system (Ferro Corp., B73225) and ball-milled for 24 h to get homogenous slurry. The mixed slurry was stirred in vacuum to remove air bubbles before subjecting to the tape casting process using the doctor blade. The blade height was kept at 400 μm and the casting speed was maintained at 300 mm/min. These tapes were cut in to desired size to get MLCC. For internal electrodes, Pt paste (Electro-Science Laboratories, Inc., 5574) was patterned through screen printing process. The ceramic tapes along with electrodes were stacked up to get MLCC. For getting compositionally graded MLCC, two layers of eight compositions of BTS-BCN (0.01 ≤ Sn ≤ 0.08) were consecutively stacked up (total 48 layers), as illustrated in Fig. 2(a). The stacked samples were hot pressed and diced, as shown in Fig. 2(c). After binder burnout, sintering was performed at 1300 °C for 2 h. The sintered samples were polished for termination on both side of the samples, and the silver paste (DuPont 7713) was painted and fired at 650 °C for 30 min.

### Microstructure and Morphology

XRD patterns were recorded using a Bruker D8 Advance diffractometer using Cu-K_alpha radiation at 40 kV and 40 mA. All powders were scanned from 20 to 60 degree. The cross-section and surface morphology of the sintered samples and MLCC were observed using a LEO Zeiss 1550 (Zeiss, Munich, Germany) scanning electron microscope (SEM). The diffusion between Pt inner electrodes and dielectric layers were inspected by elemental dispersive spectroscopy (EDS).

### Dielectric Measurements

Dielectric constant and dielectric dissipation factor were measured as a function of temperature at selected frequencies using an inductance-capacitance-resistance (LCR) meter (HP 4284 A), connected to a computer controlled oven. The capacitance and dielectric dissipation factor of MLCC were measured as a function of applied DC bias at fixed 1 kHz using a DC power supply and the LCR meter.

### Phase Field Modeling

The grain microstructure of a compositionally graded polycrystal is characterized by a grain rotation matrix field R(r) that describes the geometry (size, shape, location) and crystallographic orientation of individual grains, and the composition distribution is characterized by a composition field x(r) that describes the local composition of, say, Pb(Zr1-x Ti x )O3 (PZT) at spatial position r. Figure 5 illustrates the grain microstructures and heterogeneous compositions of ferroelectric polycrystals considered in the following simulation study. The state of such a ferroelectric polycrystal is described by a polarization field P(r), and the total system free energy under externally applied electric field E ex is33,34,35,36,44:

$$F=\int {d}^{3}r[f({R}_{ij}{P}_{j})+\frac{\beta }{2}\frac{\partial {P}_{i}}{\partial {r}_{j}}\frac{\partial {P}_{i}}{\partial {r}_{j}}-{E}_{k}^{{\rm{ex}}}{P}_{k}]+\frac{1}{2}\int \frac{{d}^{3}k}{{(2\pi )}^{3}}[\frac{{n}_{i}{n}_{j}}{{\varepsilon }_{0}}{\tilde{P}}_{i}{{\tilde{P}}_{j}}^{\ast }+{K}_{ijkl}{\tilde{\varepsilon }}_{ij}^{0}{\tilde{\varepsilon }}_{kl}^{0\,\ast }]$$
(2)

where

$$\begin{array}{rcl}f({\bf{P}}) & = & {\alpha }_{1}({P}_{1}^{2}+{P}_{2}^{2}+{P}_{3}^{2})+{\alpha }_{11}({P}_{1}^{4}+{P}_{2}^{4}+{P}_{3}^{4})+{\alpha }_{12}({P}_{1}^{2}{P}_{2}^{2}+{P}_{2}^{2}{P}_{3}^{2}+{P}_{3}^{2}{P}_{1}^{2})\\ & & +{\alpha }_{111}({P}_{1}^{6}+{P}_{2}^{6}+{P}_{3}^{6})+{\alpha }_{112}[{P}_{1}^{4}({P}_{2}^{2}+{P}_{3}^{2})+{P}_{2}^{4}({P}_{3}^{2}+{P}_{1}^{2})+{P}_{3}^{4}({P}_{1}^{2}+{P}_{2}^{2})]\\ & & +{\alpha }_{123}{P}_{1}^{2}{P}_{2}^{2}{P}_{3}^{2}\end{array}$$
(3)

is Landau-Ginzburg-Devonshire free energy function of ferroelectric single crystal45. The coefficients α i , α ij , and α ijk in the case of compositionally graded ferroelectrics are functions of x(r); for the model system PZT considered in this work, these material parameters have been experimentally determined46: $${\alpha }_{1}=(T-\theta )/2{\varepsilon }_{0}C$$ in VmC−1, $${\alpha }_{11}=-2{\alpha }_{1}({T}_{{\rm{C}}})/{P}_{s}^{2}$$ in Vm5C−3, $${\alpha }_{12}=(9.8-21.8x){\alpha }_{11}$$ in Vm5C−3, $${\alpha }_{111}={\alpha }_{1}({T}_{{\rm{C}}})/{P}_{s}^{4}$$ in Vm9C−5, $${\alpha }_{112}=8000/{\varepsilon }_{0}C$$ in Vm9C−5, $${\alpha }_{123}=-(45000-25000x)/{\varepsilon }_{0}C$$ in Vm9C−5, where T is temperature in °C, ε 0 is the permittivity of free space, $$\theta =208.2+489.6x-322.8{x}^{2}+164.7{x}^{3}-63.81{x}^{4}$$ in °C, $$C=6.2\times {10}^{5}{e}^{-37.2{(x-0.5)}^{2}}+1.5\times {10}^{5}$$ in °C, $${T}_{{\rm{C}}}=211.8+486.0x-280.0{x}^{2}+74.42{x}^{3}$$ in °C, $${P}_{s}=0.1191+0.2001x+0.04854{x}^{2}-0.002914{x}^{3}$$ in m−2C, x being the composition. For any given compositionally graded ferroelectric polycrystal as demonstrated in Fig. 5, these material parameters are conveniently expressed in terms of the composition field variable x(r), which determines the local dielectric property in such a heterogeneous material system through these material coefficients α i , α ij , and α ijk . It is worth noting that P(r) in Eq. (2) is defined in a global coordinate system attached to the polycrystal, while P(r) in Eq. (3) is defined in a local coordinate system aligned with <100> lattice axes of a ferroelectric single crystal, and the operation R ij P j in $$f({R}_{ij}{P}_{j})$$ in Eq. (2) transforms P(r) from the global sample system to the local lattice system in each grain44. The gradient term in Eq. (2) characterizes the energy contribution from polarization gradient at domain walls and grain boundaries, where β is gradient coefficient. The k-space integrals in Eq. (2) characterize the domain configuration-dependent electrostatic energy of polarization distribution P(r) and elastostatic energy of misfit strain distribution ε 0(r), where K ijkl  = C ijkl n m C ijmn Ω np C klpq n q , Ω ik  = (C ijkl n j n l )−1, C ijkl is elastic modulus tensor, and n = k/k. The spontaneous lattice misfit strain originates from electrostriction, $${\varepsilon }_{ij}^{0}={Q}_{ijkl}{P}_{k}{P}_{l}$$, where Q ijkl is electrostriction coefficient tensor. For PZT47, Q 11 = 0.0812 m4C−2, Q 12 = −0.0295 m4C−2, Q 44 = 0.0671 m4C−2. The functions $$\tilde{{\bf{P}}}({\bf{k}})$$ and $${\tilde{{\boldsymbol{\varepsilon }}}}^{0}({\bf{k}})$$ are the Fourier transforms of the respective fields P(r) and ε 0(r), and the superscript asterisk * indicates complex conjugate. The spatial-temporal evolution of polarization and domain microstructure is characterized by the time-dependent Ginzburg-Landau equation33,34,35,36,44:

$$\frac{\partial {\bf{P}}({\bf{r}},t)}{\partial t}=-L\frac{\delta F}{\delta {\bf{P}}({\bf{r}},t)}+{\boldsymbol{\xi }}({\bf{r}},t)$$
(4)

where L is kinetic coefficient, and $${\boldsymbol{\xi }}({\bf{r}},t)$$ is Gaussian-distributed Langevin noise term accounting for the effect of thermal fluctuation. In the following simulations, we consider PZT polycrystals of the grain microstructures and heterogeneous compositions as illustrated in Fig. 5. These polycrystals are discretized into 512 × 512 computational grids under periodic boundary conditions to model bulk ceramic samples. It is worth noting that the electrodes shown in Fig. 5 are not considered in the simulations, which only help illustrate the directions of the applied electric field in each case and the configurations of the layered composition distributions (i.e., in series or parallel). It is also noted that the permittivity of free space is used in Eq. (2) to calculate electrostatic dipole-dipole interaction energy. A background dielectric constant about 5–10 is usually used to account for additional susceptibility contributions that are not associated with ferroelectric polarizations, which is important for high frequencies48. In this work the phase field simulations focus on the relationship between multilayer microstructure and temperature stability of low-frequency/quasi-static dielectric property, and thus the background dielectric constant is not explored as a potential variable in the calculations.

## References

1. 1.

Hennings, D., Schnell, A. & Simon, G. Diffuse Ferroelectric Phase Transitions in Ba (Ti1‐yZry) O3 Ceramics. Journal of the American Ceramic Society 65, 539–544 (1982).

2. 2.

Hansen, P., Hennings, D. & Schreinemacher, H. High‐K Dielectric Ceramics from Donor/Acceptor‐Codoped (Ba1− xCax)(Ti1‐yZry) O3 (BCTZ). Journal of the American Ceramic Society 81, 1369–1373 (1998).

3. 3.

Kishi, H., Mizuno, Y. & Chazono, H. Base-metal electrode-multilayer ceramic capacitors: past, present and future perspectives. Japanese Journal of Applied Physics 42, 1 (2003).

4. 4.

Sakabe, Y., Hamaji, Y., Sano, H. & Wada, N. Effects of rare-earth oxides on the reliability of X7R dielectrics. Japanese journal of applied physics 41, 5668 (2002).

5. 5.

Randall, C., Wang, S., Laubscher, D., Dougherty, J. & Huebner, W. Structure property relationships in core-shell BaTiO 3–LiF ceramics. Journal of materials research 8, 871–879 (1993).

6. 6.

Pan, M.-J. & Randall, C. A. A brief introduction to ceramic capacitors. IEEE electrical insulation magazine 26 (2010).

7. 7.

Kishi, H. et al. The effect of MgO and rare-earth oxide on formation behavior of core-shell structure in BaTiO3. Japanese journal of applied physics 36, 5954 (1997).

8. 8.

Koenig, J. & Jaffe, B. Barium Zirconate Modified with Lanthanum, a High‐Temperature Capacitor Dielectric. Journal of the American Ceramic Society 47, 87–89 (1964).

9. 9.

Ogihara, H., Randall, C. A. & Trolier‐McKinstry, S. High‐Energy Density Capacitors Utilizing 0.7 BaTiO3–0.3 BiScO3 Ceramics. Journal of the American Ceramic Society 92, 1719–1724 (2009).

10. 10.

Yao, G., Wang, X., Wu, Y. & Li, L. Nb‐Doped 0.9 BaTiO3–0.1 (Bi0. 5Na0. 5) TiO3 Ceramics with Stable Dielectric Properties at High Temperature. Journal of the American Ceramic Society 95, 614–618 (2012).

11. 11.

Raengthon, N. & Cann, D. P. Dielectric relaxation in BaTiO3–Bi (Zn1/2Ti1/2) O3 ceramics. journal of the American Ceramic Society 95, 1604–1612 (2012).

12. 12.

Raengthon, N. & Cann, D. P. High-K (Ba 0.8 Bi 0.2)(Zn 0.1 Ti 0.9) O 3 ceramics for high-temperature capacitor applications. IEEE transactions on ultrasonics, ferroelectrics, and frequency control 58 (2011).

13. 13.

Yuan, Y., Zhao, C., Zhou, X., Tang, B. & Zhang, S. High-temperature stable dielectrics in Mn-modified (1-x) Bi0. 5Na0. 5TiO3-xCaTiO3 ceramics. Journal of Electroceramics 25, 212–217 (2010).

14. 14.

Yuan, Y., Zhou, X., Zhao, C., Li, B. & Zhang, S. High-temperature capacitor based on Ca-doped Bi0. 5Na0. 5TiO3-BaTiO3 ceramics. Journal of electronic materials 39, 2471–2475 (2010).

15. 15.

Wu, L. et al. Core-satellite BaTiO 3@ SrTiO 3 assemblies for a local compositionally graded relaxor ferroelectric capacitor with enhanced energy storage density and high energy efficiency. Journal of Materials Chemistry C 3, 750–758 (2015).

16. 16.

Ogihara, H., Randall, C. A. & Trolier‐McKinstry, S. Weakly coupled relaxor behavior of BaTiO3–BiScO3 ceramics. Journal of the American Ceramic Society 92, 110–118 (2009).

17. 17.

Yao, G., Wang, X., Zhang, Y., Shen, Z. & Li, L. Nb‐Modified 0.9 BaTiO3–0.1 (Bi0. 5Na0. 5) TiO3 Ceramics for X9R High‐Temperature Dielectrics Application Prepared by Coating Method. Journal of the American Ceramic Society 95, 3525–3531 (2012).

18. 18.

Schubring, N. W., Mantese, J. V., Micheli, A. L., Catalan, A. B. & Lopez, R. J. Charge pumping and pseudopyroelectric effect in active ferroelectric relaxor-type films. Physical review letters 68, 1778 (1992).

19. 19.

Mantese, J. V. et al. Slater model applied to polarization graded ferroelectrics. Applied physics letters 71, 2047–2049 (1997).

20. 20.

Mohammed, M. S. et al. Temperature dependence of conventional and effective pyroelectric coefficients for compositionally graded Ba x Sr 1− x TiO 3 films. Journal of applied physics 84, 3322–3325 (1998).

21. 21.

Jin, F. et al. Giant effective pyroelectric coefficients from graded ferroelectric devices. Applied physics letters 73, 2838–2840 (1998).

22. 22.

Ban, Z.-G., Alpay, S. & Mantese, J. Fundamentals of graded ferroic materials and devices. Physical Review B 67, 184104 (2003).

23. 23.

Kesim, M., Cole, M., Zhang, J., Misirlioglu, I. & Alpay, S. Tailoring dielectric properties of ferroelectric-dielectric multilayers. Applied Physics Letters 104, 022901 (2014).

24. 24.

Alpay, S., Ban, Z.-G. & Mantese, J. Thermodynamic analysis of temperature-graded ferroelectrics. Applied physics letters 82, 1269–1271 (2003).

25. 25.

Mantese, J. V. & Alpay, S. P. Graded ferroelectrics, transpacitors, and transponents. (Springer, 2005).

26. 26.

Okatan, M., Cole, M. & Alpay, S. Dielectric tunability of graded barium strontium titanate multilayers: Effect of thermal strains. Journal of Applied Physics 104, 104107 (2008).

27. 27.

Damodaran, A. R. et al. Large polarization gradients and temperature-stable responses in compositionally-graded ferroelectrics. Nature Communications 8 (2017).

28. 28.

Cole, M. et al. The fabrication and material properties of compositionally multilayered Ba 1− x Sr x Ti O 3 thin films for realization of temperature insensitive tunable phase shifter devices. Journal of Applied Physics 102, 034104 (2007).

29. 29.

Cole, M. et al. Microwave dielectric properties of graded barium strontium titanate films. Applied Physics Letters 92, 182906 (2008).

30. 30.

Cole, M., Ngo, E., Hirsch, S., Okatan, M. & Alpay, S. Dielectric properties of MgO-doped compositionally graded multilayer barium strontium titanate films. Applied Physics Letters 92, 072906 (2008).

31. 31.

Misirlioglu, I. & Alpay, S. Compositionally graded ferroelectrics as wide band gap semiconductors: Electrical domain structures and the origin of low dielectric loss. Acta Materialia 122, 266–276 (2017).

32. 32.

Maurya, D., Sun, F.-C., Alpay, S. P. & Priya, S. A new method for achieving enhanced dielectric response over a wide temperature range. Scientific reports 5 (2015).

33. 33.

Yang, W. & Chen, L. Q. Computer simulation of the dynamics of 180 ferroelectric domains. Journal of the American Ceramic Society 78, 2554–2556 (1995).

34. 34.

Hu, H.-L. & Chen, L.-Q. Computer simulation of 90 ferroelectric domain formation in two-dimensions. Materials Science and Engineering: A 238, 182–191 (1997).

35. 35.

Hu, H. L. & Chen, L. Q. Three‐Dimensional Computer Simulation of Ferroelectric Domain Formation. Journal of the American Ceramic Society 81, 492–500 (1998).

36. 36.

Semenovskaya, S. & Khachaturyan, A. Development of ferroelectric mixed states in a random field of static defects. Journal of applied physics 83, 5125–5136 (1998).

37. 37.

Maurya, D., Wongdamnern, N., Yimnirun, R. & Priya, S. Dielectric and ferroelectric response of compositionally graded bilayer and trilayer composites of BaTiO 3 and 0.975 BaTiO 3–0.025 Ba (Cu 1/3 Nb 2/3) O 3. Journal of Applied Physics 108, 124111 (2010).

38. 38.

Masó, N., Beltrán, H., Cordoncillo, E., Sinclair, D. C. & West, A. R. Polymorphism and Dielectric Properties of Nb‐Doped BaTiO3. Journal of the American Ceramic Society 91, 144–150 (2008).

39. 39.

Langhammer, H. T., Müller, T., Böttcher, R. & Abicht, H.-P. Crystal structure and related properties of copper-doped barium titanate ceramics. Solid State Sciences 5, 965–971 (2003).

40. 40.

Guo, X. & Zhang, Z. Grain size dependent grain boundary defect structure: case of doped zirconia. Acta materialia 51, 2539–2547 (2003).

41. 41.

Waser, R., Baiatu, T. & Härdtl, K. H. dc Electrical Degradation of Perovskite‐Type Titanates: I, Ceramics. Journal of the American Ceramic Society 73, 1645–1653 (1990).

42. 42.

Maiti, T., Guo, R. & Bhalla, A. Electric field dependent dielectric properties and high tunability of Ba Zr x Ti 1− x O 3 relaxor ferroelectrics. Applied physics letters 89, 122909 (2006).

43. 43.

Yang, G. et al. Dielectric behaviour of BaTiO3-based ceramic multilayer capacitors under high dc bias field. Journal of Physics D: Applied Physics 39, 3702 (2006).

44. 44.

Wang, Y. U. Field-induced inter-ferroelectric phase transformations and domain mechanisms in high-strain piezoelectric materials: insights from phase field modeling and simulation. Journal of materials science 44, 5225–5234 (2009).

45. 45.

Devonshire, A. F. XCVI. Theory of barium titanate: Part I. The London, Edinburgh, and Dublin Philosophical Magazine and Journal of Science 40, 1040–1063 (1949).

46. 46.

Amin, A., Haun, M., Badger, B., McKinstry, H. & Cross, L. A phenomenological Gibbs function for the single cell region of the PbZrO3: PbTiO3 solid solution system. Ferroelectrics 65, 107–130 (1985).

47. 47.

Haun, M. J., Zhuang, Z., Furman, E., Jang, S. J. & Cross, L. E. Electrostrictive Properties of the lead Zirconate Titanate Solid‐Solution System. Journal of the American Ceramic Society 72, 1140–1144 (1989).

48. 48.

Hlinka, J. & Márton, P. Phenomenological model of a 90° domain wall in BaTiO3-type ferroelectrics. Physical Review B 74, 104104 (2006).

## Acknowledgements

Financial support from DARPA MATRIX Program is acknowledged. The parallel computer simulations were performed on XSEDE supercomputers. D.M. and S.P. acknowledge the financial support from Office of basic energy science, department of energy (DE-FG02-06ER46290). Y.Y. acknowledges financial support from office of naval research through grant number (N00014-16-1-3043). Authors thanks AVX Corp. for the measurement on MLCC.

## Author information

Authors

### Contributions

H.-C.S. and D.M. conceived the idea. H.-C.S. and J. E.Z. prepared the main manuscript. H.-C.S. prepared BTS-BCN powders and fabricated MLCC samples. Y.Y. helped tape casting and fabrication of MLCC. H.-C.S., D.M. and Y.Y. characterized dielectric properties of BTS-BCN bulk and MLCC samples and discussed the experimental data. J.E.Z. and Y.U.W. carried out the phase field simulation for the compositionally graded architecture. S. Priya initiated and supervised research providing suggestions throughout the study. All authors discussed the results, wrote and commented on the manuscript.

### Corresponding author

Correspondence to Shashank Priya.

## Ethics declarations

### Competing Interests

The authors declare that they have no competing interests.

Publisher's note: Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.

## Rights and permissions

Reprints and Permissions

Song, HC., Zhou, J.E., Maurya, D. et al. Compositionally Graded Multilayer Ceramic Capacitors. Sci Rep 7, 12353 (2017). https://doi.org/10.1038/s41598-017-12402-7

• Accepted:

• Published:

• ### A novel multilayer composite structured thermoelectric module with high output power

• Xue Wang
• , Hongchao Wang
• , Wenbin Su
• , Teng Wang
• , Jinze Zhai
• , Tingting Chen
• , Andres Sotelo
•  & Chunlei Wang

Journal of Materials Chemistry A (2020)

• ### Microscale Mapping of Structure and Stress in Barium Titanate

• Jane A. Howell
• , Mark D. Vaudin
• , Lawrence H. Friedman
•  & Robert F. Cook

Journal of Research of the National Institute of Standards and Technology (2020)

• ### Enhanced dielectric performance of low firing NP0-type Bi2(Mg2/3Nb4/3)O7 based ceramics

• Haoran Zheng
• , Lingxia Li
• , Shihui Yu
• , Qianyu Guo
•  & Muying Wu

Ceramics International (2019)

• ### Structural tuning of dielectric properties of Ce-substituted Nd2Zr2O7

• Ghulam M. Mustafa
• , Murtaza Saleem
• , Shahid Atiq
• , Saira Riaz

Journal of Saudi Chemical Society (2019)