Most of what we know about adaptive immunity has come from inbred mouse studies, using methods that are often difficult or impossible to confirm in humans. In addition, vaccine responses in mice are often poorly predictive of responses to those same vaccines in humans. Here we use human tonsils, readily available lymphoid organs, to develop a functional organotypic system that recapitulates key germinal center features in vitro, including the production of antigen-specific antibodies, somatic hypermutation and affinity maturation, plasmablast differentiation and class-switch recombination. We use this system to define the essential cellular components necessary to produce an influenza vaccine response. We also show that it can be used to evaluate humoral immune responses to two priming antigens, rabies vaccine and an adenovirus-based severe acute respiratory syndrome coronavirus 2 vaccine, and to assess the effects of different adjuvants. This system should prove useful for studying critical mechanisms underlying adaptive immunity in much greater depth than previously possible and to rapidly test vaccine candidates and adjuvants in an entirely human system.
Antigen recognition by lymphocytes has been studied by immunologists since the discovery of antibodies and their specificities over a century ago1,2,3,4, followed by the more recent discovery of T cells and their antigen receptors in the 1960s–1980s5,6,7. The B cells that are responsible for forming a neutralizing antibody response develop within germinal centers (GCs) and extrafollicular regions in lymphoid organs8,9,10,11. Upon antigen presentation by antigen-presenting cells (APCs)12,13,14,15, T follicular helper (TFH) cells, and a variety of hematopoietic and non-hematopoietic cells interact and deliver signals to GC B cells for survival, proliferation, antibody affinity maturation, class-switch recombination and differentiation16,17. Almost all of these interactions have been elucidated through in vivo studies of inbred mice. While these have produced a wealth of important information8,18,19,20, the lack of a system that replicates the essential features of human adaptive immunity, such as affinity maturation and class switching, and the effects of adjuvants, leaves many mechanistic aspects inaccessible. This is especially important for vaccine testing since many candidates that worked in animal models ultimately fail in human trials21,22,23,24, suggesting that genetic and environmental differences among species are important considerations in vaccine development.
Many in vitro systems rely on isolation of small chunks or slices of a tissue sample to prepare explant cultures25,26,27,28,29,30,31. Explant methods, although useful for studying individual aspects of infection and immunity30,32,33,34, typically do not maintain cell composition for very long (3–4 d), nor do they capture all of the features of an adaptive immune response. Although bioreactor, chip-based and other specialized in vitro differentiation systems show promise, they too have not been able to replicate the complexities of adaptive immunity. We decided to take advantage of the widespread availability of human tonsils, lymphoid organs that are easily procured from tonsillectomy surgeries as discarded tissue, to develop an accessible system that replicates an antigen-specific adaptive immune response to a vaccine and supports key aspects of adaptive immunity.
Preparation of immune organoids from tonsils and other lymphoid tissues
Over 20 years ago, Owen and Jenkinson demonstrated that dissociated murine thymic cells could reassociate in culture and recapitulate major aspects of T cell selection35,36. We applied a similar approach to develop human tonsil cultures with dissociated cells that reaggregate in culture (Fig. 1a; see Supplementary Table 1 for tissue donor characteristics). For organoid preparation, frozen single-cell suspensions from tonsil tissues were thawed and plated at high density into the wells of permeable membrane plates (commonly known as Transwells) along with the antigen of interest. After several days in culture, reaggregated regions of clustered cells were visible (Fig. 1a). We assessed the cell composition of the reaggregated cultures after 7 d in the presence or absence of antigen and our optimized culture conditions (Methods) sustained appropriate tonsil cell composition (Fig. 1b). We used influenza vaccines and viruses as model antigens since much is already known about the features of the human influenza response in vivo. Upon stimulation with live attenuated influenza vaccine (LAIV), there were notable increases in B cell differentiation and a more structured culture morphology developed, suggesting additional activity in response to this immunogen.
We measured the capacity of organoid cultures to support B cell maturation and function upon LAIV stimulation (see Extended Data Fig. 1a for representative staining) and found that after 7 d, plasmablast frequencies were significantly increased compared to unstimulated controls (Fig. 1c; n = 15; P = 0.0002). Thirteen of the fifteen donors tested, ranging in age from 2–14 years, produced influenza-specific IgG antibodies in only the LAIV-stimulated samples (P < 0.0001). Of the two exceptions, one donor had a high response without stimulation and the other was a true nonresponder. The latter donor (a 3-year-old) may have been naive for influenza infection and had no reported influenza vaccination. The production of specific antibody was not a generic effect of stimulation, as total (that is, antigen agnostic) IgG was reduced by LAIV (Fig. 1d). We also performed enzyme-linked immune absorbent spot (ELISpot) analysis on day-7 cultures from five donors and found influenza-specific antibody-secreting cells (ASCs) ranging from 0.1–1.5% of total B cells (Fig. 1e; representative ELISpot data in Extended Data Fig. 1b). Almost no influenza-specific ASCs were identified in unstimulated tonsil cultures (<0.02% of total B cells in all donors). The Transwell organoid culture strategy was superior to flat-bottom tissue culture plates of similar surface area for growing tonsil mononuclear cells (Extended Data Fig. 1c).
We also tested whether our organoid culture strategy could support human lung-draining lymph node and spleen samples (Fig. 1f). These organoids responded to both LAIV and wild-type A/California H1N1 influenza virus by producing influenza-specific antibodies at levels substantially above those of control cultures and equivalent to tonsil organoids.
Longitudinal analysis of tonsil cultures in response to LAIV
Given the evidence of B cell maturation and antibody secretion in organoid cultures stimulated with LAIV, we performed longitudinal analyses to observe the differentiation process over time. CD38 and CD27 expression patterns on B cells from LAIV-stimulated cultures clearly evolved (Fig. 2a), indicating an early transition to a pre-GC phenotype (CD38+CD27−), and in two of three donors, this was followed by plasmablast differentiation (Fig. 2b). The frequency of plasmablasts typically correlated with the total amount of specific antibodies produced (Extended Data Fig. 1d). Changes in T cell phenotypes were also observed, including recovery of TFH (CXCR5+CD4+) cells during culture (in both unstimulated and LAIV-stimulated organoids), as well as transient CD4+ and CD8+ T cell activation at day 7 in LAIV-stimulated cultures (Fig. 2c). Organoids prepared from only one of the over 50 donors tested (IMD012) did not produce influenza-specific antibodies (Fig. 2d). With four additional donors, we confirmed that influenza-specific antibodies are produced with the expected kinetics (between days 5 and 10). We also gauged the ability of these cultures to produce neutralizing antibodies; in the two strains tested (of the four LAIV strains), vaccine-stimulated culture supernatants showed neutralizing capabilities, while unstimulated controls did not (Fig. 2e).
We also assessed the T cell response in HLA-A2+ donors using class I tetramers targeting the immunodominant influenza M1 specificity (Fig. 2f). Three of the four donors tested showed a two- to ten-fold expansion of M1-specific CD8+ T cells by day 7 after stimulation with LAIV. The one nonresponder had fewer M1-specific CD8+ T cells in their starting repertoire compared to the other donors, which may explain their poor CD8+ T cell response.
Spatial organization of tonsil organoids
During an adaptive immune response, peripheral lymphoid organs like the tonsils, lymph nodes and spleen develop GCs. B cells congregate in the GC area, whereas T cells are largely in outlying areas8,19. In the organoid cultures, we found GC-like structures with distinct B cell- and T cell-rich aggregates in both LAIV-stimulated and unstimulated cultures, starting around 48 h after culture initiation. These progressed to well-defined clusters by days 4–7, particularly in LAIV-treated cultures (Fig. 3a and Extended Data Fig. 2). We analyzed the embedded, frozen sections of three donors by fluorescent confocal microscopy and found evidence of light and dark zone organization, as detected by separation of CD83 and CXCR4 staining B cells, respectively, which are characteristic of GCs (Fig. 3a; additional representative images are available in Extended Data Figs. 2 and 3a).
We also performed a single-cell RNA-seq analysis along with DNA-barcoded antibodies using the BD Rhapsody platform to characterize the expression profiles of GC-phenotype B cells in organoid cultures. Dimensionality reduction (uniform manifold approximation and projection (UMAP)) was used to analyze GC B cells across different time points (Fig. 3b). Overall, GC B cells (CD38+CD27+) from the different days and time points clustered together, showing that their expression profiles were similar. The top overexpressed genes in GC B cells (compared to naive B cells) at day 5 of LAIV-stimulated cultures were related to antibody secretion (immunoglobulin heavy chains, light chains and J chain) and key B cell differentiation, proliferation and B cell receptor (BCR) signaling genes (XBP1, POU2AF1, S100A10 and PCNA). These were also the top differentially expressed genes between direct ex vivo GC and naive B cells. These data show that the cultures can functionally respond to antigen-specific stimulation, that light and dark zone phenotype B cells separate into distinct areas (Fig. 3a and Extended Data Fig. 3a) and that B cells with a GC phenotype have similar transcriptional profiles on day 0 and day 5 after culture (Fig. 3b), which collectively support the conclusion that these cultures can be considered organoids.
Diversity and maturation of hemagglutinin-specific B cells
We next examined whether activation-induced cytidine deaminase (AID), which is required for both somatic hypermutation and class switching, was expressed in these cultures. AID protein levels (Fig. 3c; see representative staining in Extended Data Fig. 3b) were significantly increased in pre-GC and GC B cells in 4-day-old organoid cultures (prevalence shown in Fig. 3c). We also single-cell sequenced BCRs from high-affinity A/California 2009 H1N1 hemagglutinin (HA)-specific plasmablasts (and other activated B cells) using a HA trimer construct37 on day-0 and day-7 LAIV-stimulated cultures to evaluate affinity maturation and isotype switching. As previously reported in peripheral blood plasmablasts of influenza-vaccinated volunteers38, immunoglobulin heavy-chain variable gene cluster (IGHV) 3 and IGHV4 dominated the response (Fig. 3d; see Extended Data Fig. 4 for complete dataset). HA-specific BCRs from LAIV-stimulated organoids were quite diverse in both gene usage and isotype; numerous oligoclonal expansions were seen at day 7, but these clones were distinct from those detected in day-0 high-affinity HA+ B cells. Clonally related BCR families were also found in LAIV-stimulated organoids, and in one of two donors, we found clonal families with single amino acid changes, showing diversification within HA-specific lineages. Using bulk BCR sequencing of total non-naive B cells, we found lineages that began as the IgM isotype and class switched during organoid culture (mostly to IgG1 and IgA1), usually with additional mutations, by day 7 (Extended Data Fig. 5).
Affinity maturation in tonsil organoids
Affinity maturation is another key function of GCs. To evaluate this, we performed depletion experiments using FACS to eliminate preexisting high-affinity HA+ B cells and also any non-naive B cells from the tonsil cell pool. Cultures were then prepared from the depleted cells, stimulated with LAIV, and stained again on day 10 to assess the development of new high-affinity HA+ B cells (Fig. 3e and Extended Data Fig. 6). In three of four donors tested, HA+ B cells reappeared in depleted cultures and influenza-specific secreted antibodies were detectable (Fig. 3f), demonstrating that affinity maturation can be directly observed in this system.
Next, we used IgH sequencing to analyze the BCR repertoire in naive versus affinity matured B cells in response to LAIV stimulation. Here, we prepared cultures where naive, HA− B cells were the only B cell source (Fig. 4a and Methods). We used day-0 HA+ B cells as the reference for high-affinity BCRs and to infer HA specificity. Organoid cultures were harvested on day 7 for bulk BCR repertoire sequencing (Fig. 4a). We compared the repertoires of these cultures to both the in vivo high-affinity HA+ B cells from day-0 tonsil cells that were depleted by FACS and the HA− naive B cells that went into culture preparations. Of the six donors tested, five secreted antibodies specific for vaccine components and four had detectable antibodies specific for the A/California 2009 H1N1 HA protein on day 7 after stimulation (Fig. 4b), showing that we can derive HA-specific antibodies from naive B cells.
Somatic hypermutation was significantly increased in day-7 LAIV-stimulated cultures compared to unstimulated control cultures and was particularly enhanced where A/California 2009 H1N1 HA antibodies were detected (IMD006, 013, 014 and 102; Fig. 4c). We also followed the development of BCR sequences likely (within one amino acid) to be specific for influenza strain A/California H1N1. In two of the six donors tested (IMD006 and IMD014), the B cell clones with inferred HA specificity for this strain were also larger than those without known HA specificity and this was dependent on vaccine stimulation (Fig. 4d). In these same donors, the average diversity was also increased, with more unique molecules per clonal lineage in HA-specific B cells from LAIV-stimulated cultures (Fig. 4d). We found other expanded and diverse lineages only in the vaccine-stimulated cultures, likely responding to other antigens or strains. We also found direct evidence for BCR sequence evolution to increased HA affinity (Fig. 4e). Here a root sequence with four nucleotide mutations from the germline heavy-chain sequence acquired an additional ten mutations to achieve an exact amino acid match to a known high-affinity HA specificity. Taken together, these data confirm that antigen-driven somatic hypermutation, affinity maturation and class switching are supported in tonsil organoid cultures.
Contributions of individual cell types to influenza responses
A major advantage of in vitro systems is the ability to define the essential components. Therefore, we depleted APC, T cell and B cell subsets and compared plasmablast differentiation (Fig. 5a,c) and antigen-specific antibody secretion (Fig. 5b,d) to wild-type organoids. Despite their low starting frequency (0.1–0.5% of live), depleting myeloid and plasmacytoid dendritic cell (pDC) populations completely abrogated plasmablast differentiation (Fig. 5a) and depleting pDCs alone was sufficient to dramatically reduce the antibody response to LAIV (Fig. 5b). We were able to rescue the effect of pDC loss by adding type I interferon (IFN), showing that type I IFN production is the main pDC function (Extended Data Fig. 7a).
As expected, depleting CD4+ cells (Extended Data Fig. 7b) significantly reduced plasmablast differentiation, although some influenza-specific antibodies were still detectable (Fig. 5c,d). We analyzed the effect of donor age and found that CD4+ T cell-depleted organoids from younger children were almost entirely unable to secrete influenza-specific antibody (Fig. 5e), in contrast to older donors who could make antibody responses. We also characterized the affinities of antibodies against A/California/07/2009 H1N1 HA in CD4+-depleted cultures. The dissociation rates for antibodies raised in the absence of CD4+ cells were four- to ten-fold higher than wild-type controls (Fig. 5f and Extended Data Fig. 7c), even when the quantity of specific antibody was comparable between intact and CD4+-depleted cultures. Thus, CD4+ T cells are important for both the magnitude and affinity of the antibody response.
We determined that three to four cell types were minimally required to consistently achieve detectable plasmablast differentiation and naive antibody responses against LAIV: naive B cells, APCs, CD4+ T cells and, in some donors, a mixed population of CD45− stromal cells (Fig. 5g). Notably, naive CD4+ T cells were either as good or better than memory CD4+ T cells in their ability to help B cells differentiate into plasmablasts and stimulate influenza-specific antibodies (Fig. 5h).
Response to other antigens and the effect of adjuvants
We next investigated whether tonsil organoids could also respond to non-influenza memory antigens. We stimulated tonsil organoids with the measles, mumps and rubella (MMR) vaccine, which is recommended to be administered at 12 months, and assessed plasmablast formation and antigen-specific IgG responses. These cultures had significantly increased plasmablasts compared to controls (Fig. 6a), and six of the seven donors made measles-specific IgG, while the mumps and rubella responses were weaker and only detected in three of the older children tested (Fig. 6b).
To determine whether tonsil organoids could serve as a platform for priming antigen-specific adaptive responses, we first stimulated cells with naive antigen phycoerythrin (PE), with and without adjuvants. Here we saw a substantial (tenfold) increase in PE+ B cells in PE-stimulated cultures compared to unstimulated or irrelevant antigen-stimulated cultures (Fig. 6c). The frequency of PE+ B cells could also be enhanced by alum hydrogel but not imiquimod (Fig. 6d), indicating that at least some naive responses can be elicited and modulated by appropriate adjuvants. We next tested the ability of tonsils, lung-draining lymph nodes and spleen cultures to respond to the T cell-dependent rabies vaccine. The donors had not previously received this vaccine. Tonsil B cells were more differentiated in vaccine-stimulated cultures after 14 d in organoid culture and four of ten donors had detectable increases in rabies nucleoprotein-specific IgM (Fig. 6e). Lung-draining lymph node and spleen organoids also showed modest rabies-specific antibody production, with some specific IgM but not IgG production, consistent with a priming response39 (Fig. 6f).
Finally, we investigated the ability of tonsil organoids to respond to a series of vaccine candidates developed in response to severe acute respiratory syndrome coronavirus 2 (SARS-CoV-2). These vaccine candidates use a replication-deficient type 5 adenovirus (Ad5) that encodes either the full-length viral spike protein, spike and nucleocapsid protein or the S1 spike subunit with nucleocapsid in the Ad5 E1 region. All tonsil tissue samples were collected before the SARS-CoV-2 pandemic and thus naive to these antigens. On day 14 after stimulation, we observed plasmablast differentiation in a subset of donors and significant CD8 T cell activation compared to unstimulated controls (Fig. 6g). Using a protein microarray to detect antibody specificities against SARS-CoV-2, specific IgG and IgA antibodies were present for some spike and nucleocapsid proteins in a few donors. One particularly robust responder, IMD163, is shown in Fig. 6g (data from all donors are available in Extended Data Fig. 8). This shows that immune organoid cultures can be used to analyze and compare vaccine candidates to new and previously encountered antigens.
Although GCs have been studied extensively in mice, to our knowledge this is the first report of an in vitro system supporting antigen-specific somatic hypermutation, affinity maturation and class switching of human B cells. Tonsils are a readily accessible and underutilized source of human immune tissue and contain all the cell types involved in adaptive immunity, including those largely absent from peripheral blood. We used tonsil organoids to characterize features of the human influenza response and validated and extended findings from previous human and murine studies. We show that the B cell response to influenza vaccine is diverse and can develop from the naive repertoire. We found that preexisting HA-specific B cells had 5–10 heavy-chain nucleotide mutations (2–4% mutation rate), and LAIV-stimulated organoids prepared with naive-only B cells had 3–9 mutations, which was adequate to make specific antibodies (Fig. 4). These rates are in line with the average 5% mutation rate measured in influenza-vaccinated adults40.
Human immune responses are incredibly variable, as seen in the current SARS-CoV-2 pandemic, and a major goal of vaccine development is to confer protective immunity as broadly as possible. Another useful feature of the organoid system is its ability to assess immune response variability. We found that while the organoids from most donors respond to LAIV, the magnitude and kinetics of those responses vary widely. In a test of 15 donors, organoids prepared from one donor did not respond to LAIV within 7 d (Fig. 1). This individual was young and not vaccinated against influenza, suggesting that they could be naive to influenza, and organoids prepared from their cells might require more time to mount a response. In our longitudinal analyses (Fig. 2), we identified a nonresponder who was treated with daily inhaled corticosteroids, demonstrating the sensitivity of the system to immunosuppressive agents. Using SARS-CoV-2 vaccine candidates, we found even more variability, with some individuals unable to make B cell and/or T cell responses. This further reinforces the need for a system like this to assess broad immunogenicity before clinical studies.
Using depletion studies, we established the functional relevance of individual immune cell types to the influenza response. pDCs were crucial to the antibody response, although they could be replaced by exogenous type I IFN. These data are consistent with a previous study that found that pDCs induce human blood B cell differentiation through type I IFN41 but contrast with a murine influenza challenge study that showed pDCs were dispensable to the response42, highlighting a difference between murine and human systems. We also identified a role for preexisting plasmablasts/plasma cells in regulating B cell differentiation (Fig. 5a,b). When plasmablasts were depleted at the initiation of the culture, influenza-specific antibody production was increased compared to wild-type controls. Secondary lymphoid tissues are competitive niches for plasma cell survival outside of the bone marrow43, so depletion of preexisting plasma cells may promote antigen-specific plasmablast survival. We demonstrated that T cell help plays an age-dependent role in the magnitude of the influenza-specific antibody response and showed that CD4+ T cells play an additional role in affinity maturation and B cell selection (Fig. 5). Memory CD4+ T cells from older children better sustained a naive B cell response, suggesting that T cell help is refined by in vivo exposure. These findings are in line with an earlier mouse study showing that memory T cells can contribute to GC responses even though naive B cells typically did not in their system44. Stem-specific antibodies were also only detectable when CD4+ T cells were present, suggesting that manipulating T cell help is a reasonable strategy to consider for future vaccine design.
Previous efforts to create artificial human lymphoid tissues depended on specialized bioreactors45,46 or complex in vitro differentiation strategies47. Blood-derived mononuclear cells combined with monocyte-derived dendritic cells can stimulate IgM and cytokine secretion consistent with an adaptive immune response45,48. It is questionable whether in vitro matured dendritic cells recapitulate the conditions that coordinate T and B cell responses in lymphoid tissues. More importantly, a major limitation of bioreactor systems is that they do not show mature GCs, class switching or affinity maturation49, likely because many cells required for GC function are absent from peripheral blood mononuclear cells. Recent work illustrated that key aspects of the immune microenvironment can be captured in organoids in several studies that focused on conferring immune protection upon transplantation into mice50,51 or recapitulating features of the GC response52,53. In these studies, designer hydrogel scaffolds for B cells combined with engineered fibroblasts were used to reveal transcriptional feedback loops involved in GC formation52 but lacked antigen specificity. Most recently, maleimide-functionalized hydrogel was shown to support GC B cell activation and an antigen-specific response in murine B cell organoid cultures53. However, these methods do not incorporate autologous APCs nor T cells that are both crucial to refine the adaptive immune response in vivo. Due to the need for bioengineered fibroblast cell lines to provide necessary survival signals, these techniques are challenging to translate to human cells because of the diversity of human leukocyte antigen genes and generation of mixed leukocyte reactions. Previous techniques to produce in vitro models of human adaptive immunity have not been widely adopted because of reliance on specialized equipment or challenging technical protocols, poor throughput, lack of evidence for antigen-specific responses, affinity maturation and/or absence of cells known to be crucial to important features of adaptive immunity. Although humanized mice are increasingly used, they are expensive to procure and still have many limitations in terms of recapitulating human immunity54.
Although this is a powerful system to assess various aspects of adaptive immunity to influenza antigens, there are some limitations. It has been established that the LAIV is less effective than the inactivated formulation in adults55, presumably due to the presence of preexisting antibodies at mucosal sites in non-naive individuals. Such conditions could theoretically be mimicked by introducing autologous serum or spiking in influenza-specific antibodies at the initiation of organoid culture. Another challenge is benchmarking against in vivo tissue responses from immunized humans; such studies are now underway to characterize tonsil and lymph node responses to immunization in situ and compare them to organoid cultures. Finally, the system we describe here involves an immunological organ model in isolation. In a true infection or immunization, the antigens first encounter immune cells at a distal site (for example, skin, muscle and nasopharyngeal mucosa) and then migrate to the lymph nodes, tonsils or spleen where GCs form and B cells are selected. Many adjuvants regulate immune cell migration and local microenvironmental characteristics that are not well captured in tonsil organoids in isolation and thus would not be well suited for studying using this model, although adjuvants that act directly on immune cells can be investigated. Future studies will aim to incorporate these migratory features to capture additional features of the adaptive response in humans.
Informed consent and sample collection
Whole tonsils from 150 consented individuals undergoing surgery for obstructive sleep apnea, hypertrophy or recurrent tonsillitis were collected in accordance with the Stanford University Institutional Review Board (IRB). Ethics approval was granted by the Stanford University IRB (protocols 30837 and 47690). Written informed consent was obtained from adult participants and from the legal guardians of children aged 0–17 years; written informed assent was also obtained from children aged 7 years and older. In this cohort, the participants were children aged 2–17 years (n = 57) and adults (n = 3) who had surgery for obstructive sleep apnea and/or hypertrophy, and overall, tonsil tissue was typically healthy. Whole tonsils were collected in saline after surgery and then immersed in an antimicrobial bath of Ham’s F12 medium (Gibco) containing Normocin (InvivoGen), penicillin and streptomycin for 1 h at 4 °C for decontamination of the tissue. Tonsils were then briefly rinsed with PBS and processed as needed for culturing (see below).
Donor lung lymph nodes and spleens were provided by the Gift of Hope Organ and Tissue Donor Network to the University of Chicago. These tissues were determined to have IRB Exempt Status by the University of Chicago IRB. Only de-identified demographic information was obtained.
Tissue and organoid preparation
For cryopreservation of tonsil cells, tissue was dissected into roughly 5 mm × 5 mm × 5 mm pieces and manually disrupted into a suspension by processing through a 100-μm strainer with a syringe plunger. Enzymatic dissociation was not necessary and did not improve the response to LAIV from cryopreserved cells. Tissue debris was reduced by Ficoll density gradient separation, although this step was not required for tonsil organoid development. After washing with complete medium (RPMI with glutamax, 10% FBS, 1× nonessential amino acids, 1× sodium pyruvate, 1× penicillin–streptomycin, 1× Normocin (InvivoGen) and 1× insulin/selenium/transferrin cocktail (Gibco)), cells were enumerated and frozen into aliquots in FBS + 10% DMSO. Frozen cells were stored at −140 °C until use.
For lung-draining lymph nodes and spleen samples, tissues were collected in saline or Hank’s Balanced Salt Solution, diced into small pieces and pressed through nylon mesh (Nitex) to break up the tissue. Cells were isolated with Ficoll density gradient separation, washed, enumerated and frozen in FBS + 10% DMSO. Frozen samples were stored in liquid nitrogen until use.
For culture of cryopreserved cells, aliquots were thawed into complete medium, enumerated and resuspended to 6 × 107 cells per ml for larger cultures or 2 × 107 cells per ml for smaller cultures. Cells were plated, 100 μl per well, into permeable (0.4-μm pore size) membranes (24-well size PTFE or polycarbonate membranes in standard 12-well plates or 96-well polycarbonate membrane plates with single-well receiver trays; Corning or Millipore), with the lower chamber consisting of complete medium (1 ml for 12-well plates, 200 μl for 96-well plates) supplemented with 1 μg ml−1 of recombinant human B cell-activating factor (BAFF; BioLegend). Adding a small amount of BAFF improved total B cell survival (and thus increased overall cell recovery) but was not a requirement for plasmablast differentiation or antibody secretion.
LAIV (1 μl per well, equivalent of 1.6 × 104 to 1.6 × 105 fluorescent focus units per strain; FluMist Quadrivalent, Medimmune), wild-type influenza virus (A/California/07/2009 pandemic strain; a gift from H. Greenberg and X.-S. He), MMR vaccine (5 μl per culture; Merck), R-phycoerythrin (1 μg per culture; Thermo Fisher), rabies vaccine (10 μl per culture; Imovax, Sanofi Pasteur) or Ad5-vectored SARS-CoV-2 vaccine candidate (1 × 108 infectious units per culture; Vaxart) was then added directly to the cell-containing portion of the culture setup. For adjuvant testing, alum (0.01%; InvivoGen, sold as a 2% stock wet gel with 9–11 mg ml−1 stock aluminum content) or imiquimod (2.5 μg ml−1; InvivoGen) was added directly into the culture immediately after antigen addition. Cultures were incubated at 37 °C, 5% CO2 with humidity and supplemented with additional medium to the lower wells as necessary. Hypoxic conditions (5% O2) were tested for B cell differentiation and antibody secretion and were not significantly different from cultures maintained at standard incubator oxygen levels (17–21%).
For the Ad5-vectored vaccine candidates, recombinant adenoviral constructs were produced using the publicly available SARS-CoV-2 DNA sequence (GenBank accession no. MN908947.3). Spike and nucleocapsid protein sequences were synthesized and codon optimized for expression in human cells and cloned into the E1 region as previously described56. The same vector backbone has been used previously in clinical trials for oral recombinant adenovirus tablets57,58. The Ad-S adenoviral vector contains a spike protein under the human cytomegalovirus (CMV) promoter. The Ad-SN vector contains spike under the CMV promoter and nucleocapsid under the human beta-actin promoter. The recombinant Ad-S1N vector uses a fusion sequence combining the S1 region of the SARS-CoV-2 spike gene (including the native furin site between S1 and S2) with the full-length SARS-CoV-2 nucleocapsid gene. All vaccine candidates were purified by cesium chloride density centrifugation and provided in a liquid form for cell culture experiments.
Organoids were harvested from the upper portion of the permeable membranes by rinsing the membranes with PBS. Cells were washed with FACS buffer (PBS + 0.1% BSA, 0.05% sodium azide and 2 mM EDTA) and stained at 4 °C with the following anti-human antibodies in the presence of Fc block and live/dead Aqua Zombie stain, all from BioLegend unless otherwise noted: FITC CD138 (1/100), FITC CD116 (1/100), FITC CD21 (1/50), FITC or Ax488 CXCR5 (1/33), PerCP-Cy5.5 CD8 (1/100), PerCP-Cy5.5 CD33 (1/100), PE CD19 (1/100), PE CD56 (1/100), PE gamma-delta TCR (1/100), PE-Cy7 CD27 (1/100), PE-Cy7 CD123 (1/50), PE-Cy7 CD8 (1/100), APC CD38 (1/200), APC HLA-DR (1/100), APC CD27 (1/200), Ax700 CD45 (1/100), Ax700 CD14 (1/100), APC-Cy7 IgD (1/50), APC-Cy7 CD16 (1/100), APC-Cy7 CD45RA (1/100), Pacific Blue HLA-DR (1/100), Pacific Blue PD-1 (1/50), BV605 CD3 (1/100), BV650 CD4 (1/100), BV650 CD19 (1/100), BUV395 IgM (1/20; BD Biosciences) and BUV395 CD45RA (1/20; BD Biosciences).
For AID staining, after surface staining, the cells were fixed and permeabilized (eBioscience) and stained intracellularly with biotinylated anti-AID antibody (1/100; clone mAID-2; eBioscience) followed by PE-streptavidin (eBioscience). A no-AID antibody control was used to discriminate positive signal. All analyzer data were collected on BD LSRII instruments and analyzed using FlowJo (TreeStar).
HLA-A2 tetramers were prepared as previously described59, with ultraviolet (UV)-sensitive peptide cleavage and exchange for the A2 immunodominant influenza M1 peptide (GILGFVFTL) or an irrelevant CMV pp65 peptide (NLVPMVATV) as a control; tetramers were prepared from the peptide-exchanged monomers by conjugation to PE-streptavidin and APC-streptavidin, respectively (eBioscience). For staining, HLA-A2 donor organoids were harvested, washed with FACS buffer and stained for 1 h at 4 °C with tetramers (0.5 μg of monomer per test) in the presence of Fc block. During the last 30 min of tetramer staining, lineage-defining antibodies were added, and samples were washed with FACS buffer. For analysis, influenza M1 tetramer-positive CD8+ T cells were identified as single-positive T cells for the influenza tetramer (negative for CMV tetramer) and with staining above a no-influenza-tetramer staining control.
Antibody detection by ELISA
For detection of influenza-specific antibodies, ELISA plates (Costar) were coated with 0.1 μg per well of season-matched Fluzone Quadrivalent inactivated influenza vaccine (based on reported total HA content from the manufacturer; Sanofi) to act as the capture antigen. For A/California HA antibody detection, recombinantly expressed soluble HA trimers were used in place of the inactivated vaccine as the capture antigen. Diluted (1:20 or 1:50) culture supernatants were added to coated, blocked plates. A human pan-influenza monoclonal IgG antibody (H1N13–M; Alpha Diagnostics) was used as a standard to estimate specific antibody concentration for experiments where antibody concentration is quantitatively defined. Horseradish peroxidase-conjugated anti-human secondary antibodies to either IgM/IgG/IgA (Sigma) or Fc-IgG alone (Bethyl; adsorbed for other isotypes) were used to detect bound antibodies. Plates were developed with TMB substrate solution (Thermo Scientific), quenched with sulfuric acid and read at 450 nm. Neutralization experiments were performed by Monogram Biosciences with a pseudovirus neutralization assay with HA matching the vaccine antigen strains.
For detection of total IgG, culture supernatants were diluted at 1:500 and assayed by ELISA (Thermo Scientific) following manufacturer’s instructions. For detection of MMR-specific IgG, culture supernatants were tested by ELISA (Abcam) following the manufacturer’s instructions. Supernatants were diluted at 1:2.5 with the provided sample diluent and serial twofold dilutions out to 1:40 confirmed signal specificity (data not shown). To measure rabies nucleoprotein-specific IgM and IgG, supernatants were diluted at 1:5 with specific IgM and IgG detection kits (Alpha Diagnostic).
Antibody detection by protein microarray
Organoid cultures stimulated with recombinant adenoviral vectors with SARS-CoV-2 sequences were tested for specific antibody production using a protein microarray. The technology has been previously described for the detection of influenza-specific antibodies60 and was recently adapted to include commercially available SARS-CoV-2 proteins61. The SARS-CoV-2 proteins are commercially available from Sino Biological. Briefly, day-14 culture supernatants were diluted 1:1 with blocking buffer and incubated for 30 min. Then, diluted samples were added to the microarray for overnight hybridization. The array was washed three times with Tris-buffered saline containing Tween20, then treated with Qdot-conjugated anti-IgM, IgG or IgA secondary antibodies for 2 h. After another three washes, the array was dried and read, with signal intensities representing relative antibody quantities bound to each protein spot.
Immunofluorescence microscopy samples were prepared from frozen tonsil cells stimulated with LAIV and harvested 4 or 7 d after stimulation. Permeable membrane inserts containing organoids were gently immersed in PBS, fixed with 4% paraformaldehyde in PBS for 30 min at 4 °C and washed three times with water. Cultures were kept at room temperature and incubated for 20 min in increasing concentrations of warmed (37 °C) OCT Compound (Fisher) diluted in PBS at 25%, 50% and 75% (vol/vol), with a final incubation in pure OCT. Samples were snap frozen on dry ice, inserts were removed with forceps, and samples were embedded in an additional layer of OCT and frozen.
Embedded samples were sectioned at 25 μm and adhered to poly-l-lysine-coated coverslips. Sections were dried for 4 min in a dehumidified chamber and permeabilized in acetone for 10 min at room temperature. Rehydration was performed in stain buffer (1% BSA, 1% normal goat serum and 0.01% sodium azide in PBS) for 30 min. Sections were stained first with primary unconjugated antibodies at room temperature for 3 h. Secondary antibody staining was performed for 1 h at room temperature followed by primary direct conjugate antibodies for 3 h at room temperature.
Immunofluorescence staining was performed using the following antibodies at the stated concentrations: BioLegend: CD3-BV421 (SK7; 1:25), CD4-AF594 (RPA-T4; 1:50), CD19–AF647 (SJ25C1; 1:25), CXCR4 (12G5; 1:100), CD21-FITC (Bu32; 1:100), PD-1-AF488 (NAT105; 1:100), BCL-6 (IG191E/A8; 1:50); Sigma-Aldrich: CXCR5 (Polyclonal; 1:100), CD83 (Polyclonal; 1:100); Thermo Fisher: AID (ZA001; 1:100), CD8-AF488 (AMC908; 1:100), CD20-eFluor 615 (L26; 1:100), CD20-eFluor 660 (L26; 1:100); BD Biosciences: Ki67-BV421 (B56; 1:5); Fisher Science: IgD-AF488 (IgD26; 1:10).
The following secondary antibodies from Thermo Fisher and their dilutions were used: goat anti-mouse IgG (H + L) AF Plus 555 (1:200), goat anti-rabbit IgG (H + L) AF Plus 555 (1:200), goat anti-rabbit IgG (H + L) AF Plus 594 (1:200).
After collecting imaging data from antibody markers, slides were stained with 1 μg ml−1 DAPI to visualize nuclear staining. Imaging was performed on an Inverted Zeiss LSM 880 confocal instrument using ×25 magnification. Sample z-stacks were taken at 2-μm slices. DAPI was stimulated at 405 nm, FITC/Alexa Fluor 488 at 488 nm, Alexa Fluor 555 at 561 nm and Alexa Fluor 594 at 594 nm. Images were processed in ImageJ (version 2.0.0). Tile stitching was performed with the Grid/Collection stitching tool using positions from files in the order defined by the image metadata. The fusion method used was Linear Blending, with Computer Overlap and Ignore Calibration (all other parameters were set to default). After despeckling, z-stacks were merged using ZProjection by Maximum Intensity and contrast adjusted to better present structure, and channels were stacked to RGB and a scale bar added.
To quantify the fraction of CXCR4- and CD83-expressing cells in GC areas, GCs were cropped into two portions that resembled light and dark zone-like regions as shown on the imaging figure. CD20-, CD83- and CXCR4-positive cells were manually counted (multipoint tool in ImageJ) in addition to double- and triple-positive cells. CD83+CXCR4−CD20+ and CD83−CXCR4+CD20+ cells in each region were calculated and presented as a proportion of the total CD20+ population from the same area. To determine the mean intensities of marker expressions in light and dark zone regions, images were converted to RGB using ‘stack to RGB’ and then ‘color histogram’ was performed on each channel using ImageJ, which displays a histogram of the intensity values. The mean of each channel was used to compare the average marker expression between different regions of equivalent size.
ASCs were detected using an ELISpot protocol based on work by Shah and Koelsch62. Briefly, cultures that were either stimulated for 7 d with LAIV or left unstimulated were resuspended and enumerated, then plated on inactivated influenza vaccine-coated and blocked 96-well PVDF membrane plates (Millipore). Each sample was plated with three, threefold dilutions in triplicate, and total live-cell counts ranged from 2.22 × 104 to 1.07 × 105 cells per well at a 1:9 dilution, which was used for enumeration of ASCs. Cells were incubated on these membranes, undisturbed for 5 h at 37 °C. Plates were then washed and treated with horseradish peroxidase-conjugated anti-IgG/IgA/IgM secondary antibody. After incubation overnight at 4 °C, plates were washed and developed with AEC substrate (BD), washed 20 times with water, dried, and spots were enumerated. The frequency of ASCs out of total B cells was determined from B cell flow cytometry data analysis and the direct cell enumeration counts.
Cells from either day-0 tonsils (processed, cryopreserved and thawed) or organoids (from day 5 and day 9 after stimulation with LAIV or left unstimulated) were stained with a mixture of fluorophore-conjugated antibodies to enable sorting for CD45+CD19+CD3− B cells and for sequencing detection of DNA-tagged antibodies (CD20 clone L27, CD19 clone SJ25C1, CD71 clone L01.1, IgM clone G20-127, IgA clone A59, CD161 clone HP-3G10, CD27 clone L128, CD38 clone HIT2, IgD clone IA6-2, IgG clone G18-145, CD83 clone HB15E, CXCR4 clone 12G5, TCR Vg9 clone B3, CD3 UCHT1, CD4 clone SK3, CD8 clone RPA-T8 and CXCR5 clone RF8B2). A cocktail of DNA-tagged antibodies was used to allow manual gating on B cells (CD19+CD3−) and B cell subsets (CD27 and CD38) to identify GC B cells and naive B cells. The sorted cells were tagged with sample barcodes to enable pooling. The cells were loaded and captured from the pooled sample using the BD Rhapsody pipeline following the manufacturer’s instructions to prepare the libraries, using the targeted human immune gene panel for amplification. Libraries were sequenced using Illumina Novaseq platforms and the resulting data processed using the Rhapsody analysis pipeline. Using SeqGeq (BD) software, individual samples were debarcoded, and B cell subsets were gated based on DNA-barcoded antibodies for CD3, CD19, CD27 and CD38. Individual populations were then exported along with their gene expression profiles for analyses. UMAP dimensionality reduction was run using the R package ‘umap’ on gene (and not DNA-tagged antibody) expression profiles. For fold change expression analyses, genes that were overexpressed in GC B cells by at least 1.5-fold were plotted.
B cell receptor sequencing
For isotype-switching analysis, tonsil cells from day-0 or day-7 organoids were harvested, washed with FACS buffer, and stained with a cocktail of lineage-defining antibodies as above in the presence of Fc block, then bulk sorted using a FACS Fusion or Aria II instrument. Bulk sequencing of immunoglobulin heavy-chain gene rearrangements for isotype-switching analysis was carried out as previously reported40,63. Briefly, RNA was isolated from sorted (memory CD38−CD27+, GC CD38+CD27+ and plasmablast CD38+++CD27+) cells using Trizol (Thermo Fisher) and reverse transcribed to cDNA using Superscript II (Life Technologies) primed with random hexamer primers. Amplicons from IgM, IgD, IgG, IgA and IgE were PCR amplified in separate reactions, using IGHV framework region 1 primers and isotype primers in the first constant region exon, modified to contain partial Illumina linker sequences, sample barcode sequences and randomized nucleotides to ensure sequence diversity in the initial cycles of sequencing (as described by Roskin et al.64). A second PCR was carried out to complete the Illumina linker sequences before amplicon quantification, pooling, gel extraction (Qiagen) and sequencing on an Illumina MiSeq instrument with 600-cycle kits as 2 × 300 paired-end reads40,63. Bulk BCR heavy-chain sequences were analyzed with an in-house developed pipeline, based on IgBLAST for V, D and J gene segment alignment and CDR-H3 parsing40,63. Clonally related sequences in the bulk sequencing data were identified based on shared usage of IGHV and IGHJ genes, equal CDR-H3 length and single-linkage clustering of CDR-H3 nucleotide sequences at a 90% identity threshold.
For analyses of somatic hypermutation and A/California 2009 HA-specific B cells, tonsil cells from day-0 or day-7 organoids were harvested, washed with FACS buffer, then treated with 2 μg per sample (4 μg ml−1) of biotinylated recombinant A/California influenza HA1 hemagglutinin (Y98F mutant; a gift from B. Graham and the Vaccine Research Center) in the presence of Fc block, then washed and stained with 0.2 μg ml−1 of fluorescently labeled streptavidin and a cocktail of lineage-defining antibodies.
For single-cell sorting, HA+ B cells of GC or plasmablast phenotype (CD38+CD27+ or CD38+++CD27+, respectively) were sorted. Single-cell antibody sequencing was performed as previously described38,65,66,67. After single-cell sorting into 96-well plates, cDNAs were labeled with well-specific barcode oligonucleotides and pooled by plate, followed by gene-specific PCR and library preparation with previously reported primer sequences65. Libraries were sequenced with Illumina MiSeq 2 × 300 paired-end sequencing. Sequence analysis was performed as previously described65. Briefly, fastq generation and plate demultiplexing were completed using the onboard MiSeq Generate FASTQ workflow. After quality filtering, paired reads were stitched, separated by well ID and consensus sequences determined by clustering well ID reads into operational taxonomic units68. Consensus operational taxonomic unit sequences were analyzed with version 126.96.36.199 of IMGT HighV-QUEST69. For single-cell data, clonal families were defined by the same V and J gene usage and at least 70% amino acid identity in the CDR3 locus for both heavy and light chains. A caveat of single-cell HA-specific B cell sequencing is that the most vigorously responding B cells may have reduced surface immunoglobulin expression as they convert to antibody secretion, and so it is possible that the highest ASCs could not be captured during HA-specific B cell sorting.
Bulk IgH sequencing and analysis was performed using MIDCIRS as previously described70. Sequencing was performed on an Illumina MiSeq with the v3, 600-cycle kit. mRNA molecules were tagged with 12N randomized molecular identifiers (MIDs) during reverse transcription. Reads with the same MID were grouped together and then further clustered into subgroups based on 85% sequence similarity to separate distinct mRNA molecules that were tagged with the same MID. Consensus sequences were then formed from the MID subgroups to average out PCR and sequencing errors and mitigate amplification and sequencing bias. Clonal lineages were defined using single-linkage clustering on the consensus sequences with the same criteria as above. The size of the clonal lineage refers to the total number of consensus sequences, or mRNA molecules, that make up the lineage, while the diversity of the lineage refers to the number of unique consensus sequences within the lineage.
To infer HA specificity of total, unsorted B cells from day-7 tonsil cultures, all FACS-sorted, HA-specific B cell sequences were first grouped together (n = 20,977). Then, all nucleotide sequences were translated to amino acid sequences, and each day-7 sequence was aligned to the pool of HA+ sequences to find the minimum distance to the nearest HA-specific sequence. If any sequence within a clonal lineage was found to be an exact match or one substitution away from a known HA-specific sequence, the lineage was labeled ‘HA-inferred’. Clonal lineages were then split into HA-inferred and non-A/California HA for further analysis.
Affinity binding experiments
Binding affinities of the indicated antigens to antibody-containing supernatant samples were determined by biolayer interferometry using an Octet QK instrument (Pall ForteBio). For analysis of the effects of T cells on antibody responses, antibodies were purified from culture supernatants using a Protein G affinity column (GE Healthcare Life Sciences). The full-length, head and stem domain H1 CA/09 HA antigens were purified as described previously using a Ni-NTA affinity column followed by size-exclusion cleanup71,72. The purified antigens were captured on anti-penta-his (HIS1K) biosensor tips in PBS-T (PBS with 0.05% Tween 20 (pH 7.4)). The ligand-bound sensors were dipped into control wells or purified antibodies (200–500 nM). A similar antibody concentration was used for all the evaluated conditions from an individual donor. Unliganded sensors dipped into the analyte served as controls for nonspecific binding. The traces were processed using ForteBio Data Analysis Software (v8.0). The data were fitted globally to a simple 1:1 Langmuir interaction model to obtain the kinetic parameters. Each binding interaction was repeated at least thrice.
Cell depletion experiments
Thawed tonsil cells were stained and bulk sorted into culture medium using a FACS Aria II or Fusion (BD). Sorting experiments involved separating individual cell subsets using the following markers: myeloid cells and DCs (CD45+ CD3−CD19−HLA-DR+, CD116+ or CD33+), pDCs (CD45+CD3−CD19−HLA-DR+CD123+), Treg cells (CD45+CD3+CD19− CD4+ CD25+ CD127lo), total B cells (CD45+CD3−CD19+), non-naive B cells (CD38+ and/or CD27+IgM− and/or IgD−), naive B cells (CD38−CD27−IgM+IgD+), pre-GC B cells (CD38+CD27−), GC B cells (CD38+CD27+), memory B cells (CD38−CD27+) and plasmablasts/plasma cells (CD38+++CD27+). Cell types were depleted by FACS from day-0 tonsil cells and cultured with LAIV for 7 d. As controls, depleted cultures were reconstituted with the cell type that was originally sorted and plated at the same cell density as the depleted cultures. For depletion of HA-specific B cells, tonsil samples were stained as described in ‘BCR sequencing’ and HA-specific B cells were defined as CD45+CD19+CD3−HA+. A post-sort analysis was used to ensure depletion purity.
All statistical analyses were performed in R. For comparing paired samples (frequencies of plasmablasts and antibody secretion in unstimulated versus LAIV-stimulated cultures, standard versus Transwell responses, unstimulated versus MMR-stimulated cultures, somatic hypermutation analyses, studying the effect of CD4+ cell depletion on plasmablast differentiation and specific antibody secretion), paired Wilcoxon signed-rank tests (two-sided) were performed. To analyze the CD4 depletion effect in young versus older children, unpaired Mann–Whitney U tests (two-sided) were performed. Welch’s t-tests (two-sided) were used to compare the somatic hypermutation levels between culture conditions and the clone size and diversity of inferred HA-specific and nonspecific B cell lineages. Two-sided, paired t-tests were used to compare the effect of PE stimulation with and without adjuvants on the frequency of PE+ B cells.
Further information on research design is available in the Nature Research Reporting Summary linked to this article.
Requests for raw data, analyzed data and materials will be reviewed by Stanford University to determine if the request is subject to intellectual property or confidentiality obligations. Data and materials that can be shared will be released using a Material Transfer Agreement. Targeted single-cell RNA-seq data are available in the Gene Expression Omnibus under GSE158459.
Behring, E. Untersuchungen uber das Zustandekommen der Diphtherie-Immunitat bei Thieren. Dtsch. Med. Wschr 16, 1145–1147 (1890).
Behring, E. & Kitasato, S. Ueber das Zustandekommen der Diphtherie-Immunitat und der Tetanus-Immunitat bei Thieren. Dtsch. Med. Wschr 16, 1113–1114 (1890).
Kaufmann, S. H. E. Emil von Behring: translational medicine at the dawn of immunology. Nat. Rev. Immunol. 17, 341–343 (2017).
Kaufmann, S. H. Immunology’s foundation: the 100-year anniversary of the Nobel Prize to Paul Ehrlich and Elie Metchnikoff. Nat. Immunol. 9, 705–712 (2008).
Miller, J. F. The discovery of thymus function and of thymus-derived lymphocytes. Immunol. Rev. 185, 7–14 (2002).
Miller, J. F. & Mitchell, G. F. The thymus and the precursors of antigen reactive cells. Nature 216, 659–663 (1967).
Zinkernagel, R. M. & Doherty, P. C. Restriction of in vitro T cell-mediated cytotoxicity in lymphocytic choriomeningitis within a syngeneic or semiallogeneic system. Nature 248, 701–702 (1974).
Allen, C. D., Okada, T. & Cyster, J. G. Germinal-center organization and cellular dynamics. Immunity 27, 190–202 (2007).
De Silva, N. S. & Klein, U. Dynamics of B cells in germinal centres. Nat. Rev. Immunol. 15, 137–148 (2015).
MacLennan, I. C. et al. Extrafollicular antibody responses. Immunol. Rev. 194, 8–18 (2003).
Victora, G. D. & Nussenzweig, M. C. Germinal centers. Annu. Rev. Immunol. 30, 429–457 (2012).
Itano, A. A. et al. Distinct dendritic cell populations sequentially present antigen to CD4 T cells and stimulate different aspects of cell-mediated immunity. Immunity 19, 47–57 (2003).
Radtke, A. J. et al. Lymph-node resident CD8α+ dendritic cells capture antigens from migratory malaria sporozoites and induce CD8+ T cell responses. PLoS Pathog. 11, e1004637 (2015).
McCloskey, M. L., Curotto de Lafaille, M. A., Carroll, M. C. & Erlebacher, A. Acquisition and presentation of follicular dendritic cell-bound antigen by lymph node-resident dendritic cells. J. Exp. Med. 208, 135–148 (2011).
Gerner, M. Y., Casey, K. A., Kastenmuller, W. & Germain, R. N. Dendritic cell and antigen dispersal landscapes regulate T cell immunity. J. Exp. Med. 214, 3105–3122 (2017).
Crotty, S. T follicular helper cell differentiation, function, and roles in disease. Immunity 41, 529–542 (2014).
Crotty, S. Follicular helper CD4 T cells (TFH). Annu. Rev. Immunol. 29, 621–663 (2011).
Cyster, J. G. & Allen, C. D. C. B cell responses: cell interaction dynamics and decisions. Cell 177, 524–540 (2019).
Qi, H., Kastenmuller, W. & Germain, R. N. Spatiotemporal basis of innate and adaptive immunity in secondary lymphoid tissue. Annu. Rev. Cell Dev. Biol. 30, 141–167 (2014).
Vinuesa, C. G., Linterman, M. A., Goodnow, C. C. & Randall, K. L. T cells and follicular dendritic cells in germinal center B cell formation and selection. Immunol. Rev. 237, 72–89 (2010).
Jameson, S. C. & Masopust, D. What is the predictive value of animal models for vaccine efficacy in humans? Reevaluating the potential of mouse models for the human immune system. Cold Spring Harb. Perspect. Biol. 10, a029132 (2018).
Buchbinder, S. P. et al. Efficacy assessment of a cell-mediated immunity HIV-1 vaccine (the Step Study): a double-blind, randomised, placebo-controlled, test-of-concept trial. Lancet 372, 1881–1893 (2008).
Watkins, D. I., Burton, D. R., Kallas, E. G., Moore, J. P. & Koff, W. C. Nonhuman primate models and the failure of the Merck HIV-1 vaccine in humans. Nat. Med. 14, 617–621 (2008).
Tameris, M. D. et al. Safety and efficacy of MVA85A, a new tuberculosis vaccine, in infants previously vaccinated with BCG: a randomised, placebo-controlled phase 2b trial. Lancet 381, 1021–1028 (2013).
James, K., Skibinski, G. & Hoffman, P. A comparison of the performance in vitro of precision cut tissue slices and suspensions of human spleen with special reference to immunoglobulin and cytokine production. Hum. Antibodies Hybrid. 7, 138–150 (1996).
Edwards, K. M., Snyder, P. N., Stephens, D. S. & Wright, P. F. Human adenoid organ culture: a model to study the interaction of influenza A with human nasopharyngeal mucosa. J. Infect. Dis. 153, 41–47 (1986).
Ferro, L. M., Weedon, H. M., Flego, L. R., Beroukas, D. & Zola, H. An organ fragment culture model to study lymphocyte activation in human lymphoid tissue. Immunobiology 188, 51–61 (1993).
Hoffmann, P., Skibinski, G. & James, K. Organ culture of human lymphoid tissue. I. Characteristics of the system. J. Immunol. Methods 179, 37–49 (1995).
Skibinski, G., Hoffmann, P., Radbruch, A. & James, K. Organ culture of human lymphoid tissue. II. Marked differences in cytokine production and proliferation between slice and suspension cultures of human spleen. J. Immunol. Methods 205, 115–125 (1997).
Soto-Rivera, J. et al. Study of HIV-1 transmission across cervical mucosa to tonsil tissue cells using an organ culture. Am. J. Reprod. Immunol. 69, 52–63 (2013).
Klinman, N. R. The mechanism of antigenic stimulation of primary and secondary clonal precursor cells. J. Exp. Med. 136, 241–260 (1972).
Skibinski, G., Skibinska, A., Deckers, M. & James, K. Tonsil stromal-cell lines expressing FDC-like properties: isolation, characterization and interaction with B lymphocytes. Dev. Immunol. 6, 273–284 (1998).
van Laar, J. M. et al. Sustained secretion of immunoglobulin by long-lived human tonsil plasma cells. Am. J. Pathol. 171, 917–927 (2007).
Grivel, J. C. & Margolis, L. Use of human tissue explants to study human infectious agents. Nat. Protoc. 4, 256–269 (2009).
Jenkinson, E. J. & Owen, J. J. T cell differentiation in thymus organ cultures. Semin. Immunol. 2, 51–58 (1990).
Robinson, J. H. & Owen, J. J. Generation of T cell function in organ culture of foetal mouse thymus. II. Mixed lymphocyte culture reactivity. Clin. Exp. Immunol. 27, 322–327 (1977).
Whittle, J. R. et al. Flow cytometry reveals that H5N1 vaccination elicits cross-reactive stem-directed antibodies from multiple Ig heavy-chain lineages. J. Virol. 88, 4047–4057 (2014).
Tan, Y. C. et al. High-throughput sequencing of natively paired antibody chains provides evidence for original antigenic sin shaping the antibody response to influenza vaccination. Clin. Immunol. 151, 55–65 (2014).
Brinkman, D. M. et al. Vaccination with rabies to study the humoral and cellular immune response to a T cell dependent neoantigen in man. J. Clin. Immunol. 23, 528–538 (2003).
Jackson, K. J. et al. Human responses to influenza vaccination show seroconversion signatures and convergent antibody rearrangements. Cell Host Microbe 16, 105–114 (2014).
Jego, G. et al. Plasmacytoid dendritic cells induce plasma cell differentiation through type I interferon and interleukin 6. Immunity 19, 225–234 (2003).
Wolf, A. I. et al. Plasmacytoid dendritic cells are dispensable during primary influenza virus infection. J. Immunol. 182, 871–879 (2009).
Radbruch, A. et al. Competence and competition: the challenge of becoming a long-lived plasma cell. Nat. Rev. Immunol. 6, 741–750 (2006).
Mesin, L. et al. Restricted clonality and limited germinal center reentry characterize memory B cell reactivation by boosting. Cell 180, 92–106 (2020).
Giese, C. et al. A human lymph node in vitro—challenges and progress. Artif. Organs 30, 803–808 (2006).
Kuzin, I. et al. Long-term immunologically competent human peripheral lymphoid tissue cultures in a 3D bioreactor. Biotechnol. Bioeng. 108, 1430–1440 (2011).
Byers, A. M., Tapia, T. M., Sassano, E. R. & Wittman, V. In vitro antibody response to tetanus in the MIMIC system is a representative measure of vaccine immunogenicity. Biologicals 37, 148–151 (2009).
Giese, C. et al. Immunological substance testing on human lymphatic micro-organoids in vitro. J. Biotechnol. 148, 38–45 (2010).
Giese, C. & Marx, U. Human immunity in vitro - solving immunogenicity and more. Adv. Drug Deliv. Rev. 69-70, 103–122 (2014).
Purwada, A. et al. Ex vivo engineered immune organoids for controlled germinal center reactions. Biomaterials 63, 24–34 (2015).
Purwada, A. & Singh, A. Immuno-engineered organoids for regulating the kinetics of B cell development and antibody production. Nat. Protoc. 12, 168–182 (2017).
Beguelin, W. et al. EZH2 enables germinal centre formation through epigenetic silencing of CDKN1A and an Rb-E2F1 feedback loop. Nat. Commun. 8, 877 (2017).
Purwada, A. et al. Ex vivo synthetic immune tissues with T cell signals for differentiating antigen-specific, high-affinity germinal center B cells. Biomaterials 198, 27–36 (2019).
Wagar, L. E., DiFazio, R. M. & Davis, M. M. Advanced model systems and tools for basic and translational human immunology. Genome Med. 10, 73 (2018).
Monto, A. S. et al. Comparative efficacy of inactivated and live attenuated influenza vaccines. N. Engl. J. Med. 361, 1260–1267 (2009).
He, T. C. et al. A simplified system for generating recombinant adenoviruses. Proc. Natl Acad. Sci. USA 95, 2509–2514 (1998).
Kim, L. et al. Safety and immunogenicity of an oral tablet norovirus vaccine, a phase I randomized, placebo-controlled trial. JCI Insight 3, e121077 (2018).
Liebowitz, D. et al. Efficacy, immunogenicity and safety of an oral influenza vaccine: a placebo-controlled and active-controlled phase 2 human challenge study. Lancet Infect. Dis. 20, 435–444 (2020).
Toebes, M. et al. Design and use of conditional MHC class I ligands. Nat. Med. 12, 246–251 (2006).
Nakajima, R. et al. Protein microarray analysis of the specificity and cross-reactivity of influenza virus hemagglutinin-specific antibodies. mSphere 3, e00592–18 (2018).
de Assis, R. R., et al. Analysis of SARS-CoV-2 antibodies in COVID-19 convalescent plasma using a coronavirus antigen microarray. Preprint at bioRxiv https://doi.org/10.1101/2020.04.15.043364 (2020).
Shah, H. B. & Koelsch, K. A. B cell ELISpot: for the identification of antigen-specific antibody-secreting cells. Methods Mol. Biol. 1312, 419–426 (2015).
Ellebedy, A. H. et al. Defining antigen-specific plasmablast and memory B cell subsets in human blood after viral infection or vaccination. Nat. Immunol. 17, 1226–1234 (2016).
Roskin, K. M. et al. IgH sequences in common variable immune deficiency reveal altered B cell development and selection. Sci. Transl. Med. 7, 302ra135 (2015).
Blum, L. K. et al. Circulating plasmablasts are elevated and produce pathogenic anti-endothelial cell autoantibodies in idiopathic pulmonary arterial hypertension. Eur. J. Immunol. 48, 874–884 (2018).
Kinslow, J. D. et al. Elevated IgA plasmablast levels in subjects at risk of developing rheumatoid arthritis. Arthritis Rheumatol. 68, 2372–2383 (2016).
Nair, N. et al. VP4- and VP7-specific antibodies mediate heterotypic immunity to rotavirus in humans. Sci. Transl. Med. 9, eaam5434 (2017).
Edgar, R. C. UPARSE: highly accurate OTU sequences from microbial amplicon reads. Nat. Methods 10, 996–998 (2013).
Alamyar, E., Duroux, P., Lefranc, M. P. & Giudicelli, V. IMGT tools for the nucleotide analysis of immunoglobulin and T cell receptor V–(D)–J repertoires, polymorphisms and IG mutations: IMGT/V-QUEST and IMGT/HighV-QUEST for NGS. Methods Mol. Biol. 882, 569–604 (2012).
Wendel, B. S. et al. Accurate immune repertoire sequencing reveals malaria infection driven antibody lineage diversification in young children. Nat. Commun. 8, 531 (2017).
Joyce, M. G. et al. Vaccine-induced antibodies that neutralize group 1 and group 2 influenza A viruses. Cell 166, 609–623 (2016).
Mallajosyula, V. V. et al. Influenza hemagglutinin stem-fragment immunogen elicits broadly neutralizing antibodies and confers heterologous protection. Proc. Natl Acad. Sci. USA 111, E2514–E2523 (2014).
The authors thank the participants for donating their tissues for this study; J. Cyster, J. Idoyaga and B. Pulendran for thoughtful comments on the manuscript; M. Leipold, C. Tato and R. DiFazio for insightful discussions and troubleshooting suggestions; A. Messner, C. Lopez Angel, R. Cadman, A. Nguyen and H. Song for their assistance with collecting tonsillectomy samples; the Gift of Hope Organ and Tissue Donor Network and J. Solway for tissue procurement through the Gift of Hope; Mike Laine for materials development advice; Mary Rieck for sorting assistance; X. Ji, M. Miranda, I. Goncharov and H. Maecker for single-cell RNA-seq help; and the Cell Sciences Imaging Facility and the Stanford Shared FACS Facility for instrument access. This work was supported by a Bill and Melinda Gates Foundation pilot grant (OPP1113682; to M.M.D.), the National Institutes of Health (NIH) grants (5U19AI05722915 to M.M.D.; 1R01AI127877 and 1R01AI130398 to S.D.B.; U54CA224081, U19AI116484, U01CA217851 and U01DK085527 to C.J.K.) and the Howard Hughes Medical Institute (to M.M.D.). Sorting and analyzing were performed in the Stanford Shared FACS facility on instruments supported by the NIH S10 Shared Instrument Grants (S10RR025518-01 and S10RR027431-01) and the Parker Institute for Cancer Immunotherapy.
S.N.T., M.C. and E.G.D. are employed and have stock options with the biotechnology company Vaxart. P.L.F. and D.H.D. have shares in Nanommune, a company that uses Sino Biological’s proteins on commercially available protein microarrays. L.E.W., A.S., C.M.C., B.S.W., M.M.L., V.M., L.P.J., J.Z.A., L.K.B., N.G., K.J.L.J., F.Y., K.R., K.M.R., K.M.B., K.D.M., I.N.A., A.I.S., A.J., G.B.H., P.S.K., W.H.R., S.D.B., C.J.K. and M.M.D. declare no competing interests.
Peer review information Saheli Sadanand was the primary editor on this article and managed its editorial process and peer review in collaboration with the rest of the editorial team.
Publisher’s note Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.
a, Flow cytometry gating scheme on representative unstimulated and LAIV-stimulated cultures. b, Representative ELISpot wells for detection of Ab-secreting cells with influenza vaccine specificity. The number of spots detected are shown in the corner of each well. c, Comparison of organoid cultures grown in standard flat-bottom wells vs. transwells. Data shown are from day 7 LAIV-stimulated cultures (n = 6 donors). p values shown were determined with paired Wilcoxon signed-rank two-sided tests. Boxplots show median values with hinges representing first and third quartiles and whiskers representing the highest and lowest value that is within 1.5X the interquartile range of the hinges. d, Correlation between specific Ab secretion and plasmablast frequency in influenza-stimulated and unstimulated cultures on day 7. Detection of influenza-specific IgG antibodies by semi-quantitative indirect ELISA. Optical density was corrected for background using unspent culture medium as a control. Each donor (n = 15) was tested under four conditions: no stimulation, IIV-stimulated, LAIV-stimulated, or H1N1 WT virus-stimulated. Plasmablast (CD19+ CD38+++ CD27+) frequencies were determined by flow cytometry.
Extended Data Fig. 2 Confocal imaging showing distribution of different cell types and their interactions in tonsil tissue and organoid cultures.
Merge does not include DAPI staining for clarity. a, One fresh tonsil tissue was stained with panels of markers to define T and B cell areas and GC structure. b, Day 4 unstimulated organoid stained for T and B cell markers. c, Day 4 LAIV organoid stained for germinal center markers. d, Day 4 unstimulated organoid stained for B and T cell distribution. e, Day 4 LAIV organoid stained for markers of T follicular helper cells. For organoid cultures (b-e), representative examples are shown from organoid cultures derived from three different donors.
a, Quantification of CXCR4 and CD83 expression levels (mean intensity, left panel) and percent positive (percentage of CD20+B cells, right panel) in day 4 tonsil organoids from one donor. Two areas of an LAIV-stimulated organoid (top GC and bottom GC as also shown in Fig. 3a) and a representative GC-organized area from an unstimulated organoid were used for the calculation. b, Representative intracellular AID flow cytometry staining profiles. Data shown are from a day 4, LAIV-stimulated organoid culture. Total B cells were subsetted based on CD38 and CD27 expression and are shown as individual profiles in red compared to a ‘no AID primary antibody’ FMO control in grey.
a, Phylogenetic trees from two donors are shown (top). Day 0 clones are indicated by black points. Different isotypes (IgM, IgA, IgG) are indicated by color (green, blue, and red respectively). Oligoclonal populations and clonal families from single cell data are represented by larger points (open circles). Clonal families were defined as BCR sequences that use the same V and J genes and have at least 70% amino acid identity in the CDR3 region for heavy and light chains. b, FACS staining and B cell phenotypes of HA-specific B cells compared to the total B cell pool.
Extended Data Fig. 5 Tracking individual heavy-chain BCR lineages before and after LAIV stimulation in tonsil organoids show evidence of isotype switching.
Immunoglobulin heavy-chain gene rearrangements for each isotype were sequenced from total memory B cells, germinal center B cells, and plasmablasts sorted from cultures of four donors on days 0 and 7. Heavy-chain BCR sequences from lineages that contained members as only IgM on day 0 and as only isotype-switched on day 7 were compared for their somatic hypermutation levels. For each lineage, the mean SHM was calculated for day 0 IgM members and for day 7 switched members, and the difference between these means was plotted. Lineages with increased mutation are shown in blue and those with decreased mutation in red.
Extended Data Fig. 6 Depletion of pre-existing HA-specific and non-naive B cells do not prevent production of new high-affinity HA+ B cells after organoid culture.
B cells with high affinity BCRs for A/California 2009 HA+ and all non-naive B cells were depleted by FACS and depletion was confirmed by post-sort analysis. After 10 days in organoid culture, cells were harvested, re-stained for A/California HA+ B cells, and run on a flow cytometer. n = 4 donors were tested.
Extended Data Fig. 7 Effects of cell depletion on influenza-specific antibodies and their affinities.
a, Rescue of plasmablast and Ab responses to LAIV stimulation by supplementing pDC-depleted cultures with type I IFNs. b, Frequency of CD4+ T cells (of live cells) in intact and CD4-depleted cultures on day 7. CD4+ cells were depleted by positive selection with magnetic particles. c, Biolayer interferometry data indicating Ab affinity for A/California 2009 H1N1 HA full length, head-specific, and stem domains. Colors are matched to patient samples in (b).
Extended Data Fig. 8 SARS-CoV2-specific Abs detected in organoid cultures stimulated with Ad5 vectored vaccine candidates.
Day 14 post-stimulation culture supernatants were tested for the presence of SARS-CoV2-specific IgM, IgG, and IgA in n = 12 donors. Abs were detected using a protein microarray. Individuals donors are represented by symbols. The signal intensities shown were background subtracted based on unstimulated control cultures from the same donor. Boxplots show median values with hinges representing first and third quartiles and whiskers representing the highest and lowest value that is within 1.5X the interquartile range of the hinges.
About this article
Cite this article
Wagar, L.E., Salahudeen, A., Constantz, C.M. et al. Modeling human adaptive immune responses with tonsil organoids. Nat Med 27, 125–135 (2021). https://doi.org/10.1038/s41591-020-01145-0