The transition to lower-carbon sources of energy will inevitably produce and, in many cases, perpetuate pre-existing sets of winners and losers. The winners are those that will benefit from cleaner sources of energy, reduced emissions from the removal of fossil fuels, and the employment and innovation opportunities that accompany this transition. The losers are those that will bear the burdens, or lack access to the opportunities. Here we review the current state of understanding—based on a rapidly growing body of academic and policy literature—about the potential adverse consequences of the energy transition for specific communities and socio-economic groups on the frontlines of the transition. We review evidence about just transition policies and programmes, primarily from cases in the Global North, and draw conclusions about what insights are still needed to understand the justice and equity dimensions of the transition, and to ensure that no one is left behind.
Subscribe to Journal
Get full journal access for 1 year
only $4.92 per issue
All prices are NET prices.
VAT will be added later in the checkout.
Rent or Buy article
Get time limited or full article access on ReadCube.
All prices are NET prices.
IPCC Special Report on Global Warming of 1.5 °C (eds Masson-Delmotte, V. et al.) (WMO, 2018).
Newell, R. G. & Raimi, D. The New Climate Math: Energy Addition, Subtraction, and Transition. Issue Brief 18–09 (Resources for the Future, 2018).
Fouquet, R. Historical energy transitions: speed, prices and system transformation. Energy Res. Soc. Sci. 22, 7–12 (2016).
Sovacool, B. K. How long will it take? Conceptualizing the temporal dynamics of energy transitions. Energy Res. Soc. Sci. 13, 202–215 (2016). Reviews the academic literature on the time scale of the current energy transition.
Smil, V. Examining energy transitions: A dozen insights based on performance. Energy Res. Soc. Sci. 22, 194–197 (2016).
Allen, R. C. Backward into the future: The shift to coal and implications for the next energy transition. Energy Policy 50, 17–23 (2012).
Mackard, J. The next phase of the energy transition and its implications for research and policy. Nat. Energy 3, 628–633 (2018).
Jenkins, K. Setting energy justice apart from the crowd: Lessons from environmental and climate justice. Energy Res. Soc. Sci. 39, 117–21 (2018).
Fuller, S. & McCauley, D. Framing energy justice: Perspectives from activism and advocacy. Energy Res. Soc. Sci. 11, 1–8 (2016).
Bazilian, M., Nakhooda, S. & Van de Graaf, T. Energy governance and poverty. Energy Res. Soc. Sci. 1, 217–25 (2014).
Middlemiss, L. & Gillard, R. Fuel poverty from the bottom-up: Characterizing household energy vulnerability through the lived experience of the fuel poor. Energy Res. Soc. Sci. 6, 146–54 (2015).
Jenkins, K., McCauley, D., Heffron, R., Stephan, H. & Rehner, R. Energy Justice: A Conceptual Review. Energy Res. Soc. Sci. 11, 174–82 (2016).
McCauley, D., Heffron, R., Stephan, H. & Jenkins, K. Advancing energy justice: The triumvirate of tenets. Int. Energy Law Rev. 32, 107–110 (2013). Provides a conceptual framework for energy justice and defines the three tenets of the concept.
Sovacool, B. K. & Dworkin, M. H. Energy justice: Conceptual insights and practical applications. Appl. Energy 142, 435–444 (2015).
Jones, B. R., Sovacool, B. K. & Sidortsov, R. V. Making the ethical and philosophical case for “energy justice”. Environ. Ethics 37, 145–68 (2015).
Heffron, R. J. & McCauley, D. The concept of energy justice across the disciplines. Energy Policy 105, 658–667 (2017).
Sovacool, B. K., Heffron, R. J., McCauley, D. & Goldthau, A. Energy decisions reframed as justice and ethical concerns. Nat. Energy 1, 1–6 (2016).
Sovacool, B. K., Burke, M., Baker, L., Kotikalapudi, C. & Wlokas, H. New frontiers and conceptual frameworks for energy justice. Energy Policy 105, 677–691 (2017).
Healy, N. & Barry, J. Politicizing energy justice and energy system transitions: Fossil fuel divestment and a “just transition”. Energy Policy 108, 451–459 (2017).
Oppenheim, J. The United States regulatory compact and energy poverty. Energy Res. Soc. Sci. 18, 96–108 (2016). Evaluates the origins and intentions of utility regulation, and then proposes measures that could improve the degree to which such regulations advance social justice.
Banzhaf, S., Ma, L. & Timmins, C. Environmental justice: The economics of race, place, and pollution. J. Econ. Perspect. 33, 185–208 (2019).
Welton, S., Eisen, J. Clean energy justice: Charting an emerging agenda. Harvard Environmental Law Review (2019). This law article provides a comprehensive discussion of the energy justice dimensions of clean energy developments.
Mills, S., Bessette, D. & Smith, H. Exploring landowners’ post-construction changes in perceptions of wind energy in Michigan. Land Use Policy 82, 754–762 (2019).
Outka, U. Environmental justice issues in sustainable development: Environmental justice in the renewable energy transition. J. Environ. Sustain. Law 19, 60–122 (2012).
Jolley, G. J., Khalaf, C., Michaud, G. & Sandler, A. M. The economic, fiscal, and workforce impacts of coal-fired power plant closures in Appalachian Ohio. Reg. Sci. Policy Pract. 11, 403–422 (2019).
Pai, S., Zerriffi, H., Jewell, J. & Pathak, J. Solar has greater techno-economic resource suitability than wind for replacing coal mining jobs. Environ. Res. Lett. 10.1088/1748–9326/ab6c6d (2020).
Carley, S., Evans, T. P. & Konisky, D. M. Adaptation, culture, and the energy transition in American coal country. Energy Res. Soc. Sci. 37, 133–139 (2018). This article assesses how the energy transition is affecting American coal country.
Cameron, L. & van der Zwaan, B. Employment factors for wind and solar energy technologies: A literature review. Renew. Sustain. Energy Rev. 45, 160–172 (2015).
Clean Jobs America (E2, 2019); https://www.e2.org/reports/clean-jobs-america-2019/
Outlook handbook: fastest growing occupations. US Bureau of Labor Statistics https://www.bls.gov/ooh/fastest-growing.htm (2019).
Pollin, R. & Callaci, B. The economics of just transition: A framework for supporting fossil fuel-dependent workers and communities in the United States. Labor Stud. J. 44, 93–138 (2019).
Lobao, M., Zhou, M., Partridge, M. & Betz, M. Poverty, place, and coal employment across Appalachia and the United States in a new economic era. Rural Sociol. 81, 343–386 (2016).
Tierney, S. The U.S. Coal Industry: Challenging Transitions in the 21st Century (Analysis Group, 2016)
Della Bosca, H. & Gillespie, J. The coal story: Generational coal mining communities and strategies of energy transition in Australia. Energy Policy 120, 734–740 (2018).
Burke, P. J., Best, R. & Jotzo, F. Closures of coal-fired power stations in Australia: local unemployment effects. Agric. Resour. Econ. 63, 142–165 (2019).
Haggerty, J. H., Haggerty, M. N., Roemer, K. & Rose, J. Planning for the local impacts of coal facility closure: Emerging strategies in the U. S. West. Resour. Policy 57, 69–80 (2018).
Morris, A., Kaufman, N. & Doshi, S. The risk of fiscal collapse in coal reliant communities. The Brookings Institution https://www.brookings.edu/research/the-risk-of-fiscal-collapse-in-coal-reliant-communities (2019).
Olson-Hazboun, S. K. “Why are we being punished and they are being rewarded?” views on renewable energy in fossil fuels-based communities of the U. S. west. Extr. Ind. Soc. 5, 366–374 (2018).
Drehobl, A. & Ross, L. Lifting the high energy burden in America’s largest cities: How energy efficiency can improve low income and underserved communities (American Council for an Energy-Efficient Economy, 2016); https://www.aceee.org/sites/default/files/publications/researchreports/u1602.pdfDetailed analysis of energy insecurity in American cities.
Ross, L., Drehobl, A. & Stickles, B. The High Cost of Energy in Rural America: Household Energy Burdens and Opportunities for Energy Efficiency (American Council for an Energy-Efficient Economy, 2018); https://aceee.org/research-report/u1806. Detailed analysis of energy insecurity in rural America.
One in three U. S. households face challenges in paying energy bills in 2015. Residential Energy Consumption Survey. U.S. Energy Information Administration https://www.eia.gov/consumption/residential/reports/2015/energybills (2015).
O’Sullivan, K., Barnard, L. T., Viggers, H. & Howden-Chapman, P. Child and youth fuel poverty: Assessing the known and unknown. People Place Policy 10, 77–87 (2016).
Papada, L. & Kaliampakos, D. Measuring energy poverty in Greece. Energy Policy 94, 157–165 (2016).
Hernández, D. Sacrifice along the energy continuum: a call for energy justice. Environ. Justice 8(4), 151–156 (2015). This article evaluates how vulnerable communities bear disproportionate burdens along the spectrum that includes both energy production and consumption.
Hernández, D. & Siegel, E. Energy insecurity and its ill health effects: A community perspective in New York City. Energy Res. Soc. Sci. 47, 78–83 (2019).
Reames, T. G. Targeting energy justice: Exploring spatial, racial/ethnic and socioeconomic disparities in urban residential heating energy efficiency. Energy Policy 97, 549–558 (2016). Maps rates of fuel poverty along racial/ethnic and socioeconomic block group characteristics, and finds that lower-income and racial- and ethnic-headed households, respectively, have higher rates of fuel poverty.
Hernández, D. & Phillips, D. Benefit or burden? Perceptions of energy efficiency efforts among low-income housing residents in New York City. Energy Res. Soc. Sci. 8, 52–59 (2015).
Graff, M., Carley, S. & Konisky, D. Stakeholder perceptions of the United States energy transition: Local-level dynamics and community responses to national politics and policy. Energy Res. Soc. Sci. 43, 144–157 (2018).
Carley, S., Evans, T. P., Graff, M. & Konisky, D. M. A framework for evaluating geographic disparities in energy transition vulnerability. Nat. Energy 3, 621–627 (2018).
Hernández, D. & Bird, S. Energy burden and the need for integrated low-income housing and energy policy. Poverty Public Policy 2, 5–25 (2010).
Bickerstaff, K., Walker, G. & Bulkeley, H. (eds.) Energy Justice in a Changing Climate (Zed Books,).
Byrne, J. & Portanger, C. Climate change, energy policy and justice: A systematic review. Anal. Krit. 2, 315–343 (2014).
Moore, T., Ridley, I., Strengers, Y., Maller, C. & Horne, R. Dwelling performance and adaptive summer comfort in low-income Australian households. Build. Res. Inf. 45, 443–456 (2017).
Passey, R., Watt, M., Bruce, A. & MacGill, I. Who pays, who benefits? The financial impacts of solar photovoltaic systems and air-conditioners on Australian households. Energy Res. Soc. Sci. 39, 198–215 (2018).
Lehr, U., Lutz, C. & Edler, D. Green jobs? Economic impacts of renewable energy in Germany. Energy Policy 47, 358–364 (2012).
Wei, M., Patadia, S. & Kammen, D. M. Putting renewables and energy efficiency to work: How many jobs can the clean energy industry generate in the US? Energy Policy 38, 919–931 (2010).
Renewable energy and jobs – Annual Review 2018 (International Renewable Energy Agency, 2018).
Occupational Outlook Handbook. Fastest Growing Occupations. US Bureau of Labor Statistics https://www.bls.gov/ooh/fastest-growing.htm (2019).
National Solar Jobs Census 2018 (Solar Foundation, 2018).
PESA Diversity Study Identifies Opportunities to Advance Women in the Workplace. Petroleum Equipment & Services Association https://pesa.org/archives/pesa-diversity-study-identifies-opportunities-to-advance-women-in-the-workplace (2018).
U.S. Energy and Employment Report (US Department of Energy, 2017).
Gender and Energy (European Institute for Gender Equality, 2017); https://eige.europa.eu/publications/gender-and-energy
Pearl-Martinez, R. & Stephens, J. C. Toward a gender diverse workforce in the renewable energy transition. Sustain. Sci. Pract. Policy 12, 8–15 (2016).
Walker, C. & Baxter, J. Procedural justice in Canadian wind energy development: A comparison of community-based and technocratic siting processes. Energy Res. Soc. Sci. 29, 160–169 (2017).
Zarate-Toledo, E., Patino, R. & Fraga, J. Justice, social inclusion and indigenous opposition: A case study of wind energy development on the Isthmus of Tehuantepec, Mexico. Energy Res. Soc. Sci. 54, 1–11 (2019).
Baker, S. H. Mexican energy reform, climate change, and energy justice in indigenous communities. Nat. Resour. J. 56, 369–390 (2016).
Daley, D. M. & Reames, T. G. in Failed Promises: Evaluating the Federal Government's Response to Environmental Justice Ch. 6 (MIT Press, 2015).
Borenstein, S. & Davis, L. W. The distributional effects of U. S. clean energy tax credits. Tax. Policy Econ. 30, 191–234 (2016).
Mullen, C. & Marsden, G. Mobility justice in low carbon energy transitions. Energy Res. Soc. Sci. 18, 109–117 (2016).
Mitra, S. & Buluswar, S. Universal access to electricity: Closing the affordability gap. Annu. Rev. Environ. Resour. 40, 261–283 (2015).
Sunter, D., Castellanos, S. & Kammen, D. M. Disparities in rooftop photovoltaics deployment in the United States by race and ethnicity. Nat. Sustain. 2, 71–76 (2019). Study evaluates the racial and ethnic disparities in rooftop solar development.
Chan, G., Evans, I., Grimley, M., Ihde, B. & Mazumder, P. Design choices and equity implications of community shared solar. Electr. J. 30, 37–41 (2017).
Balta-Ozkan, N., Davidson, R., Bicket, M. & Whitmarsh, L. Social barriers to the adoption of smart homes. Energy Policy 63, 363–374 (2013).
Wada, K., Akimoto, K., Sano, F., Oda, J. & Homma, T. Energy efficiency opportunities in the residential sector and their feasibility. Energy 48, 5–10 (2012).
Reames, T. G., Reiner, M. A. & Stacey, M. B. An incandescent truth: Disparities in energy-efficient lighting availability and prices in an urban U. S. county. Appl. Energy 218, 95–103 (2018). Studies distributional disparities in access to and price of energy efficient light bulbs.
Bednar, D. J. & Reames, T. G. Recognition of and response to energy poverty in the United States. Nat. Energy. 10.1038/s41560-020-0582–0 (2020).
Carley, S., Engle, C., Konisky, D. & Sullivan, S. Supporting vulnerable communities in a Green New Deal. Public Administration Review https://www.publicadministrationreview.com/2019/07/16/gnd17 (2020).
Zinecker, A. et al. Real People, Real Change: Strategies for Just Energy Transitions (IISD, 2017); https://iisd.org/library/real-people-real-change-strategies-just-energy-transitions
Harrahill, K. & Douglas, O. Framework development for ‘just transition’ in coal producing jurisdictions. Energy Policy 134, 1–11 (2019).
Franklin, M., Kurtz, C. Lights outs in the cold: Reforming utility shut-off policies as if human rights matter. (NAACP, 2017).
Cook, J. K. & Bird, L. Unlocking Solar For Low- And Moderate-Income Residents: A Matrix of Financing Options By Resident, Provider, And Housing Type Technical Report NREL/TP-6A20-70477 (National Renewable Energy Laboratory, 2018).
Bomberg, E. & McEwen, N. Mobilizing community energy. Energy Policy 51, 435–444 (2012).
Jenkins, K., McCauley, D. & Forman, A. Energy justice: A policy approach. Energy Policy 105, 631–34 (2017).
Reames, T. G. A community-based approach to low-income residential energy efficiency participation barriers. Local Environ. 21, 1449–1466 (2016).
Tonn, B. et al. Weatherization Works – Summary of Findings from The Retrospective Evaluation of The U. S. Department of Energy’s Weatherization Assistance Program Report ORNL/TM-2014/338 (Oak Ridge National Laboratory, 2014).
Tonn, B., Rose, E. & Hawkins, B. Evaluation of the U. S. department of energy’s weatherization assistance program: Impact results. Energy Policy 118, 279–290 (2018).
Graff, M. & Pirog, M. Red tape is not so hot: Asset tests impact participation in the Low-Income Home Energy Assistance Program. Energy Policy 129, 749–764 (2019). Evaluates how the Low-Income Home Energy Assistance Program’s asset test is regressive.
Murray, A. G. & Mills, B. F. The impact of low-income home energy assistance program participation on household energy insecurity. Contemp. Econ. Policy 32, 811–825 (2014).
Chapman, R., Howden-Chapman, P., Viggers, H., O’Dea, D. & Kennedy, M. Retrofitting houses with insulation: a cost-benefit analysis of a randomized community trial. J. Epidemiol. Commun. Health 63, 271–277 (2009).
Howden-Chapman, P. & Chapman, R. Health co-benefits from housing-related policies. Curr. Opin. Environ. Sustain. 4, 414–419 (2012).
Perl, L. LIHEAP: Program and funding Report PL31865 (Congressional Research Service, 2018); https://fas.org/sgp/crs/misc/RL31865.pdf
Lamb, A. K. Energy Efficiency and Health: A Guide for Public Health and Health Care Professionals (Public Health Institute, 2019); http://www.phi.org/resources/?resource=energy-efficiency-and-health-a-guide-for-public-health-and-health-care-professionals
Nowak, S., Kushler, M. & Witte, P. The New Leaders of the Pack: Aceee’s Fourth National Review of Exemplary Energy Efficiency Programs (American Council for an Energy-Efficient Economy, 2019); https://www.aceee.org/research-report/u1901
Gilleo, A., Nowak, S. & Drehobl, A. Making a Difference: Strategies for Successful Low-Income Energy Efficiency Programs Report U1713 (American Council for an Energy-Efficient Economy, 2017); http://www.aceee.org/sites/default/files/publications/researchreports/u1713.pdf
Sartor, O. Implementing Coal Transitions: Insights from Case Studies of Major Coal-Consuming Economies (IDDRI, Climate Strategies, 2018).
This project was supported by the Environmental Resilience Institute, funded by Indiana University’s Prepared for Environmental Change Grand Challenge initiative.
The authors declare no competing interests.
Publisher’s note Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.
About this article
Cite this article
Carley, S., Konisky, D.M. The justice and equity implications of the clean energy transition. Nat Energy 5, 569–577 (2020). https://doi.org/10.1038/s41560-020-0641-6
Nature Climate Change (2020)