Fig. 4: Influence of various factors on the perceived quality of the review. | Nature Astronomy

Fig. 4: Influence of various factors on the perceived quality of the review.

From: Distributed peer review enhanced with natural language processing and machine learning

Fig. 4

We show a number of factors that can influence the (perceived) quality of the review that was graded by the proposers in the feedback step. a,b, Evaluation of the helpfulness of the comment given expertise (inferred by DeepThought in a and self-reported in b). c, We show the conditional probability P(helpful comment|seniority) for the various combinations of helpful comment rating and reported gender. d, We show the conditional probability P(helpful comment|proposal quartile) for the various combinations of helpful comment rating and proposal quartile.

Back to article page