The onset of freezing of gait (FOG) in Parkinson’s disease (PD) is a critical milestone, marked by a higher risk of falls and reduced quality of life. FOG is associated with alterations in subcortical neural circuits, yet no study has assessed whether subcortical morphology can predict the onset of clinical FOG. In this prospective multimodal neuroimaging cohort study, we performed vertex-based analysis of grey matter morphology in fifty-seven individuals with PD at study entry and two years later. We also explored the behavioral correlates and resting-state functional connectivity related to these local volume differences. At study entry, we found that freezers (N = 12) and persons who developed FOG during the course of the study (converters) (N = 9) showed local inflations in bilateral thalamus in contrast to persons who did not (non-converters) (N = 36). Longitudinally, converters (N = 7) also showed local inflation in the left thalamus, as compared to non-converters (N = 36). A model including sex, daily levodopa equivalent dose, and local thalamic inflation predicted conversion with good accuracy (AUC: 0.87, sensitivity: 88.9%, specificity: 77.8%). Exploratory analyses showed that local thalamic inflations were associated with larger medial thalamic sub-nuclei volumes and better cognitive performance. Resting-state analyses further revealed that converters had stronger thalamo-cortical coupling with limbic and cognitive regions pre-conversion, with a marked reduction in coupling over the two years. Finally, validation using the PPMI cohort suggested FOG-specific non-linear evolution of thalamic local volume. These findings provide markers of, and deeper insights into conversion to FOG, which may foster earlier intervention and better mobility for persons with PD.
Freezing of gait (FOG) is a debilitating symptom affecting many people with Parkinson’s disease (PD), defined as a ‘brief, episodic absence or marked reduction of forward progression of the feet despite the intention to walk’1. This leads to an increased risk of falling2, and a major impact on physical and mental health-related quality of life3,4. Notoriously, FOG is challenging to treat due to the differential response to dopamine-replacement therapy and the potential negative effects of levodopa on FOG with time5,6. In addition, the effects of rehabilitation are short-term7 and only possible when FOG is still mild8,9,10. Given these challenges, markers of FOG onset are essential to screen for FOG conversion and deliver therapy pre-emptively.
Until now, various studies have looked into the clinical risk factors of conversion to FOG11,12,13,14,15,16,17. However, only one study investigated neural markers of conversion, and found that striatal dopaminergic deficits additionally contributed to a clinical prediction model of this transition18. Owing to the limited evidence, an investigation into neural markers of conversion is warranted for additional predictive purposes and to help explain the elusive mechanisms leading to the onset of FOG19. While freezing episodes likely signify transient dysfunctional information processing across the cortico-basal ganglia-thalamo-cortical parallel circuits20,21,22, these transient events are challenging to elicit and interpret, and therefore have poor applicability as predictive markers. Compensatory or maladaptive structural alterations of the nodes within these circuits, however, are more persistent and therefore easier to capture as possible predictive markers for FOG in PD. A recent systematic review23 of cross-sectional investigations of structural alterations in persons with PD and FOG revealed widespread cortical and subcortical grey matter atrophy24,25,26,27,28,29,30,31,32,33, and associations between FOG severity and atrophy24,29,31, suggesting that grey matter morphology may be a useful marker of FOG onset and progression. Furthermore, when centrally or peripherally originating PD pathology enters the brain34, subcortical structures are affected earlier35,36, and maybe early markers of FOG onset. However, a prospective assessment of this hypothesis is lacking.
In this longitudinal study, we thus investigated the FOG-related morphological changes in key subcortical structures using magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) (Fig. 1). We compared local and global volume differences at study entry and over two years between participants that did not present with or develop FOG during the study (non-converters) and those that either presented with FOG at study entry (freezers) or developed FOG during the study (converters). Based on previous cross-sectional work29,32,33, we hypothesized that individuals with, or about to develop, FOG, would show local or global volume decline in the brainstem, thalamus, and/or caudate compared to non-converters and that this might serve as a neural marker of conversion. We then assessed how well structural markers at study entry could predict conversion to FOG over two years and explored their behavioral associations and underlying sub-nuclear volumetric and functional correlates. Finally, initial validation of these markers was performed using data from the Parkinson’s Progression Markers Initiative (PPMI) cohort.
Out of the fifty-seven persons with PD enrolled in the study, forty-five had never experienced FOG at study entry (non-freezers), while twelve participants already presented with FOG (freezers). Over the two years, nine (20%) of the forty-five non-freezers converted to FOG (converters). All but two of the participants (both converters) completed the two clinical and imaging assessments. One converter dropped out of the study after the first follow-up due to co-morbidities, and the second converter performed all behavioral testing but did not undergo imaging at study exit.
Behavioral analysis at study entry revealed that the nine to-be converters had higher daily levodopa dose (P = 0.050), and higher (worse) MDS-UPDRS part I ‘non-motor activities of daily living’ (P = 0.042) and total scores (P = 0.015) than the to-be non-converters. Freezers, on the other hand, had longer disease duration (P = 0.036), worse scores on part II ‘motor activities of daily living’ (P < 0.001), part III ‘motor examination’ (P = 0.001), and total score (P < 0.001) of the MDS-UPDRS, higher likelihood to have fallen in the previous six months (P = 0.021), and lower (worse) balance scores on the MiniBEST (P = 0.004) when compared to to-be non-converters. Freezers also had worse balance scores on the MiniBEST (P = 0.005) and needed longer time to complete the alternate naming test (P = 0.045) compared to to-be converters (Table 1).
Local volume differences at study entry and over two years
At study entry (N = 57), freezers and converters showed significant local shape inflations compared to non-converters in the right (PFWE min = 0.012) and left (PFWE min = 0.006) thalamus. Voxels with PFWE < 0.05 were thresholded to create the two clusters reported in Fig. 2a and Supplementary Table 1. The mean local volume value for each cluster was extracted to perform post-hoc testing. Post-hoc tests revealed that both converters and freezers showed local inflations in each cluster compared to non-converters with only slight variation in the extent across the two clusters (Fig. 2a).
Longitudinaly (N = 43), permutation testing revealed that converters and non-converters showed significantly different local shape alterations over two years in the brainstem (PFWE max = 0.045), and clusters approaching significance in the left thalamus (PFWE max = 0.06) and left amygdala (PFWE max = 0.083). Voxels were thresholded at PFWE < 0.1 to give the clusters reported in Fig. 2b and Supplementary Table 1. In each of these clusters, the direction of each of these local shape alterations was different between converters (inflation) and non-converters (deflation) (Fig. 2b).
Global volume differences at study entry and over two years
At study entry (N = 57), differences in global volumes with a trend towards significance were found in the brainstem (P = 0.052). Post-hoc tests revealed that freezers had significantly smaller brainstem volumes compared to non-converters (P = 0.034), while no differences were found between converters and non-converters (P = 0.286). Longitudinaly (N = 43), non-converters showed a significantly greater decline in global volume over the two years in the right pallidum (P = 0.050), left thalamus (P = 0.036), and brainstem (P = 0.026); and a trend towards significance in the right thalamus (P = 0.084), compared to converters (Table 2).
Prediction of FOG conversion in non-freezers at study entry
Backward logistic regression retained gender (Odds Ratio for females = 0.074, 95%CI = 0.005–1.11, P = 0.06), daily levodopa equivalent dose (Odds Ratio = 1.006, 95%CI = 1.002–1.01, P = 0.006), and the cluster from the left thalamus (Odds Ratio = 383.45, 95%CI = 3.41–43124, P = 0.014) as significant predictors of conversion to FOG (N = 45). The model was able to predict conversion with an AUC of 0.87 (1 is ideal) and Brier score of 0.11 (0 is ideal), indicating good performance, with a sensitivity of 88.9% and specificity of 77.8% at a Youden’s point – a probability cutoff of 0.19 (Fig. 3). Bootstrap resampling the model selection and evaluation led to similar estimates (Supplementary Table 2).
Local volume associations with behavior
In the group of converters and non-converters, significant and consistent associations with various cognitive tests were found at study entry (Supplementary Table 3) (max N = 45), whereby greater inflation in the thalamic clusters related to better cognitive performance (TMTB-A: Left/Right Thalamus – r = −0.34/−0.38, Alternate Naming Test time: Left/Right Thalamus – r = −0.43/−0.32, and Figure of Rey copy time: Left/Right Thalamus – r = −0.33/−0.40). Conversely, significant associations were found with worse scores on the MDS-UPDRS part IV (Left/Right Thalamus – r = 0.43/0.44), particularly items related to the amount of time spent in OFF (Left/Right Thalamus – r = 0.37/0.36), functional impact of ON/OFF fluctuations (Left/Right Thalamus – r = 0.38/0.39), and predictability of OFF episodes (Left/Right Thalamus – r = 0.5/0.53). No significant correlations were found between clinical change scores and change in local volumes (max N = 43).
Association between local thalamic shape and thalamic sub-nuclei volume
At study entry (N = 45), we found significant positive associations between local shapes of the two thalamic clusters and volumes of a medial group of nuclei (bilaterally) comprising the anteroventral, central medial, lateral dorsal, reuniens, paracentral, mediodorsal (magnocellular) and the anterior pulvinar. An inverse association was revealed with the suprageniculate volume (Fig. 4). Changes in local volume over the two years (N = 43) were positively associated with the left paracentral volume change and negatively associated with the right suprageniculate volume change (Supplementary Table 4).
rsfMRI functional connectivity between thalamic sub-nuclei and cortical areas
At study entry (N = 41), significant differences in thalamo-cortical resting-state coupling were found between converters and non-converters. The mediodorsal magnacellular, lateral dorsal, anteroventral, parafascicular, centeromedian, and ventral anterior nuclei were more strongly coupled with prefrontal and cingulate associative and limbic regions and less strongly coupled with frontoparietal primary and association sensorimotor areas in converters compared to non-converters at study entry (Supplementary Table 5). Over the two years (N = 41), a marked decrease in coupling strength between the mediodorsal magnacellular and dorsolateral and medial prefrontal cortex was seen in converters compared to non-converters (Fig. 5).
Validation study: Progression of thalamic local volumes in PPMI cohort
Twenty-four FOG converters and a hundred and one non-converters across a five-year follow-up were included from the PPMI cohort in this analysis. Linear mixed models evaluated the effect of group (converter vs non-converter) on local volume progression within the three thalamus clusters. No significant results were found between converters and non-converters in the two study-entry clusters on the left and right thalamus. However, for the longitudinal cluster on the left thalamus, a significant main effect of group (p = 0.039) was found, as well as significant interactions between years of follow-up and group (p = 0.001), and between its quadratic term and group (p = 0.048) (Supplementary Table 6). Importantly, although converters showed local deflation compared to non-converters in this cluster within the observed follow-up (see beta estimates in Supplementary Table 6), the sign for the interaction between group and years of follow-up quadratic effect was positive, signaling that local volume increased to a greater extent in converters over time (concave upward). Further, local volume in this cluster was significantly associated with lower dopamine transporter uptake in the right putamen (p = 0.019) and tended to be associated with lower dopamine transporter uptake in the left putamen (p = 0.087), but higher dopamine transporter uptake in the left caudate (p = 0.091).
This prospective longitudinal MRI study investigated whether morphological alterations in the subcortical grey matter would predict conversion to FOG. The main analysis revealed that the thalamus showed local inflations bilaterally in persons with PD who are about to develop FOG, similar to those with overt FOG. Over two years, these local inflations persisted in those participants who converted. Furthermore, a model including thalamic local volume measures could predict conversion to FOG with good accuracy. Correlation analyses further showed that local volume inflation of the thalamus was associated with larger volumes of medial thalamic sub-nuclei and better performance on tests of executive function. Finally, thalamo-cortical resting-state functional coupling was increased between various thalamic sub-nuclei and limbic and associative cortical regions prior to conversion, which declined more in converters than in non-converters over the two years. These findings provide evidence of a novel marker of conversion to FOG in PD and suggest a specific pattern of adaptive neural plasticity prior to conversion, driven through the medial thalamic nuclei.
The candidate underlying physiological mechanisms of local increases in grey matter range from neurogenesis to angiogenesis, synaptogenesis, and gliogenesis. These alterations are likely driven by various neurotransmitters and neurotrophic factors that determine structural changes in response to experience and neural challenge (for review see Zatorre et al.37). In persons with PD, these adaptive mechanisms are not completely lost, as grey matter increases have been reported consequent to, for example, exercise38 and mindfulness39. Post-mortem studies in PD indicate that the thalamic sub-nuclei show changes in both size and shape as compared to healthy controls40, with varying patterns of neuronal loss, and medial structures are typically less affected41. Here, we found that FOG-related local inflations were related to larger volumes in the medial thalamic sub-nuclei such as those previously reported to be more spared in PD41. This medial sparing possibly potentiates the adaptive role of the medial thalamus which may result in both compensatory42 and maladaptive43,44 effects seen in animal models. In our study, larger local inflations in this region were significantly associated with better performance on executive tests, in which the mediodorsal nucleus was previously shown to play a role45. Further, resting-state coupling was stronger between the mediodorsal nucleus and dorsolateral and medial prefrontal cortex in converters prior to conversion. These prefrontal cortices are involved with goal-directed behaviors, on which persons with PD and FOG increasingly rely to operate otherwise automatic motor commands such as gait46,47, suggesting that these shape changes may indeed have an adaptive nature in origin.
Through its connections with the basal ganglia, cerebellum, and cortex48,49,50,51, the thalamus participates in feedback and feedforward mechanisms, playing a modulatory role in integrating information across the parallel motor, cognitive and limbic circuits (for reviews see Haber and McFarland49 and Varela52). Disinhibition of the ventral posterior lateral and ventral lateral motor nuclei of the thalamus53 through the direct dopaminergic pathway normally leads to a release of motor responses54. A large prospective study showed that persons at risk of developing FOG already had reduced striatal dopamine availability18. Although we did not measure dopamine availability or responsiveness, significant associations were found in this cohort between local volume in the thalamus and functional impact and predictability of OFF fluctuations, which suggests failing dopaminergic control of motor symptoms. This reduction in dopamine availability or effectiveness may thus lead to a lack of disinhibition of the lateral thalamic nuclei, triggering thalamo-striatal feedback or thalamo-cortical feedforward mechanisms to augment motor output, via the medial thalamic nuclei55.
We also assessed the OFF-medication resting-state coupling between thalamic sub-nuclei and sub-cortical and cortical areas to investigate whether thalamic functional connectivity could possibly be driving the local shape changes. We found that medial thalamic sub-nuclei showed stronger coupling with cortical associative and limbic areas, and weaker coupling with sensorimotor areas (recall Supplementary Table 5) in converters. Furthermore, we showed that the coupling between the mediodorsal nucleus and the dorsolateral and medial prefrontal cortices of the cognitive control-network declined with time in converters. These findings corroborate and prefigure prior cross-sectional work in freezers showing increased coupling across cortico-subcortical limbic circuitry at rest56, and reduced coupling within the cognitive control networks at rest56,57 and during freezing episodes58,59. Our findings thereby add to the body of literature indicating that persons with PD increasingly rely on non-motor circuits60,61 in order to overcome reduced processing in the depleted sensorimotor circuits, and that over time, altered processing in these compensatory circuits predisposes them for gait breakdown and the onset of FOG. As a result of this increasing reliance on the limbic and associative circuitry, plastic changes may occur in the coupled medial thalamic nuclei, giving rise to the morphological differences seen here.
Besides the motor, limbic and cognitive aspects mentioned in relationship to the onset of FOG, another interesting finding was that the suprageniculate nucleus volume was inversely associated with the local thalamic shape changes both at study entry and over the two years. This nucleus plays a role in spatial localization of stimuli within the visual field62, which is corroborated by the strong correlations we found between these local volumes and cognitive tests loading highly on visual search such as the trail making test and the complex Figure of Rey copy task. The decline in the volume of this structure may in fact also partly explain the visuospatial deficits found pre-16 and post-conversion to FOG in people with PD63,64. One mechanism through which visual cues may mediate their effects may be through circumventing these deficits in extracting salient features from the environment, and by guiding attention to relevant information65.
The predictive model including local volume of the thalamus was able to predict conversion with good accuracy (bootstrap-AUC = 0.82), performing similarly to a far more extensive model based on behavioral information (bootstrap-AUC = 0.79) in the same cohort17. Contrary to our expectations based on cross-sectional work29,32,33, global volumes of subcortical structures were not found to be sensitive markers of conversion to FOG (recall Supplementary Table 1). In line with the study by Snijders and others (2011), we found smaller brainstem volumes in freezers compared to non-converters, but not between converters and non-converters at study entry. Over the two years, volumes in the brainstem, left pallidum and bilateral thalami even showed a relative increase in converters compared to non-converters, indicating that the decline in the volume of these structures reported in earlier studies32,33 may occur subsequent to the onset of FOG. The increase in brainstem global volume in converters was particularly unexpected, but being in accordance with the brainstem local volume changes, likely indicates a non-linear trajectory in brainstem volume over the disease course. Importantly, the local volume changes in the brainstem may reflect involvement of the mesencephalic locomotor region and the pedunculopontine nucleus (recall Fig. 2B), which along with the thalamus and pallidum are involved in sensory-guided locomotor control through the dorsal pathway66. Although this remains to be tested, the relative volume increase in converters may suggest a compensatory shift to external sensory-guided control of locomotion to overcome a failure of the internal motor drive.
Owing to the small sample of converters in the original study, external validation was conducted using the PPMI cohort, the largest open access database of PD neuroimaging data. However, the multi-center study did not focus on FOG and therefore lacked a validated scale to establish the presence of FOG. Further, as these participants were untreated at inclusion and medication doses were frequently adjusted, the emergence and disappearance of FOG is plausible during follow-up. We therefore took a more inclusive approach to classifying FOG, using self- or rater-reported information across all follow-up visits, despite reponses at subsequent visits. Further, as the imaging protocols (scanner hardware and software, acquisition sequences) were different from our own cohort, the local volume metrics may not be comparable. Despite these sources of variability, we showed that local volumes in one thalamus cluster showed a different progression in converters and non-converters across both cohorts, and that in de novo PD these trajectories diverge as the disease progresses. Furthermore, greater local volumes in this cluster were associated with lower dopamine transporter uptake in the putamen, but tended to be associated with higher dopamine transporter uptake in the left caudate. Putamen dopamine availability reduction likely leads to reduced locomotor automaticity, leading to a compensatory shift to more cognitive control of gait mediated through the caudate-prefrontal circuits, as long as caudate dopamine is preserved. These relationships with striatal dopamine availability lend additional support to the compensatory explanation for the thalamic structural changes.
This multimodal prospective longitudinal study addressing structural imaging markers and FOG conversion is not without its limitations. Despite the large sample of non-freezers, only 20% of participants developed FOG over two years leading to a small group of converters. Although conversion rates were low, rendering the study underpowered to detect shape changes in other FOG-related nuclei29,67, multi-method investigations showed a consistent pattern of results. Further, in our primary contrast, we pooled together converters and freezers in order to increase FOG specificity by looking at deficits common to these groups as well as to increase statistical power. Despite differences in disease stage, FOG classification, and imaging parameters, results from the PPMI cohort supported the patterns found, while further suggesting that the markers of conversion found would probably not be useful in the early stages of the disease. These results were expected based on the contribution of levodopa equivalent dose to the prediction model and associations between local volumes and medication fluctuations (our data), which were also replicated with the PPMI data using more direct estimates of striatal dysfunction. Longer follow-ups of the PPMI cohort may provide the opportunity to compare the cohorts at a similar disease stage. Finally, as FOG may be heterogeneous68, it is also possible that the results may relate to a particular phenotype of FOG. Future multi-center prospective cohort studies with comprehensive FOG characterization and longer follow-ups could overcome many of these limitations.
In summary, through this prospective longitudinal MR study, we showed that alterations in bilateral thalamus morphology predicted conversion to FOG in PD. Behavioral associations and thalamo-cortical connectivity suggested that the morphological changes were compensatory in nature, and conversion to FOG was accompanied by decompensation within these circuits over two years. These findings reveal the potential of thalamus morphology as a marker for screening individuals at risk of developing FOG and shed light on the role of the thalamus in the aetiology of FOG.
Fifty-seven persons (45 without FOG and 12 with FOG) with idiopathic PD (UK Parkinson’s Disease Brain Bank criteria) were recruited and prospectively followed up for two years. Participants underwent extensive behavioral testing and MRI scanning at study entry and two years later, at the Movement Analysis Laboratory of KU Leuven and the University Hospital of Leuven, Belgium. To be eligible for inclusion, participants needed to be able to walk unassisted for 10 min, be free from Deep Brain Stimulators and other MR contraindications, and without probable dementia (Mini Mental Status Examination <24) and other comorbidity. Recruitment of participants began in August 2012 and final assessments were completed in May 2016. As FOG episodes are more common when medication is withheld69, measurements and scans were performed in the morning while participants were “OFF” medication – at least 12 h after the last dopaminergic medication intake. In accordance with the Declaration of Helsinki, participants provided written informed consent prior to enrolment. The study was approved by the Ethics Committee Research UZ/KU Leuven (Study number: B322201215418).
The full test battery of behavioral measures has been reported elsewhere17. Here, we present new neuroimaging data from this longitudinal cohort study. Global cognition was assessed with the Montreal Cognitive Assessment (MoCA)70, executive function with the Frontal Assessment Battery (FAB)71, Trail Making Test B-A time (TMTB-A), and Alternate Naming Test, and visuospatial function and working memory with the Complex Figure of Rey test. Affect was measured with the Hospital Anxiety and Depression Scale72. Balance performance was assessed with the Mini Balance Evaluation Test (MiniBEST)73 and symptom severity with the Movement Disorders Society Revision of the Unified Parkinson’s Disease Rating Scale (MDS-UPDRS)74. Participants were classified as having FOG by their response to the first question of the New Freezing of Gait Questionnaire (NFOG-Q) (“Did you experience Freezing episodes over the past month”), after showing them a video with different kinds of freezing episodes75. Importantly, none of the non-freezers showed objective freezing during the extended behavioral test battery at study entry.
High-resolution anatomical and resting-state functional MRI (rs-fMRI) were acquired in a 3T Philips ACHIEVA MRI scanner (Best, The Netherlands). Anatomical T1-weighted scans were acquired using Turbo Field Echo sequence (duration: 383 s, TR/TE: 9.6/4.6 ms, flip angle: 8°, voxel size: 0.98 × 1.2 × 0.98 mm, number of slices: 182, FOV: 218.4 × 250 × 250 mm). Rs-fMRI scans were acquired using T2*-weighted Gradient Echo Planar Imaging sequence (duration: 435 s, TR/TE: 1700/33 ms, flip angle: 90°, voxel size: 3.59 × 3.74 × 4 mm, number of slices: 31, FOV: 230 × 124 × 230 mm). During the scan, participants had their eyes open while looking at a standard crosshair on a blank screen.
MRI processing – shape analysis
Vertex-based analysis of fifteen subcortical structures (amygdala, nucleus accumbens, caudate, hippocampus, pallidum, putamen, thalamus – bilaterally; and brainstem) was performed using FMRIB Software Library’s (FSL, version 5.0.9)76 FMRIB Integrated Registration and Segmentation Tool (FIRST) (https://fsl.fmrib.ox.ac.uk/fsl/fslwiki/FIRST)77. This automated method has been validated in healthy and patient populations with high retest reliability over repeated measurements78, particularly for segmenting the striatum79. Deformable mesh models were fitted to the surface of each structure and local and global volumes were calculated. Local volume quantifies subregional shape variations on the surface of a nucleus – calculated as the scalar distance of an individual’s vertices to the mean sample vertices. Global volume quantifies the total volume of the nucleus – calculated as the volume within the surface mesh. A change score for each participant was calculated as Scan2 – Scan1, so positive values imply inflation in local volume or an increase in global volume over the two years.
For the main analysis, we investigated local and global volume differences at study entry and over the two years:
Using data from study entry (N = 57), we investigated structural alterations between non-converters (N = 36) and converters and freezers (N = 21) in order to identify FOG-specific structural markers. We then performed post-hoc analyses to test which FOG sub-group differed from non-converters. The predictive value and behavioral relationships of these markers were tested in a subsequent analysis.
Using change scores over the two years (N = 43), we investigated structural markers showing a differential progression between non-converters (N = 36) and converters (N = 7). The relationship between these markers and behavioral change was tested in a subsequent analysis.
Local volume alterations were analyzed by non-parametric permutation testing80 using FSL’s randomise tool, with age, gender and daily levodopa equivalent dose as nuisance regressors. Ten thousand permutations were performed and the family-wise error (FWE) rate was corrected using Threshold Free Cluster Enhancement (two-dimensional), which has been shown to be more sensitive and robust than voxel-based or cluster-based thresholding methods81,82. Mean local volume in clusters showing a significant effect was extracted and post-hoc analyses were performed in SPSS v.25 (IBM Corp, NY). These constituted an analysis of covariance between non-converters, converters, and freezers with age, gender, and daily levodopa equivalent dose as covariates. Disease duration and MDS-UPDRS motor scores were considered as covariates, however, models containing these measures led to worse model fit, based on the Akaike’s Information Criteria. Pairwise comparisons were corrected with the Bonferroni method.
Global volumes of the fifteen subcortical structures were extracted from the segmented meshes in native space. Total intracranial volume was estimated using SPM 12 (Wellcome Trust Centre for Neuroimaging, London)83. The two contrasts (i and ii above) were tested with an analysis of covariance, using age, gender, daily levodopa equivalent dose and total intracranial volume as covariates. Post-hoc pairwise comparisons between non-converters, freezers and converters were also corrected with the Bonferroni method.
To investigate the predictive performance of the significant local volume clusters, logistic regression in the group of non-freezers (N = 45) at study entry (non-converters and converters) was performed. Collinearity was first assessed between all predictors including the significant clusters, age, gender and daily levodopa equivalent dose. Predictors with a variance inflation factor <4 were included in a backward logistic regression model (Wald chi-square test - Pstay = 0.1). The area under the receiving operator characteristics curve (AUC), Brier score84 and optimal performance of the model based on the Youdens’s index85 are reported. Validation was performed with boostrap resampling, similar to previous work17.
Association of local volume measures with clinical measures at study entry (max N = 45) and over two years (max N = 43) was investigated using Pearson’s product moment correlations in the non-converters and converters. No multiple comparison correction was performed for this exploratory analysis.
To assess anatomical specificity of the significant thalamic local volume findings, we investigated the association between local volumes and thalamic sub-nuclei volumes in the non-converters and converters. A recently developed method86 was used to segment twenty-five thalamic sub-nuclei with FreeSurfer v.6 (http://surfer.nmr.mgh.harvard.edu/)87. Pearson product moment correlation was performed between local volume measures and sub-nuclei volumes at study entry and between volumetric changes over two years.
To explore the functional correlates of the local volume changes, we also investigated Rs-fMRI functional connectivity between the thalamic sub-nuclei and sub-cortical and cortical areas at study entry and over the two years (N = 41 for both analyses, non-converters = 34, converters = 7). Rs-fMRI volumes were preprocessed using fMRIprep v.1.5.888 (see Supplementary Methods for boilerplate and additional preprocessing details) and further denoising and ROI-to-ROI analyses were performed using the CONN toolbox v.19b89. Seed-to-target coupling was compared between non-converters and converters at study entry and over two years using an analysis of covariance with age, sex, and daily levodopa equivalent dose included as covariates. Multiple comparisons for each seed region were corrected with the (Benjamini and Hochberg) false discovery rate procedure.
Finally, to validate these findings, the progression of local volumes in the PPMI dataset were investigated. Clinical and structural MRI data were obtained from the PPMI database, downloaded on the 29th of June 2018. For up-to-date information on the PPMI study and data, visit www.ppmi-info.org. To be eligible for inclusion, participants had to have a diagnosis of PD for 2 years or less and be unmedicated. Participants from this de-novo PD cohort for whom 3T MR high resolution (1mm3) anatomical scans were available, and who did not present with FOG at diagnosis were included in the present analysis. Conversion classification was based on the MDS-UPDRS scores, with either consistent subjective reports of FOG on item 2.13 at multiple (>1) follow-ups or an objective rating of FOG on item 3.11(OFF-medication) at any follow-up visit. Shape analysis was performed similarly as described above for the MRI data of the present study for 388 scans from 125 participants, 24 of whom were classified as converters. Median follow-up was 4 years, with anatomic and dopamine transporter scans having been acquired at baseline, one-year, two-year, and four-year follow-ups. Thalamus clusters that were significant in our own cohort (left and right thalamus at study entry and left thalamus over the two years) were used as masks to extract the local volumes in the PPMI cohort.
Linear mixed models were then used to investigate differences in the cluster local volumes between PPMI converters and non-converters over time. Specifically, the models were run separately for the three thalamus clusters’ local volumes as dependent variables with years of follow-up, its quadratic term and group, and their interactions as independent variables. Age, sex, and left and right caudate and putamen dopamine transporter uptake were included as covariates. A random intercept was estimated for participants within each center, with a variance component. Fit of the models was visually assessed. If we would find significant group effects or significant interaction effects between group and years of follow-up or its quadratic term, these would indicate external validity of local volume within these clusters as predictors of conversion to FOG.
Further information on research design is available in the Nature Research Reporting Summary linked to this article.
The data used in this manuscript can be provided upon reasonable request from the author and in agreement with the KU Leuven.
All neuroimaging analyses performed in this manuscript were performed with freely available neuroimaging tools namely FSL, FreeSurfer, fMRIPrep, ANTs, CONN toolbox, and SPM. CONN toolbox was implemented in a Matlab environment (version 16b, The MathWorks, Natick, MA, USA) and statistical analyses for internal and external validation were performed in SAS version 9.4 for Windows (SAS Institute Inc., Cary, NC, USA). Code for specific processes can be obtained from the author upon reasonable request.
Nutt, J. G. et al. Freezing of gait: moving forward on a mysterious clinical phenomenon. Lancet Neurol. 10, 734–744 (2011).
Paul, S. S. et al. Three simple clinical tests to accurately predict falls in people with Parkinson’s disease. Mov. Disord. 28, 655–662 (2013).
Perez-Lloret, S. et al. Prevalence, determinants, and effect on quality of life of freezing of gait in Parkinson disease. JAMA Neurol. 71, 884 (2014).
Walton, C. C. et al. The major impact of freezing of gait on quality of life in Parkinson’s disease. J. Neurol. 262, 108–115 (2015).
Nonnekes, J., Bereau, M. & Bloem, B. R. Freezing of gait and its levodopa paradox. JAMA Neurol. 77, 287–288 (2020).
Lucas McKay, J. et al. Freezing of Gait can persist after an acute levodopa challenge in Parkinson’s disease. npj Park Dis 5, 25 (2019).
Cosentino, C. et al. Effectiveness of physiotherapy on freezing of gait in Parkinson’s disease: a systematic review and meta‐analyses. Mov. Disord. 35, 523–536 (2020).
Olson, M., Lockhart, T. E. & Lieberman, A. Motor learning deficits in Parkinson’s disease (PD) and their effect on training response in gait and balance: a narrative review. Front. Neurol. 10, 62 (2019).
Heremans, E. et al. Impaired retention of motor learning of writing skills in patients with Parkinson’s disease with freezing of gait. PLoS ONE 11, e0148933 (2016).
Vandenbossche, J. et al. Impaired implicit sequence learning in Parkinson’s disease patients with freezing of gait. Neuropsychology 27, 28–36 (2013).
Ehgoetz Martens, K. A. et al. Predicting the onset of freezing of gait: a longitudinal study. Mov. Disord. 00, 1–8 (2017).
Giladi, N. et al. Freezing of gait in patients with advanced Parkinson’s disease. J. Neural Transm. 108, 53–61 (2001).
Banks, S. J., Bayram, E., Shan, G., LaBelle, D. R. & Bluett, B. Non-motor predictors of freezing of gait in Parkinson’s disease. Gait Posture 68, 311–316 (2019).
Zhang, H. et al. A prospective study of freezing of gait with early Parkinson disease in Chinese patients. Med. (United States) 95, (2016).
Forsaa, E. B., Larsen, J. P., Wentzel-Larsen, T. & Alves, G. A 12-year population-based study of freezing of gait in Parkinson’s disease. Park. Relat. Disord. 21, 254–258 (2015).
Ou, R. et al. Predictors of freezing of gait in Chinese patients with Parkinson’s disease. Brain Behav. 8, 1–9 (2018).
D’Cruz, N. et al. Repetitive motor control deficits most consistent predictors of conversion to freezing of gait in Parkinson’s disease: a prospective cohort study. J. Parkinsons. Dis. 10, 559–571 (2020).
Kim, R. et al. Presynaptic striatal dopaminergic depletion predicts the later development of freezing of gait in de novo Parkinson’s disease: an analysis of the PPMI cohort. Park. Relat. Disord. 51, 49–54 (2018).
Weiss, D. et al. Freezing of gait: understanding the complexity of an enigmatic phenomenon. Brain 143, 14–30 (2020).
Pozzi, N. G. et al. Freezing of gait in Parkinson’s disease reflects a sudden derangement of locomotor network dynamics. Brain 142, 2037–2050 (2019).
Georgiades, M. J. et al. Hitting the brakes: Pathological subthalamic nucleus activity in Parkinson’s disease gait freezing. Brain 142, (2019).
Matar, E. et al. Identifying the neural correlates of doorway freezing in Parkinson’s disease. Hum. Brain Mapp. (2019), https://doi.org/10.1002/hbm.24506.
Bharti, K. et al. Neuroimaging advances in Parkinson’s disease with freezing of gait: a systematic review. NeuroImage Clin. 24, 102059 (2019).
Kostic, V. S. et al. Pattern of brain tissue loss associated with freezing of gait in Parkinson disease. Neurology 78, 409–416 (2012).
Brugger, F. et al. Do executive dysfunction and freezing of gait in Parkinson’s disease share the same neuroanatomical correlates? J. Neurol. Sci. 356, 184–187 (2015).
Jha, M. et al. Neuropsychological and imaging profile of patients with Parkinson’s disease and freezing of gait. Park. Relat. Disord. 21, 1184–1190 (2015).
Pietracupa, S. et al. Freezing of gait in Parkinson’s disease: gray and white matter abnormalities. J. Neurol. 265, 52–62 (2018).
Vastik, M. et al. Freezing of gait is associated with cortical thinning in mesial frontal cortex. Biomed. Pap. 161, 389–396 (2017).
Herman, T., Rosenberg-Katz, K., Jacob, Y., Giladi, N. & Hausdorff, J. M. Gray matter atrophy and freezing of gait in Parkinson’s disease: Is the evidence black-on-white? Mov. Disord. 29, 134–139 (2014).
Rubino, A. et al. Does a volume reduction of the parietal lobe contribute to freezing of gait in Parkinson’s disease? Park. Relat. Disord. 20, 1101–1103 (2014).
Tessitore, A. et al. Regional gray matter atrophy in patients with Parkinson disease and freezing of gait. Am. J. Neuroradiol. 33, 1804–1809 (2012).
Snijders, A. H. et al. Gait-related cerebral alterations in patients with Parkinson’s disease with freezing of gait. Brain 134, 59–72 (2011).
Sunwoo, M. K. et al. Thalamic volume and related visual recognition are associated with freezing of gait in non-demented patients with Parkinson’s disease. Parkinsonism Relat. Disord. 19, 1106–1109 (2013).
Horsager, J. et al. Brain-first versus body-first Parkinson’s disease: a multimodal imaging case-control study. Brain (2020), https://doi.org/10.1093/brain/awaa238.
Halliday, G. M. & McCann, H. The progression of pathology in Parkinson’s disease. Ann. N. Y. Acad. Sci. 1184, 188–195 (2010).
Braak, H. et al. Staging of brain pathology related to sporadic Parkinson’s disease. Neurobiol. Aging 24, 197–211 (2003).
Zatorre, R. J., Fields, R. D. & Johansen-Berg, H. Plasticity in gray and white: Neuroimaging changes in brain structure during learning. Nature Neuroscience (2012), https://doi.org/10.1038/nn.3045.
Sehm, B. et al. Structural brain plasticity in Parkinson’s disease induced by balance training. Neurobiol. Aging (2014), https://doi.org/10.1016/j.neurobiolaging.2013.06.021.
Pickut, B. A. et al. Mindfulness based intervention in Parkinson’s disease leads to structural brain changes on MRI: a randomized controlled longitudinal trial. Clin. Neurol. Neurosurg. 115, 2419–2425 (2013).
Hassler, R., Mundinger, F. & Riechert, T. Clinical and Pathophysiologic Findings Related to Autopsy Data in Cases of Parkinsonism Operated on by Stereotaxis. in Stereotaxis in Parkinson Syndrome 46–145 (Springer Berlin Heidelberg, 1979), https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-642-66521-9_3.
Halliday, G. M. Thalamic changes in Parkinson’s disease. Park. Relat. Disord. 15, S152–S155 (2009).
Aymerich, M. S. et al. Consequences of unilateral nigrostriatal denervation on the thalamostriatal pathway in rats. Eur. J. Neurosci. 23, 2099–2108 (2006).
Fan, L.-L. et al. Lesions of mediodorsal thalamic nucleus reverse abnormal firing of the medial prefrontal cortex neurons in parkinsonian rats. Neural Regen. Res. 14, 1635 (2019).
Tanimura, A., Du, Y., Kondapalli, J., Wokosin, D. L. & Surmeier, D. J. Cholinergic interneurons amplify thalamostriatal excitation of striatal indirect pathway neurons in Parkinson’s disease models. Neuron 101, 444–458.e6 (2019).
Mitchell, A. S. & Chakraborty, S. What does the mediodorsal thalamus do? Front. Syst. Neurosci. 7, 37 (2013).
Wu, T., Hallett, M. & Chan, P. Motor automaticity in Parkinson’s disease. Neurobiol. Dis. 82, 226–234 (2015).
Bohnen, N. I. & Jahn, K. Imaging: What can it tell us about Parkinsonian gait? Mov. Disord. 28, 1492–1500 (2013).
Quartarone, A. et al. New insights into cortico-basal-cerebellar connectome: clinical and physiological considerations. 1–11 (2019), https://doi.org/10.1093/brain/awz310.
Haber, S. & McFarland, N. R. The place of the thalamus in frontal cortical-basal ganglia circuits. Neuroscientist 7, 315–324 (2001).
Alexander, G., DeLong, M. & Peter, S. Parallel organization of functionally segregated circuits linking basal ganglia and cortex. Annu. Rev. Neurosci. 9, 357–381 (1986).
Middleton, F. A. & Strick, P. L. Basal ganglia and cerebellar loops. Brain Res. Rev. 31, 236–250 (2000).
Varela, C. Thalamic neuromodulation and its implications for executive networks. Front. Neural Circuits 8, 69 (2014).
Yuan, R., Taylor, P. A., Alvarez, T. L., Mishra, D. & Biswal, B. B. MAPBOT: Meta-analytic parcellation based on text, and its application to the human thalamus. Neuroimage 157, 716–732 (2017).
Wichmann, T. & Delong, M. R. Functional and pathophysiological models of the basal ganglia. Curr. Opin. Neurobiol. 6, 751–758 (1996).
Nanda, B., Galvan, A., Smith, Y. & Wichmann, T. Effects of stimulation of the centromedian nucleus of the thalamus on the activity of striatal cells in awake rhesus monkeys. Eur. J. Neurosci. 29, 588–598 (2009).
Gilat, M. et al. Dysfunctional limbic circuitry underlying freezing of gait in Parkinson’s disease. Neuroscience 374, 119–132 (2018).
Tessitore, A. et al. Resting-state brain connectivity in patients with Parkinson’s disease and freezing of gait. Parkinsonism Relat. Disord. 18, 781–787 (2012).
Ehgoetz Martens, K. A. et al. The functional network signature of heterogeneity in freezing of gait. Brain 4, 1145–1160 (2018).
Shine, J. M. et al. Freezing of gait in Parkinson’s disease is associated with functional decoupling between the cognitive control network and the basal ganglia. Brain 136, 3671–3681 (2013).
Tard, C. et al. Brain metabolic abnormalities during gait with freezing in Parkinson’s disease. Neuroscience 307, 281–301 (2015).
Isaias, I. U. et al. Brain metabolic alterations herald falls in patients with Parkinson’s disease. Ann. Clin. Transl. Neurol. 7, 579–583 (2020).
Eördegh, G., Nagy, A., Berényi, A. & Benedek, G. Processing of spatial visual information along the pathway between the suprageniculate nucleus and the anterior ectosylvian cortex. Brain Res. Bull. 67, 281–289 (2005).
Lord, S., Archibald, N., Mosimann, U., Burn, D. & Rochester, L. Dorsal rather than ventral visual pathways discriminate freezing status in Parkinson’s disease. Park. Relat. Disord. 18, 1094–1096 (2012).
Nantel, J., McDonald, J. C., Tan, S. & Bronte-Stewart, H. Deficits in visuospatial processing contribute to quantitative measures of freezing of gait in Parkinson’s disease. Neuroscience 221, 151–156 (2012).
Stuart, S., Lord, S., Galna, B. & Rochester, L. Saccade frequency response to visual cues during gait in Parkinson’s disease: the selective role of attention. Eur. J. Neurosci. (2018), https://doi.org/10.1111/ejn.13864.
Snijders, A. H. et al. Physiology of freezing of gait. Ann. Neurol. 80, 644–659 (2016).
Bohnen, N. I. et al. Cholinergic system changes of falls and freezing of gait in Parkinson’s disease. Ann. Neurol. 85, 538–549 (2019).
Ehgoetz Martens, K. A. et al. Evidence for subtypes of freezing of gait in Parkinson’s disease. Mov. Disord. 33, 1174–1178 (2018).
Schaafsma, J. D. et al. Characterization of freezing of gait subtypes and the response of each to levodopa in Parkinson’s disease. Eur. J. Neurol. 10, 391–398 (2003).
Nasreddine, Z. S. et al. The montreal cognitive assessment, MoCA: a brief screening tool for mild cognitive impairment. J. Am. Geriatr. Soc. 53, 695–699 (2005).
Dubois, B., Slachevsky, a, Litvan, I. & Pillon, B. The FAB: a frontal assessment battery at bedside. Neurology 55, 1621–1626 (2000).
Bjelland, I., Dahl, A. A., Haug, T. T. & Neckelmann, D. The validity of the Hospital Anxiety and Depression Scale. An updated literature review. J. Psychosom. Res. 52, 69–77 (2002).
Löfgren, N., Lenholm, E., Conradsson, D., Ståhle, A. & Franzén, E. The Mini-BESTest - a clinically reproducible tool for balance evaluations in mild to moderate Parkinson’s disease? BMC Neurol. 14, 235 (2014).
Goetz, C. G. et al. Movement disorder society-sponsored revision of the unified Parkinson’s disease rating scale (MDS-UPDRS): scale presentation and clinimetric testing results. Mov. Disord. 23, 2129–2170 (2008).
Nieuwboer, A. et al. Reliability of the new freezing of gait questionnaire: agreement between patients with Parkinson’s disease and their carers. Gait Posture 30, 459–463 (2009).
Smith, S. M. et al. Advances in functional and structural MR image analysis and implementation as FSL. in NeuroImage (2004), https://doi.org/10.1016/j.neuroimage.2004.07.051.
Patenaude, B., Smith, S. M., Kennedy, D. N. & Jenkinson, M. A Bayesian model of shape and appearance for subcortical brain segmentation. Neuroimage 56, 907–922 (2011).
Nugent, A. C. et al. Automated subcortical segmentation using FIRST: test-retest reliability, interscanner reliability, and comparison to manual segmentation. Hum. Brain Mapp. 34, 2313–2329 (2013).
Perlaki, G. et al. Comparison of accuracy between FSL’s FIRST and Freesurfer for caudate nucleus and putamen segmentation. Sci. Rep. 7, 1–9 (2017).
Winkler, A. M., Ridgway, G. R., Webster, M. A., Smith, S. M. & Nichols, T. E. Permutation inference for the general linear model. Neuroimage 92, 381–397 (2014).
Salimi-Khorshidi, G., Smith, S. M. & Nichols, T. E. Adjusting the effect of nonstationarity in cluster-based and TFCE inference. Neuroimage 54, 2006–2019 (2011).
Smith, S. M. & Nichols, T. E. Threshold-free cluster enhancement: addressing problems of smoothing, threshold dependence and localisation in cluster inference. Neuroimage 44, 83–98 (2009).
Ashburner, J. & Friston, K. J. 5. Image Segmentation. in Human brain function (2003), https://doi.org/10.1109/TPAMI.2011.130.
Brier, G. W. Verification of forecasts expressed in terms of probability. Mon. Weather Rev. 78, 1–3 (1950).
Youden, W. J. Index for rating diagnostic tests. Cancer (1950), https://doi.org/10.1002/1097-0142(1950)3:1<32::AID-CNCR2820030106>3.0.CO;2-3.
Iglesias, J. E. et al. A probabilistic atlas of the human thalamic nuclei combining ex vivo MRI and histology. Neuroimage 183, 314–326 (2018).
Fischl, B. et al. Whole brain segmentation. Neuron 33, 341–355 (2002).
Esteban, O. et al. fMRIPrep: a robust preprocessing pipeline for functional MRI. Nat. Methods 16, 111–116 (2019).
Whitfield-Gabrieli, S. & Nieto-Castanon, A. Conn: a functional connectivity toolbox for correlated and anticorrelated brain networks. Brain Connect 2, 125–141 (2012).
Support for this study was provided through a grant from the Special Research Fund of KU Leuven, Belgium (contract OT/11/091), and from the Research Foundation Flanders (FWO) (grant number G.0867.15). PPMI – a public-private partnership – is funded by the Michael J. Fox Foundation for Parkinson’s Research and funding partners including Abbvie, Allergan, Amathus therapeutics, Avid Radiopharmaceuticals, Biogen Idec, Biolegend, Briston-Myers Squibb, Celgene, Denali, GE Healthcare, Genentech, GlaxoSmithKline, Janssen Neuroscience, Lilly, Lundbeck, Merck, Meso Scale Discovery, Pfizer, Piramal, Prevail Therapeutics, Roche, Sanofi Genzyme, Servier, Takeda, Teva, UCB, Verily and Voyager Therapeutics.
The authors declare no relevant financial disclosures or conflicts of interest with regard to this work. N.D., S.C., B.W.D., M.G., and A.N. are employed by the KU Leuven. G.V. is employed by IQVIA. S.C. is the recipient of a postdoctoral fellowship from the Flander Research Funds (FWO). M.G. is funded by the European Union’s Horizon 2020 research and innovation programme under the Marie Sklodowska-Curie grant agreement No 838576. A.N. received research grants from Flanders Research Funds (FWO); Jacques and Gloria Gossweiler Foundation; King Baudouin Foundation; European Commission; KU Leuven Internal Funds and MJ Fox Foundation.
Publisher’s note Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.
Rights and permissions
Open Access This article is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License, which permits use, sharing, adaptation, distribution and reproduction in any medium or format, as long as you give appropriate credit to the original author(s) and the source, provide a link to the Creative Commons license, and indicate if changes were made. The images or other third party material in this article are included in the article’s Creative Commons license, unless indicated otherwise in a credit line to the material. If material is not included in the article’s Creative Commons license and your intended use is not permitted by statutory regulation or exceeds the permitted use, you will need to obtain permission directly from the copyright holder. To view a copy of this license, visit http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/.
About this article
Cite this article
D’Cruz, N., Vervoort, G., Chalavi, S. et al. Thalamic morphology predicts the onset of freezing of gait in Parkinson’s disease. npj Parkinsons Dis. 7, 20 (2021). https://doi.org/10.1038/s41531-021-00163-0
This article is cited by
Clinical and MRI features of gait and balance disorders in neurodegenerative diseases
Journal of Neurology (2023)
Baseline cerebral structural morphology predict freezing of gait in early drug-naïve Parkinson’s disease
npj Parkinson's Disease (2022)
MRI biomarkers of freezing of gait development in Parkinson’s disease
npj Parkinson's Disease (2022)
Cerebral blood flow alterations specific to freezing of gait in Parkinson’s disease
Neurological Sciences (2022)
Toward More Accessible Fully Automated 3D Volumetric MRI Decision Trees for the Differential Diagnosis of Multiple System Atrophy, Related Disorders, and Age-Matched Healthy Subjects
The Cerebellum (2022)