Human-assisted space exploration will require efficient methods of food production. Large-scale farming in presence of an Earth-like atmosphere in space faces two main challenges: plant yield in microgravity and plant nutrition in extraterrestrial soils, which are likely low in nutrients compared to terrestrial farm lands. We propose a plant-fungal symbiosis (i.e. mycorrhiza) as an efficient tool to increase plant biomass production in extraterrestrial environments. We tested the mycorrhization of Solanaceae on the model plant Petunia hybrida using the arbuscular mycorrhizal fungus Rhizophagus irregularis under simulated microgravity (s0-g) conditions obtained through a 3-D random positioning machine. Our results show that s0-g negatively affects mycorrhization and plant phosphate uptake by inhibiting hyphal elongation and secondary branching. However, in low nutrient conditions, the mycorrhiza can still support plant biomass production in s0-g when colonized plants have increased SL root exudation. Alternatively, s0-g in high nutrient conditions boosts tissue-specific cell division and cell expansion and overall plant size in Petunia, which has been reported for other plants species. Finally, we show that the SL mimic molecule rac-GR24 can still induce hyphal branching in vitro under simulated microgravity. Based on these results, we propose that in nutrient limited conditions strigolactone root exudation can challenge the negative microgravity effects on mycorrhization and therefore might play an important role in increasing the efficiency of future space farming.
Mycorrhizas are plant-fungal symbioses that occur in 95% of land plant families,1 among them the majority of staple crops. Through their fungal hyphae, mycorrhizas allow plants to enlarge their root system and reach eventually sparcely available nutrients such as phosphate, nitrogen, and micronutrients, as well as water. In turn, plants provide mycorrhizal fungi with sugars and lipids.2 This symbiosis is assumed to be advantageous for plant development, seed yield, and biomass accumulation when nutrient conditions are below optimal.3 The initiation of this symbiosis occurs with the plant root exudation of phytohormones belonging to the recently characterized strigolactone (SL) family.4 SLs are carotenoid derivatives that play several roles in regulating root and shoot architecture, biotic and abiotic stress resistance, and stimulate fungal hyphal branching toward the host plant root.5 As SL biosynthesis and transport are induced by low nutrient conditions, especially phosphate and nitrogen, SL signaling shapes plant development accordingly to the environmental conditions. SL biosynthesis and signaling seem to follow a rather linear pathway shared among many plant species.6 All-trans-β-carotenoids are converted to the bioactive SL precursor carlactone first by the enzymatic activities of the iron-containing protein DWARF27 (D27) and then by two carotenoid cleavage dioxygenases CCD7 and CCD8, respectively, decreased apical dominance3/DAD3 and decreased apical dominance1/DAD1 in Petunia hybrida.7 From carlactone, a plant-species-specific pool of P450 monooxygenases synthetizes SL molecules with different stereochemistry and decorations (e.g., strigol and orobanchol), which are most abundant in rice and Petunia8,9 or metyl-carlactonoic acid, isolated in Arabidopsis.10 SL signaling is detected by a heterodimeric receptor consisting of the alpha/beta hydrolase DWARF14 (D14) and the F-BOX protein—more axillary branches2 (MAX2). In the presence of SL, the two proteins assemble hydrolyzing SL. This signal starts a cascade of events leading to the ubiquitination of transcriptional repressors and to the activation of gene expression, e.g., ideal plant architecture1 (IPA1).11
SLs have several functions in planta, such as the regulation of lateral branching above ground and the already mentioned induction of fungal hyphal branching. SL transport and exudation are catalyzed through the ABCG class protein—pleiotropic drug resistance19 from P. hybrida. Up-to-date, SL cellular exporters have been isolated only in Solanaceae12 but characterized only in Petunia. However, phylogenetic analyses13 reveal the presence of PDR1 homologs in crops and Leguminosae. P. hybrida was chosen for this investigation on mycorrhization in simulated microgravity (s0-g) for its proximity to staple food plants like tomatoes, potatoes, and eggplants, and for the availability of mutant plants with altered SL transport efficiency. The latter include pdr1 ko9 and PDR1 over-expressor (PDR1 OE) plants,14 respectively, shown to be low or high in SL root exudation and root mycorrhization. Below ground, PDR1 is expressed in root tips, where DAD1 is also present, and in specialized, non-suberized root cortex cells named hypodermal passage cells (HPCs). HPCs are not only the exudation point for SL but also constitute the entrance gate for fungal hyphae into the plant root.15 A suberized hypodermis and HPCs are present in the majority of crops,16 therefore PDR1 and its homologs are assumed to have a key role in the regulation of plant nutrition even outside of the Solanaceae family.
To date, mycorrhization has not been assayed in space-like conditions, likely because environmental requirements are difficult to re-create on the International Space Station (ISS) and microgravity conditions are short-lived on parabolic flights. Recently, Dauzart et al.17 showed that nodulation of the legume model plant Medicago truncatula was affected on a two-dimensional (2D) clinostat, an alternative method of generating a simulated microgravity environment. They found that mycorrhization contributes to regulate nodulation in such conditions, but no mycorrhization data were provided. The efficiency of mycorrhization, and therefore of plant nutrient uptake, are important parameters to investigate before farming remote sites on the Moon or in space stations, where native or available soils might be extremely different from Earth18 and gravity forces are lower than on Earth or in the range of microgravity. The shipment of soil and fertilizer from Earth to space might be an expensive challenge in the long run. Instead, using lunar soil that represents a fine fraction of the native regolith might serve as basal growth medium for plants with the added help of mycorrhizal fungi. Studies have already been conducted in 2008 at the European Space Agency (ESA) where marigolds (Calendula) were cultivated on crushed rock that closely resembles lunar soil. In such or similar substrates, mycorrhization of plant roots could be vital for successful growth. Mycorrhization would also assure sustainable agriculture in space, a place where a balanced resource allocation and management are more essential than on Earth. Therefore, for the future of space-crop production, it is important to assess if mycorrhization takes place in microgravity or in altered gravity environments of long-term space stations, other planets or moons.
We hypothesized that microgravity, among the other extraterrestrial factors, might affect mycorrhization efficiency because SL biosynthesis and transport are positively regulated by the auxin signaling pathway.19,20 Auxin is a tryptophan-derived phytohormone that shapes several aspects of plant development. Its allocation in plant tissues is regulated by gravity, thus making auxin the main player in gravity sensing in plants, as reported in several scientific space missions.21 Currently, we know that microgravity influences auxin distribution and auxin transport in several plant species.22 We aim to test mycorrhization in wild-type plants and mutants for SL transport or synthesis under simulated microgravity conditions, and thus investigate not only the physical influence of microgravity on this plant-fungal symbiosis, but also to assay the efficiency of SL as a tool to promote mycorrhization under microgravity conditions. These results will establish and enhance our knowledge of mycorrhization in space and show that mycorrhiza could be a feasible and smart tool to increase plant adaptability and yield also in extraterrestrial environments.
The workshop of the Institute of Plant and Microbial Biology of the University of Zurich developed eight multigen-1-like (M1L) growth chambers to simulate plant growth conditions present on the ISS. These M1L chambers pave the way for future experiments on microgravity here on Earth. They were designed for easy mounting on a random positioning machine (RPM) (Supplementary Fig. 1)—a device that provides a simulated microgravity 0-g (s0-g) environment to samples on ground.23 Because the results obtained by this device closely reflect the results from real microgravity exposure, the RPM has evolved to the method of choice for simulating microgravity (see more in Materials and methods, Microgravity simulating devices). Petunia germination and growth was carried on into a phytotron adapted to fit the RPM. In the same phytotron, not mounted on the RPM, 1-g mock samples were grown to compare with s0-g grown plantlets (Supplementary Video 1). Petunia seedlings were initially germinated in s0-g in Petri dishes containing plant agar medium to test the efficiency of the RPM in this closed environment (Fig. 1a). Root growth was compared to 1-g seedlings placed vertically in the growth chamber. The seedling radicles that emerged after germination in s0-g were agravitropic (Fig. 1b). After 14 days, the RPM conditions strongly affected Petunia root growth, which far from being straight as in 1-g (Supplementary Fig. 2A) followed multiple-directional gravity vectors (Supplementary Fig. 2B) and confirmed the efficiency of this system to simulate 0-g and to allow Petunia growth.
Petunia seeds were then germinated on agar medium at 1-g, selected for equal developmental stage by morphology, as Petunia germination cannot be synchronized by stratification, and 1 week later transferred into M1L chambers, either mounted on the RPM or in 1-g. Root and shoot phenotypes, biomass, phosphate, gene expression levels, and mycorrhization rates were quantified and compared for s0-g and 1-g. Microgravity effects were tested in wild-type Petunia accessions W115 and W115xW138. This was necessary because Petunia mutants like pdr1 ko are obtained via the transposon-bearing ecotype W138.24 So far, this ecotype could not be transformed by the Petunia community (personal communication) and transgenes like PDR1 OE can be inserted only in accessions prone to transgenic insertion like W115. PDR1 OE plants, over-expressing PDR1 and reported to score higher mycorrhization than the wild-type25 and pdr1 ko mutants,9 were included in the experimental setup in order to investigate the role of SL exudation in s0-g conditions. First, we assessed growth adaptation of Petunia to M1L chambers since M1 chambers have only been used for ISS experiments on Arabidopsis thaliana,26 a well-known model plant that is not a host to mycorrhizal fungi. Continuous light conditions were chosen to accelerate plant growth and to allow the scoring of mycorrhization occurring 30 days after incubation (30 d.a.i.) with the fungus, compared to 60 d.a.i. under long-day conditions. The 30-day difference allowed us to increase the number of experiments and plants, the latter limited by the capacity of the RPM (8 M1L chambers per replica) and M1L chambers (3 Petunia plants per chamber). During the 30 days, M1L chambers were supplied with water alternated with a mycorrhizal inoculum buffer (Materials and methods). This is a good strategy to control the Pi amount in the soil and still supplying the required micro and macro nutrients to plants growing on clay-based substrates.25 Stem and root development of Petunia adapted to the small pot volumes (Fig. 1c) and dwarf phenotype did not affect the typical mosaic expression pattern of PDR1 in either the main or lateral roots,9 as visualized via the pPDR1:GUS reporter (Fig. 1d, e). Plant growth in M1L chambers or in mock pots (i.e., pots with the same soil and nutrient volume of M1L chambers but not built to be mounted on the RPM) showed no differences at 1-g (Fig. 1f), thus allowing us to maximize plant growth in s0-g. A clay/soil mix solution, which is higher in nutrients than clay alone, (Liu et. al.25) was initially used for plant growth tests (Fig. 1f). It was replaced with clay, as in s0-g conditions, the soil mix liquefied after the first watering. Because it leaked out of the M1L chambers, it was not possible to quantify the amount of fungal spores present in the pot after each watering.
Mycorrhization levels of W115 (WT), PDR1 OE, W115xW138 (WT), and pdr1 ko plants were quantified (Materials and methods) for 1-g and s0-g grown on clay + AMF inoculum. Equal inoculum amounts of the mycorrhizal fungus Rhizophagus irregularis were mixed with clay and aliquoted in M1L chambers, where Petunia seedlings were then transferred from plates. At 1-g, PDR1 OE roots reached mycorrhization levels up to 69% of the root segments analyzed, confirming the previously reported high mycorrhization capacity25 despite these unusual growth conditions (Fig. 1g). In contrast, mycorrhization in W115 wild-type roots did not reach 40% (Fig. 1g). This trend occurred at s0-g, although both W115 and PDR1 OE plants were significantly less mycorrhized than at 1-g, (see Materials and methods for statistical methods and Supplementary Table 1) reaching a maximum of 28.8% and 56.5% of root colonization, respectively (Fig. 1g). The same experimental setup with pdr1 ko and its wild-type background (W115xW138) plants showed that microgravity significantly decreased mycorrhization levels in both lines (Fig. 1h), especially in mutants for SL exudation, as expected. Surprisingly, mycorrhizal features, i.e., the relative amounts of arbuscule (the plant-fungal interface for the symbiotic nutrient exchange), vesicles, and hyphae changed between 1-g and s0-g conditions. At 1-g, 80% of the mycorrhiza consisted of arbuscules independent of the genotype (Fig. 1i, j and Supplementary Fig. 2C, D, G, I). At s0-g, PDR1 OE plants still harbored 75% of arbuscules, while in W115 arbuscules dropped below 60% and vesicles increased from 20 to 40% (Fig. 1k, l and Supplementary Fig. 2E, F, H, J).
The low-mycorrhization levels we observed in s0-g conditions were independent of the plant genotype and might be caused by decreased SL biosynthesis and/or exudation. Gene expression of the SL biosynthetic enzyme DAD1 and of the SL transporter PDR1 were determined by quantitative PCR. DAD1 expression was induced by s0-g up to two folds compared to 1-g samples (Fig. 2a). PDR1 levels were slightly induced by s0-g (Fig. 2b), however not significantly. Interestingly, in s0-g conditions, DAD1 expression levels of pdr1 ko plants were higher compared to 1-g (Fig. 2a), suggesting that DAD1 induction is caused by effects that are additive to the mutation in pdr1, which was previously reported to increase DAD1 expression per se.14 DAD1 and PDR1 are both induced by auxin and microgravity is known to alter auxin distribution in plant roots.22 We propose that this effect might be present in Petunia and is responsible for the higher expression levels of the SL-related genes we analyzed.
SL biosynthesis and root exudation can be also positively regulated by environmental stimuli, such as low nutrient conditions, especially phosphate and nitrogen scarcity. The so-induced SL synthesis and exudation to the rhizosphere boost mycorrhization and extend plant nutrient scavenging to larger soil volumes.27 Plants grown in s0-g might experience starvation compared to 1-g plants. Despite their higher expression of DAD1 and PDR1, they obtain lower mycorrhization rates than plants at 1-g. Also, wilting/dead leaves in each experimental setup were most abundant in s0-g low-mycorrhization conditions (Fig. 2e, i, j). Phosphate (Pi) quantification per plant confirmed that W115 and PDR1 OE plants grown in s0-g sequestrated less phosphate from soil than plants grown at 1-g (Fig. 2o). Further, low mycorrhization is supported by the low Pi uptake. A possible explanation for the discrepancy between high SL signaling and low mycorrhization could be that the s0-g environment decreases the efficiency of the mycorrhiza, independent of the amount of SL exuded into the rhizosphere. Mycorrhizal hyphae can sense gravity and elongate in an anti-gravitropic way through a gravity sensing mechanism previously described.28 We then germinated Rhizophagus irregularis spores on a 2D clinostat placed into a fungal spore incubator (Materials and methods), to assay if gravity can affect hyphal elongation and therefore mycorrhization efficiency. Four days after germination, hyphal growth in clinostat-grown spores and 1-g mock were compared, where the latter were grown vertically in the incubator. At 1-g, fungal spores elongated single- or double-main hyphae that additionally generated secondary hyphae (Fig. 3a, c). On the clinostat, hyphal elongation was reduced and multi-directional with a lower amount of secondary hyphae detected (Fig. 3b, d): 10 ± 0.42 secondary hyphae per spore at 1-g and 5.75 ± 1.18 at s0-g, respectively. The plate surface area, covered by the AMF body grown at 1-g, was in average 1.7 ± 0.3 folds larger than in clinostat conditions. We applied rac-GR24, a SL mimic molecule, in 1-g and s0-g to assay if the previously reported SL-induced hyphal branching4 was affected by changes in gravitational force. Four days after germination (Fig. 3e, f), the fungal spores were temporarily removed from the clinostat or from the fungal incubator to apply rac-GR24 (Materials and methods). At 1-g, rac-GR24 induced an average of 10.3 ± 2.5 new hyphal branches 2 days after treatment (d.a.t.) (Fig. 3g, i) and only 2 ± 0.7 at s0-g (Fig. 3h, j). Four d.a.t., fungi at 1-g developed tertiary and higher orders of branching (Fig. 3i), but not at s0-g (Fig. 3j). These results show that main hyphal elongation and secondary hyphal branching of R. irregularis are negatively regulated by simulated microgravity and that microgravity could therefore affect the development of the mycorrhiza by reducing the possibility of physical interaction between fungal hyphae and plant roots.
Plant size is clearly induced by s0-g conditions, compare, e.g., Fig. 2c, e; Fig. 2d, f; Fig. 2k, l; Fig. 2m, n. Microgravity has been previously reported to induce cell expansion in Arabidopsis hypocotyls through a mechanism that changes cell-wall plasticity29, and cell division.30 We hypothesized that similar mechanisms might be responsible for the thicker stems (Fig. 4a–e) and the larger leaves (Fig. 4g–i) we observed in s0-g. Cell size in transversal stem sections indicated that pith parenchyma cells were two folds larger in s0-g compared to 1-g (Fig. 4f). Instead, leaf epidermal cells showed the same size and density in 1-g and s0-g conditions (Fig. 4j–o), despite that leaf surface areas were clearly induced by s0-g. These results suggest that cell division also plays an important role in s0-g, at least for leaf biomass. Similarly below ground, root surfaces increased when grown in microgravity (Supplementary Fig. 2K–M). Large root volumes allow plants to scavenge nutrients more efficiently and might release plants from the option of mycorrhizal support, which is costly in terms of photosynthetic sugars.31 Still, despite their increased root volumes, s0-g plants are Pi starved, showing that in these growth conditions, mycorrhization is more efficient than an enlarged root system for scavenging Pi. Along with the increase in plant volumes was higher biomass accumulation in s0-g (Supplementary Fig. 2N). Interestingly, the largest increases in biomass production in s0-g were in PDR1 OE, V26, and dad1 plants, which reached up to 60% higher biomass compared to the corresponding 1-g mock plants. V26 and dad1 plants (Fig. 2k–n) were grown on the above mentioned liquefied soil + clay mix. The higher nutrient conditions compared to clay + AMF inoculum25 might have allowed these plants to more efficiently use the expanded root system induced by s0-g. PDR1 OE plants had larger than wild-type roots (Supplementary Fig. 2M) and higher mycorrhization rates as shown above, thus giving them an advantage in nutrient uptake compared to wild-type. No significant changes were found between FW/DW ratios in W115 and PDR1 OE plants grown at 1-g and s0-g: 89.95% ± 0.16 of shoot water content and 93.67% ± 0.29 of root water content independent of genotypes/gravity conditions. Therefore, we propose that the tissue-specific cell division and cell expansion were responsible for the differences in biomass production and were induced by microgravity.
We have shown how simulated microgravity force negatively influences the formation of mycorrhiza. We assume that a previous study on plant-microbe interactions in low gravity17 showed no differences in the mycorrhization rates of Medicago truncatula grown either at 1-g or on a clinostat because growth conditions were set for nodulation, but were not suitable to investigate mycorrhization. Also, the quantification of mycorrhization in M. truncatula was recently proven to be difficult because of the high variability between mycorrhization rates in single plants.32 Mycorrhizal symbiosis is assumed to give a selective advantage by boosting plant nutrient uptake, especially in nutrient depleted conditions. Future space farmers could meet such conditions either for long-term space flights or for the colonization of new planets: that is precisely why mycorrhization efficiency was assayed in low nutrient and different gravity conditions. We have also shown that Petunia development is possible in our s0-g M1L chambers: in 30 days, plant could develop expanded leaves, elongated stems, and a root system. No lateral branches and no flowering transition were observed, possibly because of the limited nutrient and time duration. Still we could quantify a functional AMF colonization of Petunia roots, as fungal arbuscules were detected in root cortex cells. We showed that simulated microgravity conditions negatively affected the fungal hyphal development: hyphal elongation and branching were inhibited when fungal spores were germinated on a clinostat. The negative effects we observed on hyphal branching likely influenced the higher vesicle/arbuscule ratio in plants grown on our RPM, as arbuscule are structures made of repeated branching events, although several other plant factors are known to coordinate arbuscule formation.33 The high number of vesicles we quantified in mycorrhiza in s0-g, particularly in W115 WT background, suggests a low functional mycorrhization. This hypothesis is supported by the low Pi content for the same plants compared to 1-g mocks.
Tips of fungal hyphae contain a gravity sensor made of oil droplets and protein crystals that was previously shown to sense even short-lived changes in microgravity, such as the ones obtained on parabolic flights.34 We propose that clinostat and RPM conditions do not allow hyphal gravitropic growth and slow down or inhibit the formation of higher branching orders, thus reducing mycorrhization efficiency. Lateral branching in fungal hyphae occurs only when a potential branching site is sufficiently far from the hyphal tip to break apical dominance through unknown mechanisms.35 A possible explanation for the rare hyphal branching in microgravity and for the low sensitivity to exogenous rac-GR24 that we observed may result from the inhibition of hyphal extension: at s0-g, hyphal length is approximately half compared to 1-g conditions. Interestingly, a localized GR24 source (Fig. 3g, h) could still stimulate some directional growth and hyphal branching despite s0-g. These results support the hypothesis that PDR1 OE plants in s0-g could still induce high mycorrhization levels because of enhanced SL exudation.25 PDR1 OE plants could not only be a useful tool to improve plant biomass production on Earth, but also in space and on other planets. Additionally, in space, the presence of detrimental parasitic weeds, whose germination is also induced by SL36 could be easily controlled or excluded. Finally, simulated microgravity did not affect the strong PDR1 OE mycorrhization performance compared to the wild-type, showing that SL exudation can be still modulated by increasing PDR1 expression despite the s0-g environment.
There was no significant difference in mycorrhization rates between wild-type and pdr1 ko mutants grown either at s0-g or 1-g, despite that the mutant plants do not exude SLs and were previously reported to mycorrhize very little, similar to dad1 mutants.9 We suggest that the small pot volume of M1L chambers increased the chance of contact between fungal hyphae and plant roots even with low to no contribution from SL. Still, s0-g conditions can equally decrease mycorrhization efficiency in wild-type and pdr1 ko plants, showing that not only SL exudation into the rhizosphere, but also gravity sensing on the fungal side are important for the successful establishment of the mycorrhiza.
Despite the low mycorrhization and the decreased Pi uptake, plants grown in s0-g produced higher biomass than at 1-g. A biomass increase up to 40% was reported in roots and hypocotyls of Veronica arvensis grown on a clinostat.37 Lateral root growth and hypocotyl elongation were found to be induced in clinostat conditions. The initiation of lateral roots is regulated by auxins20 and a re-distribution of the auxin transporter PIN1 due to microgravity was recently reported in cucumber roots.22 As auxin transport and synthesis are strongly conserved among land plant species,20 we propose that the observed plant architecture changes in Petunia grown in s0-g were also caused by auxin re-allocation.
The increase in plant biomass reported here in s0-g might be a result of an increased cell-cycle activity and consequently the generation of larger tissues (like in leaf epidermal cells) or of a stronger cell expansion (like in pith cells) regulated by hormonal signaling. The results of our experiments show that s0-g can induce tissue-specific cell division and cell expansion, possibly by cell-wall weakening as previously reported38 and through yet unknown, auxin-mediated effects on the cell cycle in shoot and root meristems30 that span from different distribution of cell-cycle phases to epigenetic modifications.39
To summarize, simulated microgravity reduced mycorrhization rates and Pi uptake in Petunia, likely because of inhibited hyphal growth. Additionally, the induction of root growth observed in s0-g plants might have also contributed to a decrease of the costly mycorrhization. On the other hand, microgravity could induce biomass production when plants were grown in nutrient-rich soil conditions or in limited nutrient soil if plants could perform high SL root exudation, like PDR1 OE plants. The accumulation of plant biomass in nutrient scarce soils driven by microgravity plus enhanced SL exudation will have to be assessed in staple food plants either on an Earth-bound RPM or on the International Space Station. Instead of transgenic PDR1 OE crops, natural accessions high in SL root exudation should be isolated and included in these investigations. Instead of clay, mimics for extraterrestrial soils should be generated not only to investigate their effect on plant nutrition, but also to test the adaptability of terrestrial AMF to novel alien conditions. Recent developments of mycorrhization research, focused on desert farming, showed how soil shapes mycorrhizal populations and the low adaptability of AMF strains to different niches.40 Still, the results presented here let us envisage a positive future for space-crop production, thanks to plant adaptability to microgravity regulated by phytohormonal signaling and plant-fungal symbiosis.
Materials and methods
Petunia hybrida plants var. Mitchell (W115) PDR1 OE,14,25 pdr1 ko, dad1, pPDR1:GFP-PDR1, pPDR1:GUS9 and relative wild-type backgrounds were germinated on plates at 1-g and 5 days later selected for transferring in M1L chambers or mock pots. Growth was carried on at 24 h light conditions, 60% humidity, 25 °C for 30 days on clay (Oil dri, Chicago, USA) + R. irregularis inoculum kindly supplied by Professor Dr. Marcel van der Heijden (Agroscope, Zurich, Switzerland). M1L chambers and mock pots were supplied twice a week with ½ Murashige and Skoog Basal Salt Macronutrient (MS) solution with low phosphate as in Liu et al.25
Microgravity simulating devices
Random positioning machine
Samples on the RPM turn constantly around two axes (60°/s). The motion pattern is programmed so that the gravity pull, which is working on the samples, is distributed spatially and temporally equally. The result is that the gravity vector mathematically averages to zero over time. In addition, the constant re-orientation of the gravity vector makes it impossible for biological systems to adjust to gravitational force, thus the resulting response is compatible to the response achieved by actual microgravity exposure. The results obtained on the RPM are generally in a good to fair agreement to actual space flown experiments of various cell types.41 Actually, the RPM has been established as method of choice for plant experiments under simulated microgravity conditions several years ago.42 In this study, the plastid position in columella cells of Arabidopsis seedlings had equal grown rates at low Earth orbit on board the Space Shuttle and on the RPM. This result, supported by the extensive work of Hoson et al.43,44 encourages the use of the RPM for plant experiments under simulated microgravity conditions. Today, plant scientists interested in gravitational aspects of plant physiology are still applying RPM conditions to simulate microgravity.45 The RPM, however, is just one method among others to create a microgravity-like environment and none of these replace microgravity achieved during space flights. It is also obvious that the RPM needs to be operated carefully, otherwise artifacts are introduced, which could lead to false-positive/-negative results. We have thus investigated the appropriate RPM settings in order to claim a microgravity-like environment46 and have formulated these specific recommendations.41 All our microgravity studies using the RPM follow these guidelines to ensure high-quality data.
This instrument applies a similar principle as the RPM for generating a microgravity-like environment. The moving pattern however focuses on one axis only. The effects of gravity on the fungal spores are negated on clinostats by placing the samples in the center of the rotating horizontal axis for an extended period of time.
GUS staining, PI staining, and DAPI staining
Beta-D-glucuronosideglucuronosohydrolase (GUS) staining of HPCs, propidium iodide (PI) staining of epidermal leaf cells and nucleic acid DAPI staining were performed as reported in Kretzschmar et al.9 and Sasse et al.14 with no changes. Briefly, fresh roots were incubated overnight in a GUS solution buffer and visualized with a light microscope without destaining. Fresh leaves were mounted for analysis on a Leica SP5 confocal laser scanning microscope and a drop of PI (1 μg/ml) positioned in the middle of the leaf blade. After 5 min, the signal was detected (excitation 488 nm/emission 617 nm). Same procedure was used for DAPI staining, but with different laser wavelengths (excitation 340 nm/emission 488 nm).
Mycorrhization staining and scoring
Mycorrhization and mycorrhizal structures were ink stained and quantified as described in Akiyama et al.4 at a stereoscopic microscope. Briefly, roots were collected, fixed in potassium hydroxide 5% w/v, boiled for 10 min in water, and destained in acetic acid 5% v/v. We quantified the mycorrhizal structures with 500 root-grid intersections per sample per replicate. Mycorrhizal features (arbuscules, vesicles, and hyphae) were visually recognized with a stereoscopic microscope.
Gene expression analysis
Fluorescent and light microscopy
Confocal laser scanning microscopy and light microscopy as in Sasse et al.14 but with minor changes in tissue preparation for stem analyses. Approximately 1 cm long fresh stem segments were included in 4% agarose w/v. Hundred-micrometer-thick stem slices were immediately prepared with the aid of a vibratome for further analysis at the fluorescent and light microscope. A wavelength of 488 nm for excitation and an emission window peaking at 514 nm were set for fluorescence detection.
Phosphate extraction and quantification were performed as described in Liu et al.25 Nine plants were pooled per line per replica.
Digital image quantification
Tissues for surface measurements were digitally acquired via scan or camera and areas were digitally quantified using ImageJ.
Arbuscular mycorrhizal fungi growth on clinostat
R. irregularis spores were mildly surface sterilized (0.1% bleach v/v and 0.01% Triton-X v/v) for 3 min and rinsed with sterilized water 5 times. One or two spores were placed on Phytagel (Sigma-Aldrich, Buchs, Switzerland) plates (3.5 g/l), which were first sealed with Micropore paper tape (3 M, Rüschlikon, Switzerland) and then taped on a clinostat positioned at 32 °C, 4% CO2 v/v constantly rotating at 40 ° per s. 1-g plates were vertically positioned on the floor of the incubator. Four days later, the germinated mycorrhizal fungi were observed at the microscope. Sterile filter paper pads soaked with 100 pg rac-GR24 (Chiralix, Nijmegen, Netherlands) were added as shown in Akiyama et al.4
Student’s t-test was applied to evaluate the significance of the presented results. n values and p values presented in Supplementary Table 1. Locations of M1L chambers and mock pots were randomized on the RPM and in the growth chamber, respectively.
The data that support the findings of this study are available from the corresponding author upon reasonable request.
Newman, E. I. & Reddell, P. The distribution of mycorrhizas among families of vasculature plants. New Phytol. 106, 745–751 (1987).
Rich, M. K., Nouri, E., Courty, P. E. & Reinhardt, D. Diet of arbuscular mycorrhizal fungi: bread and butter? Trends Plant Sci. 22, 652–660 (2017).
Gianinazzi, S. et al. Agroecology: the key role of arbuscular mycorrhizas in ecosystem services. Mycorrhiza 20, 519–530 (2010).
Akiyama, K., Matsuzaki, K. & Hayashi, H. Plant sesquiterpenes induce hyphal branching in arbuscular mycorrhizal fungi. Nature 435, 824–827 (2005).
Al-Babili, S. & Bouwmeester, H. J. Strigolactones, a novel carotenoid-derived plant hormone. Annu. Rev. Plant Biol. 66, 161–186 (2015).
Lopez-Obando, M., Ligerot, Y., Bonhomme, S., Boyer, F. D. & Rameau, C. Strigolactone biosynthesis and signaling in plant development. Development 142, 3615–3619 (2015).
Napoli, C. Highly branched phenotype of the petunia dad1-1 mutant is reversed by grafting. Plant Physiol. 111, 27–37 (1996).
Xie, X. et al. Confirming stereochemical structures of strigolactones produced by rice and tobacco. Mol. Plant 6, 153–163 (2013).
Kretzschmar, T. et al. A petunia ABC protein controls strigolactone-dependent symbiotic signalling and branching. Nature 483, 341–344 (2012).
Seto, Y. et al. Carlactone is an endogenous biosynthetic precursor for strigolactones. Proc. Natl Acad. Sci. USA 111, 1640–1645 (2014).
Song, X. et al. IPA1 functions as a downstream transcription factor repressed by D53 in strigolactone signaling in rice. Cell Res. 27, 1128–1141 (2017).
Xie, X. et al. Cloning and characterization of a novel Nicotiana tabacum ABC transporter involved in shoot branching. Physiol. Plant 153, 299–306 (2015).
Borghi, L., Liu, G. W., Emonet, A., Kretzschmar, T. & Martinoia, E. The importance of strigolactone transport regulation for symbiotic signaling and shoot branching. Planta 243, 1351–1360 (2016).
Sasse, J. et al. Asymmetric localizations of the ABC transporter PaPDR1 trace paths of directional strigolactone transport. Curr. Biol. 25, 647–655 (2015).
Sharda, J. N. & Koide, R. T. Can hypodermal passage cell diSstribution limit root penetration by mycorrhizal fungi? New Phytol. 180, 696–701 (2008).
Shishkoff, N. Distribution of the dimorphic hypodermis of roots in angiosperm families. Ann. Bot. 60, 1–15 (1987).
Dauzart, A. J. C., Vandenbrink, J. P. & Kiss, J. Z. The effects of clinorotation on the host plant, Medicago truncatula, and its microbial symbionts. Front. Astronom. Space Sci. 3 (2016) https://www.frontiersin.org/articles/10.3389/fspas.2016.00003/full.
Wamelink, G. W., Frissel, J. Y., Krijnen, W. H., Verwoert, M. R. & Goedhart, P. W. Can plants grow on Mars and the moon: a growth experiment on Mars and moon soil simulants. PLoS ONE 9, e103138 (2014).
Borghi, L., Liu, G. W., Emonet, A., Kretzschmar, T. & Martinoia, E. The importance of strigolactone transport regulation for symbiotic signaling and shoot branching. Planta 243, 1351–1360 (2016).
Vanneste, S. & Friml, J. Auxin: a trigger for change in plant development. Cell 136, 1005–1016 (2009).
Kittang, A. I. et al. Exploration of plant growth and development using the European Modular Cultivation System facility on the International Space Station. Plant Biol. 16, 528–538 (2014).
Yamazaki, C. et al. The gravity-induced re-localization of auxin efflux carrier CsPIN1 in cucumber seedlings: spaceflight experiments for immunohistochemical microscopy. NPJ Microgravity 2, 16030 (2016).
Wuest, S. L. et al. A novel microgravity simulator applicable for three-dimensional cell culturing. Microgravity Sci. Technol. 26, 77–88 (2014).
Koes, R. et al. Targeted gene inactivation in petunia by PCR-based selection of transposon insertion mutants. Proc. Natl Acad. Sci. USA 92, 8149–8153 (1995).
Liu, G. et al. Changes in the allocation of endogenous strigolactone improve plant biomass production on phosphate-poor soils. New Phytol. 217, 784–798 (2018).
Link, B. M., Busse, J. S. & Stankovic, B. Seed-to-seed-to-seed growth and development of Arabidopsis in microgravity. Astrobiology 14, 866–875 (2014).
Bouwmeester, H. J., Roux, C., Lopez-Raez, J. A. & Becard, G. Rhizosphere communication of plants, parasitic plants and AM fungi. Trends Plant Sci. 12, 224–230 (2007).
Grolig, F., Doring, M. & Galland, P. Gravisusception by buoyancy: a mechanism ubiquitous among fungi? Protoplasma 229, 117–123 (2006).
Soga, K., Wakabayashi, K., Kamisaka, S. & Hoson, T. Stimulation of elongation growth and xyloglucan breakdown in Arabidopsis hypocotyls under microgravity conditions in space. Planta 215, 1040–1046 (2002).
Medina, F. J. & Herranz, R. Microgravity environment uncouples cell growth and cell proliferation in root meristematic cells: the mediator role of auxin. Plant Signal. Behav. 5, 176–179 (2010).
Walder, F. et al. Mycorrhizal networks: common goods of plants shared under unequal terms of trade. Plant Physiol. 159, 789–797 (2012).
Dreher, D., Yadav, H., Zander, S. & Hause, B. Is there genetic variation in mycorrhization of Medicago truncatula? PeerJ 5, e3713 (2017).
Luginbuehl, L. H. & Oldroyd, G. E. D. Understanding the arbuscule at the heart of endomycorrhizal symbioses in plants. Curr. Biol. 27, R952–R963 (2017).
Galland, P. The sporangiophore of Phycomyces blakesleeanus: a tool to investigate fungal gravireception and graviresponses. Plant Biol. 16(Suppl 1), 58–68 (2014).
Harris, S. D. Branching of fungal hyphae: regulation, mechanisms and comparison with other branching systems. Mycologia 100, 823–832 (2008).
Cardoso, C., Ruyter-Spira, C. & Bouwmeester, H. J. Strigolactones and root infestation by plant-parasitic Striga, Orobanche and Phelipanche spp. Plant Sci. 180, 414–420 (2011).
Driss-Ecole, D., Cottignies, A., Jeune, B., Corbineau, F. & Perbal, G. Increased mass production of Veronica arvensis grown on a slowly rotating clinostat. Environ. Exp. Bot. 34, 303–310 (1994).
Dunser, K. & Kleine-Vehn, J. Differential growth regulation in plants—the acid growth balloon theory. Curr. Opin. Plant Biol. 28, 55–59 (2015).
Kamal, K. Y., Herranz, R., van Loon, J. J. W. A. & Medina, F. J. Simulated microgravity, Mars gravity, and 2g hypergravity affect cell cycle regulation, ribosome biogenesis, and epigenetics in Arabidopsis cell cultures. Sci. Rep. 8, 6424 (2018).
Al-Yahya’ei, M. N. et al. Unique arbuscular mycorrhizal fungal communities uncovered in date palm plantations and surrounding desert habitats of Southern Arabia. Mycorrhiza 21, 195–209 (2011).
Wuest, S. L. et al. Simulated microgravity: critical review on the use of random positioning machines for mammalian cell culture. Biomed. Res. Int. 2015, 8 (2015).
Kraft, T. F., van Loon, J. J. & Kiss, J. Z. Plastid position in Arabidopsis columella cells is similar in microgravity and on a random-positioning machine. Planta 211, 415–422 (2000).
Hoson, T., Kamisaka, S., Masuda, Y., Yamashita, M. & Buchen, B. Evaluation of the three-dimensional clinostat as a simulator of weightlessness. Planta 203(Suppl), S187–S197 (1997).
Hoson, T. et al. Morphogenesis of rice and Arabidopsis seedlings in space. J. Plant Res. 112, 477–486 (1999).
Jost, A. I., Hoson, T. & Iversen, T. H. The utilization of plant facilities on the international space station-the composition, growth, and development of plant cell walls under microgravity conditions. Plants 4, 44–62 (2015).
Wuest, S. L., Stern, P., Casartelli, E. & Egli, M. Fluid dynamics appearing during simulated microgravity using random positioning machines. PLoS ONE 12 (2017) http://journals.plos.org/plosone/article?id=10.1371/journal.pone.0170826.
We would like to thank Professor Dr. Enrico Martinoia and Dr. Rita de Brito Francisco (UZH) for the great help in commenting on and reviewing the manuscript and Dr. Tim Granara (HSLU) for editing. We also thank the students of the block courses (Ramona Güdel, Sandro Hofstetter, Lukas Kunz, and Moritz Rövekamp) who shared the passion for our studies in simulated microgravity. We thank for funding: Swiss National Foundation grant numbers 31003A-152831 and 31003A-169546.
The authors declare no competing interests.
Publisher's note: Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.
About this article
Cite this article
Liu, G., Bollier, D., Gübeli, C. et al. Simulated microgravity and the antagonistic influence of strigolactone on plant nutrient uptake in low nutrient conditions. npj Microgravity 4, 20 (2018). https://doi.org/10.1038/s41526-018-0054-z
This article is cited by
Efficiency and bioavailability of new synthetic strigolactone mimics with potential for sustainable agronomical applications
Plant and Soil (2021)
Effect of different light intensity on physiology, antioxidant capacity and photosynthetic characteristics on wheat seedlings under high CO2 concentration in a closed artificial ecosystem
Photosynthesis Research (2020)