Thank you for visiting nature.com. You are using a browser version with limited support for CSS. To obtain the best experience, we recommend you use a more up to date browser (or turn off compatibility mode in Internet Explorer). In the meantime, to ensure continued support, we are displaying the site without styles and JavaScript.

# Droplets in underlying chemical communication recreate cell interaction behaviors

## Abstract

The sensory-motor interaction is a hallmark of living systems. However, developing inanimate systems with “recognize and attack” abilities remains challenging. On the other hand, controlling the inter-droplet dynamics on surfaces is key in microengineering and biomedical applications. We show here that a pair of droplets can become intelligently interactive (chemospecific stimulus-response inter-droplet autonomous operation) when placed on a nanoporous thin film surface. We find an attacker-victim-like non-reciprocal interaction between spatially separated droplets leading to an only-in-one shape instability that triggers a drop projection to selectively couple, resembling cellular phenomenologies such as pseudopod emission and phagocytic-like functions. The nanopore-driven underlying communication and associated chemical activity are the main physical ingredients behind the observed behavior. Our results reveal that basic features found in many living cell types can emerge from a simple two-droplet framework. This work is a promising step towards the design of microfluidic smart robotics and for origin-of-life protocell models.

## Introduction

Complex behaviors that involve intelligence to probe, recognize and interact are essential attributes in many fundamental processes in life, without which the reproduction and immune system actions cannot be explained. Examples are the phenomena of free-swimming sperm to a stationary egg1 and the directed projection of pseudopods in a neutrophil phagocytic event2. Specific stimulus-response interplay and the ability to transform chemical energy into local mechanical work (active matter systems)3,4 are also key properties of biointeractions5. Another common feature of the two-body interactions in nature is also the role differentiation such as the case of attacker and victim6,7,8. However, achieving the generation of similar sensory-motor skills that lead to such non-reciprocal interaction scenarios remains a challenge of paramount importance in man-made systems. In a separate but related thread, droplets (restricted fluid volumes) are ubiquitous in nature and technology. The design of droplet frameworks as simple machines to achieve complex tasks is an exciting wide open field9,10,11. In that context, out-of-equilibrium droplet scenarios hold great promise as systems to perform hydrodynamic transduction of chemical signals11,12. The interaction between droplets is gaining increasing attention as models to approach dynamic behaviors of living cells13,14,15. Active droplet interplay can even serve as minimalistic models by which to gain perspective on the circumstances required for life to begin16,17,18. The ability to control the attraction and coupling of droplets on surfaces is also important for a variety of applications, ranging from thermal management technologies to microfluidic liquid handling19,20,21,22. Droplet microfluidics on planar substrates in fact has experienced a meteoric development23,24. Existing strategies for the management of droplets on surfaces beyond those triggered by external stimuli (electric, magnetic, luminic)21,22,25,26,27,28 are based either in prepared surfaces having a physico-chemical anisotropy19,29,30,31,32,33,34 or vapour emanated by nearby droplets of carefully balanced binary composition20. Active droplets that interact and act by themselves via messages through a surface are eagerly awaited. The finding of a support surface able to mediate reconfigurable inter-droplet communication to autonomously execute complex dynamic tasks would indeed be a meaningful step in the evolution of practical tools for many top emerging interdisciplinary fields. Thin nanoporous layers offer unique opportunities for many practical applications owing to their fascinating properties and high tunability35,36. Features of imbibition at the nanoporous thin film level, such as balance between capillary infiltration and liquid evaporation37,38,39, lead to peculiar transport phenomena of fluids across the nanopore network, thereby generating a steady-state annulus of infiltrated porous material around droplets lying on a nanoporous thin film surface. We consequently reasoned that such droplets may act as emitters of surface chemical messages (i.e., endowed with a peripheral signaling annulus) and thus be remotely noticed by a counter-droplet. In turn, a neighboring chemically complementary droplet could evolve transductional chemo-mechanical complex behaviors (becoming locally active) in response to the nanopore-driven annular cues from the emitting droplet. This concept of an underlying nanoporous layer to mediate an intelligent droplet interplay (chemospecific inter-droplet role-differenced autonomous operation - sketched in Fig. 1) indeed successfully works as described in the present paper.

Here we show chemo-active attacker-victim-like non-reciprocal interactions between spatially separated droplets enabled by a self-generated stimulus-response behavior when both are placed on a nanoporous thin film surface. We find that an active droplet can sense and subsequently respond with a macroscopic morphological shift and thereby coupling with a specific neighboring droplet, making use of the fluid released from the counter-droplet across the nanoporous surface as both signaling and power source. The specific droplets interplay exploits an attraction that stems from the feedback between nanopore-mediated communication and chemical activity (catalyzed decomposition of H2O2) as driving force for autonomous operation. The droplet platform that we propose and demonstrate in this study can indeed perform crucial chained actions intrinsic to living systems (sense-respond-attack), recreating even typical cell behaviors such as pseudopod projection and phagocytic actions.

## Results

### Emergence of droplet interplay on a nanoporous thin film surface

Droplets lying onto a nanoporous thin film surface present a typical hemispherical sessile drop shape, and also form an annulus of wetted pores around the droplets37, as shown in Fig. 2 and Supplementary Fig. 1 for a 1 wt% KI aqueous solution. The surface employed consists of a nanoporous titania thin film (180 nm thick – 45% pore volume) produced via a sol−gel method combined with template self-assembly on silicon substrates40, presenting pore and neck sizes of ≈ 12 and 4.5 nm, respectively (see Supplementary Fig. 2 for film characterization data).

The motion of liquids in nanopore matrices is propelled by capillarity in which the advancing flow usually follows the classic Lucas−Washburn law, which predicts a square-root of time imbibition kinetics41. Additionally nanoporous thin film imbibition is strongly influenced by evaporation, and hence, the kinematics is different to that generally found on conventional nanoporous structures37. In the case of a sessile droplet on a nanoporous thin film, since capillary filling from the drop and surface evaporation reach a balance, the capillary infiltration is arrested at a given distance and a steady annular region of the wetted material is formed in the drop periphery (see Fig. 2). The fluid-filled region that is generated into the nanopore network around the droplets can be clearly distinguished thanks to the changes in the thin film interference of reflected light, because it produces a refractive index contrast in relation to the outer empty pores region. The kinematics of the infiltration−evaporation process on these nanostructures, represented by the time-dependent width of the annular wetted region, is predicted by $${{{{{\rm{w}}}}}}\left(t\right)={\left({c}_{{{{{{\rm{I}}}}}}}\tau \right)}^{1/2}{\left[1-{{\exp }}(-2t/\tau )\right]}^{1/2}$$, which accounts for the balance between capillary infiltration from the droplet (characterized by the coefficient c1) and the rate of liquid evaporation to the ambient (characterized by the time τ)37. The prediction of this equation is plotted in Fig. 2. In order to better rationalize the arrested infiltration into nanoporous thin film structures, it is worth noticing that the steady-state width of the wetted ring around the drop (wss) thus obeys $${{{{{{\rm{w}}}}}}}_{{ss}}={\left({c}_{{{{{{\rm{I}}}}}}}\tau \right)}^{1/2}$$. The arrest of the infiltration is not usually found in the conventional porous structures, where evaporation has negligible effects and capillary filling expands indefinitely through the sample42.

When a droplet of 30 wt% hydrogen peroxide solution is placed near the KI drop, we evidence a behavior which can be figuratively envisaged as a droplet attacking after the perception of the presence of the victim drop. Both droplets contain separately the chemical species for the well-known peroxide decomposition, which is catalyzed by iodide43. As revealed by the snapshots presented in Fig. 3 and Supplementary Movie 1, the H2O2 droplet initially spreads with the typical circular shape until it reaches equilibrium. A distinctive behavior occurs when the drop “notices” the KI droplet in the vicinity and then extends a protrusion as a leading edge (qualitatively resembling the ‘pseudopods’ observed in cell morphologies44). The H2O2 droplet indeed takes action in response to the fluid released to the nanopores by neighboring KI droplet that self-generate a surrounding attractor region. The protrusion then grows from the H2O2 drop and its size increases gradually up to meet the sessile KI droplet, eventually bridging the droplets. It is noteworthy that in the absence of the H2O2 drop response, the coupling between the spatially separated droplets would not have occurred (note the perimeter extrapolation corresponding to the typical circular drop shape in Fig. 3a fifth panel). As expected, no interaction was observed when the KI and H2O2 droplets were placed onto the bare silicon substrate (in the absence of the nanoporous film coating) or onto a dense titania thin film (in the absence of template) in equivalent conditions to Fig. 3 (see Supplementary Fig. 3 and Supplementary Fig. 4 for silicon substrate only and dense titania film, respectively). These results evidence that the nanoporous layer is key to droplet interplay. Analogous experiments to Fig. 3 performed by replacing the H2O2 droplet for a pure water droplet showed no attraction between both droplets, where the peripheral annulus even behaved as a barrier for the water drop spreading (see Supplementary Movie 2). A similar “barrier” effect on the neighboring placed H2O2 droplet was also observed when the KI droplet was replaced with an equivalent 1 wt% KCl solution (see Supplementary Movie 3). These control experiments indeed illustrate a transition from an attractor to a shield behavior of the signaling annulus by changing the chemical droplet composition that clearly reveals the chemospecific stimulus-response remote interplay between the droplets on the nanoporous surface.

In order to present the spatial motion of the advancing protrusion in a more quantitative way, we tracked a material point at the protrusion front and plotted its position in Fig. 3b. The data clearly illustrates that the tracking point initially has a forward motion and then asymptotically reaches a constant value until the droplet coupling event. We also show in Fig. 3b the speed of protrusion advance as a function of time. Finally, in Fig. 3c, the temporal dependence of protrusion expanding area is plotted against the time to further illustrate the kinetics of growth. It can be seen that, as the protrusion grows in size, a decrease in the growth rate takes place. However, the protrusion tends to smoothly extend in the lateral directions as the leading edge slows down. Taken together, the dynamics of the inter-droplet connection can be divided into ‘protrusion nucleation-growth’ and ‘coupling standby’ stages. The nanoporous surface was capable of enabling an autonomous interaction between chemically complementary droplets.

### Origin of the droplet response

The fact that droplets tend to become unstable and deform is an unusual behavior, because contact line pinning opposes such shape changes. An instability of the droplet shape indeed requires non-equilibrium conditions16. On the other hand, a droplet can become chemically active if species into the droplet are produced and destroyed by chemical reactions. In such a scenario, we propose that these non-equilibrium conditions in our system are provided by the chemical energy input generated by catalytic peroxide decomposition. In other words, the origin of the droplet projection action can be traced back to a local chemical activity, a simplified view of which is sketched in Fig. 4. When and where the H2O2 droplet comes into contact with the nanopore-carried KI-releasing from the counter-droplet, the well-known catalytic conversion of hydrogen peroxide to water and molecular oxygen occurs: $${2H}_{2}{O}_{2}\left(l\right)\to {H}_{2}O\left(l\right)+{O}_{2}(g)$$. The reaction is spontaneous, exothermic and catalyzed by iodide43. The active species of the reactor droplet (H2O2) therefore degrades locally and abruptly into lower energy components that are soluble in the background fluid, because of the ions incorporated from the nearby catalyst droplet (KI) through the underlying nanopore network. The local chemical activity then supplies the energy to focusedly trigger a shape instability that leads to the generation and subsequent growth of the protrusion, converting chemical to mechanical energy.

To roughly quantify the energy exchanged, we compared the chemical energy released by KI-catalyzed H2O2 decomposition with the energy expenditure required for protrusion occurrence estimated from the work of adhesion of the interface. At equilibrium, the force balance of interfacial tensions at the three-phases contact line is described by the Young equation, $${\gamma }_{{sg}}={\gamma }_{{ls}}+{\gamma }_{{lg}}{\cos }{\theta }_{c}$$, where the subscripts stand for solid-gas, liquid-solid, and liquid-gas, respectively, and θc is the contact angle45. In this theoretical context, one may further include the Dupre equation, which defines the work of adhesion (per unit area) of the interface formed between the solid substrate and the liquid drop: $$W={\gamma }_{{sg}}+{\gamma }_{{lg}}-{\gamma }_{{ls}}$$46. By combining these equations, one obtains the adhesion energy in terms of the variables that can be readily measured; that is, $$W={\gamma }_{{lg}}(1+{\cos }{\theta }_{c})$$. Regarding the new interfacial area progressively generated due to protrusion growth, Ap (which is quantified in Fig. 3c), a simple calculation indicates that the energy change associated with this wetting event is $$\varDelta {E}_{w}=W{A}_{p}$$. On the other hand, the energy released by chemical activity can be estimated considering the protrusion as an expanding microreactor containing the fuel (H2O2), where the decomposition reaction can gradually progress in the course of protrusion growth. We can therefore estimate the chemical energy capable of being released during protrusion evolution (Ech), as a first approximation, using the Gibbs free energy change of H2O2 decomposition (ΔG), H2O2 concentration (C), and a reaction volume proportional to Ap according to the V/Ad ratio, where Vd and Ad are the volume and contact area of the drop respectively; which results in $${E}_{{ch}}={\varDelta G{C\; A}}_{p}{V}_{d}/{A}_{d}$$. The comparative value of $${E}_{{ch}}/\varDelta {E}_{w}\approx {10}^{7}$$ that is characteristic throughout protrusion growth - for $${\gamma }_{{lg}}\approx$$ 0.074 N/m47, $${\theta }_{c}\approx$$ 35° (see picture in Fig. 4), ΔG = −116.8 kJ/mol (calculated from the individual standard Gibbs free energies of formation), 30 wt% H2O2 solution and $${V}_{d}/{A}_{d}\approx$$10−4 m (considering Vd = 2 μl and a Ad estimated by extrapolation from Fig. 3) - clearly indicates that in principle there is extremely more than enough chemical energy available to fuel the protrusion developing.

Since the catalyst (iodide) can perform many rounds of catalysis and the reaction rate is relatively high for the catalyzed decomposition of hydrogen peroxide, the limiting factor for power generation rate can be inferred a priori from species diffusion in the reaction zone. However, considering the short lengths involved (say Δz = 100 μm, as typical scale) and the large diffusivity of the chemical species (for example the diffusion coefficient of H2O2 is D ≈ 1.5 10−9 m2s−1)48, the characteristic diffusion times results $$\frac{{(\triangle z)}^{2}}{2D}\approx 3\,{{{{{\rm{s}}}}}}$$, which evidences that the reaction can gradually proceed during the protrusion evolution. It is known that molecular diffusion across nanopore networks can decrease up to an order of magnitude with respect to the bulk value due to confinement effects, owing to the relevance of interfacial molecule-surface interactions49,50. In this limiting case, the estimated timescale of the diffusion can potentially increase to 30 s. This scenario still supports reaction progress during protrusion development and incidentally the slow protrusion kinetics is in line with the fact that confinement-induced effects on molecular diffusion might be present. Also related to the large amount of energy that might be released by the reaction, which would substantially increase the liquid temperature, one should note that the relatively large thermal diffusivity of water (α ≈ 1.43 10−7 m2s−1)51 yields a small value of the characteristic time for thermal diffusion, $$\frac{{(\triangle z)}^{2}}{2\alpha }\approx 0.03\,{{{{{\rm{s}}}}}}$$. This result, which is typical of microscale problems, means that the generated heat can be quickly dissipated while the reaction proceeds gradually, so while local heating is contemplated, large temperature jumps are not expected. The simple energetic approach proposed here predicts feasible the protrusion deployment powered by the catalytic reaction arising from the nanopore-mediated communication between the droplets. This locally active droplet can indeed overcome the pinning energy barrier to escape from the original shape and develop the protrusion until it meets the sessile KI droplet. Protrusion next undergoes a standby stage until the inter-droplet interfacial tension is broken to achieve the bridging junction.

In the previous paragraphs we have assessed the elemental thermodynamic variables to prove that the free energy locally released by the chemical reaction provides enough energy to feed the wetting process involved in the protrusion formation. In what follows we employ physicochemical hydrodynamics to interpret the localized motion of the triple contact line. The main hypothesis is that the driving force that promotes the advance of the liquid front is the Marangoni effect52, which originates at the H2O2-drop contact line, where the liquid surface tension γ is reduced by the chemical reaction. The generated surface tension gradient ($$d\gamma /{dx}$$, being x the direction from the H2O2-drop towards the KI-drop) yields a tangential force per unit area on the air-liquid interface (the Marangoni stress; see the schematic representation in Fig. 4)53, which pulls the H2O2-droplet contact line outwards and originates the protrusion. The progress of the reaction preserves the surface tension difference and the protrusion keeps growing.

Droplet spreading by Marangoni effect has been well described in the literature54,55. Here we inspect how the chemical reaction generates the gradient $$d\gamma /{dx}$$ in our system. The variation of γ has two contributions: $$d\gamma =(\partial \gamma /\partial C){dC}+(\partial \gamma /\partial T){dT}$$, where the first term comes from the local change of substances concentration (C) and the second one comes from local temperature (T) variation. Concerning the latter, it is worth to recall that γ always decreases with increasing liquid temperature53. For example, for pure water, γw ≈ 73 mN m−1 at 20 °C and γw ≈ 71 mN m−1 at 30 °C. Therefore, as the reaction of H2O2 decomposition is exothermic, the generated heat in the reaction zone induces a surface tension difference with the surrounding fluids. Regarding the solutal contribution, we take into account the main components of the reactive system: (i) The presence of H2O2 slightly increases the surface tension of the solution in relation to pure water (73.7 mNm−1 for H2O2 28% at 18 °C)56, however the compound is consumed by the reaction. (ii) The presence of dissolved oxygen decreases the surface tension of water (68 mNm−1 for 45 ppm at 20 °C)57, and the effect is stronger under supersaturated conditions58. In contrast, the surface tension of KI solution is slightly larger than that of water (γK ≈ 74 mN m−1 for KI 1 M at 20 °C)59, and it may further increase in the annulus due to evaporation-induced concentration. Lastly, it is relevant to point out that both thermal and solutal contributions have the same direction: $$d\gamma /{dx} > 0$$ from the reaction zone towards the KI-droplet.

Summarizing, when the chemical reaction starts, γ locally decreases and generates a Marangoni stress towards the regions where γ is higher (KI droplet). The Marangoni stress drags fluid from the H2O2-drop and drives the contact line motion (see Fig. 4). Solving the full hydrodynamical problem requires calculating the time-dependent concentration and temperature fields in the reaction zone, coupled to fluid momentum equations, which demands numerical simulations. Alternatively, here we apply scaling analysis to extract basic relations that account for the fluid front motion. We propose that the Marangoni flow pulls the droplet contact line with a velocity on the order of ux, so that the position xf of the advancing front moves as $$d{x}_{f}/{dt}={u}_{x}$$. As a first approximation, we consider the primary edge of the advancing fluid front as a thin fluid layer of thickness h that is subjected to Marangoni stress in the x-direction and then the fluid velocity at the liquid surface results in $${u}_{x}=(d\gamma /{dx})h/\mu$$, where μ is the fluid viscosity53,60. One may further assume a nearly constant surface tension difference Δγ along the flow path, $$d\gamma /{dx}\approx \triangle \gamma /{x}_{f}$$55,60, and thus the motion equation is written $${x}_{f}d{x}_{f}/{dt}=\triangle \gamma /\mu$$. After integration with the initial condition $${x}_{f}=0$$, t = t0, the front position results in $${x}_{f}\left(t\right)={\left[{c}_{{{{{{\rm{M}}}}}}}(t-{t}_{0})\right]}^{1/2}$$, where $${c}_{{{{{{\rm{M}}}}}}}=2h\triangle \gamma /\mu$$ is here defined as the Marangoni flow coefficient. Also with this nomenclature, the fluid front velocity is $$d{x}_{f}/{dt}={c}_{{{{{{\rm{M}}}}}}}/{x}_{f}(t)={\left[{c}_{{{{{{\rm{M}}}}}}}/4(t-{t}_{0})\right]}^{1/2}$$.

The model prediction is checked against experimental data in Supplementary Fig. 5a (position) and Supplementary Fig. 5b (velocity). It is readily seen that the square-root-of-time kinematics closely follows the time variation of the protrusion front position, with cM = 5396 µm2 s−1 and t0 = 8.5 s. It is relevant to note that we have arbitrarily chosen $${x}_{f0}=0$$ at the start of the position tracking. Then the existence of a sort of initial induction (t0) is associated to the time required to reach the Marangoni flow regime (formation stage of the concentration and temperature gradients). This induction time is more clearly observed in Supplementary Fig. 5b, where the experimental velocity initially raises (from still to being in motion), as physically expected in the transitional stage, and then decreases as predicted by the model (note that the driving force $$\triangle \gamma /{x}_{f}$$ of the contact line displacement decreases with the advance of the front position). Therefore, the model applies in the time range $$10\le t\le 50{{{{{\rm{s}}}}}}$$ characteristic of the protrusion growth stage, approximately. The upper limit is indeed related to the time at which the protrusion meets the KI-droplet and the front position reaches a long-lasting pseudo stationary state, before drop coupling. Regarding the magnitude of the coefficient $${c}_{{{{{{\rm{M}}}}}}}=2h\triangle \gamma /\mu$$, if one considers, for instance, Δγ ≈ 3 mN m−1 and the viscosity of water at room temperature (1 mPas), one founds that h ≈ 1 nm (thickness of the edge in the advancing contact line front) is enough to explain the macroscopic effect. Since these parameter values are quite reasonable for the system61, one may conclude that both the functionality and the quantitative scale of the model satisfactorily agree with the observed wetting phenomena.

### Versatility of inter-droplet operation

We next illustrate that droplet interaction can be programmed by controlling simple system variables. The protrusion size is related to the overlapping between the attacking droplet edge and the annular signaling from the counter droplet (see together Fig. 5a, b). The protrusion base at the standby stage encompasses on the rim of the H2O2 droplet among the two points where it intersects the KI annulus. The distance between these two points of intersection determines the hereafter named protrusion width. The different overlaps reached by the H2O2 droplets with the annulus of the KI droplets thus produce different width of the protrusions (see Fig. 5a, b), which in fact is geometrically determined by the distance between the centers of the droplet circunferences62. One may even find a protruded shape that resembles a ‘phagocytic cup’ morphology63 when the overlapping is larger (see Fig. 5b). Likewise, the connection time between the droplets (i.e., the time from protrusion nucleation to droplet coupling) is linked to the protrusion width: increasing two-fold the width of the protrusion reduces droplet connection time from 125 to 40 s (see Fig. 5b).

Interestingly, Fig. 5c also shows that the inter-droplet connection strongly depends on the H2O2 concentration: droplets of 3 wt% H2O2 concentration have an about 3 times increase in the droplets connection time with respect to the 30 wt% H2O2 droplets. The 0.3 wt% H2O2 droplet also showed the protrusion generation step but without achieving the coupling outcome. The decreased affinity between droplets with decreasing H2O2 points in the same direction as before: the chemical activity that induces active stress seems to be the main driving force towards droplet interaction.

Our minimal platform also supports the formation of other dynamical regimes of attacker-victim-like non-reciprocal interaction typical in living cells. On widening protrusion, we observe progression to an H2O2 droplet that acts to engulf the other one (see Fig. 6a and Supplementary Movie 4). The H2O2 droplet in this case extends arms guided by the signaling annulus in the KI droplet periphery. The arms finally close at the distal region internalizing the KI droplet. Fig. 6b, c quantitatively show that the arms follow a circular pathway around the nearby KI droplet, which requires constant reorientation of the forward axis direction. This take-shape droplet dynamic is reminiscent of the phagocytic events which happen when a cell needs to engulf for the remotion of pathogens as a core function of the immune response or for nutrition in unicellular organisms64.

Moreover, the square-root-of-time kinematics predicted by the model proposed for protrusion advance holds all along the circular flow paths (see Supplementary Fig. 5c). Nevertheless, in this case the flow coefficient is cM = 1.9 106 µm2 s−1, which is 350 times larger than the one found in Supplementary Fig. 5a. This outcome means that, other factors being equal, the “effective” h is larger than 300 nm for this experiment. The value is better understood if one takes into account that the inner borders of the protruding arms are merged to the KI-droplet. Hence, the relatively large values of $$d{x}_{f}/{dt}$$ can be due to extra contributions of the Marangoni effect, now acting directly from the fluid arms ($$\gamma \; < \; {\gamma }_{{{{{{\rm{w}}}}}}}$$) to the sessile drop ($$\gamma \; > \; {\gamma }_{{{{{{\rm{w}}}}}}}$$), across the coalescing zone of the drop perimeter. Effectively, these Marangoni-driven flows have been used to explain the fluid transfer from one droplet to another65 and lately investigated to enhance mixing in paired droplets66,67.

The link between the chemical activity and active H2O2 droplet motion was also clear when changing the catalyst (KI) concentration. By decreasing the KI concentration to 0.5 wt%, only a short roam of the protrusion occurred on the outline of the KI drop before coupling (see Supplementary Movie 5) and in the case of a 0.1 wt% KI droplet the “barrier” effect (locally stopped H2O2 drop spreading) was observed (see Supplementary Movie 6). The diminished action between droplets with decreasing content of the catalyst again illustrates that droplet interplay can be tuned by controlling the chemical activity. Decreasing KI concentration also caused narrower annuli at the droplets periphery. This reduction of the wetted annulus is understood from the simple model for the steady-state width $${{{{{{\rm{w}}}}}}}_{{ss}}={\left({c}_{{{{{{\rm{I}}}}}}}\tau \right)}^{1/2}$$, considering the concentration dependence of model parameters cI and τ38. A decrease of the salt concentration strengthens the liquid evaporation rate (τ decreases) leading to narrower wetted rings. An additional cause behind the wetted ring narrowing is attributed to a decrease in the porous matrix permeability by decreasing the ionic strength, which leads to smaller values of the infiltration coefficient cI. The new infiltration-evaporation balance indeed drives to narrower annulus.

We also conducted some experiments to preliminarily explore the role of the nanopore surface modification on droplet interplay. We performed two different surface modifications through grafting of either octyltriethoxysilane (OTES) or (3-aminopropyl)triethoxysilane (APTES) (see Supplementary Fig. 6 for details). Nanopore surface modification was implemented by OTES in order to make them more hydrophobic68 (represented by a significant increase in the film contact angle from 37° to 77°). This leads to a practically negligible annulus around the KI droplet (as expected, nanopore hydrophobicity strongly decreases the cI coefficient and therefore the imbibition was markedly diminished). Experiments carried out on OTES-modified films at inter-droplets (KI-H2O2) distances typical of macroscopic actuation occurrence on the non-modified films showed no response in both droplets (see Supplementary Fig. 7). The lack of response is indeed attributable to the practical absence of the signaling annulus around the KI droplet. In the case of APTES modification (a frequently used amino functionalization)69, a dissimilar scenario was observed. A relatively wide annular wetted region was self-generated around the KI droplet on the APTES-modified films (only a slight change in the contact angle was observed from 37° to 46°). When a H2O2 droplet was placed near the KI drop, although a fluidic connection was attained (H2O2 drop fraction overlapping the KI annulus), solely a slow and slight elongation of the H2O2 droplet (no protrusion generation) was observed and without achieving the coupling between the droplets (see Supplementary Movie 7). This H2O2 droplet behavior is in stark contrast to the highly dynamic droplet responses arising from the non-functionalized films. Since the system can be seen as that H2O2-containing droplet chemically transducing ionic inputs driven by nanopores into mechanical actions, such change in behavior is therefore attributable to the amine-induced physicochemical transformation of the titania surface which hinders transport of ions to the H2O2 droplet across the nanopore matrix. Indeed, ion transport though nanoporous structures has been extensively studied and is well-known to be governed by the nanopore wall surface modification40,70. These simple surface modifications of the nanopores reveal that both fluidic and chemical communication between the droplets can be significantly affected by nanopore surface tuning and consequently alter the mechanical response of the droplets. The wide palette available of organic or metallo-organic functions permits one to anticipate that droplet emerging dynamics could be controlled at will by the custom design of nanopore surface modification. Finally, we as well show that the complex emerging dynamic between the droplets is not limited to one specific nanoporous morphology. We similarly placed KI and H2O2 droplets on a nanoporous titania thin film with smaller diameter (6 nm) pores (see Supplementary Fig. 8 and Supplementary Table 1 for film characterization data) and the H2O2-attacking behavior was observed (see Supplementary Movie 8). This straightforward experiment indeed shows that the actively interacting droplets can be also obtained in a different nanopore configuration. Taken together, the results revealed in this work illustrate a versatile, robust and flexible experimental platform of intelligently interactive droplets.

## Discussion

We have introduced a minimal framework where droplets can autonomously experience chemospecific recognition and subsequent non-reciprocal interaction, without the need of surfaces that have guiding tracks or external stimuli. Only three actors are necessary: a water droplet with H2O2, a KI aqueous droplet and a nanoporous thin film surface. The nanoporous layer is able to mediate droplet interaction through nanopore-driven simple chemical messengers, which lead to emerging complex droplet dynamics. We showed that the H2O2 droplet can sense and selectively attack the neighboring KI droplet due to specific chemical interactions that trigger a physical response; the chemical energy is transformed into mechanical work. Figuratively speaking, the chemical signal emitted from the KI droplet (underlying nanoflow), is perceived by the H2O2 droplet and also employed to direct their attack. These interacting units indeed extract useful work from its chemical activity for an autonomous operation. The platform further supports the generation of different dynamic couplings between the droplets. The mechanism behind the droplet behaviors can be traced back to a local chemical activity that induces Marangoni stresses, which give rise to a directed droplet shape transformation. Many cell functions, such as cytoplasmic streaming, morphogenesis and motion, are driven by active stresses arising from a localized activity within the cell71. In particular, the cell protrusions are owing to active stress-driven actin treadmilling (polymerization) that focalizedly curve the cell membrane forward72. It is interesting to note that the mechanical droplet responses bear resemblance (although coming from a rudimentary way of localized active stress - chemically induced local Marangoni stress -) to protrusion emission and even phagocytic actions in biological cells. Our results indeed reveal that complex droplet dynamic behaviors reminiscent of cell morphogenesis can arise despite the relatively simple active matter framework employed. It should be also noted here that our abiotic platform brings together hallmark features of living systems, such as: specific stimulus-response interactions, role differentiation and transformation of chemical energy into mechanical work. Such active droplets could represent interacting protocells with a primitive intelligence based on simple chemical reactions in the challenging search for experimental models that explain the early steps in origin of life. We envisage that many other catalytic reactions can in principle be used as chemical complementarity in the underlying communication, which would launch the creation of a diversity of intelligently interacting droplet families. We also anticipate that the droplet behavior could be handled by nanoporous system design (i.e., framework composition, network morphology hierarchy, and pore surface functionalization). Accordingly, the droplet abilities here reported that are analogous to living systems (sense-response-interaction) lays the groundwork for the design of new microfluidic smart robotics, which will be of practical relevance for applications in chemistry, biology, physics, and beyond.

## Methods

Crack-free nanoporous titania thin films were prepared by dip-coating with a supramolecularly templated oxide precursor, following well-reported protocols40. The technique is based on combining sol-gel chemistry with an evaporation-induced self-assembly strategy, using an ethanol solution with an inorganic precursor (TiCl4) together a polymeric template (Pluronics F127 = (EO)106(PO)70(EO)106, where EO and PO represent ethylene oxide and propylene oxide blocks, respectively). Particularly, the process was performed by dip-coating silicon substrates (University wafers) in a precursor solution with TiCl4:EtOH:H2O:F127 = 1:40:10:0.005 molar ratios at a withdrawal rate of 3 mm s−1 and a relative humidity (RH) of 30%. After deposition, as-prepared films were aged in a 50% RH chamber for 24 h. Next, the films were subjected to a consolidation thermal treatment that consisted in the following steps: 2 h at 60 °C, 2 h at 130 °C and finally calcined 2 h at 450 °C (to remove the templating agent) with a ramp temperature of 1 °C min−1. Non-porous titania films were made as described but in the absence of the templating agent. In the case of smaller pore samples, the F127-loaded films were directly calcined after deposition (in the absence of the consolidation thermal steps) by a fast-firing treatment, with a dwell temperature of 450 °C and a dwell time of 10 min. In order to surface modification the nanoporous titania thin films were immersed in a 0.002 M F/toluene solution for 24 h at 60 °C (with F = OTES or APTES) followed by rinsing with toluene, EtOH sequentially, and drying with a soft stream of N2 to remove the unreacted organic compounds.

In order to perform the drop interplay assays, droplet pairs of chemically different solutions of a given volume of liquid (typically 2 μL) were placed on the nanoporous surfaces from a Eppendorf automatic micropipette at T = 25 °C and 45% RH controlled ambient conditions. The growth and relative stabilization of the peripheral annulus self-generated in the first placed droplet was waited to deposit the other droplet nearby. Droplet interaction behaviors were followed with an Arcano ZTX-T trinocular stereo microscope combined with an Arcano MIC-ACC-942 10 megapixels video camera and analyzed using the Tracker software (Open Source Physics). The phenomenological droplet evolution at the different experimental conditions resulted highly reproducible.

## Data availability

The data that support the findings of this study can be found in the article and the Supplementary Information files. Any other relevant data are available from the corresponding author upon reasonable request.

## References

1. Steinhorst, L. & Kudla, J. Sexual attraction channelled in moss. Nature 549, 35–36 (2017).

2. Botelho, R. J. & Grinstein, S. Phagocytosis. Curr. Biol. 21, R533–R538 (2011).

3. Popkin, G. The physics of life. Nature 529, 16–18 (2016).

4. Needleman, D. & Dogic, Z. Active matter at the interface between materials science and cell biology. Nat. Rev. Mater. 2, 17048 (2017).

5. Aberts, B. et al. Molecular Biology of the Cell (Garland Publishing, 1983).

6. Carmona-Fontaine, C. et al. Contact inhibition of locomotion in vivo controls neural crest directional migration. Nature 456, 957–961 (2008).

7. Shemi, A. et al. Dimethyl sulfide mediates microbial predator–prey interactions between zooplankton and algae in the ocean. Nat. Microbiol. 6, 1357–1366 (2021).

8. Björkström, N. K., Strunz, B. & Ljunggren, H. G. Natural killer cells in antiviral immunity. Nat. Rev. Immunol. 22, 112–123 (2022).

9. Testa, A. et al. Sustained enzymatic activity and flow in crowded protein droplets. Nat. Commun. 12, 6293 (2021).

10. Cazimoglu, I., Booth, M. J. & Bayley, H. A lipid-based droplet processor for parallel chemical signals. ACS Nano. 15, 20214–20224 (2021).

11. Lach, S., Yoon, S. M. & Grzybowski, B. A. Tactic, reactive, and functional droplets outside of equilibrium. Chem. Soc. Rev. 45, 4766–4796 (2016).

12. Lohse, D. & Zhang, X. Physicochemical hydrodynamics of droplets out of equilibrium. Nat. Rev. Phys. 2, 426–443 (2020).

13. Nakashima, K. K., van Haren, M. H. I., André, A. A. M., Robu, I. & Evan Spruijt, E. Active coacervate droplets are protocells that grow and resist Ostwald ripening. Nat. Commun. 12, 3819 (2021).

14. Qiao, Y., Li, M., Booth, R. & Mann, S. Predatory behaviour in synthetic protocell communities. Nat. Chem. 9, 110–119 (2017).

15. Meredith, C. H. et al. Predator–prey interactions between droplets driven by non-reciprocal oil exchange. Nat. Chem. 12, 1136–1142 (2020).

16. Zwicker, D., Seyboldt, R., Weber, C., Hyman, A. A. & Jülicher, F. Growth and division of active droplets provides a model for protocells. Nat. Phys. 13, 408–413 (2017).

17. Matsuo, M. & Kurihara, K. Proliferating coacervate droplets as the missing link between chemistry and biology in the origins of life. Nat. Commun. 12, 5487 (2021).

18. Taylor, J. W., Eghtesadi, S. A., Points, L. J., Liu, T. & Cronin, L. Autonomous model protocell division driven by molecular replication. Nat. Commun. 8, 237 (2017).

19. Tang, X., Li, W. & Wang, L. Furcated droplet motility on crystalline surfaces. Nat. Nanotechnol. 16, 1106–1112 (2021).

20. Cira, N., Benusiglio, A. & Prakash, M. Vapour-mediated sensing and motility in two-component droplets. Nature 519, 446–450 (2015).

21. Zhang, J. et al. Wetting ridge assisted programmed magnetic actuation of droplets on ferrofluid-infused surface. Nat. Commun. 12, 7136 (2021).

22. Hartmann, J., Schür, M. T. & Hardt, S. Manipulation and control of droplets on surfaces in a homogeneous electric field. Nat. Commun. 13, 289 (2022).

23. Zhang, Q., Feng, S., Lin, L., Mao, S. & Lin, J. M. Emerging open microfluidics for cell manipulation. Chem. Soc. Rev. 50, 5333–5348 (2021).

24. Dak, P. et al. Droplet-based biosensing for lab-on-a-chip, open microfluidics platforms. Biosensors 6, 14 (2016).

25. Ichimura, K., Oh, S. K. & Nakagawa, M. Light-driven motion of liquids on a photoresponsive surface. Science 288, 1624–1626 (2000).

26. Liu, G. L., Kim, J., Lu, Y. U. & Lee, L. P. Optofluidic control using photothermal nanoparticles. Nat. Mater. 5, 27–32 (2006).

27. Singh, D. P. et al. Interface-mediated spontaneous symmetry breaking and mutual communication between drops containing chemically active particles. Nat. Commun. 11, 2210 (2020).

28. Pollack, M. G., Shenderov, A. D. & Fair, R. B. Electrowetting-based actuation of droplets for integrated microfluidics. Lab Chip. 2, 96–101 (2002).

29. Chaudhury, M. K. & Whitesides, G. M. How to make water run uphill. Science 256, 1539–1541 (1992).

30. Sun, Q. et al. Surface charge printing for programmed droplet transport. Nat. Mater. 18, 936–941 (2019).

31. Mazaltarim, A. J., Bowen, J. J., Taylor, J. M. & Morin, S. A. Dynamic manipulation of droplets using mechanically tunable microtextured chemical gradients. Nat. Commun. 12, 3114 (2021).

32. Khoo, H. S. & Tseng, F. G. Spontaneous high-speed transport of subnanoliter water droplet on gradient nanotextured surfaces. Appl. Phys. Lett. 95, 063108 (2009).

33. Malvadkar, N., Hancock, M., Sekeroglu, K., Dressick, W. J. & Demirel, M. C. An engineered anisotropic nanofilm with unidirectional wetting properties. Nat. Mater. 9, 1023–1028 (2010).

34. Li, Q. et al. Reversible structure engineering of bioinspired anisotropic surface for droplet recognition and transportation. Adv. Sci. 7, 2001650 (2020).

35. Sanchez, C., Boissière, C., Grosso, D., Laberty, C. & Nicole, L. Design, synthesis, and properties of inorganic and hybrid thin films having periodically organized nanoporosity. Chem. Mater. 20, 682–737 (2008).

36. Innocenzi, P. & Malfatti, L. Mesoporous thin films: properties and applications. Chem. Soci. Rev. 42, 4198 (2013).

37. Mercuri, M., Pierpauli, K., Bellino, M. G. & Berli, C. L. Complex filling dynamics in mesoporous thin films. Langmuir 33, 152–157 (2017).

38. Gimenez, R., Soler-Illia, G. J., Berli, C. L. A. & Bellino, M. G. Nanopore-Enhanced Drop Evaporation: When Cooler or More Saline Water Droplets Evaporate Faster. ACS Nano 14, 2702–2708 (2020).

39. Ceratti, D. R. et al. Critical effect of pore characteristics on capillary infiltration in mesoporous films. Nanoscale 7, 5371–5382 (2015).

40. Soler-Illia, G. J. A. A. et al. Mesoporous hybrid and nanocomposite thin films. A sol-gel toolbox to create nanoconfined systems with localized chemical properties. J. Sol.-Gel Sci. Technol. 57, 299–312 (2011).

41. Xue, Y., Markmann, J., Duan, H., Weissmüller, J. & Huber, P. Switchable imbibition in nanoporous gold. Nat. Commun. 5, 4237 (2014).

42. Washburn, E. W. The dynamics of capillary flow. Phys. Rev. 17, 273–283 (1921).

43. Baxendale, J. H. Decomposition of hydrogen peroxide by catalysts in homogeneous aqueous solution. Adv. Catal. 4, 31–86 (1952).

44. Zhang, H. et al. Phosphorylation of the myosin regulatory light chain plays a role in motility and polarity during Dictyostelium chemotaxis. J. Cell Sci. 115, 1733–1747 (2002).

45. de Gennes, P. G., Brochard-Wyart, F. & Queré, D. Capillarity and Wetting Phenomena, Springer-Verlag, New York, USA 2004.

46. Israelachvili, J. N. Intermolecular and Surface Forces, Third Edition, Academic Press, San Diego, USA, 2011

47. Phibbs, M. K. & Giguère, P. A. Hydrogen peroxide and its analogues: I. Density, refractive index, viscosity, and surface tension of deuterium peroxide–deuterium oxide solutions. Can. J. Chem. 29, 173–181 (1951).

48. Abdekhodaie, M. J., Cheng, J. & Wu, X. Y. Effect of formulation factors on the bioactivity of glucose oxidase encapsulated chitosan-alginate microspheres: in vitro investigation and mathematical model prediction. Chem. Eng. Sci. 125, 4–12 (2015).

49. Weigler, M. et al. Static field gradient NMR studies of water diffusion in mesoporous silica. Phys. Chem. Chem. Phys. 22, 13989–13998 (2020).

50. Gonzalez Solveyra, E., de la Llave, E., Molinero, V., Soler-Illia, G. J. & Scherlis, D. A. Structure, dynamics, and phase behavior of water in TiO2 nanopores. J. Phys. Chem. C. 117, 3330–3342 (2013).

51. Blumm, J. & Lindemann, A. Characterization of the thermophysical properties of molten polymers and liquids using the flash technique. High. Temp. High. Press. 35/36, 627–632 (2003). /2007.

52. Schriven, L. E. & Sternling, C. V. The Marangoni effect. Nature 187, 186–188 (1960).

53. Probstein, R. F. Physicochemical hydrodynamics: an introduction. John Wiley & Sons (2005).

54. Pesach, D. & Marmur, A. Marangoni effects in the spreading of liquid mixtures on a solid. Langmuir 3, 519–524 (1987).

55. Nikolov, A. D. et al. Superspreading driven by Marangoni flow. Adv. Colloid Interface Sci. 96, 325–338 (2002).

56. Maass, O. & Hatcher, W. H. The properties of pure hydrogen peroxide. I. J. Am. Chem. Soc. 42, 2548–2569 (1920).

57. Lee, J. I., Yim, B. S. & Kim, J. M. Effect of dissolved-gas concentration on bulk nanobubbles generation using ultrasonication. Sci. Rep. 10, 1–7 (2020).

58. Jain, S. & Qiao, L. Molecular dynamics simulations of the surface tension of oxygen-supersaturated water. AIP Adv. 7, 045001 (2017).

59. Ali, K. & Bilal, S. Surface tensions and thermodynamic parameters of surface formation of aqueous salt solutions: III. Aqueous solution of KCl, KBr and KI. Colloids Surf. A: Physicochem. Eng. Asp. 337, 194–199 (2009).

60. Xue, N., Pack, M. Y. & Stone, H. A. Marangoni-driven film climbing on a draining pre-wetted film. J. Fluid Mech. 886, A24 (2020).

61. de Gennes, P. G. Wetting: statics and dynamics. Rev. Mod. Phys. 57, 827–863 (1985).

62. Jain, P. K. & Ahmad, K. A Textbook of Analytical Geometry of Two Dimensions. Hoboke n, NJ, USA: Wiley, (1986).

63. Mercanti, V., Charette, S. J., Bennett, N., Ryckewaert, J.-J. & Letourner, F. Selective membrane exclusion in phagocytic and macropinocytic cups. J. Cell Sci. 119, 4079–4087 (2006).

64. Desjardins, M., Houde, M. & Gagnon, E. Phagocytosis: the convoluted way from nutrition to adaptive immunity. Immunol. Rev. 207, 158–165 (2005).

65. Karpitschka, S. & Riegler, H. Noncoalescence of sessile drops from different but miscible liquids: hydrodynamic analysis of the twin drop contour as a self-stabilizing traveling wave. Phys. Rev. Lett. 109, 066103 (2012).

66. Ng, V. V., Sellier, M. & Nock, V. Marangoni-improved mixing in a two-droplet system. Interfacial Phenom. Heat. Transf. 5, 81–95 (2017).

67. Sykes, T. C. et al. Surface jets and internal mixing during the coalescence of impacting and sessile droplets. Phys. Rev. Fluids. 5, 023602 (2020).

68. Teleki, A., Bjelobrk, N. & Pratsinis, S. E. Continuous surface functionalization of flame-made TiO2 nanoparticles. Langmuir 26, 5815–5822 (2010).

69. Calvo, A. et al. Mesoporous aminopropyl-functionalized hybrid thin films with modulable surface and environment-responsive behavior. Chem. Mater. 20, 4661–4668 (2008).

70. Soler-Illia, G. J. D. A. A. & Azzaroni, O. Multifunctional hybrids by combining ordered mesoporous materials and macromolecular building blocks. Chem. Soc. Rev. 40, 1107–1150 (2011).

71. Peterson, M. S. E., Baskaran, A. & Hagan, M. F. Vesicle shape transformations driven by confined active filaments. Nat. Commun. 12, 7247 (2021).

72. Seara, D. S. et al. Entropy production rate is maximized in non-contractile actomyosin. Nat. Commun. 9, 4948 (2018).

## Acknowledgements

This work was supported by Agencia I+D+I funding (PICT 2016-1781), Argentina (MGB). Raúl Urteaga is acknowledged for image analysis. A.D.P. acknowledges his doctoral scholarship from CONICET, Argentina.

## Author information

Authors

### Contributions

M.G.B. and G.J.A.A.S-I. conceived the project. A.D.P. fabricated the samples and performed the experiments. C.L.A.B. built the model. G.J.A.A.S-I., C.L.A.B. and M.G.B. wrote the manuscript, and all authors were involved in analysis of data and discussions of this work.

### Corresponding author

Correspondence to Martín G. Bellino.

## Ethics declarations

### Competing interests

The authors declare no competing interests.

## Peer review

### Peer review information

Nature Communications thanks Sujeet Dutta, Olivier Vincent and the other, anonymous, reviewer(s) for their contribution to the peer review of this work. Peer reviewer reports are available.

Publisher’s note Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.

## Rights and permissions

Reprints and Permissions

Pizarro, A.D., Berli, C.L.A., Soler-Illia, G.J.A.A. et al. Droplets in underlying chemical communication recreate cell interaction behaviors. Nat Commun 13, 3047 (2022). https://doi.org/10.1038/s41467-022-30834-2

• Accepted:

• Published:

• DOI: https://doi.org/10.1038/s41467-022-30834-2