An ionizable lipid toolbox for RNA delivery

Recent years have witnessed incredible growth in RNA therapeutics, which has benefited significantly from decades of research on lipid nanoparticles, specifically its key component—the ionizable lipid. This comment discusses the major ionizable lipid types, and provides perspectives for future development.

payload release. For this reason, the linoleyl tail was chosen as the structural basis during the optimization process of the ionizable lipid DLin-MC3-DMA (MC3) 3,5 . This ionizable lipid confers robust hepatic gene silencing and is used in the first FDAapproved siRNA drug Onpattro ® for the treatment of hereditary transthyretin amyloidosis (hATTR) 6 . Importantly, both the structure and formulation of MC3 laid the groundwork for further LNP development.
Unsaturated ionizable lipids have also been demonstrated to enhance mRNA delivery. Anderson and colleagues showed a linoleic acid-derived ionizable lipid (OF-02) achieved the highest hepatic mRNA delivery and protein expression among its class 7 . Later, they demonstrated that an alkyne ionizable lipid (A6) could greatly increase membrane fusion and facilitate albuminmediated mRNA delivery when incorporated into benchmark LNPs (e.g., MC3) 8 . Interestingly, in a heterocyclic ionizable lipid library prepared by a three-component reaction, they identified an alkylene ketone-derived A18-Iso5-2DC18 that could not only deliver mRNA vaccines robustly but also activate the stimulator of interferon genes (STING) pathway 9 . However, the inclusion of unsaturated bonds in the ionizable lipid does not always correspond with potent in vivo RNA delivery 7,8,10 , indicating that both rational design and screening are necessary.

Multi-tail ionizable lipids
Multi-tail ionizable lipids are structurally distinguished from two-tail ones by having three or more tails. Such ionizable lipids are expected to produce a more cone-shaped structure with enhanced endosome-disrupting ability due to the increased crosssection of the tail region. Multi-tail ionizable lipids can be easily synthesized by combinatorial chemistry and subjected to highthroughput screening. Since the first combinatorial library created in 2008, several multi-tailed leads (e.g., 98N 12 -5, C12-200, and cKK-E12) have been identified to potently knockdown hepatic genes [11][12][13] . Mechanism for endosome disruption by ionizable lipids and five major structural classes of ionizable lipids. The cone-shaped ion pairs formed by anionic endosomal phospholipids and protonated ionizable lipids can disrupt the bilayer structure to promote endosomal escape. Based on their structural properties, RNA-delivering ionizable lipids can be categorized into unsaturated (containing unsaturated bond), multi-tail (containing more than two tails), polymeric (containing polymer or dendrimer), biodegradable (containing biodegradable bond) and branched-tail (containing branched tail) ones.
Although initially developed for siRNA delivery, multi-tail ionizable lipids can be repurposed for efficient mRNA delivery by optimizing the LNP composition via design of experiment methodologies with significantly reduced workload 14,15 . For example, the optimized formulation of C12-200 increased mRNA expression 7-fold compared to the standard formulation 14 . Later, this formulation was widely adopted by multi-tail ionizable lipids for various mRNA delivery purposes such as chimeric antigen receptor T-cell engineering and prenatal protein replacement therapy 16,17 . Recently, a class of multi-tail ionizable phospholipids was created; the top-performing 9A1P9, comprising one zwitterionic head and three tails, assisted to promote membrane destabilization and cargo release, which greatly enhanced LNPmediated tissue-selective mRNA delivery and gene editing 18 . Nevertheless, lead multi-tail ionizable lipids often have stable backbones and low degradability, so their toxicity and immunogenicity should always be taken into consideration 19 .
Ionizable polymer-lipids Substitution of free amines on cationic polymers with alkyl tails affords ionizable polymer-lipids, which can enhance particle formation through hydrophobic aggregation. From 500 structurally diverse synthetic polymer-lipid hybrids, Anderson et al. identified that C15 epoxide-modified low-molecular-weight polyethyleneimine (7C1) conferred the most efficient non-liver siRNA delivery 20 . 7C1 preferentially transfected endothelial cells -rather than hepatocytes and pulmonary epithelial cells-in multiple organs, with the highest endothelial gene silencing in the lung. In non-human primates,~80% endothelial gene knockdown in the lungs was achieved by 7C1 without significant toxicity 21 , indicating its potential to treat dysfunctional endothelium-related diseases. Recently, its re-optimized formulation was further demonstrated to achieve potent gene silencing in bone marrow endothelial cells, which could further regulate hematopoietic cell activity 22 .
Additionally, lead ionizable polymer-lipids derived from poly(amido amine) and poly(propylenimine) dendrimers have also shown strong avidity to transfect liver endothelium and lung vasculature 23,24 , implying preferential transfection of endothelium for polycation-based ionizable lipids. However, such cell population tropism can be varied depending on the LNP formulation 23,25 . For example, when co-formulated with other accessory excipients, G0-C14 confers high accumulation and effective transfection of various RNA therapeutics in tumors [26][27][28][29] , demonstrating the promise of LNPs for cancer therapy. Nevertheless, ionizable polymer-lipids, even after purification, usually comprise a mixture of different substitution compounds 20,23 , which increase their complexity. Moreover, the toxic polycation core and non-degradable backbone pose extra hurdles for clinical translation.

Biodegradable ionizable lipids
In order to reduce accumulation and potential side effects, ionizable lipids should be readily degraded into non-toxic metabolites after successful intracellular cargo delivery, which is especially crucial for RNA therapeutics requiring repeated dosing. A common strategy to introduce biodegradability into ionizable lipids is through the inclusion of ester bonds that are stable at physiological pH, but are enzymatically hydrolyzed within tissues and cells. For example, due to the slow degradability of the dilinoleyl tail in MC3, a biodegradable substitution (L319) was created by replacing one of the double bonds in each tail with a primary ester 30 . L319 not only maintained in vivo potency, but also displayed rapid elimination and improved tolerability.
Notably, the position and steric effect of the ester groups can greatly affect ionizable lipid clearance and potency 30,31 .
Alternative to rational design, diversely structured biodegradable ionizable lipids can be combinatorially synthesized using alkyl amines and acrylate tails 11,32 . The analysis of structure-activity relationships indicated that acrylate-based ionizable lipids with tertiary amines, at least three O 13 tails, and a suitable pK a (5.5-7.0) confer robust in vivo gene silencing 32 . The lead ionizable lipid (304O 13 ) had similar potency to the non-degradable C12-200 benchmark, but posed much lower toxicity at high doses. It is noteworthy that ester-containing ionizable lipids typically demonstrate lower potency compared to non-degradable analogs due to inefficient delivery caused by rapid hydrolysis 3,11 . This suggests an activity-degradability tradeoff that needs to be balanced to maximize total benefits. One viable approach to overcome this dilemma is adopting the more stable secondary ester instead of the primary one 31 . Interestingly, OF-Deg-Lin, a degradable analog of OF-02, selectively transfected splenic lymphocytes and induced >85% of total protein expression in the spleen (an organ with a relative lowabundance of hydrolases) 33 , suggesting that degradable ionizable lipids could be promising vectors for spleen transfection.
To further improve biodegradability and accelerate RNA release, disulfide bonds that are sensitive to the reductive intracellular environment can be incorporated into acrylate tails 34 . The resulting bioreducible ionizable lipids have been shown to efficiently deliver ASOs and CRISPR/Cas9 systems for gene silencing and editing with good tolerability in mice [35][36][37] . For example, 306-O12B outperformed MC3 in CRISPR-Cas9-based liver genome editing of Angptl3, and negligible toxicity or offtarget mutagenesis was observed 38 . Despite the promise of disulfide bond-containing ionizable lipids, the difficulty of synthesis and risk of premature release could limit their applications.

Branched-tail ionizable lipids
Along with tail length and saturation, tail branching can greatly influence ionizable lipid performance. Ionizable lipids with methacrylate tails (a 1C branch near the head) generally showed reduced efficacy compared to acrylate-based ones 39 . Interestingly, ionizable lipids containing isodecyl acrylate (O i10 , a 1C branch at the end) dramatically boosted hepatic mRNA expression (>10-fold) compared to their isomers with linear tails, despite their similar biodistribution 40 . This increased potency can be explained by enhanced endosomal escape due to the stronger protonation of spaced ionizable lipids at endosomal pH and the increased crosssection of the lipid tails, allowing for adoption of a more cone-shaped structure. 41 The lead ionizable lipid (306O i10 ) efficiently co-delivered multiple RNA constructs to the liver and transfected >80% of hepatocytes, Kupffer and endothelial cells, demonstrating the potential for integrating different therapeutic modalities (e.g., gene silencing, expression, and editing) to treat liver dysfunction 42 .
Recently, Dong and coworkers developed ionizable lipids with branched ester chains that had higher transfection efficiency in the liver than their analogs with linear ester chains, presumably due to the slower degradation rate of the secondary ester 10,31 . Their topperforming ionizable lipid (FTT5) demonstrated efficient delivery of large mRNA constructs for protein supplementation and base editing therapies. Notably, increased tail branching is one of the major features investigated by LNP companies 31 .

Clinical development of ionizable lipids
Before the approval of Onpattro ® in 2018, scientists have screened numerous ionizable lipids and LNP formulations for more than a decade. The success of MC3 has re-ignited the enthusiasm for RNA delivery and greatly accelerated the clinical development of other LNP-based RNA therapeutics, particularly mRNA vaccines (Fig. 2). Specifically, the COVID-19 pandemic has caused millions of deaths. However, in less than one year, two LNP-based mRNA vaccines (mRNA-1273 and BNT162b2) underwent unprecedented speed of development and received the historic approval for emergency use after demonstrating protection efficacies above 94% 43,44 . Interestingly, Moderna's SM-102 and BioNTech's Acuitas ALC-0315 have some shared features, including a tertiary amine, branched tails and ester linkers. Moreover, both of them bear extended aliphatic branches, making them appear like multi-tail structures. Currently, additional COVID-19 mRNA vaccines delivered by LNPs are undergoing clinical development. Although these ionizable lipid structures have not been publicly disclosed, the probable ones are shown based on available patents and literature (Fig. 2).
Recently, positive results from the first human trial of LNPenabled CRISPR-Cas9 in vivo gene editing were disclosed 45 . A single dose of LP000001-formulated LNPs carrying sgRNA targeting transthyretin (TTR) and Cas9 mRNA led to a 87% reduction of serum TTR in patients with hATTR, and only few or mild adverse events were observed. This study heralds an era for LNP-mediated in vivo gene editing.
When reviewing the approved MC3, SM-102, and ALC-0315 structures as well as those patented by Acuitas et al. [46][47][48]50 , the ester-based biodegradable structure appears in every ionizable lipid; the next most commonly shared features are the multi/ branched-tail and unsaturated structures. This suggests that biodegradability is a key feature for the clinical translation of ionizable lipids. Additionally, increased branching or tail number is a common characteristic for newly developed ionizable lipids. However, these multi/branched-tail ionizable lipids typically possess only one tertiary amine, which is a sharp contrast to those discussed in Fig. 1. Interestingly, while the unsaturated structure is important to ionizable lipids with long tails, it appears less important for those with multiple short tails. Challenges and future directions Despite the FDA approval of ionizable lipids for RNA delivery applications, several challenges need to be addressed in order to reach the full potential of RNA therapeutics. First, the ionizable lipid is the key LNP component to cause acute immune responses and longterm toxicity. Although degradable ionizable lipids can be used to mitigate this issue, premedication with glucocorticoids and antihistamines before LNP infusion is still needed 45 . To overcome this issue, optimization of linker chemistry and inclusion of antiinflammatory properties warrant further investigation 31,51 .
Second, the preparation of rationally designed ionizable lipid candidates is challenging due to the laborious synthesis process. For example, four synthetic steps and one week of intensive labor are required to synthesize MC3, and it is a huge burden to prepare all of its analogs 5 . Currently, clinical ionizable lipids are all synthesized by multiple steps, which results in scalable manufacturing challenges. This issue can be mitigated by adopting combinatorial chemistry for simplified synthesis and accelerated ionizable lipid screening. However, top-performing ionizable lipids synthesized using this method usually contain stable backbones and multiple tertiary amines, leading to slow degradation and potential toxicity. Therefore, there is an urgent need to develop new combinatorial reactions that can generate degradable ionizable lipids for potent RNA delivery. Meanwhile, introducing additional functional modalities (e.g., STING activation) into these lipids would be of great value for specific RNA therapeutic and vaccine applications 9 .
Third, ionizable lipid-mediated extrahepatic delivery is another challenge to the broad application of RNA therapeutics. After systemic administration, neutral LNPs mainly localize in the liver regardless of the ionizable lipid 52 . While most ester-based ionizable lipids are reported to mainly transfect the liver, OF-Deg-Lin exhibits predominant splenic transfection 33 . Further disclosure of the relationships between structure and organ selectivity would greatly benefit extrahepatic RNA delivery. Besides passive targeting of extrahepatic tissue, rationally designed ionizable lipids with targeting ability can be promising for improving non-liver delivery. For example, a neurotransmitter-derived ionizable lipid has been shown to retain its active transporting ability to cross blood-brain barrier (BBB), allowing previously BBB-impermeable LNPs to successfully deliver ASOs into the brain 53 .
In summary, based on current research progress and clinical status, degradable backbones and increased branching/tails are two of the most favorable structural properties for the future development of ionizable lipids. Apart from safety and potency, next-generation ionizable lipids with additional functionalities such as targeting and immunomodulation will be important for specific applications. Therefore, there are still vast opportunities for ionizable lipid optimization and innovation to enable the broader translation of RNA therapeutics and vaccines.