Larval metamorphosis and recruitment represent critical life-history transitions for most teleost fishes. While the detrimental effects of anthropogenic stressors on the behavior and survival of recruiting fishes are well-documented, the physiological mechanisms that underpin these patterns remain unclear. Here, we use pharmacological treatments to highlight the role that thyroid hormones (TH) play in sensory development and determining anti-predator responses in metamorphosing convict surgeonfish, Acanthurus triostegus. We then show that high doses of a physical stressor (increased temperature of +3 °C) and a chemical stressor (the pesticide chlorpyrifos at 30 µg L−1) induced similar defects by decreasing fish TH levels and affecting their sensory development. Stressor-exposed fish experienced higher predation; however, their ability to avoid predation improved when they received supplemental TH. Our results highlight that two different anthropogenic stressors can affect critical developmental and ecological transitions via the same physiological pathway. This finding provides a unifying mechanism to explain past results and underlines the profound threat anthropogenic stressors pose to fish communities.
The variety, frequency, and amplitude of anthropogenic stressors faced by organisms is unprecedented and increasing1,2. The scale of human activities has led to once localized perturbations, such as heat waves3 and waterborne chemical toxicants4 becoming issues of global importance. Exposure to stressors can directly impact how organisms function and also decrease their resilience to further exposure or exposure to other stressors, resulting in cascading negative repercussions for them and the ecosystem they inhabit5,6. The negative impacts of anthropogenic stressors can be felt by all organisms at all life stages; however, aquatic species may be more vulnerable than terrestrial organisms7. Further, disruptions at critical life-history transitions, such as during metamorphosis8, can disproportionately threaten the structure of communities and persistence of species9.
Teleost fishes represent almost half of the world’s vertebrates and generally exhibit a metamorphic transition from their larval to juvenile phase10,11. In marine species, such as coral and temperate reef fishes, this transition typically occurs as larvae move from the pelagic environment to their juvenile/adult reef-associated habitat, i.e., recruitment11. The sensory systems of many recruiting fishes undergo rapid development as they metamorphose, which may help them locate and navigate toward suitable settlement habitats12,13, and survive during this life-history transition14,15. Nevertheless, fishes often experience an extreme predation bottleneck during recruitment; for instance, recruiting coral-reef fishes have an estimated average mortality rate of 30% per day as a result of predation16. Myriad recent studies have reported that various anthropogenic stressors, such as artificial light pollution17, increasing temperature18,19,20, ocean acidification21,22, sound pollution23,24, and waterborne chemical pollutants11,14,25 can lead to the deterioration of ecologically important behaviors, including the ability to detect predators and avoid predation. Predators and prey do not appear to be equally affected by anthropogenic stressors21, suggesting that alterations to predator–prey dynamics have the potential to drastically reshape fish communities26,27,28. Despite this, our understanding of the mechanism(s) that underpin the patterns reported in these studies remains limited29,30.
The endocrine system plays an important role in post-embryonic developmental processes8,31. In teleost fishes, metamorphosis is controlled by thyroid hormones (TH), including thyroxine (T4) and triiodothyronine (T3)10. Environmental stressors (e.g., decreasing water level and food deprivation) and anthropogenic stressors (e.g., waterborne chemical pollutants) have the ability to disrupt thyroid function, which can affect the timing, duration, and completion of metamorphic processes32,33. Surprisingly, the ultimate consequences of stressor-induced developmental and endocrine impairments, such as their impact on predator–prey dynamics, remain poorly studied34. TH plays a key role in neurogenesis and sensory development in vertebrates35,36, and are central for regulating recruitment in reef fishes11. Thus, TH signaling disruption may present a generalizable physiological mechanism through which reports of behavioral and survival deteriorations in recruiting fishes following exposure to anthropogenic stressors can be understood34.
Here, we use the coral-reef-dwelling convict surgeonfish, Acanthurus triostegus, to investigate the importance of the TH endocrine pathway on sensory development during metamorphosis, whether exposure to two distinct anthropogenic stressors (increased temperature and the waterborne organophosphate pesticide chlorpyrifos) can cause TH signaling disruption, and whether the resulting impacts on sensory development increase vulnerability to predation.
TH signaling controls the development of sensory structures
To study sensory development during metamorphosis, wild settlement-stage A. triostegus (day 0 = d0, Fig. 1a) were collected at night, while they were moving from the pelagic environment to the reef, using a crest net11. Following capture, they were maintained for up to 8 days (d8) in in situ cages, during which they fully completed metamorphosis11. The olfactory, visual, and mechanosensory structures (Fig. 1b–d) showed rapid development from d0 to d8 in control individuals, with the development of new lamellae, a 50% increase in bipolar cell density in the retina, and a 240% surge in trunk canal pore density, respectively (Fig. 1e–g). We investigated the role of TH in the development of these sensory structures by injecting fish daily from d0 to d5 with different pharmacological drugs: (i) T3 + iopanoic acid (T3 treatment) to achieve TH signal activation, and (ii) NH3 (a TH antagonist, N3 treatment) to achieve TH signal disruption11. The T3 treatment induced an accelerated development of all three sensory structures, with elevated densities of bipolar cells at d2, as well as elevated number of lamellae and greater density trunk canal pores at both d2 and d5 (Fig. 1e–g). In contrast, N3-treated fish experienced repressed sensory development, at both d2 and d5 for the retina and the olfactory organ (Fig. 1e, f), and at d2 for the trunk canal (Fig. 1g). Supplemental T3 rescued olfactory organ development in N3-treated fish (Supplementary Fig. 1).
TH signaling modulates behavioral responses to predator stimuli and vulnerability to predation
As predation is high in the 2 days following settlement in reef fishes16, we examined the behavioral outcomes of different sensory structure developmental states by testing whether d0 and d2 control, T3-, and N3-treated fish responded differently when presented with chemical and visual cues from a common reef predator: the blacktail snapper, Lutjanus fulvus. In chemical choice experiments, d2 control fish showed a clear avoidance of predator cues (Fig. 2a). This response was similar in T3-treated fish, while N3-treated fish did not discriminate between water sources, similar to d0 fish (Fig. 2a). When comparing responses to visual cues in a separated aquarium, we again found that d2 control and T3-treated fish avoided predator cues, while N3-treated fish showed no preference, similar to d0 fish (Fig. 2b). To investigate whether this inability to identify predation risk makes them more vulnerable to predation, we conducted a predation test in an in situ arena. We found that d2 T3-treated fish exhibited significantly higher survival (i.e., number of fish that survived) than d2 control fish, while d2 N3-treated fish exhibited lower survival than d2 control fish (Fig. 2c).
Increased temperature and chlorpyrifos affect TH levels and sensory development
To examine whether independent exposure to two anthropogenic stressors can affect TH levels and sensory system development, we exposed A. triostegus from d0 to d2 to increased temperature and to the organophosphate pesticide chlorpyrifos (CPF). Fish were exposed to either: (i) water at 28.5 °C (control), 30.0 °C ( + 1.5 °C), or 31.5 °C ( + 3.0 °C), following end-of-century projections for the tropical Pacific37; or (ii) water containing no CPF (control), acetone (solvent control, CPF0), or CPF at 1, 5, and 30 µg L−1 (CPF1, CPF5, and CPF30, respectively)11. We found that fish exposed to +3 °C experienced a significant reduction in T4 and T3 levels at d2 compared with control fish (32% and 35%, respectively), while no difference was observed in fish exposed to +1.5 °C compared with control fish (Fig. 3a, b). Fish exposed to +3 °C also exhibited a significant reduction in both bipolar cell and trunk canal pore density (7 and 9%), but exhibited no difference in the number of lamellae compared with control fish (Fig. 3c–f). We observed a significant reduction (25%) in T4 levels at d2 in CPF30 fish compared to control fish, while there were no differences between control, CPF0, CPF1, and CPF5 fish (Fig. 3a). We also found no differences in T3 levels between control, CPF0, CPF1, and CPF5 fish, but significantly reduced T3 levels in CPF30 fish (28%) compared with control fish (Fig. 3b). CPF30 fish also exhibited reduced densities of bipolar cell (10%) and trunk canal pores (15%), but no difference in the number of lamellae compared with the control fish (Fig. 3c–f). Exposures to +3 °C or CPF30 were therefore associated with comparably affected TH levels and development of sensory structures, but CPF30 fish experienced a lower T3/T4 ratio than +3.0 °C fish (Supplementary Fig. 2).
T3 injections can restore survival in stressor-exposed fish
To investigate whether increased susceptibility to predation was causally related to anthropogenic stressor-induced TH disruption, we conducted a predation test. We compared the survival of d2 fish that were exposed to: (i) control conditions, +3 °C, or +3 °C with supplemental T3; and (ii) control conditions, CPF30, or CPF30 with supplemental T3. When compared with control fish, those exposed to +3 °C and CPF30 experienced lower survival (Fig. 3f). Interestingly, both +3 °C and CPF30 fish treated with supplementary T3 experienced higher survival compared with untreated +3 °C and CPF30 fish, respectively (Fig. 3f).
Increased temperatures and chlorpyrifos synergistically decrease TH levels
To test whether exposure to both stressors had additive or interacting effects, we simultaneously exposed d0 larvae to different suboptimal dose regimes of both stressors (i.e., dose regimes that were found to individually have no significant effect on TH levels) until d2. We found that co-exposure to +1.5 °C and CPF1 did not significantly reduce T4 or T3 levels, but that co-exposure to +1.5 °C and CPF5 significantly decreased T4 and T3 levels (43% and 26%, respectively) (Fig. 4a, b).
Our results highlight the key role an endocrine process (i.e., TH signaling) plays in regulating sensory system development in recruiting fishes, the effect anthropogenic stressors can have on this endocrine function, and the consequences of decreased TH levels and affected sensory development for determining the outcome of predator–prey interactions. Fish with pharmacologically disrupted TH signaling experienced diminished sensory development and anti-predator behaviors, and were more vulnerable to predation. Sensory development and vulnerability to predation were comparably affected by two distinct anthropogenic stressors (increased temperature and CPF). However, fish that received supplemental T3 experienced an apparently recovered ability to avoid predation, implicating TH signaling disruption as a mechanism associated with decreased survival following exposure to these stressors. In addition to the recognized role of TH for successful metamorphosis and recruitment in teleost fishes10,11, our results indicate that TH disruption may provide a unifying physiological mechanism that can help explain reports of deteriorated anti-predator behaviors following exposure to an array of anthropogenic stressors21,23,25.
Thyroid hormones are important for regulating sensory development in teleost fishes11,14,36,38, and our results provide insights into the role they play in this development during recruitment. A. triostegus exhibits an enclosed nose (Supplementary Fig. 3a), well-formed rosette lamellae (Supplementary Fig. 3b), and a fully formed trunk canal (Supplementary Fig. 4a) at the time of settlement, but relatively low cell densities in the retina (Fig. 1f; Supplementary Figs. 6–8)13,39. This suggests that, with the possible exception of the retina, the sensory structures of A. triostegus are generally more developed than other reef40,41,42 and non-reef36,43 fish species at a similar life-history stage. Despite this advanced stage of development, we found that fish with pharmacologically enhanced TH signaling experienced faster sensory development, those with disrupted TH signaling (either pharmacologically (Fig. 1e–g) or environmentally (Fig. 3c, e)) experienced diminished sensory development, and those with pharmacologically disrupted TH that received supplemental T3 experienced rescued development of their olfactory organ (Supplementary Fig. 1). This development of new lamellae promoted by TH is consistent with neurogenesis35, as the number of lamellae roughly correlates with the number of olfactory neurons44. In contrast, the development of the trunk canal involves both the differentiation of canal neuromasts (i.e., neurogenesis, not studied here) and the enclosure and elaboration of the canal itself43. The epithelial proliferation that occurs, that is relevant here, is the formation and elongation of the pores in the skin covering the lateral line canal. The fact that lamellae development was not affected by increased temperature or CPF (Fig. 3d) suggests that the endocrine disruption caused by these stressors may not be severe enough (e.g., in comparison with the N3 treatment) to affect this developmental process. These results highlight the sensitivity and complexity of the mechanisms underlying the actions of TH on sensory system development, offering an avenue for future research, in particular on the auditory system, as hearing was not studied here but is also used by larval fish during recruitment and impacted by stressors23.
In addition to causing developmental defects, TH signaling disruption also affected the behavior and survivorship of metamorphosing fish. Fish that experienced pharmacological TH disruption presented anti-predator behaviors that were comparable with pre-metamorphosed larvae and suffered increased mortality during a predation experiment (Fig. 2a–c). In contrast, fish that received supplemental T3 experienced a marked increase in their capacity to avoid predation (Figs. 2c and 3f). We found that T3-treated fish exhibited fastened sensory development (Fig. 1e, f) and comparable responses to predator cues to control fish (Fig. 2a, b), which is consistent with an accelerated sensory development facilitating more effective anti-predator abilities. Nevertheless, we cannot rule out the possibility that supplemental T3 may have also impacted their behavior in other ways. For example, supplemental T3 may affect swimming behavior (e.g., as suspected in Danio rerio, McMenamin pers. comm.) and might alter the cues emitted by these individuals (e.g., smelling or tasting different to the predators), which may have contributed to their ability to avoid predation (Fig. 2c).
While exposure to high levels of increased temperature and CPF both inhibit sensory development and reduce a fish’s likelihood of avoiding predation, the two stressors affected endocrine signaling differently. Temperature had a higher impact on T4 levels than CPF (Fig. 3a), as indicated by a higher T3/T4 ratio (Supplementary Fig. 2). This suggests a greater central effect, most probably at the neuroendocrine level, which may alter thyroid activity and thus explain the decreased levels of T3 that we observed45. In contrast, CPF had a greater effect on T3 levels than temperature (Fig. 3b), as indicated by a lower T3/T4 ratio (Supplementary Fig. 2), suggesting a more downstream or peripheral effect, possibly on T3 metabolism46,47. This variety of action modes may explain the synergistic effect of both stressors on TH levels with co-exposure to 1.5 °C or CPF5 decreasing TH levels (Fig. 4a, b), while these stressor levels did not affect TH levels when exposed separately (Fig. 3a, b). Further, as the actions of TH are temperature-specific48, the toxicity of TH-disrupting pollutants such as CPF may intensify with increasing temperatures. Given that stressors are rarely experienced individually, these results highlight the vulnerability of aquatic organism endocrine functions and the risk posed by anthropogenic stressors7,9.
Reef fish-recruitment areas (i.e., nurseries) are typically coastal, shallow, and often tidally isolated, making them highly sensitive to dramatic environmental changes, such as sudden heat waves49,50 and terrestrial pollutant runoff51, that are expected to increase in both frequency and severity globally. Organophosphates are the most widely used pesticide globally, and CPF is the second most commonly detected pesticide in water, frequently occurring in temperate and tropical coastal runoff52. Under these circumstances, acute fluctuations such as temperature spikes of +1.5 °C and +3.0 °C are environmentally relevant, and CPF levels from 1 to 30 µg L−1 are informative in the context of decreasing water quality in coastal areas in response to increasing pesticide use and land clearing51. Indeed, rapid temperature shifts are common in coastal surface waters and can reach up to 12 °C following solar and tidal forcing50. Likewise, while CPF levels in contaminated surface waters are generally below 1 µg L−1 with limited persistence in the water column, these levels can spike up to 26 µg L−1 in rivers53. This suggests that following run-offs, and on a short timescale such as the 32-h exposure of our study, CPF levels in coastal waters could largely exceed the pg/ng per liter concentrations usually reported in seawater54,55,56. Acute exposure to increased temperatures of +1.5 and +3 °C or CPF levels spanning from 1 to 30 µg L−1 therefore reflects the temperature fluctuations49,50 and potential or future pesticide fluctuations53 that larval fishes may experience when recruiting to coastal nurseries under high anthropogenic influence. Larger and older fishes are less vulnerable to TH signaling disruption and associated neurological defects than metamorphosing fishes57, indicating that exposure to acute stressors may alter fish predator–prey dynamics during this critical temporal window. As small declines in survival during recruitment can have dramatic consequences for population replenishment, our results raise concerns about the future of coastal fish nurseries, which, under the threats of climate change and anthropogenic stressors, could turn into ecological traps58.
Overall, this study highlights that short-term exposure to acute anthropogenic stressors has adverse consequences for the development, behavior, and survival of metamorphosing fish by affecting their TH endocrine function. Given the widespread nature of metamorphosis in aquatic organisms8 and that metamorphosis is typically regulated by sensitive endocrine pathways59, this study underlines the profound threat posed by anthropogenic stressors to the function, resilience, and persistence of aquatic populations and communities.
This study did not involve endangered or protected species and was carried out in accordance with the guidelines of the French Polynesia code for animal ethics and scientific research (https://www.service-public.pf/diren/partager/code/). All protocols and experiments were approved by the CRIOBE-IRCP animal ethics committee (DL-20150214).
The convict surgeonfish Acanthurus triostegus (Linnaeus, 1758) is an abundant coral-reef-associated species found throughout the Indo-Pacific60, including around Moorea Island, French Polynesia11. It has a pelagic larval duration of ~53 days60 after which larvae move back to the reef61. A. triostegus is a well-studied species with regards to metamorphosis, with a well-defined developmental sequence11. The recruitment of A. triostegus larvae to reef habitats coincides with a true metamorphosis into juveniles, with this full process taking around 1 week11. Its metamorphosis is controlled by thyroid hormones (TH, the precursor thyroxine (T4), and the active hormone triiodothyronine (T3)), which is the same as other teleosts and other metamorphosing vertebrates such as amphibians11. TH signaling in larval A. triostegus is vulnerable to disruption by anthropogenic stressors, including the waterborne pesticide chlorpyrifos and artificial light at night11,17. Given the importance of TH during teleost metamorphosis10, and as metamorphosis coincides with recruitment in a taxonomically diverse range of coral-reef fishes (i.e., Acanthuridae, Apogonidae, Balistidae, Chaetodontidae, and Pomacentridae)11, we consider A. triostegus a representative teleost model for examining the effects of anthropogenic stressors on fish recruitment via their impacts on metamorphic processes.
Study period and site
This study was conducted from February 2015 to June 2018, at Moorea Island, French Polynesia (S17°32′16.4589″, W149°49′48.3018″). Sampling for the examination of sensory development under pharmacological treatments was conducted in 2015. Sampling for the investigation of behavioral preferences and survival to predation under pharmacological treatments, as well as sensory development under anthropogenic stressor exposure, were conducted in 2016. Sampling for the examination of survival to predation under anthropogenic stressors exposure, and TH levels under co-exposure to anthropogenic stressors were conducted in 2018. Sampling for the investigation of TH levels under single anthropogenic stressors was conducted in both 2016 and 2018.
Settlement-stage A. triostegus (i.e., fully transparent individuals11, here define as day 0 (d0) individuals), were collected on the north–east coast of the island (S17°29′49.7362″, W149°45′13.899″) at night using a crest net11, as they transitioned from the ocean to the reef. Fish were then transferred to either in situ cages (for thyroid hormone signaling experiments) where they remained until d8, or to aquaria at the CRIOBE Marine Research Station (for increased temperature and chlorpyrifos exposure experiments) where they remained until d5.
Thyroid hormone signaling experiment: control, T3- and N3 treatments
To test the role of TH on sensory development, behavior (response to sensory cues), and survival (predation test) in metamorphosing A. triostegus, their TH pathway was pharmacologically manipulated. Fish were injected, at d0 immediately following capture, in their ventral cavity with 20 µl of a pharmacological treatment: (i) T3 + iopanoic acid (IOP) both at 10−6 M (T3 treatment), or (ii) NH3 at 10−6 M (N3 treatment). IOP was used as an inhibitor of deiodinase enzymes, following comparable work in mammals and amphibians62, and as routinely used in fish to prevent the immediate degradation of injected T348. The T3 treatment was therefore applied to promote TH signaling. NH3 is a known antagonist of TH receptors (TR) in vertebrates63 and in A. triostegus in particular11. NH3 prevents the binding of TH such as T3 to TR, therefore impairing the binding of transcriptional coactivators to TR, which therefore remain in an inactive and repressive conformation63,64. The N3 treatment was thus applied to repress TH signaling by disrupting the TH pathway. T3 and NH3 were initially suspended in dimethyl sulfoxide (DMSO), at 10−2 M, and then diluted in phosphate buffered saline (PBS) 1× to reach 10−6 M. Control fish were injected with 20 µL of DMSO diluted 10.000 times in PBS 1× to control for the effect of the solvent and injection. DMSO and NH3 non-toxicity has been previously determined11. Until subsequent sampling, all fish were re-treated each morning (i.e., at d2, d3, and d4 for fish sampled at d5) to maintain pharmacological activity11.
Thyroid hormone signaling experiment: fish husbandry
Following collection and subsequent treatment, larvae were transferred to a nursery area on the north coast of the island (S17°29′26.5378″, W149°53′29.2252″) where they were raised in in situ cages (cylindrical cages, diameter: 30 cm, height: 50 cm, 15 fish per cage). This allowed them to develop in in situ conditions11. As A. triostegus feeds on algal turf following settlement11,60, cages were stocked with a supply of turf-covered coral rubble that was replaced daily, ensuring both shelter and constant food availability. Fish were subsequently sampled on d2, d5, and d8, post collection to examine sensory development, behavior (response to sensory cues), and survival (predation test). Twelve in situ cages were used, and the use of any given cage was randomized prior each experiment.
Increased temperature and chlorpyrifos (CPF) exposures: fish husbandry and treatments
Following collection, d0 fish were maintained in groups of ten individuals at the CRIOBE Marine Research Station. Each group was held in a 30 L × 20 W × 20 H-cm aquaria containing 12 L of filtered (1-µm filter) seawater. All tanks were subject to a 12:12 h light–dark cycle (06:00–18:00 light period) and oxygenated with an air stone. Twelve aquaria were used (six for exposures to increased temperatures only, and six for exposures with CPF), and the use of any given aquarium was randomized prior each experiment.
For increased temperature treatments, seawater was in an open system, and water temperature was maintained at either 28.5 °C, 30.0 °C or 31.5 °C. 28.5 °C was chosen as the basal temperature as this was the mean temperature in the Moorea lagoon at the time of the study, and corresponds to the mean annual lagoon temperature in this region (http://observatoire.criobe.pf). Subsequent increases of +1.5 °C and +3.0 °C were selected, as these are in line with end-of-century projections for tropical Pacific sea surface temperatures37. Fresh coral rubble was added to the tanks and replaced each day to provide both food and shelter. Heaters controlled by thermostats were used to maintain the temperature treatments. Before the experiment, each tank was in open circuit with temperature maintained at 28.5 °C. At the beginning of the experiment, fish were introduced in the aquarium, and the thermostat temperature was then set up to 28.5 °C, 30.0 °C or 31.5 °C according to the treatment. The temperature of interest was reached within 2 h. Temperature in each tank was then visually checked (on the thermostat controller) at least five times per day, and never differed from the target temperature by more than 0.2 °C.
For CPF exposure, five different treatments were applied: unaltered seawater (control), seawater with acetone at a final concentration of 1:1.000.000 (CPF0, solvent control treatment, as CPF was made soluble using acetone), or seawater with CPF at a nominal concentration of either 1, 5, or 30 μg L−1 (CPF1, CPF5, and CPF30 treatments), based on the findings of recent studies of reef fishes exposed to CPF11,14,65. CPF was spiked in each tank from dilutions that were prepared in advance: 1 µg µL−1, 5 µg µL−1, and 30 µg µL−1. From these dilutions, 12 µL were pipetted and spiked in the 12-L exposure tanks, therefore reaching nominal concentrations of 1 µg L−1, 5 µg L−1, and 30 µg L−1. Similarly, 12 µL of acetone was spiked in the tank for the CPF0 condition. Spike was allowed to mix for 2 min (water mixing due to the air stone) before fish were introduced in the tank. At the end of the 32-h exposure, CPF concentrations in the water or in the fish tissues were not evaluated, as we were only interested in the effects of CPF spikes on fish metamorphic processes. Nevertheless, a previous study using similar methods and nominal concentrations of similar magnitude (i.e., ranging from 4 to 64 µg L−1) measured CPF levels corresponding to 80% of nominal concentrations after 24 h66, therefore suggesting a good stability of CPF levels in the condition of our study. Environmentally, these nominal concentrations represent high (CPF1) to extremely high (CPF30) exposures, as recorded contamination concentration in Australian and North American surface waters are generally below 1 µg L−1, with a few high outliers reaching up to 26 µg L−153. However, this shows that concentrations of up to 30 µg L−1 are possible on a short timescale (such as the 32-h exposure of this study), in particular in coastal and shallow areas such as fish nurseries. Aquaria used for CPF exposure treatments and associated controls were not equipped with coral rubble to prevent potential interaction with the pesticide11. This may explain the delay in trunk canal development observed in control fish from the CPF exposure treatments compared with control fish from the increased temperature treatments and control fish from the TH treatments (Figs. 1g and 3e). Water was replaced each day to ensure the maintenance of CPF concentrations11.
For combined increased temperature and CPF exposure treatments, fish were also maintained without coral rubble with water replaced daily.
For treatments where fish were exposed to an anthropogenic stressor and provided with supplemental T3, fish were maintained in either the elevated temperature or CPF exposure treatments as described above, but were also injected with either T3 (T3 treatment) or with DMSO (control, to control for solvent and injection). These injections were done as described above (thyroid hormone signaling experiment: control, T3- and N3-treatments).
Sample preparation and fish measurements
For thyroid hormone quantifications and histological analyses, fish were first euthanized in freshly prepared MS222 at 0.4 mg ml−1 in filtered seawater at 4 °C, and instantly placed on ice. Following euthanasia, all fish except those for histological analyses were weighed (W) then placed on a scale bar and photographed for standardized measurements (e.g., height (H) and standard length (SL)). These measurements were used to calculate Fulton’s condition factor K = 100*(W/SL3) (with SL, in cm, and W, in g) for each individual67. Weight measurements were performed using a precision balance (Ohaus Adventurer Precision), and length measurements were taken using the imageJ software.
The retina is the light-sensitive tissue within the eye, and is composed of different cell layers organized ventrally and dorsally around the optic nerve (Fig. 1c). To analyze the retina’s cell layers, we removed the head region of euthanized fish in a way that allowed us to distinguish the right retina from the left retina, and the dorsal and ventral sides of the retina. This region was then fixed in Bouin solution before being embedded in paraffin for microtome sectioning (5 µm). Sections were then stained using hematoxylin and eosin. We chose cross-sections of the retina that were done at similar depth by selecting sections at the level of the optical nerve (Supplementary Fig. 5a). These sections enabled us to identify different cell segments, types, and layers, among which (i) photoreceptor external segments (perceiving light signals), (ii) photoreceptor nuclei, (iii) bipolar cells (which integrate the synaptic signals originating from the photoreceptors), and (iv) ganglion cells (which integrate signals from bipolar cells and create action potential toward the optic nerve) were easily distinguishable (Supplementary Fig. 5b). We only investigated the right eye of A. triostegus fish, as evidence suggests this species is visually lateralized at recruitment, and predominantly uses its right eye to examine visual predator stimuli14. Also, we only examined the dorsal side of the retina, as the ventral side (vs) was shown to not undergo change at metamorphosis in another coral-reef fish species, the goatfish Upeneus tragula13 (Supplementary Fig. 5a). To compare the developmental state of the retina between treatments, we looked at the peripheral area of the dorsal side (see the dotted square in Supplementary Fig. 5a, magnified in Supplementary Fig. 5b) as settlement-stage individuals in another acanthurid species (Naso brevirostris) showed weak if any spatial specialization of the retina, in particular on this axis68. We prioritized the examination of bipolar cell densities as important changes in bipolar cell density was observed during U. tragula metamorphosis13. However, we also examined the densities of photoreceptor external segments, photoreceptor nuclei, and ganglion cells along metamorphosis and across TH treatments, revealing for photoreceptor external segments (Supplementary Fig. 6) and nuclei (Supplementary Fig. 7) a TH-dependent density increase at metamorphosis, while ganglion cells showed no density variation during metamorphosis (Supplementary Fig. 8). Cell counting was performed in a 50-µm wide area perpendicular to the retina cell layers (Supplementary Fig. 5b). The measure of bipolar cell density corresponds to the number of bipolar cells per 0.001 mm² in the inner-nuclear cell layer (INL), after measuring the mean thickness of this INL (average of three measurements at random non-overlapping locations within the 50-µm wide area) (Supplementary Fig. 5b). The prn and ggc densities were obtained in a similar manner after measuring the mean width of their respective cell layer. Pes density corresponds to the exact number of pes in the 50-µm wide area as the pes cell layer is monocellular (Supplementary Fig. 5b). Cells that were located on the edges of the 50-µm wide area were included in the counts.
Olfactory organ lamellae
In fish, the olfactory organ is a fluid-filled blind sac that contains the ciliated sensory epithelium, which forms a rosette comprise of a number of folds, i.e., lamellae44. In A. triostegus, the left and right olfactory organs can be found in two cavities on the dorsal surface, between the eye and the snout edge, with water moving through each cavity from the anterior nostril to the posterior nostril (Supplementary Fig. 3). Pictures (e.g., Supplementary Fig. 3) were obtained using SEM microscopy following specialized tissue preparation involving the dissection of the olfactory organ (removal of the thin skin layer between the two nostrils) and fixation in a sodium cacodylate + glutaraldehyde solution (2.5% glutaraldehyde in 1 M sucrose and 0.1 M sodium cacodylate, pH 7.4) for a week at 4 °C. Samples were then washed (10% sucrose in 0.1 M sodium cacodylate solution, pH 7.4) 15 × 15 min at room temperature (RT). Samples were then dehydrated using successive ethanol (EtOH) baths (30%, 50%, 70%, 85%, 95%, 100%, 100%, 100%, each time during 15 min at RT). Samples were then placed in EtOH:HMDS (1:1) 15 min at RT, in 100% HMDS for 15 min at RT, and lastly in 100% HMDS for 30 min at RT. HMDS was used to replace critical point drying. Samples were not metalized. SEM pictures were obtained using a MiniMEB Hitachi TM3030 (University of French Polynesia). Given that lamellae are well formed and have a macroscopic size in A. triostegus at recruitment, lamellae counting was performed on tissues samples identically prepared, but observed under a simple binocular stereomicroscope. Lamellae counting was performed on both left and right olfactory organs to then have a measure of the average number of lamellae per olfactory organ. In the case where one of the left or right olfactory organ was damaged and thus accurate lamellae counts were not possible, we used the count from the other olfactory organ as the average number, as no significant difference was observed between the number of lamellae in the left and right olfactory organs in our preliminary observations.
Lateral line trunk canal pores
The lateral line system enables fish to detect water motions and pressure gradients, such as those caused by other fish (e.g., movement from other fish in the shoal or predator strikes). It is composed of superficial and canal neuromast receptor organs, which are the functional units of the lateral line system and are ciliary sensory organs, composed of hair cells, like those in the inner ear, located either on the skin or embedded in lateral line canals43. Canal neuromasts are found in the epithelium lining the bottom of the lateral line canals, and one canal neuromast is usually found within the short canal segments between two adjacent canal pores43. The development of neuromasts and the morphogenesis of lateral line canals and their pores initiate in late-stage larvae and continue through metamorphosis43. Counting the number of pores on the trunk canal is thus an appropriate way to rapidly characterize the development of the lateral line system when one cannot perform more advanced histological analyzes of the neuromasts. In d0 to d8 A. triostegus at recruitment, a fully formed trunk canal corresponding to a complete arched canal can be observed on each of the fish body flanks (Supplementary Fig. 4a). At this stage, A. triostegus does not exhibit scales69, and the trunk canal is therefore only composed of soft tissue (Supplementary Fig. 4a). Following the same preparation protocol as used for olfactory organs, we investigated the development of the lateral line system of A. triostegus by counting the number of pores on the trunk canal (Supplementary Fig. 4a-b). Counting was performed either on the left or the right side of the body, depending on tissue preservation. Indeed, as fish body frequently curved when dried to a critical point in HMDS, only one side of the body was generally accessible for counting trunk canal pores. We did not consider this an issue, as preliminary observations revealed no significant difference between the numbers of trunk canal pores present on the left or right flanks of the body. Variation in the number of pores cannot be attributed to variation in the length of the fully formed trunk canal (measured from the vicinity of the head to the base of the tail) as it does not change in A. triostegus during metamorphosis (Supplementary Fig. 9).
Thyroid hormone quantification
TH was extracted from frozen fish, following an extraction protocol adapted from previous studies70,71,72, including on coral-reef fishes11. Fish were individually crushed in 500 µl of methanol using a Minilys and glass beads (3*30 s, 5.000 rpm), centrifuged at 4 °C (10 min, 12.000 rpm), and supernatant reserved. These operations were performed twice, then fish were crushed one last time with 400 µl of methanol, 100 µl of chloroform, and 100 µl of barbital buffer (3*30 s, 5.000 rpm, RT), centrifuged at 4 °C (10 min, 12.000 rpm), and supernatant reserved. Pooled supernatants were then dried at 70 °C for 2 h. Dried pellets were re-suspended in 400 µl of methanol, 100 µl of chloroform, and 100 µl of barbital buffer, centrifuged at 4 °C (20 min, 12.000 rpm), and supernatant reserved. The same operation was again performed on the pellets. Pooled supernatants were once again dried out at 70 °C for 2 h with the final extract reconstituted in 2 ml of PBS 1× for quantification (Roche Elica kit on a Cobas analyzer, following the manufacturer’s standardized method). TH levels in pg g−1 of fish were then transformed into relative levels by selecting the respective control fish as standards in the increased temperature and CPF exposure treatment experiments.
A two-channel chemical choice flume73,74,75 was used to assess the responses of A. triostegus towards chemical predator cues (Supplementary Fig. 10). Each trial presented an individual fish with two water sources: control seawater (Ø = UV-sterilized and 1-µm filtered seawater from the collection site) vs “seawater containing chemical cues from predator” (P = UV-sterilized and 1-µm filtered seawater from the collection site in which five Lutjanus fulvus predators were soaked, into a 125-L tank, for 2 h prior to the experiment). Water was fed into the flume through two water inlets, with equivalent flow rates of 100 ml min−1 maintained using flow meters (MM Minimaster, Admi-France). This rate ensured laminar flow of each water source was maintained in parallel while allowing fish to swim naturally between the two water sources. Fine mesh and collimators also helped to ensure laminar flow of each water source was maintained75. Preliminary experiments were conducted to ensure the absence of unanticipated biased behavior within the two-channel flume (e.g., preference for one side of the flume over the other, irrespectively of the water sources, or preference for the drain area over the choice area). Prior to each trial, dye tests were conducted to confirm laminar flow, without eddies or areas of water mixing, within the choice area. After releasing the fish in the middle of the choice area, a 2-min acclimation period was observed, then fish position (left or right part of the choice area, or drain area) was recorded every 2 s for 5 min (Supplementary Fig. 10), using a camera (GoPro Hero 2) located above the edge of the flume tank. Water inlets were then switched (to account for any side preference due to fish’s immobility) followed by another 2-min acclimation period. A second 5-min test period followed, during which fish position was again assessed every 2 s. Preference or avoidance of water sources, and the absence of a side preference, were confirmed by comparing responses during the first and second 5-min test periods. These experiments were performed in the dark with red light, to limit potential visual perturbations such as the presence of an observer and to allow comparison between d2 and d0 fish, as d0 fish were tested immediately after collection (i.e., at night) as this is when they are actively moving from the ocean to the reef, and is thus the most biologically relevant time to do so. Fish that did not swim actively during the first acclimation period were removed from the analysis (n = 3) to prevent side preference bias. However, all remaining fish swam actively between the two water sources after water inlets were switched (either during the second acclimation period or during the second test period), ensuring no continuous side bias due to immobility. Fish that spent more than 50% of the test time in the drain area (i.e., where the two water sources mix) were also removed from the analysis (n = 4) as we considered that they did not show any particular preference or avoidance for any of the two water sources. Fish that did not make a clear choice between the two water sources but spent more than 50% of the time in the choice area were included in the analysis. This was done as we wanted to assess fish preference as well as the absence of preference.
A double-choice tank was used to assess the responses of A. triostegus in the presence of a visual predator cues. Each trial presented an individual fish with a choice of two visual stimuli, each contained in a separate aquarium placed at the end of the central rectangular choice tank. These were an aquarium, containing a 10-cm (standard length) L. fulvus (P condition) vs an empty aquarium, equipped with an air stone (Ø condition) (Supplementary Fig. 11). Fish were first placed into the central “no choice” area of the choice tank for a 2-min acclimation period. During this time, fish were not able to see the contents of either adjacent aquaria or access the “choice” areas of the choice tank as opaque panels were positioned at the edges of the “no choice” area (see the dotted lines in Supplementary Fig. 11). Following the acclimation period, the opaque panels were removed, allowing fish to observe the visual stimuli in the adjacent aquaria through the transparent walls of the choice tank and to access the choice areas. Fish position (i.e., choice area 1, no choice area, choice area 2; Supplementary Fig. 11) was then assessed every 2 s over a 10 min, using a camera (GoPro Hero 2) to limit any external visual disturbances such as an observer’s presence. The camera was located above the choice tank. Location of visual stimulus (left or right side of the double-choice tank) was switched between each fish to ensure the absence of a side preference. Fish that remained immobile and spent >50% of the test time in the “no choice” area were removed from the analysis (n = 11), as we considered that they did not show any particular preference or avoidance for any of the two visual stimuli.
The survival tests presented in Figs. 2c, 3f were conducted in an arena set up in situ in a nursery lagoon area of the north coast (S17°29'7.0272″, W149°49'51.1166″). The arena consisted of a 1-m3 cage with a hard bottom covered with sand and coral rubble and four lateral walls made from 5-mm fine mesh (Supplementary Fig. 12). Each trial consisted of 45 fishes, with 15 from each treatment group. Fish from each treatment group were tagged with a specific color using visible implant fluorescent filament (Northwest Marine Technology) 2 h prior being released into the arena. For each trial, all fishes were released simultaneously and allowed to acclimate for 30 min before the introduction of six L. fulvus (15–20 cm SL). After 2 h, predators were removed, and surviving A. triostegus was identified to treatment using their color tag. Color tags attributed to each fish group were randomly switched between each replicate to ensure no predation bias based on tag color. Differences in survival during this predation test cannot be attributed to variation in fish size or condition between treatments, as these did not differ significantly between groups (Supplementary Fig. 13).
All statistical analyses were conducted using R version 3.5.376. Conway–Maxwell–Poisson (COM-Poisson) generalized linear models (GLM) were used to assess if pharmacological and anthropogenic stressor treatments influenced the number of lamellae, the number of trunk canal pores, and the number of survivors to the predation experiment77. COM-Poisson GLM were also used to assess if pharmacological treatments influenced the number of photoreceptor external segments. Linear models (LM) were used to assess if pharmacological treatments influenced the bipolar cell, ganglion cell, and photoreceptor nuclei densities, and if pharmacological and anthropogenic stressor treatments influenced fish Fulton’s K condition factor. LM were also used to assess if the trunk canal length varied with age. Gamma generalized linear mixed-effect models (GLMEM) were used to assess if anthropogenic stressor exposures influenced TH levels and T3/T4 ratios78. TH level or T3/T4 ratios were used as the dependent variable, and replicate was included as a random factor to account for differences in TH levels only due to the two different Cobas analyzers that were used in the two different years. As preliminary experiments provided no evidence that season and lunar phase affected T3 levels in metamorphosing A. triostegus, we did not include them in our analyses (Gamma GLMEM, Supplementary Fig. 14). For each model, diagnostic plots were examined and outputs compared with raw data to confirm goodness-of-fit and residual homoscedasticity, and, when applicable, residual normality was assessed using Shapiro–Wilk normality test. Paired t tests or Wilcoxon signed-rank tests were used to assess whether fish spent more time in the no cue choice area vs predator-cue choice area, depending on residual normality (Shapiro–Wilk normality test).
Further information on research design is available in the Nature Research Reporting Summary linked to this article.
R-code for statistical analyses and figure construction is available at: https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.3742258. Source data are provided with this paper.
Best, J. Anthropogenic stresses on the world’s big rivers. Nat. Geosci. 12, 7–21 (2018).
Hoegh-Guldberg, O. & Bruno, J. F. The impact of climate change on the world’s marine ecosystems. Science 328, 1523–1529 (2010).
Oliver, E. C. J. et al. Longer and more frequent marine heatwaves over the past century. Nat. Commun. 9, 1–12 (2018).
Bernhardt, E. S., Rosi, E. J. & Gessner, M. O. Synthetic chemicals as agents of global change. Front. Ecol. Environ. 15, 84–90 (2017).
Noyes, P. D. et al. The toxicology of climate change: environmental contaminants in a warming world. Environ. Int. 35, 971–986 (2009).
Noyes, P. D. & Lema, S. C. Forecasting the impacts of chemical pollution and climate change interactions on the health of wildlife. Curr. Zool. 61, 669–689 (2015).
Pinsky, M. L., Eikeset, A. M., McCauley, D. J., Payne, J. L. & Sunday, J. M. Greater vulnerability to warming of marine versus terrestrial ectotherms. Nature 569, 108–111 (2019).
Laudet, V. The origins and evolution of vertebrate metamorphosis. Curr. Biol. 21, R726–R737 (2011).
Wu, P. P. Y. et al. Timing anthropogenic stressors to mitigate their impact on marine ecosystem resilience. Nat. Commun. 8, 1–10 (2017).
McMenamin, S. K. & Parichy, D. M. Metamorphosis in teleosts. in (Yun-Bo Shi (ed)) Current Topics in Developmental Biology, Vol. 103, 127–165 (Academic Press, 2013). https://doi.org/10.1016/B978-0-12-385979-2.00005-8.
Holzer, G. et al. Fish larval recruitment to reefs is a thyroid hormone-mediated metamorphosis sensitive to the pesticide chlorpyrifos. eLife 6, 1–22 (2017).
Lecchini, D., Osenberg, C. W., Shima, J. S. St, Mary, C. M. & Galzin, R. Ontogenetic changes in habitat selection during settlement in a coral reef fish: ecological determinants and sensory mechanisms. Coral Reefs 26, 423–432 (2007).
McCormick, M. I. & Shand, J. Metamorphosis of the visual and barbel sensory systems at settlement in the reef fish Upeneus tragula (family Mullidae). Proc. Seventh Int. Coral Reef. Symp. 1, 616–623 (1992).
Besson, M. et al. Exposure to agricultural pesticide impairs visual lateralization in a larval coral reef fish. Sci. Rep. 7, 1–9 (2017).
Fobert, E. K. & Swearer, S. E. The nose knows: linking sensory cue use, settlement decisions, and post-settlement survival in a temperate reef fish. Oecologia 183, 1041–1051 (2017).
Goatley, C. H. R. & Bellwood, D. R. Body size and mortality rates in coral reef fishes: a three-phase relationship. Proc. R. Soc. B Biol. Sci. 283, 20161858 (2016).
O’Connor, J. J., Fobert, E. K., Besson, M., Jacob, H. & Lecchini, D. Live fast, die young: behavioural and physiological impacts of light pollution on a marine fish during larval recruitment. Mar. Pollut. Bull. 146, 908–914 (2019).
Allan, B. J. M., Domenici, P., Munday, P. L. & McCormick, M. I. Feeling the heat: the effect of acute temperature changes on predator-prey interactions in coral reef fish. Conserv. Physiol. 3, 1–8 (2015).
McLeod, I. M. et al. Latitudinal variation in larval development of coral reef fishes: Implications of a warming ocean. Mar. Ecol. Prog. Ser. 521, 129–141 (2015).
McLeod, I. M. et al. Climate change and the performance of larval coral reef fishes: the interaction between temperature and food availability. Conserv. Physiol. 1, 1–12 (2013).
Ferrari, M. C. O. et al. Putting prey and predator into the CO2 equation—qualitative and quantitative effects of ocean acidification on predator-prey interactions. Ecol. Lett. 14, 1143–1148 (2011).
Ferrari, M. C. O. et al. Effects of ocean acidification on visual risk assessment in coral reef fishes. Funct. Ecol. 26, 553–558 (2012).
Simpson, S. D. et al. Anthropogenic noise increases fish mortality by predation. Nat. Commun. 7, 1–7 (2016).
Gordon, T. A. C. et al. Habitat degradation negatively affects auditory settlement behavior of coral reef fishes. Proc. Natl Acad. Sci. USA 115, 5193–5198 (2018).
Johansen, J. L., Allan, B. J. M., Rummer, J. L. & Esbaugh, A. J. Oil exposure disrupts early life-history stages of coral reef fishes via behavioural impairments. Nat. Ecol. Evol. 1, 1146–1152 (2017).
Goldenberg, S. U. et al. Ecological complexity buffers the impacts of future climate on marine consumers. Nat. Clim. Chang 8, 229–233 (2018).
Theodosiou, L., Hiltunen, T. & Becks, L. The role of stressors in altering eco-evolutionary dynamics. Funct. Ecol. 33, 73–83 (2019).
Domenici, P., Allan, B. J. M., Lefrançois, C. & Mccormick, M. I. The effect of climate change on the escape kinematics and performance of fishes: implications for future predator-prey interactions. Conserv. Physiol. 7, 1–22 (2019).
Tobler, M. & Culumber, Z. W. Swimming in polluted waters. Science 354, 1232–1233 (2016).
Nilsson, G. E. et al. Near-future carbon dioxide levels alter fish behaviour by interfering with neurotransmitter function. Nat. Clim. Chang 2, 201–204 (2012).
Wada, H. Glucocorticoids: Mediators of vertebrate ontogenetic transitions. Gen. Comp. Endocrinol. 156, 441–453 (2008).
Carr, J. A. & Patiño, R. The hypothalamus-pituitary-thyroid axis in teleosts and amphibians: Endocrine disruption and its consequences to natural populations. Gen. Comp. Endocrinol. 170, 299–312 (2011).
Defo, M. A. et al. RNA-sequencing to assess the health of wild yellow perch (Perca flavescens) populations from the St. Lawrence River, Canada. Environ. Pollut. 243, 1657–1668 (2018).
Wilson, A. D. M. & Krause, J. Metamorphosis and animal personality: a neglected opportunity. Trends Ecol. Evol. 27, 529–531 (2012).
Gothié, J.-D., Demeneix, B. & Remaud, S. Comparative approaches to understanding thyroid hormone regulation of neurogenesis. Mol. Cell. Endocrinol. 459, 104–115 (2017).
Hu, Y. et al. Thyroid hormone coordinates developmental trajectories but does not underlie developmental truncation in danionins. Dev. Dyn. 248, 1144–1154 (2019).
IPCC. Climate Change 2014: Synthesis Report (IPCC, Geneva, Switzerland, 2014).
Baumann, L., Segner, H., Ros, A., Knapen, D. & Vergauwen, L. Thyroid hormone disruptors interfere with molecular pathways of eye development and function in zebrafish. Int. J. Mol. Sci. 20, 1543 (2019).
Shand, J. Ontogenetic changes in retinal structure and visual acuity: a comparative study of coral-reef teleosts with differing post-settlement lifestyles. Environ. Biol. Fishes 49, 307–322 (1997).
Lara, M. R. Development of the nasal olfactory organs in the larvae, settlement-stages and some adults of 14 species of Caribbean reef fishes (Labridae, Scaridae, Pomacentridae). Mar. Biol. 154, 51–64 (2008).
Arvedlund, M., Munday, P. L. & Takemura, A. The morphology and ultrastructure of the peripheral olfactory organ in newly metamorphosed coral-dwelling gobies, Paragobiodon xanthosomus Bleeker (Gobiidae, Teleostei). Tissue Cell 39, 335–342 (2007).
Arvedlund, M. & Takemura, A. The importance of chemical environmental cues for juvenile Lethrinus nebulosus Forsskål (Lethrinidae, Teleostei) when settling into their first benthic habitat. J. Exp. Mar. Bio. Ecol. 338, 112–122 (2006).
Webb, J. F. Morphological diversity, development, and evolution of the mechanosensory lateral line system. in The Lateral Line System. Springer Handbook of Auditory Research, Vol 48 (eds Coombs, S., Bleckmann, H., Fay, R., Popper, A.) 17–72 (Springer, New York, NY, 2013).
Kasumyan, A. O. The olfactory system in fish: structure, function, and role in behavior. J. Ichthyol. 44, 180–223 (2004).
Little, A. G. & Seebacher, F. The evolution of endothermy is explained by thyroid hormone-mediated responses to cold in early vertebrates. J. Exp. Biol. 217, 1642–1648 (2014).
Slotkin, T. A., Cooper, E. M., Stapleton, H. M. & Seidler, F. J. Does thyroid disruption contribute to the developmental neurotoxicity of chlorpyrifos? Environ. Toxicol. Pharmacol. 36, 284–287 (2013).
De Angelis, S. et al. Developmental exposure to chlorpyrifos induces alterations in thyroid and thyroid hormone levels without other toxicity signs in CD-1 mice. Toxicol. Sci. 108, 311–319 (2009).
Little, A. G., Kunisue, T., Kannan, K. & Seebacher, F. Thyroid hormone actions are temperature-specific and regulate thermal acclimation in zebrafish (Danio rerio). BMC Biol. 11, 26 (2013).
Wernberg, T. et al. An extreme climatic event alters marine ecosystem structure in a global biodiversity hotspot. Nat. Clim. Chang 3, 78–82 (2012).
McCabe, R. M. et al. Temperature variability in a shallow, tidally isolated coral reef lagoon. J. Geophys. Res. 115, 1–17 (2010).
Fabricius, K. E. Effects of terrestrial runoff on the ecology of corals and coral reefs: review and synthesis. Mar. Pollut. Bull. 50, 125–146 (2005).
John, E. M. & Shaike, J. M. Chlorpyrifos: pollution and remediation. Environ. Chem. Lett. 13, 269–291 (2015).
The NRA Review of Chlorpyrifos. Section 6 Environmental Assessment. The NRA review of chlorpyrifos. Section 6, Environmental a ssessment. in NRA Review Series 00.5. 167–308 (National Registration Authority for Agricultural and Veterinary Chemicals, Canberra, Australia, 2000). https://apvma.gov.au/sites/default/files/publication/14736-chlorpyrifos-irr-summary.pdf.
Chernyak, S. M., Rice, C. P. & McConnell, L. L. Evidence of currently-used pesticides in air, ice, fog, seawater and surface microlayer in the Bering and Chukchi seas. Mar. Pollut. Bull. 32, 410–419 (1996).
Zhen, X., Liu, L., Wang, X., Zhong, G. & Tang, J. Fates and ecological effects of current-use pesticides (CUPs) in a typical river-estuarine system of Laizhou Bay, North China. Environ. Pollut. 252, 573–579 (2019).
Bigot, M. et al. Air-seawater exchange of organochlorine pesticides in the southern ocean between Australia and Antarctica. Environ. Sci. Technol. 50, 8001–8009 (2016).
Crane, H. M., Pickford, D. B., Hutchinson, T. H. & Brown, J. A. The effects of methimazole on development of the fathead minnow, Pimephales promelas, from embryo to adult. Toxicol. Sci. 93, 278–285 (2006).
Hale, R. & Swearer, S. E. Ecological traps: current evidence and future directions. Proc. R. Soc. B Biol. Sci. 283, 1–8 (2016).
Holstein, T. W. & Laudet, V. Life-history evolution: at the origins of metamorphosis. Curr. Biol. 24, R159–R161 (2014).
Randall, J. E. A contribution to the biology of the convict surgeonfish of the Hawaiian Islands, Acanthurus triostegus sandvicensis. Pac. Sci. XV, 215–272 (1961).
Besson, M. et al. Consistency in the supply of larval fishes among coral reefs in French Polynesia. PLoS One 12, 1–14 (2017).
Renko, K., Hoefig, C. S., Hiller, F., Schomburg, L. & Köhrle, J. Identification of iopanoic acid as substrate of type 1 deiodinase by a novel nonradioactive iodide-release assay. Endocrinology 153, 2506–2513 (2012).
Lim, W., Nguyen, N.-H., Yang, H. Y., Scanlan, T. S. & Furlow, J. D. A thyroid hormone antagonist that inhibits thyroid hormone action in vivo. J. Biol. Chem. 277, 35664–35670 (2002).
Figueira, A. C. M. et al. Analysis of agonist and antagonist effects on thyroid hormone receptor conformation by hydrogen/deuterium exchange. Mol. Endocrinol. 25, 15–31 (2011).
Bertucci, F. et al. Decreased retention of olfactory predator recognition in juvenile surgeon fish exposed to pesticide. Chemosphere 208, 469–475 (2018).
Botté, E. S., Jerry, D. R., Codi King S., Smith-Keune, C. & Negri, A. P. Effects of chlorpyrifos on cholinesterase activity and stress markers in the tropical reef fish Acanthochromis polyacanthus. Mar. Pollut. Bull. 65, 384–393 (2012).
Fulton, T. The rate of growth of fishes. Annu. Rep. Fish. Board Scotl. 3, 141–241 (1904).
Tettamanti, V., de Busserolles, F., Lecchini, D., Justin Marshall, N. & Cortesi, F. Visual system development of the spotted unicornfish, Naso brevirostris (Acanthuridae). J. Exp. Biol. 222, jeb209916 (2019).
Frédérich, B., Lecchini, D. & Vandewalle, P. Evidence of an original scale development during the settlement phase of a coral reef fish (Acanthurus triostegus). J. Appl. Ichthyol. 26, 176–178 (2010).
Tagawa, M. & Hirano, T. Changes in tissue and blood concentrations of thyroid hormones in developing chum salmon. Gen. Comp. Endocrinol. 76, 437–443 (1989).
Einarsdottir, I. E., Silva, N., Power, D. M., Smaradottir, H. & Bjornsson, B. T. Thyroid and pituitary gland development from hatching through metamorphosis of a teleost flatfish, the Atlantic halibut. Anat. Embryol. 211, 47–60 (2006).
Kawakami, Y., Nozaki, J., Seoka, M., Kumai, H. & Ohta, H. Characterization of thyroid hormones and thyroid hormone receptors during the early development of Pacific bluefin tuna (Thunnus orientalis). Gen. Comp. Endocrinol. 155, 597–606 (2008).
Gerlach, G., Atema, J., Kingsford, M. J., Black, K. P. & Miller-Sims, V. Smelling home can prevent dispersal of reef fish larvae. Proc. Natl Acad. Sci. USA 104, 858–863 (2007).
Atema, J., Kingsford, M. J. & Gerlach, G. Larval reef fish could use odour for detection, retention and orientation to reefs. Mar. Ecol. Prog. Ser. 241, 151–160 (2002).
Jutfelt, F., Sundin, J., Raby, G. D., Krång, A. S. & Clark, T. D. Two-current choice flumes for testing avoidance and preference in aquatic animals. Methods Ecol. Evol. 8, 379–390 (2017).
R Core Team. R: A Language and Environment for Statistical Computing. http://www.R-project.org/ (R Foundation for Statistical Computing, Vienna, Austria, 2020).
Sellers, K. F. & Shmueli, G. A flexible regression model for count data. Ann. Appl. Stat. 4, 943–961 (2010).
Bates, D., Mächler, M., Bolker, B. M. & Walker, S. C. Fitting linear mixed-effects models using lme4. J. Stat. Softw. 67, 1–48 (2015).
We thank Te-mana-o-te-moana, G. Iwankow, A. Morgan, C. Gache, L. Latry, J. Webb, and all CRIOBE and OOB people for their help in sampling, processing, or interpreting the data presented in this paper. The IAEA is grateful for the support provided to its Environment Laboratories by the Government of the Principality of Monaco. This research was supported by Agence Nationale de la Recherche (MANINI ANR19-CE34-0006-02) to D.L. and V.L., Contrat de Projet Etat-Polynésie française 2015-2020, LabEx Corail (Etape), PSL Environment (Pesticor), and Agence de l’eau (Rhone-Méditérranée-Corse n°2018-1765) to D.L., Fondation Bettencourt-Schueller to M.B., ANSES(2015/1/076) to V.L and by Griffith University and the Alexander von Humboldt Foundation to W.E.F.
The authors declare no competing interests
Peer review information Nature Communications thanks Sarah McMenamin and the other, anonymous, reviewers for their contribution to the peer review of this work. Peer reviewer reports are available.
Publisher’s note Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.
About this article
Cite this article
Besson, M., Feeney, W.E., Moniz, I. et al. Anthropogenic stressors impact fish sensory development and survival via thyroid disruption. Nat Commun 11, 3614 (2020). https://doi.org/10.1038/s41467-020-17450-8
This article is cited by
Coral Reefs (2023)
Environmental Science and Pollution Research (2022)
Developmental exposure to triclosan and benzophenone-2 causes morphological alterations in zebrafish (Danio rerio) thyroid follicles and eyes
Environmental Science and Pollution Research (2022)