Thank you for visiting nature.com. You are using a browser version with limited support for CSS. To obtain the best experience, we recommend you use a more up to date browser (or turn off compatibility mode in Internet Explorer). In the meantime, to ensure continued support, we are displaying the site without styles and JavaScript.

A magma ocean origin to divergent redox evolutions of rocky planetary bodies and early atmospheres

Abstract

Magma oceans were once ubiquitous in the early solar system, setting up the initial conditions for different evolutionary paths of planetary bodies. In particular, the redox conditions of magma oceans may have profound influence on the redox state of subsequently formed mantles and the overlying atmospheres. The relevant redox buffering reactions, however, remain poorly constrained. Using first-principles simulations combined with thermodynamic modeling, we show that magma oceans of Earth, Mars, and the Moon are likely characterized with a vertical gradient in oxygen fugacity with deeper magma oceans invoking more oxidizing surface conditions. This redox zonation may be the major cause for the Earth’s upper mantle being more oxidized than Mars’ and the Moon’s. These contrasting redox profiles also suggest that Earth’s early atmosphere was dominated by CO2 and H2O, in contrast to those enriched in H2O and H2 for Mars, and H2 and CO for the Moon.

Introduction

The redox condition of planetary bodies influences their chemical differentiation and governs the composition of overlying atmospheres1,2,3,4,5. For instance, to understand how bio-essential volatiles such as carbon and hydrogen were initially incorporated near Earth’s surface requires knowledge about the redox state during early stages of Earth’s history. A number of studies have shown that the uppermost mantle of present-day Earth is considerably oxidized (IW + 3.5, that is, 3.5 log units above the iron-wüstite buffer)6. Petrological evidence also suggests that such oxidized conditions formed early, 4.3–4.4 Ga ago7. Unlike Earth, the present-day Martian and Lunar mantles are considered to be much more reduced (~IW − 1)8,9,10,11.

These contrasting oxidization states may have been set up during the early phase of planetary formation when magma oceans (MOs) could have existed3,12. Such an MO involved mechanism has yet to be fully established because relevant redox controlling reactions are still poorly constrained in realistic magma ocean scenarios. Several studies have inferred the oxygen fugacity ($$f_{{\mathrm{O}}_{2}}$$) profile of silicate melts at high pressures using the experimental data at zero or relatively low pressures and is applicable only for shallow magma oceans13,14. The oxygen fugacity is a function of pressure, temperature, and composition, thus likely varying greatly within MOs that could have extended very deep, even covering the entire mantle regime.

Here, we study the redox controlling reactions in magma oceans by simulating silicate melts containing ferrous and ferric iron with first-principles molecular dynamics (FPMD) and perform thermodynamic modeling at pressures that cover the entire Earth’s mantle and temperatures up to 5000 K. The results suggest that ferric iron becomes increasingly energetically favorable with pressure mainly due to its small partial molar volume in silicate melts under large compression. Consequently, the magma oceans of Earth, Mars, and the Moon, if compositionally homogeneous due to vigorous mixing, would be characterized with a vertical gradient in oxygen fugacity. Specifically, a deeper magma ocean existing in the early Earth would have more oxidizing surface conditions compared with those of smaller bodies like Mars and the Moon. The contrasting surface conditions between these planetary bodies suggest that the early atmosphere in equilibrium with Earth’s surface may have been dominated by CO2 and H2O, in contrast to those enriched in H2O and H2 for Mars and H2 and CO for the Moon.

Results and discussion

Equations of state of silicate melts

At the base of a MO where metallic melts may pond before sinking into the core15, the oxygen fugacity is governed by the equilibrium between the metallic and silicate melts, and can be directly calculated given the compositions of these melts are known. Away from the base where metallicmeltis absent due to its rapid sinking velocity16, the MO redox state is controlled by the following redox buffering reaction3,17:

$${\mathrm{FeO}}\left( {{\mathrm{melt}}} \right)\;+\frac{1}{4}{{\mathrm{O}}_{2}}={{\mathrm{FeO}}_{1.5}}\left( {{\mathrm{melt}}} \right)$$
(1)

The thermodynamic behavior of the above reaction informs how oxygen fugacity varies with temperature and pressure. Taking the oxygen fugacity at the MO base as the boundary condition, one may, in principle, obtain the oxygen fugacity throughout the MO if the thermodynamic properties of the reactants and products in Eq. 1 are known. One key-parameter is the difference in molar volumes between FeO1.5 and FeO in the melts, ΔV. Its value has been directly measured only at 1 bar18 and also inferred from experiments performed up to 23 GPa and ~2500 K12,13,18,19,20,21,22,23. However, these conditions are still far from what are expected in MOs of Earth and Mars. Our goal is to calculate ΔV as a function of pressure, temperature, and composition so that we can constrain oxygen fugacity in the redox buffering Eq. (1) under directly applicable conditions. Moreover, we evaluate the MO redox states of Earth, Mars, and the Moon in order to understand their oxidation conditions of the present-day mantle and the chemistry of earliest atmosphere.

We first present the results from FPMD simulations of iron-bearing MgSiO3 liquids with iron in different valence states at 2000–4000 K and up to 140 GPa (Methods). The calculated pressure–volume–temperature (P–V–T) relationships can be described with the following equation:

$$P(V,T) \;=\; P\left( {V,T_0} \right)\; +\; B_{TH}(T\; -\; T_0)$$
(2)

Here $$P(V,T_0)$$ represents the reference isotherm at T0 = 3000 K using a fourth-order Birch-Murnaghan equation of state. The second term contains a thermal pressure coefficient, $$B_{{\mathrm{TH}}}\left( V \right) = \left[ {a \;-\; b\left( {\frac{V}{{V_0}}} \right)\; +\; c\left( {\frac{V}{{V_0}}} \right)^2} \right]/1000$$ where a, b, and c are constants for a given melt composition. The bulk moduli of the Fe2+ -bearing melts are systematically larger than those of the Fe3+ bearing melts (Supplementary Table 1). This means that the Fe3+ bearing melts are more compressible at the conditions investigated (Fig. 1), consistent with previous low-pressure studies18,24.

Using the pressure–volume results of simulated silicate melts for the same molar content of Fe3+ and Fe2+, we calculate the difference in molar volume (ΔV) between FeO1.5 and FeO in the melts as a function of pressure (Fig. 1). Our calculated value of ΔV at zero pressure agrees well with existing experimental data18,24 (Supplementary Fig. 1). As pressure increases, ΔV decreases rapidly initially in the low-pressure regime. Thereafter, ΔV increases slightly and then decreases gradually at higher pressures. The predicted non-monotonicpressure trend weakens at higher temperatures. For silicate melts of different iron contents (i.e., 12.5 and 25 mol%), ΔV takes slightly different values, showing a weak positive trend with iron content. This is consistent with the observed weak dependency of ΔV on the melt composition18. Our results thus show that ΔV remains positive at all pressures up to 140 GPa irrespective of temperature and composition. This finding contradicts previous inferences that ΔV would keep on decreasing and eventually become negative within the pressure range of Earth’s mantle3,12.

Previous models on ΔV either adopt a bulk modulus derivative of 4 or use an equation of state fit to experimental data within a limited pressure range12,13,14,23. We compare model values with our calculated results for silicate melts of 12.5 mol% iron, as these models are designed for Earth’s relevant composition (Supplementary Fig. 1). At low pressures (<10 GPa), our results are in good agreement with the recent model by ref. 12, both showing a sharp decrease of ΔV at low pressures, whereas at higher pressures, our results are in better line with other earlier models13,14,23, all showing that ΔV gradually levels out. These ΔV differences arise mainly due to the different pressure dependencies of the incompressibility () of FeO1.5 and FeO in silicate melts adopted by the previous studies. Our 4th order Birch-Murnaghan fit yields a lightly larger for FeO1.5 (4.6) than that of FeO (3.3). Previous studies other than ref. 12 assume of FeO1.5 and FeO to be 4, thus exhibiting similar pressure dependency of ΔV to our study. The contrasting behavior of ΔV from ref. 12 is caused by drastically different values, 1.3 and 8, respectively, for FeO1.5 and FeO. These extreme values of are not consistent with other experimental studies on silicate melts for which is 3–825,26 and on FeO liquid for which is 3–427,28. The reason for this inconsistency is, however, unclear. Our analysis of the coordination environment of iron in the silicate melts shows that the mean Fe–O coordination increases rapidly initially with pressure and more gradually at pressures beyond 40 GPa (Supplementary Fig. 2). This pressure trend is similar to that of ΔV. This implies an inherent correlation between the local iron-oxygen bonding environment in the silicate melt and ΔV.

We stress that our first-principles results make no assumption on the value of of FeO1.5 and FeO, so they are directly applicable over the entire mantle regime of Earth. To explore this implication further, we evaluate ΔV along two representative magma ocean thermal profiles referred to as “cold” and “hot” hereafter (Supplementary Fig. 3). The calculated ΔV varies considerably but remains positive over wide ranges of pressure and temperature of magma ocean relevance (Supplementary Fig. 4), thus indicating a positive contribution of pressure to $$f_{{\mathrm{O}}_2}$$.

Redox profiles

Our calculated ΔV profiles along the magma ocean thermal profiles are used to assess the redox state of magma oceans of relevance to Earth, Mars, and the Moon. We assume that the MOs are fully convective and well-mixed, resulting in a homogeneous Fe3+ to the total Fe ratio (Fe3+/ΣFe)3. The thermodynamic relationship for the reaction (1) is

$$- \frac{{\Delta G_r^0\left( {P_0,T} \right)\; + \;\mathop {\smallint }\nolimits_{P_0}^P \Delta V\left( {P,T} \right)dP}}{{RT}} = \;{\mathrm{ln}}\frac{{X_{{\mathrm{FeO}}_{1.5}}^{{\mathrm{melt}}}}}{{X_{{\mathrm{FeO}}}^{{\mathrm{melt}}}}} \\ +\, {\mathrm{ln}}\frac{{\gamma _{{\mathrm{FeO}}_{1.5}}^{{\mathrm{melt}}}}}{{\gamma _{{\mathrm{FeO}}}^{{\mathrm{melt}}}}}\; - \;\frac{1}{4}{\mathrm{ln}} \, \,f_{{\mathrm{O}}_2},$$
(3)

where $$\Delta G_r^0\left( {P_0,T} \right)$$ is the free energy of the reaction (Eq.(1)) at reference pressure P0(1 bar) and temperature TX and γ are the molar fractions and activity coefficients of the Fe-oxide component, respectively, $$f_{{\mathrm{O}}_2}$$ is the oxygen fugacity, and R is the gas constant. The above equation has been widely used in many literatures3,12,13,23 and it suggests that the variation of $$f_{{\mathrm{O}}_2}$$ with pressure explicitly hinges on $$\Delta V$$ only. However, one should note that $$\Delta V(P,T)$$ not only depends on pressure and temperature but also implicitly on many extensive properties, including the configuration entropy, and excess enthalpy. We first evaluate $$\Delta G_r^0\left( {P_0,T} \right)$$ for FeO1.5, FeO, and O2 as a function of temperature (Supplementary Fig. 5 and Supplementary Note 1). We then estimate the activity ratio $${\mathrm{ln}}\frac{{\gamma _{{\mathrm{FeO}}_{1.5}}^{{\mathrm{melt}}}}}{{\gamma _{{\mathrm{FeO}}}^{{\mathrm{melt}}}}}$$ by relating it to the interaction parameters between all the components following ref. 19. Moreover, the experimental results on ferric iron content (Fe3+/ΣFe) at various conditions (listed in Supplementary Table 2) are fit to the Eq. (3) to resolve the interaction parameters (Supplementary Table 3, Supplementary Fig. 6, Supplementary Note 2). We explore four different methods to fit the interaction parameters, but all models yield very similar redox profiles for MOs (Supplementary Fig. 7). We choose the one with smallest reduced chi-square as the best model and our predicted ferric iron contents (shown in Supplementary Fig. 8) are broadly consistent with the observations by both 1-bar experiments18,19,20,21,22 and the recent high-pressure experiments12,13,23 (Supplementary Note 3).

The redox gradients in MOs of Earth, Mars, and the Moon are calculated using Eq. (3) along a cold thermal profile where 2100 K is assumed to be temperature at the surface (Fig. 2). Similar results are obtained for a hot geotherm with the surface temperature set at 2500 K (Supplementary Fig. 9).The uncertainties of all the parameters in Eq. (3) are propagated to calculate the oxygen fugacity using LMFIT package29. We use ΔV of 12.5 mol% Fe in silicate melts as a representative value for Earth30 and the Moon31 and that of 25 mol% Fe for Mars32. This assumption is justified for given mantle compositions of these three planetary bodies (Supplementary Table 4) because of relatively small effects of iron content on ΔV (Fig. 1). We quantify the redox states in terms of oxygen fugacity relative to IW buffers, that is, ΔIW = log$$f_{{\mathrm{O}}_{2}}$$ − IW, where the reference IW is taken from ref. 33. Since the temperatures considered are higher than the temperature at which this IW buffer is calibrated, we extrapolate this buffer equation to high temperatures12,13. We also assume that the bases of MOs are at depths of 55 GPa34, 14 GPa35, and 5 GPa36, and the corresponding redox states (ΔIW) are −2, −1.5, and −2 for Earth, Mars, and the Moon, respectively13. These redox values are representatives for terrestrial bodies when the molten iron ponds are assumed to be in local equilibrium with the overlaying MOs13. The pressures considered here are based on the single stage model and the complete equilibrium between the silicate melt and iron melt. More general consideration of magma ocean depths is discussed below.

Along both thermal profiles considered, the absolute oxygen fugacities of the MOs of Earth, Mars, and the Moon all increase with depth, though more gradually at greater depths (Supplementary Fig. 9). This is expected because ΔV decreases with increasing pressure and always remains positive over the conditions we investigate. However, the relative oxygen fugacity (ΔIW) first increases slightly with pressure by ~0.3 log unit in the uppermost mantle and then gradually decreases with pressure throughout the rest of mantle (Fig. 2). Our results show that the upper mantle should have been relatively more oxidized. Therefore, an oxidized upper mantle is a natural consequence of a MO because the pressure- and temperature-dependent ΔV and $$\Delta G_r^0\left( {P_0,T} \right)$$ of the Eq. (3) make ferric iron increasingly stable at greater depths even at relatively reduced conditions (this raises Fe3+/ΣFe of silicate melts in equilibrium with metal alloy). Additionally, our derived redox profiles of Earth, Mars, and the Moon are nearly parallel owing to the similar ΔV values. They show that Earth is ~2 log units more oxidized than Mars which, in turn, is ~2 log units more oxidized than the Moon at the same depth. This order of relative redox states of the MOs of the early Earth, Mars, and the Moon coincides with that of their present-day mantles, implying a possible inheritance of present-day oxidation states of these planets from their early MOs.

The comparison between the predicted redox profile of the MO with that of the present-day mantle for each planet informs us how the MO stage influences the subsequent redox evolution of each planet throughout its history. The oxidation state of the uppermost mantle of the present-day Earth is near IW + 3.537 and has remained constant within 1.0 log unit since at least the early Archean6,7. Our predicted redox state of the uppermost MO of Earth is at the lower bound of present-day values. Likewise, the ferric iron content corresponding to this redox profile is 1.0–3.5%, overlapping with the lower end of the present-day ferric iron abundances of the upper mantle37. The predicted redox state and ferric iron content suggest that Earth’s oxidizing uppermost mantle is a natural outcome of the thermodynamic equilibrium across the deep MO during the MO stage. Secondary contributions may arise from other mechanisms, including disproportionation of Fe2+ in the lower mantle by crystallization of bridgmanite38,39, and/or late accretion of oxidized materials40,41. Compared to the silicate Earth, the Martian uppermost mantle is less oxidized with $$f_{{\mathrm{O}}_2}$$ ~IW11,42, which is consistent with our predicted redox state of the shallow Martian MO. This similarity may suggest negligible effects of subsequent tectonic processes and other oxidizing mechanisms mentioned above on the redox state of the Martian mantle43. Lunar basalts record oxygen fugacity ranging from IW to IW‒28,9,10 and our predicted redox state falls into the lower end of the observed values. Our predicted redox profiles differ considerably from those based on previous models (Fig. 2). Previous models have generally predicted relatively more reduced MOs of the Moon and Mars and either very reducing13 or very oxidizing MO of Earth12. It is important to note that the previously used data are limited with respect to pressure and temperature, for example, up to 3 GPa and 1673 K23, 7 GPa and 2023 K13, and 23 GPa and 2300 K12 (Supplementary Table 3).

We also investigate the effects of varying depth of the MOs on the redox states of the surface and equilibrium ferric iron content (Fig. 3 and Supplementary Fig. 10). The redox states of the MO bases (ΔIW) are assumed to be fixed at −2, −1.5, −2, respectively, for Earth, Mars, and the Moon. A deeper MO generally shifts upwards its oxygen fugacity profile at shallower depths (Fig. 3a). The redox states and ferric iron contents of the Lunar and Martian MOs are marginally affected due to their small sizes. In contrast, the Earth’s MO may have reached 25–90 GPa based on moderately siderophile elements abundances, assuming models for single or multi-stage core formation with partial or complete equilibrium between impactor and proto Earth34,44. The oxygen fugacity of Earth’s surface would decrease by ~1.5 log units if the base of MO moved upwards from 55 GPa to 25 GPa. Concurrently, Fe3+/ΣFe would also drop by a factor of two. An even deeper magma ocean may induce the spin transition of iron in the silicate melts. However, the effect of the spin transition on the oxygen fugacity is shown to be insignificant within the MO thermal profiles considered here (Methods and Supplementary Fig. 11). Note our assumption that the ferric iron distribution is homogeneous within the MO due to vigorous convection. However, this ferric iron content profile likely evolves during the solidification of the MO. The evolution is controlled by how the MO crystallizes and the partitioning of iron species between the melt and crystal, which are still poorly constrained. Nevertheless, our study suggests that the whole mantles of Earth and Mars could have been as enriched in ferric iron as the present-day upper mantle since the MO stage.

Chemistry of early atmospheres

The redox states of the MOs may have dictated the chemical speciation of the early atmospheres. For simplicity, we consider a case where the early atmosphere is at chemical equilibrium with the underlying MO3 and use the approach of ref. 45 to calculate the speciation of volatiles. Based on our results shown in Fig. 3, the redox state at the MO surface corresponds to ~IW + 2 for Earth, ~IW − 0.3 for Mars, and ~IW − 2 for the Moon. Assuming a simple C–O–H atmosphere with a mass H/C ratio of 0.5 at 1 bar and 1800 K, we show that the Earth’s early atmosphere would be enriched in H2O (~70 mol%) and CO2 (~15 mol%) but depleted in CO and H2. The early Martian atmosphere would consist of H2O and Hin almost equal amounts (each ~40 mol%), ~15 mol% CO, and ~5 mol% CO2. In contrast, the early lunar atmosphere would be enriched in H2 (>70 mol%) and CO (~20 mol%) and relatively depleted in H2O (10 mol%)3,45 (Fig. 4). These early atmospheres further evolve as the planets cool down. The speciation and mass of the atmosphere would likely change over time due to the thermodynamic re-equilibrium, hydrodynamic loss, as well as subsequent degassing and ingassing/regassing. Nevertheless, these distinct early atmospheric compositions may have fundamentally influenced the subsequent evolution of these terrestrial planets, including climate, magma ocean solidification, and the evolution of surficial conditions3,46.

The vertical gradient in the MO redox state predicted here may also apply to other rocky planets where MOs were once formed. For example, Earth’s sister planet Venus is of similar size and has similar iron content. The redox state of the post-MO upper mantle of Venus, to first order, may be similar to that of Earth and could be tested by future Venusian missions. In addition, super-Earths close to their host stars may have MOs extended to various depths and their atmospheres can potentially be detected in the near future with space telescope missions47.

Methods

Computational details

First-principles molecular dynamics (FPMD) simulations were carried out using the VASP software48 in the NVT-canonical ensemble with temperature controlled by a Nosé thermostat49. The projector augmented wave potentials50,51 were employed together with the generalized gradient approximation (GGA) to the exchange-correlation potential52. The plane-wave basis cutoff was set at 400 eV and Brillouin zone sampling was performed at the Gamma point. Pulay stress corrections were applied to the calculated pressures. We simulated Mg14Fe2Si16O48(ferrous) and Mg14Fe2Si16O49(ferric) melts for 12.5 mol% iron and Mg12Fe4Si16O48(ferrous) and Mg12Fe4Si16O50(ferric) melts for 25 mol% iron. Iron was set to be in high-spin state in all simulations. At each volume, the system was initially melted and thermalized at 6000 K, and then subsequently quenched down to desired lower temperatures of 4000, 3000, 2500, and 2000 K. Simulations were run for 10–30 picoseconds with time step of 1 femtosecond. Further details can be found in ref. 53.

Calculation of volume difference (ΔV)

The molar volume difference between FeO1.5 and FeO defined as $${\mathrm{\Delta }}V = V_{{\mathrm{FeO}}_{1.5}} - V_{{\mathrm{FeO}}}$$ is calculated as the volume difference between the ferric and ferrous iron-bearing silicate melts. Take the silicate melt with 12.5 mol% iron as an example. The volumes of Mg14Fe2Si16O48 and Mg14Fe2Si16O49 melts referred to as $$V_{{\mathrm{Mg}}_{14}{\mathrm{Fe}}_2{\mathrm{Si}}_{16}{\mathrm{O}}_{48}}$$ and $$V_{{\mathrm{Mg}}_{14}{\mathrm{Fe}}_2{\mathrm{Si}}_{16}{\mathrm{O}}_{49}}$$, respectively, are calculated at the same pressure and temperature conditions using the resolved equation of state parameters (Supplementary Table 1). These volumes can be related to the partial volumes of components by:

$$V_{{\mathrm{Mg}}_{14}{\mathrm{Fe}}_2{\mathrm{Si}}_{16}{\mathrm{O}}_{48}} = 14V_{{\mathrm{MgSiO}}_3} + 2V_{{\mathrm{FeO}}} + 2V_{{\mathrm{SiO}}_2} + V^{{\mathrm{E}},{\mathrm{reduced}}}$$
(4)

and

$$V_{{\mathrm{Mg}}_{14}{\mathrm{Fe}}_2{\mathrm{Si}}_{16}{\mathrm{O}}_{49}} = 14V_{{\mathrm{MgSiO}}_3} + 2V_{{\mathrm{FeO}}_{1.5}} + 2V_{{\mathrm{SiO}}_2} + V^{{\mathrm{E}},{\mathrm{oxidized}}},$$
(5)

where $$V^{{\mathrm{E}},{\mathrm{reduced}}}$$ and $$V^{{\mathrm{E}},{\mathrm{oxidized}}}$$ are the excess volumes for reduced and oxidized systems, respectively, and are sensitive to the amount of iron. Several previous low-pressure experiments show that the excess terms are small for silicate melts if Na2O, Al2O3, and TiO2 components are absent18,24. In this case, we can approximate ΔV by

$${\mathrm{\Delta }}V = V_{{\mathrm{FeO}}_{1.5}} - V_{{\mathrm{FeO}}} \approx \left( {V_{{\mathrm{Mg}}_{14}{\mathrm{Fe}}_2{\mathrm{Si}}_{16}{\mathrm{O}}_{49}} - V_{{\mathrm{Mg}}_{14}{\mathrm{Fe}}_2{\mathrm{Si}}_{16}{\mathrm{O}}_{48}}} \right)/2$$
(6)

Similarly, for 25 mol% iron content, we use

$${\mathrm{\Delta }}V = V_{{\mathrm{FeO}}_{1.5}} - V_{{\mathrm{FeO}}} \approx \left( {V_{{\mathrm{Mg}}_{12}{\mathrm{Fe}}_4{\mathrm{Si}}_{16}{\mathrm{O}}_{50}} - V_{{\mathrm{Mg}}_{12}{\mathrm{Fe}}_4{\mathrm{Si}}_{16}{\mathrm{O}}_{48}}} \right)/4.$$
(7)

By using the above equation to calculate ΔV, we assume that $$V^{{\mathrm{E}},{\mathrm{oxidized}}}$$ and $$V^{{\mathrm{E}},{\mathrm{reduced}}}$$ take small similar values so $$V^{{\mathrm{E}},{\mathrm{oxidized}}} - V^{{\mathrm{E}},{\mathrm{reduced}}} \approx 0$$. If $$V^{{\mathrm{E}},{\mathrm{oxidized}}} - V^{{\mathrm{E}},{\mathrm{reduced}}}$$ is a large non-zero value, one would expect that the ΔV differs significantly between the two compositions considered (12.5 and 25 mol% iron in silicate melts). However, our calculated results show that the ΔV values of 12.5 and 25 mol% iron contents differ slightly from each other and the difference diminishes especially at high pressures, which justifies our assumptions.

It should be noted that the small excess volume is not conflicted with the large Margules interaction parameters resolved for silicate melts. The excess volume is thermodynamically defined as $$V^{\mathrm{E}} = \left( {\frac{{\partial G_{{\mathrm{mix}}}}}{{\partial {\mathrm{P}}}}} \right)_{\mathrm{T}} = \left( {\frac{{\partial H_{{\mathrm{mix}}}}}{{\partial {\mathrm{P}}}}} \right)_{\mathrm{T}}$$, where Gmix and Hmix are the Gibbs free energy and enthalpy of mixing, respectively; P is pressure; and T is temperature. Hmix is a function of interaction parameter (W) and composition54. For a binary system with endmember components A and B, Hmix = WXAXB, where XA and XB are the molar fractions of A and B, respectively. Therefore, a small VE requires that the pressure derivative of the interaction parameter to be small but does not necessarily mean that the value of W is small. Indeed, both in this study and many other studies13,23, W is assumed to be pressure independent, which is in line with the assumption that VE is small.

Effects of spin transition of iron on $$\Delta V$$ and oxygen fugacity

Both ferric and ferrous irons undergo electronic spin transitions at high pressure as predicted by a recent FPMD study53. The high- to low-spin transition of Fe3+ and Fe2+ occurs gradually over pressure intervals centered around 90 and 110 GPa, respectively, at 3000 K. These transition pressures are higher than the maximum pressures of the magma oceans considered in this study (Fig. 2). As both Fe3+ and Fe2+ will be mostly in high-spin (HS) state at relevant magma ocean pressures, we evaluate the volume difference between FeO1.5 and FeO as $$\Delta V\; = \;V_{{\mathrm{HS}}}^{{\mathrm{FeO}}_{1.5}}\; -\; V_{{\mathrm{HS}}}^{{\mathrm{FeO}}}$$. However, all Fe3+ and Fe2+ will not undergo the HS-LS transition at a given condition. This means that the spin transition-induced changes in volume also contribute to our ΔV evaluation. We assess the spin effects on ΔV using the spin phase diagrams from Karki et al.53. Considering exact HS and LS distributions for both ferrous and ferric irons, we can evaluate the volume difference between FeO1.5 and FeO as

$$\Delta V_{{\mathrm{exact}}} \;= \;(V_{{\mathrm{HS}}}^{{\mathrm{FeO}}_{1.5}} \;-\; V_{{\mathrm{HS}}}^{{\mathrm{FeO}}})\; -\; n_{{\mathrm{LS}}}^{{\mathrm{Fe}}^{3 + }}(V_{{\mathrm{HS}}}^{{\mathrm{FeO}}_{1.5}} \;-\; V_{{\mathrm{LS}}}^{{\mathrm{FeO}}_{1.5}}) \\ + \;n_{{\mathrm{LS}}}^{{\mathrm{Fe}}^{2 + }}(V_{{\mathrm{HS}}}^{{\mathrm{FeO}}} \;-\; V_{{\mathrm{LS}}}^{{\mathrm{FeO}}}),$$
(8)

where $$V_{{\mathrm{HS}}}^{{\mathrm{FeO}}_{1.5}} - V_{{\mathrm{HS}}}^{{\mathrm{FeO}}} = \Delta V$$ has been rigorously constrained in this study. $$n_{{\mathrm{LS}}}^{{\mathrm{Fe}}^{3 + }}$$ and $$n_{{\mathrm{LS}}}^{{\mathrm{Fe}}^{2 + }}$$ represent the fractions of Fe3+and Fe2+ in low-spin (LS) state, respectively (satisfying the relations $$n_{{\mathrm{HS}}}^{{\mathrm{Fe}}^{3 + }} + n_{{\mathrm{LS}}}^{{\mathrm{Fe}}^{3 + }} = n_{{\mathrm{HS}}}^{{\mathrm{Fe}}^{2 + }} + n_{{\mathrm{LS}}}^{{\mathrm{Fe}}^{2 + }} = 1$$, where $$n_{{\mathrm{HS}}}^{{\mathrm{Fe}}^{3 + }}$$ and $$n_{{\mathrm{HS}}}^{{\mathrm{Fe}}^{2 + }}$$ represent the corresponding HS fractions) and their values as a function of pressure and temperature for silicate melt with 25% Fe can be found in ref. 53. Karki et al.53 also evaluated the $$V_{{\mathrm{HS}}}^{{\mathrm{FeO}}_{1.5}} - V_{{\mathrm{LS}}}^{{\mathrm{FeO}}_{1.5}}$$ and $$V_{{\mathrm{HS}}}^{{\mathrm{FeO}}} - V_{{\mathrm{LS}}}^{{\mathrm{FeO}}}$$ to be constant with respect to pressure within the computational uncertainties. At 3000 and 4000 K, $$V_{{\mathrm{HS}}}^{{\mathrm{FeO}}_{1.5}} - V_{{\mathrm{LS}}}^{{\mathrm{FeO}}_{1.5}} \approx$$1.25 cm3 mol−1and 1.00 cm3mol−1, respectively, and $$V_{{\mathrm{HS}}}^{{\mathrm{FeO}}} - V_{{\mathrm{LS}}}^{{\mathrm{FeO}}} \approx$$ 1.75 cm3 mol‒1 and 1.10 cm3 mol‒1, respectively53. We calculate the difference of $$\Delta V_{{\mathrm{exact}}}$$ and $$\Delta V$$ at 3000 and 4000 K as well as the difference of the oxygen fugacity using these two volume differences (Supplementary Fig. 11).

At pressures less than 60 GPa, we find that the deviation of the volume difference caused by considering the spin transition is less than 3%, so the oxygen fugacity does not change much when spin effects are included (Supplementary Fig. 11). With increasing pressure, the magnitude of (ΔVexact − ΔV) further increases and bounces back at around 100 GPa, at which the fraction of low-spin Fe3+ reaches around 50%. Note that at pressures greater than 80 GPa, the temperature of the MO is around 3500 K for a cold thermal profile and continues increasing with pressure. Therefore, the results at 4000 K are more relevant at these pressures. Overall, neglecting the spin transition of Fe tends to overestimate the oxygen fugacity, especially at high pressures. The maximum deviation occurs around 120 GPa, which is ~0.6 log units, comparable to the uncertainties of our model prediction (~0.5). Therefore, we consider the effects of spin transition of iron on the redox state of MOs to be mostly insignificant.

Data availability

Authors can confirm that all relevant data are included in the paper and/or its supplementary information files.

References

1. 1.

Armstrong, L. S., Hirschmann, M. M., Stanley, B. D., Falksen, E. G. & Jacobsen, S. D. Speciation and solubility of reduced C–O–H–N volatiles in mafic melt: Implications for volcanism, atmospheric evolution, and deep volatile cycles in the terrestrial planets. Geochim. Cosmochim. Acta 171, 283–302 (2015).

2. 2.

Stanley, B. D., Hirschmann, M. M. & Withers, A. C. Solubility of COH volatiles in graphite-saturated martian basalts. Geochim. Cosmochim. Acta 129, 54–76 (2014).

3. 3.

Hirschmann, M. M. Magma ocean influence on early atmosphere mass and composition. Earth Planet. Sci. Lett. 341–344, 48–57 (2012).

4. 4.

Wetzel, D. T., Rutherford, M. J., Jacobsen, S. D., Hauri, E. H. & Saal, A. E. Degassing of reduced carbon from planetary basalts. PNAS. 110, 8010–8013 (2013).

5. 5.

Dingwell, D. B. Redox viscometry of some Fe-bearing silicate melts. Am. Mineralogist 76, 1560–1562 (1991).

6. 6.

Li, Z.-X. A. & Lee, C.-T. A. The constancy of upper mantle fO2 through time inferred from V/Sc ratios in basalts. Earth Planet. Sci. Lett. 228, 483–493 (2004).

7. 7.

Trail, D., Watson, E. B. & Tailby, N. D. The oxidation state of Hadean magmas and implications for early Earth’s atmosphere. Nature 480, 79 (2011).

8. 8.

Wadhwa, M. Redox conditions on small bodies, the Moon and Mars. Rev. Mineral. Geochem. 68, 493–510 (2008).

9. 9.

Weitz, C. M., Rutherford, M. J. & Head, J. W. Oxidation states and ascent history of the Apollo 17 volcanic beads as inferred from metal-glass equilibria. Geochim. Cosmochim. Acta 61, 2765–2775 (1997).

10. 10.

Nicholis, M. G. & Rutherford, M. J. Graphite oxidation in the Apollo 17 orange glass magma: implications for the generation of a lunar volcanic gas phase. Geochim. Cosmochim. Acta 73, 5905–5917 (2009).

11. 11.

Herd, C. D. K., Papike, J. J. & Brearley, A. J. Oxygen fugacity of martian basalts from electron microprobe oxygen and TEM-EELS analyses of Fe-Ti oxides. Am. Mineralogist 86, 1015–1024 (2001).

12. 12.

Armstrong, K., Frost, D. J., McCammon, C. A., Rubie, D. C. & Boffa Ballaran, T. Deep magma ocean formation set the oxidation state of Earth’s mantle. Science 365, 903–906 (2019).

13. 13.

Zhang, H. L., Hirschmann, M. M., Cottrell, E. & Withers, A. C. Effect of pressure on Fe3+/ΣFe ratio in a mafic magma and consequences for magma ocean redox gradients. Geochim. Cosmochim. Acta 204, 83–103 (2017).

14. 14.

Schaefer, L. & Elkins-Tanton, L. T. Magma oceans as a critical stage in the tectonic development of rocky planets. Philos T R Soc. A 376, 20180109 https://doi.org/10.1098/rsta.2018.0109 (2018).

15. 15.

Stevenson, D. J. Models of the Earths core. Science 214, 611–619 (1981).

16. 16.

Rubie, D. C., Nimmo, F.& Melosh, H. J. in Treatise on Geophysics (2nd Edition) (ed. Gerald Schubert) 43–79 (Elsevier, 2015).

17. 17.

Righter, K. & Ghiorso, M. S. Redox systematics of a magma ocean with variable pressure-temperature gradients and composition. PNAS. 109, 11955–11960 (2012).

18. 18.

Kress, V. C. & Carmichael, I. S. E. The compressibility of silicate liquids containing Fe2O3 and the effect of composition, temperature, oxygen fugacity and pressure on their redox states. Contributions Mineral. Petrol. 108, 82–92 (1991).

19. 19.

Jayasuriya, K. D., Campbell, S. J., Berry, A. J. & O’Neill, H. S. C. A Mössbauer study of the oxidation state of Fe in silicate melts. Am. Mineralogist 89, 1597–1609 (2004).

20. 20.

Thornber, C. R., Roeder, P. L. & Foster, J. R. The effect of composition on the ferric-ferrous ratio in basaltic liquids at atmospheric pressure. Geochim. Cosmochim. Acta 44, 525–532 (1980).

21. 21.

Sack, R. O., Carmichael, I. S. E., Rivers, M. & Ghiorso, M. S. Ferric-ferrous equilibria in natural silicate liquids at 1 bar. Contributions Mineral. Petrol. 75, 369–376 (1981).

22. 22.

Kress, V. C. & Carmichael, I. S. E. Stoichiometry of the iron oxidation reaction in silicate melts. Am. Mineralogist 73, 1267–1274 (1988).

23. 23.

O’Neill, H. S. C. et al. An experimental determination of the effect of pressure on the Fe3+/ΣFe ratio of an anhydrous silicate melt to 3.0 GPa. Am. Mineralogist 91, 404–412 (2006).

24. 24.

Lange, R. A. & Carmichael, I. S. E. Densities of Na2O-K2O-CaO-MgO-FeO-Fe2O3-Al2O3-TiO2-SiO2 liquids: new measurements and derived partial molar properties. Geochim. Cosmochim. Acta 51, 2931–2946 (1987).

25. 25.

Rigden, S. M., Ahrens, T. J. & Stolper, E. M. High-pressure equation of state of molten anorthite and diopside. J. Geophys. Res. Solid Earth 94, 9508–9522 (1989).

26. 26.

Miller, G. H., Stolper, E. M. & Ahrens, T. J. The equation of state of a molten komatiite: 1 Shock wave compression to 36 GPa. J. Geophys. Res. Solid Earth 96, 11831–11848 (1991).

27. 27.

Komabayashi, T. & Fei, Y. Internally consistent thermodynamic database for iron to the Earth’s core conditions. J. Geophys. Res. Solid Earth 115, B03202 (2010).

28. 28.

Frost, D. J. et al. Partitioning of oxygen between the Earth’s mantle and core. J. Geophys. Res. Solid Earth 115, B02202 (2010).

29. 29.

Newville, M., Stensitzki, T., Allen, D. B. & Ingargiola, A. LMFIT: Non-Linear Least-Square Minimization and Curve-Fitting for Python (Zenodo, 2014) https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.11813.

30. 30.

McDonough, W. F. & Sun, S. S. The composition of the Earth. Chem. Geol. 120, 223–253 (1995).

31. 31.

Elardo, S. M., Draper, D. S. & Shearer, C. K. Lunar Magma Ocean crystallization revisited: Bulk composition, early cumulate mineralogy, and the source regions of the highlands Mg-suite. Geochim. Cosmochim. Acta 75, 3024–3045 (2011).

32. 32.

Bertka, C. M. & Fei, Y. Mineralogy of the Martian interior upto core-mantle boundary pressure. J. Geophys. Res. Solid Earth. 102, 5251–5264 (1997).

33. 33.

Campbell, A. J. et al. High pressure effects on the iron-iron oxide and nickel-nickel oxide oxygen fugacity buffers. Earth Planet. Sci. Lett. 286, 556–564 (2009).

34. 34.

Fischer, R. A. et al. High pressure metal–silicate partitioning of Ni, Co, V, Cr, Si, and O. Geochim. Cosmochim. Acta 167, 177–194, https://doi.org/10.1016/j.gca.2015.06.026 (2015).

35. 35.

Yang, S. et al. Siderophile and chalcophile element abundances in shergottites: implication for Martian core formation. Meteorit. Planet Sci. 50, 691–714 (2015).

36. 36.

Garcia, R. F., Gagnepain-Beyneix, J., Chevrot, S. & Lognonne, P. Physics of the Earth and Planetary Interiors vol 188, 96–113 (Elsevier, 2012).

37. 37.

Frost, D. J. & McCammon, C. A. The redox state of Earth’s mantle. Annu Rev. Earth Pl Sc. 36, 389–420 (2008).

38. 38.

Wade, J. & Wood, B. J. Core formation and the oxidation state of the Earth. Earth Planet. Sci. Lett. 236, 78–95 (2005).

39. 39.

Frost, D. J. et al. Experimental evidence for the existence of iron-rich metal in the Earth’s lower mantle. Nature 428, 409–412 (2004).

40. 40.

O’Neill, H. S. C. The origin of the moon and the early history of the earth—a chemical model. Part 2: the Earth. Geochim. Cosmochim. Acta 55, 1159–1172 (1991).

41. 41.

Wood, B. J., Walter, M. J. & Wade, J. Accretion of the Earth and segregation of its core. Nature 441, 825 (2006).

42. 42.

Herd, C. D. K., Borg, L. E., Jones, J. H. & Papike, J. J. Oxygen fugacity and geochemical variations in the martian basalts: implications for martian basalt petrogenesis and the oxidation state of the upper mantle of Mars. Geochim. Cosmochim. Acta 66, 2025–2036 (2002).

43. 43.

Schmidt, M. E., Schrader, C. M. & McCoy, T. J. The primary fO2 of basalts examined by the Spirit rover in Gusev Crater, Mars: Evidence for multiple redox states in the martian interior. Earth Planet. Sci. Lett. 384, 198–208 (2013).

44. 44.

Li, J. & Agee, C. B. Geochemistry of mantle–core differentiation at high pressure. Nature 381, 686–689 (1996).

45. 45.

Kress, V. C., Ghiorso, M. S. & Lastuka, C. Microsoft EXCEL spreadsheet-based program for calculating equilibrium gas speciation in the C–O–H–S–Cl–F system. Comput. Geosci. 30, 211–214 (2004).

46. 46.

Ramirez, R. M. et al. Warming early Mars with CO2 and H2. Nat. Geosci. 7, 59 (2013).

47. 47.

Seager, S. & Deming, D. Exoplanet atmospheres. Annu. Rev. Astron. Astrophys. 48, 631–672 (2010).

48. 48.

Kresse, G. & Furthmüller, J. Efficiency of ab-initio total energy calculations for metals and semiconductors using a plane-wave basis set. Comput. Mater. Sci. 6, 15–50 (1996).

49. 49.

Nosé, S. A unified formulation of the constant temperature molecular dynamics methods. J. Chem. Phys. 81, 511–519 (1984).

50. 50.

Kresse, G. & Joubert, D. From ultrasoft pseudopotentials to the projector augmented-wave method. Phys. Rev. B 59, 1758–1775 (1999).

51. 51.

Blöchl, P. E., Jepsen, O. & Andersen, O. K. Improved tetrahedron method for Brillouin-zone integrations. Phys. Rev. B 49, 16223–16233 (1994).

52. 52.

Perdew, J. P., Burke, K. & Ernzerhof, M. Generalized gradient approximation made simple. Phys. Rev. Lett. 77, 3865–3868 (1996).

53. 53.

Karki, B. B., Ghosh, D. B., Maharjan, C., Karato, S.-i & Park, J. Density-pressure profiles of Fe-bearing MgSiO3 liquid: effects of valence and spin states, and implications for the chemical evolution of the lower mantle. Geophys. Res. Lett. 45, 3959–3966 (2018).

54. 54.

Deng, J. & Lee, K. K. M. Melting temperature depression due to the electronic spin transition of iron. Am. Mineralogist 104, 1189–1196 (2019).

55. 55.

Cartier, C. & Wood, B. J. The role of reducing conditions in building mercury. Elements 15, 39–45 (2019).

56. 56.

Herd, C. D. K. The oxygen fugacity of olivine-phyric martian basalts and the components within the mantle and crust of Mars. Meteorit. Planet Sci. 38, 1793–1805 (2003).

57. 57.

Dyar, M. D. Ferric iron in SNC meteorites as determined by Mössbauer spectroscopy: implications for martian landers and martian oxygen fugacity. Meteorit. Planet Sci. 38, 1733–1752 (2003).

Acknowledgements

The research is supported by NSF grants (EAR-1321956 and EAR-1551348 to K.K.M.L. and EAR 1764140 to B.B.K.) and from Chinese Academy of Sciences (No. 29Y93301701 and 51Y8340107 to Z.D.). We benefited from discussions with Colin Jackson and Lars Stixrude. The computing resources were provided by the Yale Center for Research Computing (thanking Kaylea Nelson for guidance) and Louisiana State University High Performance Computing. K.K.M.L.’s effort was partially supported under the auspices of the U.S. Department of Energy by Lawrence Livermore National Laboratory under Contract DE-AC52-07NA27344.

Author information

Authors

Contributions

J.D. and Z.D. conceived and designed the project. J.D. performed the simulations and thermodynamic modelling. J.D., Z.D., B.B.K., D.B.G., and K.K.M.L. contributed to the analysis and manuscript preparation.

Corresponding authors

Correspondence to Jie Deng or Zhixue Du.

Ethics declarations

Competing interests

The authors declare no competing interests.

Peer review information Nature Communications thanks Jonathan Tucker, Marc Hirschmann and the other anonymous reviewer(s) for their contribution to the peer review of this work. Peer reviewer reports are available.

Publisher’s note Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.

Rights and permissions

Reprints and Permissions

Deng, J., Du, Z., Karki, B.B. et al. A magma ocean origin to divergent redox evolutions of rocky planetary bodies and early atmospheres. Nat Commun 11, 2007 (2020). https://doi.org/10.1038/s41467-020-15757-0

• Accepted:

• Published:

• Did Mars Possess a Dense Atmosphere During the First $\sim400$ Million Years?

• M. Scherf
•  & H. Lammer

Space Science Reviews (2021)

• Ariel planetary interiors White Paper

• Ravit Helled
• , Stephanie Werner
• , Caroline Dorn
• , Tristan Guillot
• , Masahiro Ikoma
• , Yuichi Ito
• , Mihkel Kama
• , Tim Lichtenberg
• , Yamila Miguel
• , Oliver Shorttle
• , Paul J. Tackley
• , Diana Valencia
•  & Allona Vazan

Experimental Astronomy (2021)