Abstract
The lowenergy edge of optical absorption spectra is critical for the performance of solar cells, but is not well understood in the case of organic solar cells (OSCs). We study the microscopic origin of exciton bands in molecular blends and investigate their role in OSCs. We simulate the temperature dependence of the excitonic density of states and lowenergy absorption features, including lowfrequency molecular vibrations and multiexciton hybridisation. For model donoracceptor blends featuring chargetransfer excitons, our simulations agree very well with temperaturedependent experimental absorption spectra. We unveil that the quantum effect of zeropoint vibrations, mediated by electronphonon interaction, causes a substantial exciton bandwidth and reduces the opencircuit voltage, which is predicted from electronic and vibronic molecular parameters. This effect is surprisingly strong at room temperature and can substantially limit the OSC’s efficiency. Strategies to reduce these vibrationinduced voltage losses are discussed for a larger set of systems and different heterojunction geometries.
Introduction
Studies of UV–Vis–NIR absorption for conventional semiconductors usually focus on the absorption strength and the energy of spectral features. This is similar for organic semiconductors, which exhibit strong excitonic effects^{1} and for which the nature of the excitons (molecular excitons, chargetransfer (CT) excitons or hybrids) and their connection to performance limitations of optoelectronic devices are of great interest^{2,3,4,5,6,7}. For instance, the physical mechanisms and microscopic interactions that influence the key electrontransfer events in OSCs are broadly debated^{1,3,8,9,10,11,12} and can be studied by absorption spectroscopy. Important characteristics of the spectra are the lineshape and the width of the absorption bands, whose lowenergy tail determines the maximum achievable opencircuit voltage of the material system. Temperaturedependent exponential absorption tails, socalled Urbach tails^{13}, have been frequently found in conventional semiconductors such as GaAs^{14}—a highperforming photovoltaic material. More recently, in conjugated polymers, absorption tails with linewidths or Urbach energies^{15,16,17,18} in the range of k_{B}T at room temperature have been reported. Investigating the temperature dependence of such bands would be of particular importance because the excitonic processes in these systems, including absorption, depend on both the strong electron–phonon coupling (EPC), induced by molecular vibrations^{19}, and the ubiquitous disorder^{15,16} either of which are assumed to dominate the exciton bandwidth on the lowenergy side. However, up to now, neither the lineshape nor its microscopic origin are well understood in polymer or smallmoleculebased blends.
To investigate the impact of microscopic molecular parameters on lineshape, linewidth and thermal disorder, as well as their influence on OSC device parameters, we study theoretically and experimentally model systems of electron donating (donor) and electron accepting (acceptor) molecules. Based on the simulation of excitonic properties (including molecular vibrations and exciton hybridisation) and sensitively measured external quantum efficiency (EQE) spectra for temperatures between 80 and 350 K, we find that absorption tails can be dominated by zeropoint vibrations^{20} even at room temperature. This fundamental quantum effect is responsible for lowering the performance of OSCs, thus rendering vibrations and their EPC an important subject for future OSC research. When pure electronic optimisation strategies, such as reducing the electronic driving energy, are exhausted^{21,22}, voltage losses can be reduced by lowering the molecular vibrational coupling to lowfrequency vibrations or increasing the electronic/excitonic coupling between states. Both directions lead to steeper absorption tails and mitigate the impact of this quantum effect towards higher solar cell efficiencies.
Results
Theoretical approach
We want to model the lowenergy optical absorption of OSC materials, which is strongly influenced by the electron–electron and the electron–phonon interaction that lead to excitonic states that are spatially more localized than Wannier excitons in traditional semiconductors. To include excitonic effects, we need to simulate the excitonic density of states (EDOS). The prediction of the EDOS takes into account the electronic and vibrational properties of the organic systems, which we describe with the Hamiltonian
where H_{el} describes the orbital energies and electronic couplings via transfer integrals in a molecular site basis. We study the lowenergy excitations and can restrict ourselves to the states derived from the highest occupied molecular orbitals (HOMO) and lowest unoccupied molecular orbitals (LUMO) of donor and acceptor molecules. H_{el−el} is the Coulombtype electron–hole interaction, H_{ph} describes the molecular vibrations and H_{el−ph} their EPC^{23,24} (see Supplementary Methods for details).
Analogous to the conventional electronic density of states that describes the energetic distribution of charged excitations (by adding electrons or holes in bulk organic films)^{25,26,27,28}, we simulate the EDOS
which describes chargeneutral excitations. Its temperature dependence, which will be discussed below, enters Eq. (2) through the statistical operator ρ and the sum runs over initial vibrational and electronic states i〉 of energy E^{i}. Note that this definition is analogous to an absorption coefficient apart from the matrix elements for optical transitions (see Supplementary Methods).
In order to study the subgap lineshape of the CT EDOS in organic blends, we need to describe the effect of lowfrequency vibrations in microscopic detail^{29}. Here, a convenient simplification is to describe the skeletal intramolecular modes (highfrequency vibrations with typical mode energies ħω_{hf} > 125 meV) by their vibrational ground states because of the negligibly small population of these modes (k_{B}T ≪ ħω_{hf}) at room temperature and below. This allows avoiding unnecessary complexity arising from phonon replica in the present study since their EPCs are not large^{19}. The lowfrequency vibrations enter the thermal average for the EDOS (see Supplementary Methods)
which depends only on the reduced Hamiltonian \(H^{\prime}=HH^{\mathrm{lf}}_{\mathrm{ph}}H^{\mathrm{lf}}_{\mathrm{el}\mathrm{ph}}\) that still includes all electronic and excitonic coupling terms. In particular the hybridisation between molecular and CT excitons due to electron and hole transfer integrals can be described. The lowfrequency vibrations manifest in a vibrational submanifold for the exciton states and can be described by the concept of thermal disorder V(T). Its strength is related to their molecular EPC parameters. We emphasise that this analytical result is exact in the limit of low vibration frequencies. It is central to an efficient treatment of these modes. This thermal disorder can be superimposed with conventional static disorder V_{D}, which may add an inhomogeneous disorder contribution.
Simulation of EDOS and its lowenergy tails
In the first part of our study, we focus on smallmolecule donor–acceptor blends with a low donor concentration of 6 mol%, where the molecules are randomly distributed in the host^{30} for convenience of modelling. We demonstrate the emergence of CT tails for the first model system rubrene:C_{60}. Its EDOS is calculated numerically from Eq. (3) with a Lanczos approach^{31} (see “Methods”) in Fig. 1. To the ease of the reader, we first discuss a purely electronic (i.e. vibrationless) model of the rubrene:C_{60} blend that has zero exciton bandwidth henceforth denoted manifold of uncoupled excitons (MUE) and subsequently study three bandwidth broadening mechanisms (details are given in Supplementary Methods). The EDOS of the MUE exhibits sharp peaks (Fig. 1c), which correspond to the discrete submanifold of uncoupled lowenergy donor–acceptor CT excitons.
To study excitonic interactions, we investigate the broadening of CT exciton bands in bulk DA systems. This broadening is the quantity of interest and needs to be distinguished from the residual broadness of zerophonon lines in recent singlemolecule spectroscopy experiments^{32} (see Supplementary Methods for a detailed discussion). The broadening of CT exciton bands can be induced by three mechanisms. Firstly, conventional static disorder may lead to an inhomogeneous broadening (for illustration purpose we choose V_{D} = 10 meV in the simulations plotted in Fig. 1c). Secondly, we study the vibrationinduced mechanism by lowfrequency vibrations by including their EPC in the simulations (henceforth denoted MUE + EPC). In this model, we obtain a strong broadening effect due to the thermal molecular motion (Fig. 1c). The excitonic states that dominate the EDOS at low energies and the impact of the EPC on these states are schematically illustrated in Fig. 1d, where the black arrows indicate the vibrational modes of the rubrene and the C_{60} molecule. The third mechanism is the electronic and/or excitonic coupling (EC) between states (henceforth denoted MUE + EC). This is simulated by describing the full hybridisation between CT states (CT–CT coupling) and between CT and molecular excitons (CT–ME coupling)—a substantial extension to threestate models achieved in recent literature. Here, the exciton band is a consequence of the high connectivity of the C_{60} molecules surrounding the donor, which is illustrated in Fig. 1f. Previous experiments have suggested that electrons can rapidly delocalise in a related set of CT states hosted by C_{60} clusters^{2,9} and also prior theoretical studies have emphasised the role of molecular aggregation^{33}. Intriguingly, the tail at the lowenergy side of this simulated CT band resembles an exponential rather than a Gaussian lineshape that occurred in MUE + EPC.
We turn to the full description of the blends and study—in absence of disorder V_{D}—the interrelation of electronic coupling and thermal vibrational disorder from EPC (blue line in Fig. 1e). In contrast to the exponential lowenergy CT tail of MUE + EC, it exhibits a Gaussian tail. Quite surprisingly, we find that the extracted standard deviation of this tail is not increased upon combining the two broadening mechanisms but slightly decreased (σ_{tot} = 69.7 meV) compared with MUE + EPC despite the presence of random EC. This leads us to the conclusion that the vibrations and their thermal disorder dominate the absorption linewidth at the lowenergy tail for which we predict a Gaussian shape.
Sensitive EQE measurements and temperaturedependent tails
In order to study these effects experimentally and to validate the simulations, we perform ultrasensitive EQE spectroscopy on the rubrene:C_{60} system and other donorC_{60} systems (see Supplementary Fig. 2b for an illustration of all compounds and “Methods” for experimental details). All donorC_{60} systems are prepared at 6 mol% donor diluted in the C_{60} host. The comparison of the lowenergy region (subgap absorption) of the blended systems to the absorption of pristine C_{60} films (whose excitonic gap is above 1.8 eV) clearly indicates the intermolecular CT character of the absorption bands in the blends, which are centred at about 1.3–1.5 eV.
To identify the dominant broadening effect, we study theoretically and experimentally the temperature dependence of the EQE spectrum for TAPC:C_{60} for temperatures between 80 and 350 K in Fig. 2a. In the simulations, the lowenergy band tails exhibit a Gaussian lineshape whose linewidth is significantly reduced when reducing the temperature down to 80 K—a direct consequence of freezing the vibrations. The corresponding temperaturedependent EQE measurement at the same donor concentration shows also a strong narrowing of the absorption tails upon cooling, which would not occur for disorderinduced bands (i.e. inhomogeneous broadening). The absence of inhomogeneous disorder in the simulations and the close agreement for the temperaturedependent spectral tails leads us to the conclusion that indeed the vibrations with their couplings are the dominant source of the CT exciton bandwidth in the studied system and the influence of disorder is rather small. We note that small disorder for chargeneutral excitations is not in conflict with possible larger disorder that could occur for charges (reflected in the conventional DOS) or for other blend compositions or materials.
The close agreement between experiment and theory for the large temperature range is confirmed in Fig. 2b for a larger set of systems comprising donor molecules: rubrene, mMTDATA, SpiroMeOTPD and TAPC (see Supplementary Methods for molecular structures), thus demonstrating the generality of these findings and the ability of the approach to describe efficiently the microscopic physical interactions in these systems. The donor molecules in this set are chosen to have different size and conformational (or vibrational) flexibility. Indeed, the donors with the largest EDOS tails (SpiroMeOTPD and mMTDATA) are known for their flexible dynamics at room temperature as compared for instance with rubrene. This requires conformational sampling of the flexible donor:C_{60} pairs by simulating the thermal motion with molecular dynamics simulations of molecular clusters (see Supplementary Methods).
Lower bound for thermal disorder
Despite the different magnitudes for the width of the EDOS tails of different materials, each donor:C_{60} system shows a reduced broadening σ(T) when cooling down to 80 K, which indicates reduced thermal disorder (Fig. 2b). Interestingly, in absence of inhomogeneous disorder in the simulations (V_{D} = 0), all systems exhibit a finite broadness at low temperature. This is also a universal feature for all studied donor molecules in our experimental work in which we were able to measure EQE spectra at liquid nitrogen temperatures. The lowtemperature value of the tail broadness varies between different donors. This residual width at low T is caused by the slow vibrational modes, which lead to a zeropoint vibration effect. That is, at zero temperature, quantum fluctuations of the lowfrequency vibrations induce an effective broadening that is of fundamental quantum nature. This sets a lower bound of the thermal disorder, which causes a width of the band tail that remains even if all other sources of inhomogeneous disorder can be avoided. For all studied systems, thermal disorder describes the experiment accurately down to the lowest accessible temperatures. Substantial inhomogeneous disorder would increase the tail broadness beyond this value, which would be inconsistent with the measurements. Surprisingly, this quantum effect is not restricted to 0 K. In contrast, even at room temperature, one observes a broadness for rubrene and TAPC that is similar to the one at absolute zero, evidencing that zeropoint fluctuations may contribute significantly to the absorption tails of organic devices even at ambient conditions. Indeed, at T = 300 K we determine their relative contribution to \(\frac{{\sigma \left( {T \, = \, 0{\mathrm{K}}} \right)}}{{\sigma \left( {T \, = \, 300{\mathrm{K}}} \right)}} = 60{\hbox{}}85\%,\), i.e. they dominate the tails for the systems shown in Fig. 2.
Impact on the radiative limit of the opencircuit voltage
The above findings have direct consequences for the efficiency of OSCs since the zeropoint vibrations impact the lowenergy tail of the absorption that is connected to the opencircuit voltage (V_{oc})—a crucial quantity for their efficiency^{34,35,36}. We simulate the influence of the absorption linewidth on V_{oc} in the radiative limit (denoted as V_{r}), which is the thermodynamic upper limit of V_{oc} considering only radiative recombination^{37}. A solar cell’s V_{r} at temperature T is described by the relation^{38}
with the solar spectrum ϕ_{Sun}(E) and the thermal blackbodyradiation spectrum ϕ_{BB}(E,T). Σ(E) is the photovoltaic quantum efficiency spectrum^{37}.
We evaluate Eq. (4) numerically using the simulated EDOS \(D\left( {\frac{E}{\hbar }} \right)\) of the four systems, the numerical AM1.5G spectrum for ϕ_{Sun}(E) and \(\Sigma \left( E \right) = fD\left( {\frac{E}{\hbar }} \right)/E\) with f the oscillator strength. Fig. 3a shows the temperaturedependent V_{r}, which depends on the molecular species. For instance, despite higher E_{CT} of TAPC:C_{60} as compared with rubrene:C_{60} (Supplementary Table 2), rubrene provides a slightly higher V_{r} because of its narrow linewidth. Similarly, the V_{r} of mMTDATA:C_{60} is strongly suppressed by its broad EDOS tail when compared with SpiroMeOTPD:C_{60}, which has almost the same E_{CT}, indicating the importance of other molecular parameters for the voltage V_{r} apart from E_{CT}. The agreement with experimentally obtained values, shown in Fig. 3b, is excellent.
To rationalise the influence of molecular parameters on V_{r}, we compare the cases of finite and infinite absorption tail steepness. The grey curve in the inset of Fig. 3c with infinitely steep absorption tail represents the established Shockley–Queisser (SQ) model^{39} describing an upper limit for the opencircuit voltage \(V_{\mathrm{r}}^{\mathrm{SQ}}\) for a given optical gap energy (E_{g} = \(E_{\mathrm{CT}}^{1}\)). While the SQ limit only depends on E_{g}—a wellestablished tuning parameter in OSC research to match the solar spectrum^{21,40}—we demonstrate that the observed losses depend on additional molecular parameters. Compared with the SQ reference model, we calculate voltage losses due to an additional vibrationinduced Gaussian tail below E_{g} with a width σ(T) for Σ(E) (green in the inset of Fig. 3c). The solar spectrum is approximated by the blackbody radiation ϕ_{Sun}(E) → ϕ′_{Sun}(E,T_{S}) at the effective temperature of the sun (T_{S} = 5800 K), which yields an analytical model for comparison between both cases (see Supplementary Methods). The voltage loss due to the additional lowenergy tail is
where \(V_{\mathrm{r}}^{\mathrm{SQ}+\mathrm{t}}\) is the voltage for the case with finite tail. In Fig. 3c, \(V_{\mathrm{r}}^{\mathrm{SQ}+\mathrm{t}}\) is simulated for the TAPC:C_{60} system from the temperaturedependent σ(T) from Fig. 2b and shows close similarity to the numerical evaluation of Eq. (4) in Fig. 3a, thus indicating the suitability of the “SQ + t” model for further analysis. The tailinduced voltage drop ΔV_{r} below the SQ model is temperature dependent but starts to saturate at room temperature (Fig. 3d). This behaviour can be approximated by an analytical expression. In the limit of small or moderate broadening, i.e. k_{B}T ≲ σ(T) ≪ E_{g}, we find a simple relation between the radiative losses ΔV_{r} and σ(T), namely
This relation describes the behaviour at and below room temperature and closely approaches the numerical results in Fig. 3d. We observe a substantial donordependent voltage drop at room temperature (ΔV_{r} = 0.12–0.5 V) due to the vibrationinduced tail and an increase of these losses upon cooling for all considered donor:C_{60} blends. Therefore, one consequence of zeropoint fluctuations is the increase of ΔV_{r} upon cooling. We note that at very low temperatures V_{r} and ΔV_{r} vanish (see Supplementary Methods).
Based on these findings, we elaborate on strategies to reduce these linewidthinduced losses because they can cause a significant reduction of the opencircuit voltage. Since the EPC dominates the temperaturedependent broadening σ(T) the most intuitive way might be to reduce the coupling to the vibrations. While concrete examples are discussed in the next section, we demonstrate its effect in Fig. 3e by simulating the radiative losses ΔV_{r} as a function of a scaling of the total molecular EPC strength for all vibrational modes of donor and acceptor. For the example of mMTDATA:C_{60}, increasing the total EPC strength and keeping all other parameters constant increases ΔV_{r} (additional 100 mV for +25% EPC for all vibrational modes), while reducing EPC (−25%) would decrease its voltage losses by about 180 mV at room temperature.
Additional modifications of other molecular parameters based on the TAPC:C_{60} simulations show that enhanced excitonic coupling (EC) and lower driving energies also reduce the vibrationinduced ΔV_{r}. This is illustrated in Fig. 4a, where we shift the driving energy ΔG away from the reference value of ΔG = 0.4 eV of the TAPC:C_{60} blend. Lower driving energies shift the CTpeak below the molecular exciton band of the C_{60} host. We observe a significant change in the linewidth while reducing ΔG, which results in a significant change in ΔV_{r}. The losses are reduced from around 0.2 to 0.07 V at ΔG ≤ 0 V (see Fig. 4c green circles), which corresponds to the transition from CT to ME exciton absorption at low excitation energies. But why do both type of exciton states have different linewidth?
The reason is the different efficiency of the EPCinduced broadening mechanism for the CT states and the ME states. In Fig. 4d, we illustrate how the broadening of the CT states σ_{CT} is composed of the individual EPC contributions from the involved orbitals (given by the coupling constants g^{HOMO} and g^{LUMO} for an arbitrary vibration mode). The broadening of the CT states is governed by the sum of the squared coupling constants both of which increase the broadening independently of the sign of the couplings. However, for the ME states it is the sum of the coupling constants that is to be squared and that causes the linewidth. This is because the HOMO and the LUMO occupy the same vibrating molecule and opposite charges partly compensate. In contrast, both orbitals in the CT states are typically coupled to the vibrations of the respective molecular species. Therefore, the broadening σ_{ME} of the ME states can vanish if the EPC constants cancel each other (i.e. g^{HOMO} = −g^{LUMO}) as illustrated in Fig. 4d. If the overlap of the HOMO and the LUMO on a single molecule is very large, this cancellation effect becomes important. Thus, the EPCinduced broadening is expected to be smaller for ME states than for CT states, which entails a reduction of ΔV_{r} with decreasing driving force (Fig. 4c). This compensation effect acts independently of the electronic coupling.
The impact of the EC on the EDOS is further analysed in Fig. 4b by modifying the strength of the electronic coupling while keeping the rotational disorder of randomly oriented C_{60}molecules. We make two observations while changing the EC. Firstly, we identify a slight shift of the EDOS towards lower energies when increasing the EC (see Fig. 4b, blue line)^{33}. This shift is due to the stronger hybridisation of different CT states and of CT with ME states due to the increased CT–ME coupling. Secondly, we find an increase in steepness for the lowenergy absorption tail with increasing EC for the excitonic states that have dominant CT character. An increasing EC also facilitates the CT–CT hybridisation, which enables the electrons to delocalise over several C_{60} molecules yielding a transition from a Gaussian to an exponential lowenergy tail, while at lower EC the Gaussian shape dominates the tail as seen for the EC of 0 meV (black line in Fig. 4b) and 17 meV (green line in Fig. 4b), respectively.
Finally in Fig. 4c, we calculated the resulting radiative voltage losses ΔV_{r} (compared with the tailfree SQ limit) for all values of the driving energy ΔG and the electronic coupling of standard deviation σ_{TI}. We find that the radiative losses ΔV_{r} are usually smaller at higher EC and that the latter counteracts the EPC and yields a reduced tail broadness σ_{hybrid}. The effect of the EC is strongest when its energy is comparable with the driving energy—a regime that deserves increased attention in future work.
Reduction of radiative voltage losses in prototypical systems
Based on the analysis of the EDOS, we derive guidelines for reducing the linewidth losses that are summarised in Table 1 and for which we extend our study to other classes of systems, e.g. nonfullerene acceptors, and study different heterojunction geometries. Based on these systems, we discuss three strategies to reduce these losses and how they can be implemented. Figure 5a shows an overview that indicates a clear agreement between all simulated and experimental vibrationinduced voltage losses and demonstrates material specificity of the theoretical approach.
Clearly, zeropoint fluctuations per se cannot be circumvented. Still, the losses can be reduced even when pure electronic tuning approaches are exhausted^{21,22}. The first strategy in this direction is reducing the EPC (cf. Fig. 3e). This can be realised by choosing appropriate material systems with reduced EPCs of lowfrequency modes. An example is the rubrene:C_{60} blend with much lower ΔV_{r} as compared with the mMTDATA:C_{60} blend (Fig. 5a). Alternatively one can actively tailor the molecular structure. Here, viable chemical design strategies to reduce the EPC are rigidification and orbital delocalisation^{41,42,43}, for instance by extending the conjugated core (see Table 1 and more detailed discussion in Supplementary Methods). These strategies have already been exploited to tune orbital energies^{44,45}.
Secondly, for the class of systems with low driving energy, where the lowenergy absorption is dominated by molecular excitons or hybrid states, the EPC strength of electrons and holes on the same molecule should have opposite sign and similar absolute values (for illustration see Fig. 4d). The latter can be realised when the molecular orbital shapes for HOMO and LUMO become similar or located on the same part of the molecule (or the entire molecule). This reduces the effective excitonic EPC and the vibrationinduced tail even if HOMO and LUMO on their own are affected by significant vibrational coupling (see Supplementary Methods). Examples are nonfullerene acceptors such as SubNc, SubPc, and Cl_{6}SubPc whose losses are below the best C_{60} based blends (Fig. 5b). Independent evidence for this rule is materialised in the popular class of nonfullerene acceptors based on indacenodithiophene (IDT) or indacenodithienothiophene (IDTT) molecular cores such as IEICO (see Supplementary Fig. 2b)^{46,47}, which we take as an example compound from the IDT and IDTT classes. In blends with polymer donors that are adjusted for low driving energy^{21}, IEICO is the lowenergy absorbing species. We confirm that the EPCs of both electrons and holes are relatively large (\(\sigma^{\mathrm{HOMO}}_{\mathrm{IEICO}}\) = 58.5 meV and \(\sigma^{\mathrm{LUMO}}_{\mathrm{IEICO}}\) = 55.6 meV) but similar in size, while the resulting excitonic EPC is below both individual contributions. We predict a small Gaussian linewidth (\(\sigma^{\mathrm{ME}}_{\mathrm{IEICO}}\) = 55.4 meV). The narrow absorption tail^{21} (Fig. 5b) is therefore a consequence of the HOMO and LUMO being delocalised over the same part of the molecule or the entire molecule, which can be induced by a symmetric acceptor–donor–acceptor (A–D–A) type molecular structure. It manifests in a reduced vibrationinduced radiative voltage loss of 95 mV. In general, acceptors of A–D–A type should avoid a separation of the frontier electronic states (e.g. that the LUMO is located on the acceptor part and the HOMO on the donor part). We believe that also the recent record performances of PM6:Y6 blends^{48,49} would be likely unachievable if the nonfullerene acceptor Y6 did not follow the guidelines outlined in Table 1.
Finally, the third strategy is to increase the EC by means of the number of transfer integrals (e.g. number of neighbours) and their size. Transfer integrals couple different CT states and also CT excitons with molecular excitons. For example, in neat SubNc, CT states would have even narrower tails (19 meV Urbach energy) as compared with molecular excitons despite somewhat larger effective EPCs. The reason is that the larger number of transfer integrals that couple such CT states overcompensates the disadvantageous EPC increase. Another example for this strategy has been realised experimentally with a planar heterojunction interface of rubrene:C_{60}^{50}. As compared with bulk heterojunctions of the same compounds, structural order in the donor domain facilitates large hole transfer integrals (134 meV) between adjacent rubrene molecules^{51}. This coupling connects different rubrene:C_{60} CT states, which results in an Urbach energy of 14 meV and a voltage loss ΔV_{r} as low as 20 mV, which is much smaller than the 130 mV for the BHJ with the same materials (Fig. 5a) and agrees well with the literature^{50}.
Discussion
We conclude that strong electron–electron interaction and EPC, which are caused by the molecular structure of the organic semiconductors, determine the properties of the manifold of lowenergy excitons that includes molecular excitons, CT excitons and hybrids. The molecular vibrations of lowfrequency modes (including zeropoint effects) impact the absorption properties of OSCs and hence their device parameters. The developed theory can be used to describe their subgap absorption. The proposed strategies to minimise vibrationinduced voltage losses (of up to several hundred meV, depending on the system), i.e. reduction of EPC, EPC compensation and exciton delocalisation, are supported by the excellent agreement between theory and experiment for many systems in Fig. 5a. These strategies should therefore be considered in future research to mitigate the effect of the molecular vibrations and to lower radiative voltage losses down to the best inorganic semiconductors.
Methods
Theoretical approach
Our approach to describe excitons and vibrations in the studied systems is based on a general form of the Hamiltonian H = H_{el} + H_{el−el} + H_{el−ph} + H_{ph}, where \(H_{{\mathrm{el}}} = \mathop {\sum }\nolimits_{vMN} \varepsilon _{vMN}a_{vM}^\dagger a_{vN}\) is the electronic (onebody) Hamiltonian with the indices M (N) running over sites and v over orbitals, i.e. HOMO and LUMOderived states, \(H_{{\mathrm{el}}  {\mathrm{el}}} = \mathop {\sum }\nolimits_{KLMN} V_{KLMN}a_K^\dagger a_L^\dagger a_Ma_N\) is the Coulomb interaction term, \(H_{{\mathrm{ph}}} = \mathop {\sum }\nolimits_\lambda \hbar \omega _\lambda \left( {b_{M\lambda }^\dagger b_{M\lambda } + \frac{1}{2}} \right)\) describes the molecular vibrations and \(H_{{\mathrm{el}}  {\mathrm{ph}}} = \mathop {\sum }\nolimits_{v\lambda M} g_{vMM}^\lambda \hbar \omega _\lambda \left( {b_{M\lambda }^\dagger + b_{M\lambda }} \right)a_{vM}^\dagger a_{vM}\) their local EPC with electrons. The coupling constant \(g_{vMM}^\lambda\) describes the changes in the site energy (site M) due to mode λ^{52}. The different molecular species, donor and acceptor molecules, are encoded in the Hamiltonian with their local orbital energies ε_{vMN}, which are given by the molecular ionisation energies and electron affinities in bulk phase. The material parameters, which include also the vibrations and their coupling, are obtained by ab initio calculations (see Supplementary Methods for more details on the modelling). The definition of the exciton density of states in Eq. (2) of the main text describes the limit that in the initial state no excitons or charges are present and the indices to the electron creation \(\left( {a_l^\dagger } \right)\) and annihilation (a_{h}) operators run over unoccupied and occupied set of states, respectively. Numerically, the EDOS is obtained from the Hamiltonian in electron–hole tensor space with a localised electron–hole basis. System sizes of about 40,000 molecules are employed in the EDOS simulations. We calculate the spectral function with a Lanczos approach^{31} and continued fraction expansion, which are wellestablished techniques^{53} that are applied here to the large sets of exciton states. Specific details are discussed in Supplementary Methods.
Device preparation
The photovoltaic devices are thermally evaporated at ultrahigh vacuum (base pressure lower than 10^{−7} mbar) onto a glass substrate with a prestructured ITO contact (Thin Film Devices, USA). Two nanometers of MoO_{3} is deposited to adjust the ITO work function. The active layer comprises 50 nm of C_{60} (CreaPhys GmbH, Germany) doped with 6 mol% of each donor molecule. Afterwards, 8 nm of Bathophenanthroline (BPhen, abcr GmbH, Germany), used as electron contact, is evaporated and finished with 100 nm of Al. The donor materials rubrene and TAPC were supplied by Sensient, mMTDATA and SpiroMeOTPD by Lumtec and BDTADTP by the Georgia Institute of Technology. Before processing, the organic materials were purified two to three times by sublimation. The device is defined by the geometrical overlap of the bottom and the top contact with an active area of 6.44 mm^{2}. To avoid exposure to ambient conditions, the organic part of the device is covered by a small glass substrate, glued on top. The neat SubNc device is comprised ITO (90 nm), MoO3 (3 nm), SubNc (12 nm), BPhen (8 nm) and Ag (100 nm). The neat SubPc device is comprised ITO (90 nm), BPAPF:NDP9 (10 wt%, 30 nm), BPAPF (5 nm), SubPc (20 nm), BPhen (8 nm) and Ag (100 nm). The SubPc/Cl_{6}SubPc is comprised ITO (90 nm), BPAPF:NDP9 (10 wt%, 30 nm), BPAPF (5 nm), SubPc (21 nm), Cl_{6}SubPc (21 nm), BPhen (8 nm) and Ag (100 nm). All layers are sequentially deposited apart from the pdoped BPAPF:NDP9 layer. BPAPF, SubNc, SubPc and Cl_{6}SubPc were purchased from Lumtec (Taiwan), while NDP9 is a pdopant purchased from Novaled (Germany). Ag and Al were purchased from Kurt. J. Lesker company and MoO_{3} from Sigma Aldrich.
Sensitive EQE measurements
The light of a quartz halogen lamp (50 W) is chopped at 140 Hz and coupled into a monochromator (Cornerstone 260 1/m, Newport). The resulting monochromatic light is focused onto the device that is mounted on a liquid nitrogen cryostat (Optistat DN, Oxford Instruments, UK) with programmable temperature controller. To ensure a constant temperature at the set value, the device itself was used as a thermometer by measuring the temperature sensitive opencircuit voltage, induced by the monochromatic illumination. After ca. 20 min, the measured opencircuit voltage saturates and the set temperature has been reached in the cryostat. The measurement was started after 10 min additional settling time. The device’s shortcircuit current is fed to a current preamplifier before it is analysed with a lockin amplifier (7280 DSP, Signal Recovery, Oak Ridge, USA). The time constant of the lockin amplifier was chosen to be 1 s and the amplification of the preamplifier was increased to resolve low photocurrents. The EQE is determined by dividing the photocurrent by the flux of incoming photons, which was obtained with a calibrated silicon and/or indiumgalliumarsenide photodiode.
Data availability
All the data supporting the findings of this study are available within the article, its Supplementary Material files or from the corresponding authors upon reasonable request.
Code availability
The custom codes used for the simulations are available from the corresponding author upon reasonable request.
Change history
22 April 2020
An amendment to this paper has been published and can be accessed via a link at the top of the paper.
References
Brédas, J. L. Molecular understanding of organic solar cells: the challenges. AIP Conf. Proc. 1519, 55–58 (2013).
Bakulin, A. A. et al. The role of driving energy and delocalized States for charge separation in organic semiconductors. Science 335, 1340–1344 (2012).
Vandewal, K. et al. Efficient charge generation by relaxed chargetransfer states at organic interfaces. Nat. Mater. 13, 63–68 (2014).
Deibel, C., Strobel, T. & Dyakonov, V. Role of the charge transfer state in organic donoracceptor solar cells. Adv. Mater. 22, 4097–4111 (2010).
Menke, S. M., Ran, N. A., Bazan, G. C. & Friend, R. H. Understanding energy loss in organic solar cells: toward a new efficiency regime. Joule 2, 25–35 (2018).
Yu, R. et al. Improved charge transport and reduced nonradiative energy loss enable over 16% efficiency in ternary polymer solar cells. Adv. Mater. 31, 1902302 (2019).
Olivier, Y. et al. Nature of the singlet and triplet excitations mediating thermally activated delayed fluorescence. Phys. Rev. Mater. 1, 075602 (2017).
Grancini, G. et al. Hot exciton dissociation in polymer solar cells. Nat. Mater. 12, 29–33 (2013).
Gélinas, S. et al. Ultrafast longrange charge separation in organic semiconductor photovoltaic diodes. Science 343, 512–516 (2014).
Chen, X.K., Coropceanu, V. & Brédas, J.L. Assessing the nature of the chargetransfer electronic states in organic solar cells. Nat. Commun. 9, 5295 (2018).
Azzouzi, M. et al. Nonradiative energy losses in bulkheterojunction organic photovoltaics. Phys. Rev. X 8, 031055 (2018).
Eisner, F. D. et al. Hybridization of local exciton and chargetransfer states reduces nonradiative voltage losses in organic solar cells. J. Am. Chem. Soc. 141, 6362–6374 (2019).
Urbach, F. The longwavelength edge of photographic sensitivity and of the electronic absorption of solids. Phys. Rev. 92, 1324–1324 (1953).
Lautenschlager, P., Garriga, M., Logothetidis, S. & Cardona, M. Interband critical points of GaAs and their temperature dependence. Phys. Rev. B 35, 9174–9189 (1987).
Kronemeijer, A. J. et al. Twodimensional carrier distribution in topgate polymer fieldeffect transistors: correlation between width of density of localized states and Urbach energy. Adv. Mater. 26, 728–733 (2014).
Venkateshvaran, D. et al. Approaching disorderfree transport in highmobility conjugated polymers. Nature 515, 384–388 (2014).
Ran, N. A. et al. Harvesting the full potential of photons with organic solar cells. Adv. Mater. 28, 1482–1488 (2016).
Menke, S. M. et al. Order enables efficient electronhole separation at an organic heterojunction with a small energy loss. Nat. Commun. 9, 277 (2018).
Marcus, R. A. Relation between charge transfer absorption and fluorescence spectra and the inverted region. J. Phys. Chem. 93, 3078–3086 (1989).
Born, M., Heisenberg, W. & Jordan, P. Zur Quantenmechanik. II. Z. für. Phys. 35, 557–615 (1926).
Qian, D. et al. Design rules for minimizing voltage losses in highefficiency organic solar cells. Nat. Mater. 17, 703–709 (2018).
Liu, J. et al. Fast charge separation in a nonfullerene organic solar cell with a small driving force. Nat. Energy 1, 16089 (2016).
Holstein, T. Studies of polaron motion: part II. The “small” polaron. Ann. Phys. 8, 343–389 (1959).
Giustino, F. Electronphonon interactions from first principles. Rev. Mod. Phys. 89, 015003 (2017).
Shirley, E. L. & Louie, S. G. Electron excitations in solid C60: energy gap, band dispersions, and effects of orientational disorder. Phys. Rev. Lett. 71, 133–136 (1993).
Blase, X., Duchemin, I. & Jacquemin, D. The Bethe–Salpeter equation in chemistry: relations with TDDFT, applications and challenges. Chem. Soc. Rev. 47, 1022–1043 (2018).
Gaul, C. et al. Insight into doping efficiency of organic semiconductors from the analysis of the density of states in ndoped C60 and ZnPc. Nat. Mater. 17, 439–444 (2018).
Li, J., D’Avino, G., Duchemin, I., Beljonne, D. & Blase, X. Accurate description of charged excitations in molecular solids from embedded manybody perturbation theory. Phys. Rev. B 97, 035108 (2018).
Vandewal, K. et al. Absorption tails of donor:C60 blends provide insight into thermally activated chargetransfer processes and polaron relaxation. J. Am. Chem. Soc. 139, 1699–1704 (2017).
Zhang, M., Wang, H., Tian, H., Geng, Y. & Tang, C. W. Bulk heterojunction photovoltaic cells with low donor concentration. Adv. Mater. 23, 4960–4964 (2011).
Haydock, R., Heine, V. & Kelly, M. J. Electronic structure based on the local atomic environment for tightbinding bands. J. Phys. C. Solid State Phys. 5, 2845–2858 (1972).
Wang, D. et al. Turning a molecule into a coherent twolevel quantum system. Nat. Phys. 15, 483–489 (2019).
Chen, X.K., Ravva, M. K., Li, H., Ryno, S. M. & Brédas, J.L. Effect of molecular packing and charge delocalization on the nonradiative recombination of chargetransfer states in organic solar cells. Adv. Energy Mater. 6, 1601325 (2016).
Vandewal, K., Tvingstedt, K., Gadisa, A., Inganäs, O. & Manca, J. V. On the origin of the opencircuit voltage of polymer–fullerene solar cells. Nat. Mater. 8, 904–909 (2009).
Linderl, T. et al. Energy losses in smallmolecule organic photovoltaics. Adv. Energy Mater. 7, 1700237 (2017).
Hou, J., Inganas, O., Friend, R. H. & Gao, F. Organic solar cells based on nonfullerene acceptors. Nat. Mater. 17, 119–128 (2018).
Rau, U. Reciprocity relation between photovoltaic quantum efficiency and electroluminescent emission of solar cells. Phys. Rev. B 76, 085303 (2007).
Wang, Y. et al. Optical gaps of organic solar cells as a reference for comparing voltage losses. Adv. Energy Mater. 8, 1801352 (2018).
Shockley, W. & Queisser, H. J. Detailed balance limit of efficiency of p‐n junction solar cells. J. Appl. Phys. 32, 510–519 (1961).
Veldman, D., Meskers, S. C. J. & Janssen, R. A. J. The energy of chargetransfer states in electron donoracceptor blends: insight into the energy losses in organic solar cells. Adv. Funct. Mater. 19, 1939–1948 (2009).
Geng, H. et al. Theoretical study of substitution effects on molecular reorganization energy in organic semiconductors. J. Chem. Phys. 135, 104703 (2011).
Schellhammer, K. S. et al. Tuning nearinfrared absorbing donor materials: a study of electronic, optical, and chargetransport properties of azaBODIPYs. Chem. Mater. 29, 5525–5536 (2017).
da Silva Filho, D. A. et al. Holevibronic coupling in oligothiophenes: impact of backbone torsional flexibility on relaxation energies. Philos. Trans. R. Soc. A Math. Phys. Eng. Sci. 365, 1435–1452 (2007).
Qiu, N. et al. A new nonfullerene electron acceptor with a ladder type backbone for highperformance organic solar cells. Adv. Mater. 29, 1604964 (2017).
Feng, H. et al. New anthracene‐fused nonfullerene acceptors for high‐efficiency organic solar cells: energy level modulations enabling match of donor and acceptor. Adv. Energy Mater. 9, 1803541 (2019).
Wadsworth, A. et al. Critical review of the molecular design progress in nonfullerene electron acceptors towards commercially viable organic solar cells. Chem. Soc. Rev. 48, 1596–1625 (2019).
Yan, C. et al. Nonfullerene acceptors for organic solar cells. Nat. Rev. Mater. 3, 18003 (2018).
Yuan, J. et al. Singlejunction organic solar cell with over 15% efficiency using fusedring acceptor with electrondeficient core. Joule 3, 1140–1151 (2019).
Yu, R. et al. Improved charge transport and reduced nonradiative energy loss enable over 16% efficiency in ternary polymer solar cells. Adv. Mater. 31, 1902302 (2019).
Fusella, M. A. et al. Bandlike charge photogeneration at a crystalline organic donor/acceptor interface. Adv. Energy Mater. 8, 1701494 (2018).
Ordejón, P., Boskovic, D., Panhans, M. & Ortmann, F. Ab initio study of electronphonon coupling in rubrene. Phys. Rev. B 96, 035202 (2017).
Ortmann, F., Bechstedt, F. & Hannewald, K. Charge transport in organic crystals: theory and modelling. Phys. Status Solidi 248, 511–525 (2011).
Ortmann, F., Cresti, A., Montambaux, G. & Roche, S. Magnetoresistance in disordered graphene: the role of pseudospin and dimensionality effects unraveled. Europhys. Lett. 94, 47006 (2011).
Benduhn, J. et al. Intrinsic nonradiative voltage losses in fullerenebased organic solar cells. Nat. Energy 2, 17053 (2017).
Acknowledgements
We would like to thank the Deutsche Forschungsgemeinschaft for financial support through the Emmy Noether program (OR 349/11) and the project Photogen (VA 1035/51) as well as the German Federal Ministry for Education and Research (BMBF) for financial support (InnoProfile project “Organische pin Bauelemente 2.2” (03IPT602X)). Grants for computer time from the Zentrum für Informationsdienste und Hochleistungsrechnen of TU Dresden (ZIH) and the Leibniz Supercomputing Centre in Garching (SuperMUCNG) are gratefully acknowledged. Insightful discussions with K. Tvingstedt are gratefully acknowledged.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Contributions
M.P. and F.O. developed the theoretical approach. M.P. performed the simulations of exciton properties and solar cell parameters. S.H. and K.S.S. performed ab initio simulations. J.B. and T.V. carried out the temperaturedependent EQE measurements, for which J.B. performed the data analysis. V.C.N. designed and optimised the nonfullerene acceptor based solar cells. K.V. supervised the experimental work. All authors contributed to the discussion of the results. F.O. supervised the entire study and wrote the paper with input from all coauthors.
Corresponding author
Ethics declarations
Competing interests
The authors declare no competing interests.
Additional information
Peer review information Nature Communications thanks the anonymous reviewer(s) for their contribution to the peer review of this work.
Publisher’s note Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.
Supplementary information
Rights and permissions
Open Access This article is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License, which permits use, sharing, adaptation, distribution and reproduction in any medium or format, as long as you give appropriate credit to the original author(s) and the source, provide a link to the Creative Commons license, and indicate if changes were made. The images or other third party material in this article are included in the article’s Creative Commons license, unless indicated otherwise in a credit line to the material. If material is not included in the article’s Creative Commons license and your intended use is not permitted by statutory regulation or exceeds the permitted use, you will need to obtain permission directly from the copyright holder. To view a copy of this license, visit http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/.
About this article
Cite this article
Panhans, M., Hutsch, S., Benduhn, J. et al. Molecular vibrations reduce the maximum achievable photovoltage in organic solar cells. Nat Commun 11, 1488 (2020). https://doi.org/10.1038/s4146702015215x
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1038/s4146702015215x
This article is cited by

Insight on chargetransfer regimes in electronphonon coupled molecular systems via numerically exact simulations
Communications Physics (2023)

Semitransparent organic photovoltaics for buildingintegrated photovoltaic applications
Nature Reviews Materials (2022)

A unified description of nonradiative voltage losses in organic solar cells
Nature Energy (2021)

Longlived and disorderfree charge transfer states enable endothermic charge separation in efficient nonfullerene organic solar cells
Nature Communications (2020)
Comments
By submitting a comment you agree to abide by our Terms and Community Guidelines. If you find something abusive or that does not comply with our terms or guidelines please flag it as inappropriate.