Although plasma proteins may serve as markers of neurological disease risk, the molecular mechanisms responsible for inter-individual variation in plasma protein levels are poorly understood. Therefore, we conduct genome- and epigenome-wide association studies on the levels of 92 neurological proteins to identify genetic and epigenetic loci associated with their plasma concentrations (n = 750 healthy older adults). We identify 41 independent genome-wide significant (P < 5.4 × 10−10) loci for 33 proteins and 26 epigenome-wide significant (P < 3.9 × 10−10) sites associated with the levels of 9 proteins. Using this information, we identify biological pathways in which putative neurological biomarkers are implicated (neurological, immunological and extracellular matrix metabolic pathways). We also observe causal relationships (by Mendelian randomisation analysis) between changes in gene expression (DRAXIN, MDGA1 and KYNU), or DNA methylation profiles (MATN3, MDGA1 and NEP), and altered plasma protein levels. Together, this may help inform causal relationships between biomarkers and neurological diseases.
Plasma proteins execute diverse biological processes and aberrant levels of these proteins are implicated in various disease states. Consequently, plasma proteins may serve as biomarkers, contributing to individual disease risk prediction and personalised clinical management strategies1. Identifying circulating biomarkers is of particular importance in neurological disease states in which access to diseased neural tissue in vivo is almost impossible. Furthermore, in neurodegenerative disorders, symptomatology may appear in only advanced clinical states, necessitating early detection and intervention2. Elucidating the factors which underpin inter-individual variation in plasma protein levels can inform disease biology and also identify proteins with likely causal roles in a given disease, augmenting their value as predictive biomarkers. Indeed, studies have characterised genetic variants (protein quantitative trait loci; pQTLs) associated with circulating protein levels and utilised such genetic information to identify proteins with causal roles in conditions such as cardiovascular diseases3,4,5. However, studies which have aimed to examine the genetic determinants of neurology-related protein levels in human plasma are limited6,7,8. Furthermore, few studies have combined genetic with epigenetic data to provide an additional layer of information regarding the molecular mechanisms responsible for regulating blood protein levels9. Therefore, the goal of the present study was to characterise genetic and epigenetic (using DNA methylation) factors associated with putative neurology-related protein biomarkers in order to identify potential molecular determinants which regulate their plasma levels.
Here, genome-wide and epigenome-wide association studies (GWAS/EWAS) are carried out on the plasma levels of 92 neurological proteins in 750 relatively healthy older adults from the Lothian Birth Cohort 1936 study (mean age: 73; levels adjusted for age, sex, population structure and array plate; hereafter simply referred to as protein levels). These proteins represent the Olink® neurology panel and encompass a mixture of proteins with established links to neurobiological processes (such as axon guidance and synaptic function) and neurological diseases (such as Alzheimer’s disease (AD)), as well as exploratory proteins with roles in processes including cellular regulation, immunology, and development. Following the identification of genotype-protein associations (pQTLs), functional enrichment analyses are performed on independent pQTL variants. Upon identification of epigenetic factors associated with protein levels, tissue specificity and pathway enrichment analyses are conducted to reveal possible biological pathways in which neurological proteins are implicated. Protein QTL data are integrated with publicly available expression QTL data to probe the molecular mechanisms which may modulate circulating protein levels. Finally, GWAS summary data for proteins and disease states are integrated using two-sample Mendelian Randomisation (MR) to determine whether selected proteins are causally associated with neurological disease states.
Genome wide study of neurological protein biomarkers
For the GWAS, a Bonferroni P value threshold of 5.4 × 10−10 (genome-wide significance level: 5.0 × 10−8/92 proteins) was set. The GWAS analysis in 750 older adults identified 2734 significant SNPs associated with 37 proteins (Supplementary Data 1). Conditional and joint analysis (GCTA-COJO) resulted in the identification of 41 conditionally significant pQTLs associated with the levels of 33 proteins (P < 5.4 × 10−10; Fig. 1a; Supplementary Data 2). Notably, while genome-wide significant associations were present for an additional four proteins (Alpha-2-MRAP, CD38, MRS1 and SMPD1), the conditional P value for these signals following COJO (n = 1 independent signal per protein) did not surpass the Bonferroni-corrected threshold of P < 5.4 × 10−10. Of these 41 variants, 36 (87.8%) were cis pQTLs (SNP within 10 Mb of the transcription start site (TSS) of the gene) and 5 (12.2%) were trans variants. Three of the five trans variants were located on chromosomes distinct from their respective Olink® gene. Furthermore, cis only associations were present for 28/33 proteins (84.8%), compared to trans only associations for 3/33 proteins (9.1%). Two proteins (6.1%) were associated with both cis and trans pQTLs (CD200R and Siglec-9). For all conditionally significant cis pQTLs associated with a given protein, the pQTL with the lowest P value was denoted as the sentinel variant (n = 30). The significance of cis associations decreased as the distance of the sentinel variant from the TSS increased (Fig. 1b).
The minor allele frequency of independent pQTL variants was inversely associated with effect size (Fig. 1c). Notably, this association may be, in part, due to ascertainment bias as rarer variants (with lower minor allele frequencies) must have large effect sizes to attain the same level of power as more common variants. Independent pQTLs explained between 5.1% (rs12139487; DRAXIN; P = 4.38 × 10−10) and 52.5% (rs6938061; MDGA1; P = 1.39 × 10−87) of the phenotypic variance in plasma protein levels (Supplementary Data 2; Fig. 1d). The majority of pQTL variants were located in intergenic and intronic regions (Supplementary Data 2; Fig. 1e). The number of independent loci associated per protein is shown in Fig. 1f. One trans conditionally significant variant (rs4857414) was shared between Siglec-9 and CD200R. This variant was annotated to the ST3GAL6-AS1 gene. Figure 2 demonstrates the effect of genetic variation at the most significant cis pQTL (rs6938061; MDGA1) and trans pQTL (rs4857414; Siglec-9) on protein levels.
We also used an alternative method, FUMA (FUnctional Mapping and Annotation) to find independent pQTLs. This approach identified 62 significant pQTLs associated with the levels of 37 proteins (90.3% cis and 9.7% trans effects; Bonferroni-corrected level of significance: P < 5.4 × 10−10) (Supplementary Data 3). In contrast to GCTA-COJO, FUMA retains the most significant pQTL to identify independent signals through linkage disequilibrium (LD)-based pruning; therefore, variants were identified for all 37 proteins. Seven independent pQTLs associated with the levels of 6 proteins were found using both approaches, whereas the remaining SNPs identified by COJO for a given protein were located within the same locus as corresponding SNPs identified by FUMA (overlapping SNPs highlighted in Supplementary Data 2). In addition, we calculated a measure of LD (r2) between SNPs which were discordant between COJO and FUMA. As 7 independent pQTLs were identified by both methods, this left 34 (41–7) discordant SNPs from COJO and 55 (62–7) discordant SNPs from FUMA. Furthermore, as some proteins contained multiple QTLs, this resulted in 74 SNP-SNP comparisons between COJO and FUMA. SNPs which exhibited an r2 coefficient > 0.75 were considered to show evidence of replication (through LD) between both methods. In total, 27 COJO SNP-FUMA SNP comparisons exhibited an r2 > 0.75. This consisted of 26 unique SNPs identified by COJO and encompassed 24 proteins (Supplementary Table 1).
Colocalisation of cis pQTLs with cis eQTLs
Of the 30 sentinel cis pQTL variants, 12 (40.0%) were cis eQTLs for the same gene in blood tissue. For 3/12 proteins (DRAXIN, KYNU and MDGA1), there was strong evidence (posterior probability (PP) > 0.95) for colocalisation of cis pQTLs and cis eQTLs and for 2 proteins, LAIR-2 and SIGLEC9, there was weaker evidence (PP > 0.75) for colocalisation. For 5/13 proteins, there was strong evidence (PP > 0.95) for two distinct causal variants affecting transcript and protein levels in the locus. For CTSC, there was weaker evidence (PP > 0.75) for two separate causal signals affecting gene expression and plasma protein levels within the locus. Finally, for CLM-6, there was weak evidence (PP > 0.75) for a causal variant affecting gene expression, but not protein levels, within the locus (Supplementary Table 2).
For the 3 proteins with strong evidence in favour of a shared causal variant for gene expression and plasma protein levels, two-sample MR was performed to test for a causal association between perturbations in gene expression (using data from eQTLGen Consortium) and plasma protein levels (using our GWAS data). Pruned cis protein and expression QTL variants (LD r2 < 0.1) were used as instrumental variables for the bidirectional MR analyses. For each trait, the intercept from MR Egger regression was non-significant, which does not suggest strong evidence for directional pleiotropy (DRAXIN: P = 0.82; MDGA1: P = 0.38; KYNU: P = 0.36). For 2 proteins, variation in gene expression was causally associated with plasma protein levels (Inverse variance-weighted method; MDGA1: beta = 0.99, se = 0.49, P = 0.02; KYNU: beta = 1.05, se = 0.22, P = 2.2 × 10−6). We did not observe a causal relationship between gene expression of DRAXIN and altered plasma protein levels (Inverse variance-weighted method; beta = −0.98, se = 0.62, P = 0.10); however, we did observe a causal relationship between DRAXIN plasma protein levels and changes in gene expression (beta = −0.72, se = 0.07, P = 1.2 × 10−23).
Epigenome wide study of neurological protein biomarkers
For the EWAS, a Bonferroni P value threshold of 3.9 × 10−10 (genome-wide significance level: 3.6 × 10−8/92 proteins) was set10 and analyses were performed using limma, a linear-model-based method. We identified 26 genome-wide significant CpG sites associated with the levels of 9 neurological proteins (P < 3.9 × 10−10). Of these associations, 17 were cis effects (65.4%) and 9 associations were trans effects (35.6%; with 6 trans variants located on chromosomes distinct from their respective Olink® gene) (Fig. 3; Supplementary Table 3). As an additional analysis, we performed a mixed-linear-model approach termed OSCA (OmicS-data-based Complex trait Analysis)-MOMENT. OSCA has been recently shown to identify fewer spurious signals than other methods (including linear regression) (Zhang et al.41). Of the 9 proteins with genome-wide significant CpG sites identified using limma (n = 26 CpG sites), 8 proteins were also shown to have genome-wide significant associations using OSCA (n = 23 CpG sites; 14 cis (60.9%) and 9 trans (39.1%) associations). Indeed, only CRTAM failed to show a Bonferroni-corrected significant association using OSCA when compared to limma. Furthermore, of the 23 CpG sites identified using OSCA, 19/23 CpGs (82.6%) were also identified by EWAS performed using limma showing a strong overlap between both methods (Supplementary Table 4).
Three proteins exhibited both genome-wide significant SNP and CpG site associations: MATN3, MDGA1, and NEP (Fig. 4). For MATN3, the cis pQTL identified in this study (rs3731663) has previously been identified as a methylation QTL (mQTL) for the single cis CpG site associated with MATN3 levels identified by our EWAS (cg24416238)11. Similarly, the 2 cis pQTLs for differential blood MDGA1 concentrations in our study have been significantly associated with methylation levels of cis CpG sites identified by our EWAS on MDGA1 levels11. Finally, for NEP, we identified a sole independent trans pQTL (rs4687657) annotated to the ITIH4 gene (beta: 0.53; effect allele: T), as well as three trans genome-wide significant CpG sites (cg11645453, cg18404041 and cg06690548 annotated to ITIH1, ITIH4 and SLC7A11, respectively). In addition to higher circulating levels of NEP, this SNP has previously been associated with lower methylation levels of cg18404041 (ITIH4; beta: −0.93; effect allele: T; P = 4.20 × 10−17) and higher methylation levels of cg11645453 (ITIH1; beta: 0.83; effect allele: T; P = 1.28 × 10−87)12. We performed bidirectional MR analyses to formally test whether there was a causal relationship between DNA methylation at these sites and Olink® protein levels (see methods). For each protein, MR analyses suggested that differential DNA methylation was causally associated with changes in protein levels. Conversely, altered protein levels of MATN3, MDGA1 and NEP were also causally associated with differential methylation levels at CpG sites identified by our EWAS (Supplementary Table 5).
We conducted tissue specificity and pathway enrichment analyses (KEGG and GO—see methods for details) based on genes identified by methylation for each of the 9 proteins with genome-wide significant CpG associations. Tissue-specific patterns of expression were observed for 5/9 proteins (Supplementary Data 4). Neural tissue was the most common tissue type in which genes were differentially expressed (n = 4/5 proteins), followed by cardiac and splenic tissue (n = 3/5 proteins). Gene ontology analyses revealed that genes annotated to CpG sites associated with circulating SIGLEC1 and G-CSF levels are over-represented in immune system processes, viral response and cytokine response pathways (Supplementary Data 5–6; FDR-adjusted P value < 0.05). Furthermore, genes incorporating CpG sites associated with NEP levels are over-represented in metabolic pathways involving extracellular matrix components (Supplementary Data 7; FDR-adjusted P value < 0.05). For CRTAM, MDGA1, MATN3, NC-Dase, SMPD1 and TN-R, there were no significant results following multiple testing correction.
Causal evaluation of biomarkers in neurological disease
From our GWAS, we identified a conditionally significant cis pQTL for plasma poliovirus receptor (PVR) levels. Furthermore, variation in the PVR gene has been implicated in AD13. Therefore, colocalisation analysis was performed to test if the same SNP variant might be driving both associations. A 200 kb region surrounding the sentinel cis pQTL for PVR was extracted from GWAS summary statistics for PVR levels, as well as AD14. Default priors were applied. There was evidence to suggest that there are two distinct causal variants for altered protein levels and AD risk within the region (PP > 0.99).
In addition to the colocalisation analysis, two-sample MR was used to test for putatively causal associations between plasma PVR levels and AD14. After LD pruning, only one independent SNP remained (rs7255066). Therefore, causal effect estimates were determined using the Wald ratio test, i.e., a ratio of effect per risk allele on AD to effect per risk allele on PVR levels. MR analyses indicated that PVR levels were causally associated with AD (beta = 0.17, se = 0.02, P = 5.2 × 10−10; Wald ratio test). Testing for horizontal pleiotropy was not possible owing to an insufficient number of instruments. Conversely, AD risk was not causally associated with PVR levels (number of SNPs: 5; Inverse variance-weighted method: beta = 0.38, se = 0.29, P = 0.34). The intercept from MR Egger regression was −0.08 (se: 0.08; P = 0.42), which does not provide strong evidence for directional pleiotropy.
Replication of previous pQTL studies
Replication of the pQTL findings was carried out via lookup of genotype-protein summary statistics from existing pQTL studies4,5,15,16. Of the 33 proteins with a conditionally significant pQTL in the present study, 15 (with 18 QTLs) were available for lookup. In total, 6/18 (33.3%) pQTLs replicated at P < 1.25 × 10-7 (denoting the least conservative threshold across all studies) (Supplementary Data 8). We tested the correlation of beta values for these six significant pQTLs from our study versus those reported in the literature. Notably, beta values were only available for 3/6 pQTLs in the literature. However, for these remaining 3 pQTLs, there was strong agreement between our observed values and previously reported beta statistics (rs2075803: 0.50 vs. 0.55; rs481076: 0.44 vs. 0.46 and rs1448903: 0.76 vs. 0.65, respectively). In addition, in relation to the 15 proteins from the Olink® panel which were available for look-up, we extracted beta values for all significant pQTLs associated with the levels of these proteins reported in the literature. Notably, many of these pQTLs were non-significant in our study; indeed, in this case, we wished only to determine the correlation of betas for those pQTLs reported as significant in the literature with betas from our GWAS. Beta statistics were reported for 13/15 proteins (totalling 38 pQTLs). There was a strong correlation between betas for previously reported significant pQTLs and pQTLs from our study (r2 = 0.89, Supplementary Fig. 1). Finally, of the 23 pQTLs identified by FUMA which were available for look-up, 9/23 (39.1%) replicated at P < 1.25 × 10−7 (Supplementary Data 9).
Using a multi-omics approach, we identified 41 independent genome-wide significant pQTLs and 26 genome-wide significant CpG sites associated with circulating neurological protein levels. To probe the molecular mechanisms which modulate plasma protein levels, we integrated pQTL and eQTL data allowing for the examination of whether pQTLs affect gene expression. For three proteins, we found strong evidence that a common causal variant underpinned changes in transcript and protein levels. Mendelian randomisation analyses suggested that variants for two of these proteins (MDGA1 and KYNU) influence protein levels by altering gene expression. However, for one protein (DRAXIN), the converse may be true as our data suggested that altered plasma protein levels of this neurodevelopmental protein may affect gene expression, perhaps through a feedback mechanism. Genotype-protein associations for other proteins may exert their influence on protein levels through modulation of protein clearance, degradation, binding or secretion. Finally, methylation data revealed that neurological proteins were also implicated in immune, developmental and metabolic pathways.
In addition to leveraging methylation data to identify pathway enrichment for plasma proteins, identification of trans pQTLs may highlight previously unidentified pathways relevant to disease processes. For instance, we found that genetic variation at the inter-alpha-trypsin inhibitor heavy chain family member 4 locus (ITIH4) is associated with differential NEP levels (trans pQTL: rs4687657). In addition, two CpG sites annotated to ITIH4 and ITHI1 (cg18404041 and cg11645453, respectively) were associated with NEP levels. Methylation QTL analyses revealed that the SNP rs4687657 has been previously associated with lower methylation levels of cg18404041 (ITIH4) and higher DNA methylation levels of cg11645453 (ITIH1)12. Similarly, this SNP has been associated with higher gene expression of ITIH417 and lower protein levels of ITIH14. Together, these data suggest that the expression of NEP, ITIH4 and ITIH1 may be co-regulated, involving inverse relationships between NEP and ITIH4 with ITIH1. Given that mutations in NEP have been linked to Alzheimer’s pathology and that upregulation of ITIH4 has been demonstrated in sera of AD patients18, mechanistic studies relating to co-expression of these proteins are merited in pathological states.
In this study, a single trans variant (rs4857414) was associated with the circulating levels of two proteins—CD200R1 and Siglec-9. This polymorphism mapped to the ST3GAL6-AS1 gene. ST3GAL6-AS1 is a long non-coding RNA which is associated with increased expression of ST3GAL6, an enzyme responsible for catalysing the addition of sialic acid to cell surfaces19. Upregulation of ST3GAL6 has been reported in multiple myeloma20,21; this permits evasion of immune responses against cancer cells through binding of sialic acid to Siglec receptor proteins, such as Siglec-9. The recognition of sialic acid by Siglec proteins ignites signalling cascades which promotes immune inhibitory responses22,23. Furthermore, CD200-CD200R interaction results in the inhibition of immune responses against multiple myeloma cells24. Therefore, as polymorphisms in ST3GAL6-AS1 are associated with altered expression of Siglec-9 and CD200R, this may provide further evidence for co-regulation of these proteins in pathological milieux, such as tumorigenesis in cancers including multiple myeloma. Polymorphisms in such trans pQTLs may also be used to predict disease risk, progression and provide pharmacogenomic information in predicting individual patient responses to inhibition of these co-regulated proteins.
By using cis pQTLs as instruments for MR analyses, it is possible to test whether plasma proteins are causally associated with disease states25. PVR is a component of the AD risk-associated APOE/TOMM40 cluster on chromosome 19 and has been hypothesised to influence risk of AD through susceptibility to viral infections13. However, it is unknown whether PVR is causally linked to the disease. MR analyses suggested that circulating PVR levels may be causally associated with AD and not vice versa. However, an insufficient number of instruments were available to permit testing for potential pleiotropic effects. Furthermore, colocalisation analysis revealed that independent variants in the PVR locus are likely causally associated with altered plasma PVR levels and AD risk. While this does not support the argument for a single causal SNP underlying both altered plasma PVR levels and AD risk, it may nevertheless suggest that genetic variation in the PVR locus is causally associated with development of AD.
The discrepancy in replication of pQTLs reported in previous studies may be due to a number of factors. First, the sample sizes of these studies (n < 10015,16; n > 10004,5) are different from that of the present study (n = 750) leading to differences in statistical power. Second, diverse proteomic platforms may result in the detection of different genotype-protein associations. Our study is the first to characterise the genetic variants associated with the Olink® neurology panel and thus, the protein list and measurement technology do not overlap with platforms employed in earlier studies. Depending on platform technology, susceptibility to cross-reactive events and detection of proteins in their free, versus complexed, forms can result in inappropriate readouts. SOMAmer technology, employed in the previous pQTL studies, is a highly sensitive, aptamer-based platform which overcomes limitations associated with antibody-based methods, such as cross-reactivity26. Moreover, Olink® technology is particularly effective in limiting the reporting of cross-reactive events. However, when compared to these platforms, other technologies such as mass-spectrometry can produce highly accurate measurements but with low sensitivity27. Lack of standardisation amongst proteomic platforms, insufficient power to detect associations and differences in study demographics may all contribute to variability in the detection of pQTLs for a given protein. In addition, we performed both FUMA (LD-based method) and COJO (stepwise conditional regression) to identify independent pQTL-protein associations and found a small overlap (17%) between SNPs identified by both methods. However, SNPs which were differentially identified by COJO and FUMA for a given protein were located within the same region. Indeed, the maximum distance between discordant SNPs for a given protein was 3 Mb.
We acknowledge several limitations in the present study. First, analyses were restricted to individuals of European descent, complicating the generalisability of our findings to individuals of other ethnic backgrounds. Second, functional enrichment analyses indicated that a number of cis pQTL variants may alter the amino acid sequence of the coded protein. This may lead to altered structural properties of the protein product, resulting in impaired antibody–antigen binding and consequently, the ability of assays to accurately detect protein levels. Notably, as the LBC1936 cohort consists of relatively healthy older adults, it is possible that levels of putative neurological-disease related proteins may differ in the general elderly population. Therefore, this may complicate the generalisability of our findings to other age ranges and other elderly cohorts with higher incidences of neurological and psychiatric conditions. Finally, as our findings pertain to whole blood samples, studies examining the genetic and epigenetic regulation of neurological proteins in post-mortem brain tissue are warranted.
In conclusion, we have identified genetic and epigenetic factors associated with neurological proteins in an older-age population. We have shown that use of a multi-omics approach can help define whether such proteins are causal in disease processes. We have shown that PVR may be causally associated with AD. Furthermore, we have provided a platform upon which future studies can interrogate pathophysiological mechanisms underlying neurological conditions. Together, this information may help inform disease biology, as well as aid in the prediction of disease risk and progression in clinical settings.
The Lothian Birth Cohort 1936
The Lothian Birth Cohort 1936 (LBC1936) comprises Scottish individuals born in 1936, most of whom took part in the Scottish Mental Survey 1947 at age 11. Participants who were living within Edinburgh and the Lothians were re-contacted approximately 60 years later, 1091 consented and joined the LBC1936. Upon recruitment, participants were approximately 70 years of age (mean age: 69.6 ± 0.8 years). Participants subsequently attended four additional waves of clinical examinations every three years. Detailed genetic, epigenetic, physical, psychosocial, cognitive, health and lifestyle data are available for members of the LBC1936. Recruitment and testing of the LBC1936 cohort have been described previously28,29. LBC1936 participants were 49.8% female. Key inclusion/exclusion criteria for the present study are highlighted in Supplementary Fig. 2.
Ethical permission for the LBC1936 was obtained from the Multi-Centre Research Ethics Committee for Scotland (MREC/01/0/56) and the Lothian Research Ethics Committee (LREC/2003/2/29). Written informed consent was obtained from all participants.
Protein measurements in the Lothian Birth Cohort 1936
Plasma was extracted from 816 blood samples collected in citrate tubes at mean age 72.5 ± 0.7 years (Wave 2). Plasma samples were analysed using a 92-plex proximity extension assay (Olink® Bioscience, Uppsala Sweden). The proteins assayed constitute the Olink® neurology biomarker panel. This panel represents proteins with established links to neuropathology, as well as exploratory proteins with roles in processes including cellular communication and immunology. In brief, 1 µL of sample was incubated in the presence of proximity antibody pairs linked to DNA reporter molecules. Upon binding of an antibody pair to their corresponding antigen, the respective DNA tails form an amplicon by proximity extension, which can be quantified by high-throughput real-time PCR. This method limits the reporting of cross-reactive events. The data were pre-processed by Olink® using NPX Manager software. Protein levels were transformed by rank-based inverse normalisation. Normalised plasma protein levels were then regressed onto age, sex, four genetic principal components of ancestry derived from the Illumina 610-Quadv1 genotype array (to control for population structure) and Olink® array plate. To obtain an estimate of population structure, multidimensional scaling (MDS) was performed on LBC1936 genotyping data and the first four MDS components were used to control for genetic ancestry in the analytic models. Standardised residuals from these linear regression models were used in our genome-wide and epigenome-wide association studies. Pre-adjusted (raw) and transformed (rank-based inverse normalised levels regressed on age, sex, population structure and array plate) protein levels are presented in Supplementary Data 10 and 11, respectively. The associations of pre-adjusted protein levels with biological and technical covariates are presented in Supplementary Data 12.
Methylation preparation in the Lothian Birth Cohort 1936
DNA from whole blood was assessed using the Illumina 450 K methylation array at the Edinburgh Clinical Research Facility (Wave 2; n = 895; mean age: 72.5 ± 0.7 years). Details of quality control procedures have been described in detail elsewhere30. Briefly, raw intensity data were background-corrected and normalised using internal controls. Following background correction, manual inspection permitted removal of low quality samples presenting issues relating to bisulphite conversion, staining signal, inadequate hybridisation or nucleotide extension. Quality control analyses were performed to remove probes with low detection rate <95% at P < 0.01. Samples with a low call rate (samples with <450,000 probes detected at p-values of less than 0.01) were also eliminated. Furthermore, samples were removed if they had a poor match between genotype and SNP control probes, or incorrect DNA methylation-predicted sex.
Genotyping in the Lothian Birth Cohort 1936
LBC1936 DNA samples were genotyped at the Edinburgh Clinical Research Facility using the Illumina 610-Quadv1 array (Wave 1; n = 1005; mean age: 69.6 ± 0.8 years; San Diego). Preparation and quality control steps have been reported previously31. SNPs were imputed to the 1000 G reference panel (phase 1, version 3). Individuals were excluded on the basis of sex discrepancies, relatedness, SNP call rate of less than 0.95, and evidence of non-Caucasian descent. SNPs with a call rate of greater than 0.98, minor allele frequency in excess of 0.01, and Hardy-Weinberg equilibrium test with P ≥ 0.001 were included in analyses.
Genome-wide association studies
Genome-wide association analyses were conducted on 8,683,751 autosomal variants against protein residuals in 750 individuals from the Lothian Birth Cohort 1936. Linear regression was used to assess the effect of each genetic variant on the protein residuals using mach2qtl32,33.
GWAS model: Olink® protein residuals~SNP
Epigenome-wide association studies
Epigenome-wide association analyses were conducted by regressing each of 459,309 CpG sites (as dependent variables) on transformed protein levels using linear regression with adjustments for age, sex, estimated white blood cell proportions (CD4+ T cells, CD8+ T cells, B cells, Natural Killer Cells and granulocytes) and technical covariates (plate, position, array, hybridisation, date). White blood cell proportions were estimated from methylation data using the Houseman method34. Outliers for white blood cell proportions (n = 22) were excluded prior to analyses. Complete methylation and proteomic data were available for 692 individuals. Genome-wide significant CpG associations mapping to sites with underlying polymorphisms were excluded, as well as those predicted to cross-hybridise based on findings by Chen et al.35. Analyses were performed using the limma package in R36.
EWAS model: CpG site~Olink® protein residuals + age + sex + estimated white blood cell proportions + array + plate + date + set + position
Pathway enrichment was assessed among KEGG pathways and Gene Ontology (GO) terms via hypergeometric tests using the phyper function in R. All gene symbols from the 450 K array annotation (null set of sites) were converted to Entrez IDs using biomaRt37,38. GO terms and their corresponding gene sets were obtained from the Molecular Signatures Database (MSigDB)-C539 while KEGG pathways were downloaded from the KEGG REST server40. Furthermore, tissue specificity analyses were conducted using the GENE2FUNC function in FUnctional Mapping and Annotation (FUMA). Differentially expressed gene sets with Bonferroni-corrected P values of <0.05 and an absolute log-fold change of ≥0.58 (default settings) were considered to be enriched in a given tissue type (GTEx v7).
We also performed EWAS analyses of Olink® protein levels using OmicS-data-based Complex trait Analysis software (OSCA). We carried out OSCA as an additional EWAS analysis as it has recently been shown to identify less spurious associations when compared to other methods (including linear regression)41. CpG site was the independent variable whereas Olink® protein levels were input as dependent variables. Models were adjusted for age, sex, estimated white blood cell proportions (CD4+ T cells, CD8+ T cells, B cells, Natural Killer Cells and granulocytes) and technical covariates (plate, position, array, hybridisation, date) as in the previous section. The MOMENT method was used to test for associations between traits of interest and DNAm at individual probes. MOMENT is a mixed-linear-model-based method that can account for unobserved confounders and the correlation between distal probes which may be introduced by such confounders.
Conditional and joint analysis
We performed approximate genome-wide stepwise conditional analysis through GCTA-COJO using the ‘cojo-slct’ option as the primary means to identify independent genetic-protein associations42. Individual level genotype data were used with default settings of the software.
Functional mapping and annotation of pQTLs
In addition to GCTA-COJO, the identification of independent pQTL variants from the GWAS which yielded significant genotype-protein associations, and their subsequent functional annotation, were performed using the independent SNP algorithm implemented in FUMA analysis43. Initial independent significant SNPs were identified using the SNP2GENE function. These were defined as variants with a P value of <5 × 10−8 that were independent of other genome-wide significant SNPs at r2 < 0.6. Lead independent SNPs were further defined as the initial independent significant SNPs that were independent from each other at r2 < 0.1. Independent significant SNPs were functionally annotated using ANNOVAR44 and Ensembl genes (build 85).
Characterisation of cis and trans effects
Genome-wide significant pQTLs and CpG sites were categorised into cis and trans effects. Cis associations were defined as loci which reside within 10 Mb of the TSS of the gene encoding the protein of interest. Trans effects were defined as those loci which lay outside of this region or were located on a chromosome distinct from that which harboured the gene TSS. TSS positions were defined using the biomaRt package in R37,38 and Ensembl v83.
Identification of overlap between cis pQTLs and eQTLs
We cross-referenced sentinel cis pQTLs with publicly available cis eQTL data from the eQTLGen consortium45. Cis eQTLs were filtered to retain only variants with P < 5.4 × 10−10. Furthermore, only cis eQTLs for the same gene as the cis pQTL protein were retained. These associations were then tested for colocalisation.
To test the hypothesis that a single causal variant might underlie both an eQTL and pQTL, resulting in modulation of transcript and protein levels, we conducted Bayesian tests of colocalisation. Colocalisation analyses were performed using the coloc package in R46. For each pQTL variant, a 200 kb region (upstream and downstream) was extracted from our GWAS summary statistics for each protein of interest. This window previously has been recommended in order to capture cis eQTLs, which often lie within 100 kb of their target gene47. Expression QTLs for genes within this region were extracted from eQTLGen consortium summary statistics and subset to the gene encoding the protein of interest45. All SNPs shared by transcripts and proteins were used to determine the posterior probability for five distinct hypothesis. Default priors were applied. Posterior probabilities (PP) > 0.95 provided strong evidence in favour of a given hypothesis. Hypothesis 4 states that two association signals were attributable to the same causal variant. Associations with PP4 > 0.95 were deemed highly likely to colocalise. Associations with PP3 > 0.95 provided strong evidence for hypothesis 3 that there were independent causal variants for protein levels and gene expression. In this study, hypothesis 2 referred to a causal variant for condition 2 (gene expression only) whereas hypothesis 1 represented a causal variant for protein levels only. Associations with PP0 > 0.95 (for hypothesis 0) indicated that it is highly likely there were no causal variants for either trait in the region.
Two-sample bidirectional Mendelian randomisation was used to test for putatively causal relationships between (i) PVR, a cell-surface glycoprotein, and AD risk, (ii) gene expression and plasma protein levels and (iii) DNA methylation and plasma protein levels. Pruned variants (LD r2 < 0.1) were used as instrumental variables (IV) in MR analyses. In cases where only one independent SNP remained after LD pruning, causal effect estimates were determined using the Wald ratio test. When multiple independent variants were present, and if no evidence of directional pleiotropy was present (non-significant MR-Egger intercept), multi-SNP MR was conducted using inverse variance-weighted estimates. All MR analyses were conducted using MRbase48.
While 72 genome-wide significant cis pQTLs were identified for PVR levels, only one SNP (rs7255066) remained after LD pruning. Five independent SNPs were identified and used as IV to test for a causal relationship between AD risk and altered plasma PVR levels.
Expression QTLs obtained from eQTLGen consortium were used as IV to test whether changes in gene expression were causally associated with protein levels45. Protein QTLs identified by our GWAS were used as IV to test whether protein levels were causally associated with altered gene expression.
For the three proteins with GWAS and EWAS associations (MATN3, MDGA1 and NEP), we wished to test whether methylation affected protein levels and/or whether protein levels affected methylation. We queried Phenoscanner to examine whether pQTLs for protein levels of MATN3, MDGA1 and NEP, identified in this study, were previously identified as methylation QTLs (mQTLs) for corresponding genome-wide significant CpG sites49. Methylation QTLs were used as IV to test whether changes in DNA methylation were causally associated with Olink® protein levels. Conversely, pQTLs were used as IV to determine whether altered protein levels were causally linked to differential methylation levels. Of note, as methylation of the 11 cis CpG sites associated with differential MDGA1 levels in our study are highly inter-correlated (Supplementary Fig. 3), we considered only the most significant cis CpG site (cg20053110) for MR analyses.
Further information on research design is available in the Nature Research Reporting Summary linked to this article.
Full and openly accessible summary statistics from the association studies on Olink® neurology protein levels are available on the University of Edinburgh Datashare site (https://datashare.is.ed.ac.uk/). For GWAS data, see: https://datashare.is.ed.ac.uk/handle/10283/3366; https://doi.org/10.7488/ds/2580. For EWAS data, see: https://datashare.is.ed.ac.uk/handle/10283/3367; https://doi.org/10.7488/ds/2581.
Code will be available from the authors on request.
Geyer, P. E., Holdt, L. M., Teupser, D. & Mann, M. Revisiting biomarker discovery by plasma proteomics. Mol. Syst. Biol. 13, 942–942 (2017).
Polivka, J., Polivka, J. Jr., Krakorova, K., Peterka, M. & Topolcan, O. Current status of biomarker research in neurology. EPMA J. 7, 14–14 (2016).
Yao, C. et al. Genome-wide mapping of plasma protein QTLs identifies putatively causal genes and pathways for cardiovascular disease. Nat. Commun. 9, 3268 (2018).
Sun, B. B. et al. Genomic atlas of the human plasma proteome. Nature 558, 73–79 (2018).
Suhre, K. et al. Connecting genetic risk to disease end points through the human blood plasma proteome. Nat. Commun. 8, 14357 (2017).
Kim, S. et al. Genome-wide association study of CSF biomarkers Abeta1-42, t-tau, and p-tau181p in the ADNI cohort. Neurology 76, 69–79 (2011).
Kauwe, J. S. et al. Genome-wide association study of CSF levels of 59 alzheimer’s disease candidate proteins: significant associations with proteins involved in amyloid processing and inflammation. PLoS Genet. 10, e1004758 (2014).
Sasayama, D. et al. Genome-wide quantitative trait loci mapping of the human cerebrospinal fluid proteome. Hum. Mol. Genet. 26, 44–51 (2017).
Ahsan, M. et al. The relative contribution of DNA methylation and genetic variants on protein biomarkers for human diseases. PLoS Genet. 13, e1007005–e1007005 (2017).
Saffari, A. et al. Estimation of a significance threshold for epigenome-wide association studies. Genet. Epidemiol. 42, 20–33 (2018).
Bonder, M. J. et al. Disease variants alter transcription factor levels and methylation of their binding sites. Nat. Genet. 49, 131–138 (2017).
Gaunt, T. R. et al. Systematic identification of genetic influences on methylation across the human life course. Genome Biol. 17, 61 (2016).
Porcellini, E., Carbone, I., Ianni, M. & Licastro, F. Alzheimer’s disease gene signature says: beware of brain viral infections. Immun. Ageing 7, 16 (2010).
Jansen, I. E. et al. Genome-wide meta-analysis identifies new loci and functional pathways influencing Alzheimer’s disease risk. Nat. Genet. https://doi.org/10.1038/s41588-018-0311-9 (2019).
Di Narzo, A. F. et al. High-throughput characterization of blood serum proteomics of IBD patients with respect to aging and genetic factors. PLoS Genet. 13, e1006565–e1006565 (2017).
Lourdusamy, A. et al. Identification of cis-regulatory variation influencing protein abundance levels in human plasma. Hum. Mol. Genet. 21, 3719–3726 (2012).
Consortium, G. T. Human genomics. The Genotype-Tissue Expression (GTEx) pilot analysis: multitissue gene regulation in humans. Science 348, 648–660 (2015).
Yang, M. H. et al. Activity-dependent neuroprotector homeobox protein: A candidate protein identified in serum as diagnostic biomarker for Alzheimer’s disease. J. Proteom. 75, 3617–3629 (2012).
Bull, C., den Brok, M. H. & Adema, G. J. Sweet escape: sialic acids in tumor immune evasion. Biochim. et. Biophys. Acta 1846, 238–246 (2014).
Shen, Y. et al. Focusing on long non-coding RNA dysregulation in newly diagnosed multiple myeloma. Life Sci. 196, 133–142 (2018).
Glavey, S. V. et al. The sialyltransferase ST3GAL6 influences homing and survival in multiple myeloma. Blood 124, 1765–1776 (2014).
Jandus, C. et al. Interactions between Siglec-7/9 receptors and ligands influence NK cell-dependent tumor immunosurveillance. J. Clin. Investig. 124, 1810–1820 (2014).
Adams, O. J., Stanczak, M. A., von Gunten, S. & Laubli, H. Targeting sialic acid-Siglec interactions to reverse immune suppression in cancer. Glycobiology 28, 640–647 (2018).
Conticello, C. et al. CD200 expression in patients with multiple myeloma: another piece of the puzzle. Leuk. Res. 37, 1616–1621 (2013).
Zheng, J. et al. Recent developments in Mendelian randomization studies. Curr. Epidemiol. Rep. 4, 330–345 (2017).
Gold, L. et al. Aptamer-based multiplexed proteomic technology for biomarker discovery. PLoS ONE 5, e15004 (2010).
Hathout, Y. Proteomic methods for biomarker discovery and validation. Are we there yet? Expert Rev. Proteom. 12, 329–331 (2015).
Deary, I. J. et al. The Lothian Birth Cohort 1936: a study to examine influences on cognitive ageing from age 11 to age 70 and beyond. BMC Geriatr. 7, 28–28 (2007).
Taylor, A. M., Pattie, A. & Deary, I. J. Cohort profile update: the Lothian Birth Cohorts of 1921 and 1936. Int. J. Epidemiol. 47, 1042–1042r (2018).
Shah, S. et al. Genetic and environmental exposures constrain epigenetic drift over the human life course. Genome Res. 24, 1725–1733 (2014).
Davies, G. et al. Genome-wide association studies establish that human intelligence is highly heritable and polygenic. Mol. Psychiatry 16, 996–1005 (2011).
Li, Y., Willer, C., Sanna, S. & Abecasis, G. Genotype imputation. Annu. Rev. Genom. Hum. Genet. 10, 387–406 (2009).
Li, Y., Willer, C. J., Ding, J., Scheet, P. & Abecasis, G. R. MaCH: using sequence and genotype data to estimate haplotypes and unobserved genotypes. Genet. Epidemiol. 34, 816–834 (2010).
Houseman, E. A. et al. DNA methylation arrays as surrogate measures of cell mixture distribution. BMC Bioinforma. 13, 86 (2012).
Chen, Y.-a et al. Discovery of cross-reactive probes and polymorphic CpGs in the Illumina Infinium HumanMethylation450 microarray. Epigenetics 8, 203–209 (2013).
Ritchie, M. E. et al. limma powers differential expression analyses for RNA-sequencing and microarray studies. Nucleic Acids Res. 43, e47–e47 (2015).
Durinck, S. et al. BioMart and Bioconductor: a powerful link between biological databases and microarray data analysis. Bioinformarmatics 21, 3439–3440 (2005).
Durinck, S., Spellman, P. T., Birney, E. & Huber, W. Mapping identifiers for the integration of genomic datasets with the R/Bioconductor package biomaRt. Nat. Protocol 4, 1184 (2009).
Liberzon, A. et al. The Molecular Signatures Database (MSigDB) hallmark gene set collection. Cell Syst. 1, 417–425 (2015).
Tenenbaum, D. KEGGREST: Client-side REST access to KEGG. R package version 1 (2016).
Zhang, F. et al. OSCA: a tool for omic-data-based complex trait analysis. Genome Biol. 20, 107 (2019).
Yang, J. et al. Conditional and joint multiple-SNP analysis of GWAS summary statistics identifies additional variants influencing complex traits. Nat. Genet. 44, s361–s363 (2012).
Watanabe, K., Taskesen, E., van Bochoven, A. & Posthuma, D. Functional mapping and annotation of genetic associations with FUMA. Nat. Commun. 8, 1826 (2017).
Wang, K., Li, M. & Hakonarson, H. ANNOVAR: functional annotation of genetic variants from high-throughput sequencing data. Nucleic Acids Res. 38, e164–e164 (2010).
Võsa, U. et al. Unraveling the polygenic architecture of complex traits using blood eQTL meta-analysis. bioRxiv 447367, https://doi.org/10.1101/447367 (2018).
Giambartolomei, C. et al. Bayesian test for colocalisation between pairs of genetic association studies using summary statistics. PLoS Genet. 10, e1004383 (2014).
Guo, H. et al. Integration of disease association and eQTL data using a Bayesian colocalisation approach highlights six candidate causal genes in immune-mediated diseases. Hum. Mol. Genet. 24, 3305–3313 (2015).
Hemani, G. et al. The MR-Base platform supports systematic causal inference across the human phenome. eLife 7, https://doi.org/10.7554/eLife.34408 (2018).
Staley, J. R. et al. PhenoScanner: a database of human genotype-phenotype associations. Bioinformatics 32, 3207–3209 (2016).
The authors thank all LBC1936 study participants and research team members who have contributed, and continue to contribute, to ongoing LBC1936 studies. The LBC1936 is supported by Age UK (Disconnected Mind program) and the Medical Research Council (MR/M01311/1). Methylation typing was supported by Centre for Cognitive Ageing and Cognitive Epidemiology (Pilot Fund award), Age UK, The Wellcome Trust Institutional Strategic Support Fund, The University of Edinburgh, and The University of Queensland. This work was conducted in the Centre for Cognitive Ageing and Cognitive Epidemiology, which is supported by the Medical Research Council and Biotechnology and Biological Sciences Research Council (MR/K026992/1), and which supports I.J.D. We acknowledge NIH Grants R01AG054628 and R01AG05462802S1 for supporting this research and Grant P2CHD042849 for supporting the Population Research Center at the University of Texas. R.F.H. and A.J.S. are supported by funding from the Wellcome Trust 4-year PhD in Translational Neuroscience–training the next generation of basic neuroscientists to embrace clinical research [108890/Z/15/Z]. A.S. is supported by a Medical Research Council PhD Studentship in Precision Medicine with funding by the Medical Research Council Doctoral Training Programme and the University of Edinburgh College of Medicine and Veterinary Medicine. D.L.Mc.C. and R.E.M. are supported by Alzheimer’s Research UK major project grant ARUK-PG2017B−10. This research was supported by Australian National Health and Medical Research Council (grants 1010374, 1046880 and 1113400) and by the Australian Research Council (DP160102400). P.M.V., N.R.W. and A.F.M. are supported by the NHMRC Fellowship Scheme (1078037, 1078901 and 1083656).
The authors declare no competing interests.
Peer review information: Nature Communications thanks the anonymous reviewers for their contribution to the peer review of this work. Peer reviewer reports are available.
Publisher’s note: Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.
About this article
Cite this article
Hillary, R.F., McCartney, D.L., Harris, S.E. et al. Genome and epigenome wide studies of neurological protein biomarkers in the Lothian Birth Cohort 1936. Nat Commun 10, 3160 (2019). https://doi.org/10.1038/s41467-019-11177-x
Nature Reviews Genetics (2021)
Genome Medicine (2020)
Multi-method genome- and epigenome-wide studies of inflammatory protein levels in healthy older adults
Genome Medicine (2020)
Genetics’ Piece of the PI: Inferring the Origin of Complex Traits and Diseases from Proteome‐Wide Protein–Protein Interaction Dynamics