Discharge of treated sewage leads to release of antibiotic resistant bacteria, resistance genes and antibiotic residues to the environment. However, it is unclear whether increased abundance of antibiotic resistance genes in sewage and sewage-impacted environments is due to on-site selection pressure by residual antibiotics, or is simply a result of fecal contamination with resistant bacteria. Here we analyze relative resistance gene abundance and accompanying extent of fecal pollution in publicly available metagenomic data, using crAssphage sequences as a marker of human fecal contamination (crAssphage is a bacteriophage that is exceptionally abundant in, and specific to, human feces). We find that the presence of resistance genes can largely be explained by fecal pollution, with no clear signs of selection in the environment, with the exception of environments polluted by very high levels of antibiotics from manufacturing, where selection is evident. Our results demonstrate the necessity to take into account fecal pollution levels to avoid making erroneous assumptions regarding environmental selection of antibiotic resistance.
Growing concern over the threat posed by antibiotic resistant bacteria to human health has turned attention also to the environmental dimensions of the problem. Only fairly recently, the role of the environment as a source and dissemination route for antibiotic resistance has been acknowledged1,2,3. Treated effluent from wastewater treatment plants (WWTPs) is one of the most important point sources of resistant bacteria and resistance genes release to the environment4,5. Along with gut microbes, which contain a wide array of resistance determinants6, antibiotics consumed by humans and animals are released into the environment in urine and fecal material contained in treated wastewaters and sludge applied to land.
Untreated sewage contains bacteria from human, animal, and environmental origin and a mixture of sub-therapeutic concentrations of antibiotics and other co-selective agents4. For these reasons WWTPs have been considered hotspots for antibiotic resistance emergence and dissemination5,7. While WWTPs are generally quite effective in removing antibiotic resistant bacteria (ARB) and resistance genes (ARGs) from the raw sewage8,9,10,11 they are important point sources for ARBs and ARGs to the environment due to the large volumes released. The receiving environments form another possible hotspot for antibiotic resistance dissemination when bacteria originating from sewage and fecal material come in contact with environmental bacteria2.
Although a distance-decay-effect can be found from point sources, there has been limited efforts to separate between enrichment of ARGs as a result of simple dissemination versus on-site selection12,13. It has been speculated that ARGs could be selected in the receiving environment by antibiotics and other co-selective agents originating from the WWTP, contributing to further dissemination of ARGs to environmental bacteria3,14,15,16. However, there are experimental studies (using complex microbial communities) suggesting that the concentrations of selective agents in a sewage-impacted environment might not be sufficient to cause selection17,18 despite that competition experiments with two strains occasionally suggest otherwise (reviewed in ref. 19). If there is selection for antibiotic resistance either in WWTPs or receiving environments, it could promote the emergence of novel resistance mechanisms and the dissemination of existing ARGs. A selection pressure would favor evolution of novel resistance mechanisms and the maintenance of recently transferred ARGs in the new host2.
To determine the resistance levels in WWTPs and receiving environments several methods have been used including selective culturing of indicator bacteria, quantitative PCR (qPCR) of ARGs and metagenomics8,9,10,11,20,21. The class 1 integron (CL1) integrase gene has often been used as a proxy for anthropogenic impact and total ARG abundance with good resolution22. However, as CL1s can contain a wide array of ARGs and, thus, can be subjected to selection themselves, they are not an independent measure which can be used to distinguish between environmental selection or simple dissemination of ARGs from fecal matter. Fecal pollution levels have rarely been incorporated in the determination of possible selection or dissemination of ARGs. Detecting fecal marker bacteria using metagenomics is often difficult due to the low abundance of common marker bacteria in the whole community23. A robust marker for fecal pollution provides the means for distinguishing between on-site selection and dissemination of the genes versus accumulation and to observe decrease in ARGs which is due to dilution of fecal pollution in the receiving environments. If ARG abundance shows a strong and positive correlation with a fecal marker, it would indicate that the ARG abundance could be explained by fecal contamination alone without involving environmental selection as an explanation, while if ARG abundance is not well correlated with the fecal marker, it would suggest that other processes, like selection and/or HGT, is explaining elevated ARG abundances in addition to or instead of fecal contamination. Therefore, taking fecal pollution into account in models of ARB and ARG pollution from sewage would help in determining the critical control points for antibiotic resistance selection by enabling distinguishing between mere accumulation and selection.
Recently, crAssphage, a bacteriophage was identified from human fecal metagenomes24. The phage, which infects Bacteroides intestinalis25, is highly abundant in the human intestine, as ~1.7% of human fecal metagenome reads align to it, and it is six times more abundant in public metagenomes compared to all the other known phages together24 while being rare in feces from other animals26. It also performs equally well or better than traditional fecal markers in qPCR assays27,28. Given its high abundance, it can be used in metagenomic studies for estimating the human fecal pollution levels in the environment29,30. crAssphage has been observed to correlate with ARGs in storm drain outfalls31 and thus, could be a good candidate for estimating the effect of fecal pollution in ARG dynamics. Moreover, it is not physically linked to resistance genes like integrons are and hence likely not co-selected with ARGs. Still, the environmental ecology of crAssphage is not fully understood and we do not know whether it can replicate also outside the gut environment. Another fecal Bacteroides phage, ɸB124-14, has been used for microbial source tracking but unlike crAssphage, it is also abundant in porcine and bovine gut32, therefore making it possibly a good candidate for estimating the combined effect of human and production animal fecal pollution.
In this study, we analyze a selected set of public metagenomes from sewage-polluted environments and, in addition, nearly 500 metagenomes from MG-RAST. We show that in practically all the studied environments, the ARG, CL1, and MGE abundances correlate with fecal pollution levels with no evident signs of selection or dissemination of the resistance genes, except in sediments polluted with wastewater from drug manufacturing containing exceptionally high levels of antibiotics33,34. Using fecal samples from ref. 35 and the Integrative Human Microbiome project (iHMP)36, we confirm the independence of mobile ARGs and the crAssphage in feces. The latter is crucial to be detect possible selection in environmental samples. Taken together, this approach can help in disentangling environmental on-site selection and/or horizontal dissemination of ARGs from passive dissemination/enrichment by fecal pollution.
Results and Discussion
Fecal pollution and ARG patterns in sewage polluted environments
Concerns about the elevated levels of antibiotic resistant bacteria and resistance genes in the receiving environments of treated sewage have been raised in several publications3,14,16,37,38. However, relying solely on abundance data, it is difficult to determine whether the increase is explained by selection and dissemination of ARGs from bacteria originating from the WWTP to environmental microbiota or by the continuous input of fecal bacteria. To elucidate this question, we analyzed mobile antibiotic resistance genes in metagenomes from environments with anthropogenic impact from sewage discharge and correlated the total abundance of the mobile ARGs with a human fecal pollution marker, crAssphage, abundance. Our results show that the observed ARG abundances strongly correlate with crAssphage, meaning that the fecal pollution levels largely explain the observed abundances and there are no clear signs of wide scale selection or dissemination of antibiotic resistance in the affected environments.
crAssphage and ARG dynamics in human fecal metagenomes
To determine the independence of crAssphage and mobile ARGs in human feces, we analyzed fecal metagenomes from 74 Chinese, 234 European35, and 141 subjects from the USA (HMP) (Supplementary Data 1) for ARG and crAssphage abundance. The screening of fecal metagenomes proved that crAssphage had a potential for revealing selection dynamics in receiving environments by correlating ARG abundance with the phage abundance in environments with human fecal pollution. We did not find any correlation between the ARG and crAssphage abundance in fecal metagenomes of the studied populations (linear regression, F = 25.51, adj. R2 = 0.21, p > 0.05, Fig. 1a, Supplementary Data 2), confirming that ARG abundance is independent from crAssphage abundance. On the other hand, the correlation between total ARG abundance and intI1 gene abundance was significant when taking in to account the different base levels of ARG abundance in the populations (linear regression, F = 20.55, adj. R2 = 0.29, p < 0.05, Fig. 1b, Supplementary Data 2) showing the expected dependence between ARGs and CL1s.
We observed that the crAssphage abundance was similar in all cohorts, even though the abundance varied dramatically between individual subjects (Fig. 1a). The uniform abundance of crAssphage across the studied populations suggests that crAssphage could be used as a fecal pollution marker globally, which is in line with previous observations39. However, it should be noted that in another study, crAssphage was reported to be less abundant in sewage from Asia and Africa compared to Europe and US30. In our analysis, the total relative ARG abundances were similar in US and European subjects, while the Chinese subjects had higher relative abundance of resistance genes in their fecal metagenomes (Analysis of variance, Tukey post-hoc test, adj. p < 0.05 for both, Fig. 1b). The higher ARG levels in Chinese subjects compared to Europeans, using the same samples which were analyzed in here, has been reported earlier35. Differences on the ARG levels on population level might originate from the historical amount of antibiotics used regionally as well as the degree of transmission control. However, even with differences on the initial crAssphage to ARG ratio in different populations, deviations from this relationship in the receiving environment will reveal possible selection hotspots.
Industrially polluted sediment is a hotspot for ARG selection
To determine the relationship between ARG abundance and fecal pollution in environments with anthropogenic impact, we selected metagenomic studies from literature where sequence data was available (Supplementary Data 1). In all environments, except in environments polluted directly by wastewater from the manufacturing of antibiotics (see below), the total ARG abundance positively correlated with the crAssphage abundance, showing that in these environments the ARG abundance could largely be explained by the extent of fecal pollution (linear regression, F = 32.51, adj. R2 = 0.75, p < 0.05, Fig. 2, Supplementary Data 2). The highest ARG abundances were detected in industrially polluted Indian sediments and in hospital and WWTP effluents from UK and Singapore. Lower levels of ARGs were detected in sediments and river water downstream of a hospital as well as WWTP effluent discharge points, in line with the diluted fecal material quantified with crAssphage abundance (Supplementary Data 2).
Antibiotic resistance genes conferring resistance to different classes of antibiotics followed the same trend in all datasets (Supplementary Figure 1, Supplementary Data 4), with the exception for quinolones in two datasets. The deviations, however, were explained by a single gene, oqxB, coding for part of an RND efflux pump with very broad substrate specificity40. Also, the counterpart of the mobilized RND system, oqxA did not follow the pattern of oqxB. This suggests that the elevated presence of reads matching oqxB in some samples reflects a taxonomic change towards bacteria carrying the gene chromosomally, and not likely as a consequence of quinolone exposure and selection by quinolones.
Overall, the strong and consistent correlation between crAssphage and ARGs (also across antibiotic classes) suggests the observed enriched ARG abundance is primarily due to fecal contamination rather than selection of the ARGs in the downstream environments. Similarly, the ARG richness, total abundance of MGEs and intI1 gene abundance could also be explained by fecal pollution levels (Supplementary Figure 2).
Indian sediments polluted with exceptionally high levels of antibiotics from drug manufacturing33,41 provided a clear exception to the general trend. Here, ARG levels were very high, at the same time crAssphage was not detected in most of these samples indicating that they contained very little human fecal material. These and other sediments from the same industrially polluted area contain the highest levels of antibiotics ever measured in the environment33. The exceptionally high abundance of ARGs and together with very few or no crAssphage reads observed in the metagenomes provides strong support for the hypothesis that direct selection for resistance rather than fecal contamination explains the abundance of ARGs in the polluted sediments. It should be noted that the DNA in these samples was amplified using RepliG prior to sequencing, which could favor small circular plasmids and thereby inflate the counts for genes carried by these34. However, even by removing the most abundant ARGs, the pattern was still consistent (Supplementary Figure 3).
ARG abundance is largely explained by fecal matter, not selection
To expand our analysis beyond the selected studies of polluted environments, we analyzed 484 publicly available metagenomes from MG-RAST, previously analyzed for ARGs in Pal et al. (2016) including environments with human fecal pollution. We were able to detect crAssphage only in samples taken from the Mississippi river (USA), WWTPs, activated sludge with high ammonia content, Beijing air and from laboratory mice. Fecal pollution correlated with the observed ARG abundance in the river water, Beijing air and in wastewaters (excluding activated sludge with high ammonia content) (Fig. 3). The strong correlation of ARGs and crAssphage in the large-scale analysis of metagenomes with varying levels of fecal contamination is in line with our results in the selected anthropogenically polluted sites, confirming that also in these environments the mobile ARG abundance could be explained with fecal pollution and no apparent signs of large-scale selection or horizontal gene dissemination could be detected (Fig. 3, Supplementary Data 2). Interestingly, this was true also for Beijing smog samples, hosting a particular high diversity of ARGs42. The activated sludge samples with high ammonia concentrations were from a laboratory experiment43 and conclusions about possible selection during wastewater treatment in these samples should not be drawn.
A sometimes high abundance of crAssphage and consistently high abundances of ARGs were found from mice gut metagenomes in MG-RAST. All of these mice were from murine model experiments and were not given antibiotics44,45,46. It is known that laboratory mice gut microbiota bear some similarities to human gut microbiota47 and differs from the gut microbiota of wild mice48,49, which could explain these findings. As in human feces, the crAssphage abundance in mice feces was not linked to the total ARG abundance.
The samples with elevated resistance levels where we could not detect crAssphage were either animal fecal metagenomes or environments polluted with animal feces (Supplementary Figure 4). Since crAssphage is reported to be rather specific to human feces, we accordingly could not find a correlation with ARG abundance in these environments. To further verify the lower abundance of crAssphage in other animals compared to humans we analyzed 12 chicken gut50, 100 pig gut51, and 42 cow rumen52 metagenomes and did not detect crAssphage, in agreement with the results of others24,26,29,30. Hence, crAssphage is very specific for detecting anthropogenic pollution. To disentangle selection from fecal pollution in environments polluted with animal feces, additional markers for animal feces would be needed. We therefore determined the abundance of ɸB124-14 phage in the MG-RAST metagenomes. We found it to be less abundant than crAssphage in human impacted environments and not to perform well with other pollution sources such as animal feces either. Overall ɸB124-14 was detected in fewer metagenomes than crAssphage (Supplementary Data 3). The lower abundance of ɸB124-14 in the studied metagenomes suggests it is not suitable to be used for tracking fecal pollution in metagenomic data sets. However, a qPCR-based approach with lower detection limit could give better results. Due to the low detection frequency, we did not use ɸB124-14 in this study to detect possible selection hotspots.
Predicting antibiotic resistance gene abundance with crAssphage
From the abundance of crAssphage, we were able to predict antibiotic resistance gene abundances with good accuracy (linear regression, F = 34.76, adj. R2 = 0.54, p < 0.05) in the environments with anthropogenic impact in MG-RAST using a linear model constructed from the selected metagenomes from polluted environments (Beijing air, river water, & WWTP) (Supplementary Figure 5). However, due to the different base levels of resistance genes in the point source (sewage), the baseline (intercept) of ARG abundance cannot be predicted with high accuracy. It has been shown that different parts of the world have different resistance burden35, which is seen also in fecal samples analyzed in this study (Fig. 1). Furthermore, different environments might have different levels of fecal pollution from domestic animals, which could explain some of the varying background levels of resistance when compared to the crAssphage abundance. However, when the baseline level of an environment is estimated, the model using crAssphage performs well in predicting the ARG abundance.
Antibiotic resistance gene dynamics in wastewater treatment plants
As noted earlier, WWTPs could potentially serve as hotspots for antibiotic resistance selection and horizontal gene transfer. To determine correlation between ARG abundance and fecal pollution in WWTPs during the treatment process, we analyzed metagenomes from three Swedish WWTPs8 and two WWTPs in Wisconsin, USA53. These studies were selected since the sequence data was publicly available and accompanied by comprehensive metadata. The results show clearly the ARG abundance decreases from raw sewage to the treated sewage in parallel with a similar decrease in fecal material during the treatment process (Fig. 4). In sludge, the ARG abundance seems to be even lower than expected based on the crAssphage abundance (Supplementary Figure 6). These results speak against WWTPs being hotspots with a strong antibiotic resistance selection acting as a driver for horizontal gene transfer5,7 and show that at least in the studied treatment plants the treatment process eliminates ARGs along with fecal pollution with high efficiency. Although differential survival and growth of bacterial taxa during the treatment process carrying ARGs or crAssphage can add to noise in the analysis, we could see clear correlation between fecal pollution and ARG abundance along the treatment process indicating that there is no evident selection for resistance. The same was concluded in the Swedish WWTP study even though the authors found tetracycline and ciprofloxacin concentrations slightly above predicted selective concentrations in the influents8. A very recent culture-based study of over 4000 E. coli isolates from influent and effluent from Scandinavias´s largest WWTP also found no support for within-species selection in the treatment plant54. Yet other studies have shown a reduction of ARGs during the treatment process9,11. Our results connect the reduction of ARGs to elimination of fecal material from sewage during the process. In all of the five treatment plants studied here, the correlation between crAssphage and ARG abundance was similar (Fig. 4). A linear model between ARG abundance and crAssphage detection confirmed that the correlation was significant and similar in both countries and all WWTPs (linear regression, F = 71.26, adj. R2 = 0.59, p < 0.05). Only the intercepts differed between the WWTPs in Sweden and USA indicating that the proportion of ARGs to crAssphage in the sewage entering the plant was different in the two countries, but the ARG removal efficiencies of the treatment processes were on par for all treatment plants.
One would perhaps expect a similar ARG to crAssphage ratio in Swedish and US sewage influents, given the overall comparable resistance gene abundance in gut metagenomes of Swedish and US subjects55. Explanations behind the differences found might be technical and come from sample handling or be related to the sources of sewage entering the plant but unfortunately, we cannot asses that with the data available. The ARGs per metagenomic read were, on average, slightly higher and crAssphage more common in the US populations (refer to Fig. 1 to see differences in ARG abundances in different countries). This suggest that one should probably restrict comparisons of ARG to crAssphage ratios to samples that are contaminated by the same population of people and prepared using similar protocols, as we have done in this study.
Estimated resistance risk correlates with fecal pollution
A computational pipeline estimating the potential of ARGs being associated with MGEs and mobilized to pathogens (resistome risk) was published recently56. We analyzed the same samples that were used for benchmarking the pipeline and found that the resistance risks as estimated by the authors56 followed fecal pollution levels in each environment having human fecal pollution. The correlation was even stronger between the resistance risk and the total count of mobile ARGs than between resistance risk and fecal pollution in all environments (Supplementary Figure 7). Our analysis show that in one of the hospital samples there was elevated levels of ARGs compared to the fecal content (Supplementary Figure 7). However, their overall contribution to the resistance load at WWTPs has been shown to be small57. So, to fine-tune the risk assessment, we would propose to include the fecal content in to the analysis to be able to determine possible selection or dissemination scenarios (risks for evolution of resistance) with better precision, as opposed to situations where there mainly is a risk for transmission of already resistant pathogens58.
Estimating the risk associated with environmental antibiotic resistance is far from simple. Besides the total amount of ARGs, it clear that association of resistance genes with MGEs and pathogens elevates the risk caused to human health59. However, detecting a resistance gene in the environment does not necessarily mean a risk for human health. Certainly, there is a higher probability of transfer when there are more transferrable genes and recipient cells together and when the genes are already on mobile genetic elements ready to be transferred to pathogens. However, selection plays a critical role in the processes required for the transferred gene to persist in the new host or a newly emerged gene to disseminate60. Using proxies for fecal pollution such as crAssphage enables detecting possible selection hotspots where the detected ARG abundances cannot be solely explained with human fecal contamination and thus, can help in assessing risks associated with elevated levels of ARGs in the environment.
In conclusion, our results provide a framework to help disentangling dissemination of resistant human fecal bacteria from the possible selection and horizontal gene transfer of resistance genes in the environment. We were able to detect true hotspots for antibiotic resistance gene selection in sediments receiving exceptionally high levels of antibiotics from industry. In addition, we show that in all other studied environments receiving anthropogenic waste, there was no clear evidence of wide scale selection. On the contrary, the ARG abundance correlated strongly with fecal pollution, which does not support the prevailing speculations that major selection for antibiotic resistance occurs in WWTPs or effluent receiving environments. It should be noted that antibiotic concentrations were not measured in most studies. Knowing the concentrations of antibiotics in these environments would have provided an even deeper insight on the selection dynamics. A lack of apparent selection in these environments would mean that the emergence of new resistance determinants is less likely and the transferred resistance genes are not likely to be fixated on new hosts due to selection pressure. In the heavily polluted Indian sediments new resistance determinants are possibly more persistent and disseminate more efficiently in the population due to the competitive advantage they give to the receiving strains.
It should be noted that selection occurring on small scale, which does not affect the entire population, or selection of limited types of resistance genes would probably not be detected using this method. Furthermore, rare horizontal transfer events will definitely be missed and more precise methods are needed. Reported increases in relative proportion of individual ARGs in certain environments exposed to sewage/low levels of antibiotics could reflect such small-scale selection. However, community-based analyses, including qPCR or metagenomics, do not provide evidence for within-species selection. Hence, increases of individual ARGs would more easily be explained by simple changes in species composition, caused by other factors than the exposure to antibiotics. A lack of consistency with regards to the type of antibiotics the enriched ARGs provide resistance to, provides further support to the latter explanation8.
Another important source of antibiotic resistance determinants is animal husbandry, which uses more antibiotics than are prescribed to humans. In the US animal manure exceeds the human sewage sludge by ~100-fold61. As crAssphage is abundant only in human fecal material it cannot be used to estimate fecal content of environments receiving animal manure and feces. However, it is likely that similar phages that are specific to different production animals could be identified and used in a similar fashion. Discovering more markers for fecal pollution would advance the field of studying antibiotic resistance in the environment. We argue that the use of crAssphage, or similar fecal pollution markers, should be incorporated broadly in studies determining the persistence, fate and possible selection of resistance genes originating from fecal pollution, which is likely the main source of resistance genes of environmental ARG pollution.
In terms of ranking risk in resistomes, we argue that the total count of ARGs or their genetic context does not give the whole picture of the actual risks. Without a way to estimate the extent of selection pressure in the environment, the total count of ARGs or the association of an ARG to mobile element adds only a few pieces to the entire puzzle of disentangling the risks related to resistance genes, especially when in most cases the genes are eventually diluted to near zero concentrations following the diminishing fecal pollution. Real-time PCR primers for detecting crAssphage are already available27,28, so the use of metagenomics is not necessary, making the analysis quick, easy and affordable. When collecting data, we encountered many studies where sequencing data was not available, even though sometimes presented as available for download in public repositories. This is unfortunate, as all this data would have been valuable in this study. Re-analyzing these samples using markers for fecal pollution would expand our knowledge on resistance gene dynamics is diverse environments. To conclude, we argue that including a proxy for fecal pollution in future studies would enable a more comprehensive understanding of the antibiotic resistance dynamics in the receiving environments, providing more reliable estimates of the risk scenarios and perhaps most importantly, discovering true environmental hotspots for selection and dissemination of antibiotic resistance.
The crAssphage (NC_024711.1) and ɸB124-14 (HE608841.1) genomes were downloaded from GenBank and indexed for mapping using bowtie2-build62.
Metagenomic studies on human impacted environments were searched from the literature and six studies where the sequencing data was available were selected and downloaded from either SRA or ENA13,33,34,38,63,64,65,66. The studies included samples from river and lake sediments, WWTP and hospital effluents and river water. Two wastewater treatment plant studies with comprehensive metadata were used to determine the impact of wastewater treatment on the ARG abundance and fecal content8,53. Accession numbers for all metagenomic data can be found from Supplementary Data 1. Many data sets from peer-reviewed studies that were candidates for being included in this study were unfortunately not made publicly available.
A set of 484 metagenomes from MG-RAST, excluding metagenomes from different human body sites, analyzed in42, were used for the study. The metagenomes included soil, freshwater, marine, animal, wastewater, agricultural, and air samples. Full list of accessions and annotations are available in Supplementary Data 1.
To study the abundance of crAssphage and its association to the total ARG abundance in human gut metagenome samples, 74 Chinese and 234 European subjects were used from a previous study35. In addition, gut metagenomes from 141 US subjects were downloaded from the HMP portal (https://portal.hmpdacc.org/). Accessions and download links for HMP subjects can be found from Supplementary Data 1.
To determine the abundance of crAssphage in animal gut metagenomes, 12 chicken metagenomes50, 100 pig metagenomes (a subset from a larger study)51, and 42 cow rumen metagenomes52 were downloaded from SRA. Accession numbers are given in Supplementary Data 1.
crAssphage and ARG annotation
Metagenomic reads were mapped against the crAssphage genome using bowtie262 and the crAssphage genome coverage was calculated using Samtools67. Only read pairs mapping in proper pairs were calculated in case of paired-end sequencing. For single end metagenomes, the mapped reads were filtered with quality value 10 using Samtools. The genome coverage was used as a measure for crAssphage abundance in the sample. ResFinder, a database of mobile, acquired antibiotic resistance genes68 was translated from nucleotide sequences into amino acid sequences using Biopython. The longest ORF for each gene was selected to represent the gene in the database as some genes included upstream and/or downstream regions. MGE database69 (available from: https://github.com/KatariinaParnanen/MobileGeneticElementDatabase) was used for MGE annotation by first removing all plasmid marker sequences. All remaining entries were translated to amino acid sequence as described earlier. ARGs and MGEs were annotated against the translated ResFinder/MGE database using DIAMOND blastx70 with the following parameters: minimum identity 90%, minimum match length 20 AA. The parameters were chosen to be less conservative in order to identify also genes not stretching over the whole read. It should be noted that this approach can result in false-positives. In case of paired-end sequencing, matches on the second read were counted only if there was no match on the first read. Both crAssphage abundance and antibiotic resistance gene abundance were normalized with the total base pair count in the metagenome. Mapping against ɸB124-14 was done exactly as with crAssphage.
Both normalized crAssphage abundance and normalized total ARG abundance were log10 transformed and linear regression was done using the lm function in R v.3.271. The ARG abundances in the MG-RAST metagenomes were predicted from the crAssphage abundance based on the linear model based on the selected studies using the function predict in R. Figures were drawn in R using the base graphic package and ggplot2 package v.2.2.172. Smoothing curves using a linear model were drawn with function geom_smooth in ggplot2. Statistical comparison of mobile antibiotic resistance gene abundance between European, Chinese and US subjects was done using the aov function in R. A post-hoc test was done using the TukeyHSD function in R.
All scripts and R code for the data analysis and statistics can be found at https://github.com/karkman/crassphage_project.
The sequence data analyzed in this study are available in public repositories with the accession codes given in Supplementary Data 1.
Wright, G. D. Antibiotic resistance in the environment: a link to the clinic? Curr. Opin. Microbiol. 13, 589–594 (2010).
Bengtsson-Palme, J., Kristiansson, E. & Larsson, D. G. J. Environmental factors influencing the development and spread of antibiotic resistance. FEMS Microbiol. Rev. 42, 68–80 (2018).
Berendonk, T. U. et al. Tackling antibiotic resistance: the environmental framework. Nat. Rev. Microbiol. 13, 310–317 (2015).
Karkman, A., Do, T. T., Walsh, F. & Virta, M. P. J. Antibiotic-resistance genes in waste water. Trends Microbiol. 26, 220–228 (2018).
Rizzo, L. et al. Urban wastewater treatment plants as hotspots for antibiotic resistant bacteria and genes spread into the environment: a review. Sci. Total Environ. 447, 345–360 (2013).
van Schaik, W. The human gut resistome. Philos. Trans. R. Soc. B Biol. Sci. 370, 20140087–20140087 (2015).
Guo, J., Li, J., Chen, H., Bond, P. L. & Yuan, Z. Metagenomic analysis reveals wastewater treatment plants as hotspots of antibiotic resistance genes and mobile genetic elements. Water Res. 123, 468–478 (2017).
Bengtsson-Palme, J. et al. Elucidating selection processes for antibiotic resistance in sewage treatment plants using metagenomics. Sci. Total Environ. 572, 697–712 (2016).
Karkman, A. et al. High-throughput quantification of antibiotic resistance genes from an urban wastewater treatment plant. FEMS Microbiol. Ecol. 92, fiw014 (2016).
Yang, Y., Li, B., Zou, S., Fang, H. H. P. & Zhang, T. Fate of antibiotic resistance genes in sewage treatment plant revealed by metagenomic approach. Water Res. 62, 97–106 (2014).
Laht, M. et al. Abundances of tetracycline, sulphonamide and beta-lactam antibiotic resistance genes in conventional wastewater treatment plants (WWTPs) with different waste load. PLoS ONE 9, e103705 (2014).
Czekalski, N., Gascón Díez, E. & Bürgmann, H. Wastewater as a point source of antibiotic-resistance genes in the sediment of a freshwater lake. ISME J. 8, 1381–1390 (2014).
Chu, B. T. T. et al. Metagenomics reveals the impact of wastewater treatment plants on the dispersal of microorganisms and genes in aquatic sediments. Appl. Environ. Microbiol. 84, e02168–17 (2017).
Eckert, E. M., Di Cesare, A., Coci, M. & Corno, G. Persistence of antibiotic resistance genes in large subalpine lakes: the role of anthropogenic pollution and ecological interactions. Hydrobiologia 824, 93–108 (2018).
Li, L. et al. Estimating the transfer range of plasmids encoding antimicrobial resistance in a wastewater treatment plant microbial community. Environ. Sci. Technol. Lett. 5, 260–265 (2018).
Martinez, J. L. Environmental pollution by antibiotics and by antibiotic resistance determinants. Environ. Pollut. 157, 2893–2902 (2009).
Lundström, S. V. et al. Minimal selective concentrations of tetracycline in complex aquatic bacterial biofilms. Sci. Total Environ. 553, 587–595 (2016).
Kraupner, N. et al. Selective concentration for ciprofloxacin resistance in Escherichia coli grown in complex aquatic bacterial biofilms. Environ. Int. 116, 255–268 (2018).
Andersson, D. I. & Hughes, D. Microbiological effects of sublethal levels of antibiotics. Nat. Rev. Microbiol. 12, 465–478 (2014).
Harris, S., Morris, C., Morris, D., Cormican, M. & Cummins, E. Antimicrobial resistant Escherichia coli in the municipal wastewater system: effect of hospital effluent and environmental fate. Sci. Total Environ. 468–469, 1078–1085 (2014).
Sidrach-Cardona, R., Hijosa-Valsero, M., Marti, E., Balcázar, J. L. & Becares, E. Prevalence of antibiotic-resistant fecal bacteria in a river impacted by both an antibiotic production plant and urban treated discharges. Sci. Total Environ. 488–489, 220–227 (2014).
Gillings, M. R. et al. Using the class 1 integron-integrase gene as a proxy for anthropogenic pollution. ISME J. 9, 1269–1279 (2015).
Bengtsson-Palme, J., Larsson, D. G. J. & Kristiansson, E. Using metagenomics to investigate human and environmental resistomes. J. Antimicrob. Chemother. 72, 2690–2703 (2017).
Dutilh, B. E. et al. A highly abundant bacteriophage discovered in the unknown sequences of human faecal metagenomes. Nat. Commun. 5, 4498 (2014).
Shkoporov, A. N. et al. ΦCrAss001 represents the most abundant bacteriophage family in the human gut and infects Bacteroides intestinalis. Nat. Commun. 9, 4781 (2018).
García-Aljaro, C., Ballesté, E., Muniesa, M. & Jofre, J. Determination of crAssphage in water samples and applicability for tracking human faecal pollution. Microb. Biotechnol. 10, 1775–1780 (2017).
Stachler, E. et al. Quantitative CrAssphage PCR assays for human fecal pollution measurement. Environ. Sci. Technol. 51, 9146–9154 (2017).
Stachler, E., Akyon, B., de Carvalho, N. A., Ference, C. & Bibby, K. Correlation of crAssphage qPCR markers with culturable and molecular indicators of human fecal pollution in an impacted urban watershed. Environ. Sci. Technol. 52, 7505–7512 (2018).
Ahmed, W. et al. Evaluation of the novel crAssphage marker for sewage pollution tracking in storm drain outfalls in Tampa, Florida. Water Res. 131, 142–150 (2018).
Stachler, E. & Bibby, K. Metagenomic evaluation of the highly abundant human gut bacteriophage CrAssphage for source tracking of human fecal pollution. Environ. Sci. Technol. Lett. 1, 405–409 (2014).
Ahmed, W. et al. Precipitation influences pathogenic bacteria and antibiotic resistance gene abundance in storm drain outfalls in coastal sub-tropical waters. Environ. Int. 116, 308–318 (2018).
Ogilvie, L. A. et al. Resolution of habitat-associated ecogenomic signatures in bacteriophage genomes and application to microbial source tracking. ISME J. 12, 942–958 (2018).
Kristiansson, E. et al. Pyrosequencing of antibiotic-contaminated river sediments reveals high levels of resistance and gene transfer elements. PLoS ONE 6, e17038 (2011).
Bengtsson-Palme, J., Boulund, F., Fick, J., Kristiansson, E. & Larsson, D. G. J. Shotgun metagenomics reveals a wide array of antibiotic resistance genes and mobile elements in a polluted lake in India. Front. Microbiol. 5, 648 (2014).
Hu, Y. et al. Metagenome-wide analysis of antibiotic resistance genes in a large cohort of human gut microbiota. Nat. Commun. 4, 2151 (2013).
Integrative HMP (iHMP) Research Network Consortium. The integrative human microbiome project: dynamic analysis of microbiome-host omics profiles during periods of human health and disease. Cell. Host. Microbe 16, 276–289 (2014).
Martinez, J. L. Antibiotics and antibiotic resistance genes in natural environments. Science 321, 365–367 (2008).
Rowe, W. P. M. et al. Overexpression of antibiotic resistance genes in hospital effluents over time. J. Antimicrob. Chemother. 72, 1617–1623 (2017).
Cinek, O. et al. Quantitative CrAssphage real-time PCR assay derived from data of multiple geographically distant populations. J. Med. Virol. 90, 767–771 (2018).
Hansen, L. H., Jensen, L. B., Sørensen, H. I. & Sørensen, S. J. Substrate specificity of the OqxAB multidrug resistance pump in Escherichia coli and selected enteric bacteria. J. Antimicrob. Chemother. 60, 145–147 (2007).
Larsson, D. G. J., de Pedro, C. & Paxeus, N. Effluent from drug manufactures contains extremely high levels of pharmaceuticals. J. Hazard. Mater. 148, 751–755 (2007).
Pal, C., Bengtsson-Palme, J., Kristiansson, E. & Larsson, D. G. J. The structure and diversity of human, animal and environmental resistomes. Microbiome 4, 54 (2016).
Crovadore, J. et al. Metatranscriptomic and metagenomic description of the bacterial nitrogen metabolism in waste water wet oxidation effluents. Heliyon 3, e00427 (2017).
Everard, A. et al. Microbiome of prebiotic-treated mice reveals novel targets involved in host response during obesity. ISME J. 8, 2116–2130 (2014).
Langille, M. G. et al. Microbial shifts in the aging mouse gut. Microbiome 2, 50 (2014).
Rooks, M. G. et al. Gut microbiome composition and function in experimental colitis during active disease and treatment-induced remission. ISME J. 8, 1403–1417 (2014).
Nguyen, T. L. A., Vieira-Silva, S., Liston, A. & Raes, J. How informative is the mouse for human gut microbiota research? Dis. Model Mech. 8, 1–16 (2015).
Kreisinger, J., Čížková, D., Vohánka, J. & Piálek, J. Gastrointestinal microbiota of wild and inbred individuals of two house mouse subspecies assessed using high-throughput parallel pyrosequencing. Mol. Ecol. 23, 5048–5060 (2014).
Rosshart, S. P. et al. Wild mouse gut microbiota promotes host fitness and improves disease resistance. Cell 171, 1015–1028.e13 (2017).
Xiong, W. et al. Antibiotic-mediated changes in the fecal microbiome of broiler chickens define the incidence of antibiotic resistance genes. Microbiome 6, 34 (2018).
Xiao, L. et al. A reference gene catalogue of the pig gut microbiome. Nat. Microbiol 1, 16161 (2016).
Stewart, R. D. et al. Assembly of 913 microbial genomes from metagenomic sequencing of the cow rumen. Nat. Commun. 9, 870 (2018).
Petrovich, M. et al. Antibiotic resistance genes show enhanced mobilization through suspended growth and biofilm-based wastewater treatment processes. FEMS Microbiol. Ecol. 94, fiy041 (2018).
Flach, C., Genheden, M., Fick, J. & Larsson, D. G. J. A comprehensive screening of Escherichia coli isolates from Scandinavia’s largest sewage treatment plant indicates no selection for antibiotic resistance. Environ. Sci. Technol. 52, 11419–11428 (2018).
Feng, J. et al. Antibiotic resistome in a large-scale healthy human gut microbiota deciphered by metagenomic and network analyses: antibiotic resistome. Environ. Microbiol. 20, 355–368 (2018).
Oh, M. et al. MetaCompare: a computational pipeline for prioritizing environmental resistome risk. FEMS Microbiol. Ecol. 94, fiy079 (2018).
Buelow, E. et al. Limited influence of hospital wastewater on the microbiome and resistome of wastewater in a community sewerage system. FEMS Microbiol. Ecol. 94, fiy087 (2018).
Larsson, D. G. J. et al. Critical knowledge gaps and research needs related to the environmental dimensions of antibiotic resistance. Environ. Int. 117, 132–138 (2018).
Martínez, J. L., Coque, T. M. & Baquero, F. What is a resistance gene? Ranking risk in resistomes. Nat. Rev. Microbiol. 13, 116–123 (2014).
Bengtsson-Palme, J. & Larsson, D. G. J. Antibiotic resistance genes in the environment: prioritizing risks. Nat. Rev. Microbiol. 13, 396–396 (2015).
Gerba, C. P. & Smith, J. E. Sources of pathogenic microorganisms and their fate during land application of wastes. J. Environ. Qual. 34, 42–48 (2005).
Langmead, B. & Salzberg, S. L. Fast gapped-read alignment with Bowtie 2. Nat. Methods 9, 357–359 (2012).
Lekunberri, I., Balcázar, J. L. & Borrego, C. M. Metagenomic exploration reveals a marked change in the river resistome and mobilome after treated wastewater discharges. Environ. Pollut. 234, 538–542 (2018).
Marathe, N. P. et al. Untreated urban waste contaminates Indian river sediments with resistance genes to last resort antibiotics. Water Res. 124, 388–397 (2017).
Ng, C. et al. Characterization of metagenomes in urban aquatic compartments reveals high prevalence of clinically relevant antibiotic resistance genes in wastewaters. Front. Microbiol. 8, 2200 (2017).
Rowe, W. et al. Comparative metagenomics reveals a diverse range of antimicrobial resistance genes in effluents entering a river catchment. Water Sci. Technol. 73, 1541–1549 (2016).
Li, H. et al. The sequence alignment/map format and SAMtools. Bioinformatics 25, 2078–2079 (2009).
Zankari, E. et al. Identification of acquired antimicrobial resistance genes. J. Antimicrob. Chemother. 67, 2640–2644 (2012).
Pärnänen, K. et al. Maternal gut and breast milk microbiota affect infant gut antibiotic resistome and mobile genetic elements. Nat. Commun. 9, 3891 (2018).
Buchfink, B., Xie, C. & Huson, D. H. Fast and sensitive protein alignment using DIAMOND. Nat. Methods 12, 59–60 (2015).
R. Core Team. R: A Language and Environment for Statistical Computing. (R Foundation for Statistical Computing, 2016).
Wickham, H. ggplot2: Elegant Graphics for Data Analysis. (Springer-Verlag, New York, 2009).
This research was funded by the Swedish Research Councils VR (2015-02492) and FORMAS (942-2015-750) to D.G.J.L. and the Adlerbert Research Foundation to A.K. The Centre for Antibiotic Resistance Research at University of Gothenburg (www.care.gu.se) also supported the project.
The authors declare no competing interests.
Journal peer review information: Nature Communications thanks the anonymous reviewers for their contribution to the peer review of this work. Peer reviewer reports are available.
Publisher’s note: Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.
About this article
Cite this article
Karkman, A., Pärnänen, K. & Larsson, D.G.J. Fecal pollution can explain antibiotic resistance gene abundances in anthropogenically impacted environments. Nat Commun 10, 80 (2019). https://doi.org/10.1038/s41467-018-07992-3
Association of the colistin resistance gene mcr‐1 with faecal pollution in water environments in Hanoi, Vietnam
Letters in Applied Microbiology (2021)
Antibiotic resistance in the environment: a critical insight on its occurrence, fate, and eco-toxicity
Environmental Science and Pollution Research (2021)
Ultrathin iron-cobalt oxide nanosheets with enhanced H2O2 activation performance for efficient degradation of tetracycline
Applied Surface Science (2021)
Does over a century of aerobic phage work provide a solid framework for the study of phages in the gut?
Potentials of low-cost methods for the removal of antibiotic-resistant bacteria and their genes in low budget communities: A review
Journal of Water Process Engineering (2021)