Natural hair colour within European populations is a complex genetic trait. Previous work has established that MC1R variants are the principal genetic cause of red hair colour, but with variable penetrance. Here, we have extensively mapped the genes responsible for hair colour in the white, British ancestry, participants in UK Biobank. MC1R only explains 73% of the SNP heritability for red hair in UK Biobank, and in fact most individuals with two MC1R variants have blonde or light brown hair. We identify other genes contributing to red hair, the combined effect of which accounts for ~90% of the SNP heritability. Blonde hair is associated with over 200 genetic variants and we find a continuum from black through dark and light brown to blonde and account for 73% of the SNP heritability of blonde hair. Many of the associated genes are involved in hair growth or texture, emphasising the cellular connections between keratinocytes and melanocytes in the determination of hair colour.
Natural hair colour within European populations is strikingly variable and is a complex genetic trait that is impacted relatively little by known, non-genetic, factors1. Furthermore, hair colour is largely determined by only a few well-characterised cell types: the melanocytes where the melanin pigment is made, the keratinocytes of the hair to which the pigment is transferred and fibroblasts of the dermal papilla, which signal to and regulate the melanocytes. It is thus an excellent model system to explore genetic and cellular interactions in development and homoeostasis. Hair colour variation is partially correlated with skin and eye colour variation, reflecting differences in cellular interaction in different tissues2,3.
Several studies have examined the genetic basis of hair colour variation. Red hair is well established as being associated with coding variation in the MC1R gene4,5. Less well known is the observation that most of these variants are only partially penetrant, and some of them have very low penetrance indeed6. Other genetic factors must be interacting with MC1R to modify the penetrance of these variants. MC1R is a G-protein-coupled receptor, expressed on the surface of skin and hair melanocytes. Binding of the MC1R cognate ligand, α-melanocyte stimulating hormone (α-MSH), induces a melanogenic cascade resulting in the production of dark eumelanin. This is packaged into vesicles, termed melanosomes, for transport to epidermal keratinocytes where it provides protection against ultraviolet radiation. The cellular trafficking of melanosomes to keratinocytes in the hair follicle additionally gives colour to the growing hair. Loss of MC1R signalling in many vertebrate species results in the inability of the melanocytes to produce eumelanin that instead default to synthesising phaeomelanin, a red or yellow pigment. MC1R has a second ligand, an inverse agonist, agouti signalling protein (ASIP)7. Overexpression of ASIP, in mice for example, leads to synthesis of only yellow phaeomelanin, even in the presence of a functional MC1R and α-MSH8. Previous studies have defined a role for ASIP in red hair in humans, but its molecular basis is largely unknown9,10.
Until recently, genome-wide association studies (GWAS) identified only a small number of loci associated with blonde hair, compared to black and brown11,12,13,14. Each of these studies identified between 4 and 8 genes, with a total of 11 genes associated with hair colour differences. Most of these genes have been previously described as causing coat colour variation in mice (MC1R, ASIP, OCA2, SLC45A2, KITLG, TYR, TYRP1, EDNRB), zebrafish (SLC24A5) and humans (TPCN2, IRF4). However, during preparation of this manuscript a GWAS was reported identifying over 100 loci contributing to hair colour15. Hysi et al.15 analysed a subset of participants in a very large population health cohort of British individuals, UK Biobank, in addition to a similar number of individuals from 23andMe, totalling 290,891. This report, however, mostly considered hair colour as a single ordered variable including red hair. This has the potential to mask associations due to differences in genetic architecture for separate categories of hair colour.
We report here the analysis of the majority of UK Biobank, a total of almost 350,000 subjects. By performing genome-wide analyses across hair colours, we have discovered novel variation in and around MC1R that contributes to red hair. Furthermore, we identify eight additional variants that explain most of the SNP heritability of red hair, including variants at ASIP, where an eQTL shows epistatic interactions with the poorly penetrant MC1R variants. Additional epistatic interactions are seen between MC1R and the HERC2/OCA2 locus and with PKHD1. Furthermore, we identify more than 200 genetic variants independently associated with multiple hair colours on the spectrum of blond to black. Notably, we find that many of the associated genes seem not to be involved in melanocyte biology per se, but are rather involved in hair growth or texture. This highlights the importance of the melanocyte–keratinocyte interactions in the determination of hair pigmentation and the impact of hair shape on colour perception.
Results and Discussion
Participants in UK Biobank responded to the question “what is your natural hair colour” with one of six possible answers. We used only self-reported, white British individuals, confirmed by genotype16. In addition, of the individuals who were third-degree relatives (first cousins) or closer, identified by genotyping16, only one of any related group was analysed. This left 343,234 participants with hair colours shown in Table 1. The white non-British individuals and the relatives removed from the primary analysis were subsequently analysed to validate the genetic risk scores that we derive.
Generally the frequencies of different hair colours are comparable to other populations with considerable Northern European ancestry, such as the QIMR cohort from Australia15, but as expected the prevalence of red hair is higher and black hair is lower than in Southern European cohorts. Within UK Biobank a higher proportion of females report red or blonde hair than males and a much lower proportion of females report black hair. Whilst there may be some self-reporting bias, we and others have previously shown using colorimetry that females on average have hair that is both more red and lighter3,17.
Genotypes for more than 800,000 SNPs and indels were directly assayed by UK Biobank using custom Affymetrix arrays, and an additional ~40 M variants imputed using the Haplotype Reference Consortium panel16.
Red hair colour and MC1R
We performed a GWAS comparing individuals with red hair to a combined group of black- and brown-haired individuals. Accounting for genetic structure within the UK Biobank by inclusion of the first 15 genetic principal components adequately controlled the genomic inflation in our analysis (λGC 1.024). The strongest association with red hair is located around the MC1R gene on human chromosome 16 (Fig. 1a, Supplementary Table 1, Supplementary Figure 1a), which fits with the expectation that this locus is the principal genetic factor determining red hair colour. We find that the strongest signal of association in the region of MC1R (rs34357723; OR 9.59, p < 2.25×10−308) does not originate from any observed amino acid changes, but is an SNP located some 97 kb from the 5′ end of MC1R and remains significant even after adjusting for all coding variants in MC1R. As we know that multiple MC1R alleles affect red hair colour, we performed stepwise conditional association testing and identified 31 additional association signals in this region at genome-wide levels of statistical significance (p ≤ 5×10−8), altering the odds of having red hair compared to brown and black hair (Supplementary Table 1). Only ten association signals can be directly attributed to amino acid changes, nonsense or frameshift mutations within the MC1R coding region. Included in these are two missense variants rs368507952 (R306H) and rs200000734 (R213W) not previously associated with red hair colour.
In addition to these 10 coding variants, we find 21 associations beyond the MC1R coding region at distances up a megabase both 3′ and 5′. These distant associations have been observed in other studies2,12. Although these variants potentially could affect long-range regulatory elements of MC1R, it is likely that they are synthetic associations caused by low linkage disequilibrium (LD) between the associated SNPs and multiple coding variants.
We asked how many cases of red hair can be accounted for by MC1R coding variation. We included rs3212379, located only 120 bp 5′ of the transcription start site of MC1R, as a candidate transcriptional regulatory variant. Including this variant, the two newly associated missense variants described above and 13 previously described coding variants we find that the proportion of red-haired individuals with two MC1R alleles is 92%, whilst only 6.3% carry a single allele. The cases of red hair with only one or no variants (similar to that seen in a study of an Australian cohort6) may be explained by, for instance, (a) rare coding variant alleles not genotyped or imputed in this study, (b) additional extragenic variation affecting MC1R expression, (c) dominant action of specific alleles, (d) variation in other genes in the same or a parallel pathway or (e) misreporting of hair colour.
It is well established that different MC1R coding variants have different penetrance with respect to red hair (termed “R” and “r” for high and low penetrance)6. With this very large cohort we are able to more precisely quantify the degree of penetrance of each allele, whether as homozygotes or in combination with any other allele. (Fig. 2, Supplementary Table 2). Similar to others we find that penetrance of missense variants ranges from less than 1% as homozygotes (V60L, V92M) to over 90% (D294H). Given the large odds ratios (OR) we consider the three newly identified variants to be high penetrance alleles. We also calculated the minor allele frequency and the OR for red hair for all analysed variants (Table 2). When analysed without conditioning, the three “r” variants have ORs less than 1, as previously described18. However, when conditioning on multiple high penetrance variants, the OR for V60L is >3 indicating its effect occurs primarily in combination with other alleles.
Additional red hair colour-associated loci
In addition to the associations around MC1R on chromosome 16, we observe 8 additional associations at genome-wide significance (Supplementary Table 1). Statistical fine-mapping of causal SNPs (PICS)19 in some cases indicated a single likely casual variant, whilst in others one of more than 50 variants could potentially be the causal SNP. We find a previously unreported association at rs276645354, at which the minor allele reduces the probability of red hair. This variant lies less than 2 kb from transcriptional start site (TSS) of POMC, which encodes α-MSH, the agonist of MC1R. Increased expression of POMC is likely to promote melanogenic signalling and thus dampen the effect of those MC1R variants which have some, albeit reduced, signalling activity. A single variant in an intron of RALY, located 5′ of ASIP, the gene encoding the inverse agonist of MC1R, was associated with red hair. This variant, rs6059655, is also an expression QTL (eQTL) for ASIP expression in skin, with the red-hair-associated allele showing higher mean expression levels20 (www.gtexportal.org) (Fig. 3a). We suggest that variants that increase ASIP expression in the skin or hair follicles lead to greater competition with α-MSH for melanocyte MC1R binding, antagonising melanogenic induction and increasing the pheomelanin in melanocytes.
We find a variant in HERC2 associated with a decreased probability of red hair. It is well established that variants in HERC2 alter transcription of the neighbouring pigmentation gene OCA2 which is additionally associated with blue eyes and blonde hair colour12,21,22,23,24. Recessive mutations in OCA2 result in albinism. It is possible that varied expression of OCA2 modifies the effect of reduced signalling though variant MC1R, such that red hair colour is not expressed.
An association is also seen in the TSPAN10 gene, also known as oculospanin, which is highly expressed in melanocytes and retinal pigment epithelium. The lead SNP lies in strong LD (r2 = 0.995) with a non-synonymous variant (rs6420484; Y177C) affecting a conserved amino acid. This association signal is also in moderate LD (r2 ~ 0.4, D′ ≥ 0.95) with a previously reported association with increased hue-saturation of eye colour, which corresponds to darker eyes, in a Dutch cohort25. Previous targeted knockdown of the murine Tspan10 mRNA resulted in reduced melanocyte migration in a trans-well migration assay26, indicating this gene may be a good functional candidate as a novel hair colour gene.
Epistasis between alleles at MC1R and other loci
Detecting epistasis in complex traits is challenging. Epistatic effects are believed to be much smaller than main effects, which are typically already very small in the case of polygenic traits. However, due to the large effects of some genetic variants on hair colour this might be a more tractable model to detect epistasis. We tested all associated genetic variants from our analysis of red hair colour against each of the MC1R coding variants, including the known “R” and “r” MC1R red hair colour alleles, by constructing a logistic regression model whilst correcting for relevant covariates (see Methods). At a P value of 3.9×10−7 (i.e. 0.05/128,205, the number of statistical tests performed), we found consistent epistasis signals between MC1R variation and a ±1.5 MB region surrounding rs6059655, which is the hair colour-associated ASIP eQTL SNP (Fig. 3b, d, Supplementary Figure 2, Supplementary Table 3). We also detect epistasis between both rs1805005 (V60L) and rs1805008 (R160W) and the HERC2/OCA2 region. It has been noted previously that OCA2 variation affects the penetrance of the weaker red hair alleles of MC1R6. Finally, we also find evidence of epistasis between V60L and PKHD1 on chromosome 6. The magnitude of the UK Biobank cohort has allowed the identification of hitherto unknown epistatic interactions contributing to red hair.
Genome-wide association analysis of blonde hair colour
Whilst red hair is essentially a Mendelian trait modified by additional loci, the genetic architecture of blonde hair colour is concordant with a polygenic trait. We performed a genome-wide association analysis comparing blonde hair to combined brown and black hair-coloured individuals. Following conditional association testing to uncover additional signals of association, we discover 213 lead variants associated with blonde hair colour (Fig. 1b, Supplementary Table 4, Supplementary Figure 1b). In many cases multiple signals of association are found close to the same genes. This could be a result of multiple, independent associations (as is the case for MC1R, for example). Alternatively some or all signals may each be correlated with the same variant that has been neither genotyped nor imputed. Many signals of association are close to, or within, previously known pigmentation genes from both human and model organism studies These allelic effects span a spectrum of OR and minor allele frequencies consistent with many other phenotypes with an underlying polygenic architecture27,28 (Fig. 4a). Using probabilistic association of causal SNPs (PICS)19 on these independent variants we are able to find 64 which were likely to be to a single candidate causal SNP, amongst which are 23 coding variants (7of which lie within MC1R). Several variants notably stand out, which have been previously associated with a variety of pigmentation related traits in humans (including SLC24A4, HERC2/OCA2, SLC45A2, TYR, TYRP1, EDNRB), some of which have been specifically linked to alterations in transcriptional regulation (IRF4 and KITLG)29,30.
Genes associated with red hair colour, in particular MC1R, are also identified in our blonde hair analysis. Although 93% of individuals with red hair carry two MC1R variants, these make up only 15% of people who carry two MC1R variants. The majority of people with two variants have blonde (15%) or light brown hair (41%). The proportion of individuals with blonde hair decreases with one or no variants whilst the proportion with dark brown and black increases (Supplementary Table 5). We show the incidence of different hair colours on each combination of MC1R variants in Supplementary Figures 3−6.
Given the observed differences in red and blonde hair frequency between males and females, we performed association analyses separately for each gender. Directly comparing the ORs of all significantly associated variants for males and females we find a strong correlation between the sexes (Supplementary Figures 7−8).
We compared our results for both red and blonde hair with those of Hysi et al.15. The variants we identify correspond to 163 distinct genes, of which 93 are also reported by Hysi et al. Conversely, they report 137 significantly associated lead variants, 23 of which we did not analyse because they did not pass our quality control. Of the remaining 114, only 73 show a significant association in our study. However, to better compare the results we looked for significant associations within fixed genomic distances from the 137 of Hysi et al. Within 10 kb of their associated variants we find 93 associations, and within 100 kb we find 100 (Supplementary Table 6). Hence 43% of the genes we identify are novel, and we find 73% of those found by Hysi et al.
Genome-wide association analysis of brown hair colour
Based on the large number of associations with blonde hair, we hypothesised that hair colour may lie on a continuous genetic spectrum from black to blonde through brown hair. Thus, we might expect to observe a subset of the blonde-associated variants associated with brown hair. Following both primary and conditional analyses we find 56 lead variants associated with brown vs. black hair (Fig. 1c, Supplementary Figure 1c, Supplementary Table 7), 28 of which are the same associated variant with blond hair and with the same direction of effect. Of the remaining lead variants 23 identify the same genes seen in our blonde hair analysis, and further 3 are associated with red hair. Of the two novel genes, KRT31 lies within a large locus encoding multiple keratin genes, in which we also observe associations with blonde hair. Only PIGU does not have a significant association with other hair colours, although we observe an association with another member of the same gene family, PIGV, suggesting that paralogous genes may be associated with hair colour differences. Additional GWAS of light brown and dark brown hair colours as expected identify more associations when light brown is compared to dark brown/ black than when brown is taken as a single category. Fewer associations are seen with dark brown alone vs. black (Supplementary Figures 9 and 10).
Polygenic phenotype scoring
To test the hypothesis that the genetic basis of hair colour is polygenic and that hair colour falls on a continuum as a genetic trait, we constructed a polygenic score for hair colour. Specifically we constructed a blonde hair colour polygenic phenotype score by taking the variants that reached genome-wide significance in the blonde vs. brown and black hair colour conditional analysis (5×10−8), as a linear combination of the allele-weighted regularised logistic regression coefficients. We found that self-reported black, dark brown, light brown and blond hair lie on an approximately linear spectrum (Fig. 4b). We confirmed the same pattern across hair colours in two groups of individuals excluded from all previous analyses; related individuals (Supplementary Figure 11a) and individuals with European, but non-British ancestry (Supplementary Figure 11b).
Additionally we calculated the SNP heritability of the different hair colours in the Biobank cohort (Supplementary Table 8). We estimate the SNP heritability of red hair to be 0.403, blonde as 0.301 and brown as 0.234. Removing the MC1R-associated variants on chromosome 16 results in a residual model for red hair with SNP heritability of just 0.018; MC1R therefore explains 73% of the observed red hair heritability. Removing all variants associated with red hair, we find a heritability estimate of 0.041 which indicates that the identified loci explain ~90% of the heritability of red hair. Performing the equivalent analysis for blonde hair shows that the identified loci account for 73% of the SNP heritability, and for brown hair the identified loci account for 47% of the SNP heritability.
In order to aid the interpretation of our GWAS and identify functional hypotheses, we tested associated variants for statistical colocalisation with eQTL signals from skin biopsies in the GTex20 (Supplementary Tables 9−14) and TwinsUK cohorts31, (Supplementary Tables 15−17). We were able to link 37 variants with cis eQTLs with high probability (posterior probability > 0.8). Among the variants with the highest probability are at RALY, upstream of ASIP as noted above and in the first intron of TSPAN10 for red hair. Most of the eQTLs are associated with gene expression at considerable distance and often with several genes. Among the most significant eQTLs, across all three datasets, are several missense variants in MC1R, which are independently linked to expression changes in multiple genes located up to several hundred kb from MC1R. These may well be synthetic associations reflecting weak LD and the unusual behaviour of this segment of the genome. Whist the colocalisation of hair colour association signals with skin tissue cis-eQTLs may appear promising, they are at best a strong indication of biological effect and will require extensive further hypothesis testing to establish any role in determining pigmentation.
Hair colour loci are enriched for regulatory features
To understand the transcriptional regulatory mechanisms that might underpin the observed genetic associations with hair colour, we examined the potential for these variants to affect the chromatin landscape in cell types relevant to pigmentation. Specifically, we tested histone tail modifications associated with gene activation or repression and with chromatin accessibility (DNase I hypersensitive sites) in melanocytes, keratinocytes, fibroblasts and other cells. Additionally, the proximity of several association signals to core promoter regions raises the possibility of alterations to TSS and pigmentation cell-specific regulatory factors, i.e. the melanogenesis master regulator MITF.
Using a permutation-based approach (GoShifter)32, we tested each annotation in each cell type where data were available (Table 3). We find statistical evidence of enrichment of pigmentation-associated genetic variation overlapping histone marks of both gene activation (H3K4me3) in melanocytes and repression (H3K9me3, H3K27me3) in melanocytes, fibroblasts and keratinocytes. In addition there is enrichment of MITF binding sites in melanocytes and TSS in iris pigmentation cells. These associations give strong support to the notion that we are able to identify functional elements altered by genetic variation.
Enrichment for skin and hair genes
To further aid the interpretation of our GWAS findings, and identify shared biological pathways related to pigmentation determination, we took all of the blonde hair lead variants overlapping genic regions extending 2 kb upstream of the TSS and 500 bp downstream of the 3′ end. If no genic region overlapped the lead SNP, then we used the two closest genes within 500 kb (Supplementary Table 18). These candidate genes were then used as input to test for enrichment in known pigmentation phenotypes, utilising the MouseMine database33. We identified ~200 orthologous mouse genes in the database, which we analysed for site of expression and mutational phenotypes. Of the 172 genes with expression data, 89 were expressed in the skin (P = 1.3×10−9) (Supplementary Table 19). One hundred and thirty-two genes had mouse mutant phenotype data and of these, 50 had an integument phenotype (affecting the skin and skin appendages) (P = 5.2×10−7). Not surprisingly, 18 of these affected pigmentation, but we unexpectedly found that 70% affect primarily skin, hair or other skin appendages rather than pigmentation (Table 4).
Follicular melanocytes, keratinocytes and dermal papilla cells have mutual interactions; the dermal papilla signals to melanocytes with ASIP, the melanocytes transfer melanin granules into the keratinocytes. Perturbations of these interactions could affect the amount and type of melanin delivered to the hair. Furthermore, variation in growth rate could impact the effectiveness of melanin transfer. Recent GWAS have identified 14 loci associated with hair shape variation34. Remarkably, we have identified seven of these, ERRFI1, FRAS1, HOXC13, PADI3, KRTAP, PEX14 and LGR4 as affecting blonde/non-blonde hair colour (P = 1×10−11, Fisher’s exact test). In addition, the refractive and reflective properties of individual hairs may affect perceived colour35 and there is evidence that different coloured hairs have different morphology. Vaughn et al. have demonstrated a strong inverse correlation between the lightness of hair colour and the diameter of the shaft; blonde hair is thinner than dark36.
In summary, the very large dataset provided by UK Biobank has enabled us to dissect the complex genetic nature of hair colour. This forms the foundation for functional analysis linking genetic variation to phenotype and exploring the cellular interactions between melanocytes and other cells in the hair follicle.
Study individuals were derived from the UK Biobank cohort that consists of 502,655 individuals aged between 40 and 69 years at recruitment, ascertained from 22 centres across the UK between 2006 and 2010. The study was approved by the National Research Ethics Committee, reference 11/NW/0382, and informed consent was obtained from all participants as part of the recruitment and assessment process. From these, we analysed 343,234 unrelated individuals, who reported their background as “British” and with similar ancestral backgrounds based on PCA16.
Genotype quality control
Variants included in the analysis were autosomal SNPs present in HRC imputation file, with a χ2 P value for the Hardy−Weinberg equilibrium >10−10 (calculated using plink and unrelated white British individuals), a call rate >0.95 in unrelated white British individuals, a UKBB imputation score > 0.9 and an MAF >10−4. The number of SNPs analysed after quality control is 9,154,080.
Phenotype quality control
Self-reported hair colour (before greying occurred) for UK Biobank participants was selected from one of eight possible categories: “Blonde”, “Red”, “Light brown”, “Dark brown”, “Black”, “Other”, “Prefer not to answer”. The number of individuals in each category are: Red: 15,731, blonde: 39,397, light brown: 141,414, dark brown: 127,980, black: 14,526, other: 4186, Do not know/Prefer not to answer: 650. Individuals with missing data (“Prefer not to answer”, “Other”, “Do not know”) were excluded from all the analysis. For the red hair colour against brown and black hair colour, the blonde individuals were removed (red = 15,731, non-red = 283,920) and self-reported red hair individuals were removed from the blonde against brown and black analysis (blonde = 39,397, non-blonde = 283,920). For the comparison of brown vs. black, light and dark brown individuals were combined and compared to black hair individuals (brown = 269,394, black = 14,526).
Genome-wide association and conditional analysis
Following individual and genotype-level QC, a logistic regression model was used to regress presence/absence of each hair colour on bi-allelic variant genotype assuming a (log) additive model, adjusting for the first 15 axes of variation from the PCA and genotyping batch (Eq. (1)).
Conditional analyses used the same multivariate logistic regression model above, with the addition of the lead SNP (denoted by βAglead) from each signal of association .
In the chromosomes where more than one signal of association was apparent (lead SNP p ≤ 5×10−8), subsequent rounds of conditional analysis were performed, adding each new lead SNP as an extra conditioning SNP (denoted by βAglead, where Aglead in Eq. (2) is a matrix of individual lead SNP genotypes). To start this stepwise procedure, we first removed the SNPs with P value > 0.1 in the initial GWAS, and then performed the conditional analysis until no single SNP association exceeded p ≤ 5×10−8. Then, SNPs with an initial P value > 0.1 were included again and the conditional analysis continued until no SNPs exceeded P ≤ 5×10−8. There were just three SNPs that were ~10−8 in blonde hair colour, and only one extra round of conditional analysis was needed. PLINK v1.9 was used for the regression analysis and Manhattan and Q-Q plots were generated using the R package qqman37 and ggplot2.
The penetrance of allelic combinations was calculated by summing the number of individuals of a particular hair colour with a given allelic combination over the sum of all individuals (all hair colours) with that allele combination. The calculation and plot were made using the .ped and .map plink files, and plotting was performed using ggplot2 in R.
Probabilistic inference of causal SNPs
We implemented the probabilistic inference of causal SNPs (PICS)19 which takes into account the strength of association of the lead genetic variant and the LD structure in the fine-mapping interval to calculate the posterior probability that a particular genetic variant is the causal variant given that another variant is the lead variant. PICS calculates the conditional posterior probability P(Bcausal|Alead), that is the probability that SNP B is the causal variant given SNP A is the lead SNP. Under the assumption that effect sizes for non-causal SNPs are drawn from a Normal distribution, N(μ,σ2), Farh et al. derive from empirical data the sample standard deviation, σs, and the expected mean association signal, μs, which scales linearly with the LD to the true causal SNP.
where indexP is the −log10P of association of the causal SNP for that locus, which is taken to be the lead SNP for that fine-mapping interval. The calculated posterior probabilities were used to construct 95% credible intervals, defining the resolution of fine-mapping over a given genomic interval.
Variants within 3.0 Mb of the index SNP (±1.5 Mb either direction) for each signal of association were selected for epistasis analysis. Explicit testing of interactions between MC1R non-synonymous variants and red hair colour-associated loci was performed by comparing the following full (5) and reduced (6) logistic regression models:
where β0 is the model intercept, βgA is the regression coefficient for SNP A, βgA is the regression coefficient for SNP B and βgAgB is the joint regression coefficient for SNPs A and B, i.e. the interaction term. Covariates were included in the model, denoted by the model term βX. For instance, population structure confounding may be accounted for by including N principal components in the model as covariates. Significance testing was performed using a likelihood ratio test, comparing model (5), with the reduced model (6) that omitted the interaction term, βgAgB. Epistasis testing was performed using cassi (see URLs) using the --lr command. Due to complex LD structure around the MC1R region it was necessary to remove variants in LD (r2 ≥ 0.1) with the target variant in each case. Additionally, SNP alleles that co-occur on the same haplotypes, but are in imperfect LD, may generate the false impression of interactions, Wood et al.38. suggest including the main effects as covariates to remove these false interactions. Therefore, in the SNPs where there was apparent epistasis in chromosome 16, we corrected for rs34357723 and the MC1R SNPs (Table 2), and if there were still signs of epistasis, we corrected for all the significant SNPs in the red vs. brown and black hair conditional analysis (Supplementary Table 1). Correcting for these SNPs we removed most of the epistasis signals on chromosome 16.
Hair colour polygenic scoring
In order to calculate the hair colour genetic score we performed least absolute shrinkage and selection operator (LASSO). A penalised logistic regression model was created for blonde colour, including all lead variants for blonde vs. black and brown hair colour. The parameter λ was selected using the most regularized model from a ten-fold cross validation, within one standard error of the minimum using the glmnet package in R39. The regularized effect estimates were used to create genetic scores for blonde hair colour, assuming an additive genetic model. Non-British (n = 44,595) and related (n = 64,571) individuals were taken as independent test for the blonde hair genetic scoring. The summed genetic score for each individual was calculated using Plink v1.9.
Bed format files were downloaded for epigenetic marks associated with activated or accessible chromatin from the Roadmap Epigenome and ENCODE project websites (October 2017). Files were downloaded for annotations in primary melanocytes, keratinocytes, and fibroblasts included in the Roadmap Epigenome Project. Annotations were H3K4me1, H3K4me3, H3K27ac and DNase I hypersensitive sites (DHS; where available). Primary melanocyte, keratinocyte and other pigmentation cell type transcriptional start site (TSS ± 100 bp) data were downloaded from the FANTOM5 website (October 2017).
Micropthalmia-associated transcription factor is generally considered the master regulator of melanogenesis in melanocytes. Short read data were downloaded from SRA corresponding to MITF ChIP-seq data derived from primary melanocytes and the melanocytic cell line Hermes3A40,41,42. Short sequencing reads were extracted using fastq-dump and assessed for quality using fastQC (see URLs). Reads were processed in order to remove adaptor contamination using trimmomatic and then aligned to GRCh37/hg19 using BWA-aln43. As there are no replicates in the ChIP-seq data, peaks were called with MACS244 with an FDR 1%. For each cell type and annotation where more than one sample existed, intervals were merged using Bedtools45 intersect intersect for two files and multiIntersectBed for >2 files per cell type. To test for genomic enrichment we used a method that tests for the local enrichment of lead variants and those in LD with genomic features by randomly shifting annotations to generate a null distribution; implemented in GoShifter32. LD values calculated from the 1000 Genomes phase 3 EUR reference panel were used in conjunction with the lead variant from each independent signal of association (after conditional analyses). GoShifter was run for 10,000 permutations and enrichment P values were adjusted for multiple testing using the Benjamini and Hochberg procedure implemented in the R function p.adjust with a 5% FDR.
To test for the potential of non-coding association signals to impact on gene regulation, we utilised eQTL summary statistics from the GTex20,46 and MuTHER31,47 studies in tissues relevant to pigmentation (MuTHER; skin biopsies, GTex; sun-exposed and sun not-exposed skin tissue). Summary statistics for genes that fell within 3 Mb intervals of the lead SNP of each association signal were extracted. We wished to test the explicit hypothesis that the same causal variants underlie each eQTL and our association signal for each hair colour (HA). Subsequently the null hypothesis is a compound null of no association for either trait (H01) and the combinations of overlapping but independent eQTL and trait associations (H02) and an association in one trait/eQTL but not the other (H03 and H04). A Bayesian testing framework that tests the set of hypotheses relating to those defined above (H01−4 and HA) was developed by Giambartolomei et al.48 and is implemented in the R package coloc. Subsequently, we report the posterior probability for each association signal-gene eQTL signal and the alternative hypothesis HA (PP4).
Hysi et al. comparison
Hysi et al.15 report 141 significant SNPs in 123 different loci in a meta analysis of UKBiobank phase 1 and 23andme data. As the Hysi et al. analysis takes hair colour as a quantitative variable (1 = blonde, 2 = red, 3 = light brown, 4 = dark brown and 5 = black), we could not compare the results directly. To compare the results, we took their significant SNPs and then we took the lowest P value in our GWAS analyses (red vs. non-red, blonde vs. non-blonde or brown vs. black) and calculated the overlap between their significant SNPs and ours. We also ran a new GWAS taking hair colour as a quantitative variable and compared our results to Hysi et al. Some of the SNPs reported in their analysis do not pass our QC, so they have been reported as missing SNPs (NA). Finally, we calculated the overlap with significant SNPs in our data for different distances (1kb, 5kb, 10kb, 50kb, 100kb, 500kb) around SNPs reported significant in the Hysi et al. paper.
Genotype by sex interactions
UK Biobank unrelated white British data consist in 184,929 females and 158,957 males. In females 12.7% have blonde hair and 5.2% have red hair, while in males 9.9% have blonde hair and 3.7% have red hair. We performed a GWAS for red vs. non-red (excluding blonde hair individuals) and blonde vs. non-blonde (excluding red hair individuals) for males and females separately. With SNPs significant in at least one of the GWAS results (male or female) we did a linear regression of the OR for each hair colour, to see the different effects of the SNPs in different sexes. Using LD Score49,50 we calculated the genetic correlation between males and females for blonde and red hair colours
LD score was also used to calculate SNP heritability for hair colour. To calculate the amount of heritability explained by the significant SNPs we removed these SNPs from the analysis and we calculated the heritability again, the change in heritability is the heritability explained by the SNPs we removed. In red hair individuals, we were also interested in the heritability explained by chromosome 16, so we removed the significant SNPs in chromosome 16 and calculated again the heritability of red hair
Twins UK: http://www.muther.ac.uk/
Roadmap Epigenomics Project: www.roadmapepigenomics.org/data/
Summary statistics can be obtained on request from the authors. The raw genetic and phenotypic data that support the findings of this study are available from UK Biobank, but restrictions apply to the availability of these data, which were used under licence for the current study, and so are not publicly available. Data are, however, available from the authors on reasonable request and with permission from UK Biobank (http://www.ukbiobank.ac.uk). A Reporting Summary for this Article is available as a Supplementary Information file.
Lin, B. D. et al. Heritability and genome-wide association studies for hair color in a Dutch twin family based sample. Genes (Basel) 6, 559–576 (2015).
Sulem, P. et al. Genetic determinants of hair, eye and skin pigmentation in Europeans. Nat. Genet. 39, 1443–1452 (2007).
Mengel-From, J., Wong, T. H., Morling, N., Rees, J. L. & Jackson, I. J. Genetic determinants of hair and eye colours in the Scottish and Danish populations. BMC Genet. 10, 88 (2009).
Valverde, P., Healy, E., Jackson, I., Rees, J. L. & Thody, A. J. Variants of the melanocyte-stimulating hormone receptor gene are associated with red hair and fair skin in humans. Nat. Genet. 11, 328–330 (1995).
Box, N. F., Wyeth, J. R., O’Gorman, L. E., Martin, N. G. & Sturm, R. A. Characterization of melanocyte stimulating hormone receptor variant alleles in twins with red hair. Hum. Mol. Genet. 6, 1891–1897 (1997).
Duffy, D. L. et al. Interactive effects of MC1R and OCA2 on melanoma risk phenotypes. Hum. Mol. Genet. 13, 447–461 (2004).
Suzuki, I. et al. Agouti signaling protein inhibits melanogenesis and the response of human melanocytes to alpha-melanotropin. J. Invest. Dermatol. 108, 838–842 (1997).
Ollmann, M. M., Lamoreux, M. L., Wilson, B. D. & Barsh, G. S. Interaction of Agouti protein with the melanocortin 1 receptor in vitro and in vivo. Genes Dev. 12, 316–330 (1998).
Sulem, P. et al. Two newly identified genetic determinants of pigmentation in Europeans. Nat. Genet. 40, 835–837 (2008).
Duffy, D. L. et al. Multiple pigmentation gene polymorphisms account for a substantial proportion of risk of cutaneous malignant melanoma. J. Invest. Dermatol. 130, 520–528 (2010).
Eriksson, N. et al. Web-based, participant-driven studies yield novel genetic associations for common traits. PLoS Genet. 6, e1000993 (2010).
Han, J. et al. A genome-wide association study identifies novel alleles associated with hair color and skin pigmentation. PLoS Genet. 4, e1000074 (2008).
Zhang, M. et al. Genome-wide association studies identify several new loci associated with pigmentation traits and skin cancer risk in European Americans. Hum. Mol. Genet. 22, 2948–2959 (2013).
Gerstenblith, M. R., Shi, J. & Landi, M. T. Genome-wide association studies of pigmentation and skin cancer: a review and meta-analysis. Pigment. Cell. Melanoma Res. 23, 587–606 (2010).
Hysi, P. G. et al. Genome-wide association meta-analysis of individuals of European ancestry identifies new loci explaining a substantial fraction of hair color variation and heritability. Nat. Genet. 50, 652–656 (2018).
Bycroft, C. et al. The UK Biobank resource with deep phenotyping and genomic data. Nature 562, 203–209 (2018).
Shekar, S. N. et al. Spectrophotometric methods for quantifying pigmentation in human hair-influence of MC1R genotype and environment. Photochem. Photobiol. 84, 719–726 (2008).
Raimondi, S. et al. MC1R variants, melanoma and red hair color phenotype: a meta-analysis. Int. J. Cancer 122, 2753–2760 (2008).
Farh, K. K. et al. Genetic and epigenetic fine mapping of causal autoimmune disease variants. Nature 518, 337–343 (2015).
Lonsdale, J. et al. The Genotype-Tissue Expression (GTEx) project. Nat. Genet. 45, 580–585 (2013).
Eiberg, H. et al. Blue eye color in humans may be caused by a perfectly associated founder mutation in a regulatory element located within the HERC2 gene inhibiting OCA2 expression. Hum. Genet. 123, 177–187 (2008).
Kayser, M. et al. Three genome-wide association studies and a linkage analysis identify HERC2 as a human iris color gene. Am. J. Hum. Genet. 82, 411–423 (2008).
Sturm, R. A. et al. A single SNP in an evolutionary conserved region within intron 86 of the HERC2 gene determines human blue-brown eye color. Am. J. Hum. Genet. 82, 424–431 (2008).
Visser, M., Kayser, M. & Palstra, R. J. HERC2 rs12913832 modulates human pigmentation by attenuating chromatin-loop formation between a long-range enhancer and the OCA2 promoter. Genome Res. 22, 446–455 (2012).
Liu, F. et al. Digital quantification of human eye color highlights genetic association of three new loci. PLoS Genet. 6, e1000934 (2010).
Seong, I. et al. Sox10 controls migration of B16F10 melanoma cells through multiple regulatory target genes. PLoS ONE 7, e31477 (2012).
Yang, J. et al. Common SNPs explain a large proportion of the heritability for human height. Nat. Genet. 42, 565–569 (2010).
Yang, J. et al. Ubiquitous polygenicity of human complex traits: genome-wide analysis of 49 traits in Koreans. PLoS Genet. 9, e1003355 (2013).
Praetorius, C. et al. A polymorphism in IRF4 affects human pigmentation through a tyrosinase-dependent MITF/TFAP2A pathway. Cell 155, 1022–1033 (2013).
Guenther, C. A., Tasic, B., Luo, L., Bedell, M. A. & Kingsley, D. M. A molecular basis for classic blond hair color in Europeans. Nat. Genet. 46, 748–752 (2014).
Grundberg, E. et al. Mapping cis- and trans-regulatory effects across multiple tissues in twins. Nat. Genet. 44, 1084–1089 (2012).
Trynka, G. et al. Disentangling the effects of colocalizing genomic annotations to functionally prioritize non-coding variants within complex-trait loci. Am. J. Hum. Genet. 97, 139–152 (2015).
Motenko, H., Neuhauser, S. B., O’Keefe, M. & Richardson, J. E. MouseMine: a new data warehouse for MGI. Mamm. Genome 26, 325–330 (2015).
Liu, F. et al. Meta-analysis of genome-wide association studies identifies 8 novel loci involved in shape variation of human head hair. Hum. Mol. Genet. 27, 559–575 (2018).
Bustard, H. K. & Smith, R. W. Investigation into the scattering of light by human hair. Appl. Opt. 30, 3485–3491 (1991).
Vaughn, M. R., Brooks, E., van Oorschot, R. A. & Baindur-Hudson, S. A comparison of macroscopic and microscopic hair color measurements and a quantification of the relationship between hair color and thickness. Microsc. Microanal. 15, 189–193 (2009).
Turner, S. D. qqman: an R package for visualizing GWAS results using Q-Q and manhattan plots. Preprint at https://doi.org/10.1101/005165 (2014).
Wood, A. R. et al. Another explanation for apparent epistasis. Nature 514, E3–E5 (2014).
Friedman, J. H., Hastie, T. & Tibshirani, R. Regularization paths for generalized linear models via coordinate descent. J. Stat. Softw. 33, 1–22 (2010).
Laurette, P. et al. Transcription factor MITF and remodeller BRG1 define chromatin organisation at regulatory elements in melanoma cells. eLife 4, e06857 (2015).
Strub, T. et al. Essential role of microphthalmia transcription factor for DNA replication, mitosis and genomic stability in melanoma. Oncogene 30, 2319–2332 (2011).
Webster, D. E. et al. Enhancer-targeted genome editing selectively blocks innate resistance to oncokinase inhibition. Genome Res. 24, 751–760 (2014).
Li, H. & Durbin, R. Fast and accurate short read alignment with Burrows-Wheeler transform. Bioinformatics 25, 1754–1760 (2009).
Zhang, Y. et al. Model-based analysis of ChIP-Seq (MACS). Genome Biol. 9, R137 (2008).
Quinlan, A. R. & Hall, I. M. BEDTools: a flexible suite of utilities for comparing genomic features. Bioinformatics 26, 841–842 (2010).
Lappalainen, T. et al. Transcriptome and genome sequencing uncovers functional variation in humans. Nature 501, 506–511 (2013).
Nica, A. C. et al. The architecture of gene regulatory variation across multiple human tissues: the MuTHER study. PLoS Genet. 7, e1002003 (2011).
Giambartolomei, C. et al. Bayesian test for colocalisation between pairs of genetic association studies using summary statistics. PLoS Genet. 10, e1004383 (2014).
Bulik-Sullivan, B. et al. An atlas of genetic correlations across human diseases and traits. Nat. Genet. 47, 1236–1241 (2015).
Bulik-Sullivan, B. K. et al. LD Score regression distinguishes confounding from polygenicity in genome-wide association studies. Nat. Genet. 47, 291–295 (2015).
This work was carried out under UK Biobank study number 7206. It was funded by MRC core support to the Human Genetics Unit and to the Computational Genomics Analysis and Training programme through grant G1000902 and by BBSRC funding through Strategic Grant funding to the Roslin Institute BB/P013759/1 and BB/P013732/1. We would like to thank Sebastian Luna-Valero for extensive systems admin support and the other members of the CGAT programme for numerous robust and constructive discussions.
The authors declare no competing interests.
Publisher’s note: Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.
About this article
Cite this article
Morgan, M.D., Pairo-Castineira, E., Rawlik, K. et al. Genome-wide study of hair colour in UK Biobank explains most of the SNP heritability. Nat Commun 9, 5271 (2018). https://doi.org/10.1038/s41467-018-07691-z
This article is cited by
Journal of Physiological Anthropology (2023)
Fine-mapping of retinal vascular complexity loci identifies Notch regulation as a shared mechanism with myocardial infarction outcomes
Communications Biology (2023)
Addressing the ethical and societal challenges posed by genome-wide association studies of behavioral and brain-related traits
Nature Neuroscience (2023)
Pediatric Research (2023)
Genome-wide analysis identifies genetic effects on reproductive success and ongoing natural selection at the FADS locus
Nature Human Behaviour (2023)