Selective conversion of an aqueous solution of mixed oxygenates produced by biomass fermentation to a value-added single product is pivotal for commercially viable biomass utilization. However, the efficiency and selectivity of the transformation remains a great challenge. Herein, we present a strategy capable of transforming ~70% of carbon in an aqueous fermentation mixture (ABE: acetone–butanol–ethanol–water) to 4-heptanone (4-HPO), catalyzed by tin-doped ceria (Sn-ceria), with a selectivity as high as 86%. Water (up to 27 wt%), detrimental to the reported catalysts for ABE conversion, was beneficial for producing 4-HPO, highlighting the feasibility of the current reaction system. In a 300 h continuous reaction over 2 wt% Sn-ceria catalyst, the average 4-HPO selectivity is maintained at 85% with 50% conversion and > 90% carbon balance. This strategy offers a route for highly efficient organic-carbon utilization, which can potentially integrate biological and chemical catalysis platforms for the robust and highly selective production of value-added chemicals.
With the development of sustainable energy and chemicals, interest in fermentation processes is reviving, because they can transform non-edible biomass feedstock to low-molecular-weight oxygenates, such as acetone, n-butanol, and ethanol in the acetone–butanol–ethanol–water (ABE) fermentation broth1,2. The crude fermentation broth contains low concentrations of oxygenates, which can be enriched by specific techniques such as pervaporation, gas stripping, and adsorption. However, the complexity/cost of the purification process limits its widespread practical applications. Thus, finding a method to directly and selectively convert crude aqueous oxygenate mixture to value-added chemicals, especially water-immiscible ones, thus allowing easy separation after reaction, is of great importance.
The efficiency and selectivity of the transformation process for biomass-derived intermediates remains a major techno-economic challenge3. Significantly, carbon–carbon coupling enables the conversion of small intermediate molecules to larger ones, which is critical for fuel production4,5,6,7. However, carbon–carbon cross-coupling between oxygenates is complicated. For homogeneous catalysts, although high yield can be achieved, the separation of the catalyst after reaction is difficult8,9. For heterogeneous catalysts, the selectivities for certain reactions are rather low10 and both types of catalysts demand high purity of feedstock11, which is a major obstacle to industrialization of biomass conversion. In ABE fermentation broth conversion, deprotonation of the C–H group at the α-positions of the primary products, including acetone, acetaldehyde, and butanal is not selective. Enolate intermediates generated in the process react with aldehyde or ketone to produce a randomly distributed ketone mixture with carbon number ranging from 5 to 11, which is ideal for fuel production but not enough for single chemical fabrication. Moreover, the presence of large amount of water deactivates the reported catalytic system in aqueous ABE solution12. It is pivotal to develop a highly efficient water-resistant catalyst for the direct conversion of crude aqueous oxygenate mixture.
Herein we report a simple reaction for the conversion of aqueous ABE fermentation broth, containing acetone, n-butanol, ethanol, acetic acid, and butyric acid to a water-immiscible product efficiently and selectively. Catalyzed by Sn-ceria catalyst, the biomass-derived oxygenates mixture was transformed to 4-heptanone (4-HPO) (a flexible precursor for the synthesis of various value-added chemicals or fuels (Supplementary Figure 1 and Supplementary Table 1)) with selectivity as high as 86%. A series of characterizations verified the importance of highly dispersed tin oxide and oxygen vacancies in the selective production of 4-HPO from the ABE mixture. A biomass conversion route to transform low-quality biomass fermentation broth to easily separable value-added product was constructed using this strategy, thereby greatly reducing process complexity.
Results and Discussion
First, a mixture of acetone, n-butanol, ethanol, and water in a f 9:51:1:22 ratio (by weight) was fed into a vertical fixed-bed reactor loaded with a ceria catalyst, which was prepared by a precipitation method13. Liquid products were collected using a cold-trap. Carbon balance, conversion, yield, and selectivity were calculated based on carbon number of each molecule, as per the following equations (see Supplementary Figure 2 and Supplementary Table 2).
where n(c)4-HPO is the number of moles of carbon atoms in 4-HPO, n(c)feed is the number of moles of carbon atoms in the feedstock, and n(c)liquid is the number of moles of carbon atoms in the liquid trapped in the tank, including products and unreacted feedstock. The terms n(c)liquid, butanol, n(c)liquid, acetone, and n(c)liquid, ethanol represent the number of moles of carbon atoms of n-butanol, acetone, and ethanol, respectively, trapped in the liquid. The terms n(c)gas is the number of moles of carbon atoms in gaseous products.
When the reaction was conducted at 400–420 °C over ceria catalyst, the liquid-phase product naturally separates into two layers: the light-yellow upper layer is the oil phase and the colorless bottom layer is the aqueous phase. The oil phase was found to consist of 78% 4-HPO and 15% 2-pentanone, whereas in the aqueous phase mainly unreacted acetone and water were detected. In the gas phase, < 4% CO2 was detected, demonstrating that most of the converted reactants have been fixed into liquid products. For comparison, no product was obtained in the uncatalyzed reaction (Table 1).
The reaction with pure oxygenate mixture without water was studied. Interestingly, the selectivity of 4-HPO decreased from 84% to 31% together with a decrease of conversion from 22% to 10%, suggesting that water is critical for the highly selective synthesis of 4-HPO in this system. (Fig. 1(a, b)). This also holds when using pure n-butanol or n-butanol/water as the feed (Supplementary Figure 3). Significantly, with n-butanol/water as the feed, 4-HPO was proposed to be produced by the following steps (Supplementary Figure 4): (i) dehydrogenation of n-butanol to butanal and hydrogen, (ii) esterification of butanol and butanal to butyl butyrate and hydrogen, (iii) reduction of ceria by hydrogen to produce oxygen vacancies, (iv) water dissociation on the oxygen vacancies to produce active oxygen (O*) and hydrogen, (v) aldol condensation of butanal to hydroxyaldehyde, (vi) reaction of hydroxyaldehyde with O* to form surface-adsorbed carboxylate, and finally, (vii) dehydrogenation and decarboxylation of the carboxylate to obtain 4-HPO14. In order to confirm the role of water in the oxygenate conversion process, isotope labeling experiments were conducted over ceria at 400 °C. Upon injecting D2O to the pretreated ceria in H2 at 400 °C, hydrogen deuteride and deuterium (HD and D2) are observed (Supplementary Figure 5), indicating that the water dissociates at the oxygen vacancies on the ceria surface to produce hydrogen and heal the defects15,16. When a mixture of n-butanol and D2O (5 mL and 1 mL, respectively) was injected and carried to the catalyst bed by Ar gas, the formation of H2 (m/z = 2), HD (m/z = 3), D2 (m/z = 4), and CO2 (m/z = 44) was immediately detected by on-line mass spectrometry, which confirms the role of water in the transformation of n-butanol. In all of the conducted five pulses, HD and D2 were detected (Fig. 1(c)).
To elucidate the reaction pathways for forming 4-HPO, ceria-catalyzed reactions with different mixed oxygenate substrates were conducted. For the substrate without n-butanol, condensation of acetone and ethanol can produce 4-HPO over ceria. The feed containing only ethanol generated 38% acetone, 31% 2-pentanone, 20% 2-pentanol, and 11% n-butanol in the liquid17. The condensation of 2-pentanone and ethanol selectively generated 4-HPO, confirmed by co-feeding 2-pentanone, and ethanol (Supplementary Figure 6). In addition, the feed containing only acetone resulted in self-condensation products of acetone, including 15% mesityl oxide, 7% isophorone, and the further isomerized (6% 4-methylpent-4-en-2-one) or hydrogenated products (5% 4-methylpentan-2-one). 3, 5-Dimethylphenol (26%), formed via demethanation of isophorone, and its derivative (13% 2, 4, 6-trimethylphenol), were also observed in the liquid phase18,19,20. However, this complex product distribution was not observed for ABE mixture conversion, suggesting that under our reaction condition, the condensation of acetone with ethanol is more favorable than the self-condensation of acetone. Acetone is a product of acetic acid ketonization reaction over acid-base catalysts21.
Interestingly, although ceria is a versatile catalyst for dehydrogenation, alcohol Guerbet reaction, condensation, and esterification reactions, all these reactions generate 4-HPO with high selectivity. Figure 1(d) illustrates the complicated reaction network with the feedstock of acetone, n-butanol, ethanol, and water, which could be summarized as follows:
(1) n-Butanol can be dehydrogenated to butanal, which reacts with water on reduced ceria catalyst to form 4-HPO, as confirmed by the result of co-feeding of butanal and water (Supplementary Figure 7).
(2) Besides acting as reactant, n-butanol is also a product generated via ethanol Guerbet reaction, from which 4-HPO was produced via route (1).
(3) n-Butanol can be dehydrogenated to butanal, and then to butyl butyrate via esterification of n-butanol and butanal. The reaction of butyl butyrate and water generates 4-HPO, experimentally confirmed by the co-feeding of butyl butyrate and water (Supplementary Figure 8).
(4) Dehydrogenation of ethanol produces acetaldehyde, which then condenses with acetone to give 2-pentanone, whose further condensation with ethanol produces 4-HPO.
Catalyst synthesis and characterization
From the above discussion, it is noteworthy that aldehydes produced by the dehydrogenation of ethanol and n-butanol are important precursors for selective 4-HPO generation. Promoters were introduced to ceria, to further enhance the dehydrogenation ability, including a series of metal oxides such as MgO, ZnO, Fe2O3, and SnO2. In the n-butanol dehydrogenation reaction (Supplementary Figure 9 (a)), butanal, which is a key intermediate for 4-HPO generation, was the major product obtained over these metal oxide catalysts, among which SnO2 offers the best selectivity toward butanal (over 99%). We then prepared a series of Sn-modified ceria catalysts with different approaches (marked A, B, C, and D) and employed them in aqueous ABE conversion (Supplementary Figure 9 (b)). Among these catalysts, the Sn-doped ceria catalyst (marked as Sn-ceria) prepared by co-precipitation (style D), showed the highest selectivity toward 4-HPO and the best catalytic stability (Supplementary Figure 9 (c)), the optimal loading for Sn being 2 wt% (Supplementary Figure 10). For comparison, 2 wt% In-, Fe-, and Zn-doped ceria catalyts were also prepared with the similar method. All of them showed less efficient catalytic performances with either moderate conversion or lower selectivity of 4-HPO (Table 1). Ceria can provide redox sites especially oxygen vacancies, for the condensation, esterification, and Guerbet reactions, whereas tin is proposed to promote catalytic hydrogen removal. We conducted X-ray diffraction (XRD), inductively coupled plasma (ICP) analysis, N2 adsorption–desorption, and transmission electron microscopy (TEM) experiments to characterize the best Sn-ceria catalysts (Fig. 2, Supplementary Figure 11-13, Supplementary Table 3-5). From the XRD profile, only the cubic phase of ceria is observed with Sn loading ≤ 5 wt% (please note the 5 wt% means that the weight loading of Sn added to the ceria catalyst is 5 wt%, whereas the loading amounts of the corresponding catalysts, determined by ICP, can be found in Supplementary Table 3). In contrast, the SnO2 phase appeared when 10 wt% and 20 wt% Sn was doped into the ceria catalysts (Fig. 2(a)). This indicates that when the loading of Sn is not too high, the tin species are highly dispersed over the ceria surface. The highly dispersed state of the tin species on 2 wt% Sn-ceria catalyst is further confirmed by TEM observations and energy dispersive spectroscopic elemental mappings, which show that the tin species are almost homogeneously distributed over the ceria surface and no aggregation or sintering of Sn is identified (Fig. 2(d)). This highly dispersed tin species may accelerate the dehydrogenation of the complex reaction network of ABE mixture transformation and drive the reaction towards 4-HPO. Furthermore, UV-Raman spectra are found to be dominated by the strong F2g mode of the ceria fluorite phase at 462 cm−1 and a band at 592 cm−1 due to the defect-induced (D) mode for both ceria and 2 wt% Sn-ceria (Fig. 2(b)). The relative intensity ratio of ID/IF2g (concentration of oxygen vacancy) is about 0.86 for 2 wt% Sn-ceria, which is a little higher than that for ceria (0.81), indicating that Sn addition promoted the formation of oxygen vacancies, as confirmed by the higher concentration of Ce(III) in 2 wt% Sn-ceria than pristine ceria (32.8% vs. 23.3%, Fig. 2(c)). Both the highly dispersed tin species and oxygen vacancies are critical for the good catalytic performance obtained.
Effects of feedstock
Different bacteria and fermentation technologies generate ABE solutions with different concentrations and compositions1. Thus, it is imperative to know the effect of water content on this reaction process. We conducted the reaction using three artificial aqueous ABE solutions with different water contents (623 g L−1, 707 g L−1, and 783 g L−1), selected based on the representative water content that can be obtained by current separation techniques reported in literature (Supplementary Figure 14). In all the cases, the selectivity towards 4-HPO is higher than 80%. Apart from substrate concentration, the ratio of different oxygenates might also have an impact on the reaction. We tested an aqueous ABE solution with different reactant ratios (e.g.: A:B:E mass ratio = 3:6:1, water content: ~20 wt%, to simulate fermentation by Clostridium acetobutylicum) and observed that 4-HPO selectivity of ~68% and yield of ~55% can be obtained, suggesting the pervasiveness of the current method (Table 1). In addition, organic acids, mainly acetic acid and butyric acid, are usually produced during ABE fermentation2,22. Here, the addition of acetic acid and butyric acid (1.7 wt% and 1.5 wt%, respectively) increased 4-HPO selectivity from 84% to 90% (Supplementary Figure 15).
To test the catalyst stability, we performed a continuous reaction by using 2 wt% Sn-ceria (Fig. 3(a)). Initially, 4-HPO was produced with ~70% conversion and ~86% selectivity. After about 300 h, the average 4-HPO selectivity was maintained at 85% with 50% conversion and > 90% carbon balance. The cold-trapped liquid phase naturally separates into two layers (Fig. 3(b)), easily separable in a separatory funnel. Phase (A) contains 4-HPO, 2-pentanone, unreacted acetone, and n-butanol, while phase (B) mainly contains unreacted acetone and water (Supplementary Figure Figure 16). High purity of 4-HPO ( > 95%) can be obtained by fractional distillation of phase (A), showing the power of current process (Supplementary Figure 17). After 300 h of reaction, extensive shrinkage was observed in the catalyst surface area, possibly due to carbonaceous deposition, which are the main reasons for the slight deactivation of the catalyst (Supplementary Figure 18-20). Developing highly stable tin–ceria-based catalyst system is the next goal of this biomass transformation process.
In summary, herein we have developed a strategy for the catalytic conversion of aqueous ABE solutions to phase-separable 4-HPO with ~86% selectivity and ~70% conversion over Sn-ceria catalyst. The presence of water was critical for this highly selective catalytic system. Sn-modified ceria serves as a versatile catalyst for the complicated catalytic reaction network and all the catalyzed reactions yield 4-HPO with high selectivity. This system paves a path for effective biomass conversion to obtain value-added products.
All data are available from the corresponding author upon reasonable request.
Tashiro, Y., Yoshida, T., Noguchi, T. & Sonomoto, K. Recent advances and future prospects for increased butanol production by acetone-butanol-ethanol fermentation. Eng. Life Sci. 13, 432–445 (2013).
Kujawska, A., Kujawski, J., Bryjak, M. & Kujawski, W. ABE fermentation products recovery methods-a review. Renew. Sust. Energ. Rev. 48, 648–661 (2015).
Alamillo, R., Crisci, A. J., Gallo, J. M. R., Scott, S. L. & Dumesic, J. A. A tailored microenvironment for catalytic biomass conversion in inorganic-organic nanoreactors. Angew. Chem. Int. Ed. 52, 10349–10351 (2013).
Orozco, L. M., Renz, M. & Corma, A. Carbon-carbon bond formation and hydrogen production in the ketonization of aldehydes. ChemSusChem 9, 2430–2442 (2016).
Sacia, E. R. et al. Highly selective condensation of biomass-derived methyl ketones as a source of aviation fuel. ChemSusChem 8, 1726–1736 (2015).
Huber, G. W., Chheda, J. N., Barrett, C. J. & Dumesic, J. A. Production of liquid alkanes by aqueous-phase processing of biomass-derived carbohydrates. Science 308, 1446–1450 (2005).
Kunkes, E. L. et al. Catalytic conversion of biomass to monofunctional hydrocarbons and targeted liquid-fuel classes. Science 322, 417–421 (2008).
Liu, D. J., Zhang, Y. T. & Chen, E. Y. X. Organocatalytic upgrading of the key biorefining building block by a catalytic ionic liquid and N-heterocyclic carbenes. Green. Chem. 14, 2738–2746 (2012).
Wilson, J. & Chen, E. Y. X. Organocatalytic cross-coupling of biofuranics to multifunctional difuranic C-11 building blocks. Acs Sustain. Chem. Eng. 4, 4927–4936 (2016).
Harvey, B. G. et al. Renewable thermosetting resins and thermoplastics from vanillin. Green. Chem. 17, 1249–1258 (2015).
Zang, H. J. et al. Catalytic coupling of biomass-derived aldehydes into intermediates for biofuels and materials. Catal. Sci. Technol. 8, 1777–1798 (2018).
Anbarasan, P. et al. Integration of chemical catalysis with extractive fermentation to produce fuels. Nature 491, 235–239 (2012).
Wang, Y. H. et al. Heterogeneous ceria catalyst with water-tolerant Lewis acidic sites for one-pot synthesis of 1,3-diols via Prins condensation and hydrolysis reactions. J. Am. Chem. Soc. 135, 1506–1515 (2013).
Nishiguchi, T. et al. Catalytic steam reforming of ethanol to produce hydrogen and acetone. Appl. Catal. A Gen. 279, 273–277 (2005).
Rodriguez, J. A. et al. Activity of CeOx and TiOx nanoparticles grown on Au(111) in the water-gas shift reaction. Science 318, 1757–1760 (2007).
Montini, T., Melchionna, M., Monai, M. & Fornasiero, P. Fundamentals and catalytic applications of CeO2-based materials. Chem. Rev. 116, 5987–6041 (2016).
Moore, C. M. et al. Acetaldehyde as an ethanol derived bio-building block: an alternative to Guerbet chemistry. Green. Chem. 19, 169–174 (2017).
Faba, L., Diaz, E. & Ordonez, S. Gas phase acetone self-condensation over unsupported and supported Mg-Zr mixed-oxides catalysts. Appl. Catal. B Environ. 142, 387–395 (2013).
Quesada, J. et al. Role of surface intermediates in the deactivation of Mg-Zr mixed oxides in acetone self-condensation: a combined DRIFT and ex situ characterization approach. J. Catal. 329, 1–9 (2015).
Moore, C. M. et al. Synthesis of acetone-derived C-6, C-9, and C-12 carbon scaffolds for chemical and fuel applications. Chemsuschem 9, 3382–3386 (2016).
Gliński, M., Kijeński, J. & Jakubowski, A. Ketones from monocarboxylic acids: catalytic ketonization over oxide systems. Appl. Catal. A Gen. 128, 209–217 (1995).
Thang, V. H., Kanda, K. & Kobayashi, G. Production of acetone-butanol-ethanol (ABE) in direct fermentation of cassava by Clostridium saccharoperbutylacetonicum N1-4. Appl. Biochem. Biotechnol. 161, 157–170 (2010).
This work received financial support from the “Strategic Priority Research Program of the Chinese Academy of Sciences” (XDB17000000, XDB17020300), the National Key R&D Program of China (2017YFB0602200), and the Natural Science Foundation of China (21721004, 21690080, 21711530020, 21725301, 91645115, 21473003, 21673273, 21872163, and 21821004).
The authors declare no competing interests.
Publisher’s note: Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.
Electronic supplementary material
Rights and permissions
Open Access This article is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License, which permits use, sharing, adaptation, distribution and reproduction in any medium or format, as long as you give appropriate credit to the original author(s) and the source, provide a link to the Creative Commons license, and indicate if changes were made. The images or other third party material in this article are included in the article’s Creative Commons license, unless indicated otherwise in a credit line to the material. If material is not included in the article’s Creative Commons license and your intended use is not permitted by statutory regulation or exceeds the permitted use, you will need to obtain permission directly from the copyright holder. To view a copy of this license, visit http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/.
About this article
Cite this article
Wang, Y., Peng, M., Zhang, J. et al. Selective production of phase-separable product from a mixture of biomass-derived aqueous oxygenates. Nat Commun 9, 5183 (2018). https://doi.org/10.1038/s41467-018-07593-0
By submitting a comment you agree to abide by our Terms and Community Guidelines. If you find something abusive or that does not comply with our terms or guidelines please flag it as inappropriate.