Post-transcriptional RNA modifications play a critical role in the pathogenesis of human mitochondrial disorders, but the mechanisms by which specific modifications affect mitochondrial protein synthesis remain poorly understood. Here we used a quantitative RNA sequencing approach to investigate, at nucleotide resolution, the stoichiometry and methyl modifications of the entire mitochondrial tRNA pool, and establish the relevance to human disease. We discovered that a N1-methyladenosine (m1A) modification is missing at position 58 in the mitochondrial tRNALys of patients with the mitochondrial DNA mutation m.8344 A > G associated with MERRF (myoclonus epilepsy, ragged-red fibers). By restoring the modification on the mitochondrial tRNALys, we demonstrated the importance of the m1A58 to translation elongation and the stability of selected nascent chains. Our data indicates regulation of post-transcriptional modifications on mitochondrial tRNAs is finely tuned for the control of mitochondrial gene expression. Collectively, our findings provide novel insight into the regulation of mitochondrial tRNAs and reveal greater complexity to the molecular pathogenesis of MERRF.
Defects in mitochondrial gene expression are among the most common causes of human mitochondrial disorders1. Mitochondria contain a unique set of ribosomes and tRNAs dedicated to the synthesis of the 13 proteins encoded in mitochondrial DNA (mtDNA) (Fig. 1a), all of which are essential for aerobic energy metabolism. Mutations in mitochondrially encoded tRNA genes are the most frequent pathogenic disruptions of mitochondrial protein synthesis2. These mutations manifest as diseases with tremendous clinical heterogeneity, in which the tissue specificity, severity, and age of onset do not strictly correlate with the magnitude of the biochemical defect in energy metabolism. Despite the clinical importance of these disorders, the molecular mechanisms by which mitochondrial tRNA mutations affect protein synthesis remain poorly understood.
One such mtDNA mutation is m.8344 A > G in tRNALys, first identified >25 years ago in patients with MERRF (myoclonus epilepsy, ragged-red fibers) syndrome3(Fig. 1b). This mutation causes a severe translation defect during mitochondrial protein synthesis, which has been attributed to a decrease in the steady-state abundance of the mitochondrial tRNALys, reduced aminoacylation of tRNALys, and lack of a post-transcriptional 5-taurinomethyl 2-thiouridine RNA modification of the anticodon wobble base4,5,6,7. A deficiency in the abundance of aminoacylated tRNALys would lead ribosomes to stall when the lysine codons AAA or AAG enter the A-site, and chronic stalling would be expected to trigger premature termination of nascent chain synthesis. The 5-taurinomethyl 2-thiouridine modification of U34 prevents superwobbling by restricting decoding of the third codon position to purines8,9. In the absence of this modification on tRNALys two outcomes are possible: asparagine codons (AAC and AAU) could be misread by tRNALys, leading to amino acid misincorporation, or altered stability of the codon recognition complex leading to ribosome pausing10,11,12. Individually or collectively, these molecular mechanisms would impinge on mitochondrial protein synthesis.
Mitochondrial protein synthesis can be assayed by metabolic labeling with 35S methionine in the presence of translation inhibitors of cytoplasmic ribosomes such as anisomycin, so that the radiolabel is only incorporated into mitochondrial nascent chains. Metabolic labeling of mitochondrial protein synthesis in cultured cells homoplasmic for mitochondrial DNA with the m.8344 A > G in tRNALys demonstrated the rate of 35S incorporation is severely impaired, generating specific aberrantly sized polypeptides (e.g., pMERRF) as well as full-length polypeptides all of which are unstable4,13,14(Fig. 1c). This pattern of mitochondrial nascent chain synthesis is not consistent with random premature termination at lysine codons15. Nonetheless, tRNA stoichiometry and RNA modifications are critical regulators of protein synthesis16, but the molecular basis by which mitochondrial gene expression is disrupted with this pathogenic tRNALys mutation associated with MERRF remains unclear.
To bridge this gap, we capitalized on a methodological advance in next-generation RNA sequencing to investigate the consequences of the MERRF tRNALys mutation on the stoichiometry and modifications of the entire mitochondrial tRNA pool in affected patient cells and tissues. Our results implicate a novel tRNA modification in the pathogenesis of MERRF and reveal an extensive and unexpected influence of RNA modifications on the regulation and fidelity of mitochondrial gene expression.
Cell type-specific regulation of mitochondrial tRNA abundance
To investigate transcript-wide regulation of mitochondrial tRNA stoichiometry and RNA modifications in cells harboring the MERRF mutation, we used demethylase-thermostable group II intron RT tRNA sequencing (DM-tRNA-seq)17. This method uses a highly processive thermostable group II intron reverse-transcriptase (TGIRT) coupled with two demethylases, to overcome the stable secondary structure and Watson–Crick face methylations of tRNAs to obtain quantitative genome-wide information on cellular tRNA populations and their modifications. We prepared tRNA libraries from deacylated RNA isolated from wild-type myoblasts and myoblasts homoplasmic for the MERRF mutation, with or without demethylase treatment. The demethylase-treated samples generated longer reads, which greatly facilitated specific tRNA assignment and quantitation, whereas the untreated samples allowed identification and quantitative comparison of many modifications at the Watson–Crick face18. These libraries were sequenced, and tRNAs were mapped to the human nuclear and mitochondrial genomes (16–40 million total reads per sample, 6–13 million uniquely mapped per sample). Between 12.1–13.4% of all mapped tRNA reads corresponded to mitochondrially encoded tRNAs. The data were highly reproducible among three replicate experiments for both wild-type and homoplasmic mutant cells (Pearson’s coefficient > 0.992 for all pairs of replicates; Supplementary Figure 1A). The abundance of mitochondrial tRNALys was significantly reduced in MERRF cells (Fig. 1d, e), whereas the steady-state levels of the other 21 mitochondrial tRNAs were essentially identical between wild-type and MERRF cells (Fig. 1e).
The mode of mtDNA transcription can vary across human cell types (so far not studied in myoblasts) and appears to be biased towards nascent RNA synthesis from the promoter of the light coding strand of the genome (Fig. 1a)19. We compared the steady-state abundance of each tRNA with the gene position along the mitochondrial coding strands (heavy and light (Fig. 1a)), but observed no trends for either strand (Fig. 1e). Within the mitochondrial genome, the genes encoding tRNAPhe and tRNAVal flank the 12 S rRNA gene (Fig. 1a), and are transcribed together, along with the 16 S rRNA, as a short polycistronic RNA at a level 1.4–8.8-fold greater than genes downstream along the H-strand depending upon the cell type19. In HeLa cells, the steady-state levels of tRNAPhe and tRNAVal were 2–3-fold higher compared to those of other H-strand tRNAs when determined by quantitative northern blotting20 and concordant with nascent RNA synthesis of these genes for this cell type. This difference was not observed in myoblasts using DM-tRNA-seq. To test whether the discrepancy in the steady-state tRNA abundance may be attributable to methodological or actual biological differences in tRNA regulation between diploid and aneuploid cells, we analyzed mitochondrial tRNA stoichiometry in a high-throughput tRNA sequencing dataset obtained from HEK293T cells using DM-tRNA-seq17. This analysis revealed that, as in HeLa cells, the levels of tRNAPhe and tRNAVal in HEK293T were 2–3-fold higher than those of other H-strand tRNAs (Fig. 1f, g). Taken together, our data suggest differential regulation of the mitochondrial genome in proliferating human cultured cells, highlighting the need to use diploid cells to investigate the pathogenic mechanisms of human mitochondrial gene expression disorders.
The m1A58 modification in tRNALys is absent in myoblasts with the MERRF mutation
Post-transcriptional modifications of mitochondrial tRNAs are functionally important to achieve and stabilize the cloverleaf structure, and for decoding during translation elongation21. In MERRF, the 5-taurinomethyl 2-thiouridine modification on the anticodon wobble base is missing on the tRNALys purified from cybrid cells7 and from a patient liver biopsy22. In the absence of this U34 modification, translation on cognate codons is impaired using an in vitro5 assay. However, metabolic labeling of mitochondrial protein synthesis in human cells is at odds (Fig. 1c) with the in vitro data. Furthermore, lack of the analogous 5-methoxycarbonylmethyl-2-thiouridine (mcm5s2U) U34 modification of the yeast cytoplasmic tRNALys does not prevent decoding but rather substantially slows down the rate of translation elongation due to ribosome pausing on lysine codons10,11. Therefore, we asked whether other RNA modifications were important to the molecular pathogenesis either directly on tRNALys or to the entire pool of mitochondrial tRNAs as part of regulatory feedback from impaired protein synthesis.
DM-tRNA-seq allowed us to assess quantitatively differences in specific RNA modifications across all mitochondrial tRNAs between wild-type and MERRF-mutant cells. At Watson–Crick face methylation sites, such as N1-methyladenosine (m1A), the thermophilic RT generates both stop and read-through mutation sequencing reads. We used the term “modification index” (MI) to quantify the mutation and stop fractions at each nucleotide position18. (Please see the Methods section for a discussion comparing the sensitivity and accuracy of DM-tRNA-seq vs. traditional mass-spectrometry approaches for detecting RNA modifications).
First, we addressed the abundance of the τm5s2U anticodon wobble base modification of tRNALys between wild-type and MERRF. As expected, we detected a significant decrease in the modification at this position in MERRF samples (Fig. 2a, b), but it was not completely absent. Unlike N1-methyladenosine (m1A), for which the MI value can be used to approximate the modified fraction, the MI of 0.2 for τm5s2U in wild-type cells likely under-represents the modified fraction because the Watson–Crick face perturbation of τm5s2U is 2-thio, which weakens, but does not block, base pairing between the template and dNTP during cDNA synthesis. Nevertheless, the markedly reduced MI in the MERRF sample was consistent with a reduction of the τm5s2U modification. Anticodon wobble base modifications in other mitochondrial tRNAs were also detected in our sequencing reads, but did not differ between wild-type and MERRF cells (Fig. 2b).
Next, we investigated whether there were any differences in the known m1A modifications. To our surprise, the m1A at position 58 of tRNALys (Fig. 1b) was absent in MERRF cells (Fig. 2a, c). It is important to note that mitochondrial tRNAs do not possess classical D and T arms 9so the actual position of the m1A in mitochondrial tRNALys is nucleotide 54 (m.8348 in the genome), however, we kept with conventional tRNA numbering for this modification. The m1A58 is catalyzed by the methyltransferase ‘writer’ TRMT61B23 and our quantitation of the modification by DM-tRNA-seq in wild-type cells is consistent with previous reports by primer extension and mass-spectrometry23,24, which demonstrate that this methyl modification was present only in a fraction of tRNALys. In contrast, the m1A9 on the D arm required for the formation of the cloverleaf structure of tRNALys25 and catalyzed by a different methyltransferase complex26, was detected in both wild-type and MERRF cells. To test whether other known m1A58 modifications in mitochondrial tRNAs were affected, we analyzed the m1A58 on tRNAs Leu(UUR) and Ser(UCN), as well as m1A16 in tRNAArg and found no difference between wild-type and MERRF cells (Fig. 2c). Together, these data indicated that the loss of the m1A modification in MERRF cells was restricted to tRNALys at position 58. Our sequencing approach expanded the landscape of MERRF pathogenesis by implicating a novel methyl modification on tRNALys, highlighting the versatility and robustness of DM-tRNA-seq for investigating the regulation of mitochondrial gene expression disorders.
m1A58 tRNALys is linked to the MERRF pathogenesis in human skeletal muscle
To assess the disease relevance of the modifications present in the tRNALys from proliferating myoblasts to the molecular pathogenesis of MERRF, we analyzed mitochondrial tRNAs from skeletal muscle biopsies obtained from a control and MERRF patient. Total RNA was isolated from control and MERRF muscle, and tRNA libraries were prepared for sequencing. From each of the libraries, 22–50 million reads were mapped. The levels of nuclear-encoded tRNAs were strongly correlated between the two samples (Supplementary Figure 1B). By contrast, the steady-state level of tRNALys was ~ 50% lower in MERRF skeletal muscle than in the control (Fig. 3a), similar to our findings in myoblasts (Fig. 1e) (note that our cultured myoblasts originated from a different patient than the skeletal muscle biopsy). In skeletal muscle, the frequency of the MERRF mutation was approximately 80% (Fig. 3b), which is consistent with the threshold mutational load sufficient to cause a biochemical defect in oxidative phosphorylation13.
To test the disease relevance of the post-transcriptional modifications on tRNALys to MERRF in skeletal muscle, we analyzed the modification index at positions 9, 34, and 58 (Fig. 1b) between the healthy control and patient. The cloverleaf stabilizing m1A9 modification was found on the majority of tRNALys in both the MERRF patient and control (Fig. 3b). In contrast, the modification fraction of the m1A58 in tRNALys was ~0.3 in control and absent in MERRF (Fig. 3b). This finding is entirely consistent with our data from proliferating myoblasts, strongly suggesting a key role of this modification in the pathogenesis of MERRF. The τm5s2U anticodon wobble base modification at U34 was modestly down in MERRF (Fig. 3b). Unfortunately, our analyses could not distinguish whether the m1A58 co-exists in cis with the τm5s2U anticodon wobble base modification. Together, our findings establish the relevance and expand the landscape of post-transcriptional RNA modifications on tRNALys to the molecular pathogenesis of MERRF.
A recent study demonstrated that aminoacylation of mitochondrial tRNAs bearing a CCA tail is regulated by oligoadenylation, catalyzed by the mitochondrial poly(A) polymerase (PAPD1); the steady-state level of this modification is governed by the balance between the activities of PAPD1 and phosphodiesterase 12 (PDE12), and is particularly prominent for tRNALys and tRNASer2(AGY)15. Whereas another study showed how structurally abnormal mitochondrial tRNAs can be polyadenylated for degradation27. Therefore, we asked whether the adenylation mechanism is relevant to the pathogenesis of MERRF. For this analysis, we sorted sequence reads into two pools based upon the presence or absence of the CCA tail. Aminoacylation of tRNAs requires the addition of the CCA extension, which is catalyzed by a mitochondrially targeted TRNT1, and is critical for mitochondrial protein synthesis and human health28,29. When we analyzed the tRNA sequencing reads, oligoadenylation was widespread but only among the tRNA pool lacking the CCA extension in both control and MERRF (Fig. 3c). There was differential oligoadenylation between control and MERRF of selected mitochondrial tRNAs, including tRNALys (Fig. 3c). These data indicate that adenylation of mitochondrial tRNAs is a far more complex process than previously thought and may play a role in the regulation of mitochondrial tRNA populations and the pathogenesis of human disease.
tRNALys RNA modifications have specific effects on translation
Since the m1A58 modification on tRNALys is consistently absent in MERRF myoblasts and skeletal muscle, we asked whether re-establishing the modification in the MERRF myoblasts could modulate mitochondrial translation. To this end, we retrovirally transduced myoblasts with the TRMT61B cDNA, reasoning that overexpression of this key methyltransferase would restore the modification on the tRNALys. Indeed, TRMT61B overexpression restored the m1A modification in MERRF tRNALys (Fig. 4), but did not alter the steady-state abundance of tRNALys (Supplementary Figure 2A). Importantly, TRMT61B overexpression increased the synthesis of selected proteins and suppressed the generation of aberrantly sized polypeptides (Fig. 5a, b; Supplementary Figure 2B). The magnitude of this effect did not correlate with the number of lysine codons of a given polypeptide. (Supplementary Figure 2C).
Next, we asked whether the increased protein synthesis with TRMT61B overexpression also modulated the short term and long-term stability of mitochondrial nascent chains. Even though there was a 2-fold increase in 35S-incorporation in MT-CO1 and MT-ATP6 (Fig. 5b), these proteins were still unstable but with differential effects (Fig. 5c-e). By contrast, TRMT61B overexpression in the wild-type background led to a two-fold increase of the m1A58 on tRNALys (Fig. 4c) and a selective dominant-negative effect specific to MT-CO1 nascent chain synthesis and long-term stability (Fig. 5a, b, e). Recent reports have also documented specific m1A modifications in mitochondrial 12 S and 16 S rRNA, and mRNAs, including MT-CO130,31,32. The m1A modification at position 947 of the 16 S rRNA was proposed to be important for human mitochondrial ribosome subunit stability and is catalyzed by TRMT61B30. To test if mitochondrial ribosome stability was affected by TRMT61B overexpression, we assessed the steady-state levels of mitochondrial ribosomal proteins from the small and large subunit by immunoblotting because their abundance is a reliable proxy for stability33 but found no difference (Fig. 5e). Our data showed that restoration of the m1A58 on tRNALys can enhance translation in MERRF, arguing against this methyl modification as being a strictly negative regulator of mitochondrial gene expression as has been proposed for the m1A modification on mitochondrial mRNAs31,32. Rather, there appears to be a tight regulation of this methyl modification on mitochondrial RNAs to finely tune mitochondrial protein synthesis.
Because reduced modification of the anticodon wobble base position is implicated in MERRF pathogenesis, we wanted to test whether overexpression of the key enzymes could also modulate mitochondrial translation. MTU1 catalyzes the thiol modification of the anticodon wobble base, a reaction that is required for human health34, but appears to have no effect on mitochondrial protein synthesis in human fibroblasts35. Consistent with this finding, overexpression of MTU1 in wild-type and MERRF myoblasts had no effect on mitochondrial protein synthesis (Supplementary Figure 2D and 2E). In contrast, overexpression of MTO1 had a marked effect on mitochondrial protein synthesis and protein stability (Fig. 5). MTO1 forms a complex with the small GTPase GTPBP3 to catalyze the 5-methylaminomethyl (mnm5U34) modification on the anticodon wobble base found in mitochondrial tRNAs of Glu, Lys, Gln, Leu(UUR), and Trp9. MTO1 overexpression restored mitochondrial protein synthesis to wild-type levels (Fig. 5a, b), but there was a differential effect on the stability of individual proteins (Fig. 5c–e) that did not correlate with the abundance of lysine codons in a given polypeptide (Supplementary Figure 2C). Moreover, these effects were independent of the m1A58 modification (Fig. 4b, c). Although the rate of MT-CO1 synthesis increased, these nascent chains remained unstable in contrast to MT-ATP6. No adverse effects were observed on wild-type myoblasts overexpressing MTO1. Collectively, these findings demonstrate that post-transcriptional modifications of mitochondrial tRNAs exert differential effects on protein synthesis and stability, revealing the profound influence that RNA modifications have on mitochondrial gene expression and the pathogenesis of human disease.
RNA modifications have emerged as major regulators of gene expression across all domains of life36. In this study, we showed that post-transcriptional modifications on a single mitochondrial tRNA modulate nascent chain synthesis and protein stability. Our data also highlight the importance of using diploid patient cells to investigate the regulation of mitochondrial gene expression in the pathogenesis of mitochondrial diseases.
Our data show that the MERRF tRNALys mutation simultaneously impacts modifications at the wobble anticodon position (τm5s2U) and m1A58 in the T-loop. Although the effect of the MERRF mutation on τm5s2U was previously established5, the complete elimination of m1A58 in the MERRF mutation was unexpected. m1A58 introduces a positive charge in the elbow region of the tRNA tertiary structure, which can affect the binding of the elongation factor that delivers tRNA to the ribosome37. Therefore, weakened binding of the m.8344 A > G mutant tRNALys to mitochondrial EF-Tu due to elimination of m1A58 may also contribute to the disease phenotype. Consistent with this interpretation, overexpression of the m1A58 methyltransferase, TRMT61B, restored the modification, increasing the synthesis of mitochondrial nascent chains and preventing the generation of aberrantly sized polypeptides. In fact, restoring the methyl modification on tRNALys completely rescued the translation defect in MT-ATP6 synthesis. Together, these data argue that the m1A58 modification is a positive regulator for mitochondrial translation elongation. Despite rescuing the translation defect, however, most nascent chains were still unstable. Strikingly, the stability of MT-ATP6 and MT-ATP8 was completely different from the other mitochondrial nascent chains, a phenotype that did not correlate with the number of lysine codons within in the mRNA. These data point to a more complex molecular pathogenesis of the m.8344 A > G tRNALys mutation.
It is curious that the m1A58 is found only in a subset of tRNALys molecules whereas for the tRNALeu(UUR) >90% of the tRNAs possess this methyl modification. In a canonical tRNA fold such as tRNALeu(UUR) the m1A58 forms a reverse-Hoogsteen base pair with 5-methyluridine or adenosine at position 54 in the T-loop, a m1A58-A54 interaction may also form in tRNALys and the m1A modification may affect the stability of this interaction too. In contrast, the frequency of the cloverleaf inducing m1A9 modification is similar between tRNALys and tRNALeu(UUR). Absence of the post-transcriptional modification of the wobble anticodon position of the cytoplasmic tRNALys has been shown to cause ribosome pausing on lysine codons, inducing a severe delay in the rate of translation elongation10,11,12. The data from other translation systems suggest a uniform rate of decoding for all tRNAs38. The main differences appear to be in the stability of the codon recognition complex among tRNAs, which specifically affect the geometry of the codon–anticodon complex and disassociation rates12. Consistent with this interpretation, overexpressing MTO1 dramatically increased the rate of mitochondrial protein synthesis, but most of the nascent chains were still unstable, suggesting the fidelity of mitochondrial protein synthesis is still disrupted. Our data suggest the m.8344 A > G MERRF mutation causes protein misfolding at two levels: one, from decreased rates of translation elongation and two, from a decreased fidelity of protein synthesis. Together, our data point to two post-transcriptional modifications on the tRNALys that are important for the efficiency and fidelity of mitochondrial protein synthesis. Since the 13 mitochondrial proteins are co-translationally inserted into the lipid bilayer to assemble into large heterooligomeric complexes39, nascent chain misfolding would interfere with the kinetics of assembly for the oxidative phosphorylation complexes.
A recent study found that the tRNALys m1A58 methyltransferase TRMT61B is also responsible for m1A modifications in several mitochondrial mRNAs31. Upon TRMT61B overexpression, the m1A level in mitochondrial MT-CO2 and MT-CO3 mRNAs increased, but the steady-state levels of these proteins decreased, leading to the conclusion that m1A in mitochondrial mRNAs is a negative regulator of protein synthesis31. The methyltransferase TRMT10C, which is responsible for the m1A9 modification in tRNAs, can also post-transcriptionally modify mitochondrial mRNAs, in particular MT-ND5, in a process that is developmentally regulated during embryogenesis and post-natally between germline and somatic tissues32. Since m1A on mitochondrial mRNAs would interfere with Watson–Crick base pairing, this modification would be inhibitory in mRNA during translation. In contrast to the mRNA m1A effects, our results show that m1A58 in tRNALys strongly increases protein synthesis, and this tRNA modification is also important for the stability of MT-ATP6. These results suggest that m1A modifications catalyzed by the same methyltransferase could have opposing effects on mitochondrial protein synthesis: an inhibitory role on mRNAs and positive role with mitochondrial tRNA. Such a mechanism on mitochondrial mRNAs might be a part of a quality control step to ensure aberrant mRNAs are not fully engaged in translation to minimize the potential for misfolded proteins. These opposing effects may explain the sub-stoichiometric m1A58 level in tRNALys in wild-type cells. An elevated m1A58 level on tRNALys may compete with decoding of other tRNAs at near-cognate codons, thereby decreasing translational fidelity and ultimately promoting protein misfolding and degradation. The optimal modification level could be maintained by the activities of the writer, TRMT61B, and the mitochondrial tRNA m1A eraser ALKBH124. The expression level of these enzymes could vary across different cell types and tissues, and be a key regulator for modulating mitochondrial protein synthesis. In the cytosol, dynamic regulation of the m1A modification on tRNAs in response to metabolic cues is a significant regulator of cellular protein synthesis37. Therefore, it is intriguing to speculate that a similar metabolic regulation of this post-transcriptional modification exists for mitochondrial gene expression.
An interesting finding of our study points to different pools of tRNAs within the organelle. This effect is exemplified by the oligoadenylation of molecules lacking the CCA extension, which implies the existence of separate pools of tRNAs with and without this post-transcriptional polyA extension. A previous report found that deficiency of PDE12, the phosphodiesterase that removes oligoadenlyates from mitochondrial RNA, triggers oligoadenylation of tRNALys containing a CCA extension, which was proposed to be a regulator step for aminoacylation15. The physiological significance of these distinct tRNA populations remains unclear. Polyadenylation status in mitochondrial mRNA is largely positively correlated with stability and translational competence40, and defects in the enzyme responsible for this modification, PAPD1, are linked to spastic ataxia in humans41. In Drosophila, the mitochondrial poly(A) polymerase (MTPAP) is required to protect the integrity of mRNA 3′ ends, but not for stability or translation42. Loss of this enzymatic activity in flies inhibits the maturation of tRNACys, a very rare codon in mitochondrial mRNAs (1.1% in flies; 0.6% in humans). Moreover, a recent report suggests structurally unstable tRNAs are polyadenylated as part of a degradation step27. Our ability to distinguish different pools of mitochondrial tRNA was only possible because of the ability of DM-tRNA-seq to obtain nucleotide resolution. Future studies should seek to systematically address the dynamic regulation of 3′ adenylation and its consequences on tRNA stability and maturation.
Equally surprising was the discovery that RNA modifications have distinct effects on the stability and synthesis of the 13 mitochondrial proteins. These observations highlight the limitations of our current understanding of mitochondrial protein synthesis and its regulation. The application of new RNA sequencing approaches to this organelle should provide insight into these mechanisms, as well as their contributions to human disease.
Homoplasmic human myoblasts for wild-type or the m.8344 A > G tRNALys mutation were derived from satellite cells from a skeletal muscle biopsy13 and immortalized with E6/E743 and hTERT. Cells were cultured at 37 °C and 5% CO2 in Cell Applications Inc. Skeletal Muscle Cell Growth Medium (#151–500) supplemented with 50 μg/ml uridine. Retrovirus was generated by transient transfection of retroviral plasmids into the Phoenix amphotropic packaging line as in44. Cells were used directly following selection with blasticidin. All cells were tested for mycoplasma before use.
Human skeletal muscle biopsy
The human control skeletal muscle biopsy was obtained after informed consent, according to Helsinki Declaration, accepted by the Ethical Review Board of Helsinki University Hospital (nr 43/13/03/04/2008). The MERRF skeletal muscle biopsy was obtained after informed consent from a subject with progressive muscle weakness. The skeletal muscle biopsy showed accumulation of COX negative and ragged-red muscle fibers and a high level of heteroplasmy for the mutation m. 8344 A > G in tRNALys.
Wild-type cDNAs (TRMT61B, clone BC010365.1; MTU1 (TRMU), clone CU013043; MTO1, clone BC011051) were obtained from the ORFeome or Mammalian Genome Collection. These cDNAs were in a Gateway entry vector (pENTR221 or pCMV-SPORT6) or cloned into pDONR201 using PCR with KAPA HiFi followed by recombination. The TRMT61B cDNA was missing a stop codon, which was added by PCR using the primers BB-477 (5′-aaaaagcaggctaccATGCTAATGGCATGGTGCCG-3′) and BB-478 (5′-agaaagctgggtttattaGTTAAGTTGTGGTTTGACC-3′) with KAPA HiFi followed amplification with attB1 and attB2 adapters then by gateway cloning into pDONR201. All full-length cDNAs were recombined into Gateway converted pMXs-IRES-Blasticidin with LR Clonase II (Thermo Fisher). All cDNAs were thoroughly sequenced by Sanger sequencing for verification initially and after all PCR manipulations.
Total RNA was isolated from cultured myobalsts (homoplasmic for wild-type mtDNA or the MERRF mtDNA mutation) from three independent cultures with Trizol according to the manufacturer’s instructions. Muscle samples were homogenized with a Precellys 24 (Bertin Technologies). For next-generation sequencing, all samples were reprecipitated with 0.1 volume 3 M Sodium acetate and 3 volume ice cold 100% Ethanol.
DM-tRNA-seq was performed as previously described17. Briefly, purified RNA was mixed with three T7 transcribed tRNA standards (0.01pmol each standard per μg total RNA). Deacylation of total RNA (at < 0.5 μg/μL) was performed in 100 mM Tris-HCl pH = 9.0 at 37 °C for 30 min. Small RNA was isolated from total RNA by using the small RNA isolation protocol for the RNA Clean and Concentrator Kit (Zymo R1015).
Up to 1.5 μg of small RNA (~60 pmol) was demethylated with 2× molar ratio WT AlkB and 4X molar ratio of D135S AlkB in 25 mM MES pH = 5.0, 30 mM KCl, 2 mM MgCl2, 2 mM ascorbic acid, 300 μM α-ketoglutarate, 50 μM (NH4)2Fe(SO4)2 in the presence of RNasin at room temperature for 2 h. Demethylated small RNA was purified using an RNA Clean and Concentrator Kit (Zymo). Next, 3′-phosphate removal was performed on both demethylase-treated and -untreated small RNA. Small RNA was treated with T4 PNK (Affymetrix, final concentration 0.1U/μL) in 1× T4 PNK buffer at 37 °C for 30 min. The RNA Clean and Concentrator (Zymo) was again used to clean up the reaction.
For cDNA synthesis, the TGIRT DNA primer was 5′ labeled with T4 PNK. 4pmol of 5′ labeled TGIRT primer (5′-GATCGTCGGACTGTAGAACTAGACGTGTGCTCTTCCGATCTT-3′) was annealed to 4pmol of complementary RNA (5′-AGAUCGGAAGAGCACACGUCUAGUUCUACAGUCCGACGAUC/3SpC3/-3′) in 100 mM Tris-HCl pH = 7.5, 0.5 mM EDTA at 82 °C for 2 min, then slow cooled to room temp. Up to 100 ng small RNA (~4 pmol tRNA) was then added. The small RNA/primer mixture (~200 nM) was then preincubated at room temp for 30 min in 100 mM Tris-HCl pH = 7.5, 450 mM NaCl, 5 mM MgCl2, 5 mM DTT with 500 nM TGIRT (InGex, Inc.). dNTPs were added to 1 mM, and the reverse transcription reaction was carried out at 60 °C for 60 min. NaOH was added to 0.25 M and the mixture was heated at 95 °C for 5 min to hydrolyze RNA. HCl was added to 0.25 M to neutralize the reactions.
An equal volume of 50% formamide, 4.5 M urea, 50 mM EDTA, 0.05% Bromophenol blue, 0.05% xylene cyanol was added to the cDNA, and the mixture was heated at 95 °C for 15 min. cDNA was then gel purified by denaturing 10% PAGE (7 M urea, 1X TBE), and extended products were excised from the gel and eluted overnight at room temperature in 200 mM KCl, 50 mM KOAc. Purified cDNA was ethanol precipitated with addition of linear acrylamide (Thermo) to 20 µg/mL.
Purified cDNA was circularized using CircLigase II (Epicentre) at 60 °C overnight. The enzyme was inactivated at 80 °C for 10 min, and samples were then phenol/chloroform extracted and ethanol precipitated. Illumina libraries were prepared using Phusion Master Mix (Thermo) for 12 PCR cycles (98 °C 5 s, 60 °C 10 s, 72 °C 10 s). AMPure XP Beads (Beckman-Coulter) were used to clean up the libraries before Illumina sequencing. All libraries were sequenced on an Illumina HiSeq 2000 with paired-end mapping using read lengths of 100 base pairs.
tRNA-seq data analysis
Alignment and analysis of tRNAs at single-base resolution was performed similarly as in ref. 18. Briefly, paired-reads were processed using Trimmomatic v 0.32n and custom Python scripts to remove traces of adapter. For the purpose of poly-A tail analysis, low quality homo-nucleotide stretches were preserved. Processed reads were aligned in Bowtie 1.0 according to the parameters: –v 3 –m 10 –best –strata. Fragments shorter than 15 base pairs during alignment were removed in subsequent analysis, and further C and Python scripts merged reads onto individual tRNAs. For poly-A tail analysis, additional remapping was performed by isolating reads and aligning them onto reference genomes with poly-A(30) appended. Sequence mapping of human mitochondrial-encoded tRNAs is straightforward because each mt-tRNA sequence is unique and divergent from the nuclear-encoded tRNAs.
Modifications are measured as the sum of mutation fractions and the RT stop fraction for any given tRNA seed sequence at each nucleotide position. This sum of mutation and stop fraction is presented as a Modification Index (MI) value which is between 0–1 for each position. The DM-tRNA-seq method does not have a fragmentation step prior to cDNA synthesis, and all sequencing reads start from the 3′ CCA17. Therefore, stop fraction can be accurately mapped for the tRNA positions more than ~25 nucleotides away from the 3′ end. For the tRNA positions close to the 3′ end, stop fraction mapping is much less accurate because the cDNA products generated by RT stop can be too short to be in cluded in the sequencing library construction. For these positions, which can include A58 of mitochondrial tRNALys, the MI value would represent a lower bound of the modification fraction.
Our MI-value based quantitation of m1A modification compares well with those determined by mass spectrometry. For HEK293T cells, mass-spectrometry results from Suzuki and co-workers24 shows a modification fraction of 17.9% for m1A16 in mitochondrial tRNAArg and 48.3% for m1A58 in mitochondrial tRNALys. The MI value determined by DM-tRNA-seq18 is 0.16 for m1A16 of mt-tRNAArg and m1A58 of 0.24 for mt-tRNALys. m1A16 is 52 nucleotides away from the 3′ end, its MI includes both mutation (0.074) and stop (0.086). m1A58 is 20 nucleotides away from the 3′ end, its MI shows only the mutation fraction, therefore, the modification fraction is likely higher. Both m1A16 and m1A58 have the same sequence context of m1ACA so that a similar level of mutation and RT stop ratios may be present in regards to context dependence45. Therefore, the m1A58 modification fraction can be estimated to be around 0.48 which is similar to the mass spectrometry result.
For statistical analysis of tRNA-seq, the data were analyzed were indicated with paired sample t test.
Primer extension assay
RNA oligonucleotide probes (tRNALys 5′-TGGTCACTGTAAAGAG-3′, where TGG correlates to CCA) were 5′ labeled with gamma 32P ATP by T4 Polynucleotide Kinase (NEB) according to the manufacturer’s instructions. Labeled oligonucleotides were separated from non-incorporated nucleotides via G40 MicroSpin columns (GE Healthcare). A concentration of 4 μg of total RNA from patient and control myoblasts was annealed to 0.36 pmol of radiolabeled specific primer in 30 mM Tris-Cl pH 7.5 and 2 mM KCl at 90 °C for 2 min and then cooled down to room temperature for 5 min. Reverse transcription reaction with 0.2 U/μL AMV Reverse Transcriptase (NEB) was performed at 42 °C for 30 min using a dNTP/ddCTP mix at 0.25 mM each (final concentration). Subsequently, RNaseH (Epicentre) was added, and the reaction incubated at 37 °C for 10 min to degrade RNA. To 5 μL cDNA, 5 μL RNA Loading dye (Formamide + bromophenol blue) was added and RT products resolved on a 12% denaturing PAGE (7 M Urea,1× TBE, 30 cm). After the run, the gel was fixed and dried on whatman paper and exposed to a Phosphor screen.
Total RNA was isolated from myoblasts with the Monarch total RNA Miniprep Kit (NEB) with on-column DNAseI digest. A gene-specific primer (5′-GGCACTCCATCATCTTGTCC-3′ for MTU1 and 5′-CTTCCAGGCTGGGACTGAG-3′ for ATAD3A) was annealed to 400 ng of RNA and reverse transcribed with Maxima H Minus RT (Thermo Scientific) at 50 °C for 30 min. For the subsequent PCR, 5% of the RT-reaction was used as a template with Econo-Taq (Lucigen) and primers specific for MTU1 (forward 5′-CAGGTTTCCCAGGATGCCC-3′, reverse 5′-AGGAACCAACCTTTATGTGTTCC-3′) and ATAD3A (forward 5′-TGAGGAGAGGAGGAAGACCC-3′, reverse 5′-TGCTGCTTCAGTTGGTCCTC-3′).
Cells were prepared as described in ref. 44. Briefly, whole-cell pellets were solubilized in phosphate buffered saline, 1% dodecyl-maltoside (DDM), 1 mM PMSF (phenylmethylsulfonyl fluoride), and complete protease inhibitor (Thermo Fisher). Protein concentrations were measured by the Bradford assay (BioRad). Equal amounts of proteins were separated by Tris-Glycine SDS-PAGE. Membranes were blocked in TBST with 1% milk at room temperature for 1 h then primary antibodies (Proteintech Group: MTO1 (15650-1AP, 1:5000); TRMT61B (26009-1AP, 1:2000); MT-CYB (55090-1-AP, 1:1000); MT-ATP6 (55313-1-AP, 1:2000); MRPL11 (15543-1-AP, 1:20000); MRPL45 (15682-1-AP, 1:5000); MRPS27 (17280-1-AP, 1:5000). Abcam: MT-CO1 (1D6E1A8, 1:1000); SDHA (2E3GC12FB2AE2, 1:10000). Santa Cruz: TOM40 (sc-11414, 1:2000)) were incubated overnight at + 4 °C in 5% BSA/TBST and detected the following day with secondary HRP conjugates (Jackson ImmunoResearch) using ECL with film. Representative data of independent experiments were cropped in Photoshop with only linear corrections applied.
Metabolic labeling of mitochondrial protein synthesis
Mitochondrial protein synthesis was analyzed by metabolic labeling with 35S methionine/cysteine44. Cells were pre-treated with anisomycin (100 μg/ml) to inhibit cytoplasmic translation then pulsed with 200 μCi/ml 35S Met-Cys (EasyTag-Perkin Elmer). In chase experiments, cells were pulsed for 30 min with radiolabel then the medium removed and replaced with fresh medium lacking the radioisotope for the indicated time. Equal amounts of sample protein were first treated with Benzonase (Thermofisher) on ice and then resuspended in 1x translation loading buffer (186 mM Tris-Cl pH 6.7, 15% glycerol, 2% SDS, 0.5 mg/ml bromophenol blue, 6% beta-mercaptoethanol). A 12–20% gradient Tris-Glycine SDS-PAGE was used to separate samples then dried for exposure with a Phospho screen and scanned with a Typhoon 9400 or Typhoon FLA 7000 (GE Healthcare) for quantification. Gels were rehydrated in water and Coomassie stained to confirm loading.
All tRNA-seq data are deposited to NCBI GEO with the accession number GSE106601 and all other data is available from the authors.
Suomalainen, A. & Battersby, B. J. Mitochondrial diseases: the contribution of organelle stress responses to pathology. Nat. Rev. Mol. Cell Biol. 19, 77–92 (2018).
Yarham, J. W., Elson, J. L., Blakely, E. L., McFarland, R. & Taylor, R. W. Mitochondrial tRNA mutations and disease. Wiley Interdiscip. Rev. RNA 1, 304–324 (2010).
Shoffner, J. M. et al. Myoclonic epilepsy and ragged-red fiber disease (MERRF) is associated with a mitochondrial DNA tRNA(Lys) mutation. Cell 61, 931–937 (1990).
Enriquez, J. A., Chomyn, A. & Attardi, G. MtDNA mutation in MERRF syndrome causes defective aminoacylation of tRNA(Lys) and premature translation termination. Nat. Genet. 10, 47–55 (1995).
Yasukawa, T., Suzuki, T., Ishii, N., Ohta, S. & Watanabe, K. Wobble modification defect in tRNA disturbs codon–anticodon interaction in a mitochondrial disease. EMBO J. 20, 4794–4802 (2001).
Kirino, Y. et al. Codon-specific translational defect caused by a wobble modification deficiency in mutant tRNA from a human mitochondrial disease. Proc. Natl Acad. Sci. USA 101, 15070–15075 (2004).
Yasukawa, T. et al. Defect in modification at the anticodon wobble nucleotide of mitochondrial tRNA(Lys) with the MERRF encephalomyopathy pathogenic mutation. FEBS Lett. 467, 175–178 (2000).
Rogalski, M., Karcher, D. & Bock, R. Superwobbling facilitates translation with reduced tRNA sets. Nat. Struct. Mol. Biol. 15, 192–198 (2008).
Suzuki, T., Nagao, A. & Suzuki, T. Human mitochondrial tRNAs: biogenesis, function, structural aspects, and diseases. Annu. Rev. Genet. 45, 299–329 (2011).
Nedialkova, D. D. & Leidel, S. A. Optimization of codon translation rates via tRNA modifications maintains proteome integrity. Cell 161, 1606–1618 (2015).
Zinshteyn, B. & Gilbert, W. V. Loss of a conserved tRNA anticodon modification perturbs cellular signaling. PLoS Genet. 9, e1003675 (2013).
Ranjan, N. & Rodnina, M. V. Thio-modification of tRNA at the wobble position as regulator of the kinetics of decoding and translocation on the ribosome. J. Am. Chem. Soc. 139, 5857–5864 (2017).
Boulet, L., Karpati, G. & Shoubridge, E. A. Distribution and threshold expression of the tRNA(Lys) mutation in skeletal muscle of patients with myoclonic epilepsy and ragged-red fibers (MERRF). Am. J. Hum. Genet. 51, 1187–1200 (1992).
Sasarman, F., Antonicka, H. & Shoubridge, E. A. The A3243G tRNALeu(UUR) MELAS mutation causes amino acid misincorporation and a combined respiratory chain assembly defect partially suppressed by overexpression of EFTu and EFG2. Hum. Mol. Genet. 17, 3697–3707 (2008).
Pearce, S. F. et al. Maturation of selected human mitochondrial tRNAs requires deadenylation. eLife 6, e27596 (2017).
Lewis, C. J. T., Pan, T. & Kalsotra, A. RNA modifications and structures cooperate to guide RNA-protein interactions. Nat. Rev. Mol. Cell Biol. 18, 202–210 (2017).
Zheng, G. et al. Efficient and quantitative high-throughput tRNA sequencing. Nat. Methods 12, 835–837 (2015).
Clark, W. C., Evans, M. E., Dominissini, D., Zheng, G. & Pan, T. tRNA base methylation identification and quantification via high-throughput sequencing. RNA 22, 1771–1784 (2016).
Blumberg, A., Rice, E. J., Kundaje, A., Danko, C. G. & Mishmar, D. Initiation of mtDNA transcription is followed by pausing, and diverges across human cell types and during evolution. Genome Res. 27, 362–373 (2017).
King, M. P. & Attardi, G. Post-transcriptional regulation of the steady-state levels of mitochondrial tRNAs in HeLa cells. J. Biol. Chem. 268, 10228–10237 (1993).
Van Haute, L. et al. Mitochondrial transcript maturation and its disorders. J. Inherit. Metab. Dis. 38, 655–680 (2015).
Yasukawa, T. et al. Wobble modification deficiency in mutant tRNAs in patients with mitochondrial diseases. FEBS Lett. 579, 2948–2952 (2005).
Chujo, T. & Suzuki, T. Trmt61B is a methyltransferase responsible for 1-methyladenosine at position 58 of human mitochondrial tRNAs. RNA 18, 2269–2276 (2012).
Kawarada, L. et al. ALKBH1 is an RNA dioxygenase responsible for cytoplasmic and mitochondrial tRNA modifications. Nucleic Acids Res. 45, 7401–7415 (2017).
Helm, M. et al. The presence of modified nucleotides is required for cloverleaf folding of a human mitochondrial tRNA. Nucleic Acids Res. 26, 1636–1643 (1998).
Vilardo, E. et al. A subcomplex of human mitochondrial RNase P is a bifunctional methyltransferase--extensive moonlighting in mitochondrial tRNA biogenesis. Nucleic Acids Res. 40, 11583–11593 (2012).
Toompuu, M. et al. Polyadenylation and degradation of structurally abnormal mitochondrial tRNAs in human cells. Nucleic Acids Res. (2018) https://doi.org/10.1093/nar/gky159
Sasarman, F. et al. The 3’ addition of CCA to mitochondrial tRNASer(AGY) is specifically impaired in patients with mutations in the tRNA nucleotidyl transferase TRNT1. Hum. Mol. Genet. 24, 2841–2847 (2015).
Chakraborty, P. K. et al. Mutations in TRNT1 cause congenital sideroblastic anemia with immunodeficiency, fevers, and developmental delay (SIFD). Blood 124, 2867–2871 (2014).
Bar-Yaacov, D. et al. Mitochondrial 16S rRNA is methylated by tRNA methyltransferase TRMT61B in all vertebrates. PLoS Biol. 14, e1002557 (2016).
Li, X. et al. Base-resolution mapping reveals distinct m1A methylome in nuclear- and mitochondrial-encoded transcripts. Mol. Cell 68, 993–1005 (2017).
Safra, M. et al. The m1A landscape on cytosolic and mitochondrial mRNA at single-base resolution. Nature 551, 251–255 (2017).
Carroll, C. J. et al. Whole-exome sequencing identifies a mutation in the mitochondrial ribosome protein MRPL44 to underlie mitochondrial infantile cardiomyopathy. J. Med. Genet. 50, 151–159 (2013).
Zeharia, A. et al. Acute infantile liver failure due to mutations in the TRMU gene. Am. J. Hum. Genet. 85, 401–407 (2009).
Sasarman, F., Antonicka, H., Horvath, R. & Shoubridge, E. A. The 2-thiouridylase function of the human MTU1 (TRMU) enzyme is dispensable for mitochondrial translation. Hum. Mol. Genet. 20, 4634–4643 (2011).
Roundtree, I. A., Evans, M. E., Pan, T. & He, C. Dynamic RNA modifications in gene expression regulation. Cell 169, 1187–1200 (2017).
Liu, F. et al. ALKBH1-mediated tRNA demethylation regulates translation. Cell 167, 816–828 (2016).
Ledoux, S. & Uhlenbeck, O. C. Different aa-tRNAs are selected uniformly on the ribosome. Mol. Cell 31, 114–123 (2008).
Ott, M., Amunts, A. & Brown, A. Organization and regulation of mitochondrial protein synthesis. Annu. Rev. Biochem. 85, 77–101 (2016).
Rorbach, J. & Minczuk, M. The post-transcriptional life of mammalian mitochondrial RNA. Biochem. J. 444, 357–373 (2012).
Crosby, A. H. et al. Defective mitochondrial mRNA maturation is associated with spastic ataxia. Am. J. Hum. Genet. 87, 655–660 (2010).
Bratic, A. et al. Mitochondrial polyadenylation is a one-step process required for mRNA integrity and tRNA maturation. PLoS Genet. 12, e1006028 (2016).
Lochmüller, H., Johns, T. & Shoubridge, E. A. Expression of the E6 and E7 genes of human papillomavirus (HPV16) extends the life span of human myoblasts. Exp. Cell Res. 248, 186–193 (1999).
Richter, U., Lahtinen, T., Marttinen, P., Suomi, F. & Battersby, B. J. Quality control of mitochondrial protein synthesis is required for membrane integrity and cell fitness. J. Cell Biol. 211, 373–389 (2015).
Hauenschild, R. et al. The reverse transcription signature of N-1-methyladenosine in RNA-Seq is sequence dependent. Nucleic Acids Res. 43, 9950–9964 (2015).
We thank L.S. Churchman, H.T. Jacobs, and M. Toompuu for valuable discussion; K.Y. Ng for technical help; and C. Patil for editing. This work was supported by the Academy of Finland Centre of Excellence on Mitochondria to B.J.B.; an Academy of Finland postdoctoral award to U.R.; by the National Institutes of Health [RM1HG008935 to T.P.]; M.E.E. and W.C.C. were supported by the National Institutes of Health Chemistry and Biology Training Grant [T32 GM008720]; and M.E.E. was a recipient of the National Science Foundation pre-doctoral fellowship [DGE-1144082].
The authors declare no competing interests.
Publisher's note: Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.
About this article
Cite this article
Richter, U., Evans, M.E., Clark, W.C. et al. RNA modification landscape of the human mitochondrial tRNALys regulates protein synthesis. Nat Commun 9, 3966 (2018). https://doi.org/10.1038/s41467-018-06471-z
Current Opinion in Microbiology (2020)
Expert Review of Neurotherapeutics (2020)
Journal of Internal Medicine (2020)
Nature Chemical Biology (2020)
Frontiers in Genetics (2019)