Tractography based on non-invasive diffusion imaging is central to the study of human brain connectivity. To date, the approach has not been systematically validated in ground truth studies. Based on a simulated human brain data set with ground truth tracts, we organized an open international tractography challenge, which resulted in 96 distinct submissions from 20 research groups. Here, we report the encouraging finding that most state-of-the-art algorithms produce tractograms containing 90% of the ground truth bundles (to at least some extent). However, the same tractograms contain many more invalid than valid bundles, and half of these invalid bundles occur systematically across research groups. Taken together, our results demonstrate and confirm fundamental ambiguities inherent in tract reconstruction based on orientation information alone, which need to be considered when interpreting tractography and connectivity results. Our approach provides a novel framework for estimating reliability of tractography and encourages innovation to address its current limitations.
Tractography, a computational reconstruction method based on diffusion-weighted magnetic resonance imaging (DWI), attempts to reveal the trajectories of white matter pathways in vivo and to infer the underlying structural connectome of the human brain1. Numerous algorithms for tractography have been developed and applied to connectome research in the field of neuroscience2 and psychiatry3. Given the broad interest in this approach, advantages and shortcomings of tractography have been addressed using a wide range of approaches1, 4,5,6,7,8. Particularly, in vivo tractography of the human brain has been evaluated by subjective assessment of plausibility9, 10 or qualitative visual agreement with post-mortem Klingler-like dissections11, 12. Reproducibility13 or data prediction errors14,15,16 have been evaluated in the context of tractography model verification. However, these evaluations cannot validate the accuracy of reconstructions due to the lack of ground truth information17. Ex vivo imaging and tracing17,18,19,20,21,22,23 or physically24,25,26,27,28,29,30 and numerically simulated phantoms31,32,33,34 allow validation to some extent, and in specific circumstances such as basic fiber configurations. The nervous system, however, is complex and precise ground truth information on the trajectories of pathways and their origins, as well as terminations in the human brain is lacking. This makes it hard to obtain quantitative and comprehensive reliability estimations of tractography and to determine which discoveries are reliable when regarding brain connectivity in health and disease.
State-of-the-art tractography algorithms are driven by local orientation fields estimated from DWI, representing the local tangent direction to the white matter tract of interest1. Conceptually, the principle of inferring connectivity from local orientation fields can lead to problems as soon as pathways overlap, cross, branch, and have complex geometries7, 35, 36. Since the invention of diffusion tractography, these problems have been discussed in schematic representations or theoretical arguments7, 8, 37, but have not yet been quantified in brain imaging. To determine the current state of the art in tractography, we organized an international tractography competition (tractometer.org/ismrm_2015_challenge). We employed simulated DWI of a brain-like geometry as a novel reliability estimation method that allowed for a quantitative evaluation of the submissions based on the Tractometer connectivity metrics38.
At the closing of the competition, we evaluated 96 distinct tractography pipelines submitted by 20 different research groups, in order to assess how well the algorithms were able to reproduce the known connectivity. We also assessed essential processing steps to pinpoint critical flaws that many current pipelines have in common. An important positive finding is that most proposed algorithms are able to produce tractograms containing 90% of the ground truth bundles, recovering about one-third of their volumetric extent. At the same time, most algorithms produce large amounts of false-positive bundles, even though they are not part of the ground truth. Results do not improve when employing higher-quality data or even using the gold standard field of local tract orientations at high spatial resolution. The findings highlight that novel technological and conceptual developments are needed to address these limitations.
Data sets and submissions
Prior investigations of tractography methodology have chosen artificial fiber geometries to construct synthetic ground truth models26, 38. Here, we defined our models based on the fiber bundle geometry of a high-quality Human Connectome Project (HCP) data set that was constructed from multiple whole-brain global tractography maps39 (Fig. 1). Following the concepts introduced in ref. 40, an expert radiologist (B.S.) extracted 25 major tracts (i.e., bundles of streamlines) from the tractogram. This ground truth data set included association, projection, and commissural tracts that have been previously described using post-mortem anatomical and electrophysiological methods41. In total the tracts occupy 71% of the white matter volume in the human brain. The data set features a brain-like macro-structure of long-range connections, mimicking in vivo DWI clinical-like acquisitions based on a simulated diffusion signal. An additional anatomical image with T1-like contrast was simulated as a reference. The final data sets and all files necessary to perform the simulation are openly available (see Data availability).
Twenty research groups with extensive expertise in diffusion imaging from 12 countries (Fig. 2a) participated in the competition and submitted a total of 96 tractograms (see Data availability) generated using a large variety of tractography pipelines with different pre-processing, local reconstruction, tractography, and post-processing algorithms (Fig. 2b, Supplementary Note 1).
Performance metrics and evaluation
The Tractometer connectivity metrics38 were used for a quantitative evaluation of the submissions. Based on the known ground truth bundles, we calculated true positives, corresponding to the valid connection (VC) ratio, that is, the proportion of streamlines connecting valid end points and the associated number of valid bundles (VB), where a bundle is a group of streamlines. We also computed false positives, corresponding to the invalid connection (IC) ratio and the associated number of invalid bundles (IB), as well as reconstructed volumes, based on the bundle volumetric overlap (OL) and volumetric overreach (OR) in percent (see “Methods” section for details and Supplementary Figs. 1, 2 for alternative metrics).
Tractograms contained most of the ground truth bundles
The volumetric reconstruction of the existing bundles varied greatly from tract to tract. Figure 3a shows that identified VBs can be arbitrarily grouped into three clusters of very hard, hard, and medium difficulty, according to the percentage of OL. Figure 3b shows corresponding examples that were reconstructed by different tractography techniques. All submissions had difficulties reconstructing the smallest tracts, that is, the anterior (CA) and posterior commissures (CP) that have a cross-sectional diameter of no more than 2 mm, or one or two voxels (very hard, 0% <= OL < 10%). A family of hard bundles was partly recovered (10% <= OL < 50%). Bundles of medium difficulty were the corpus callosum (CC), inferior longitudinal fasciculus (ILF), superior longitudinal fasciculus (SLF), and uncinate fasciculus (UF) with an average of more than 50% volumetric recovery (50% <= OL <= 100%). A Pearson product-moment correlation coefficient was computed to assess the relationship between OL and OR (r = 0.88, p < 10–8), indicating a direct link between the probability of reconstructing a greater portion of a tract (OL) and generating artefactual trajectories (OR).
Figure 4 shows that on average 21 out of 25 VBs (median 23) were identified by the participating teams with only four teams submitting tractograms that contained an OL of more than 60%. No submission contained all 25 VBs, but 10 submissions (10.4%) recovered 24 VBs, and 69 submissions (71.9%) detected 23 or more VBs (Fig. 5a). However, tractography pipelines clearly need to improve their recovery of the full spatial extent of bundles: the mean value of bundle volume overlap (OL) across all submissions was 36 ± 16%, with an average overreach (OR) of 29 ± 26% (Fig. 4c). At the level of individual streamlines, an average of 54 ± 23% connections were valid (Fig. 4a).
Tractograms contained more invalid than valid bundles
Across submissions, 36 ± 17% of the reconstructed individual streamlines connected regions that were not actually connected. The fraction of streamlines not connecting any endpoints was 10 ± 15%. Even though not part of the ground truth, these streamlines often occur in dense, structured, and coherent bundles. Submitted tractograms contained an average of 88 ± 58 IBs, which is more than four times the amount of VBs they contained on average (Fig. 4b). This demonstrates the inability of current state-of-the-art tractography algorithms to control for false positives. Forty-one of these IBs occurred in the majority of submissions (Fig. 5, Supplementary Fig. 3). Overall average precision on the bundle level was 23 ± 9% (recall 85 ± 15%, specificity 93 ± 5%). Submissions with at least 23 VBs showed no fewer than 37 IBs (mean 88 ± 39, n = 69). Submissions with 23 or more VBs and a volumetric bundle overlap of >50% identified between 99 and 204 IBs.
The bundles illustrated in Fig. 5b were systematically found by 81–95% of submissions without being part of the ground truth. Interestingly, several of these invalid streamline clusters exhibited similarities in anatomical location to bundles known or previously debated in tractography literature, such as the frontal aslant tract (FAT)42, the arcuate fasciculus (AF)43, the inferior frontal occipital fasciculus (IFOF)44, the middle longitudinal fasciculus (MdLF)45, the extreme capsule fasciculus46, the superior fronto-occipital fasciculus (SFOF)44, 47, and the vertical occipital fasciculus (VOF)48. These findings suggest that evidence for the existence of tracts should not be taken solely from tractography at its current state but complemented by other anatomical and electrophysiological methods.
Higher image quality may improve tractography validity
To confirm that our findings revealed fundamental properties of tractography itself and are not related to effects of our specific phantom simulation process, we ran two independent implementations of deterministic streamline tractography (Supplementary Note 2) directly on the ground truth field of fiber orientations (Fig. 6), that is, without using the diffusion-weighted data at all. This experiment was repeated for multiple resolutions (2, 1.75, 1.5, 1.25, 1.0, 0.75, and 0.5 mm). This setup was, thus, independent of image quality, artifacts, and many other influences from specific pipeline configurations and the phantom generation process. Based on the ground truth orientations, the tractography pipelines achieved overlap scores (76 ± 6%) that were previously unreached at similar levels of overreach (29 ± 8%). VC ratios were between 71 and 82%. However, the tractograms still contained 102 ± 24 IBs (minimum 73).
Methodological innovation may improve tractography validity
Our results show that the geometry of many junctions in the simulated data set is too complex to be resolved by current tractography algorithms, even when given a perfect ground truth field of orientations. Thus, the problems seem to relate to essential ambiguities in the directional information (Fig. 7). They persisted in supplementary experiments performed to test the potential of currently available anatomical constraints and global tractography approaches (Supplementary Note 2), in which none of the additionally ran methods surpassed the challenge submissions in bundle detection performance (Supplementary Fig. 4).
We further investigated the ambiguities tractography encounters in the synthetic phantom as well as in an in vivo data set. In the temporal lobe, for example, multiple bundles overlap and clearly outnumber the count of fiber orientations in most of the voxels. As illustrated in Fig. 8, single fiber directions in the diffusion signal regularly represent multiple bundles (see also Supplementary Movie 1). Such funnels embody hard bottlenecks for tractography, leading to massive combinatorial possibilities of plausible configurations for connecting the associated bundle endpoints as sketched in Figs. 7c and 8c. Consequently, for the real data set as well as the synthetic phantom, dozens of structured and coherent bundles pass through this bottleneck, exhibiting similar fiber counts (cf. Supplementary Figs. 5, 6) and a wide range of anatomically reasonable geometries as illustrated in Supplementary Movie 2. A tractogram based on real HCP data exhibits a whole family of theoretically plausible bundles going through the temporal lobe bottleneck even though, locally, the diffusion signal often shows only one fiber direction (cf. Fig. 8d). Methodological innovation will be necessary to resolve these issues and better exploit additional information sources that complement the local orientation fields estimated from DWI.
Statistical analysis of processing steps
Effects of the methodological setup of the different submissions on the results were investigated in a multivariable linear mixed model and revealed the influence of the individual processing steps on the tractography outcome (Table 1). The choice of tractography algorithm, as well as the post-tracking filtering strategy and the underlying diffusion modeling had a strong effect on overall scores, revealing a clear tradeoff between sensitivity and specificity (Supplementary Note 3). Manual editing of tractograms following anatomical priors had a negative impact on the number of VBs identified (mean effect: 3.8 ± 2.6 bundles) and on the bundle overlap (mean effect: −15 ± 11%). However, such techniques showed a positive impact on the average bundle overreach (mean effect: −16 ± 9%). Notably, Team 3 post-processed the tractograms using clustering, reaching 92% validly connecting streamlines keeping only the larger clusters.
We assessed current state-of-the-art fiber tractography approaches using a ground truth data set of white matter tracts and connectivity that is representative of the challenges that may occur in human in vivo brain imaging. Advanced tractography strategies in combination with current diffusion modeling techniques successfully recovered most VBs, covering up to 77% of their volumetric extent. This result demonstrates the capability of current methods and teams to adequately handle numerous artifacts in DWI and overcome local crossing situations during tract reconstruction. However, tractography also produced thick and dense bundles of plausible looking streamlines in locations where such streamlines did not actually exist. When focusing on the 64 bundles that were systematically recovered by the majority of submissions, 64% of them were in fact absent from the ground truth. Current tractography pipelines, and even tracking of the ground truth fiber orientations on high-resolution images, produce substantial amounts of false-positive bundles. The employed simulation-based approach cannot quantify the effects related to in vivo connectivity in an absolute sense; that is, our results do not mean that anyone who is doing tractography should expect the reported VB-to-IB and coverage-to-overreach ratios. However, the presented findings do expose the degree of ambiguity associated with whole-brain tractography and show that the computational problem of tractography goes far beyond the local reconstruction of fiber directions1, 7 and issues of data quality. Our findings, therefore, present a core and open challenge for the field of tractography and connectivity mapping in general.
Previous studies have reported high invalid-connection ratios under simplified conditions26, 38 (www.tractometer.org), and some of the underlying ambiguities in tractography have been discussed using schematic representations and theoretical arguments1, 7, 8, 37. Regions of white matter bottlenecks have been discussed in the past35 and have been highlighted as critical with respect to tractographic findings36. The current results reveal the consequences of such limitations under more complex conditions as might be found in human brain studies in vivo, addressing important questions that previously remained speculative. The findings were derived from a brain-like geometry that encompasses some of the major known long-range connections and covers 71% of the white matter. Future versions of the phantom are planned to include additional bundles such as the middle and inferior temporal projections of the AF, the MdLF, and the IFOF, as well as smaller U-fibers, medial forebrain fibers, deep nuclei, and connections between them. In addition, more advanced diffusion modeling methods will allow generating even more realistic DWI signals, potentially simulated at increased spatial and q-space resolutions49.
These developments, however, will not resolve the fundamental ambiguities which tractography faces and thus will only have a limited effect on the main findings of our study. We showed that false-positive bundles occur at similar rates even when using the maximal angular precision of the signal, that is, using ground truth orientations. These findings confirm those shown in previous studies5 and relate to the fundamental problem formulation in tractography: inferring connectivity from local orientation fields. Increasing the anatomic complexity of the phantom by adding more bundles most likely will even lead to further increased false-positive rates. The construction process of the current phantom resembles a potential limitation, since it involves tractography itself and thus raises self-validation issues. This aspect should be considered in direct method comparisons as there may exist a possible bias toward algorithms that are similar to the algorithm used for phantom generation. This caveat, however, has only a very limited effect on our general findings. It can be expected that the identified limitations of tractography will become even more pronounced in phantoms of higher anatomic complexity that might be achievable by involving independent methods such as polarized light imaging50. In summary, our observations confirm the fundamental ill-posed nature of the computational problem that current tractography approaches strive to solve.
Accordingly, substantial methodological innovations will be necessary to resolve the problem of IBs. Several directions of current research might improve the specificity of tractography. Streamline filtering techniques can optimize the signal prediction error in order to reduce tractography biases14, 16, 51. They are part of the more general trend to integrate non-local information, as well as advanced diffusion microstructure modeling that goes beyond the raw directional vectors52,53,54,55,56,57,58. Recent advances in machine-learning-driven tractography also show great potential in improving the specificity of tractograms59, 60. Future versions of our phantom will be generated with multiple b-values, better signal-to-noise ratio (SNR), and fewer artifacts to further encourage research in these directions.
In addition, tractography should increasingly employ reliable anatomical priors from ex vivo histology, high-resolution post-mortem DWI61, or complementary electrophysiology for optimal guidance. While manual or automated clean-up of streamlines may help (as demonstrated by our results showing decreased overreach at the expense of VB detection and volumetric reconstruction), the real challenge is our limited knowledge of the anatomy to be reconstructed. Currently, post-mortem dissection with Klingler’s method reveals the macroscopic organization of the human brain white matter11, 62,63,64, although this method shares some of the mentioned limitations of tractography in complex fiber configurations or near the cortex. In the future, the community will have to gain further insights into the underlying principles of white matter organization and increasingly learn how to leverage such information for tractography1, 65, 66.
Potential advances achieved in tractography will have an important impact on graph-analytical studies of the structural connectome2, 67. The hitherto demonstrated diagnostic or predictive capability of such analyses (e.g., in psychiatric settings) should not let us overlook which aspects of tractography are reliable and which are not. One of the present findings is particularly relevant for the field of connectomics: the traditional metrics that require streamlines to exactly end in head or tail regions of a bundle are far too restrictive for bundle dissection and connectivity assessment. None of the submissions generated exact streamlines that perfectly overlap with ground truth bundles and dilated endpoint masks. This finding is in line with previous reports, which found termination of tracts in the gray matter (GM) to be inaccurate5 and highlights an important limitation of approaches that use a voxel-wise definition of parcellations on the T1 image for selecting relevant streamlines. Future versions of our phantom will include ground-truth parcellations of the white matter/GM cortical band to encourage further developments for tackling these problems and extend the evaluation method to apply to graph theory metrics.
Despite any limitations, DWI is currently the only tool to map short and long-range structural brain connectivity in vivo and is essential for comparing brains, detecting differences, and simulating brain activity39. Our findings should foster the development of novel tractography methods that are carefully evaluated using the present approach. The most important goal for the next generation of tractography algorithms is an improved ability to reconstruct the full spatial extent of existing tracts while better controlling for false-positive connections. A tighter integration of anatomical priors, advanced diffusion microstructure modeling, and multi-modality imaging should help to resolve ambiguities in the signal and overcome current limitations of tractography57, 58. Fundamentally, there is an urgent need for methodological innovation in tractography in order to advance our knowledge of human white matter anatomy and build anatomically correct human connectomes1, 7.
Generation of ground truth fiber bundles
The set of ground truth long-range fiber bundles was designed to cover the whole human brain and features many of the relevant spatial configurations, such as crossing, kissing, twisting and fanning fibers, thus representing the morphology of the major known in vivo fiber bundles. The process to obtain these bundles consisted of three steps. First, a whole-brain global tractography was performed on a high-quality in vivo diffusion-weighted image. Then, 25 major long-range bundles were manually extracted from the resulting tractogram. In the third step, these bundles were refined to obtain smooth and well-defined bundles. Each of these steps is detailed in the following paragraphs.
We chose one of the diffusion-weighted data sets included in the Q3 data release of the HCP39, subject 100307, to perform whole-brain global fiber tractography52, 68. Among other customizations, the HCP scanners are equipped with a set of high-end gradient coils, enabling diffusion encoding gradient strengths of 100 mT m−1. By comparison, most standard magnetic resonance scanners feature gradient strengths of about 30 to 40 mT m−1. This hardware setup allows the acquisition of data sets featuring exceptionally high resolutions (1.25 mm isotropic, 270 gradient directions) while maintaining an excellent SNR. All data sets were corrected for head motion, eddy currents and susceptibility distortions and are, in general, of very high quality69,70,71,72,73. Detailed information regarding the employed imaging protocols as well as the data sets themselves may be found on http://humanconnectome.org.
Global fiber tractography was performed using MITK Diffusion74 with the following parameters: 900,000,000 iterations, a particle length of 1 mm, a particle width of 0.1 mm, and a particle weight of 0.002. Furthermore, we repeated the tractography six times and combined the resulting whole-brain tractograms into one large data set consisting of over five million streamlines. The selected parameters provided for a very high sensitivity of the tractography method. The specificity of the resulting tractogram was of lesser concern since the tracts of interest were extracted manually in the second step.
Bundle segmentation was performed by an expert radiologist using manually placed inclusion and exclusion regions of interest (ROI). We followed the concepts introduced in ref. 40 for the ROI placement and fiber extraction. Twenty-five bundles were extracted, covering association, projection, and commissural fibers across the whole brain (Fig. 1): CC, left and right cingulum (Cg), Fornix (Fx), anterior commissure (CA), left and right optic radiation (OR), posterior commissure (CP), left and right inferior cerebellar peduncle (ICP), middle cerebellar peduncle (MCP), left and right superior cerebellar peduncle (SCP), left and right parieto-occipital pontine tract (POPT), left and right cortico-spinal tract (CST), left and right frontopontine tracts (FPT), left and right ILF, left and right UF, and left and right SLF. As mentioned in the “Discussion” section, the IFOF, the MdLF, as well as the middle and inferior temporal projections of the AF were not included.
After manual extraction, the individual long-range bundles were further refined to serve as ground truth for the image simulation as also shown in Fig. 1. The original extracted tracts featured a large number of prematurely ending fibers and the individual streamlines were not smooth. To obtain smooth tracts without prematurely ending fibers, we simulated a diffusion-weighted image from each original tract individually using Fiberfox (www.mitk.org33). Since no complex fiber configurations, such as crossings, were present in the individual tract images and no artifacts were simulated, it was possible to obtain very smooth and complete tracts from these images with a simple tensor-based streamline tractography. Supplementary Fig. 7 illustrates the result of this refining procedure on the left CST.
Simulation of phantom images with brain-like geometry
The phantom diffusion-weighted images (Supplementary Movie 3) were simulated using Fiberfox (www.mitk.org33), which is available as open-source software. We employed a four-compartment model of brain tissue (intra and inter-axonal), GM, and cerebrospinal fluid (CSF)33. The parameters for simulation of the four-compartment diffusion-weighted signal were chosen to obtain representative diffusion properties and image contrasts (compare75 for details on the models). The intra-axonal compartment was simulated using the stick model with a T2 relaxation time of 110 ms and a diffusivity of 1.2 × 10-9 m2 s−1. The inter-axonal compartment was simulated using the zeppelin model with a T2 relaxation time of 110 ms, an axial diffusivity of 1.2 × 10-9 m2 s−1 and a radial diffusivity of 0.3 × 10-9 m2 s−1. The GM compartment was simulated using the ball model with a T2 relaxation time of 80 ms and a diffusivity of 1.0 × 10-9 m2 s−1. The CSF compartment was also simulated using the ball model with a T2 relaxation time of 2500 ms and a diffusivity of 2.0 × 10-9 m2 s−1.
Using Fiberfox, one set of diffusion-weighted images and one T1-weighted image were simulated. The final data sets as well as all files needed to perform the simulation are available online (see Data availability).
The acquisition parameters that we report below were chosen to simulate images that are representative for a practical (e.g., clinical) setting, specifically a 5–10-min single shot echo-planar imaging scan with 2 mm isotropic voxels, 32 gradient directions, and a b-value of 1000 s mm−2. The chosen acquisition setup represents a typical scenario for an applied tractography study and embodies a common denominator supported by the large majority of methods. Since acquisitions with higher b-values, more gradient directions and fewer artifacts are beneficial for tractography, we additionally report a least upper bound tractography performance under perfect image quality conditions using a data set that directly contains ground truth fiber orientation information at high spatial resolution with no artifacts (Fig. 6 and Supplementary Note 2).
The parameters are a matrix size of 90 × 108 × 90, echo time (TE) 108 ms, dwell time 1 ms; T2′ relaxation time 50 ms. The simulation corresponded to a single-coil acquisition with constant coil sensitivity, no partial Fourier and no parallel imaging. Phase encoding was posterior-anterior. Two unweighted images with posterior-anterior/anterior-posterior phase encoding were also generated.
Since Fiberfox simulates the actual k-space acquisition, it was possible to introduce a number of common artifacts into the final image. Complex Gaussian noise was simulated yielding a final SNR relative to the mean white matter baseline signal of about 20. Ten spikes were distributed randomly throughout the image volumes (Fig. 9a). N/2 ghosts were simulated (Fig. 9b). Distortions caused by B0 field inhomogeneities are introduced using an existing field map measured in a real acquisition and registered to the employed reference HCP data set (Fig. 9c). Head motion was introduced as random rotation (±4° around z-axis) and translation (±2 mm along x-axis) in three randomly chosen volumes. Volume 6 was rotated by 3.36° and translated by −1.74 mm, volume 12 was rotated by 1.23° and translated by −0.72 mm, and volume 24 was rotated by −3.12° and translated by −1.55 mm.
The image with the T1-like contrast was generated at an isotropic resolution of 1 mm, an SNR of about 40 and no further artifacts as an anatomical reference.
Performance metrics and evaluation
The groups submitted sets of streamlines (see Data availability) and a brief description of their methods which is available in Supplementary Note 1. Potential operator-dependent errors were not taken into account but these are likely to have contributed to the quality of the final results. Probabilistic tractography techniques were preprocessed with a user-defined uncertainty threshold that each group decided independently before submission.
The Tractometer definition of a VC is extremely restrictive for current tractography algorithms, as it requires streamlines (1) not to exit the area of the ground truth bundle at any point and (2) to terminate exactly within the endpoint region that is defined by the dilated ground truth fiber endpoints (Supplementary Figs. 8, 9)38. Hence, we adopted an alternative definition with less stringent criteria based on robust shape distance measures76 and clustering between streamlines77, as detailed in Supplementary Note 4. The bundle-specific thresholds were manually configured to account for bundle shape and proximity to other bundles. The following distances were used, with identical distances on both sides for lateralized bundles: 2 mm for CA and CP; 3 mm for CST and SCP; 5 mm for Cingulum; 6 mm for Fornix, ICP, OR, and UF; 7 mm for FPT, ILF, and POPT; 10 mm for CC, MCP, and SLF. The full script used to run this bundle recognition implementation was based on the DIPY library78 (www.dipy.org) and is available online (Supplementary Software 1).
Once VCs are identified, the remaining streamlines can be classified into ICs and non-connecting streamlines. The details of this procedure are described in Supplementary Note 4. We clustered the remaining invalid streamlines using a QuickBundles-based clustering algorithm77. The best matching endpoint regions for each resulting cluster were identified by majority voting of the contained streamlines. If multiple clusters were assigned to the same pair of regions, they were merged. Streamlines that were not assigned to any cluster or that fell below a length threshold were labeled as non-connecting.
On the basis of this classification of streamlines, the following metrics were calculated:
VC ratio: Number of VCs/total number of streamlines (percentage between 0 and 100).
VB: For each bundle that has at least one valid streamline associated with it, this counter is incremented by one (integer number between 0 and 25).
IB: With 25 bundles in the ground truth, each having two endpoint regions, there are 1275 possible combinations of endpoint regions. Taking the 25 VBs out of the equation, 1250 potential IBs remain (integer number between 0 and 1250).
Overlap: Proportion of the voxels within the volume of a ground truth bundle that is traversed by at least one valid streamline associated with the bundle. This value shows how well the tractography result recovers the original volume of the bundle (percentage between 0 and 100).
Overreach: Fraction of voxels outside the volume of a ground truth bundle that is traversed by at least one valid streamline associated with the bundle over the total number of voxels within the ground truth bundle. This value shows how much the VCs extend beyond the ground truth bundle volume (percentage between 0 and 100). This value is always zero for the traditional definition of a VC, but can be non-zero for the non-stringent criteria we adopted in our study.
Following previously defined criteria of evaluation79, our study is mainly about accuracy with respect to the reference, rather than reproducibility or robustness of tractography.
Statistical multi-variable analysis
Effects of the experimental settings were investigated in a multivariable linear mixed model. The experimental variables describing the methods used for the different submissions were included as fixed effects (Fig. 2b). The VC ratio, the VB count, the IB count, the bundle overlap percentage, and the bundle overreach percentage were modeled as dependent variables, each of which is used for the calculation of a separate model. The submitting group was modeled as a random effect. The software SAS 9.2, Proc Mixed, SAS Institute Inc., Cary, NC, USA, was used for the analysis.
The authors declare that the data supporting the findings of this study are available within the paper and its Supplementary Information files. The ISMRM 2015 Tractography Challenge data sets and the submitted tractograms are available under doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.572345 and doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.840086, respectively.
Jbabdi, S., Sotiropoulos, S. N., Haber, S. N., Van Essen, D. C. & Behrens, T. E. Measuring macroscopic brain connections in vivo. Nat. Neurosci. 18, 1546–1555 (2015).
Bullmore, E. & Sporns, O. Complex brain networks: graph theoretical analysis of structural and functional systems. Nat. Rev. Neurosci. 10, 186–198 (2009).
Deco, G. & Kringelbach, M. L. Great expectations: using whole-brain computational connectomics for understanding neuropsychiatric disorders. Neuron 84, 892–905 (2014).
Craddock, R. C. et al. Imaging human connectomes at the macroscale. Nat. Methods 10, 524–539 (2013).
Thomas, C. et al. Anatomical accuracy of brain connections derived from diffusion MRI tractography is inherently limited. Proc. Natl Acad. Sci. USA 111, 16574–16579 (2014).
Reveley, C. et al. Superficial white matter fiber systems impede detection of long-range cortical connections in diffusion MR tractography. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 112, E2820–E2828 (2015).
Jbabdi, S. & Johansen-Berg, H. Tractography: where do we go from here? Brain Connect. 1, 169–183 (2011).
Jones, D. K. Challenges and limitations of quantifying brain connectivity in vivo with diffusion MRI. Imaging Med. 2, 341–355 (2010).
Pujol, S. et al. The DTI challenge: toward standardized evaluation of diffusion tensor imaging tractography for neurosurgery. J. Neuroimaging 25, 875–882 (2015).
Feigl, G. C. et al. Magnetic resonance imaging diffusion tensor tractography: evaluation of anatomic accuracy of different fiber tracking software packages. World Neurosurg. 81, 144–150 (2014).
Martino, J. et al. Cortex-sparing fiber dissection: an improved method for the study of white matter anatomy in the human brain. J. Anat. 219, 531–541 (2011).
Wang, X. et al. Subcomponents and connectivity of the superior longitudinal fasciculus in the human brain. Brain Struct. Funct. 221, 2075–2092 (2015).
Wakana, S. et al. Reproducibility of quantitative tractography methods applied to cerebral white matter. Neuroimage 36, 630–644 (2007).
Pestilli, F., Yeatman, J. D., Rokem, A., Kay, K. N. & Wandell, B. A. Evaluation and statistical inference for human connectomes. Nat. Methods 11, 1058–1063 (2014).
Neher, P. F., Descoteaux, M., Houde, J.-C., Stieltjes, B. & Maier-Hein, K. H. Strengths and weaknesses of state of the art fiber tractography pipelines—a comprehensive in-vivo and phantom evaluation study using Tractometer. Med. Image Anal. 26, 287–305 (2015).
Daducci, A., Dal Palù, A., Lemkaddem, A. & Thiran, J.-P. COMMIT: convex optimization modeling for microstructure informed tractography. IEEE Trans. Med. Imaging 34, 246–257 (2015).
Dyrby, T. B. et al. Validation of in vitro probabilistic tractography. Neuroimage 37, 1267–1277 (2007).
Campbell, J. S., Siddiqi, K., Rymar, V. V., Sadikot, A. F. & Pike, G. B. Flow-based fiber tracking with diffusion tensor and q-ball data: validation and comparison to principal diffusion direction techniques. Neuroimage 27, 725–736 (2005).
Dauguet, J. et al. Comparison of fiber tracts derived from in-vivo DTI tractography with 3D histological neural tract tracer reconstruction on a macaque brain. Neuroimage 37, 530–538 (2007).
Schmahmann, J. D. et al. Association fibre pathways of the brain: parallel observations from diffusion spectrum imaging and autoradiography. Brain 130, 630–653 (2007).
Seehaus, A. K. et al. Histological validation of DW-MRI tractography in human postmortem tissue. Cereb. Cortex 23, 442–450 (2013).
Knösche, T. R., Anwander, A., Liptrot, M. & Dyrby, T. B. Validation of tractography: comparison with manganese tracing. Hum. Brain Mapp. 36, 4116–4134 (2015).
Donahue, C. J. et al. Using diffusion tractography to predict cortical connection strength and distance: a quantitative comparison with tracers in the monkey. J. Neurosci. 36, 6758–6770 (2016).
Bach, M., Maier-Hein (ne Fritzsche), K. H., Stieltjes, B. & Laun, F. B. Investigation of resolution effects using a specialized diffusion tensor phantom. Magn. Reson. Med. 71, 1108–1116 (2013).
Fieremans, E. et al. The design of anisotropic diffusion phantoms for the validation of diffusion weighted magnetic resonance imaging. Phys. Med. Biol. 53, 5405–5421 (2008).
Fillard, P. et al. Quantitative evaluation of 10 tractography algorithms on a realistic diffusion MR phantom. Neuroimage 56, 220–234 (2011).
Maier-Hein (ne Fritzsche), K. H., Laun, F. B., Meinzer, H.-P. & Stieltjes, B. Opportunities and pitfalls in the quantification of fiber integrity: what can we gain from Q-ball imaging? Neuroimage 51, 242–251 (2010).
Moussavi-Biugui, A., Stieltjes, B., Fritzsche, K., Semmler, W. & Laun, F. B. Novel spherical phantoms for Q-ball imaging under in vivo conditions. Magn. Reson. Med. 65, 190–194 (2011).
Poupon, C. et al. New diffusion phantoms dedicated to the study and validation of high-angular-resolution diffusion imaging (HARDI) models. Magn. Reson. Med. 60, 1276–1283 (2008).
Pullens, P., Roebroeck, A. & Goebel, R. Ground truth hardware phantoms for validation of diffusion-weighted MRI applications. J. Magn. Reson. Imaging 32, 482–488 (2010).
Close, T. G. et al. A software tool to generate simulated white matter structures for the assessment of fibre-tracking algorithms. Neuroimage 47, 1288–1300 (2009).
Leemans, A., Sijbers, J., Verhoye, M., Van der Linden, A. & Van Dyck, D. Mathematical framework for simulating diffusion tensor MR neural fiber bundles. Magn. Reson. Med. 53, 944–953 (2005).
Neher, P. F., Laun, F. B., Stieltjes, B. & Maier-Hein, K. H. Fiberfox: facilitating the creation of realistic white matter software phantoms. Magn. Reson. Med. 72, 1460–1470 (2014).
Perrone, D. et al. D-BRAIN: anatomically accurate simulated diffusion MRI brain data. PLoS ONE 11, e0149778 (2016).
Mangin, J.-F., Regis, J. & Frouin, V. Shape bottlenecks and conservative flow systems. In Proceedings of the 1996 Workshop on Mathematical Methods in Biomedical Image Analysis 131-138 (IEEE Computer Society, 1996).
Guevara, P. et al. Robust clustering of massive tractography datasets. Neuroimage 54, 1975–1993 (2011).
Basser, P. J. Fiber-tractography via diffusion tensor MRI. in Proc. International Society for Magnetic Resonance in Medicine 1226 (1998).
Cote, M. A. et al. Tractometer: towards validation of tractography pipelines. Med. Image Anal. 17, 844–857 (2013).
Glasser, M. F. et al. The Human Connectome Project’s neuroimaging approach. Nat. Neurosci. 19, 1175–1187 (2016).
Stieltjes, B., Brunner, R. M., Maier-Hein (ne Fritzsche), K. H. & Laun, F. B. Diffusion Tensor Imaging: Introduction and Atlas. (Springer, Berlin Heidelberg, 2013).
Catani, M. & Schotten, M. T. de. Atlas of Human Brain Connections. (OUP, Oxford, 2012).
Catani, M. et al. A novel frontal pathway underlies verbal fluency in primary progressive aphasia. Brain J. Neurol. 136, 2619–2628 (2013).
de Schotten, M. T. et al. A lateralized brain network for visuospatial attention. Nat. Neurosci. 14, 1245–1246 (2011).
Forkel, S. J. et al. The anatomy of fronto-occipital connections from early blunt dissections to contemporary tractography. Cortex 56, 73–84 (2014).
Makris, N. et al. Human middle longitudinal fascicle: variations in patterns of anatomical connections. Brain Struct. Funct. 218, 951–968 (2013).
Mars, R. B. et al. The extreme capsule fiber complex in humans and macaque monkeys: a comparative diffusion MRI tractography study. Brain Struct. Funct. 221, 4059–4071 (2015).
Meola, A., Comert, A., Yeh, F.-C., Stefaneanu, L. & Fernandez-Miranda, J. C. The controversial existence of the human superior fronto-occipital fasciculus: connectome-based tractographic study with microdissection validation. Hum. Brain Mapp. 36, 4964–4971 (2015).
Yeatman, J. D. et al. The vertical occipital fasciculus: a century of controversy resolved by in vivo measurements. Proc. Natl Acad. Sci. USA 111, E5214–E5223 (2014).
Maier-Hein, K. H. et al. Tractography challenge ISMRM 2015 high-resolution data. Zenodo https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.579933 (2017).
Larsen, L., Griffin, L. D., Graessel, D., Witte, O. W. & Axer, H. Polarized light imaging of white matter architecture. Microsc. Res. Tech. 70, 851–863 (2007).
Smith, R. E., Tournier, J.-D., Calamante, F. & Connelly, A. The effects of SIFT on the reproducibility and biological accuracy of the structural connectome. Neuroimage 104, 253–265 (2015).
Neher, P. F. et al. MITK global tractography. In SPIE Medical Imaging: Image Processing (Eds. Haynor, D. R. & Ourselin, S.) 83144D (SPIE, 2012).
Mangin, J.-F. et al. Toward global tractography. Neuroimage 80, 290–296 (2013).
Jbabdi, S., Woolrich, M. W., Andersson, J. L. R. & Behrens, T. E. J. A Bayesian framework for global tractography. Neuroimage 37, 116–129 (2007).
Christiaens, D. et al. Global tractography of multi-shell diffusion-weighted imaging data using a multi-tissue model. Neuroimage 123, 89–101 (2015).
Reisert, M., Kiselev, V. G., Dihtal, B., Kellner, E. & Novikov, D. S. MesoFT: unifying diffusion modelling and fiber tracking. Med. Image Comput. Comput. Assist. Interv. 17, 201–208 (2014).
Girard, G., Fick, R., Descoteaux, M., Deriche, R. & Wassermann, D. AxTract: microstructure-driven tractography based on the ensemble average propagator. Inf. Process. Med. Imaging Proc. Conf. 24, 675–686 (2015).
Daducci, A., Dal Palú, A., Descoteaux, M. & Thiran, J.-P. Microstructure informed Tractography: pitfalls and open challenges. Front. Neurosci. 10, 247 (2016).
Neher, P. F., Götz, M., Norajitra, T., Weber, C. & Maier-Hein, K. H. A machine learning based approach to fiber tractography using classifier voting. in International Conference on Medical Image Computing and Computer-Assisted Intervention (Eds. Navab, N., Hornegger, J., Wells, W. & Frangi, A.) 45–52 (Springer, 2015).
Neher, P. F., Côté, M.-A., Houde, J.-C., Descoteaux, M. & Maier-Hein, K. H. Fiber tractography using machine learning. Neuroimage 158, 417–429 (2017).
Dell’Acqua, F., Bodi, I., Slater, D., Catani, M. & Modo, M. MR diffusion histology and micro-tractography reveal mesoscale features of the human cerebellum. Cerebellum 12, 923–931 (2013).
Zemmoura, I. et al. FIBRASCAN: a novel method for 3D white matter tract reconstruction in MR space from cadaveric dissection. Neuroimage 103, 106–118 (2014).
De Benedictis, A. et al. New insights in the homotopic and heterotopic connectivity of the frontal portion of the human corpus callosum revealed by microdissection and diffusion tractography. Hum. Brain Mapp. 37, 4718–4735 (2016).
Hau, J. et al. Revisiting the human uncinate fasciculus, its subcomponents and asymmetries with stem-based tractography and microdissection validation. Brain Struct. Funct. 222, 1645–1662 (2016).
Wedeen, V. J. et al. The geometric structure of the brain fiber pathways. Science 335, 1628–1634 (2012).
Galinsky, V. L. & Frank, L. R. The lamellar structure of the brain fiber pathways. Neural Comput. 28, 2533–2556 (2016).
Sporns, O. Contributions and challenges for network models in cognitive neuroscience. Nat. Neurosci. 17, 652–660 (2014).
Reisert, M. et al. Global fiber reconstruction becomes practical. Neuroimage 54, 955–962 (2011).
Andersson, J. et al. A comprehensive Gaussian process framework for correcting distortions and movements in diffusion images. in Proceedings of International Society of Magnetic Resonance in Medicine 2426 (2012).
Andersson, J. L. R., Skare, S. & Ashburner, J. How to correct susceptibility distortions in spin-echo echo-planar images: application to diffusion tensor imaging. Neuroimage 20, 870–888 (2003).
Fischl, B. FreeSurfer. Neuroimage 62, 774–781 (2012).
Jenkinson, M., Beckmann, C. F., Behrens, T. E. J., Woolrich, M. W. & Smith, S. M. FSL. Neuroimage 62, 782–790 (2012).
Jenkinson, M., Bannister, P., Brady, M. & Smith, S. Improved optimization for the robust and accurate linear registration and motion correction of brain images. Neuroimage 17, 825–841 (2002).
Maier-Hein (ne Fritzsche), K. H. et al. MITK diffusion imaging. Methods Inf. Med. 51, 441–448 (2012).
Panagiotaki, E. et al. Compartment models of the diffusion MR signal in brain white matter: a taxonomy and comparison. Neuroimage 59, 2241–2254 (2012).
Garyfallidis, E., Ocegueda, O., Wassermann, D. & Descoteaux, M. Robust and efficient linear registration of white-matter fascicles in the space of streamlines. Neuroimage 117, 124–140 (2015).
Garyfallidis, E., Brett, M., Correia, M. M., Williams, G. B. & Nimmo-Smith, I. QuickBundles, a method for tractography simplification. Front. Neurosci. 6, 175 (2012).
Garyfallidis, E. et al. Dipy, a library for the analysis of diffusion MRI data. Front. Neuroinform. 8, 8 (2014).
Jannin, P. et al. Validation of medical image processing in image-guided therapy. IEEE Trans. Med. Imaging 21, 1445–1449 (2002).
K.H.M.-H. was supported by the German Research Foundation (DFG), grants MA 6340/10-1, MA 6340/12-1. M.D. was supported by the NSERC Discovery Grant program as well as the institutional Université de Sherbrooke Research Chair in Neuroinformatics. C.M.W.T. was supported by a grant (No. 612.001.104) from the Physical Sciences division of the Netherlands Organization for Scientific Research (NWO). The research of H.Y.M., S.D., S.S., A.M.H., and A.L. was supported by VIDI grant 639.072.411 from NWO. The research of F.G. was funded by the Chinese Scholarship Council (CSC). M.Ch. was supported by the Alexander Graham Bell Canada Graduate Scholarships-Doctoral Program (CGS-D3) from the Natural Sciences and Engineering Research Council of Canada (NSERC). M.C. was supported by the Investigator Award No. 103759/Z/14/Z from the Wellcome Trust. C.C.H. was supported by DFG SFB grants 936/A1, Z3 and TRR 169/A2. The research of J.-P.T., D.R., M.B., A.A., A.L., and A.D. was supported by the Center for Biomedical Imaging (CIBM) of the Geneva-Lausanne Universities and the EPFL, as well as the foundations Leenaards and Louis-Jeantet, and by the Swiss National Science Foundation grants 205321_144529 and 31003A_157063. W.E.R. was supported by CA90246 from National Cancer Institute. The research of Y.F., C.G., Y.W., J.M., H.R., Q.L., and C.-F.W. was supported by grant 61379020 from National Nature Science Foundation of China. C.-F.W. was supported by NIH grants P41EB015902 and P41EB015898.
The authors declare no competing financial interests.
Publisher's note: Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.
About this article
Cite this article
Maier-Hein, K.H., Neher, P.F., Houde, JC. et al. The challenge of mapping the human connectome based on diffusion tractography. Nat Commun 8, 1349 (2017). https://doi.org/10.1038/s41467-017-01285-x
This article is cited by
Communications Biology (2023)
Validate your white matter tractography algorithms with a reappraised ISMRM 2015 Tractography Challenge scoring system
Scientific Reports (2023)
In vivo evidence of microstructural hypo-connectivity of brain white matter in 22q11.2 deletion syndrome
Molecular Psychiatry (2023)
The organization of frontostriatal brain wiring in non-affective early psychosis compared with healthy subjects using a novel diffusion imaging fiber cluster analysis
Molecular Psychiatry (2023)
MFCSC: Novel method to calculate mismatch between functional and structural brain connectomes, and its application for detecting hemispheric functional specialisations
Scientific Reports (2023)