Topological insulators constitute a new phase of matter protected by symmetries. Time-reversal symmetry protects strong topological insulators of the Z2 class, which possess an odd number of metallic surface states with dispersion of a Dirac cone. Topological crystalline insulators are merely protected by individual crystal symmetries and exist for an even number of Dirac cones. Here, we demonstrate that Bi-doping of Pb1−x Sn x Se (111) epilayers induces a quantum phase transition from a topological crystalline insulator to a Z2 topological insulator. This occurs because Bi-doping lifts the fourfold valley degeneracy and induces a gap at , while the three Dirac cones at the points of the surface Brillouin zone remain intact. We interpret this new phase transition as caused by a lattice distortion. Our findings extend the topological phase diagram enormously and make strong topological insulators switchable by distortions or electric fields.
Topological insulators are bulk insulators with a metallic surface state1. Provided that the system stays in the same symmetry class of the Hamiltonian2, it is fundamentally impossible to follow a path from this topologically distinct phase of matter to a trivial phase without closing the insulating bulk band gap. For a strong topological insulator, metallic surface states are necessarily present at the boundary to a trivial insulator as, for example, air or vacuum. These topological surface states are protected by time-reversal symmetry and their energy vs. momentum dispersion mimics quasirelativistic, massless particles, with the shape of a Dirac cone and a peculiar helical spin texture1,2,3,4. The topological classification is given by the so-called Z2 invariant ν 0, which for odd number of Dirac cones is ν 0 = 1, giving rise to strong (Z2) topological insulators, but for even number of cones is zero, characterizing weak topological or trivial insulators5, 6.
It is possible to transform a strong (Z2) topological insulator to a trivial insulator by alloying as has been shown for Bi2Se3:In7, 8 and BiTl(S1−x Se x )2 9. The fundamental principle of bulk-boundary correspondence dictates again that this topological phase transition proceeds through a transition point where the bulk band gap closes. In this picture, it is supposed that the crystal symmetry is maintained through the phase transition. However, the crystal symmetry itself can protect topologically distinct phases as well, termed topological crystalline insulators (TCIs)5, 10,11,12,13,14. For TCIs, the decisive role of the crystal symmetry renders the topological protection dependent on the specific crystal face10. The topological invariants allow for an even number of Dirac cones, which are, however, not robust against disorder5. Pb1−x Sn x Se and Pb1−x Sn x Te represent such mirror-symmetry protected TCIs with fourfold valley degeneracy5, 11 in which the trivial-to-TCI phase transition is reached for sufficiently large Sn contents10, 15. Upon cooling, the lattice contracts and the enhanced orbital overlap leads to an inverted (i.e., negative) bulk band gap, which, via bulk-boundary correspondence, gives rise to Dirac cone surface states. This has impressively been shown by temperature-dependent angle-resolved photoemission (ARPES)15.
On the other hand, there are crystals that are not necessarily topological, but change their symmetry and their electronic properties with temperature. Such phase-change materials have been studied intensively for non-volatile data storage because their properties can be altered dramatically at the structural phase transition16. GeTe is such a prototypical material16, 17 that transforms upon cooling from the cubic rock salt to a rhombohedral structure characterized by a large relative sublattice displacement. This gives rise to pronounced ferroelectricity of GeTe18 and has recently been found to allow for an electrical switching of electronic properties19. Symmetry changes are potentially very interesting also for topological insulators. In fact, it has been shown for the TCI Pb1−x Sn x Se that by breaking of mirror symmetries two out of the four Dirac cones at its (100) surface can be gapped11, 20,21,22. In that case, the topological phase remains, however, unchanged by the symmetry breaking and the Z2 invariant stays even. It is crucial for the present work to note that in principle the topological phase does not need to be preserved by a distortion. Indeed, topological phase transitions have recently been predicted for two-dimensional TlSe23 and three-dimensional SnTe by distortions24 and by finite-size effects25.
Here, we investigate the band topology of the (111) surface of Pb1−x Sn x Se by cooling through the complete trivial to topological phase transition. We demonstrate a new type of phase transition from crystal-symmetry-protected to time-reversal symmetry-protected topology controlled by Bi incorporation. We show that when Bi is introduced in the bulk making the system n-type, a gap is opened up at the one Dirac cone at the center of the surface Brillouin zone at , while the three Dirac cones located at the points at the zone boundaries behave as in pure Pb1−x Sn x Se, that is, are gapless at low temperature. Our findings provide the first experimental evidence for a topological phase transition from a TCI with an even number of Dirac cones to a Z2 time-reversal symmetry-protected strong topological insulator where the number is odd (three). Following the recent prediction24, the origin of the novel topological phase transition is interpreted as due to a sublattice shift and rhombohedral distortion along the  direction, which lifts the bulk band inversion only at the Z-point (L-point in the undistorted phase) projected onto . At the same time, we do not find any evidence for a bulk band gap closing across the phase transition, most likely, because the rhombohedral distortion does not leave the system in the same symmetry class where the TCI is defined.
Effect of temperature and Sn concentration
We have grown both undoped and Bi-doped epitaxial (111) Pb1−x Sn x Se films of high quality by molecular beam epitaxy (see Supplementary Fig. 1–6 and Supplementary Notes 1–4 for details). The samples were capped in-situ by a thin Se layer to protect the surface during transport to the ARPES setup, where the cap was desorbed by annealing (see also “Methods” section and Supplementary Note 5). ARPES measurements were performed using linearly polarized light incident on the sample under the geometry shown in Fig. 1a, which also depicts the bulk and (111) surface Brillouin zones of rock salt Pb1−x Sn x Se. In contrast to the natural (100) cleavage plane of bulk crystals previously studied12, 13, 15, 26, for the (111) orientation, the four bulk L-points project on the following four time-reversal invariant surface momenta: and three equivalent points27. This is seen in the ARPES data shown in Fig. 1b, where the intensity from the Dirac cones at the three points is enhanced by a photoemission final-state effect. Due to the sensitive dependence of the bulk band inversion on the lattice constant, the trivial to topological phase transition can be monitored during cooling by tracing the evolution of the bulk band gap28 or by observation of the appearance of the Dirac cones in ARPES15, 26. Indeed, as seen in Fig. 1c–q, for our (111) films with low Sn concentrations and without Bi doping (x Sn = 10%, Fig. 1c, f, i, and l), the Dirac cone at the point does not form down to 22 K, while for x Sn = 20% (Fig. 1d, g, j, and m) and x Sn = 28% (Fig. 1e, h, k, and n), the gapless Dirac cone appears at around 90 and 130 K, respectively.
Impact of Bi incorporation in the bulk
Figure 2 shows the effect of bulk Bi doping on the Dirac cone of Pb0.72Sn0.28Se. When substitutionally incorporated at cation (Pb, Sn—group IV) lattice sites, the group V element Bi acts as electron donor due to its excess valence electron29. Increasing the Bi concentration n Bi thus leads to a strong upward shift of the Fermi level by 200 meV for n Bi = 2.2% (Fig. 2a–e). Remarkably, while for undoped Pb0.72Sn0.28Se, an intact Dirac cone is seen at 30 K, a surface gap as large as ~100 meV opens up at the Dirac cone upon Bi doping and increases strongly with increasing Bi content (see Fig. 2f, g, Supplementary Fig. 7, and Supplementary Note 6). This leads to the general conclusion that for Bi concentrations >~0.6%, the gap at does not close. Figure 2h–n demonstrates that within the experimental error bars, this gapped surface state does not disperse with the photon energy, i.e., momentum perpendicular to the surface plane, pinpointing its two-dimensional nature (see also Supplementary Fig. 8 and discussion in Supplementary Note 7). This observation is important to rule out that the probed state corresponds to the gapped bulk states.
The effect of Bi on the Dirac cones at the and points was evaluated in dependence of the Bi and Sn contents as well as of temperature. On the topologically trivial side (x Sn < 16%), for Bi doping n Bi < 0.6%, no difference in the gaps Δ at and is found, which remain open at all temperatures (Supplementary Figs. 9, 10, and Supplementary Note 8). On the topologically non-trivial side (x Sn > 16%), the Dirac cones at (Fig. 3a–d) and (Fig. 3e–h) close synchronously as a function of temperature for low Bi concentrations. This is shown by Fig. 3a, b, e, and f, where corresponding ARPES dispersions at 305 and 50 K are presented. In contrast, for high Bi concentrations (Fig. 3c, d, g, and h), the fourfold valley degeneracy is completely lifted such that the gap is closed to zero at all three points (Fig. 3h–k), but opens as wide as 100 meV at the point at 30 K (Fig. 3d). Thus, we conclude that of the even numbered Dirac cones per surface Brillouin zone, characteristic of a TCI, only three remain, qualifying Pb1−x Sn x Se:Bi as a strong Z2 topological insulator already for moderate Bi doping. This is the central result of the present work. While a TCI is protected by mirror symmetry, the odd numbered Dirac cones of strong topological insulators are protected by time-reversal symmetry and robust against disorder. Figure 3i shows that the new Z2 phase, which has never been observed before for this material class, exists in a wide temperature range from ~150 K down to the lowest temperature probed in our experiments.
Due to the bulk-boundary correspondence, the formation of the Dirac cones at the surface indicates a bulk band inversion at the parent momenta in the Brillouin zone as indicated by Fig. 1a. The band structures and shape of the Dirac cones corresponding to the different topological phases are illustrated schematically in Fig. 4a–c, where the open and closed Dirac cones are colored such as to indicate the changes of the predominant charge density at the anion (orange) and cation sites (blue) occurring during the band inversion (see Supplementary Fig. 11 and Supplementary Note 9). The topological phase transition so far reported for Pb1−x Sn x Se15, 26 occurs between trivial (Fig. 4a) and TCI phase (Fig. 4b) where all bulk band inversions behave equally. For the new topological phase transition into the Z2 topological insulator phase (Fig. 4c), the bulk band inversion along the momenta normal to the surface does not occur, triggered by the Bi doping. This means the discovery of two new topological phase transitions in Pb1−x Sn x Se: (i) from trivial to Z2 topological by cooling and (ii) from topological crystalline to Z2 topological by adding Bi. The resulting topological phase diagram (Fig. 4d) derived from our data shows the interdependence of these two pathways.
The observed behavior resembles the predictions by Plekhanov et al.24 for SnTe. SnTe is known for its ferroelectric phase transition in which the anion and cation sublattices are shifted against each other along the  direction17, connected to a transverse optical phonon softening30. Plekhanov et al.24 tested small displacements and theoretically predicted that for a certain range of displacements a Z2 topological insulator can exist.
In general, all IV–VI compounds are close to such a structural phase transition due to their mixed covalent-ionic bonding. They belong to the family of 10 electron systems and crystallize either in the cubic rock salt, rhombohedral, or orthorhombic structure. As calculated by Littlewood31, 32, the type of structure in which a IV–VI compound crystallizes critically depends on the values of two bond orbital coordinates—one is a measure of the ionicity and the other of covalency or s–p hybridization, and based on these a phase diagram has been established31, 32. Due to the not fully saturated p-bonds, the rock salt structure is inherently unstable against rhombohedral distortions31,32,33, which reduces the six nearest neighbors to three. The cubic/rhombohedral phase boundary is determined by the electronegativity difference between the constituting elements and as a physical explanation of the instability the resonating bond model was invoked34. For the six nearest neighbors, the number of available p-electrons (six per atom pair) is not sufficient to stabilize the cubic bonds35. Thus, SnTe and GeTe assume a rhombohedral structure and even for PbTe minute addition of <0.5% of Ge suffices to drive Pb1-x Ge x Te into the rhombohedral phase, rendering it ferroelectric36, 37. Thus, very small changes on the group IV lattice sites give rise to structural phase transitions. Indeed, for our Bi-doped films, we find a small Bi-induced rhombohedral distortion along the  direction using x-ray diffraction (Supplementary Figs. 4–6 and Supplementary Note 4). This indicates a ferroelectric inversion symmetry breaking as the underlying physical mechanism, which has been suggested to be much enhanced at the surface21, 38. Because of the (111) orientation of our films, this symmetry breaking lifts the even number degeneracy of the Dirac cones such that a gap is opened only at the point. This leaves an odd number of Dirac cones intact at the three points, causing the topological phase transition.
Finally, we would like to address the role of Bi as decisive ingredient for symmetry breaking even at small concentrations. Bi is another 10 electron system33, covalently bonded and crystallizing in a rhombohedral structure. Accordingly, when incorporated at group IV lattice sites in Pb1−x Sn x Se, it shifts the alloy toward a more covalently bonded structure in the phase diagram31, 32, 39. Moreover, on such lattice sites, Bi also reduces the cation vacancy concentration and the latter strongly enhances the ferroelectric Curie temperature T C of the cubic-to-rhombohedral phase transition30, 35, 38, 40. Indeed, in SnTe thin films with reduced vacancy concentration, ferroelectricity up to room temperature was recently reported38. Thus, both effects of the Bi, higher covalency, and lower vacancy concentration, contribute to structural symmetry breaking and trigger the novel TCI-to-Z2 topological phase transition discovered in the present work.
Sample growth and characterization
Epitaxial growth of (111) Pb1−x Sn x Se films on BaF2 substrates was performed using molecular beam epitaxy (MBE) in ultrahigh vacuum conditions better than 5 × 10−10 mbar at a substrate temperature of 380 °C. Effusion cells filled with stoichiometric PbSe and SnSe were used as source materials, as well as a ternary Pb1−x Sn x Se source with x Sn = 25%. Bi-doping was realized using a Bi2Se3 effusion cell. The chemical composition of the layers was varied over a wide range from x Sn = 0 to 40% by control of the SnSe/PbSe beam flux ratio, and a two-dimensional growth was observed by in situ reflection high-energy electron diffraction (Supplementary Fig. 1). The film thickness was in the range of 1–3 µm.
For the ARPES measurements, the films were capped in situ in the MBE chamber with a 200 nm thick amorphous Se layer at room temperature to protect the surface against oxidation during transport to the BESSY II synchrotron radiation source in Berlin, Germany. There the Se cap was completely desorbed in the ARPES preparation chamber by annealing at about 230 °C for 15 min in 3 × 10−10 mbar. ARPES measurements were performed at the UE112-PGM2a beamline of BESSY II at pressures better than 1 × 10−10 mbar using linearly polarized p + s photons incident on the sample under an angle ϕ = 45°. We used photon energies between 18 and 23 eV for the temperature-dependent ARPES measurements of the band dispersions, and a photon energy of 90 eV for the core levels (see Supplementary Fig. 12 and Supplementary Note 10). Emitted photoelectrons were detected with a Scienta R8000 electron energy analyzer at the ARPES 12 endstation. Overall resolutions of the ARPES measurements were 5 meV (energy) and 0.3° (angular).
Composition and structural characterization
The composition of the epilayers was determined using high-resolution x-ray diffraction and the Vegard’s law (Supplementary Fig. 2 and Supplementary Note 2). We employed a Seifert diffractometer equipped with primary and secondary monochromator crystals. Upon Bi incorporation, the rhombohedral lattice distortion was determined from reciprocal space maps recorded around the (513) reflection (see Supplementary Figs. 4–6 and Supplementary Note 4).
The dopant concentration and transport properties were assessed by Hall effect measurements at 77 K (Supplementary Fig. 3 and Supplementary Note 3), evidencing carrier mobilities as high as 104 cm2 V−1 s−1 in dependence of the carrier concentration.
The authors declare that all data supporting the findings of this study are available within the paper and its Supplementary Information files.
Publisher's note: Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.
This work was supported by SPP 1666 of DFG and the SFB-025 IRON of the Austrian Science Funds. P.S.M. is supported by Helmholtz Virtual Institute “New states of matter and their excitations.” We thank Andrzej Szczerbakow for providing the MBE source material.