Early Solar System planetesimal thermal models predict the heating of the chondritic protolith and the preservation of a chondritic crust on differentiated parent bodies. Petrological and geochemical analyses of chondrites have suggested that secondary alteration phases formed at low temperatures (<300 °C) by fluid-rock interaction where reduced and oxidized Vigarano type Carbonaceous (CV) chondrites witness different physicochemical conditions. From a thermodynamical survey of Ca-Fe-rich secondary phases in CV3 chondrites including silica activity (aSiO2), here we show that the classical distinction between reduced and oxidized chondrites is no longer valid and that their Ca-Fe-rich secondary phases formed in similar reduced conditions near the iron-magnetite redox buffer at low aSiO2 (log(aSiO2) <−1) and moderate temperature (210–610 °C). The various lithologies in CV3 chondrites are inferred to be fragments of an asteroid percolated heterogeneously via porous flow of hydrothermal fluid. Putative ‘onion shell’ structures are not anymore a requirement for the CV parent body crust.
Few chondritic meteorites still preserve a pristine record of the physicochemical processes that occurred in the early solar accretion disk via their primordial components, i.e., presolar grains, calcium aluminum-rich inclusions, chondrules, or matrices1. Instead, the great majority has been affected by secondary fluid-assisted thermal processes occurring after accretion in their asteroidal parent bodies (refs 2, 3 for a review). Despite their obliterating role, these secondary processes shed light on chondrite parent body internal structure and dynamics and their timing provides important constraints on the accretion ages of these bodies, the first building blocks of our planetary system.
In addition to mineralogical observations, thermodynamic analysis, and oxygen-isotope compositions3 recent 53Mn–53Cr ages of secondary minerals (e.g., fayalite) confirmed an early accretion age of the CV and CO parent bodies of about 1.8–2.5 Myr after CV CAIs4 and provides compelling evidence that these secondary minerals formed in an asteroidal setting3,4,5. CV3 chondrites possessing a unidirectional magnetization have been thus interpreted as the unmelted crusts of internally differentiated early planetesimals heated primarily by the short-lived radioisotope 26Al6, 7. The preservation of a conductively cooled chondritic crust on the CV-differentiated parent body likely requires a progressive heating (and devolatilization?) of the CV chondritic protolith that should be recorded in the thermal and redox conditions of formation of the secondary phases present in the CV chondrites of our collections.
Here, our objective is to ascertain the physicochemical conditions of the formation of the secondary phases in the different CV chondrites, in order to check the consistency of the proposed evolution of the carbonaceous chondrites as the crust of a partially differentiated body7,8,9. The ubiquitous occurrence of Ca-Fe-rich secondary phases, e.g., andradite (adr), hedenbergite (hd), kirschsteinite (kst), wollastonite (wo), fayalite (fa), Fe ± Ni metal, sulfides, and/or Fe-oxides, in the CV chondrite subgroups (CVRed, CVOxA, CVOxB) provides motivation for this study. Indeed, there are still uncertainties associated with the temperature, the oxygen fugacity, and the nature of the fluid and its composition prevailing during secondary thermal processes in different carbonaceous chondrites2, 3, 10. Further, the intricacies of the physicochemical processes between aqueous alteration and Fe-alkali-halogen metasomatism still remain debatable3.
Survey of secondary Ca-Fe-rich phases in CV3 matrices
Following the classifications of McSween11, CV3 chondrites were historically divided into oxidized (CVOx) and reduced (CVRed) subgroups based on their bulk chemistry and their secondary mineralogy, especially the presence or absence of magnetite. Although, recent X-ray12 and Mossbauer13 characterizations have shown that magnetite abundance alone is not always consistent with this classification. Weisberg et al.14 further subdivided the oxidized subgroup into the Bali-like (CVOxB) and Allende-like (CVOxA) types in part because of different chondrule/matrix ratios and oxygen isotope composition but mostly on the basis of their secondary mineralogy again. The Bali-like meteorites are characterized by the presence of nearly pure fayalite (Fa > 95), which is rare in the CVRed and largely lacking in the CVOxA chondrites, and the relatively high abundance of hydrous minerals, even if hydrous minerals and Fe-oxides on which these classifications are based never exceed 5–6 vol% in the CV312. Our survey of mineralogy in the CV3 subgroups confirms the ubiquitous occurrence of Ca-Fe-rich assemblages (see Fig. 1 and Table 1). Ca-Fe-rich pyroxenes (i.e., hedenbergite) are by far the most dominant secondary phases and are frequently found in association with andradite (only in CVOx), wollastonite, and/or kirschsteinite15, 16 (abundant in CVRed, rare but present in CVOx). Calcium-rich phases: larnite (Ca2SiO4) and rankinite (Ca3Si2O7), indicative of silica-depleted conditions, were also documented as inclusions in andradite in Bali. Finally, we confirm the occurrence of both FeNi metal and sulfides in the reduced and oxidized subgroups15.
Our observations on the representative CV3 samples, i.e., Vigarano (CVRed), Bali (CVOxB), and Allende (CVOxA), show that matrix consists largely of abundant iron-rich olivine (Fa45–55), 1–10 μm in length, in some cases hosting minute inclusions of iron sulfides, hercynitic spinel and voids, and frequently associated with pyrrhotite/pentlandite sulfides. The secondary minerals include abundant Ca-Fe-rich silicates, Fe-oxides, sulfides, Fe-Ni-Co metal, Na-Al-Cl-rich feldspathoids, and phyllosilicates. Secondary Ca-, Fe-rich silicates are abundant not only in the CVOx chondrites but also in the CVRed chondrites (Table 1), suggesting that the major physical and chemical process responsible of their formation occurred widely in the CV parent bodies.
Hedenbergite-dominated Ca-Fe secondary phases in CV3 subgroups occur under three similar types of textural setting (Fig. 1): micron-sized porous and polycrystalline nodules or patches scattered in the iron-rich olivine dominated matrix, fine polycrystalline veinlets, forming in some cases an imbricated network in the matrix or in dark inclusions, and larger delineated area (veins or dark inclusions) showing radial or lateral mineralogical zoning. In the former case, secondary phases formed mineralogical zoned concentric patches of several tens of microns in diameter showing imbricated associations of Ca-Fe pyroxene and/or andradite, with or without nepheline and/or sodalite. In the other settings, a mineral zoning still exists but parallels the boundaries of the vein or the dark inclusion with the matrix. Irregular shaped hedenbergite ± andradite or hedenbergite ± kirschsteinite assemblages form veins in matrix that surround not only CAI or dark inclusions15, 16 but also chondrules (Fig. 1). Frequently these assemblages insulate a discontinuous porous central part made of voids or elongated cavities17 filled with euhedral Ca-Fe crystals. Finally, it worth noticing that the CV chondrites contain FeNi metal and sulfides in the reduced and oxidized subgroups (this study and ref. 18).
There is an historical agreement in the cosmochemist community on the fact that the reduced and oxidized assemblages in CV3 chondrites formed under different physicochemical conditions5, 16. On the basis of the thermodynamical modeling of phase equilibrium among mineral phases and the oxygen isotopic composition, it has been further suggested that secondary phases resulted from low temperatures (<300 °C) fluid-rock interaction in an asteroidal setting4, 15, 19, 20.
In CVOxA, documented here with Allende (Supplementary Fig. 1), the matrix consists largely of abundant lath-shaped, elongate, iron-rich olivine (Fa45–55), 1–10 μm in length, hosting minute inclusions of iron sulfides, hercynitic spinel and voids, and frequently associated with pyrrhotite/pentlandite sulfides. The secondary minerals include abundant Ca-Fe-rich pyroxenes belonging to the diopside-salite-hedenbergite solid solution, andradite, wollastonite, and abundant nepheline and sodalite. We did not observed pure fayalite and kirschsteinite in this study, the later being documented in the litterature3. In agreement with previous studies, we only found scarce phyllosilicates, questioning the interpretation that Allende may have been affected quite extensively by aqueous fluids on an asteroidal parent body.
It is generally admitted that the CVOxB chondrites (e.g., Kaba, Bali) experienced aqueous alteration resulting in the replacement of primary minerals in chondrules, CAIs and ameboid olivine aggregates by secondary phyllosilicates, magnetite, Fe,Ni-sulfides, Fe,Ni-carbides, fayalite, salite-hedenbergite pyroxenes, and andradite. This is what we observed in our sample (Supplementary Fig. 1). As calcium bearing silicates, we also documented larnite (Ca2SiO4) and rankinite (Ca3Si2O7), both occurring as inclusion in andradite. Our observations do not document fayalite24 neither abundant phyllosilicates25 as generally described. Sodalite is a very common other secondary, sometimes closely associated with andradite or hedenbergite.
In our last case of CVRed chondrite, our reference sample of Vigarano, (Supplementary Fig. 1) contains clasts of the CVOxB and CVOxA materials26, which were not the objectives of our work. Pure fayalite (Fa99) is found as clast and associated to magnetite in the matrix. The matrix also contains abundant secondary Ca-Fe phases (frequent kirschsteinite and hedenbergite) that display the same type of occurrence than secondary Ca-Fe silicates in CVOxA and CVOxB. In both Leoville and Vigarano, kirschsteinite solid solution (Kir82–94Mon1–15) and Ca-, Fe-rich pyroxene coexist together in clumps, with Fe-Ni metal enclosed within the kirschsteinite27. Frequently, hedenbergite and/or kirschsteinite are zoned from Fe-rich endmember in the crystal core to a more Mg-rich composition in the crystal rim16, 27, 28.
Metal in the CVRed and CVOxB chondrites is mainly low-Ni, while high-Ni awaruite (FeNi3) dominates in the CVOxA chondrites. In the CVOxB lithologies, the secondary minerals include magnetite, Ni-rich metal (awaruite), and sulfides, whereas in the CVOxA lithologies the secondary minerals include magnetite, Ni-rich sulfides, Ni-and Co-rich metal (awaruite and wairauite). InCVRed, the matrix contain Fe,Ni-metal and sparse Fe,Ni sulfide, but no magnetite except at the periphery of type IA chondrules in Vigarano29. Hydrous phyllosilicates are almost absent in both the CVRed, rare in CVOxA chondrites (up 2 vol%) and slightly more common in the CVOxB chondrites in which their modal abundances rise up to 5 vol%12. CVRed and CVOxB chondrites are dominated by saponite with only rare serpentine30. Neither saponite nor serpentine has been reported from Allende, only talc and amphibole (tremolite with minor anthophyllite) have been described as hydrated alteration products31.
Silica activity: an overlooked key parameter
That metal, oxides, and silicates hosting both metallic, ferrous, and ferric iron may coexist clearly suggests that oxygen fugacity plays a significant role in determining the composition and the occurrence of Ca-Fe-rich secondary phases in CV chondrite matrices. This view is supported by paragenetic relations obtained experimentally by Gustafson32 in the system Ca-Fe-Si-O and his Schreinemaker’s analysis, where the stability field of andradite must be confined to relatively oxidizing conditions well above the Fayalite-Magnetite-Quartz (FMQ), while hedenbergite (and/or kirschsteinite) may extend their stability field down to more reducing conditions. Both single phases: andradite and/or hedenbergite, are thus stable over a range of log fO2 and T, and so their conditions of formation are poorly constrained (Fig. 2). Nevertheless, this analysis provides a consistent thermodynamic framework for the present subdivision of CV3 chondrites into andradite-bearing oxidized (CVOx) and kirschsteinite-bearing reduced (CVRed) subgroups16 and their inferred different conditions of formation5.
We challenge this classical view by noticing that the low silica activity of CV3 chondrites, as suggested by the noteworthy absence of silica phases in their matrices, is an overlooked key parameter controlling the stability field of the Ca-Fe-rich secondary phase assemblages. Indeed, if we examine andradite in a Ca-Fe-Si-O system, its stability relative to hedenbergite32, 33 is governed by the reaction:
In a silica-saturated system involving pure phases, this equilibrium lies between the Hematite-Magnetite and FMQ buffers at about two log units above FMQ as aforementioned (Fig. 2). We note, however, that in a silica-undersaturated system with pure phases, the equilibrium constant for reaction (1) is
Solving for log fO2 gives then
and the shift in the equilibrium logfO2 due to degree of silica undersaturation is
Changes in silica undersaturation causing the term log aSiO2 to be negative shift then significantly (−4.5 log units fO2 shift per order of magnitude of aSiO2) the equilibrium location of reaction (1). Thus, the effect of the silica activity is significant and should have profound implications on the phase relationships in the Ca-Fe-Si-O system.
We calculated the stability fields in the Ca-Fe-Si-O system as functions of log aSiO2 – log fO2 – T at an indicative pressure of 2000 bars, between 100 and 900 °C, and plausible ranges of fO2 and aSiO2. The bulk composition of Allende from Jarosewich34 simplified to its Ca-Fe-Si-O components was used as a representative input composition. Visual inspection of calculated log aSiO2 – log fO2 isothermal sections at 300 and 500 °C (Fig. 3) shows how silica-saturated phases (e.g., quartz and ferrosilite) and silica-undersaturated phases, (e.g., hedenbergite, kirschsteinite, rankinite, and larnite) are located according to their silica activity potential. Clearly, as the silica activity of the system decreases, the andradite stability field (reaction (1)) shifts toward lower oxygen fugacity and, at moderate temperatures (≈350 °C), encounters the iron-magnetite reaction curve (IM), which is independent of aSiO2. Such a trend contrasts, for instance, with the appearance of hedenbergite in reduced conditions in the reaction
for which the opposite effect is expected—the hedenbergite stability field shifts toward higher oxygen fugacities as the silica activity of the system is decreased
These log aSiO2 – logfO2 relationships can be generalized for different reactions involving Ca-Fe secondary phases in silica-undersaturated systems as follows:
This new finding has major implications: occurrences of hedenbergite, kirschsteinite, rankinite, and larnite in that order in different assemblages require significant decreases in the silica activity of the system. Kirschsteinite is stable only in reduced (IM buffered), low silica activity (log aSiO2 << −1), and high-temperature conditions (T > 450 °C). Fayalite + hedenbergite ( ± magnetite) assemblages are restricted to Fe-rich and high silica activity. Stable association of fayalite with kirschsteinite ( ± hedenbergite) is possible only at high-temperature. If andradite is stable at high temperature in oxidizing conditions (Fig. 3b), it noticeably expands its stability field towards reducing conditions at low temperature in low silica activity environments (≈ log aSiO2 < −1.7); andradite being co-stable with iron and magnetite below 350 °C. That the stability of andradite is highly sensitive to silica activity explains therefore why, in rocks of low silica activity, andradite can be stable even in the presence of native iron (Fig. 3a, see also ref. 35).
Reduced redox conditions for CV3 parent body metamorphism
Ca-Fe secondary phase stability fields in the CV3 chondrites can be then interpreted in the light of this new thermodynamic frame as follows. The occurrence in CVOxA of clusters of awaruite ± pentlandite ± magnetite3, 36,37,38, the occurrence in CVOxB of Fe-Ni sulfide ± magnetite ± fayalite ± hedenbergite assemblages either as patches in the matrix or as veins destabilizing pristine Fe-rich metal blebs3, and the occurrence in CVRed of hedenbergite, kirschsteinite, and Fe metal associations (e.g., ref. 27.) hint all in favor of redox conditions buffered at or very closed to the IM buffer curve for the formation of Ca-Fe-rich secondary phases in CV3 chondrites, as already suggested for the formation of the opaque assemblages in the same chondrite group36 (see also refs 37, 39).
Thus, a log aSiO2 –T diagram (Fig. 4a) can be generated at such IM reducing conditions. It depicts clearly that andradite is a low temperature (T<350 °C) phase, kirschsteinite is a high temperature (>450 °C) phase, wollastonite is intermediate, and fayalite and/or hedenbergite, despite being stable over a large range of temperature, are indicative of higher silica activity; in addition, fayalite is more stable in an iron-rich system. In such a frame, it is remarkable that a single trend can account for the different Ca-Fe secondary phase assemblages observed in all CV3 chondrite lithologies. Incidentally, this suggests a general evolution governed by a silica activity depletion as the temperature of the system is decreased. Changes in silica activity required for the formation of Ca-Fe secondary phases in CV3 chondrites are significant between −2 < log aSiO2 < −1 if only the major phases (i.e., fayalite, kirschsteinite, wollastonite, and andradite buffered by hedenbergite) are considered and between −6 < log aSiO2 < −1 if the minor phases (i.e., rankinite and larnite from the CV3 Bali) are included. The temperature range is more difficult to estimate but a conservative range from 210 to 610 °C is inferred from this survey of CV chondrites considering the lack of xonotlite replacing wollastonite and the occurrence of pentlandite, respectively. The absence of awaruite (T max = 520 °C40) and pentlandite (T max = 610 °C41) and the occurrence of kirschsteinite (T min = 450 °C, Fig. 4a) suggest that the kirschsteinite ± hedenbergite bearing assemblages, as observed for instance Allende, Vigarano, Leoville or Efremovka, are amongst those requiring the highest temperatures. Whereas, andradite ± hedenbergite bearing assemblages, as observed in Efremovka, Allende or Bali, require lower temperatures (<350 °C).
Adequacy of these conditions with respect to other observables from CV3
Temperature. The proposed large temperature range (i.e., <277 °C up to 1050 °C for the formation of secondary phases in CV3 chondrites) and the numerous discordant interpretations of the involved processes in the literature (see review in ref. 3.) echo the difficulty of assigning metamorphic grades and absolute peak temperatures to the metamorphism of most CV3 chondrites, mainly because of their complex histories before, during and after accretion. Peak temperature assemblages are not fully constrained, and may undergo partial or full retrogression to lower grade phase, especially if fluids are present. A temperature as high as >1050 °C is deduced from the ferrobustamite-augite two phase field in the Allende matrix23. The consideration of bulk rock noble gas or presolar grain abundances also points to high-temperature process for Allende with relatively the other CV chondrites42. Independently to our study on inorganic phases, it is of note that Insoluble Organic Matter’s sulfur speciation and structural order43, support the formation of secondary phases in Allende parent body at temperature as high as 624 °C and reduced redox conditions. If the presence of amphibole and talc in Allende has been used to argue for temperatures >400 °C31, occurrences of serpentine/saponite intergrowths (e.g., saponite) document lower temperatures (100–200 °C)44. Meanwhile, from thermodynamical calculations of precipitation from aqueous fluid, fayalite and Ca-Fe-rich minerals in CV chondrites were inferred to form at relatively low temperatures (<250–300 °C)5, 19, 26. If bulk rock considerations are taken into account, carbonaceous matter in CV matrices (see ref. 10 and references therein) is used to infer the petrologic grade and to sort the CV chondrites from the intensity of their thermal processing. It shows a wide range of estimates of peak temperature (e.g., Kaba 300–420 °C, Allende: 330–600 °C45,46,47,48). That Ca-Fe-rich phases and carbonaceous matter indicate a range of temperature extending over several hundreds of degrees suggests that thermal heterogeneity is a characteristic feature of matrix of CV chondrites. The conditions inferred for the formation of the hydrous secondary phases (anthophyllite and talc) in the chondrule mesostasis of Allende31 at higher temperature than our estimates from CV matrices, are also consistent with the higher local silica activity imposed by the ubiquitous occurrence of olivine and low-Ca pyroxene in chondrules according to the reaction Mg2SiO4 (Fo) + SiO2 (Qtz) = Mg2Si2O6 (En) (ref. 19 and Fig. 4). As aforementioned, low-temperature alteration certainly below 150 °C31 are required to form saponite and Fe-rich serpentine. In the light of these factual heterogeneities, we thus interpret our estimated temperature range for the formation of Ca-Fe-rich assemblages (from 210 to 610 °C) as recording only a portion of the putative thermal variation suffered by the CV3 parent body, without excluding the possibility of locally higher peak temperatures. As Ca-Fe-rich minerals does not inform on higher temperature process, the present model is not inconsistent with the classical order of metamorphic temperature inferred from presolar grain abundances and Raman spectroscopy studies of organic material, i.e., temperature increasing from Leoville to Vigarano to Allende.
Redox. The inferred reduced conditions near the IM buffer curve are compatible with intrinsic oxygen fugacity estimates for CV3 chondrite matrices as long as an Fe sulfide ± fayalite40–60 ± magnetite ± Fe,Ni metal ± awaruite assemblage in presence of graphite is concerned (Supplementary Fig. 2). Intrinsic oxygen fugacity has to be in fact below C-CO2 buffer curve, due to graphite saturation, close to awaruite saturation35 and above the fayalite-iron-quartz (QIF) buffer curve in response of the silica undersaturation of CV3 chondrite matrices. In these conditions, it is worth noticing that magnetite is indicative of reduced conditions well below the FMQ buffer, not of oxidizing ones. The first discovery of cohenite: (Fe,Ni)3C in association with metal—magnetite—fayalite in a Bali-like clast in the reduced CV3 chondrite Vigarano and its spontaneous formation at T < 700 K49 according to
further supports such assertion of reduced conditions at IM. Finally, a secondary effect of low oxygen fugacity is the reduction of sulfur50, leading the stabilization of low-sulfur sulfides (e.g. heazlewoodite) and sulfur-free metal alloys (e.g., awaruite and/or wairauite), as indicated by the occurrence of cluster of awaruite and Ni-sulfide in several matrices of CV3 (see Fig. 2 of O’Brien and Tarduno38 for Allende). We notice however that these redox and thermal conditions for the formation of secondary Ca-Fe-rich minerals in the matrix disagree with the igneous temperature and more oxidizing conditions proposed for magnetite in chondrules51.
Hydrous phases. The lack of xonotlite Ca6Si6O17(OH)2 replacing wollastonite (T max = 210 °C32), of ilvaite CaFe2+ 2Fe3+Si2O8(OH) replacing hedenbergite ± magnetite (T max = 450 °C32), or of calcite CaCO3 replacing wollastonite (T max ≈ 300 °C33, 34) not only strengthen our T ≥ 210 °C temperature scheme for the formation of Ca-Fe secondary phases in CV3 chondrites17 but also hint for low or very low partial pressures of H2O and CO2 in the system, a feature also consistent with the inferred reducing conditions.
Nepheline and sodalite. Finally, Sodium-rich nepheline ((Na,K)2Al2Si2O8) and occasionally sodalite (Na4Al3Si3O12Cl) are present in matrices of CV3 chondrites, associated or not with Ca-Fe secondary phases (Fig. 1 and Supplementary Fig. 1; refs 3, 53). Referred as evidences for an alkali-halogen metasomatism in CV3 chondrites of still an unknown nature, it is however difficult to evaluate if they crystallized prior to, simultaneously with, or clearly after the Ca-Fe secondary phases, showing the need of a dedicated study on this topic. Nevertheless, the crystallization of these Na-Al-Cl-rich feldspathoids are very good tracers of low silica activity environments (i.e., log aSiO2 < −1; Fig. 4b), supporting once again the presented assertion.
Crustal evolution in the CV3 parent body
Silica undersaturation of CV3 chondrites together with their intrinsically unique reduced character have thus profound implications on the stability field of the Ca-Fe secondary phases, on which the subdivision of CV3 chondrites is based on. Accordingly, the present distinction between the CVRed, CVOxA and CVOxB subtypes on the basis of redox considerations (e.g., presence or absence of magnetite and/or andradite) is no longer valid. Instead, we advocate that the formation of Ca-Fe secondary phases in the matrices of the different CV3 lithologies occurred at the same reduced redox conditions, which are close to the IM buffer during a unique silica-undersaturated allochemical metamorphism path that can be best approximated by a single log aSiO2 – T pathway (Fig. 4b). Decreases in aSiO2 with respect to the intrinsic composition of unprocessed CV3 matrix (close to olivine/orthopyroxene silica activity buffer), and their correlative increases in aCaO and aFeO to match the observed Ca-Fe secondary assemblages indicate an open system behavior, in which the CV3 unreacted matrices interact with Ca-Fe enriched pervasive fluids in a 210–610 °C temperature range. If their composition cannot be apprehended in detail from the presented data, it seems however unavoidable that such fluids must have been enriched in calcium to form hedenbergite, abundant and almost ubiquitous in the CV3 chondrites group. At the time of hedenbergite crystallization, these fluids must have been buffered by a reduced environment characterized by CO/CO2 ≈ 1, H2/H2S ≈ 5x103, and H2/H2O ≈ 5, if a temperature of 500 °C is considered54. Assuming a solar composition gas of CO/CO2 ≈ 104, H2/H2S ≈ 2.7×104, and H2/H2O ≈ 3.3×103 55, this rules out a nebular origin for these Ca-Fe-rich secondary phases as already proposed4, 5. Even if solubilities of these gaseous species are unknown, the likely addition of chlorine and alkalis to the system makes these hot fluids resembling pervasive, Darcy flow type, supercritical hydrothermal fluids. This assertion is also consistent with textural settings of secondary phases, mainly as scattered patches or, when the fluid is channelized, as subtle veinlet networks (Fig. 1). Alteration in CV chondrites does not appear to have been controlled by fluid-filled fractures, rather the entire sample is homogenously altered. Although debate continues regarding the degree and the scale to which CV chondrites were closed systems with respect to aqueous fluids, it is extremely unlikely that they were closed systems with respect to gases or supercritical fluids whatever their origin56.
The simplest inferences for explaining such low silica activity environments are that the fluids formed very likely in a chondritic environment, naturally poorer in silica than their Earth analogs, and that CV3 matrices undergo the beginning of serpentinization. The low silica activity and the reducing conditions are the critical properties that produce the unusual geochemical environment, which is similar to a serpentinization front57. By analogy, such a process is capable of explaining the simultaneous occurrence of low-silica and reduced minerals, like andradite, magnetite and awaruite, in close association with serpentine-like hydrous phases (e.g., saponite), a feature very similar indeed with those observed in the CV3 chondrites.
On Earth, where ultramafic rocks are exposed to water at temperatures <400 °C, they inevitably undergo serpentinization reactions due to the efficiency of this process58, 59. The scarcity of serpentine in Allende, Vigarano, or more generally in CV3 chondrites12 has thus to be questioned. Several keys could be invoked: a dehydration event following serpentization and erasing evidence of the hydration processus5, 60, a short duration fluid flow preventing kinetically the progress of serpentinization58, a ‘dry’ system with very low water partial pressure, and/or a high temperature (>360 °C58) that would thermodynamically prevent the serpentinization. While answering these questions is clearly beyond the scope of this work, we notice that our high temperature, H2O-depleted reduced and low silica activity metamorphic conditions provide an alternative to the classical aqueous alteration models proposed for the CV3 chondrite parent body19, 24, 61, in which Ca-Fe-rich pyroxenes, andradite, fayalite, phyllosilicates, and magnetite are all inferred to form at relatively low temperatures (<300 °C) in the presence of aqueous solutions. In our model, Ca-Fe-rich anhydrous phases crystallize first at the highest aSiO2 due to the intrinsic composition of unprocessed matrix, while rare serpentine-like hydrous phases should witness the low temperature part of the fluid-assisted metamorphic trend (Fig. 4b).
From this perspective, fayalite overgrowths in CVOxB are thought to be the result of high-temperature sub-solidus crystallization rather than low-temperature aqueous precipitation4, 19, 24, 61. If this is correct, the very limited Fe–Mg interdiffusion boundaries62 ( ⩽ 1 µm) between fayalite and forsterite grains in the CV matrices should imply short periods of hydrothermal activity on the parent body4, 61 (<104–105 year between 500–600 °C), which could have wide-ranging implications for the asteroidal history of CV chondrites.
Both bulk rocks and dark inclusions in CV3 chondrites show a large range in their oxygen isotopic compositions (−5.9 < ∆17O < −0.8‰) indicating various degrees of interaction between solids and one or several fluid reservoirs. Such heavy-isotope enrichment is interpreted as resulting from low-temperature aqueous alteration associated with oxidation63, 64. Given the present observations of significant abundances of Ca-Fe-rich secondary phases vs. hydrous phases in the matrix (Fig. 1), our work supports instead a heavy-isotope enrichment resulting from interactions with hot and reduced hydrothermal fluids as recorded by the systematic heavy-isotope compositions, ∆17O ≈ −1‰, of Ca-Fe-rich silicates (e.g., fayalite, andradite, and hedenbergite3, 65 and references therein).
The various lithic fragments forming the CV3 chondrites including the presence of the CVOxA lithology in the reduced breccia Vigarano, the presence of the CVOxB and CVRed clasts in the Mokoia breccia, and the presence of dark lithic fragments in all CV3 subtypes and their diverse porosity and permeability16 are in good agreement with CV3 lithologies being variably altered crustal pieces coming from one heterogeneously Darcy flow percolated asteroid. Each fragment records a part of a unique log aSiO2 – log fO2 – T fluid-assisted allochemical metamorphic trend. A feature of Darcy flow, for example in aquifers on Earth, is that the percolation varies in different directions, such that different physiochemical environments may exist spatially and overlap in time. Meaning that, in different regions of the same crustal level, aSiO2 and temperature could vary such that assemblages typical of CVOx and CVRed form contemporaneously. These results, which are also consistent with the similar cosmic-ray exposure ages for the different CV3 lithologies66, collectively indicate that fluid-assisted metamorphism on the CV3 parent asteroid should not be considered as a continuous, protracted event but rather as the cumulative effects of hydrothermal activity changes (see also ref. 60).
Reconciling the short-duration of reduced H2O-depleted hydrothermal events with the effects of internal heating by the most likely heat source in primitive planetesimals, decay of 26Al (t 1/2 = 0.7 Ma), is certainly a challenge but plausible in a context of internally active pristine parent body and the short duration of supercritical fluids or vapors migration by buoyancy-driven Darcy flow56. Despite paleomagnetic evidence for differentiated asteroidal interiors, a stratified ‘onion shell’ structure as envisioned for the crust of CV chondrite parent body, e.g., with the least metamorphosed, brecciated, and reduced CV chondrites (CVRed) nearest the surface, beneath the Bali-type oxidized CV chondrites (CVOxB), and at greater depth, the Allende-type oxidized CV chondrites (CVOxA)7, is not anymore a requirement.
Origin of the samples
A polished thin section of Allende, provided by the Museum National d’Histoire Naturelle (MNHN), Paris, and containing a massive Dark Inclusion about 0.35 and ~1.5 mm long (Fig. 1a) was compared with others in a massive sample of Allende provided by the Statens Naturhistoriske Museum (Copenhagen) (Fig. 1b). The sample of Bali (Fig. 1c) and Vigarano, were respectively provided by the MNHN and by the Smithsonian National Museum of Natural History (Washington, DC).
Mineral characterization: In addition to the figure presented in the main text (Fig. 1), detailed textural and mineralogical characterizations (Supplementary Fig. 1a–i) were performed with a FEG-SEM JEOL 7000 F at CRHEA CNRS-Nice (France) operating at 15–20 kV accelerating voltage and 1–2 nA beam current.
A detailed mineralogical and petrological survey has been undertaken on four different samples from three CV3 chondrites: Allende (CVOxA; two samples), Bali (CVOxB), and Vigarano (CVRed). The general overview with coupled backscattered electron images and energy-dispersive X-ray spectroscopy chemical maps (Fig. 1 and Supplementary Fig. 1) was acquired at CEMEF Mines ParisTech-Nice (France) with a MEB FEI XL30 ESEM LaB6 operated at 20 kV and 200 nA beam current, equipped with a BRUKER Quantax 655 detector with XFlash 6|30 technology silicon drift 10 mm2 at 129 eV (100 k.c.p.s.). BRUKER Microanalysor QUANTAX was associated with the software ESPRIT (semi-quantitative analyses without standard by P/B-ZAF method).
Thermodynamical analyses and equilibrium phase assemblage diagrams were computed using the Domino program from the Theriak-Domino software67 and the internally consistent thermodynamic data sets from Holland and Powell68 extended with kirschsteinite properties. Data for kirschsteinite were added to the thermodynamical database keeping its self-consistent properties as following: the entropy was calculated with the method of Holland69, using the volume of 5.239 J bar−1 70. Heat capacity was calculated as proposed by Berman and Brown71 and translated in the formalism of Holland and Powell72. The thermal expansion—not critical for the range of pressure investigated in this study—was supposed identical to the one of monticellite. Enthalpy was estimated from the enthalpy of monticellite corrected by a Fe-Mg substitution. This estimation (−1903.9 kJ mol−1) was decreased by 20 kJ mol−1 to fit the results of Markl et al.73, who showed that the reaction hd = kst + qz occurs at 400 °C at 1 kb and log(aSiO2) = −0.5.
In such modeling, the calculated stable mineral assemblage is a combined function of the selected bulk chemical composition (X) of a given volume and the prevailing conditions (P, T) during crystallization. The results presented here used Allende bulk composition simplified to its Ca-Fe-Si-O components as input. Computations using bulk composition of other CV3 lithologies (including bulk of other subgroups, dark inclusion and matrix alone33) and different pressures from 100 to 2000 bars show similar outputs.
With the exception of the thermodynamical properties of kirschsteinite calculated and fully described in the main text, other data sets used in the current study are referenced in the methods section. The original data in this article are available from the corresponding author on reasonable request.
Scott, E. R. & Krot, A. N. Thermal processing of silicate dust in the solar nebula: clues from primitive chondrite matrices. Astrophys. J. 623, 571–578 (2005).
Huss, G. R., Rubin, A. E., Grossman & J. N. Thermal metamorphism in chondrites. Meteorites and the Early Solar System II, 567-586 (Arizona University Press, Tucson, 2006).
Brearley, A. J. & Krot, A. N. in Metasomatism and the Chemical Transformation of Rock, (eds Harlov D. E. and Austrheim H.) 659–789 (Springer, 2012).
Doyle, P. M. et al. Early aqueous activity on the chondrite parent asteroids recorded by fayalite. Nat. Commun. 6, 7444 (2014).
Krot, A. N. et al. Progressive alteration in CV3 chondrites: more evidence for asteroidal alteration. Meteoritics 33, 1065–1085 (1998).
Carporzen, L. et al. Magnetic evidence for a partially differentiated carbonaceous chondrite parent body. Proc. Natl Acad. Sci. USA 108, 6386–6389 (2011).
Elkins-Tanton, L. T., Weiss, B. P. & Zuber, M. T. Chondrites as samples of differentiated planetesimals. Earth Planet. Sci. Lett. 305, 1–10 (2011).
Šrámek, O., Milelli, L., Ricard, Y. & Labrosse, S. Thermal evolution and differentiation of planetesimals and planetary embryos. Icarus 217, 339–354 (2012).
Weiss, B. P. & Elkins-Tanton, L. T. Differentiated planetesimals and the parent bodies of chondrites. Annu. Rev. Earth Planet. Sci. 41, 529–560 (2013).
Bonal, L., Quirico, E., Flandinet, L. & Montagnac, G. Thermal history of type 3 chondrites from the antarctic meteorite collection determined by Raman spectroscopy of their polyaromatic carbonaceous matter. Geochim. Cosmochim. Acta 189, 312–337 (2016).
McSween, H. Y. Petrographic variations among carbonaceous chondrites of the Vigarano type. Geochim. Cosmochim. Acta 41, 1777–1790 (1977).
Howard, K. T., Benedix, G. K., Bland, P. A. & Cressey, G. Modal mineralogy of CV3 chondrites by X-ray diffraction (PSD-XRD). Geochim. Cosmochim. Acta 74, 5084–5097 (2010).
Bland, P. A., Cressey, G. & Russell, S. S. Towards a laboratory-based X-ray microprobe for the characterisation and quantification of phases in meteorites. Meteorit. Planet. Sci. Suppl. 35, A27–A28 (2000).
Weisberg, M. K., Prinz, M., Clayton, R. N. & Mayeda, T. K. CV3 chondrites: three subgroups, not two. Meteorit. Planet. Sci. Suppl. 32, 138–139 (1997).
Krot, A. N. et al. Secondary calcium-iron minerals in the Bali-like and Allende-like oxidized CV3 chondrites and Allende dark inclusions. Meteoritics 33, 623–645 (1998).
MacPherson, G. J. & Krot, A. N. The formation of Ca‐, Fe‐rich silicates in reduced and oxidized CV chondrites: the roles of impact‐modified porosity and permeability, and heterogeneous distribution of water ices. Meteorit. Planet. Sci. 49, 1250–1270 (2014).
Fuchs, L. H. Occurrence of wollastonite, rhonite, and andradite in the Allende meteorite. Am. Mineral. 56, 2053–2068 (1971).
Krot, A. N., Petaev, M. I. & Bland, P. A. Multiple formation mechanisms of ferrous olivine in CV3 carbonaceous chondrites during fluid-assisted metamorphism. Antarc. Meteorit. Res. 17, 154–172 (2004).
Zolotov, M. Y., Mironenko, M. V. & Shock, E. L. Thermodynamic constraints on fayalite formation on parent bodies of chondrites. Meteorit. Planet. Sci. 41, 1775–1796 (2006).
Zolensky, M. E., Krot, A. N. & Benedix, G. Record of low-temperature alteration in asteroids. Rev. Mineral. Geochem. 68, 429–462 (2008).
Kimura, M. & Ikeda, Y. Anhydrous alteration of Allende chondrules in the solar nebula; II, alkali-Ca exchange reactions and formation of nepheline, sodalite and Ca-rich phases in chondrules. Proc. NIPR Symp. Antarct. Meteor. 8, 123–138 (1995).
Kimura, M. & Ikeda, Y. Hydrous and anhydrous alterations of chondrules in Kaba and Mokoia CV chondrites. Meteorit. Planet. Sci. 33, 1139–1146 (1998).
Brenker, F. E. & Krot, A. N. Late-stage, high-temperature processesing in the Allende meteorite: record from Ca, Fe-rich silicate rims around dark inclusions. Am. Mineral. 89, 1280–1289 (2004).
Jogo, K., Nakamura, T., Noguchi, T. & Zolotov, M. Y. Fayalite in the Vigarano CV3 carbonaceous chondrite: occurrences, formation age and conditions. Earth. Planet. Sci. Lett. 287, 320–328 (2009).
Krot, A. N. et al. in Meteorites and the Early Solar System II. (eds Lauretta D. & McSween H.) 525–555 (The University of Arizona Press, 2006).
Krot, A. N., Petaev, M. I., Meibom, A. & Keil, K. In situ growth of Ca-rich rims around Allende dark inclusions. Geochem. Int. 38, S351 (2000).
MacPherson, G. J., Nagashima, K., Krot, A. N., Doyle, P. M. & Ivanova, M. 53Mn-53Cr systematics of Ca-Fe silicates in CV3 chondrites. 46th Lunar and Planetary Science Conference, 16–20 March 2015, The Woodlands, 2760 (2015).
Krot, A. N. & Todd, C. S. Metal-carbide-magnetite-fayalite association in a Bali-like clast in the reduced CV3 chondrite breccia Vigarano. Meteorit. Planet. Sci. Suppl. 33, A89 (1998).
Abreu, N. M. & Brearley, A. J. Deciphering the nebular and asteroidal record of silicates and organic material in the matrix of the reduced CV3 chondrite Vigarano. Meteorit. Planet. Sci. 46, 252–274 (2011).
Ohnishi, I. & Tomeoka, K. Hydrothermal alteration experiments of enstatite: implications for aqueous alteration of carbonaceous chondrites. Meteorit. Planet. Sci. 42, 49–61 (2007).
Brearley, A. J. Disordered biopyriboles, amphibole, and talc in the Allende meteorite: products of nebular or parent body aqueous alteration? Science 276, 1103–1105 (1997).
Gustafson, W. I. The stability of andradite, hedenbergite, and related minerals in the system Ca—Fe—Si—O—H. J. Pet. 15, 455–496 (1974).
Liou, J. G. Stability relations of andradite-quartz in the system Ca-Fe-Si-OH. Am. Mineral. 59, 1016–1025 (1974).
Jarosewich, E. Chemical analyses of meteorites: a compilation of stony and iron meteorite analyses. Meteoritics. 25, 323–337 (1990).
Frost, B. R. On the stability of sulfides, oxides, and native metals in serpentinite. J. Petrol. 26, 31–63 (1985).
Blum, J. D., Wasserburg, G. J., Hutcheon, I. D., Beckett, J. R. & Stolper, E. M. Origin of opaque assemblages in C3V meteorites: implications for nebular and planetary processes. Geochim. Cosmochim. Acta 53, 543–556 (1989).
Murakami, T. & Ikeda, Y. Petrology and mineralogy of the Yamato‐86751 CV3 chondrite. Meteoritics. 29, 397–409 (1994).
O’Brien, T. M. & Tarduno, J. A. Allende meteorite remanence: evidence for magnetic interactions. 47th Lunar and Planetary Science Conference, 21–25 March 2016, The Woodlands, 2913 (2016).
Righter, K. & Neff, K. E. Temperature and oxygen fugacity constraints on CK and R chondrites and implications for water and oxidation in the early solar system. Polar Sci. 1, 25–44 (2007).
Kubaschewski, O. IRON-Binary phase diagrams, 1–185 (Springer-Verlag, 1982).
Kullerud, G. Thermal stability of pentlandite. Can. Mineral. 7, 353–366 (1963).
Huss, G. R., Meshik, A. P., Smith, J. B. & Hohenberg, C. M. Presolar diamond, silicon carbide, and graphite in carbonaceous chondrites: implications for thermal processing in the solar nebula. Geochim. Cosmochim. Acta 67, 4823–4848 (2003).
Bose, M., Root, R. A. & Pizzarello, S. A XANES and Raman investigation of sulfur speciation and structural order in Murchison and Allende meteorites. Meteorit. Planet. Sci. 52, 1–14 (2017).
Jones, C. L. & Brearley, A. J. Experimental aqueous alteration of the Allende meteorite under oxidizing conditions: constraints on asteroidal alteration. Geochim. Cosmochim. Acta 70, 1040–1058 (2006).
Busemann, H., Alexander, M. D. & Nittler, L. R. Characterization of insoluble organic matter in primitive meteorites by microRaman spectroscopy. Meteorit. Planet. Sci. 42, 1387–1416 (2007).
Bonal, L., Quirico, E., Bourot-Denise, M. & Montagnac, G. Determination of the petrologic type of CV3 chondrites by Raman spectroscopy of included organic matter. Geochim. Cosmochim. Acta. 70, 1849–1863 (2006).
Rietmeijer, F. J. M. & MacKinnon, I. D. R. Poorly graphitized carbon as a new cosmothermometer for primitive extraterrestrial materials. Nature 315, 733–736 (1985).
Huss, G. R. & Lewis, R. S. Noble gases in presolar diamonds II: component abundances reflect thermal processing. Meteoritics 29, 811–829 (1994).
Krot, A. N. & Todd, C. S. Metal-carbide-magnetite-fayalite association in a Bali-like clast in the reduced CV3 chondrite breccia Vigarano. Meteorit. Planet. Sci. Suppl. 33, A89 (1998).
Klein, F. & Bach, W. Fe–Ni–Co–O–S phase relations in peridotite–seawater interactions. J. Petrol. 50, 37–59 (2009).
Marrocchi, Y., Chaussidon, M., Piani, L. & Libourel, G. Early scattering of the solar protoplanetary disk recorded in meteoritic chondrules. Sci. Adv. 2, e1601001 (2016).
Bowman, J. R. Basic aspects and applications of phase equilibria in the analysis of metasomatic Ca-Mg-Al-Fe-Si skarns. Mineralized intrusion-related skarn systems. Mineral. Assoc. Can. Short Course 26, 1–49 (1998).
Matsumoto, M., Tomeoka, K., Seto, Y., Miyake, A. & Sugita, M. Nepheline and sodalite in the matrix of the Ningqiang carbonaceous chondrite: implications for formation through parent-body processes. Geochim. Cosmochim. Acta 126, 441–454 (2014).
Ellingham, H. J. T. Reducibility of oxides and sulfides in metallurgical processes. J. Soc. Chem. Ind. 63, 125–133 (1944).
Lodders, K. Solar system abundances and condensation temperatures of the elements. Astrophys. J. 591, 1220–1247 (2003).
Fu, R. & Elkins-Tanton, L. T. The fate of magmas in planetesimals and the retention of primitive chondritic crusts. Earth Planet. Sci. Lett. 390, 128–137 (2014).
Frost, B. R. & Beard, J. S. On silica activity and serpentinization. J. Petrol. 48, 1351–1368 (2007).
Malvoisin, B., Brunet, F., Carlut, J., Rouméjon, S. & Cannat, M. Serpentinization of oceanic peridotites: 2. Kinetics and processes of San Carlos olivine hydrothermal alteration. J. Geophys. Res. B 117, 1978–2012 (2012).
Klein, F., Bach, W. & McCollom, T. M. Compositional controls on hydrogen generation during serpentinization of ultramafic rocks. Lithos 178, 55–69 (2013).
Dyl, K. A. et al. Early Solar System hydrothermal activity in chondritic asteroids on 1–10-year timescales. Proc. Natl Acad. Sci. USA 109, 18306–18311 (2012).
Krot, A. N., Scott, E. R. D. & Zolensky, M. E. Mineralogical and chemical modification of components in CV3 chondrites: nebular or asteroidal processing? Meteoritics 30, 748–775 (1995).
Cuvillier, P., Leroux, H., Jacob, D. & Hirel, P. Fe‐Mg interdiffusion profiles in rimmed forsterite grains in the Allende matrix: time–temperature constraints for the parent body metamorphism. Meteorit. Planet. Sci. 50, 1529–1545 (2015).
Clayton, R. N. & Mayeda, T. K. Oxygen isotope studies of carbonaceous chondrites. Geochim. Cosmochim. Acta 63, 2089–2104 (1999).
Young, E. D., Ash, R. D., England, P. & Rumble, D. Fluid flow in chondritic parent bodies: deciphering the compositions of planetesimals. Science 286, 1331–1335 (1999).
Krot, A. N. & Nagashima, K. Evidence for oxygen-isotope exchange in chondrules and refractory inclusions during fluid-rock interaction on the CV chondrite parent body. 79th Annual Meeting of the Meteoritical Society, 7–12 August 2016, Berlin. LPI Contributions 1921, 6014 (2016).
Scherer, P. & Schultz, L. Noble gas record, collisional history, and pairing of CV, CO, CK, and other carbonaceous chondrites. Meteorit. Planet. Sci. 35, 135–145 (2000).
De Capitani, C. & Petrakakis, K. The computation of equilibrium assemblage diagrams with Theriak/Domino software. Am. Mineral. 95, 1006–1016 (2010).
Holland, T. J. B. & Powell, R. An improved and extended internally consistent thermodynamic dataset for phases of petrological interest, involving a new equation of state for solids. J. Metamorph. Geol 29, 333–383 (2011).
Holland, T. J. B. Dependence of entropy on volume for silicate and oxide minerals: a review and a predictive model. Am. Mineral. 74, 5–13 (1989).
Mukhopadhyay, D. K. & Lindsley, D. H. Phase relations in the join kirschsteinite (CaFeSiO4)-fayalite (Fe2SiO4). Am. Mineral. 68, 1089–1094 (1983).
Berman, R. G. & Brown, T. H. Heat capacity of minerals in the system Na2O-K2O-CaO-MgO-FeO-Fe2O3-Al2O3-SiO2-TiO2-H2O-CO2: representation, estimation, and high temperature extrapolation. Contrib. Min. Pet 89, 168–183 (1985).
Holland, T. J. B. & Powell, R. An internally consistent thermodynamic data set for phases of petrological interest. J. Metamorph. Geol. 16, 309–343 (1998).
Markl, G., Marks, M. & Wirth, R. The influence of T, aSiO2, and fO2 on exsolution textures in Fe-Mg olivine: an example from augite syenites of the Ilimaussaq Intrusion, South Greenland. Am. Mineral. 86, 36–46 (2001).
We thank Seth Jacobson and Nathalie Vigier for their corrections that greatly improved this article. Benoit Dubacq is warmly acknowledged for his invaluable support when calculating kirschsteinite thermodynamical data. We are grateful for the samples provided by the MNHN (Paris), the Statens Naturhistoriske Museum (Copenhagen) and the Smithsonian NMHN (Washington, DC). We thank Olivier Tottereau, Suzanne Jacomet and Valentina Batanova for technical assistance. This project was financially supported by Université de la Côte d’Azur (UCA) IDEX Académie 3, BQR from the Observatoire de la Côte d’Azur (OCA), Programme National de Planétologie (PNP) CNRS and CSI from the Université de Nice Sophia Antipolis. Géoazur and Lagrange are also acknowledged for their support.
Competing financial interests
The authors declare no competing financial interests.
Publisher's note: Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.
About this article
Cite this article
Ganino, C., Libourel, G. Reduced and unstratified crust in CV chondrite parent body. Nat Commun 8, 261 (2017). https://doi.org/10.1038/s41467-017-00293-1
Progress in Earth and Planetary Science (2018)