A Japanese family with dystonia due to a pathogenic variant in SGCE

Dystonia (DYT) is a heterogeneous neurological disorder, and there are many types of DYT depending on the responsible genes. DYT11 is an autosomal dominant DYT caused by functional variants in the SGCE gene. We examined a Japanese patient with myoclonic dystonia. By using exome analysis, we identified a rare variant in the SGCE gene, NM_003919.3: c.304C > T [Arg102*], in this patient. Therefore, this patient has been molecularly diagnosed with DYT11. By Sanger sequencing, we confirmed that this variant was paternally inherited in this patient. By allele-specific PCR, we confirmed that the maternally inherited normal allele of SGCE was silenced, and only the paternally inherited variant allele was expressed in this patient. Despite the pathogenicity, identical variants have been recurrently reported in eight independent families from different ethnicities, suggesting recurrent mutations at this mutational hotspot in SGCE.

Dystonia (DYT) is a heterogeneous neurological disorder, and there are many types of DYT depending on the responsible genes. DYT11 is an autosomal dominant DYT caused by functional variants in the SGCE gene. We examined a Japanese patient with myoclonic dystonia. By using exome analysis, we identified a rare variant in the SGCE gene, NM_003919.3: c.304C > T [Arg102*], in this patient. Therefore, this patient has been molecularly diagnosed with DYT11. By Sanger sequencing, we confirmed that this variant was paternally inherited in this patient. By allele-specific PCR, we confirmed that the maternally inherited normal allele of SGCE was silenced, and only the paternally inherited variant allele was expressed in this patient. Despite the pathogenicity, identical variants have been recurrently reported in eight independent families from different ethnicities, suggesting recurrent mutations at this mutational hotspot in SGCE.
Human Genome Variation (2022) 9:1-3; https://doi.org/10.1038/s41439-022-00207-8 Dystonia is a neurological disorder characterized by abnormal involuntary movements or postures owing to sustained or intermittent muscle contractions 1 . Monogenic forms of dystonia/ dyskinesias (DYTs) are classified from DYT1 to DYT25, and 17 genes are known to be responsible for DYT 2 . In addition to these 17 genes, 9 new genes have been suggested to be responsible for DYT 3 . SGCE is the gene responsible for DYT11 1 .
A 19-year-old female, without a family history of involuntary movements, noticed occasional jerking in her right hand when writing or using chopsticks at the age of eight. She often had difficulty holding things in her right hand. Her symptoms were aggravated by psychological stress. Her symptoms gradually worsened and spread to her left hand. She had no other significant medical history. Neurological examination revealed no abnormalities except for action myoclonus in her hands with right dominancy and occasionally dystonic posture in her right foot during walking. Her action myoclonus was inhibited by dorsiflexion of the wrist joint. No abnormalities were observed in brain magnetic resonance imaging or electroencephalography. Her symptoms improved dramatically with clonazepam (1.5 mg/ day). Her parents showed no neurological abnormalities. The patient was diagnosed with myoclonus-dystonia syndrome.
We performed exome sequencing for the patient who was diagnosed with DYT ( Fig. 1A). We identified a total of 130,940 variants in the patient (II-1). Since she was diagnosed with myoclonus-dystonia syndrome 2,3 , we selected 80 variants located in 26 genes known to be associated with DYT (Table S1). Out of the 80 variants, we identified only two functional variants with a MAF (minor allele frequency) <0.02. One was a heterozygous variant in PKRA that is known to be associated with the autosomal recessive form of DYT, so we excluded this variant. Then, we retained only one variant, NM_003919.3:c.304C > T [Arg102*], in the epsilon sarcoglycan gene SGCE.
We validated the variant by Sanger sequencing for all family members (forward primer, 5'-ACTACCAAAGCAACATGTGTGA-3' and reverse primer 5'-GCTTCCCCACATTTTCAGCT-3'). This variant was also found in the unaffected father (I-1) of the patient as well as the patient, indicating the paternal inheritance of this variant for this patient (Fig. 1B). SGCE is known to be an imprinted gene and is expressed only from paternal alleles by silencing maternal alleles 4,5 . Since the father (I-1) carrying the variant does not show DYT symptoms, it is highly likely that the variant was maternally inherited from the patient's grandmother and was silenced in I-1 by genomic imprinting. To confirm genetic silencing, we performed allele-specific real-time qPCR using total RNA extracted from peripheral blood to determine which allele was expressed ( Fig. 2A and Supplementary  Table S2). Allele-specific PCR revealed that the SGCE mRNA of the patient (II-1) was only transcribed from the variant allele. The amount of SGCE mRNA in the patient (II-1) was lower than that in the mother (I-2) ( Fig. 2A). This is likely due to nonsense-mediated decay degrading abnormal mRNAs. Allele-specific qPCR also revealed that the SGCE mRNA in the patient (II-1) was transcribed almost exclusively from the variant allele (Fig. 2B). However, we could not obtain statistical significance due to the very low expression of SGCE in the peripheral blood. Unfortunately, we could not include the father (I-1) in the analyses due to the unavailability of his total RNA. This variant has already been identified as the variant responsible for DYT in eight independent families worldwide [6][7][8][9] .
This suggests that the identical variants have recurrently arisen at the mutational hotspot in the SGCE gene, despite the high CADD score (CADD = 41). According to the ACMG/AMP/CAP guidelines, the variant meets the criteria of PVS1, PS1, PM1, PM2, PP1, PP3, PP4, and PP5 10 . Collectively, we concluded that the SGCE variant is responsible for DYT in the current patient, and she has been molecularly diagnosed with DYT11. We also directly confirmed that the genomic imprinting of SGCE affects the pathogenesis of DYT11. Specifically, the maternally inherited normal allele of SGCE was silenced, and only the paternally inherited variant allele was expressed in this patient.

HGV DATABASE
The relevant data from this Data Report are hosted at the Human Genome Variation Database at https://doi.org/10.6084/ m9.figshare.hgv.3213.