Expanding the PURA syndrome phenotype with manifestations in a Japanese female patient

We report on a 15-year-old Japanese female patient with hypotonia and global developmental delay from the neonatal period who was revealed to carry a known pathogenic PURA variant (NM_005859.5:c.697_699del, p.Phe233del) by whole-exome sequencing. She had previously unreported clinical features, including a rectovestibular fistula, extremely short stature, and underweight, expanding the known phenotype of PURA syndrome.

syndrome was normal, and there were no SMN1 gene mutations. She was discharged at 3 months of age with a weight of 4734 g. At the age of 1.5 years, she weighed 8.7 kg (-1.2 SD). She had severe allergies to eggs, milk, and wheat and experienced anaphylaxis several times. She also had severe constipation during infancy.
At the age of 5 years, she presented with marked hypotonia, a myopathic face, frontal bossing, a high-arched palate, esotropia, almond-shaped palpebral fissures, long, thin fingers, and soft skin (Fig. 1A). At the age of 7 years, she developed atonic, tonic, and gelastic seizures. An electroencephalogram (EEG) revealed occasional spikes, mainly over the left parietal region (Fig. 1B). She was diagnosed with epilepsy and was prescribed several anti-seizure medications. A nonepileptic exaggerated startle response to slight stimulation involving splaying of her arms was also often seen. Repeat brain MRI revealed no abnormalities.
At the age of 10 years, feces was observed to pass from her vaginal vestibule. Physical examination revealed a slight fistula in her vaginal vestibule but no imperforate anus. An enema of gastrografin containing pyoctanin showed no fistula from her rectum to vaginal vestibule, but pyoctanin was attached to the vaginal vestibule after examination. Histological examination of the excrement from her vaginal vestibule showed the presence of food residue, so we diagnosed her with a rectovestibular fistula.
The patient has global developmental delay; she achieved head control at 6 years of age, sat alone at 7 years of age, and stood with support at 10 years of age. At 15 years of age, she cannot stand alone and needs full assistance when bathing and at mealtimes. Mobility is only possible in a wheelchair operated by another individual. She demonstrates social smiling and can use jargon but does not speak recognizable words. Growth was also significantly delayed; her height was 106 cm (-3.5 SD), her weight was 12 kg, her body mass index (BMI) was 10.7 at 8 years of age, and at 15 years of age, her height is 118 cm (-7.6 SD), her weight is 16 kg, and her BMI is 11.5 (Fig. 1C).
To confirm a molecular diagnosis, we analyzed DNA samples of the patient obtained at the age of 11 years and of both parents by whole-exome sequencing (WES) using the HiSeq 2500 System (Illumina, San Diego, CA). DNA samples were extracted from peripheral blood after receiving written informed consent from her parents. WES detected a heterozygous in-frame deletion (NM_005859.5:c.697_699del, p.Phe233del) in exon 1 of PURA in the patient but not her parents. This was confirmed by Sanger sequencing.
PURA p.(Phe233del) is the most commonly reported variation and was first identified by Hunt et al. in 2014; our patient is the ninth reported to carry the variant [5][6][7][8][9] . Table 1 compares all nine patients with the variant, revealing common clinical features including neonatal hypotonia, postnatal hypotonia, intellectual disability, language delay, and motor development delay. However, Patient 14, described by Reijnders et al., first sat alone at 1-2 years of age, while our patient achieved this at 7 years of age. Similarly, patient DB15-027, described by Lee et al., was able to walk alone at 4 years of age, while our patient remains unable to do so at 15 years of age. This suggests the presence of a wide range of developmental phenotypes among patients with the same PURA variant. Feeding difficulties, respiratory problems, hypersomnolence and hypothermia in the neonatal period, an exaggerated startle response, epilepsy, EEG abnormalities, brain MRI abnormalities, gastrointestinal abnormalities (e.g., constipation or drooling), vitamin D deficiency, and dermatological abnormalities (e.g., soft skin and cutis laxa) were observed in more than half of the nine patients. Our patient shared these clinical features, except for hypersomnolence and hypothermia in the neonatal period, brain MRI abnormalities, and vitamin D deficiency. The clinical features of patients carrying the PURA p.
Phe233del variant do not differ from those reported for all patients with PURA syndrome, suggesting that it is difficult to describe reliable genotype-phenotype correlations 5,9 . Our patient had a rectovestibular fistula, which has not previously been reported in patients with PURA syndrome. Congenital rectovestibular fistulas comprise the majority of anorectal malformations 10 . However, female anorectal malformations can be difficult to diagnose precisely because of anatomical complexities and the approximation of genital organs 11 . Acquired rectovestibular fistulas are often a symptom of a disorder such as Crohn's disease, pelvic infection, and malignancy 12 . Our patient was diagnosed with a rectovestibular fistula at the age of 10 years when feces were observed to pass from her vaginal vestibule, but it was difficult to distinguish whether this was congenital or acquired by physical examination and imaging. Therefore, although it is unclear whether the fistula is associated with the PURA variant, our patient may expand the phenotypic spectrum associated with PURA syndrome.
Patients with PURA syndrome often have a short stature 5,13 . Indeed, Reijnders et al. reported that the height of 8/49 (16%) patients was ≤2.5 SD 5 . However, the extent of short stature and low weight of our patient, as shown in Fig. 1C, is incomparably stronger than in previous reports. Our patient lacks the limb shortening characteristic of achondroplasia, which is associated with a markedly short stature. Severely stunted height and weight growth can also result from inadequate caloric intake (such as that caused by difficulties with nursing or limited food availability), inadequate caloric absorption (such as that resulting from metabolic or gastrointestinal disorders), or excessive caloric    expenditure/ineffective utilization (e.g., resulting from hyperthyroidism, diabetes, pulmonary, or cardiac conditions) 14 . Our patient could eat a certain amount of food with assistance, and physical examinations revealed no metabolic disorders, hyperthyroidism, diabetes, or cardiac disease. The possibility of inadequate caloric absorption from gastrointestinal disorders cannot be ruled out, but it should be noted that PURA syndrome itself can strongly slow growth.
In conclusion, we report on a 15-year-old Japanese female with hypotonia and global developmental delay from the neonatal period that had an unknown cause for many years but was finally revealed to result from the PURA p.Phe233del variant, which was identified by WES. In a comparison with eight previously reported patients carrying the same variant, all shared neonatal/postnatal hypotonia, intellectual disability, and language delay. However, other phenotypes vary widely among patients, suggesting that it is difficult to identify reliable genotype-phenotype correlations for PURA syndrome. Our patient also has a rectovestibular fistula and is of a markedly short stature and low weight; these findings may expand our current knowledge of the phenotypic spectrum associated with PURA syndrome.

HGV DATABASE
The relevant data from this Data Report are hosted at the Human Genome Variation Database at https://doi.org/10.6084/m9.figshare.hgv.3155.