In their commentary in ISME Journal, Steen and coworkers expressed concerns over my recent analysis about the culturability of microorganisms [1, 2]. My analysis challenged the long-standing and oft-repeated ‘1% culturability paradigm’ stating that most microbes cannot be cultured. First and foremost, I argue that the paradigm is poorly defined but can be classified into at least three hypotheses: (H1) 1% of cells in a community can be cultivated, (H2) 1% of taxa in a community can be cultivated or (H3) 1% of cells in a community grow when plated on a standard agar medium. A second complication centers on how one defines whether two organisms are the same vs. different, and studies abound with discussions of this point [3]. A narrow definition of similarity will invariably lead to a low representation of microbial communities in culture collections due to the sheer abundance and sequence variants of microorganisms. Depending on how one defines the problem, when something is the same or different, and the specific environments in which it is tested, you get different answers. However, I show that if you apply the most common interpretation of the paradigm (H1) and the usual definition of taxon similarity (~97% 16S rRNA similarity), you reach the conclusion that many and especially abundant lineages have already been cultured across diverse environments.
Steen and coworkers commentary challenge this conclusion but do not identify which version(s) of the paradigm they challenge. I do not doubt the quality of their analysis, and the differences in their conclusion would seem to support my original point that framing the problem matters. I interpret their analysis as a test of H2 as they dereplicate their sequence libraries and thereby remove taxon-abundance effects. In my original analysis, the interpretation of H2 is sensitive to the inclusion of rare sequence variants (Figure S5 in the original paper). Some of these rare variants are real organisms, whereas others may represent sequencing errors. Many recent culturing efforts have focused on abundant lineages. Thus, the increased representation of either rare members or sequencing errors in your analysis should lead to a low observed culturability. Steen and coworkers also advocate for a narrow definition of taxon similarity. They state ‘that it is impossible to know whether a microbe is culturable until it has been cultured’ and that ‘a great deal of genomic and phenotypic diversity can exist among strains of the same species.’ Thus, it is not surprising that they come to a conclusion that most microbial taxa have not been cultured.
The different interpretations can be well illustrated with the abundant marine cyanobacterium Prochlorococcus. There are ~1027 Prochlorococcus cells in the ocean [4], and we have ~50 diverse isolates in culture representing most subclades [5]. Culture experiments have revealed much about the shared physiology (and variation) of Prochlorococcus, but sequencing has also revealed that key traits and specific genotypes are missing among the isolates [6,7,8]. Is Prochlorococcus culturable and/or cultured? The answer differs depending on your criteria.
Personally, I have for many years taken the paradigm of 1% culturability as a discouragement for trying to isolate microorganisms—and I suspect many others have been discouraged, too. We are developing increasingly sophisticated techniques for molecular in situ analyses of microbial communities, whereas very few cultivation-based model systems are proposed. However, some (but too few) studies have revealed that traditional techniques like dilution-to-extinction or using substrate-poor agar plates can lead to the isolation of many abundant microbial lineages [9,10,11]. I hope to illustrate with this work that, since the 1% culturability paradigm was proposed, we have made great strides in culturing representatives of abundant lineages from multiple environments, and we should continue down this path.
References
Martiny AC. High proportions of bacteria are culturable across major biomes. ISME J. 2019. https://doi.org/10.1038/s41396-019-0410-3
Steen AD, et al. High proportions of bacteria and archaea across most biomes remain uncultured. ISME J. 2019. https://www.nature.com/articles/s41396-019-0484-y
Rosselló-Móra R, Amann R. Past and future species definitions for Bacteria and Archaea. Syst Appl Microbiol. 2015;38:209–16.
Flombaum P, Gallegos JL, Gordillo RA, Rincon J, Zabala LL, Jiao N, et al. Present and future global distributions of the marine Cyanobacteria Prochlorococcus and Synechococcus. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA. 2013;110:9824–9.
Biller SJ, Berube PM, Lindell D, Chisholm SW. Prochlorococcus: the structure and function of collective diversity. Nat Rev Microbiol. 2015;13:13–27.
Malmstrom RR, Rodrigue S, Huang KH, Kelly L, Kern SE, Thompson A, et al. Ecology of uncultured Prochlorococcus clades revealed through single-cell genomics and biogeographic analysis. ISME J. 2013;7:184–98.
Rusch DB, Martiny AC, Dupont CL, Halpern AL, Venter JC. Characterization of Prochlorococcus clades from iron-depleted oceanic regions. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA. 2010;107:16184–9. https://doi.org/10.1073/pnas.1009513107
Martiny AC, Tai APK, Veneziano D, Primeau F, Chisholm SW. Taxonomic resolution, ecotypes and the biogeography of Prochlorococcus. Environ Microbiol. 2009;11:823–32. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1462-2920.2008.01803.x
Giovannoni S, Stingl U. The importance of culturing bacterioplankton in the “omics” age. Nat Rev Microbiol. 2007;5:820–6.
Joseph SJ, Hugenholtz P, Sangwan P, Osborne CA, Janssen PH. Laboratory cultivation of widespread and previously uncultured soil bacteria. Appl Environ Microbiol. 2003;69:7210–5. https://doi.org/10.1128/AEM.69.12.7210-7215.2003
Chase AB, Karaoz U, Brodie EL, Gomez-Lunar Z, Martiny AC, Martiny JBH. Microdiversity of an abundant terrestrial bacterium encompasses extensive variation in ecologically relevant traits. MBio. 2017. https://doi.org/10.1128/mbio.01809-17
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Ethics declarations
Conflict of interest
The author declare that he has no conflict of interest.
Additional information
Publisher’s note Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Martiny, A.C. The ‘1% culturability paradigm’ needs to be carefully defined. ISME J 14, 10–11 (2020). https://doi.org/10.1038/s41396-019-0507-8
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1038/s41396-019-0507-8
This article is cited by
-
The microbial dark matter and “wanted list” in worldwide wastewater treatment plants
Microbiome (2023)
-
Life history strategies of soil bacterial communities across global terrestrial biomes
Nature Microbiology (2023)
-
Microfluidic hotspots in bacteria research: A review of soil and related advances
Soil Ecology Letters (2023)
-
Microbial Interaction is Among the Key Factors for Isolation of Previous Uncultured Microbes
Journal of Microbiology (2023)
-
Colonization by the Red Imported Fire Ant, Solenopsis invicta, Modifies Soil Bacterial Communities
Microbial Ecology (2022)