Selective serotonin reuptake inhibitors (SSRIs) and tricyclic antidepressants (TCAs) increase neurogenesis in the dentate gyrus (DG) of rodents and nonhuman primates. We determined whether SSRIs or TCAs increase neural progenitor (NPCs) and dividing cells in the human DG in major depressive disorder (MDD). Whole frozen hippocampi from untreated subjects with MDD (N=5), antidepressant-treated MDD (MDDT, N=7), and controls (C, N=7) were fixed, sectioned, and immunostained for NPCs and dividing cell markers (nestin and Ki-67, respectively), NeuN and GFAP, in single and double labeling. NPC and dividing cell numbers in the DG were estimated by stereology. Clinical data were obtained by psychological autopsy, and by toxicological and neuropathological examination performed on all subjects. NPCs decreased with age (p=0.034). Females had more NPCs than males (p=0.023). Correcting for age and sex, MDDT receiving SSRIs had more NPCs than untreated MDD (p0.001) and controls (p0.001), NPCs were not different in SSRI- and TCA-treated MDDT (p=0.169). Dividing cell number, unaffected by age or sex, was greater in MDDT receiving TCAs than in untreated MDD (p0.001), SSRI-treated MDD (p=0.001), and controls (p0.001). The increase of NPCs and dividing cells in MDDT was localized to the rostral DG. MDDT had a larger DG volume compared with untreated MDD or controls (p=0.009). Antidepressants increase NPC number in the anterior human DG. Whether this finding is critical or necessary for the antidepressants effect remains to be determined.
Neurogenesis has been detected in the adult hippocampus of rodents (Miller and Nowakowski, 1988; Kee et al, 2002; Santarelli et al, 2003), nonhuman primates (Kornack and Rakic, 1999; Gould et al, 1999), and humans (Eriksson et al, 1998). Adult neurogenesis seems to be functional, as abolishing it affects hippocampal-dependent learning (Van Praag et al, 2002; Sahay and Hen, 2007). In rodents, stress decreases neurogenesis, whereas antidepressants (Dranovsky and Hen, 2006), environmental enrichment, exercise (Kempermann et al, 1998; van Praag et al, 1999), and learning (Leuner et al, 2004) stimulate neurogenesis. Furthermore, some behavioral effects of pharmacological antidepressants are blocked by abolishing dentate gyrus (DG) neurogenesis in some species (Santarelli et al, 2003; Wang et al, 2008; Surget et al, 2008; David et al, 2009). Neurogenesis decreases with age in different mammals (Rao et al, 2006; Siwak-Tapp et al, 2007; Leuner et al, 2007). The effect of fluoxetine on neurogenesis is reported to be age-dependent in Balb/c and C57Bl/6 (Navailles et al, 2008), but not in 129sv mice (Santarelli et al, 2003).
Dividing cells become neurons in the granule cell layer (GCL) of the DG in the adult human hippocampus, in which BrdU immunoreactive (IR) cells double label with antibodies specific to neurons (neuron-specific enolase, calbindin, and neuron-specific nuclear protein (NeuN, Eriksson et al, 1998)). The human DG consists of the GCL, external molecular layer (ML), and an inner polymorphic layer, the subgranular zone (SGZ, Figure 1a and b). BrdU-IR cells are localized to the SGZ and to the inner part of the GCL in rodents (Holick et al, 2007; Santarelli et al, 2003). In adult primates, labeled cells extend to the ML and hilus (Kornack and Rakic, 1999; Gould et al, 1999). The location of BrdU-IR cells in the human brain is the same as in nonhuman primates (Eriksson et al, 1998). A cell cycle and mitosis-related protein, Ki-67 (Jakob et al, 2008), labels proliferating cells, and co-localizes with BrdU in the nonhuman primate (Gould et al, 1999) and rodent (Kee et al, 2002; Reif et al, 2006; Saravia et al, 2007) brain. In rats, BrdU co-localizes with Ki-67 over a 4-day window, making the co-localization timeframe specific (Dayer et al, 2003). In the SGZ of nonhuman primates, BrdU-IR and Ki-67-IR cell densities are positively correlated (Perera et al, 2007). Nestin is a neuron-specific intermediate filament, expressed by quiescent and amplifying neural progenitor cells (NPCs, Encinas et al, 2006; Crespel et al, 2005; Takei et al, 2007). In rodents, quiescent NPCs have a triangular soma in the SGZ, and a single or double apical process that extends radially across the GCL, terminating in elaborate arbors of fine leaf-like processes in the ML. Quiescent NPCs undergo asymmetric divisions and generate the amplifying NPCs that propagate in the SGZ through a series of symmetric divisions and exit the cell cycle within 1–3 days thereby becoming post-mitotic neuroblasts type 1. Unlike quiescent NPCs, amplifying NPCs do not stain for GFAP or vimentin in mice (Encinas et al, 2006). Nestin has been successfully used in human studies to detect NPCs in the brains of adults and children with temporal lobe epilepsy (Crespel et al, 2005; Takei et al, 2007).
Impaired adult neurogenesis has been hypothesized to be a part of the pathogenesis of major depressive disorder (MDD, Duman et al, 2000; Kempermann and Kronenberg, 2003). Neurogenesis is impaired in stress-induced models of depression in rodents (Kempermann and Kronenberg, 2003; Coyle and Duman, 2003; Pham et al, 2003). However, blocking cell replication by irradiation does not induce depression-like behavior in mice (Santarelli et al, 2003). Similarly, inescapable shock decreases cell proliferation, but does not produce helpless behavior in rats (Vollmayr et al, 2003). Therefore, other factors, besides impaired neurogenesis, mediate the development of a depressive phenotype in rodents. Smaller hippocampal volume has been reported in MDD (Sheline et al, 1999; Bremner et al, 2000) together with apoptosis in neuronal cells of the entorhinal cortex, subiculum, DG, CA1, and CA4 regions of the hippocampus (Lucassen et al, 2001). However, in MDD, neuron density in the hippocampus was not reduced (Stockmeier et al, 2004). Therefore, it is not clear why the hippocampus might be smaller in MDD.
We determined the anatomical location within postmortem adult human DG of NPCs (Nestin-IR) and dividing cells (Ki-67-IR). We sought to test the hypotheses that antidepressant treatment increases NPC number and cell division in the human DG, and that dividing cells are fewer in subjects with MDD. To assess this, we compared the number of Nestin-IR and Ki-67-IR cells in the DG from non-psychiatric controls, untreated MDD, and antidepressant-treated MDD (MDDT) who had received serotonin reuptake inhibitors (SSRIs) or tricyclic antidepressants (TCAs) in the past 3 months.
MATERIALS AND METHODS
Tissue was obtained from the Brain Collection of the Human Neurobiology Core of the Conte Center for the Neuroscience of Mental Disorders and the Macedonia/NYS Psychiatric Institute Brain Collection. All research was conducted with IRB (Psychiatric Institute, Columbia University, NY, USA) approval. Brain collection followed a standardized protocol at the time of autopsy. The right hemisphere was cut into 2 cm-thick coronal blocks, which were flash-frozen in liquid Freon (−20°C) and stored at −80°C. Samples of tissue from multiple areas of the left hemisphere were fixed in formalin for neuropathological examination. Brain pH determination (Harrison et al, 1995) and toxicological analyses were performed on cerebellar samples. Over 30 drugs were screened for and quantified if present, including amphetamine, methamphetamine, methylphenidate, fluoxetine, fluvoxamine, methadone, cocaine, amitriptyline, nortriptyline, imipramine, trimipramine, maprotiline, sertraline, citalopram, chlorimipramine, diazepam, nordiazepam, 6-monacetyl morphine, paroxetine, amoxapine, heroin, olanzapine, clozapine, alprazolam, haloperidol, triazolam, buspirone, and others. Samples of blood and urine were screened for alcohol, antidepressants, barbiturates, benzodiazepines, cannabis, CO, cocaine, opioids, amphetamine, phencyclidine, salicylates, and methadone. A portion of the tissue was fixed in formalin for neuropathological examination.
A total of 19 cases were studied: MDD (N=5) without treatment for more than 3 months before death (negative toxicology); MDDT who were on SSRIs (N=4) or TCAs (N=3) during the 3 months before death (positive toxicology); and controls, without Axis I psychiatric disorder or history of any psychotropic medication for at least 3 months before death (C, N=7, clear toxicology). Subjects (7 females and 12 males) were 17–62 years of age, and had a postmortem interval (PMI) of 4–24 h. Four MDD and five MDDT cases died by suicide, one MDD and two MDDT cases died from other sudden death causes (Table 1). A psychological autopsy was used to obtain DSM-IV Axis I and II diagnoses, according to the American Psychiatric Association Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders, fourth edition (DSM-IV, APA, 1994) Lifetime information on suicidal behavior, aggressive impulsive behavior, medical illness, medications, family history, and developmental history was obtained (Kelly and Mann, 1996). Controls inclusion criteria were death by accident, homicide, or sudden natural causes, no psychiatric disorder by DSM-IV criteria (APA, 1994) or history of suicide attempts, and negative toxicology for psychoactive drugs. The inclusion criteria for MDD were Axis I diagnosis of MDD, major depressive episode within 4 months of death and not in remission at death, no history of treatment during the 3 months before death, and negative toxicology for psychoactive drugs. Inclusion criteria for MDDT were the same as that for MDD, but subjects had to have a history of treatment for at least the last 6 weeks of life and positive toxicology for SSRIs or TCAs. Exclusion criteria for all groups were alcohol or drug dependence or abuse, as determined by the psychological autopsy, positive toxicology for alcohol, liver changes associated with alcoholism, presence of neuropathology, verdict of undetermined death, mental retardation, chronic illness that may affect CNS function (for example, epilepsy, renal failure, metastatic malignancy, AIDS), PMI >24 h, brain not available owing to injury and resuscitation with prolonged (>10 min) hypoxia.
The whole hippocampal formation was dissected from two or three consecutive 2 cm-thick frozen coronal blocks. To optimize the tissue preparation, Bouin's, Carnoy's, Zamboni's, paraformaldehyde, and glutaraldehyde/paraformaldehyde fixatives were tested, and 4% paraformaldehyde was selected as the most suitable for the antibodies used and for preservation of the integrity of the tissue. After fixation for 1 week at 4°C, tissue was cryoprotected in increasing concentrations of sucrose (up to 30%), sectioned frozen at 50 μm on a sliding microtome (Microm HM 440E, Walldorf, Germany), collected into 40-well boxes, each well containing a series of sections at 2 mm intervals along the anterior–posterior extent of the hippocampal formation, and stored at −20°C in cryoprotectant solution (30% ethylene glycol in 0.1 M PBS) until use.
We used immunocytochemistry to identify NPCs (anti-nestin mouse monoclonal antibody, 1 : 8000, Chemicon, Temecula, CA), dividing cells (anti-Ki-67 mouse monoclonal antibody, Clone-MM1, 1 : 200, Novocastra Laboratories, Newcastle upon Tyne, UK), mature neurons (anti-NeuN mouse monoclonal antibody, 1 : 100 000; Chemicon), and mature astrocytes (anti-GFAP mouse monoclonal antibody, 1 : 9000; Sigma-Aldrich, St Louis, MO). Primary antibody was omitted in negative control sections. For single labeling, sections were removed from the cryoprotectant and exhaustively washed in 0.01 M PBS for 60 min, then treated with 0.5% sodium borohydride to remove aldehydes, rinsed in PBS, and incubated for 10 min in PBS with 3% hydrogen peroxide to inhibit endogenous peroxidase activity. Sets of immediately adjacent sections were processed for Ki-67 or nestin. Primary antibodies were added to blocking buffer and sections were incubated over 5 days at 4°C. This incubation time was used to ensure full penetration of the antibody through the entire 50 μm thickness of the sections, thus allowing 3D stereological cell counting and a correct estimate of the total cell counts. As a secondary antibody, biotinylated horse anti-mouse IgG (1 : 200, Vectastain Elite ABC, Vector Laboratories, Burlingame, CA) was used. Sections were processed with ABC reagents (Vector Laboratories) and immunostaining visualized with 3′,3-diaminobenzidine (DAB, Sigma-Aldrich). Sections immunoreacted with nestin were stained for Nissl and those assayed with Ki-67 were stained for eosin to highlight neuronal elements. Sections were then dehydrated, cleared, and coverslipped. Double-labeling experiments were performed to ascertain whether nestin-IR co-localized with NeuN-IR in neurons or GFAP-IR in astrocytes, or with QNPs, which also stain for GFAP (Encinas et al, 2006). The first antigens were visualized by using the ABC reagents and 1% nickel sulfate (Sigma-Aldrich) with 0.05% DAB and 0.01% H2O2 in PBS to yield a black precipitate. Then avidin and biotin were blocked using an Avidin/Biotin blocking kit (Vector SP-2001, Vector Laboratories, Jin et al, 2004) and immunocytochemistry for the second marker was performed using the same method described, but with 0.05% DAB to yield a brown precipitate. Thus, different antigens were distinguished by their color and appearance, and double-labeled cells were theoretically identifiable.
We quantified the number of dividing cells (Ki-67-IR) and NPCs (Nestin-IR) in the DG, which included the SGZ, GCL, and ML. The boundaries of the DG were initially defined at low magnification using a 1.6 × objective. Sampling was performed at every 2 mm throughout the anterior–posterior extent of the DG using a 40 × objective for Nestin-IR cells and a 63 × objective for Ki-67-IR cells. Reliability of counting cells with a 40 × objective was obtained counting the Nestin-IR cells with a 40 × and a 63 × objective in two subjects. We counted 6–10 sections per case. Each immunoreacted section was matched using a Leica Wild M3Z type stereoscope (Leica Heerburg, Heerburg, Switzerland) to a near adjacent Nissl-stained section that was numbered during the sectioning protocol and served as a reference for cytoarchitectonic details. This matching allowed for accurately aligning nestin- and Ki-67-IR sections along the anterior–posterior axis of the DG. We compared the total number of nestin-IR and Ki-67-IR cells across the anterior–posterior axis of the DG in the four groups (controls, MDD, MDDT who received SSRIs, and MDDT who received TCAs). To estimate the total number of nestin-IR and Ki-67-IR cells, we used the optical disector approach with the fractionator method (West and Gundersen, 1990; Gundersen et al, 1988; Joelving et al, 2006). The counting protocol was done with oversampling, as required when estimating the number of rare elements (Ngwenya et al, 2005). The upper and lower 3 μm in the z planes were not counted. The total number of objects counted in the individual disectors was multiplied by the reciprocals of sampling fraction for section (SSF), area (ASF), and thickness (TSF). The sampling parameters used to estimate the total cell number were SSF=0.019, ASF=0.652, and TSF=0.816. The equipment consisted of a Leica Diaplan microscope (Leitz Wetzlar, Germany) equipped with a motorized stage (Ludl Electronic Products, Hawthorne, NY) and a CCD color camera (MicroFire CCD, Optronics, Goleta, CA) connected to a computer to run the stereology software (StereoInvestigator, MBF Biosciences, Williston, VT). We measured the volume of the region of interest using the Cavalieri's principle, which allows obtaining an estimated volume of an object of arbitrary shape and size. The area of the region of interest within a section was determined by point counting and then the volume was calculated by multiplying the sum of the areas of the region of interest by the mean section thickness, times the distance between each section. We used the following formula:
, where V is the volume, T the distance between parallel sections, A the calculated area of a section, i is the section number, and n the total number of sections. The first slide to be sampled was the one in which the DG first appeared and subsequent sections were measured every 2 mm thereafter. All sampling was done by personnel who were blinded to the group assignment of the case.
Data analysis was performed using SPSS (16.0 for Mac). An alpha value of 0.05 was used for significance level. Different cell types, Ki-67-IR and nestin-IR, were analyzed separately. Regression analysis on log-transformed data was used to test the effect of age, PMI, and pH on cell number within groups. We tested cell number and DG volume differences between MDD, MDDT on TCAs, MDDT on SSRIs, and controls using ANOVA, with age as covariate when analyzing nestin-IR cells, and Tukey post hoc analysis for pair-wise comparisons. We did an age median split and used age 38 years and age >38 years as factor in a univariate ANOVA with three between-subjects factors, namely, age, sex, and group, to test the effect of sex on progenitor and dividing cells. Data are expressed as mean±SEM and p values are two-tailed.
Anatomical Distribution of Progenitor and Dividing Cells
Nestin-IR cells were detected in the SGZ of the DG, in which they can be found in niches wherein multiple cells appear in groups and often show connections with the vasculature (Figure 1c and d). They also appear isolated along the SGZ of the DG. Nestin-IR cells can also be found in the fimbria and in the sub subependymal layer, but those areas were not analyzed in this study. There were no nestin-IR cells in the ML (Figure 1e), CA regions, or in the neocortex. The nestin antibody stains the cell's cytoplasm and processes (Figure 1d). Nestin-IR cells found in the SGZ were multipolar (Figure 1c and d), although, less frequently, had a unipolar appearance as they migrated into the GCL (Figure 1c, arrow). Nestin-IR cells were present throughout the SGZ, in a non-uniform pattern. They appeared distributed along the SGZ, more often in the crest of the DG (Figure 1e), sometimes in groups. Blood vessels also stained for nestin (Figures 1c–e), and NPCs were found adjacent to capillaries, but only in the SGZ of the DG and not in other regions of the hippocampus. In MDDT, Nestin-IR cells exhibited prominent processes and a more complex structure than that in untreated MDDs (Figure 2).
GFAP-IR cells were ubiquitously located throughout the hilus (Figure 3a and b) and the hippocampal formation. Astrocytes do not stain for nestin, but they do stain for GFAP (Figure 3c and d). The nestin/GFAP double labeling show that GFAP labels astrocytes that are distributed in all subregions of the hippocampus (Figure 3a), including the hilus (Figure 3b), CA regions, and the adjacent neocortex. GFAP-IR cells located in the SGZ had processes that crossed the GCL and extended into the ML of the DG (Figure 3c). Two different populations of cells in human hippocampus expressed GFAP (Figure 3c and d) or nestin (Figure 3e and f). A few cells were labeled using both GFAP and nestin.
NeuN-IR neurons were observed in the GCL, the hilus, and the CA regions (Figure 1a). Dendrites were clearly visible at high magnification (Figure 1b). Double-labeling experiments (Figure 1e and f) showed that nestin-IR cells never stained for NeuN (Figure 1f).
Ki-67-IR cells were present in the GCL and the SGZ (Figure 1g). Ki-67 is a nuclear stain; Ki-67-IR cells were identified by a black nucleus (nickel-intensified reaction product) and a pink (eosinophilic) cytoplasm (Figure 1h). Occasionally, mitotic figures were observed.
Effect of Age, Sex, PMI, and pH on Progenitor and Dividing Cell Number and DG Volume
Increasing age was associated with fewer NPCs in the MDDT group (R2=0.749, F=11.966, df=1,4, p=0.026, Figure 4a), with MDDs and controls showing a similar, but not statistically significant, trend (Figure 4b and c; MDD: R2=0.596, F=3.578; df=1,4; p=0.126; C: R2=0.334, F=2.007; df=1,4; p=0.230). Age, used as covariate in a model comparing nestin-IR cell number between groups, was associated with fewer total NPCs (F=5.628; df=1,17; p=0.034). We used an age median split (age38 years and age >38 years) as factor in an ANOVA, including three between-subjects factors, namely, age, sex, and group. In the whole sample, age showed a significant effect, subjects38 years old had more NPCs (13 386±155; F=1.154; df=1,17; p0.001) compared with subjects >38 years old (457±188). Females had more NPCs (11 183±199) than males (6682±150; F=13.034; df=1,17; p=0.023). To estimate the effect size of age, sex, PMI, pH, brain weight, and group on NPCs and dividing cells number, we performed univariate ANOVA with covariates comparing untreated MDD with controls and with MDDT with SSRIs or TCAs. The results are shown in Table 2.
Dividing cells did not decrease with age in MDDT (R2=0.252, F=0.271, df=1,4, p=0.630), MDD (R2=0.310, F=1.348; df=1,4; p=0.330), or controls (R2=0.010, F=0.040; df=1,4; p=0.852, Figure 4d), and were not different in males and females. Neither age nor sex was related to DG volume. There was no correlation between pH or PMI and NPCs, dividing cell number, or DG volume in any group.
Quantification of NPCs and Dividing Cells
Controlling for age and sex, there were more progenitor cells in the MDDT group (C: 360±246; MDD: 1119±752; MDDT: 17 229±3443; F=6.935; df=3,17; p=0.005) compared with controls and untreated MDD subjects. MDD treated with SSRIs had more progenitor cells (Figure 5a and c: 360±246; MDD: 1119±221; MDDT*TCAs=14 613±271; MDDT*SSRIs=19 844±272; F=984.105; df=3,17; p0.001) than untreated MDD (p0.001) and controls (p0.001). NPCs were not different in SSRIs- and TCAs-treated MDDTs (p=0.169). Without controlling for age or sex, there were more Nestin-IR cells (C: 360±246; MDD: 1119±752; MDDT: 17 229±3443; F=6.935; df=3,17; p=0.015) in treated MDDs than in untreated MDDs (p=0.028) or controls (p=0.038). Dividing the MDDT group into subjects treated with SSRIs and subjects treated with TCAs also indicated a significant difference between groups (C: 360±246; MDD: 1119±221; MDDT*TCAs=14 613±271; MDDT*SSRIs=19 844±272; F=984.105; df=3,17; p=0.038).
The number of dividing cells in the MDDT group was about three times greater than that in controls and five times greater than that in MDD (C=20 808±8301; MDD=10 944±7593; MDDT=57 913±17 045; F=3.712; df=2,17; p=0.049). The number of dividing cells in MDDT receiving TCAs (C=20 808±8301; MDD=10 944±7593; MDDT*TCAs=94 229±7494; MDDT*SSRIs=21 597±8814; F=16.243; df=3,17; p0.001) was 5.9 times higher than that in untreated MDD (p0.001), 4.3 times higher than that in SSRI-treated MDD (p=0.001) and 4.5 times higher than that in controls (p0.001, Figure 5b). SSRI-treated MDDT subjects had a comparable number of dividing cells with controls (p=0.812). There was half the number of dividing cells in untreated MDD compared with controls, but the difference was not statistically significant (p=0.434).
Nestin-IR and Ki-67-IR cells distribution in the anterior vs posterior DG
Analysis of the anterior–posterior distribution of NPCs (Figure 5c) and dividing cells (Figure 5d) in the DG revealed that the increase in cell number in the treated subjects was more prominent in the rostrum. Few cells were found in the most posterior hippocampal sections.
The volume (mm3) of the DG was larger in MDDT (C=106.3±24.4; MDD=79.6±11.2; MDDT=188.4±19.1; F=6.331; df=2,17; p=0.009) compared with untreated MDD (p=0.014) and control (p=0.033). MDDT subjects receiving TCAs (C=115.4±19.0; MDD=96.0±19.4; MDDT*TCAs=220.6±32.4; MDDT*SSRIs=164.2±34.9; F=5.450; df=3,17; p=0.010) had a larger DG volume than that of untreated MDD (p=0.011) and controls (p=0.024), but not different from that of MDDT receiving SSRIs (p=0.418, Figure 5e). Brain weight (grams) was not different among groups (C=1450.0±52.9; MDD=1360.0±88.9; MDDT*TCAs=1386.6±63.5; MDDT*SSRIs=1307.5±66.1; F=0.637; df=3,17; p=0.608), as well as section thickness (μm) after processing (C=32.0±2.4; MDD=36.7±2.9; MDDT*TCAs=28.8±1.2; MDDT*SSRIs=36.7±3.1; F=1.315; df=3,14; p=0.309). DG volume did not correlate with brain weight (p=0.732) or section thickness (p=0.218).
We present the first evidence in the human DG of more NPCs (Nestin-IR) and more dividing cells (Ki-67-IR) in SSRI- (sertraline, fluoxetine) or TCA (nortriptyline, clomipramine)-treated MDD compared with untreated MDD or controls. The untreated MDD group had 50% fewer dividing cells than controls, but the difference was not statistically significant. The number of NPCs decreased with age. Age was not related to the number of dividing cells. Females had more NPCs than males. Overall, these results are consistent with many findings hitherto only observed in rodents.
In rodents, fluoxetine administration for 15 days does not affect division of quiescent NPCs, but increases the number and symmetric divisions of amplifying NPCs (Encinas et al, 2006). The nestin-IR cells counted in the present study did not show vertical processes crossing the GCL and ending in elaborate arbors in the ML—a characteristic of quiescent (or Type 1) NPCs, at least in rodents—but it is the appearance of the human GFAP-IR cells in this study that was observed. The human GFAP-IR cells in this study are either astrocytes (Figure 3d), which are ubiquitously located in the hippocampal formation (Figure 3a) or have the appearance of quiescent (or Type 1) NPCs (Figure 3c), but they do not stain for nestin. In lower mammals, quiescent NPCs stain both for nestin and GFAP, whereas amplifying (or Type 2) NPCs stain for nestin but not for GFAP, and have the morphology of the human nestin-IR cells detected in this study (Encinas et al, 2006). We counted nestin-IR cells that were in the SGZ of the human DG and that stained for nestin but not GAFP, and that had the morphology of amplifying NPCs. These NPCs were often found in groups of multiple cells associated with the vasculature in the SGZ of the DG, as has been previously described in rats (Palmer et al, 2000, see Figure 2 on page 484). Palmer et al, (2000) suggested this to be a niche, in which neurogenesis and angiogenesis are linked. Isolated nestin-IR cells were also found along the SGZ. In humans, nestin is known to be strongly expressed in newly formed vascular endothelial cells in the adult heart, pancreas, and brain, and its expression decreases after cellular differentiation when nestin is replaced by other intermediate family proteins (see Salehi et al, 2008). Therefore, nestin immunostaining of blood vessels cannot solely be attributed to poor fixation of the tissue or to poor blood clearance. In addition, we used hydrogen peroxide to remove endogenous peroxidase activity, and the same fixed tissue, immunoreacted for NeuN and Ki-67, did not show any vessel immunoreactivity.
Given the morphological characteristics of the cells that stain for nestin, antidepressants in this study seemed to increase amplifying NPCs in human DG, consistent with rodent findings (Encinas et al, 2006). MDD subjects treated with SSRIs and TCAs had more NPCs than untreated MDD or controls. TCAs had a more robust effect than did SSRIs on dividing cell number (Ki-67-IR), and SSRI-treated MDD had a comparable number of dividing cells compared with controls. One previous study used Ki-67 in human tissue to identify dividing cells and did not find an effect of antidepressants on Ki-67-IR cell number in anterior human hippocampal formation (Reif et al, 2006). All the MDD subjects they studied, with the exception of one, were prescribed antidepressant medications. Unfortunately, no toxicology data were available for those subjects (Torrey et al, 2000), and thus, it is not known whether the medications prescribed were actually taken. Fluoxetine, imipramine (Santarelli et al, 2003; Malberg et al, 2000), tranylcypromine, and reboxetine (Malberg et al, 2000) increase DG cell proliferation in mice and rats. Inhibition of neurogenesis blocks some behavioral effects of antidepressants (Santarelli et al, 2003), suggesting that DG cell proliferation may be a mechanism of antidepressant action (Santarelli et al, 2003; Duman, 2004). As BDNF expression increases in the GCL and CA subfields after chronic antidepressant administration (Nibuya et al, 1995; Dias et al, 2003), action of growth factors may play a role in the observed increased neurogenesis with antidepressant treatment. The functional relevance of enhanced neurogenesis in response to antidepressants in man needs to be tested by clinical studies to determine whether the increased cell proliferation is associated with symptoms improvement in MDD. In our postmortem study, a significant proportion of the subjects died by suicide, raising the possibility that antidepressant treatment in the last 6 weeks of life produced cell proliferation that might not have been sufficient or prolonged enough, or even necessary to produce a significant antidepressant effect. Moreover, as neurogenesis is not required for the behavioral effects of environmental enrichment (Meshi et al, 2006), which has antidepressant-like effects, mechanisms other than new cell birth can produce an antidepressant effect.
The average number of dividing cells in untreated MDD was about half found in controls, but the difference did not reach statistical significance, perhaps because either there is no real difference or the modest sample size meant insufficient statistical power. Impaired adult hippocampal neurogenesis has been hypothesized to be a part of the biological and cellular basis of major depression (Duman et al, 2000; Kempermann and Kronenberg, 2003; Coyle and Duman, 2003). Nevertheless, blocking or inhibiting cell proliferation does not induce learned helplessness in rats (Vollmayr et al, 2003), and does not affect anxiety and depression-related behaviors in mice (Santarelli et al, 2003; David et al, 2009), raising doubts about the etiological role of neurogenesis in major depression.
The increase in NPCs and dividing cells in MDDT was localized to the rostral hippocampus, which, in primates (Thierry et al, 2000), is interconnected with the prefrontal cortex, amygdala, and nucleus accumbens. The equivalent structure in rodents (Risold and Swanson, 1996; Moser and Moser, 1998; Sahay and Hen, 2007) is the ventral hippocampus, which has been shown to be involved in anxiety-related behaviors (Sahay and Hen, 2007) and to regulate the neuroendocrine responses to psychological stress (Risold and Swanson, 1996; Nettles et al, 2000). Changes in neurogenesis seem to be subregion-specific depending on the conditions. Adult animals performing spatial learning tasks have the highest levels of neurogenesis in dorsal hippocampus (Snyder et al, 2009). Similar to our findings, chronic administration of an antidepressant (agomelatine) increased cell proliferation and neurogenesis, specifically in the ventral DG of the rat (Banasr et al, 2006). A functional dissociation of the anterior and posterior axis of the hippocampus has been shown by studies of the lesions in rats (Bannerman et al, 2004), and by functional studies in primates (Colombo et al, 1998; Strange et al, 1999; Strange and Dolan, 2001). Moreover, anterograde tracer injection studies showed that there is a topographic organization of the intrinsic connections of the DG, and that it is similar in macaque monkey (Kondo et al, 2008) and rat (Amaral and Witter, 1989). The anatomical specificity of our findings requires further investigation and may link effects on hippocampal function to neuroendocrine responses to stress.
The NPCs in the DG decrease with increasing age. In rodents, neurogenesis decreases with age (Siwak-Tapp et al, 2007; Rao et al, 2006) and the effect of fluoxetine on DG proliferation is age-dependent (Navailles et al, 2008; Couillard-Despres et al, 2009). Age affects antidepressant responsiveness in depression (Keller et al, 1986). Impaired neurogenesis and unavailability of NPCs in older age could be a factor contributing to the poor antidepressant response observed in some elderly individuals. Increasing age was associated with fewer NPCs (Nestin-IR), but age did not affect dividing cells (Ki-67-IR). One possible explanation is that the pool of NPCs decreases with age, whereas the number of Ki-67-IR cells, which labels all dividing cells, including glial and endothelial cells, remains unaltered. Estrogens affect neurogenesis and stimulate progenitor cell proliferation (Saravia et al, 2007; Tanapat et al, 1999), and we found more NPCs in females than in males, but a larger sample size is needed to confirm this observation. An effect of sex on neurogenesis would be of particular relevance to mood disorders, wherein sex differences are pronounced (Oquendo et al, 2007; Kessler et al, 1993).
Ki-67 seems to be a good marker for cell division in the DG, and it co-localizes with BrdU in the nonhuman primates (Gould et al, 1999) and rodents (Kee et al, 2002; Reif et al, 2006; Saravia et al, 2007; Reif et al, 2006). In monkeys, there is a positive correlation between the density of BrdU- and Ki-67-IR cells in the SGZ (Perera et al, 2007). We found more Ki-67-IR cells than nestin-IR cells in every group. It is possible that a proportion of the dividing cells that we observed here are astroglia, microglia, or endothelial cells. Owing to the differences in the timing of the expression of proteins, we cannot identify cells double labeled for Ki-67 and NeuN (Kee et al, 2002). Double labeling with BrdU and NeuN was shown when BrdU was injected antemortem in rodents, and 75–90% of BrdU-IR cells eventually expressed NeuN (Madsen et al, 2000). Moreover, Ki-67, similar to BrdU is also expressed during apoptosis (Kuan et al, 2004). Therefore, Ki-67-IR cell number may not be as good a surrogate of neurogenesis as nestin-IR cell number in the human DG. In keeping with this idea, we observed differences between nestin and Ki-67, both in the response to SSRIs and in the age effect. The fact that no effect of age is observed with Ki-67 could be explained by this marker labeling not only neural precursors, but also all the dividing cells.
The volume of the DG was larger in MDDT compared with untreated MDD and control groups. MDD treated with TCAs or SSRIs showed similar DG volume. We did not find differences in brain weight or post-processing section thickness among groups, suggesting that the observed larger DG volume in MDDT was not attributable to a larger brain or less shrinkage with fixation. Some imaging studies in vivo found smaller hippocampal volume in MDD compared with healthy controls (Sheline et al, 1999; Bremner et al, 2000; McKinnon et al, 2009), but effects of treatment are less studied. The increased DG volume in MDDT may suggest that antidepressant treatment increases total mature granule cell number or volume of the neuropil. The animal model of stress-induced depression is associated with cell death and dendritic shrinkage in the hippocampal formation, which is reversed by antidepressant treatment (McEwen, 1999; Moore et al, 2000). Inescapable foot shock caused loss of spine synapses selectively in CA1, CA3, and DG, reversed by desipramine (McEwen, 1999; Moore et al, 2000). One previous study showed higher density of granule cells and glia in the DG and CA regions, and smaller soma of pyramidal neurons in MDD compared with controls, suggesting that a reduction in neuropil may account for smaller hippocampal volume in MDD (Stockmeier et al, 2004). The observed larger volume of the DG and the higher NPC number in MDDT could be attributable not only to the increased neurogenesis, but also to an increase of cell survival resulting from antidepressants increasing Bcl-2 (Peng et al, 2008; Fricker et al, 2005) and BDNF (Nibuya et al, 1995; Dias et al, 2003), which also regulates cell survival (Sairanen et al, 2005; Benraiss et al, 2001). Whether potential antidepressant effects on neurogenesis or neuropil can change the hippocampus volume and how that affects the course of MDD remains to be determined.
We did not find an effect of PMI or pH on cell number. PMI could affect brain antigenicity (Lewis, 2002; Li et al, 2003), and thus, immunocytochemistry, whereas the effect of pH on antigenicity is not known. We limited the potentially deleterious effects of PMI and pH by using samples with a PMI24 h and pH>6.0.
The primary limitation of this study is the small sample size. Larger samples should be used for replication of the observations and to determine whether the changes in neurogenesis are present in untreated MDD. In addition, comparing subjects who died by suicide with subjects who did not may help determine the effect of stress on neurogenesis in humans. We used every protocol-eligible case at the time of the study and are collecting other cases for future studies. The possibility of a difference in MDD severity between treated and untreated MDDs should also be considered. Treated MDDs may have been more severely ill than untreated MDDs and, therefore, more likely to have sought or been prescribed treatment. On the other hand, the high percentage of suicide cases in the untreated MDD group raises the possibility that this group was untreated because of poor compliance or because of failure to access treatment. Finally, the fact that antidepressant exposure is associated with evidence of more neurogenesis does not mean it is the mechanism of antidepressant action. Future studies must determine whether degree of antidepressant response is linked to increased neurogenesis, and if it is so, would it motivate seeking new treatments that have this property.
Mihran J Bakalian assisted with graph preparation and data management and Jennifer Lau with stereological analysis. This study was supported by PHS grants MH40210, MH62185, MH64168, and MH083862, the American Foundation for Suicide Prevention, the Diane Goldberg Foundation, and the Janssen Fellowship in Translational Neuroscience.
DISCLOSURE/CONFLICT OF INTEREST
The authors Maura Boldrini, Mark D Underwood, Andrew J Dwork, Gorazd B Rosoklija and Victoria Arango declare that, except for income received from their primary employer, no financial support or compensation has been received from any individual or corporate entity over the past 3 years for research or professional service, and there are no personal financial holdings that could be perceived as constituting a potential conflict of interest. Dr Rene' Hen receives compensation as a consultant for BrainCells Inc, PsychoGenics Inc, and AstraZeneca in relation to the generation of novel antidepressants. Dr J John Mann received grants from GlaxoSmithKline and Novartis.