Abstract
Colossal negative magnetoresistance and the associated field-inducedinsulator-to-metal transition—the most characteristic features of magnetic semiconductors—are observed in n-type rare-earth oxides1 and chalcogenides2, p-type manganites3 and n-type4,5 and p-type diluted magnetic semiconductors4,6, as well as in quantum wells of n-type diluted magnetic semiconductors7,8,9. Here, we report on magnetotransport studies of Mn-modulation-doped InAs quantum wells, which reveal an insulator-to-metal transition that is driven by a magnetic field and dependent on bias voltage, with abrupt and hysteretic changes of resistance over several orders of magnitude. These phenomena coexist with the quantized Hall effect in high magnetic fields. We show that the exchange coupling between a hole and the parent Mn acceptor produces a magnetic anisotropy barrier that shifts the spin relaxation time of the bound hole to a 100 s range in compressively strained quantum wells. This bistability of the individual Mn acceptors explains the hysteretic behaviour while opening prospects for information storing and processing. At high bias voltage another bistability, caused by the overheating of electrons10, gives rise to abrupt resistance jumps.
Similar content being viewed by others
Main
Molecular beam epitaxy has been used to grow Mn-modulation-doped compressively strained InAs quantum wells (QWs) embedded in InAlAs/InGaAs host material with an In mole fraction of 75% (for details, see, ref. 11). In this material system Mn substitutes the group III elements (In, Al or Ga), providing a localized spin of S=5/2 and a hole6,12,13, in contrast to II–VI materials, where Mn is an isoelectric impurity4,7,8,9,14. Our transport studies have been accomplished on Mn-modulation-doped InAs QW structures depicted schematically in Fig. 1. In the ‘normal’ sample (Fig. 1b), the Mn doping is done after the InAs/InGaAs layer growth, so that the InAs channel is free of Mn (refs 11, 15). In the ‘inverted’ doped structures (Fig. 1a), the Mn-doped layer is deposited before the growth of the 4-nm-thick InAs channel, which is spaced 7.5 nm from the Mn-doped layer. This leads to a significant concentration of Mn in the InAs channel, estimated by secondary ion mass spectroscopy to be ∼1% of the maximum doping concentration11.
Figure 1 documents remarkable differences in the transport properties at 1.6 K of ‘normal’ and ‘inverted’ doped samples with comparable two-dimensional hole densities of p=4.3×1010 cm−2 and p=4.4×1010 cm−2, respectively. Both types of sample show temperature- and field-dependent resistances typical for modulation-doped structures, including pronounced Shubnikov–de Haas oscillations and quantum Hall plateaus in high fields. This clearly demonstrates the two-dimensional nature of the charge-carrier system and the absence of parallel conductance, a conclusion consistent with a sufficiently low Mn concentration to prevent an insulator-to-metal transition of Mn acceptors in the InAlAs barrier.
According to the experimental findings summarized in Figs 1a, 2 and 3, the ‘inverted’ structure (sample A) shows a dramatic and temperature-dependent increase of resistance in the zero-field range, indicating a strong hole localization under these conditions. The application of a perpendicular magnetic field leads to a colossal negative magnetoresistance, resulting eventually in the quantum Hall insulator transition at , above which the longitudinal resistance decreases with decreasing temperature (Fig. 2). In this high-field range the quantum Hall effect emerges with a well-developed plateau and a corresponding zero-resistance state at low temperatures (Figs 1a and 2).
Because of the extremely high resistance values at low temperatures and magnetic fields, measurements in this region have been made in a two-terminal geometry by applying a constant voltage Ubias to the sample and measuring the current I according to R=Ubias/I. As depicted in Fig. 3a–c, field-induced hole delocalization is accompanied by resistance jumps over several orders of magnitude from above 1011 to below 106 Ω, particularly abrupt for a relatively high bias voltage of Ubias=0.5 V (Fig. 3b,c), where the dependence R(Ubias) is nonlinear at low temperatures (Fig. 3d). At the same time, the resistance shows evidence of a notable hysteretic behaviour when sweeping the magnetic field across zero, that is, the resistance at high and low B is asymmetric with respect to zero field (Fig. 3a–c). As seen, the changes and jumps of the resistance as well as the hysteretic behaviour diminish and finally disappear above ∼0.6 K.
According to results collected in Fig. 3c, hole accumulation by a negative top-gate voltage shifts the system away from the localization boundary to a region where the resistance is smaller and much less temperature dependent. In this regime, (abrupt) resistance changes vanish and hystereses are reduced. Depletion of the channel moves both the magnetic-field value where the resistance drops (Bjump) and the resistance at B>Bjump to higher values.
Importantly, only the perpendicular component of the external magnetic field matters for switching the conductivity state. In the inset to Fig. 3d, Bjump and its sample normal component (Bz) are plotted for several angles between the sample normal (0°) and the field direction. The switching occurs at the same value of Bz for all angles.
We note that, according to our results obtained for samples grown at various Mn fluxes, the relevant quantity influencing the resistance is not the absolute value of the hole density but rather the ratio of the hole density to Mn concentration. This is demonstrated in Fig. 3e, where the relevant data for an ‘inverted’ structure (sample B) with about three times higher Mn density and more than doubled two-dimensional hole density p are shown. The extraordinary magnetoresistance behaviour in this sample is virtually identical to that discussed above.
To interpret these findings we note that, as expected from the theory of the Anderson–Mott localization, when the carrier density is very low the holes are strongly localized by the parent acceptors, independent of the strength of the external magnetic field. If, in turn, the hole density is sufficiently high, in particular greater than the Mn concentration, owing to the combined effect of many-body screening, large kinetic energy and the extended character of wavefunctions corresponding to the upper Hubbard band of the acceptor states, the holes become delocalized, the effect visible in Figs 2 and 3c. Most interesting is the intermediate range of carrier densities, in which the metallic-like conductivity is observed at high magnetic field, but a crossover to the strongly localized regime occurs when the magnetic field decreases. This phenomenon, accounting for the celebrated colossal negative magnetoresistance1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8,9, occurs if the spins do not show long-range ferromagnetic order. As reviewed elsewhere16, in such a case carrier localization is enhanced at low magnetic fields by two effects: (1) spin-disorder scattering on randomly oriented preformed ferromagnetic bubbles brought about by spatial fluctuations in the local density of carrier states near the Anderson–Mott localization, and (2) the decrease of the kinetic energy associated with the carrier redistribution over the two spin subbands. Obviously, the redistribution of holes between the relevant subbands depends strongly on the magnetization direction4,17, and is accompanied by an increasing contribution of light holes to the effective mass of carriers at the Fermi level, which enhances dramatically the field-induced hole delocalization4.
This scenario implies that no spontaneous long-range ferromagnetic order develops in the InAs channel hosting the two-dimensional hole gas (2DHG) in the relevant temperature range. This assumption seems to be true, as for the QWs containing weakly localized holes with the determined effective mass of m*=0.16mo (see Methods) the expected Curie temperature is14 TC<20 mK for the Mn content indicated by the secondary-ion mass spectroscopy measurements, x<10−4.
We now make evident that the high-resistance state, resistance jumps and hysteresis are due to the interplay of two bistabilities. First, following a recent theory10, we address the consequences of bistability due to overheating of the hole gas in the region of high electric fields: owing to a strong temperature dependence of the resistance in weak magnetic fields and at fixed high bias voltage, the system of Mn spins and carriers is either in the overheated (low-resistance) state or in the much less heated high-resistance state. The starting point to show the significance of overheating at non-zero bias voltages is the heat-balance equation,
where FS(T) is the energy loss rate per unit of the QW surface L W, determined by the coupling to acoustic phonons at the hole and substrate temperatures Th(s), respectively10. The right-hand side of equation (1) describes the energy flow from the hole bath to the phonon bath, provided by the Joule heating on the left-hand side. As the effects of the Mn spins on charge transport scale with magnetic susceptibility4,5,9 and the resistance R(T) varies exponentially10 in this regime, (see Fig. 2 inset), we assume
where B5/2(T,B) is the Brillouin function for S=5/2; R0, a and γ are parameters determined by fitting R(T,B=0) to the experimental zero-field resistance.
As shown in Fig. 3f, the model, developed with no further fitting parameters (see Supplementary Information), describes the presence of the resistance jumps, corresponding to the transition from the high-resistance state to the overheated low-resistance state. However, as the potential drop and carrier cooling at the contacts are ignored10, the range of Ubias, T and B where the jumps occur is lower than in the experiment.
Although the above picture reproduces the jumps occurring at different B fields for up- and down-sweeps, the model fails to describe the hysteresis at low B, as the calculated resistance is symmetric with respect to B, in contrast to experiment. Actually, according to data in Fig. 3a and direct magnetization measurements18, the magnetic hystereses persist even for Ubias→0. At the same time, minor loops with magnetic field stopped for different time durations (Fig. 3e) point to a finite relaxation time of several minutes, implying the absence of ferromagnetic order.
We shall now demonstrate that the presence of magnetic hysteresis without long-range magnetic order follows from specific properties of our system. Unlike (Ga,Mn)As (refs 19, 20), compressively strained InAs QWs show a large energy separation between the heavy- and the light-hole subbands, which reduces the admixture of jz=±1/2 states to the wavefunctions of the holes residing in the ground-state subband, jz=±3/2 (with the z-axis perpendicular to the QW plane). Accordingly, the heavy-hole intraband matrix elements of jx and jy are very small, so the system is immune to an in-plane magnetic field, in agreement with the experimental findings shown in Fig. 3d. This also means the appearance of large anisotropy energy barriers for reversing the magnetization direction of the preformed ferromagnetic bubbles. The corresponding relaxation time will grow exponentially with the number of holes contributing to the bubble, resulting in superparamagnetic-like metastabilities.
We expect the presence of a metastable behaviour in weak magnetic fields, even if the holes are bound by individual Mn acceptors. In this limit, the hole spin is coupled to the parent Mn acceptor by a strong antiferromagnetic exchange interaction12, which in the present case assumes the Ising form H=−ɛcjzSz, where ɛc=−(β/3)|ψ(0)|2. Here β=−0.054 eV nm3 is the p–d exchange integral and ψ(0) is the value of the acceptor envelope function at the Mn ion. The relaxation time τs between the two relevant heavy-hole jz=±3/2 states is rather long, presumably in a millisecond to microsecond range21,22. A somewhat shorter relaxation time is expected for Mn spins in the relevant range of concentrations23,24. Under these conditions a direct hole-spin relaxation is possible through a flip-flop, jz→−jz,−Sz→Sz, process. However, the corresponding rate is expected to be rather small, particularly at low temperatures, where it would involve particularly slow transitions between ±5/2 states of the ion in the orbital singlet state. Furthermore, the p–d coupling removes the degeneracy of the Mn spin states, which reduces the role of nuclear magnetic moments in the spin relaxation24,25.
In this situation, spin relaxation of holes towards thermal-equilibrium values of 〈jz〉 and, then, 〈Sz〉, leading to the corresponding values of resistance, proceeds primarily through high-energy intermediate states determined by the magnitude of Sz. The presence of the magnetic anisotropy barrier Ea elongates the relaxation time τs of the hole spin by exp(Ea/kBT). According to the quantitative model presented in Supplementary Information, the barrier vanishes in the magnetic field Bc≈ɛcS/(2κ μB) and attains the value Ea≈ɛcS j at B=0 and T→0, where for the QW in question the Luttinger parameter is κ=7.53 (ref. 26) and ɛc varies between 0 and ∼0.12 meV for the Mn acceptors at the QW edge and centre, respectively.
We find that for ɛc=0.12 meV and τs=1 ms τ reaches 100 s at 0.49 K, the time during which the magnetic field changes by ∼0.4 T in our experiment. This explains the hysteretic behaviour and resistance relaxation in the way seen in millikelvin studies of molecular magnets27,28 and individual rare-earth ions25. In agreement with this evaluation, hystereses disappear above ∼0.6 K. At the same time, the barrier is expected to vanish at Bc=0.34 T, in accordance with the magnitudes of the apparent coercive fields at T→0. When the hole concentration increases, more and more holes occupy states with smaller values of ɛc, meaning that the barrier height, and thus the relaxation time and the width of the hystereses, diminishes, the effect visible in Fig. 3c. Moreover, the model invoking properties of individual acceptors rather than a collective action of many Mn ions explains why the observed behaviour scales with the ratio of the Mn to hole density and not with the Mn concentration.
In conclusion, our results demonstrate that the field-induced delocalization of holes in Mn-modulation-doped III–V QWs proceeds through an intermediate and previously unknown metastable insulator phase. Within our model the jumps result from hole overheating, whereas hysteresis stems from a large magnetic anisotropy of the heavy holes, coupled to the parent Mn acceptors by the strong p–d exchange interaction. The slow spin relaxation of individual bound holes revealed here, appealing from the viewpoint of quantum information processing and storing, should also appear in the case of single Mn acceptors residing in InAs quantum dots29. Interestingly, it may compete with spin quantum tunnelling at sufficiently low temperatures25,27,28, provided that the decoherence rate of the complex is be smaller than the matrix element coupling the Sz=±5/2 states.
Methods
The samples are patterned into standard L-shaped Hall bar geometries (1,000 μm×200 μm and 200 μm×40 μm) employing optical lithography and wet chemical etching. Ohmic contacts are prepared by soldering alloyed InZn and annealed for 60 s at 300 °C. For gate electric-field-dependent measurements some samples are covered with a 130-nm-thick insulating parylene film and a thin Ti/Au top-gate electrode. The measurements are carried out either in a 4He bath cryostat or in a dilution refrigerator. Transport measurements in the low-resistance range (high magnetic fields and/or temperatures above 1.5 K) are made using a standard low-frequency lock-in technique with operation currents of 100 nA. In the high-resistance state (low temperatures and low magnetic fields), a constant voltage Ubias was applied, the current through the sample was monitored, and the two-terminal resistance was calculated as R2-term=Ubias/I. In the low-B, low-T regime, the magnetotransport depends on the sweep rate, which was here set to 0.25 T min−1.
The hole density p of the 2DHG was determined from classical Hall resistance and confirmed by the period of Shubnikov–de Haas oscillations. The characteristic value for the ‘normal’ doped 2DHGs is p=4.3×1011 cm−2. The corresponding values for the ‘inverted’ doped 2DHGs are p=4.4×1011 cm−2 and 11×1011 cm−2, for samples A and B, respectively. The values of the effective mass m*=0.16m0 determined from the cyclotron resonance measurements30 for an ‘inverted’ doped sample is larger than expected for the band-edge in-plane hole mass of the ground-state subband in an infinitely deep InAs QW (ref. 31), but consistent with previous experimental studies32.
References
Shapira, Y., Foner, S., Aggarwal, R. L. & Reed, T. B. EuO. II. Dependence of the insulator–metal transition on magnetic order. Phys. Rev. B 8, 2316–2326 (1973).
von Molnar, S., Briggs, A., Flouquet, J. & Remenyi, G. Electron localization in a magnetic semiconductor: Gd3−xvxS4 . Phys. Rev. Lett. 51, 706–709 (1983).
Dagotto, E., Hotta, T. & Moreo, A. Colossal magnetoresistant materials: The key role of phase separation. Phys. Rep. 344, 1–153 (2001).
Wojtowicz, T., Dietl, T., Sawicki, M., Plesiewicz, W. & Jaroszyński, J. Metal–insulator transition in semimagnetic semiconductors. Phys. Rev. Lett. 56, 2419–2422 (1986).
Terry, I., Penney, T., von Molnár, S. & Becla, P. Low-temperature transport properties of Cd0.91Mn0.09Te:In and evidence of a magnetic hard gap in the density of states. Phys. Rev. Lett. 69, 1800–1803 (1992).
Oiwa, A. et al. Giant negative magnetoresistance of (Ga,Mn)As/GaAs in the vicinity of a metal–insulator transition. Phys. Status Solidi 205, 167–171 (1998).
Smorchkova, I. P., Samarth, N., Kikkawa, J. M. & Awschalom, D. D. Spin transport and localization in a magnetic two-dimensional electron gas. Phys. Rev. Lett. 78, 3571–3574 (1997).
Smorchkova, I. P., Samarth, N., Kikkawa, J. M. & Awschalom, D. D. Giant magnetoresistance and quantum phase transitions in strongly localized magnetic two dimensional electron gases. Phys. Rev. B 58, R4238–R4241 (1998).
Jaroszyński, J. et al. Intermediate phase at the metal–insulator boundary in a magnetically doped two-dimensional electron system. Phys. Rev. B 76, 045322 (2007).
Altshuler, B. L., Kravtsov, V. E., Lerner, I. V. & Aleiner, I. L. Jumps in current–voltage characteristics in disordered films. Phys. Rev. Lett. 102, 176803 (2009).
Wurstbauer, U. et al. Coexistence of ferromagnetism and quantum Hall-effect in Mn modulation-doped two-dimensional hole system. J. Cryst. Growth 311, 2160–2162 (2009).
Ohno, H., Munekata, H., Penney, T., von Molnár, S. & Chang, L.L. Magnetotransport properties of p-type (In,Mn)As diluted magnetic III–V semiconductors. Phys. Rev. Lett. 68, 2664–2667 (1992).
Bhattacharjee, A. K. & Benoit à la Guillaume, C. Model for the Mn acceptor in GaAs. Solid State Commun. 113, 17–21 (2000).
Boukari, H. et al. Light and electric field control of ferromagnetism in magnetic quantum structures. Phys. Rev. Lett. 88, 207204 (2002).
Wurstbauer, U. & Wegscheider, W. Magnetic ordering effects in a Mn-modulation-doped high mobility two-dimensional hole system. Phys. Rev. B 79, 155444 (2009).
Dietl, T. Interplay between carrier localization and magnetism in diluted magnetic and ferromagnetic semiconductors. J. Phys. Soc. Jpn 77, 031005 (2008).
Pappert, K. et al. Magnetization-switched metal–insulator transition in a (Ga,Mn)As tunnel device. Phys. Rev. Lett. 97, 186402 (2006).
Rupprecht, B. et al. Magnetism in a Mn modulation-doped InAs/InGaAs heterostructure with a two-dimensional hole system. J. Appl. Phys. 107, 093711 (2010).
Sheu, B. L. et al. Onset of ferromagnetism in low-doped Ga1−xMnxAs. Phys. Rev. Lett. 99, 227205 (2007).
Myers, R. C. et al. Zero-field optical manipulation of magnetic ions in semiconductors. Nature Mater. 7, 203–208 (2008).
Gerardot, B. D. et al. Optical pumping of a single hole spin in a quantum dot. Nature 451, 441–444 (2007).
Heiss, D. et al. Observation of extremely slow hole spin relaxation in self-assembled quantum dots. Phys. Rev. B 76, 241306(R) (2007).
Dietl, T., Peyla, P., Grieshaber, W. & Merle d’Aubigné, Y. Dynamics of spin organization in diluted magnetic semiconductors. Phys. Rev. Lett. 74, 474–477 (1995).
Goryca, M. et al. Magnetization dynamics down to a zero field in dilute (Cd,Mn)Te quantum wells. Phys. Rev. Lett. 102, 046408 (2009).
Giraud, R., Wernsdorfer, W., Tkachuk, A. M., Mailly, D. & Barbara, B. Nuclear spin driven quantum relaxation in LiY0.998Ho0.002F4 . Phys. Rev. Lett. 87, 057203 (2001).
Sanders, G. D. et al. Electronic states and cyclotron resonance in n-type InMnAs. Phys. Rev. B 68, 165205 (2003).
Friedman, J. R., Sarachik, M. P., Tejada, J. & Ziolo, R. Macroscopic measurement of resonant magnetization tunneling in high-spin molecules. Phys. Rev. Lett. 76, 3830–3833 (1996).
Thomas, L. et al. Macroscopic quantum tunnelling of magnetization in a single crystal of nanomagnets. Nature 383, 145–147 (1996).
Kudelski, A. et al. Optically probing the fine structure of a single Mn atom in an InAs quantum dot. Phys. Rev. Lett. 99, 247209 (2007).
Wurstbauer, U. et al. Anomalous magnetotransport and cyclotron resonance of high mobility magnetic 2DHG in the quantum Hall regime. Physica E 42, 1022–1025 (2010).
Suemune, I. Band-edge hole mass in strained-quantum-well structures. Phys. Rev. B 43, 14099–14106 (1991).
Oettinger, K. et al. Dispersion relation, electron and hole effective masses in InxGa1−xAs single quantum wells. J. Appl. Phys. 79, 1481–1485 (1996).
Acknowledgements
U.W., D.W. and W.W. acknowledge financial support from the Deutsche Forschungsgemeinschaft (DFG) through SFB 689, U.W. also acknowledges support from the Hamburg Cluster of Excellence on Nanospintronics, and T.D. and C.S. acknowledge financial support by the Humboldt Foundation and EC project FunDMS (ERC Advanced Grant).
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Contributions
Project planning, W.W., D.W.; structure growth and processing, U.W., W.W.; experiments and data analysis, U.W., W.W., D.W.; theory, C.Ś., T.D.; writing, T.D., U.W., W.W., D.W., C.Ś.
Corresponding author
Ethics declarations
Competing interests
The authors declare no competing financial interests.
Supplementary information
Supplementary Information
Supplementary Information (PDF 620 kb)
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Wurstbauer, U., Śliwa, C., Weiss, D. et al. Hysteretic magnetoresistance and thermal bistability in a magnetic two-dimensional hole system. Nature Phys 6, 955–959 (2010). https://doi.org/10.1038/nphys1782
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1038/nphys1782
This article is cited by
-
Ferromagnetism from non-magnetic ions: Ag-doped ZnO
Scientific Reports (2019)
-
Origin of ferromagnetism in Cu-doped ZnO
Scientific Reports (2019)