Theories based on the coupling between spin fluctuations and fermionic quasiparticles are among the leading contenders to explain the origin of high-temperature superconductivity, but estimates of the strength of this interaction differ widely1. Here, we analyse the charge- and spin-excitation spectra determined by angle-resolved photoemission and inelastic neutron scattering, respectively, on the same crystals of the high-temperature superconductor YBa2Cu3O6.6. We show that a self-consistent description of both spectra can be obtained by adjusting a single parameter, the spin–fermion coupling constant. In particular, we find a quantitative link between two spectral features that have been established as universal for the cuprates, namely high-energy spin excitations2,3,4,5,6,7 and ‘kinks’ in the fermionic band dispersions along the nodal direction8,9,10,11,12. The superconducting transition temperature computed with this coupling constant exceeds 150 K, demonstrating that spin fluctuations have sufficient strength to mediate high-temperature superconductivity.
Looking back at conventional superconductors, the most convincing demonstration of the electron–phonon interaction as the source of electron pairing was based on the quantitative correspondence between features in the electronic tunnelling conductance and the phonon spectrum measured by inelastic neutron scattering (INS; for reviews, see the articles by Scalapino, McMillan and Rowell in ref. 13). The rigorous comparison of fermionic and bosonic spectra was made possible by the Eliashberg theory, which enabled the tunnelling conductance to be derived from the experimentally determined phonon spectrum. Various difficulties have impeded a similar approach to the origin of high-temperature superconductivity. First, the d-wave pairing state found in these materials implies a strongly momentum-dependent pairing interaction. A more elaborate analysis based on data from momentum-resolved experimental techniques such as INS and angle-resolved photoemission spectroscopy (ARPES) is thus required. These methods, in turn, impose conflicting constraints on the materials. To avoid surface-related problems, most ARPES experiments have been carried out on the electrically neutral BiO cleavage plane in Bi2Sr2Can−1CunO2(n+2)+δ (ref. 8). However, as a consequence of electronic inhomogeneity, this family of materials exhibits broad INS spectra that greatly complicate a quantitative comparison with ARPES data7. Conversely, compounds with sharp spin excitations, including YBa2Cu3O6+x, have generated problematic ARPES spectra due to polar surfaces with charge distributions different from the bulk 8. Finally, an analytically rigorous treatment of the spin-fluctuation-mediated pairing interaction is difficult, because small expansion parameters used in the traditional Eliashberg theory (such as the ratio of Debye and Fermi energies) are missing14. Because of these difficulties, widely different values have been quoted for the spin–fermion coupling constant1.
The analysis of YBa2Cu3O6.6 data reported here was made possible by recent advances on several fronts. First, INS experiments on this material now consistently yield high-quality spin-excitation spectra over a wide energy and momentum range 2,4. Second, recent ARPES experiments on YBa2Cu3O6+x (refs 11, 12) have overcome problems related to polar surfaces and enabled the observation of superconducting gaps and band renormalization effects (‘kinks’) akin to those previously reported in La- and Bi-based cuprates 8. Third, calculations based on the two-dimensional Hubbard model have demonstrated Fermi surfaces, single-particle spectral weights, antiferromagnetic spin correlations and dx2−y2 pairing correlations in qualitative agreement with experimental measurements15,16,17. Numerically accurate solutions of this model can thus serve as a valuable guideline for a treatment of the spin-fluctuation interaction in the cuprates. This is the approach we take here.
Recent quantum Monte Carlo calculations of the two-dimensional Hubbard model within the dynamical cluster approximation17 for a realistic value of the bare U/t=8 and different doping levels ranging from underdoping to optimal doping have shown that the effective pairing interaction can be parameterized in terms of the numerically computed spin susceptibility χ(Q,Ω) in the form
where is a renormalized coupling strength, and that this interaction generates reasonable values for the superconducting transition temperature Tc. Here, we follow a similar strategy, but use χ(Q,Ω) determined by INS, on high-quality detwinned YBa2Cu3O6.6 single crystals described previously4. To serve as input for the numerical calculations, we have used an analytic form of Imχ that provides an excellent description of the INS data (see Supplementary Information). Figure 1 shows a plot of this form in absolute units. In the superconducting state, the spin excitations exhibit the well-known ‘hour glass’ dispersion, with a neck at the wave vector Q=(π,π) characteristic of antiferromagnetism in the copper oxide planes and the ‘resonance’ energy Ω=38.5 meV. (We use a notation in which the lattice parameter a and the reduced Planck constant ℏ are set to unity. Q=(π,π) corresponds to (0.5,0.5) in reciprocal lattice units, r.l.u.) The lower branch of the hour glass seems to be influenced by materials-specific details. For instance, recent INS work on La2−xSrxCuO4 indicates two characteristic energies5,6, rather than the single resonance found in YBa2Cu3O6+x. The upper branch of high-energy spin excitations, on the other hand, is common to all copper oxides thus far investigated by INS in this energy range2,3,4,5,6,7. Moreover, whereas the resonance in YBa2Cu3O6.6 disappears above Tc (ref. 4), the intensity of the spin excitations above Ω∼50 meV is not noticeably affected by the superconducting transition and only decreases slowly on further heating2,4.
We extract the second parameter in equation (1), the coupling strength , from a combined analysis of the INS data parameterized in this way and the fermionic band dispersions observed by ARPES on the same crystals (see the Methods section). As noted before, bonding and antibonding combinations of electronic states on the two Cu–O layers in the YBa2Cu3O6.6 unit cell give rise to two distinct Fermi surfaces (Fig. 2). The most prominent signature of many-body effects in the ARPES data, namely the ‘kink’ along the nodal direction (cut 1 in Fig. 3), is highlighted in Fig. 4, where the bonding band is singled out by a proper choice of excitation energy.
We now proceed to a quantitative analysis of the renormalization of the nodal band dispersion by spin fluctuations. Before describing the results, we take a look at the kinematics of spin-fluctuation scattering near the nodal points, where complications from the superconducting gap are absent. The spin fluctuations shown in Fig. 1 scatter electrons between bonding and antibonding bands, as indicated by factors in the INS (refs 2, 4) and ARPES (refs 11, 12) cross-sections. (Weak high-energy excitations corresponding to intraband scattering18 are neglected here.) An analysis of our numerical results below shows that the scattering probability for electrons near the nodal points is greatly enhanced when energy-momentum conservation enables interband scattering into opposite nodal regions (green arrow in Fig. 2). The INS data (green line in Fig. 1) reveal that this condition is satisfied by spin fluctuations of energy ∼80 meV on the upper, universal, weakly temperature-dependent branch of the hour glass. At this characteristic energy in the temperature range studied here, we therefore expect a weakly temperature-dependent anomaly in the band dispersion, as experimentally observed.
A self-consistent numerical procedure with a single adjustable parameter, the coupling strength , was developed to quantitatively assess the influence of the spin-fluctuation interaction on the spectral function determined by ARPES (see the Methods section). Figure 4 shows that an excellent description of the nodal band dispersion over a wide energy range is obtained with , in rough agreement with values found in earlier calculations based on phenomenological models of the spin susceptibility1. In particular, both theoretical and experimental results show deviations from linear behaviour (‘kink’) for ω≥80 meV (arrow in Fig. 4). The corresponding mass renormalization at the nodal point is Re ZA=3.7.
Figure 3 shows a comparison of the calculated spectral weight to the ARPES intensity for all three cuts in Fig. 2. It is evident that the calculation yields an excellent description of the ARPES data set over the entire Brillouin zone without further fitting parameters. In particular, the low-intensity region (‘dip’) below the renormalized band in cut 3 can be understood as a consequence of coupling to the magnetic resonance at the neck of the hour-glass dispersion. As noted before1,19, the resonance wave vector (red lines in Figs 1 and 2) connects antinodal regions in bonding and antibonding bands, and the resonance and gap energies add up to the dip energy ∼65 meV. The only noticeable difference between the numerical and experimental data is the width of the momentum distribution curves, which is substantially larger in the ARPES data, presumably at least in part owing to residual surface inhomogeneities20.
Encouraged by the self-consistent description of INS and ARPES data, we proceed to a calculation of the critical temperature of the d-wave superconducting state arising from the exchange of spin fluctuations. A recent quantum Monte Carlo calculation of the two-dimensional Hubbard model within the dynamical cluster approximation has shown that a good estimate of Tc can be obtained by using the same effective interaction as in the calculation of the self-energy17. For the set of parameters found above, the linearized gap equations (see the Methods section) yield the d-wave eigenvalue λd=1.39 in the normal state (T=70 K), corresponding to a transition temperature Tc=174 K. In principle, the INS and ARPES spectra would now have to be remeasured at this higher temperature, the calculation repeated, and so on, until self-consistency is achieved. However, as the spectral weight rearrangement of spin excitations in this temperature range is largely confined to low excitation energies, our estimates for and Tc are not expected to change substantially (see the Methods section). In this context, it is instructive to compare the eigenvalue at T=70 K with the one obtained from the INS spectrum at 5 K that includes the ‘resonance’, λd=1.49. The enhanced eigenvalue implies that the redistribution of spectral weight of the spin excitations below Tc leads to an increase of the effective pairing strength. This lends support to an interpretation of the magnetic resonance and associated antinodal dip in terms of a superconductivity-induced feedback effect on the spin-fluctuation spectrum1. It is also consistent with the large 2Δ0/kBTc ratio.
In summary, we have shown that data from two momentum-resolved experimental probes of a cuprate superconductor can be related in a quantitative fashion, in close analogy to the traditional analysis of the electron–phonon interaction in conventional superconductors. Our analysis is in overall agreement with conclusions drawn from previous work based on phenomenological spin-excitation spectra and/or data from probes without momentum resolution1,19,21,22,23, and it resolves some problems that appeared in the context of these studies. In particular, models that attribute the nodal kink in ARPES either directly to the magnetic resonance24 or to incoherent scattering processes from a node into gapped states at the antinode19 generally predict that the kink is strongly modified by the onset of superconductivity, whereas the experiments indicate at most a weak effect at Tc (ref. 10). The node-to-node interband scattering process mediated by weakly temperature-dependent, universal, incommensurate spin excitations we have identified provides a straightforward explanation of this observation. As the incommensurate spin excitations persist into the optimally doped5,7 and overdoped6 regimes, it also explains the persistence of both the kink and superconductivity at high doping, where feedback effects related to the magnetic resonance are progressively reduced22. There is thus no need to invoke phonon scattering at this level9. Although some contribution of phonons to the nodal kink cannot be ruled out25,26, recent work has shown that it is hard to obtain a quantitative description of the kink on the basis of the electron–phonon interaction alone19,27,28. An estimation of the influence of the electron–phonon interaction on our results can be found in Supplementary Information.
It was previously shown29 that the change in the magnetic exchange energy between the normal and superconducting states is more than enough to account for the cuprate superconducting condensation energy. However, the crucial question of whether the exchange of magnetic spin fluctuations actually has the strength to give rise to high-Tc pairing, was not answered. Here, we have shown that this interaction can generate d-wave superconducting states with transition temperatures comparable to the maximum Tc observed in the cuprates. In any given material, especially underdoped cuprates such as YBa2Cu3O6.6, a variety of effects not considered in our analysis can reduce the actual Tc, including vertex corrections of the spin-fluctuation interaction14, phase fluctuations of the order parameter, competition with other types of order and pair breaking by phonons and impurities. It is also possible that phonons9,27,28 or higher-energy excitations30 contribute to the pairing interaction. However, our analysis indicates that the exchange of spin excitations already directly observed by INS is a major factor driving the high-temperature superconducting state in the cuprates.
The ARPES measurements were carried out on the same YBa2Cu3O6.6 crystals used for the INS experiment, thus avoiding systematic uncertainties invariably associated with measurements on different materials. The details of the ARPES experiments have been described elsewhere11,12. Usually, YBa2Cu3O6+x single crystals cleave between the Ba–O and Cu–O chain layers, resulting in an effective overdoping of the Cu–O layer closest to the surface 11,12. A recent comprehensive study has revealed, however, that in some cases the ARPES spectra are dominated by a signal from the nominally doped Cu–O plane12. Here, we present data taken on a particular spot on the surface after one such successful cleave (Figs 2,3). The strong many-body renormalization of the band structure typical for underdoped cuprates (Fig. 4) as well as the anisotropic superconducting gap (cuts 2 and 3 in Fig. 3) in the ARPES spectra demonstrates that contributions from the overdoped surface-related component are negligible. The superconducting component we observe corresponds to the nominal doping level, which we estimate from the size of the gap and the temperature evolution of the coherence peaks, which disappear above the bulk superconducting transition temperature12.
where Δk is the superconducting gap, which we assume to be of the d-wave form Δk=Δ0(coskx−cosky)/2 with Δ0=30 meV, and is the renormalized band structure. The unrenormalized band dispersions εkA,B were derived from tight-binding fits to the ARPES Fermi surface in combination with extra information from band-structure calculations (see Supplementary Information). We have found that the results of our calculations are quite robust against modifications of εkA,B (see Supplementary Information). Finally, ω ZA,B(k,ω)=ω−(1/2)(ΣA,B(k,ω)−ΣA,B*(k,−ω))+i Γel is the mass renormalization function and ξA,B(k,ω)=(1/2)(ΣA,B(k,ω)+ΣA,B*(k,−ω)) is the energy shift function. Apart from an elastic scattering rate Γel∼30 meV, which accounts for impurity scattering, the mass renormalization function is determined by the imaginary part of the electron self-energy ΣA,B, which can be written as
Here, denotes a sum of the in-plane momenta over the full Brillouin zone, n and f are the Bose and Fermi functions, respectively, and Veff is the spin-fluctuation interaction equation (1). The real parts of ΣA,B that enter into equation (2) are obtained by Kramers–Kronig transformations. Note that the self-energy in the antibonding band is determined by the interaction with the bonding band and vice versa.
Together with equation (1), this defines a self-consistent system of equations with a single adjustable parameter, the coupling strength . Starting with non-interacting values for the Green’s functions, these equations were solved iteratively until convergence was achieved. The renormalized band dispersion and spectral weight, f(ω) Im G(k,ω), can then be compared with ARPES data.
The linearized gap equations
were solved for the same set of parameters. Note that the INS data used for the calculations were taken at T=5 and 70 K, whereas the ARPES data were taken at 30 K. As the changes in the superconducting gap and INS spectrum between 5 and 30 K are negligible, we use the 5 K INS results along with the 30 K ARPES data to determine the coupling constant . As T is raised further, the superconducting gap decreases, and there is a shift of Imχ to lower frequencies. However, we expect that is unchanged for the range of temperatures of interest, because it is determined by weakly T-dependent high-energy processes.
For discussions of the influence of a high-energy cutoff in χ(Q,Ω) and of a normal-state pseudogap on the results of the numerical calculations, see Supplementary Information.
Eschrig, M. The effect of collective spin-1 excitations on electronic spectra in high-Tc superconductors. Adv. Phys. 55, 47–183 (2006).
Hayden, S. M., Mook, H. A., Dai, P., Perring, T. G. & Dogan, F. The structure of the high-energy spin excitations in a high-transition-temperature superconductor. Nature 429, 531–534 (2004).
Tranquada, J. M. et al. Quantum magnetic excitations from stripes in copper oxide superconductors. Nature 429, 534–538 (2004).
Hinkov, V. et al. Spin dynamics in the pseudogap state of a high-temperature superconductor. Nature Phys. 3, 780–785 (2007).
Vignolle, B. et al. Two energy scales in the spin excitations of the high-temperature superconductor La2−xSrxCuO4 . Nature Phys. 3, 163–167 (2007).
Lipscombe, O. J., Hayden, S. M., Vignolle, B., McMorrow, D. F. & Perring, T. G. Persistence of high-frequency spin fluctuations in overdoped superconducting La2−xSrxCuO4 (x=0.22). Phys. Rev. Lett. 99, 067002 (2007).
Fauqué, B. et al. Dispersion of the odd magnetic resonant mode in nearly-optimally doped Bi2Sr2CaCu2O8+δ . Phys. Rev. B 76, 214512 (2007).
Damascelli, A., Hussain, Z. & Shen, Z.-X. Angle-resolved photoemission studies of the cuprate superconductors. Rev. Mod. Phys. 75, 473–541 (2003).
Lanzara, A. et al. Evidence for ubiquitous strong electron–phonon coupling in high-temperature superconductors. Nature 412, 510–514 (2001).
Kordyuk, A. A. et al. Constituents of the quasiparticle spectrum along the nodal direction of high-Tc cuprates. Phys. Rev. Lett. 97, 017002 (2006).
Borisenko, S. V. et al. Kinks, nodal bilayer splitting and interband scattering in YBa2Cu3O6+x . Phys. Rev. Lett. 96, 117004 (2006).
Zabolotnyy, V. B. et al. Momentum and temperature dependence of renormalization effects in the high-temperature superconductor YBa2Cu3O7−δ . Phys. Rev. B 76, 064519 (2007).
Parks, R. D. (ed.) Superconductivity Vol. 1 (Dekker, 1969).
Huang, Z. B., Hanke, W., Arrigoni, E. & Chubukov, A. V. Renormalization of the electron-spin-fluctuation interaction in the t–t′–U Hubbard model. Phys. Rev. B 74, 184508 (2006).
Dahm, T. & Tewordt, L. Physical quantities in nearly antiferromagnetic and superconducting states of the two-dimensional Hubbard model and comparison with cuprate superconductors. Phys. Rev. B 52, 1297–1308 (1995).
Aichhorn, M., Arrigoni, E., Potthoff, M. & Hanke, W. Phase separation and competition of superconductivity and magnetism in the two-dimensional Hubbard model: From strong to weak coupling. Phys. Rev. B 76, 224509 (2007).
Maier, T. A., Macridin, A., Jarrell, M. & Scalapino, D. J. Systematic analysis of a spin-susceptibility representation of the pairing interaction in the two-dimensional Hubbard model. Phys. Rev. B 76, 144516 (2007).
Pailhès, S. et al. Doping dependence of bilayer resonant spin excitations in (Y,Ca)Ba2Cu3O6+x . Phys. Rev. Lett. 96, 257001 (2006).
Chubukov, A. V. & Norman, M. R. Dispersion anomalies in cuprate superconductors. Phys. Rev. B 70, 174505 (2004).
Graser, S., Hirschfeld, P. J. & Scalapino, D. J. Local quasiparticle lifetimes in a d-wave superconductor. Phys. Rev. B 77, 184504 (2008).
Carbotte, J. P., Schachinger, E. & Basov, D. N. Coupling strength of charge carriers to spin fluctuations in high-temperature superconductors. Nature 401, 354–356 (1999).
Hwang, J., Timusk, T. & Gu, G. D. High-transition-temperature superconductivity in the absence of the magnetic-resonance mode. Nature 427, 714–717 (2004).
Valla, T. Electronic interactions in strongly correlated systems: What is the ‘glue’ for high temperature superconductivity? Proc. SPIE 5932, 593203 (2005).
Manske, D., Eremin, I. & Bennemann, K. H. Renormalization of the elementary excitations in hole- and electron-doped cuprates due to spin fluctuations. Phys. Rev. B 67, 134520 (2003).
Cuk, T. et al. Coupling of the B1g phonon to the antinodal electronic states of Bi2Sr2Ca0.92Y0.08Cu2O8+δ . Phys. Rev. Lett. 93, 117003 (2004).
Reznik, D., Sangiovanni, G., Gunnarson, O. & Devereaux, T. P. Photoemission kinks and phonons in cuprates. Nature 455, E6–E7 (2008).
Giustino, F., Cohen, M. L. & Louie, S. G. Small phonon contribution to the photoemission kink in the copper oxide superconductors. Nature 452, 975–978 (2008).
Heid, R., Bohnen, K.-P., Zeyher, R. & Manske, D. Momentum dependence of the electron–phonon coupling and self-energy effects in superconducting YBa2Cu3O7 within the local density approximation. Phys. Rev. Lett. 100, 137001 (2008).
Woo, H. et al. Magnetic energy change available to superconducting condensation in optimally doped YBa2Cu3O6.95 . Nature Phys. 2, 600–604 (2006).
Pasupathy, A. N. et al. Electronic origin of the inhomogeneous pairing interaction in the high-Tc superconductor Bi2Sr2CaCu2O8+δ . Science 320, 196–201 (2008).
This project is part of the Forschergruppe FOR538 of the German Research Foundation. D.J.S. acknowledges the Center for Nanophase Material Sciences at Oak Ridge National Laboratory, US Department of Energy. We thank P. Bourges, A. Ivanov and D. Inosov for discussions.
About this article
Cite this article
Dahm, T., Hinkov, V., Borisenko, S. et al. Strength of the spin-fluctuation-mediated pairing interaction in a high-temperature superconductor. Nature Phys 5, 217–221 (2009). https://doi.org/10.1038/nphys1180
This article is cited by
Coupled electronic and magnetic excitations in the cuprates and their role in the superconducting transition
Communications Physics (2022)
Monte Carlo study of the pseudogap and superconductivity emerging from quantum magnetic fluctuations
Nature Communications (2022)
Nature Materials (2022)
Strong band renormalization and emergent ferromagnetism induced by electron-antiferromagnetic-magnon coupling
Nature Communications (2022)
Nature Reviews Methods Primers (2022)