Seeking feedback, whatever the setting, can help you plan for the next stage of your career.
If you're like most people, waiting for a performance review is akin to sitting in reception at the dentist's. You hope your appointment isn't going to result in any pain, but you expect the worst.
Perhaps some scientists aspire to academia in order to avoid such meddlesome interactions, but two UK lab heads say that feedback is a valuable part of the scientific process. The trick, they say, is making these routine check-ups a two-way process. They advise keeping the meetings relatively informal and focused on progress, rather than deficiency.
Kay Davies is head of the University of Oxford's anatomy department, honorary director of the Medical Research Council's Functional Genetics Unit and co-director of the Oxford Centre for Gene Function. She makes appraisals an annual event for the scientists she directs, and says they keep her researchers focused on specific objectives. Yearly meetings help them to see what sort of research opportunities exist and how to pick up the necessary skills and resources, she adds.
A different strategy is used by Steve Jackson, who heads a lab at the Gurdon Institute of Cancer and Developmental Biology in Cambridge. He conducts informal exit interviews when students and postdocs end their stint. These casual conversations give the young scientists career goals and provide Jackson with valuable feedback about his lab's direction. He has also used the chats to find employees for KuDOS Pharmaceuticals, a biotechnology company that he created in 1997.
Labs all over the world differ in their policy towards such interactions. Some provide few opportunities for appraisals or feedback, others rely on casual conversations, still others apply a more formal framework. But in science, as in dentistry, regular appointments — whether initiated by you or your supervisor — can improve your long-term health.
Author information
Author notes
Naturejobs editor
- Paul Smaglik
Related links
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Smaglik, P. They'll see you now. Nature 436, 143 (2005). https://doi.org/10.1038/nj7047-143a
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1038/nj7047-143a