Marine biology

Twilight budget in balance

Large quantities of carbon are captured from the atmosphere and converted into organic matter in the sunlit waters of the surface ocean. A significant fraction of this material sinks down from the surface waters into the twilight zone, that dimly lit stretch of the ocean that extends from the base of the photosynthetic zone down to 1,000 metres depth. Resolving the fate of the material that enters this zone is a key challenge in carbon cycle research.

The organic matter that enters the twilight zone serves as a source of food for the zooplankton — multicellular marine organisms that populate much of the world ocean — and microbes that reside in these waters. However, the amount of carbon consumed by these organisms exceeds that supplied by sinking particles, according to a number of observational studies. This apparent mismatch between supply and demand has proved tricky to resolve.

Sarah Giering and colleagues balance the carbon budget in the twilight zone at the Porcupine Abyssal Plain site in the northeastern Atlantic Ocean (Nature; 2014). They constructed a comprehensive carbon budget for the these waters — using oceanographic measurements, satellite data and a food web model — and show that the net input of organic carbon into the twilight zone matches that lost through the respiration of organic matter, within the uncertainty range of the observations. They suggest that the reconciliation of carbon supply and demand in these waters can be attributed to improved estimates of carbon inputs, and the consideration of community respiration as opposed to carbon demand.


Giering et al. find that the majority of the carbon that enters the twilight zone floats down in the form of large, fast-sinking particles, ideal fodder for zooplankton. However, using a simple model, they show that more than 30% of the organic matter fragmented and consumed by these creatures is ejected into the surrounding water column in the form of slow-sinking particles, ripe for colonization by microbes. Indeed, microbial respiration accounts for most of the carbon respired and ultimately lost from these waters.

Marine biota mediate the fate of the carbon that enters the twilight waters of the world ocean, with consequences for ocean carbon storage and release. Although much remains to be learnt about carbon dynamics in these waters, it seems clear that ecological interactions play an important role in shaping twilight zone carbon consumption and release.


Rights and permissions

Reprints and Permissions

About this article

Cite this article

Armstrong, A. Twilight budget in balance. Nature Geosci 7, 255 (2014).

Download citation


Nature Briefing

Sign up for the Nature Briefing newsletter — what matters in science, free to your inbox daily.

Get the most important science stories of the day, free in your inbox. Sign up for Nature Briefing