Mechanical degradation and resultant capacity fade in high-capacity electrode materials critically hinder their use in high-performance rechargeable batteries. Despite tremendous efforts devoted to the study of the electro–chemo–mechanical behaviours of high-capacity electrode materials, their fracture properties and mechanisms remain largely unknown. Here we report a nanomechanical study on the damage tolerance of electrochemically lithiated silicon. Our in situ transmission electron microscopy experiments reveal a striking contrast of brittle fracture in pristine silicon versus ductile tensile deformation in fully lithiated silicon. Quantitative fracture toughness measurements by nanoindentation show a rapid brittle-to-ductile transition of fracture as the lithium-to-silicon molar ratio is increased to above 1.5. Molecular dynamics simulations elucidate the mechanistic underpinnings of the brittle-to-ductile transition governed by atomic bonding and lithiation-induced toughening. Our results reveal the high damage tolerance in amorphous lithium-rich silicon alloys and have important implications for the development of durable rechargeable batteries.
Energy storage with high performance and low cost is critical for applications in consumer electronics, zero-emission electric vehicles and stationary power management1,2. Lithium-ion batteries (LIBs) are the widely used energy storage systems due to their superior performance3,4,5. The operation of a LIB involves repeated insertion and extraction of lithium (Li) ions in active battery electrodes, which are often accompanied with considerable volume changes and stress generation6,7,8,9,10,11,12. In the development of next-generation LIBs, mechanical degradation in high-capacity electrode materials arises as a bottleneck. Such high-capacity electrode materials usually experience large volume changes (for example, up to about 280% for silicon (Si)), leading to high mechanical stresses and fracture of electrodes during electrochemical cycling13,14,15,16,17,18,19,20,21,22. Fracture causes the loss of active materials and yields more surface areas for solid electrolyte interphase (SEI) growth, both of which contribute to the fast capacity fade of LIBs.
To mitigate the mechanical degradation in LIBs, it is essential to quantitatively understand the electrochemically-induced mechanical responses and fundamental mechanical properties of high-capacity electrode materials. The past decade has witnessed a marked increase in studies on the mechanical behaviours of high-capacity electrode materials6,7,8,9,10,11,12,13,14,15,16,17,18,19,20,21,22. Focusing on the promise of Si as the next-generation anode material, significant progress has been made in the experimental measurement and modelling of lithiation/delithiation-induced stresses11,23, Li concentration-dependent modulus and hardness24,25,26, time-dependent creep26,27 and strain-rate sensitivities28. However, there is still a critical lack of fundamental understanding on the fracture-related properties29,30, which ultimately dictate the resistance of the electrode material to mechanical degradation and failure.
Here we report an integrated experimental and computational investigation on the damage tolerance of lithiated Si. We performed in situ nanomechanical bending test on a partially lithiated Si nanowire inside a transmission electron microscope (TEM). The result reveals a direct contrast between the low fracture resistance in the brittle core of pristine Si and the high damage tolerance in the ductile shell of fully lithiated Si. We conducted systematic measurements of the fracture toughness of lithiated Si thin films with nanoindentation. The results show a rapid brittle-to-ductile transition of fracture in LixSi alloys with increasing Li concentration. We also performed continuum finite element (FE) and molecular dynamics (MD) simulations to interpret these experimental findings, thereby gaining mechanistic insights into the fracture mechanisms of lithiated Si. These results have important implications for the development of durable Si-based anodes for next-generation LIBs.
In situ electrochemical and bending tests of Si nanowires
Figure 1a,b show the schematic illustrations of in situ electrochemical lithiation and fracture testing of a single Si nanowire inside a TEM. The nano-sized electrochemical cell31 consisted of a Si nanowire on Si substrate as the working electrode and a Li probe as the counter electrode; the native Li2O layer on Li surface served as a solid electrolyte. The <111>-oriented single crystal Si nanowire had an initial diameter of about 142 nm. To start the lithiation, the Li probe was brought into contact with the free end of the Si nanowire and then a bias voltage of −2 V was applied between the working and the counter electrodes. Because Li diffusion/reaction on the surface of Si is much faster than that in the bulk14, Li ions first migrated preferably along the free surface of the Si nanowire and then diffused towards its centre. In the bulk of the Si nanowire, lithiation proceeded in a core-shell mode, yielding a core of crystalline Si (c-Si) and a shell of amorphous LixSi (a-LixSi, x≈3.75). The core-shell interface was atomically sharp and oriented parallel to the longitudinal axis of the nanowire12. Across this interface, an abrupt change of Li concentration occurred, resulting in high compressive stresses near the core-shell interface (that is, behind the lithiation front)32. The lithiation-induced compression slowed down and eventually stalled the movement of the interface. At the end of the lithiation process, the diameter of the unlithiated c-Si core was 85 nm; the thicknesses of the a-Li3.75Si shell and the layer of lithiated surface oxide (LiySiOz) were 47 and 17 nm, respectively.
After the lithiation experiment, the partially lithiated Si nanowire was subjected to in situ compression by the Li probe, as shown in Fig. 1c and Supplementary Movie 1. As the compressive load was increased, the nanowire buckled and subsequently bent, resulting in a single sharp kink in the nanowire. Figure 1d shows a zoom-in TEM image near the kinked region. It is seen that brittle fracture occurred in the unlithiated c-Si core, evidenced by the nearly flat fracture surfaces. The fracture strength of the c-Si core was determined to be about 7.7 GPa, which is consistent with the literature data on the strength of pristine <111>-oriented Si nanowires with similar sizes (see Supplementary Fig. 1 and related text). In contrast, the a-Li3.75Si shell underwent considerably large tensile deformation accompanied by pronounced lateral thinning, without observable damages such as cracking or shear banding. The lithiated surface oxide layer (LiySiOz) remained coherent to the a-Li3.75Si shell and thus underwent similar straining as the latter. Figure 1e shows the result of a continuum FE simulation of large local deformation near the kinked region (see the modelling details in Supplementary Fig. 4 and Supplementary Methods). In the FE simulation, we assumed that the brittle fracture of the c-Si core was a much faster process than the elastic–plastic deformation in the a-Li3.75Si shell, such that the latter occurred after the crack in the c-Si core had been fully formed. As a result, the large tensile deformation in the a-Li3.75Si shell was primarily accommodated by the sliding at the core-shell interface, yielding a large crack opening in the c-Si core near the core-shell interface. The deformation morphology from the FE simulation (Fig. 1e) was in close agreement with that in the TEM image (Fig. 1d). The most striking observation from Fig. 1d,e is the large tensile (plastic) strain of ∼47% occurring in the a-Li3.75Si shell, with a concurrent large lateral contraction (that is, thinning) of ∼45%. Therefore, the in situ TEM experiment and FE simulation demonstrate that the amorphous Li-rich Si alloy (a-Li3.75Si) exhibits extraordinary damage tolerance, while c-Si is brittle as expected.
Fracture toughness measurements of lithiated Si
To quantitatively study the damage tolerance of electrochemically lithiated Si at different Li concentrations, we employed an in-house developed nanoindentation system (Supplementary Fig. 2) to characterize the fracture toughness of a-LixSi, a property that describes the ability of a material to resist crack propagation33. The Si electrodes for nanoindentation tests were fabricated in a thin-film form by sputter deposition of 325 nm thick amorphous Si (a-Si) films onto flat titanium (Ti) substrates. Each Si electrode was lithiated in a custom-fabricated Teflon electrochemical cell, as illustrated in Fig. 2a, with a Li foil as the reference electrode. During the electrochemical testing of each a-Si electrode, a Michelson interferometer was used to measure the curvature change of the substrate from which the lithiation-induced biaxial film stress was deduced using Stoney’s equation34.
Figure 2b,c show the electrochemical profiles and corresponding film stresses measured for five a-Si thin-film electrodes. The Li concentrations in these electrodes were controlled by galvanostatical lithiation at 20 μΑ cm−2 to different cutoff potentials. The sloping voltage profiles below 0.5 V versus Li/Li+ suggest the formation of a single-phase a-LixSi during lithiation. As shown in Fig. 2c, all thin-film electrodes exhibited an initial compressive stress of about 200 MPa that resulted from the sputtering process. The compressive stress in the thin-film electrodes increased to 500–800 MPa at the end of lithiation, due to the substrate constraint on lithiation-induced volume expansion. This large residual compressive stress may impede crack growth during nanoindentation testing and thus affect the measurement of fracture toughness. To reduce the influence of those residual stresses, we first lithiated the a-Si electrode to a targeted Li concentration and then delithiated it to 0.25–0.3 V above the lithiation cutoff potential. During the delithiation, a small fraction of Li was extracted from the electrodes, resulting in small volume shrinkages so as to reverse the film stress from compression to tension. The tensile stress in the thin film was small, but found to be beneficial for promoting the nanoindentation-induced cracking and enabling the evaluation of fracture toughness of a-LixSi. The effects of SEI formation on electrode cracking were estimated to be negligibly small35 and therefore were not considered in the fracture toughness measurement.
To measure the facture toughness, the a-LixSi thin-film electrodes were indented with a cube-corner indenter tip in an argon-filled glove box. After unloading of the indenter, residual indents and surrounding areas were imaged using a scanning electron microscope (SEM). Figure 3a–c show the nanoindentation results for a partially lithiated Si electrode with low Li concentration (Li0.87Si) under different indentation loads, which exhibit distinct cracking behaviours including (i) no cracking, (ii) indent corner cracking and (iii) massive cracking. Specifically, under a small load of 3.92 mN, residual plastic deformation at the permanent indent was observed without obvious cracking (Fig. 3a). As the load was increased to 9.8 mN, three radial cracks emanated from the sharp corners of the indent (Fig. 3b). A further increase in the indentation load to 29.4 mN resulted in massive cracking around the indent (Fig. 3c). Similar cracking behaviours were observed for low Li concentrations from x=0 to 1.09. However, as the Li:Si ratio was increased to above 1.56, no cracking was observed from indents for a wide range of indentation loads up to 93 mN, as shown in Fig. 3d–f. Critical indentation loads separating the above three regimes of cracking behaviours are plotted in Fig. 3g. The two critical load curves, respectively, represent the upper load limit above which massive cracking occurred and the lower limit below which no crack was induced. The upper load limit curve varies substantially with the Li concentration when x exceeds 0.6, indicating that the fracture toughness of lithiated Si starts to depend sensitively on the Li concentration. Similar drastic change of the lower load limit curve can be inferred as x varies from 1.09 to 1.56 (as indicated by the dashed line), since no cracking was observed for indentation loads up to 93 mN when x=1.56. Therefore, our results indicate that a brittle-to-ductile transition of fracture occurs when the Li composition falls in the range of x=1.09–1.56. For x≤1.09, the indentation loads in between the two limits induced well-developed radial cracks. We used these loads to evaluate the fracture toughness of a-LixSi with the Morris nanoindentation model (see Supplementary Fig. 3 and Supplementary Methods for model details).
Figure 3h shows the measured fracture toughness, ϰIc, as a function of Li concentration. Also shown in this figure is the fracture energy, defined as Γ=ϰIc2/E, where E is Young’s modulus of lithiated Si taken from the experimental measurement25. Figure 3h clearly reveals that the fracture toughness of a-LixSi alloys depends sensitively on the Li concentration. For example, the fracture toughness and fracture energy of unlithiated a-Si are and 2.85±0.15 J m−2, respectively. These low values are typical of brittle materials with little fracture resistance33. As the Li concentration increases, the fracture resistance of lithiated Si first decreases slightly, indicating lithiation-induced embrittlement. This trend is in qualitative agreement with the recent ab initio calculations36 that show a small amount of Li insertion into Si substantially weakens Si–Si bonds, and hence reduces the surface energy of the material. However, upon further lithiation beyond x=0.31, both the measured fracture toughness and fracture energy increase substantially with increasing Li concentration, reaching and 8.54±0.72 J m−2 for Li1.09Si, respectively. Since a further increase in Li concentration gave rise to large residual plastic deformation at and around indents without cracking (for example, Fig. 3d–f), we take the Li:Si ratio of x≈1.5 as the characteristic composition above which the brittle-to-ductile transition of fracture occurs in a-LixSi alloys.
Atomistic modelling of fracture in lithiated Si
To understand the experimentally measured brittle-to-ductile transition phenomenon, we performed MD simulations of deformation and fracture in a-LixSi alloys using the reactive force field23 (see Methods section). In Fig. 4, we contrast the MD results by showing the brittle crack growth in Li-lean a-Li0.5Si versus the ductile crack blunting in Li-rich a-Li2.5Si. In both cases, MD simulations were performed for samples containing a sharp-edge pre-crack and subjected to a far-field tensile load. Figure 4a presents a sequence of MD snapshots showing brittle crack growth in a-Li0.5Si. In this case, the local tensile deformation near the crack tip is primarily accommodated by the stretching and breaking of Si–Si bonds, as shown in Fig. 4b. Due to the high fraction of strong covalent Si bonds, the bond alteration events are mostly discrete and disruptive, lacking bond reformation. A small damage zone forms near the crack tip, and it contains a high fraction of dangling bonds and atomic-sized voids. As the crack extends through such a damage zone, the crack faces become atomically rough, but the crack tip remains sharp, as seen from Fig. 4a. In contrast, Fig. 4c presents a sequence of MD snapshots showing the crack blunting in a-Li2.5Si. In this case, the local tensile deformation near the crack tip is accommodated by the stretching, rotation, breaking and frequent reformation of atomic bonds, as shown in Fig. 4d. Several Li atoms often collectively participate in a bond-switching process, so that the amorphous structure near the crack tip remains nearly homogenous without significant damage. As a result, the crack tip becomes considerably blunt without apparent crack growth, as seen from Fig. 4c. In addition, we compare the stress-strain curves during tensile straining of the above two pre-cracked samples in Fig. 4e; the fast brittle fracture in a-Li0.5Si is manifested as a sharp load drop, while the ductile crack blunting in a-Li2.5Si is characterized by a gradual load decrease, indicative of extensive plastic deformation near the crack tip. The above MD results of brittle versus ductile behaviours in Li-lean and Li-rich a-LixSi alloys are consistent with the trend in nanoindentation measurements. Hence, our MD study reveals a plausible atomistic mechanism of brittle-to-ductile transition in a-LixSi alloys, namely, the decreasing fraction of strong covalent Si bonding and the concomitant increasing fraction of delocalized metallic Li bonding give rise to an alteration of the dominant atomic-level processes of deformation and fracture with increasing Li concentration.
The above experimental and modelling results underscore the notion of the high damage tolerance of amorphous Li-rich Si alloys and thus have important implications for the design of durable Si-based anodes for next-generation LIBs. Recently, lithiation experiments have been conducted with a-Si nanoparticles with a wide range of diameters up to 870 nm18, as well as with a-Si pillars of a few microns in diameter37. In those experiments, no cracking and fracture were observed in lithiated a-Si electrodes. However, it has been shown that the surface layers of lithiated a-Si particles and wires should have undergone large hoop tensile deformation resulting from the two-phase lithiation and associated volume expansion at curved phase boundaries17,18. Given the large hoop tension and accordingly high driving force of fracture, the lack of observed cracking37,38 implies that the fully lithiated a-Si should be mechanically robust. In this work, our in situ TEM and nanoindentation experiments collectively provide direct evidence for the high damage tolerance (that is, high tensile ductility and high fracture toughness) of Li-rich Si alloys, which is the essential mechanistic information for the design of durable Si-based electrodes. In addition, the quantitative fracture characteristics obtained in our work constitute an important input for optimizing the microstructures and lithiation/delithiation windows of Si-based LIBs. Incidentally, the mechanical robustness of lithiated a-Si is in contrast with the commonly observed surface cracking and fracture after lithiation in large c-Si nanostructures16,19. The ease of fracture in lithiated c-Si has been attributed to a crystallographic effect on the lithiation anisotropy, resulting in inhomogeneous phases and deformation near the interface between anisotropically lithiated domains39. For a-Si electrodes, there is no such lithiation anisotropy. As a result, both the lithiated phases and deformation processes in a-Si particles and wires are more homogenous than those in c-Si counterparts, which contribute to the high mechanical robustness of the former.
To conclude, we have integrated experiments and modelling to reveal the high damage tolerance of electrochemically lithiated Si electrodes. The in situ TEM experiment on a partially lithiated Si nanowire showed a striking contrast of the brittle fracture in the unlithiated Si core versus the ductile tensile deformation in the lithiated Si shell. The nanoindentation testing of amorphous lithiated Si alloys indicated a drastic increase of fracture toughness as the Li to Si ratio was increased to above 1.5. Our atomistic simulations elucidated the mechanistic underpinnings of the brittle-to-ductile transition in terms of atomic bonding and lithiation-induced toughening. The quantitative characterization and mechanistic understanding of high damage tolerance of Li-rich Si alloys represent a critical step towards the rational design of durable Si-based electrodes for next-generation LIBs. Broadly, our integrated experimental and modelling approach can be applied to the mechanical characterization of a wide range of electrochemically active materials for energy storage applications.
Thin-film electrode fabrication and electrochemical cell assembly
Single-side polished titanium (Ti) plates with a thickness of 0.5 mm were used as substrates for fabrication of thin-film electrodes, and they also served as current collectors for electrochemical measurements. Before a Ti substrate was placed inside the deposition system (Denton Discovery RF/DC Sputterer), it was etched with 5% HCl to remove the surface Ti oxide. A 26 nm Ti thin film was first sputtered onto the polished side of the Ti substrate, followed by the deposition of a 325 nm thick Si film. The Ti interlayer, serving as an adhesion-promoting layer, was prepared by DC sputtering of a Ti target (3" diameter disc, 99.995% Ti, Kurt J. Lesker Co., Livermore, CA) at a power of 53 W and a pressure of 6.29 mTorr of argon. The Si film was prepared by RF magnetron sputtering of an Si target (3" diameter disc, 99.995% Si, Kurt J. Lesker Co., Livermore, CA, USA) at a power of 200 W and a pressure of 5 mTorr of argon. Previous studies have shown that Si thin films formed under these sputtering conditions are amorphous40.
After Si was deposited on the polished side of the Ti substrate, a thin layer of polydimethylsiloxane (PDMS) was coated on the unpolished side of the Ti substrate to prevent the formation of an SEI layer on the Ti surface. The Si film-coated Ti electrode was then assembled into a custom-fabricated Teflon electrochemical cell with a glass window (Fig. 2a) inside an argon-filled glove box that was maintained at <0.1 ppm of O2 and H2O. A Li foil was used as the reference/counter electrode, and 1 M of lithium hexafluoro-phosphate (LiPF6) in 1:1:1 (weight %) ratio of ethylene carbonate (EC) to dimethyl carbonate (DMC) to diethyl carbonate (DEC) was used as the electrolyte.
Electrochemical and in situ film stress measurement
The electrochemical measurement was conducted with a battery tester (UBA 5, Vencon Technologies, Ontario, Canada). Five Si electrode samples were first lithiated galvanostatically at 20 μΑ cm−2 with pre-determined cutoff potentials. The lithiation was followed by delithation at the same current density until potentials of 0.2–0.3 V versus Li/Li+ above the cutoff potentials for lithiation were reached. Subsequently, delithiation was continued potentiostatically until the current was reduced below 0.2 μΑ cm−2. The Si electrodes were then removed from the cell inside the glove box and thoroughly cleaned by rinsing them with DMC. Stress evolution in the Si films during lithiation and delithiation was measured by monitoring the substrate curvature with a Michelson interferometer. The biaxial film stress was deduced from the measured curvature using Stoney’s equation34.
The fracture toughness of lithiated Si electrodes was measured by an in-house developed nanoindentation system inside an argon-filled glove box (Supplementary Fig. 2). Peak loads, ranging from 1 to 93 mN at constant loading and unloading rates of 500 μN s−1, were used during nanoindentation tests. Ten indents at each load were made for each Si electrode sample and spaced 100 μm apart. The indented Si electrodes were imaged by a Zeiss Ultra60 FE-SEM (Carl Zeiss Microscopy, LLC, North America, Peabody, MA) operated at an accelerating voltage of 5 kV. During the sample transfer from the glove box to the SEM chamber, the lithiated Si electrodes were coated with a thin layer of anhydrous DMC to avoid the reaction of lithiated Si with ambient oxygen and moisture.
Molecular dynamics simulations
Molecular dynamics simulations were performed using the large-scale atomic molecular massively parallel simulator (LAMMPS). Atomic interactions were modelled by a reactive force field developed for Li–Si alloys23. The a-LixSi samples were prepared from melting-and-quenching simulations with a quench rate of 2 × 1012 K s−1. In these simulations, the initial structures were created by randomly inserting Li atoms into a crystalline Si lattice. After quenching at zero stresses, the a-LixSi samples had the final dimensions of ∼16 × 10 × 1.5 nm. A sharp crack with a length of ∼3 nm was created in each sample. The pre-cracked samples were then loaded in tension with a strain rate of 5 × 108 s−1, while the system temperature was maintained at 5 K. Periodic boundary conditions were applied along the loading and the thickness directions. A plane-strain condition was imposed by fixing the thickness of the simulation box. The time step in all the molecular dynamics simulations was 1 fs.
How to cite this article: Wang, X. et al. High damage tolerance of electrochemically lithiated silicon. Nat. Commun. 6:8417 doi: 10.1038/ncomms9417 (2015).
We acknowledge the support of the following grants: NSF-CMMI-1300458 (S.X.), NSF-CMMI-1300805 (H.B.C.), NSF-CMMI-1100205 (T.Z.), NSF-DMR-1410936 (T.Z.), and NSF-CMMI-08010934 through the University of Pittsburgh and Sandia National Lab (S.X.M.). We thank Sergiy Krylyuk and Albert V. Davydov at NIST for providing Si nanowires used for in situ TEM experiments. This work was performed, in part, at the Center for Integrated Nanotechnologies, a US Department of Energy, Office of Basic Energy Sciences user facility. Sandia National Laboratories is a multiprogram laboratory managed and operated by Sandia Corporation, a wholly owned subsidiary of Lockheed Martin Corporation, for the US Department of Energy’s National Nuclear Security Administration under Contract DE-AC04-94AL85000.
The buckling and bending test of a partially lithiated Si nanowire subjected to compressive loading.
About this article
Experimental Mechanics (2018)