Skip to main content

Thank you for visiting nature.com. You are using a browser version with limited support for CSS. To obtain the best experience, we recommend you use a more up to date browser (or turn off compatibility mode in Internet Explorer). In the meantime, to ensure continued support, we are displaying the site without styles and JavaScript.

Giant dielectric and magnetoelectric responses in insulating nanogranular films at room temperature

Abstract

The electric and magnetic properties of matter are of great interest for materials science and their use in electronic applications. Large dielectric and magnetoelectric responses of materials at room temperature are a great advantage for electromagnetic device applications. Here we present a study of FeCo-MgF nanogranular films exhibiting giant dielectric and magnetoelectric responses at room temperature; with dielectric constant ε′=490 and magnetoelectric response Δε′/ε0=3%. In these films, Fe-Co alloy-based nanometer-sized magnetic granules are dispersed in a Mg-fluoride-based insulator matrix. Insulating nanogranular films are a new class of multifunctional materials. The giant responses are caused by spin-dependent charge oscillation between magnetic granules via quantum-mechanical tunnelling. A possible application of such insulating nanogranular materials with giant response is in the construction of a tunable device, in which impedance components such as capacitance and inductance are tunable at room temperature.

Introduction

Response of matter to electric and magnetic fields is of great interest in physics1,2,3 and its applications4,5. A number of candidates have been reported as magnetoelectric systems such as oxides6,7 and quantum dots8,9. However, the magnetic field response of these systems is too small at room temperature from the viewpoint of applications. This is because the magnetic transition temperature of reported oxide materials possessing the magnetoelectric effect is much lower than room temperature or the effect operates only at low temperatures.

Insulating nanogranular films consist of magnetic nanometer-sized metal granules and an insulator matrix, and exhibit various functional properties depending on the composition ratio of the metal granules and the insulator matrix in the film10,11. They have significant practical advantages of easy fabrication and thermal stability12 and have been applied in magnetic sensors13,14.

Magnetoelectric coupling shows great promise for achieving tunable devices15,16,17,18,19 where the impedance in a specific frequency range can be changed according to the input signal. Recently, such devices need to operate in a wide frequency band that includes both digital and analogue broadcasts. Up to now, such tunable devices have been prepared by combining two or more materials of different properties. However, if a magnetoelectric material with multifunctional properties can be utilized, the device structures may become simplified and an expansion in further applications of the devices can be expected.

In this work, we have studied the dielectric properties of insulating nanogranular materials, reporting specifically on the magnetoelectric effects in FeCo-MgF nanogranular films. Fe-Co alloy has the largest magnetization, and good interface between Fe-Co nanogranules and MgF2 matrix is obtained14. These properties result in the giant dielectric and magnetoelectric response in FeCo-MgF nanogranular films at room temperature. The experimental results are well explained by spin-dependent charge oscillation caused by quantum mechanical tunnelling between magnetic granules.

Results

Structure of the FeCo-MgF nanogranular films

Figure 1a illustrates a nanogranular structure, which consists of nanometer-sized magnetic granules dispersed in an insulator matrix. Figure 1b shows a high-resolution transmission electron microscope image obtained from Fe9Co8Mg26F57 (Fe+Co=17 at.%) thin film, which is one of the samples produced in this study. In this micrograph, many small dark and deformed circles with diameters ranging from about 2 to 4 nm are observed. In addition, a bright network-like pattern covering the whole area is identified. The dark deformed circles are Fe-Co alloy-based granules, and the small bright section indicates the Mg-fluoride-based matrix.

Figure 1: Structure and electric polarization of a nanogranular film.
figure 1

(a) A schematic of a nanogranular film with nanometer-sized granules dispersed in an insulator matrix. The right-side figure in a represents a schematic of the electric potential profile of two granules in an ac electric field that generate oscillating transition of an electric charge carrier (electron, hole) between them via quantum-mechanical tunnelling through the thin insulating barrier. The oscillating transition of the charge-carrier with spin depends on the relative orientation of the magnetization of the granules. This spin-dependent charge oscillation is the origin of the dielectric and magnetoelectric (magneto-dielectric) responses of the nanogranular films. (b) A high-resolution transmission electron microscope image (in plain) of Fe9Co8Mg26F57 (Fe+Co=17 at.%) film of a typical sample (scale bar, 10 nm).

Dielectric properties and magneto-dielectric effects

Figure 2a shows the dependence of the real part of the dielectric constant at 1 kHz (ε1k) on the composition ratio of the Fe+Co content in FeCo-MgF films. ε1k of the Mg-F film produced in this experiment is about 5.6. This value is in agreement with the value of reference bulk MgF2 (ref. 20). On the other hand, the value of ε1k of the films increases with the Fe+Co content, and attains 490 at 30 at.%. The frequency dependence of the real part of the dielectric constant (ε′) of the FeCo films at 14, 17, 21 and 29 at.% is presented in Fig. 2b. The ε′ increases with increasing Fe+Co over the whole frequency range, and exhibits a sharp decrease with increasing frequency. As discussed later, this dielectric dispersion may be caused by dielectric relaxation characterized by the relaxation time τr. The dielectric relaxation frequency fr=1/τr, at which ε′ sharply decreases, is shifted to the higher frequency side with increasing Fe+Co. As seen in Fig. 2, , FeCo-MgF nanogranular films have a giant dielectric constant of around 490, and fr shifts to the higher frequency side with increasing Fe+Co. Films having giant dielectric constant and high fr have high potentials for applications.

Figure 2: Dielectric properties of the FeCo-MgF nanogranular films.
figure 2

(a) Dielectric constant at 1 kHz (ε′1k) measured using an LCR meter vs the composition ratio of Fe+Co in FeCo-MgF films. The value of ε′1k is 5.6 at 0 at.%, and increases with increasing Fe+Co content, attaining 490 at 30 at.%. (b) Dielectric constant ε′ vs frequency f of FeCo-MgF films for Fe+Co=14, 17, 21, and 29 at.% measured in the frequency range of 1 kHz–1 MHz. The red dots represent the experimental results, and the blue solid lines represent the theoretical results obtained from calculations based on the spin-dependent dielectric relaxation model calculations (see formula (15)).

Figure 3: Magnetic property of FeCo-MgF nanogranular films.
figure 3

Magnetization curves of FeCo-MgF films for Fe+Co=14, 17 and 21 at.% measured up to an applied magnetic field of 1,200 kA m−1.

Figure 3 shows the magnetization curves of the Fe+Co films at 14, 17 and 21 at.%. It is understood that the films are in the superparamagnetic state, that is, their magnetization (M) versus magnetic field (H) curves follow the Langevin function and the coercivity is nearly zero21,22,23. This behaviour indicates that the nanogranules are uniformly dispersed. They possess magnetization at 0.1 T above room temperature.

Figure 4 represents the change in the dielectric constant (Δε′) of Fe9Co8Mg26F57 (Fe+Co=17 at.%) film at applied magnetic field 800 kA m−1. The dielectric constant increases by the application of magnetic field over the whole frequency range, indicating a positive magnetoelectric effect. The ratio of Δε′ and the dielectric constant in zero magnetic field ε0ε′/ε0) is plotted as a function of H for Fe9Co8Mg26F57 film at 10 kHz in Fig. 5. This electromagnetic effect has been observed at room temperature.

Figure 4: Magnetoelectric response of Fe9Co8Mg26F57 nanogranular film.
figure 4

Change in the dielectric constant Δε′ due to the application of magnetic field H=800 kA m−1 versus frequency f of the applied electric field for the Fe9Co8Mg26F57 (Fe+Co=17 at.%) film. The dielectric change Δε′=εHε0 is the difference between the dielectric constants at magnetic field H and zero field H=0. The red dots represent the experimental results, and the blue solid lines represent the theoretical result obtained from calculations based on the spin-dependent dielectric-relaxation model (see equations (2) and (15)), where the tunnelling spin polarization31 PT=0.44 and the magnetization normalized by the saturation magnetization M/Ms=0.62 are used.

Figure 5: Magnetization dependence of the magnetoelectric effect of Fe9Co8Mg26F57 nanogranular film.
figure 5

Magnetodielectric ratio Δε′/ε0 versus applied magnetic field H in the Fe9Co8Mg26F57 (Fe+Co=17at.%) film. The solid blue curve represents the values of (M/M1,200)2 as a function of magnetic field H, where the magnetization curve in Fig. 3 is used and M1,200 is the magnetization at the maximum measured magnetic field of 1,200 kA m−1. The DC resistivity of the film is beyond 1010 μΩm.

Mechanism of dielectric and magnetoelectric responses

Dielectric and magnetoelectric responses in insulating nanogranular films may be explained by transition of the thermally activated electric charges between neighbouring granules through an insulating barrier via quantum-mechanical tunnelling24,25. The transition rate depends on the charging energy, the separation between granules, the tunnel barrier height and the relative orientation of magnetization of the granules. When thermally activated charge carriers (electrons, holes) in a granule are subject to an ac applied electric field, the electric potentials of neighbouring granules become time-varying as schematically shown in the left side of Fig. 1a. This potential oscillation gives rise to tunnelling of charge carrier back and forth through the intervening thin insulator barrier. Therefore, the oscillation of charging states between granules in the ac electric field induces electric polarization. This is the origin of the dielectric response of nanogranular films.

By incorporating the spin-dependent tunnelling process24,25 between a pair of granules into the Debye–Fröhlich model26 and taking into account a broad distribution of dielectric relaxation around the characteristic relaxation given by the spin-dependent tunnelling rate (1/2τr), which is proportional to 1+PT2(M/Ms)2 (refs 22, 25), where PT is the tunnelling spin polarization and Ms is saturation magnetization, we obtain the complex dielectric constant of granular films

where Δε is the dielectric strength, ε is the high-frequency dielectric constant and β is an exponent (0<β≤1) representing a measure of the distribution of relaxation time27. The dielectric constant ε′ is the real part of equation (1), and is analysed in Fig. 2b by setting β=0.75 and ε=10 and adjusting parameters Δε and τr. The fitting values are Δε=185 and τr=1.2 × 10−4 s, Δε=195 and τr=1.65 × 10−5 s, Δε=270 and τr=5.5 × 10−7 s and Δε=430 and τr=2.2 × 10−8 s for Fe+Co of 14, 17, 21 and 29 at.%, respectively. We find excellent agreement between the experimental and theoretical data over the entire frequency range as seen in Fig. 2b. The strong decrease in τr with increasing Fe+Co content is consistent with the reduction of tunnel barrier thickness, which enhances the tunnelling rate 1/(2τr) and explains the strong dependence of the dielectric response on the Fe+Co content shown in Fig. 2a. In addition, Δε increases with the Fe+Co content because of the increase in the number density of granule pairs (see equation (11) in Method section for details). Furthermore, using 1/τr=(1/τr0)[1+PT2(M/Ms)2], we can reproduce both frequency and magnetic-field dependences of the magnetoelectric effect Δε′/ε0 as shown in Figs 4 and 5. These results further support our model for the magnetoelectric effect in nanogranular films.

These insulating nanogranular FeCo-MgF films are a new class of multifunctional materials. These films have giant dielectric and magnetoelectric responses at room temperature with dielectric constant ε′=490 and magnetoelectric response Δε′/ε0=3%. Our results suggest that the granular films can be used at higher frequencies. Our preliminary experimental results show that our films work in the digital broadcast frequency range (0.3–3 GHz) as well. Although tunable devices combining two or more materials with different properties have been proposed, these materials may be replaced with these newly discovered insulating nanogranular materials, thus producing more compact and functional devices.

Methods

Preparation of the thin film samples

The thin films investigated were prepared by a tandem deposition method28 using a conventional rf-sputtering apparatus. The sputter deposition was performed on a 50 × 50 mm2 glass (Corning eagle 2000) substrate in an argon atmosphere with 1.3 Pa pressure during deposition, using a Fe60Co40 alloy disk target with 76 mm diameter and a MgF2 powder target compacted in the form of a disc with 76 mm in diameter. To obtain a uniformly composed granular state, the substrate holder was rotated so that it alternately faced the Fe60Co40 alloy target and the MgF2 target. The speed of rotation was kept constant at 11.54 r.p.m. for each preparation.

Composition and structural analysis

The composition ratio of Fe+Co (granule) and Mg+F (matrix) was controlled by changing the radio frequency (RF) power applied to each target. The chemical composition of Fe, Co, Mg and F in the thin films was analysed by wavelength dispersion spectroscopy. For the structural analysis, transmission electron microscopy was performed on selected several thin films.

Measurements of the dielectric and magnetoelectric responses

The dielectric properties were measured by inductance, capacitance and resistance (LCR) meter with measurement range 1 kHz–1 MHz and 0–800 kA m−1 in magnetic field. The magnetization curves were measured by an alternating gradient magnetometer. All the measurements reported in this paper were carried out at room temperature.

Derivation of the dielectric constant

We derive the dielectric constant of a granular system composed of ferromagnetic granules of nanometer size in an insulating matrix. In a granular system, the transport is governed by thermally activated charge carriers that move from granule to neighbouring granule by tunnelling through an insulating barrier. Depending on the separation and tunnel barrier height, a charge carrier activated in one granule may tunnel to another. A simple model for a pair of granules 1 and 2 and the double potential well is schematically shown in Fig. 6a,b. In the absence of applied ac electric field, the transition rate between the two granules is determined by the charging energies and the tunnelling process25,29:

Figure 6: Derivation of the dielectric constant.
figure 6

(a) Ferromagnetic metal granules 1 and 2 embedded in insulating matrix. (b) A double potential wells illustrating an electric polarization due to tunneling of charge (electron) through the barrier from one well to the other back and forth under the ac electric field E(t). (c) The real parts of the dielectric constant are calculated from the equation (1) for three different values of β. The lines show the results of fitting values of β=0.6, 0.75, and 0.9, (Δε=185 (εs=195, ε=10), τr=1.65 × 10−5 s), and the circles represent the experimental results.

where s12 is the distance between the granular surfaces along the line connecting their centres, m=M/Ms is the magnetization of the granular system normalized to the saturation magnetization, κ is the decay rate of the electron wave function in the insulating barrier region of the matrix, kB is the Boltzmann constant, T is the temperature and E12 is the thermal activation energy involved in the tunnelling process29:

where Eci~e2/(ε0di) (i=1, 2) is the charging energy of granule i, ε0 is the dielectric constant and di is the diameter of granule i.

When an ac electric field E(t) is applied, the chemical-potential shifts Δμ1(t) and Δμ2(t) of granule 1 and 2 become time-varying according to

where d12 is the distance between the centres of the two granules: d12=(d1/2)+(d2/2)+s12. The time-varying electrochemical potentials give rise to the oscillation of the charging state back and forth between the granules via tunnelling of an electron. Based on the Debye–Fröhlich model26,30, the rate equations for the occupation probabilities, P1(t) and P2(t), of the thermally activated electron in granules 1 and 2 are given by

where Wij are the transition probabilities:

Taking the difference of (5-a) and (5-b),

It is highly probable that a charging state is activated in either granule 1 or granule 2, for which P1+P2 is independent of time and may be given by

For the applied electric field E(t)=E(ω)eiωt, the electric polarization of the two granules is given by

from which we can calculate the electric polarization α(ω)=p(ω)/E(ω) and therefore the dielectric constant ε(ω)=ε+4πα(ω) is obtained as

with

where Δε=εsε is the dielectric strength, εs=ε(0) and ε=ε(∞) are the static and high-frequency dielectric constants, respectively, and np is the number density of granule pairs, which is roughly equal to the granules’ density.

The Debye–Fröhlich equation (10) above is derived from a particular pair of granules with a single relaxation time τr. In the granular system, there are so many pairs of granules with different size and separation that the relaxation time for different granular pairs is distributed over a wide range, in which case the electric polarization may be written as

where f(τ) is the relaxation time distribution satisfying . In the case of the Debye–Fröhlich equation, the distribution function is taken as f(τ)=δ((τ/τr)−1).

An empirical model for dielectric relaxations that takes into account the effect of a distribution of relaxation times is the equation (1) (ref. 27), where τr depends on the magnetization as

The distribution function of the Cole–Cole equation is given by27

which shows that the distribution becomes broader with decreasing β value.

The real part ε′(ω) of the dielectric constant in equation (1) is

Figure 6c shows the real part of the dielectric constant as a function of frequency of applied ac electric field for β=0.6, 0.75 and 0.9, Δε=185 (εs=195, ε=10) and τr=1.65 × 10−5 s. It is clearly seen that β=0.75 provides an excellent fit to the experimental results of Fe9Co8Mg26F57 granular film.

Additional information

How to cite this article: Kobayashi, N. et al. Giant dielectric and magnetoelectric responses in insulating nanogranular films at room temperature. Nat. Commun. 5:4417 doi: 10.1038/ncomms5417 (2014).

References

  1. Dzyaloshinskii, I. E. On the magneto-electrical effect in antiferromagnets. Sov. Phys. JETP 10, 628–629 (1960).

    MathSciNet  Google Scholar 

  2. Astrov, D. N. The magnetoelectric effect in antiferromagnetics. Sov. Phys. JETP 11, 708–709 (1960).

    Google Scholar 

  3. Kimura, T. et al. Magnetic control of ferroelectric polarization. Nature 426, 55–58 (2003).

    ADS  CAS  Article  Google Scholar 

  4. Fiebing, M. Revival of the magnetoelectric effect. J. Phys. D. Appl. Phys 38, R123–R125 (2005).

    ADS  Article  Google Scholar 

  5. Eerenstein, W., Mathur, N. D. & Scott, J. F. Multiferroic and magnetoelectric materials. Nature 442, 759–765 (2006).

    ADS  CAS  Article  Google Scholar 

  6. Sawamura, S., Wakiya, N., Sakamoto, N., Shinozaki, K. & Suzuki, H. Modification of ferroelectric properties of BaTiO3-CoFe2O4 multiferroic composite thin film by application of magnetic field. Jpn J. Appl. Phys. 47, 7603–7606 (2008).

    ADS  CAS  Article  Google Scholar 

  7. Kimura, T., Sekio, Y., Nakamura, H., Siegrist, T. & Ramirez, A. P. Cupric oxide as an induced-multiferroic with high-T c . Nat. Mater. 7, 291–294 (2008).

    ADS  CAS  Article  Google Scholar 

  8. Austing, D. G. et al. Ellipsoidal deformation of vertical quantum dots. Phys. Rev. B 60, 11514–11523 (1999).

    ADS  CAS  Article  Google Scholar 

  9. Abolfath, R. M., Petukov, A. G. & Zutic, I. Piezomagnetic quantum dot. Phys. Rev. Lett. 101, 207202 (2008).

    ADS  Article  Google Scholar 

  10. Fujimori, H., Ohnuma, S., Kobayashi, N. & Masumoto, T. Spintronics in metal-insulator nanogranular magnetic thin films. J. Magn. Magn. Mater. 304, 32–35 (2006).

    ADS  CAS  Article  Google Scholar 

  11. Ohnuma, S., Kobayashi, N., Fujimori, H. & Masumoto, T. Metal-insulator type nano-granular magnetic thin films. J. Phys. Conf. Series 191, 012020 (2009).

    Article  Google Scholar 

  12. Kobayashi, N., Ohnuma, S., Masumoto, T. & Fujimori, H. Effects of substrate temperature and heat treatment on GMR properties of Co-RE-O nano-granular films. Mater Trans. JIM 39, 679–683 (1998).

    CAS  Article  Google Scholar 

  13. Kobayashi, N. et al. Enhancement of low-field magnetoresistive response of tunnel-type magnetoresistance in metal-nonmetal granular thin films. J. Magn. Magn. Mater. 188, 30–34 (1998).

    ADS  CAS  Article  Google Scholar 

  14. Kobayashi, N., Ohnuma, S., Masumoto, T. & Fujimori, H. (Fe-Co)-(Mg-fluoride) insulating nanogranular system with enhanced tunnel-type magnetoresistance. J. Appl. Phys. 90, 4159–4162 (2001).

    ADS  CAS  Article  Google Scholar 

  15. Okada, K., Sugawara, H. & Masu, K. Reconfigurable RF COMS circuit using on-chip MEMS variable inductor. IEICE Tech. Rep. 105, 45–50 (2005).

    Google Scholar 

  16. Huang, Z. Theoretical modeling on the magnetization by electric field through product property. J. Appl. Phys. 100, 114104 (2006).

    ADS  Article  Google Scholar 

  17. Kuanr, B. K. et al. Microstrip-tunable band-pass filter using ferrite (nanoparticles) coupled lines. IEEE Trans. Magn. 45, 4226–4229 (2009).

    ADS  CAS  Article  Google Scholar 

  18. Bakkiali, M. E., Chan Wai, Po, F., De Foucauld, F., Viala, B. & Michel, J. P. Design of a RF matching network based on a new tunable inductor concept. Microelectronics J. 42, 233–238 (2011).

    Article  Google Scholar 

  19. Sonehara, M., Kamada, H., Iida, S. & Sato, T. Characterization of tunable magnetic sensor usuing bias magnetic field of a hard magnetic film magnetized by pulsed-magnetic field. IEEE Trans. Magn. 49, 3854–3857 (2013).

    ADS  CAS  Article  Google Scholar 

  20. Fontanella, J., Andeen, C. & Schuele, D. Low-frequency dielectric constans of α-quartz, sapphire, MgF2, and MgO. J. Appl. Phys. 45, 2852–2854 (1974).

    ADS  CAS  Article  Google Scholar 

  21. Fujimori, H. & Mitani, S. Tunnel-type GMR in metal-nonmetal granular alloy thin films. Mater. Sci. Eng. B 31, 219–223 (1995).

    Article  Google Scholar 

  22. Mitani, S., Fujimori, H. & Ohnuma, S. Spin-dependent tunneling phenomena in insulating granular systems. J. Magn. Magn. Mater. 165, 141–148 (1997).

    ADS  CAS  Article  Google Scholar 

  23. Honda, S., Okada, T. & Nawate, M. Tunneling giant magnetoresistance in heterogeneous Fe-SiO2 granular films. Phys. Rev. B 56, 566–573 (1997).

    Article  Google Scholar 

  24. Maekawa, S. & Gäfvert, U. Electron tunneling between ferromagnetic films. IEEE Trans. Mag. 18, 707–708 (1982).

    ADS  Article  Google Scholar 

  25. Inoue, J. & Maekawa, S. Theory of tunneling magnetoresistance in granular magnetic films. Phys. Rev. B 53, R11927–R11929 (1996).

    ADS  CAS  Article  Google Scholar 

  26. Fröhlich., H. Theory of Dielectrics 2nd edn Clarendon Press (1958).

  27. Cole, K. S. & Cole, R. H. Dispersion and absorption in dielectrics. J. Chem. Phys. 9, 341–351 (1941).

    ADS  CAS  Article  Google Scholar 

  28. Kobayashi, N., Ohnuma, S., Masumoto, T. & Fujimori, H. Tunnel-type magnetoresistance in metal-nonmetal granular films prepared by tandem deposition method. J. Magn. Soc. Jpn 23, 76–78 (1999).

    CAS  Article  Google Scholar 

  29. Ambegaokar, V., Halperin, B. I. & Langer, J. S. Hopping conductivity in disordered system. Phys. Rev. B 4, 2612–2620 (1971).

    ADS  Article  Google Scholar 

  30. Debye., P. Polar Molecule Chemical Catalog (1929).

  31. Tedrow, P. M. & Meservey, R. Spin polarization of electrons tunneling from films of Fe, Co, Ni, and Gd. Phys. Rev. B 7, 318–325 (1973).

    ADS  CAS  Article  Google Scholar 

Download references

Acknowledgements

We are grateful to T. Masumoto and K.I. Arai for valuable discussions. They are indebted to K. Ishida for the sample preparation and to T. Iwasa for the measurement of dielectric constant. This work was supported by Grant-in-Aids for Scientific Research (Grant Nos.23246118, 25400337) from the JSPS.

Author information

Affiliations

Authors

Contributions

The experiments were carried out by N.K. The data were discussed by N.K. and H.M. The theoretical model was developed by S.T. and S.M. All authors contributed to the writing and editing of the paper.

Corresponding author

Correspondence to Nobukiyo Kobayashi.

Ethics declarations

Competing interests

The authors declare no competing financial interests.

Rights and permissions

This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License. The images or other third party material in this article are included in the article’s Creative Commons license, unless indicated otherwise in the credit line; if the material is not included under the Creative Commons license, users will need to obtain permission from the license holder to reproduce the material. To view a copy of this license, visit http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/

Reprints and Permissions

About this article

Verify currency and authenticity via CrossMark

Cite this article

Kobayashi, N., Masumoto, H., Takahashi, S. et al. Giant dielectric and magnetoelectric responses in insulating nanogranular films at room temperature. Nat Commun 5, 4417 (2014). https://doi.org/10.1038/ncomms5417

Download citation

  • Received:

  • Accepted:

  • Published:

  • DOI: https://doi.org/10.1038/ncomms5417

Further reading

Comments

By submitting a comment you agree to abide by our Terms and Community Guidelines. If you find something abusive or that does not comply with our terms or guidelines please flag it as inappropriate.

Search

Quick links

Nature Briefing

Sign up for the Nature Briefing newsletter — what matters in science, free to your inbox daily.

Get the most important science stories of the day, free in your inbox. Sign up for Nature Briefing