Erythropoietin (Epo) supports both primitive erythropoiesis in the yolk sac and definitive erythropoiesis in the fetal liver and bone marrow. Although definitive erythropoiesis requires kidney- and liver-secreted Epo, it is unclear which cells produce Epo for primitive erythropoiesis. Here we find neural Epo-producing (NEP) cells in mid-gestational stage embryos using mouse lines that express green fluorescent protein (GFP) under the Epo gene regulation. In these mice, GFP is expressed exclusively in a subpopulation of neural and neural crest cells at embryonic day 9.0 when Epo-deficient embryos exhibit abnormalities in primitive erythropoiesis. The GFP-positive NEP cells express Epo mRNA and the ex vivo culture of embryonic day 8.5 neural tubes results in the secretion of Epo, which is able to induce the proliferation and differentiation of yolk sac-derived erythroid cells. These results thus suggest that NEP cells secrete Epo and might support the development of primitive erythropoiesis.
Erythropoietin (Epo) is one of the best-characterized cytokines that stimulates the proliferation and differentiation of erythroid cells1. Epo binds to the Epo receptor (EpoR) on the surface of erythroid progenitor (EP) cells and stimulates the proliferation and maturation of progenitor cells via the phosphorylation of EpoR and associated signalling molecules2. Tissue hypoxia that is caused by anaemia or altitude sickness induces Epo gene expression in the kidney and liver of adult humans and mice1,3. This hypoxia-induced Epo gene expression is transcriptionally regulated by hypoxia-inducible transcription factors (HIFs). The first characterized HIF-binding sequence (that is, hypoxia responsive element or HRE) resides in the 3′-region of the Epo gene4,5,6.
The first wave of murine erythropoiesis begins in the blood islands of the visceral yolk sac at embryonic day 7.5 (E7.5). This erythropoiesis is referred to as primitive erythropoiesis7,8. The fetal liver subsequently becomes the principal erythropoietic tissue in late-stage embryos. Around birth, erythropoiesis moves to the bone marrow and spleen6. The latter type of erythropoiesis is referred to as definitive erythropoiesis7,8. Yolk sac-derived erythrocytes express embryonic β-globin (εy-globin), whereas definitive erythrocytes express adult-type β-globin (primarily βmaj-globin)8. This shift of erythropoiesis from one tissue to another and the change in globin-gene expression are common features of vertebrate erythropoiesis. Mouse and human definitive erythrocytes in the peripheral blood are enucleated, whereas primitive erythrocytes have a nucleus when they are released from yolk sac and complete their maturation (enucleation) while circulating9,10.
Tissues other than the liver and kidney also secrete Epo, but whether Epo makes critical contributions to non-haematopoietic tissues or cells remains to be clarified11,12,13,14,15,16. In contrast, transgenic complementation rescue analyses of EpoR gene revealed that EpoR expression in non-haematopoietic tissues is dispensable for mouse survival and fertility17. Thus, while Epo also has non-haematopoietic functions under pathological or stress conditions, the principal role of Epo is to support erythropoiesis.
Epo or EpoR gene knockout mice are lethal at ~E12.5 because of a defect in definitive erythropoiesis18. We have identified renal Epo-producing (REP) cells in the interstitial space of the kidney19,20,21. REP cells secrete Epo into the bloodstream where it acts as an endocrine factor for bone marrow EPs6,22. While adult mouse hepatocytes also produce low levels of Epo, this hepatic Epo production is dispensable for erythropoiesis in adult mice6,23. In contrast, fetal liver-derived Epo stimulates liver erythropoiesis in a paracrine manner6.
Importantly, Epo or EpoR gene knockout mice also exhibit an inefficient production of primitive erythrocytes, suggesting that Epo plays important roles in primitive erythropoiesis18. However, Epo-producing cells in the early stages of mouse development have not been identified. Therefore, in the present study we address Epo production in early-stage embryos. We observe Epo production in neural and neural crest cells of E8.5–E11.5 embryos. We also determine that this Epo production is able to induce the proliferation and differentiation of yolk sac-derived erythroid cells under ex vivo co-culture conditions. The major source of Epo for primitive erythropoiesis might be a subpopulation of neural and neural crest cells, which we refer to as neural Epo-producing (NEP) cells.
The indispensable roles of Epo in primitive erythropoiesis
To elucidate the contribution of Epo to primitive erythropoiesis, we analysed an Epo-knockout (Epo-KO or Epo−/−) mouse line (Supplementary Fig. S1)20,21. No apparent abnormality was observed in Epo-KO embryos at E8.5 (5–9 somite pair stages (sp); Fig. 1a) or E9.0 (16–20 sp; Fig. 1a). Nonetheless, the yolk sacs of Epo-KO mice were moderately and severely anaemic at E10.5 and E11.5, respectively (Fig. 1a). We found that Epo-KO embryos died by E12.5 due to anaemia, and this is consistent with the previous observations18.
To characterize the yolk sac cells of Epo-KO embryos, we conducted flow cytometry analyses. In wild-type yolk sacs, transferrin receptor (CD71) expression in Ter119+ erythroblasts (EBs) gradually increased during embryonic development (Fig. 1b), whereas the increase was not so significant for Epo-KO yolk sacs. The CD71 fluorescence intensity was markedly lower in Epo-KO yolk sacs than that in wild-type yolk sacs after E9.0 (Fig. 1c). Moreover, the relative abundance of CD71+Ter119+ cells was decreased in Epo-KO yolk sacs after E10.5 compared with those in wild-type yolk sacs (Fig. 1c). These results support our contention that Epo contributes to primitive erythropoiesis and is required for the differentiation of primitive erythroid cells towards the CD71-positive stage in yolk sacs after E9.0.
Epo expression in developing neural tissues
To our current knowledge, the earliest time of Epo expression is at E9.5 in the liver24. However, the impaired primitive erythropoiesis in Epo-KO mice implies that Epo is produced in embryos around E9.0, although Epo-producing tissues or cells have not been identified in early-stage embryos.
To identify Epo-producing tissues or cells in mid-gestational stage embryos, we dissected embryos (Supplementary Fig. S2a–c) at E8.5 (5–9 sp), E9.5 (22–25 sp) and E10.5, and analysed Epo messenger RNA expression using reverse transcription (RT)–quantitative PCR (qPCR). To our surprise, Epo mRNA was exclusively expressed in the head region at E8.5 (Fig. 2a). As Epo mRNA was not detected in samples from whole embryos at E7.5, the head region of E8.5 embryos appeared to be the first Epo-producing tissue during mouse embryogenesis. Epo mRNA expression was detected in the head region and in the fetal liver in E9.5 and E10.5 embryos (Fig. 2a)6,24. The relative Epo mRNA expression level in the head region gradually decreased during development and was undetectable at E11.5, whereas Epo mRNA expression in the fetal liver gradually increased over this period (Fig. 2a).
To identify which cell types express Epo in the embryonic head region, we next examined transgenic mouse lines that express green fluorescent protein (GFP) under the control of the Epo regulatory region. To this end, we used transgenic mouse lines that carried various bacterial artificial chromosome-based GFP reporter transgenes that we previously established (Table 1; Supplementary Fig. S1)6,15,19,22. Importantly, it has been shown that GFP fluorescence in these mice faithfully recapitulates the endogenous Epo gene expression profile in adult livers and kidneys.
We analysed seven lines of transgenic mice that carried wt-Epo-GFP, 22K-Epo-GFP or 17KXh-Epo-GFP transgenes6,15,19,22 and found that all these mice exhibited green fluorescence in rostral neural tissues and liver at E9.5 (22–25 sp) with a conserved expression profile (Table 1). The representative GFP expression patterns in 22K-Epo-GFP transgenic mouse embryos are shown in Fig. 2b–g. In E8.5–E10.0 embryos, green fluorescence was detected in rostral neural tissues, and the expression in the rhombomeres (especially in r1, r3 and r5) was strong (Fig. 2f,g). E9.5–E11.5 embryos also expressed GFP in the liver (Fig. 2e; Supplementary Fig. S2c,d). The expression profile and GFP intensity in the transgenic mouse embryos were comparable with the RT–qPCR data, revealing high-level expression in the head region at E8.5 and a decrease in this expression during development. Thus, these results demonstrate that cells in neural tissues of E8.5–E11.5 embryos express Epo. We refer to these cells as NEP cells.
Regulatory elements for Epo gene expression in NEP cells
To examine cis-acting regulatory elements of the Epo gene using transgenic reporter expression assays, we assessed GFP reporter expression in two bacterial artificial chromosome transgenic mouse lines that carry the wt-Epo-GFP, three lines that carry the 22K-Epo-GFP and two lines that carry the 17KXh-Epo-GFP (transgene structures are shown in Supplementary Fig. S1)15,19,22. Transgenic mouse embryos of all seven lines expressed GFP in NEP cells at E9.5 (Table 1), strongly supporting the notion that the GFP reporter expression, and hence Epo gene expression, in NEP cells is reproducible and physiological. We also conclude that the transactivation event that induces Epo gene expression in NEP cells resides within a 32-kb region that spans the 17-kb upstream and 15-kb downstream of the Epo gene (Supplementary Fig. S1).
Of the regulatory motifs within this 32-kb region, we have identified important roles such as (i) the GATA-binding motif (5′-GATA) in the proximal promoter19 and (ii) the HIF-binding motif in the 3′-enhancer (3′-HRE)6 play. These findings were drawn by using mouse lines that carry the wt-Epo-GFP and its mutant transgene constructs. Taking advantage of these transgenic mouse lines, we examined the contribution of these cis-acting elements to Epo gene expression in NEP cells. Two types of mutations in the 5′-GATA motif in a total of four transgenic mouse lines (two lines for each mutation) were utilized to assess GFP expression in E9.5 embryos. The 5′-GATA motif was not required for GFP expression in NEP cells but was essential to repress ectopic GFP expression in the epidermis (Table 1). Similarly, analyses of 3′-HRE-mutant transgenes (m3-Epo-GFP) revealed that 3′-HRE was dispensable for reporter expression in NEP cells (Table 1). These results indicate that the cis-acting regulatory elements for Epo gene expression in NEP cells reside in the 35-kb region but are independent of 5′-GATA and 3′-HRE.
Epo-GFP transgene expression in developing neuroepithelium
We found that GFP expression in the head region decreased in Epo-GFP transgenic mouse embryos after E10.5, while the fetal liver consistently expressed GFP after E9.5 (Fig. 3a–d). Since GFP expression was observed in the neuroepithelium around hindbrain (Fig. 3a,b), we conducted immunofluorescent analyses using antibodies against GFP and Sox2, a marker for developing neuroepithelial cells25. There are GFP+ cell fractions in the neuroepithelium and nuclear staining of Sox2 in the GFP+ cells, demonstrating that a part of neural lineage cells express the Epo gene at E9.5 (Fig. 3e,f).
We isolated the GFP+ cells from the head region of 17KXh-Epo-GFP transgenic mouse embryos at E9.5 using fluorescence-activated cell sorter (FACS; Supplementary Fig. S2e). RT–qPCR analyses of the isolated cells showed co-expression of neural marker mRNAs (Sox2 and Nestin)25,26 with Epo mRNA in NEP cells (Supplementary Fig. S3a). Epo-GFP expression was also observed in neuroepithelia of the otic and optic vesicles (Figs 2e,f and 3a,b), and the expression was detectable in the retinal neuroepithelium until E11.5 (Fig. 3g). These results thus demonstrate that Epo is expressed transiently in a subpopulation of developing neural cells.
Strong Epo-GFP expression in a neural crest cell cluster
We detected a cell cluster expressing very bright green fluorescence posterior to the otic vesicle in the 17KXh-Epo-GFP and 22K-Epo-GFP transgenic embryos at E9.0 (arrowheads in Figs 2d and 3a,h,i). The cell cluster formed a line from the dorsal neural tube to the developing heart (Supplementary Fig. S3b), which was considered to be a migration stream of cardiac neural crest cells27, and the cells seemed to be derived from the initially emerged NEP cells in E8.5 embryos (arrowheads in Fig. 2b,c). These GFPhigh cells were observed in all Epo-GFP transgenic mouse lines examined (Table 1). Since Epo is a secreted factor, it is plausible that these GFPhigh cells dominantly produce Epo among NEP cells.
At E9.5, GFP-positive cells were detected in intersomitic spaces (Fig. 3j,k). These GFP-positive cells resided posterior to the intersomitic vessels, which were lined with CD31+ endothelial cells (Fig. 3j,k). It seems plausible that the close proximity between NEP cells and the vessels (Fig. 3g,j,k) is effective for prompt secretion of Epo into the bloodstream. Since trunk neural crest cells migrate into the intersomitic space from dorsal to ventral side of embryos27, we conclude that NEP cells consist of a subpopulation of neural crest cells and a subpopulation of neural lineage cells.
A subpopulation of neural crest cells produces Epo
To further verify that NEP cells include neural crest cells, we crossed the 17KXh-Epo-GFP mice with the neural crest cell-tracer mouse line Wnt1-Cre::Rosa26R-tdTomato (Supplementary Fig. S3c)28. We found that a subpopulation of tdTomato-positive cells around the neural tube expressed GFP in E9.5 embryos (Fig. 4a,b). We conducted similar experiments using two additional neural crest tracer lines of mice, Pax3-Cre::Rosa26R-tdTomato29 and P0-Cre::Rosa26R-tdTomato30. The results demonstrated that GFP-positive cells were partially overlapped with tdTomato-positive cells in these tracer mouse lines (Supplementary Fig. S3d–i).
The GFP-positive cells in E9.5 17KXh-Epo-GFP embryos were separated with FACS, and the expressions of GFP reporter mRNA and endogenous Epo mRNA were examined using RT–qPCR. Consistent with the transgenic GFP expression, endogenous Epo mRNA expression was exclusively detected in the GFP-positive cell fraction of both the head and the liver regions (Fig. 4c; Supplementary Fig. S3a). This result confirmed the faithful recapitulation of endogenous Epo gene expression by the 17KXh-Epo-GFP transgene.
In the head region, the expression levels of the neural crest markers (Wnt1, Foxd3 and Sox10)31,32,33 were enriched in the GFP-positive cell fraction compared with the GFP-negative cell fraction (Fig. 4d). This indicates that a subpopulation of neural crest cells express the Epo gene. In contrast, very low-level expression of neural crest markers was observed in GFP-positive cells of the liver that expressed the Albumin gene, a hepatocyte marker (Fig. 4d,e). This result conclusively demonstrates that the Epo-expressing head cells are a different type of cells from Epo-expressing fetal hepatocytes6,19. Significant EpoR mRNA expression was detectable in GFP-negative head cells, which were circulating erythroid cells. Moreover, EpoR expression was strong in the GFP-negative liver cell fraction; the majority of these cells were definitive haematopoietic cells (Fig. 4e).
When E8.5 embryos (5–9 sp) were dissected and each portion of the embryo was incubated for 24 h under normoxic or hypoxic (1% oxygen) conditions, we detected a significant concentration of Epo in the culture supernatant of the E8.5 head region, which contained GFP-positive cells. However, no Epo was observed in the supernatant from the heart or yolk sac regions (Fig. 4f). Epo production was not altered by hypoxic exposure of the neural tissue culture (Fig. 4f). These results demonstrate the consistency of GFP expression and Epo secretion in NEP cells.
NEP cell-derived Epo induces primitive erythrocyte growth
We then examined the activity of NEP cell-derived Epo by establishing a novel bioassay system (Fig. 5a,b). In this assay, we collected haematopoietic cells from yolk sacs of E8.5 Gata1-HRD (haematopoietic regulatory domain)-GFP transgenic mice, which contain GFP-positive primitive erythroid/megakaryocytic lineage cells34,35. The yolk sac cells were incubated with the dissected head region that contained NEP cells or heart region from E8.5 littermates without the transgene as a non-Epo-producing control. We performed cultures under hypoxic conditions (1% oxygen) to inhibit megakaryopoiesis, which is stimulated by ambient oxygen tension in yolk sac cell cultures36,37.
Following 5 days of incubation, we observed that more than half of the cells in the head region culture were morphologically erythroid cells (Fig. 5c, Hd), which exhibited a small and mononuclear appearance that was similar to that of primitive erythroid cells that can normally be observed in E9.5 yolk sacs (Fig. 5d). These erythroid-lineage cells were predominant in the culture that was supplemented with recombinant Epo, and this culture condition was used as a positive control (Fig. 5c, Epo). In contrast, no apparent stimulation of erythropoiesis was observed in the culture without supplementation (Fig. 5c, No). In the co-culture with the heart region, megakaryocyte-like cells (Fig. 5c, Ht, arrowheads) were increased in number, but erythroid cells were not.
Using Gata1-HRD-GFP expression (Supplementary Fig. S4), the primitive haematopoietic cells in the 5-day cultures were divided into four flow cytometric fractions: a CD45−Ter119− fraction containing megakaryocytes, a CD45+Ter119− fraction containing EP, a CD45+Ter119+ fraction containing EBs and a CD45−Ter119+ fraction containing mature erythrocytes (Ery)38. The number of Gata1-HRD-GFP-positive cells was ~10-fold higher in the culture with the head region than that in the control culture without supplementation (Fig. 5e). The number of Gata1-HRD-GFP-positive cells at the beginning of culture was estimated to be 500–1,000. Therefore, according to our previous finding that 10–20% of the 5,000 yolk sac cells at E8.5 were Gata1-HRD-GFP positive35, we estimated that a three- to sixfold increase in the number of Gata1-HRD-GFP-positive cells was induced during the 5-day culture with the head region. Although Gata1-HRD-GFP-positive cells were also increased in the culture with the heart region, the majority of the growing GFP-positive cells belonged to the megakaryocytic lineage (Fig. 5e).
Recombinant Epo stimulates the maturation and anti-apoptosis activity of primitive erythrocytes in this culture system, and 17.8% of the GFP+ cells were CD45−Ter119+ Ery in the cultures that were supplemented with Epo (Fig. 5f, Epo). In contrast, virtually no CD45−Ter119+ cells were observed in the culture without supplementation (Fig. 5f, No). In the culture with the head region, 5.1% of the cells were CD45−Ter119+ (Fig. 5f; Hd), and the addition of a neutralizing antibody against Epo significantly inhibited erythroid differentiation (Fig. 5f, Hd+Ab). These results demonstrate that NEP cells in the embryonic head region secrete functional Epo that can stimulate the proliferation and maturation of primitive erythroid cells.
NEP cell-derived Epo stimulates erythroid cells in yolk sac
Necessity of NEP cells for primitive erythropoiesis should be defined by NEP cell-specific deletion of the Epo gene. However, currently available Cre transgenic mouse lines are not suitable for the loss-of-function analyses of Epo secretion from NEP cells because only a small number of NEP cells are labelled in any of three mouse lines (Wnt1-Cre, Pax3-Cre and P0-Cre), which are known for Cre expression in neural crest cells (see Fig. 4 and Supplementary Fig. S3).
We then hypothesized that Epo secreted from NEP cells reached the yolk sac through circulation to support the primitive erythropoiesis (Fig. 6a), as true heartbeats initiate around E9.0 (refs 7, 8) and Epo-KO embryos exhibit abnormalities in the primitive erythropoiesis at this timing (Fig. 1b,c). To verify this hypothesis, we examined whether Epo from NEP cells reach the yolk sac and primitive erythroid cells are stimulated at E9.0.
We analysed Epo levels in the embryonic parts using enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay (ELISA). Consistent with the above RT–qPCR results (Fig. 2a; Supplementary Fig. S5), we detected significant concentrations of Epo in the embryo proper at E8.5, and in the head regions at E9.0 and E9.5 (Fig. 6b). In the yolk sac, while Epo was below the detectable level at E8.5, Epo started reaching the yolk sac after E9.0 and became detectible (Fig. 6b). These results are consistent with NEP cells in the head region beginning to produce Epo at E8.5, and the Epo being delivered into yolk sac through the blood flow after E9.0 when the circulatory system is activated7,8.
We next examined downstream pathway of the Epo-EpoR system in the yolk sac. Gata1 mRNA level was decreased in the yolk sac from E8.5 to E9.5, when the level was normalized with the housekeeping Gapdh mRNA level (Fig. 6c), suggesting that the ratio of erythroid cells decreased in the yolk sac that is rapidly expanding during these embryonic stages35. The expression of Stat5 genes (Stat5a and Stat5b) was detected at E8.5 and the levels were decreased at E9.0 and E9.5, similar to the Gata1 gene expression (Fig. 6c). In contrast, phosphorylated Stat5 level was very low at E8.5 but the amount in each yolk sac was significantly increased after E9.0 (Fig. 6d). Since Epo-binding to EpoR immediately induces phosphorylation and transcriptional activity of Stat5 (ref. 39), these results are consistent with NEP cell-derived Epo activating the primitive erythropoiesis at E9.0. We also found that the Cish gene, one of the early response genes to Epo stimulation2,21, was dramatically induced at E9.0 (Fig. 6e). The gene for CD71 (Tfrc), which is known as a target of Stat5 (ref. 39), was also upregulated after E9.0, showing a very good agreement with the decreased expression level of CD71 in yolk sac of E9.0 Epo-KO embryos (Fig. 1c).
These results are thus consistent with NEP cell-derived Epo reaching EpoR on the yolk sac erythroid cells through the bloodstream after E9.0, and inducing Stat5 activation and expressions of the Cish and Tfrc genes (Supplementary Fig. S6). Since NEP cells are the only source of Epo in E9.0 embryos (Supplementary Fig. S5), it is possible to think that defects in the primitive erythropoiesis of Epo-KO embryos at E9.0 (Fig. 1b,c) are provoked by the loss of Epo production in NEP cells.
Although Epo or EpoR deficiency appears to affect primitive erythropoiesis, the roles that Epo plays in primitive erythropoiesis or the cells that supply Epo for primitive erythropoiesis have not been elucidated. As summarized in Fig. 6a, in the present study we demonstrate that Epo is indeed required for the progression of primitive erythropoiesis in mouse embryos. We further have discovered that a major source of Epo for primitive erythropoiesis might be a subpopulation of neural and neural crest cells, which we refer to as NEP cells. Consistent with our observation, the principal Epo-producing tissue in zebrafish larvae is neural tissue, and Epo production moves to the heart and liver during adulthood40,41. We also observed that a subpopulation of NEP cells migrate along the blood vessels in the intersomitic space. It therefore appears that NEP cell-derived Epo may efficiently stimulate the differentiation of primitive erythroid cells in the yolk sac and bloodstream (see Fig. 6a). Indeed, defects in the heartbeat of mouse embryos cause the maturation arrest of primitive erythroid cells42. These results firmly support the contention that NEP cells support primitive erythropoiesis in the yolk sac.
CD71, a transferrin receptor, plays important roles in iron uptake for haemoglobin synthesis43. As CD71 expression in primitive EBs is reduced significantly after E9.0 in Epo-deficient mice, Epo appears to be indispensable for the CD71 expression and late-stage primitive erythropoiesis. The CD71 expression is also impaired in the definitive erythroid cells of EpoR-deficient mice17, indicating that the Epo signal is essential for the upregulation of CD71 expression during erythroid maturation in both primitive and definitive erythropoiesis. The loss of Stat5, an important transcription factor in the Epo signalling cascade, in definitive erythroid cells causes the downregulation of CD71 expression39. Thus, our finding that CD71 expression is decreased in primitive erythroid cells of Epo-KO embryos suggests that the Epo-mediated induction of CD71 expression via Stat5 activation may play an indispensable role in primitive erythroid cells.
The neural crest is considered to be the fourth germ layer of vertebrates. The neural crest appears transiently in embryos at the mid-gestational stage, and neural crest cells differentiate into a variety of cell types, including neuronal, cardiac and skeletal cells27,31. Many studies have sought to delineate the nature of the neural crest cells and their derivatives, including studies in avian embryos. However, many aspects of mammalian neural crest cells that are related to cell fate and other properties remain unknown. This study provides evidence that a subpopulation of mouse neural crest cells, which express Wnt1, Foxd3 and Sox10, produce Epo.
In this regard, the origin of the REP cells is an intriguing question and remains unknown20. REP cells express the interstitial fibroblast marker CD73 and neuronal markers, such as microtubule-associated protein 2 and neurofilament light polypeptide19,20,21,44,45. Neural crest-derived cells distribute in the interstitial space of renal tubules in adult mice45. These observations support the notion that REP cells are derived from neural crest cells. This hypothesis is further supported by the similarity in the regulatory mechanisms for the Epo gene in NEP and REP cells. Epo gene expression levels in both NEP and REP cells do not require the GATA motif or the HIF-binding motif, both of which are essential for the regulation of Epo in hepatocytes6,19.
Several reports have demonstrated that the Epo-EpoR signalling plays important roles in non-haematopoietic cells, including neuronal and cardiac cells11,12,13. To address the non-haematopoietic roles of Epo, we have developed a mouse line that expresses EpoR only in haematopoietic cells; however, these mice exhibit no apparent abnormality during embryogenesis17. We have also observed that Epo-KO embryos exhibit no apparent abnormality until E11.5 in non-haematopoietic organs. In zebrafish, the overexpression and knockdown of Epo dramatically alter erythropoiesis in the embryonic intermediate cell mass and the adult kidney, but these alterations in Epo levels do not affect the development of non-haematopoietic systems41. Moreover, NEP cells express low EpoR mRNA levels compared with haematopoietic cells. On the basis of these observations, we conclude that NEP cell-secreted Epo is dispensable for the morphogenesis of non-haematopoietic tissues and for the migration of neural and neural crest cells.
In summary, we have determined that a subpopulation of neural cells and a subpopulation of neural crest cells produce Epo to support primitive erythropoiesis during ontogeny. Of the many important issues that remain to be clarified, the following two are particularly intriguing. One is whether Epo signalling is required for the stress response of embryonic tissues, as observed in adult tissues. Another is whether neural crest-derived cells in adults have the potential to produce Epo in response to anaemic stress conditions. Further studies are necessary to elucidate the nature of NEP cells and the contributions of NEP cell-derived Epo to embryonic haematopoiesis.
We previously established the Epo-deficient mouse line in which enhanced GFP complementary DNA (BD Biosciences) was inserted into the Epo locus20,21. The Epo-GFP transgenic mouse lines and the Gata1-HRD-GFP transgenic mouse line were also previously generated6,15,19,22,34. The 17KXh-Epo-GFP transgene contains the upstream 17-kb and downstream 15-kb sequences of the Epo gene (Supplementary Fig. S1). The 5′-GATA (5′-TGATAA-3′) motif in the wt-Epo-GFP construct was mutated to 5′-TTATAA-3′ and 5′-TTTTAA-3′ in the m1-Epo-GFP and the m2-Epo-GFP constructs, respectively19. The m3-Epo-GFP transgene has a mutation in the 3′-HRE (from 5′-ACGTG-3′ to 5′-AAAAG-3′)6. To trace the neural crest cells, Rosa26R-tdTomato mice46 were crossed with Wnt1-Cre28, Pax3-Cre29 or P0-Cre30 transgenic mouse lines, all of which except P0-Cre mice (the Kumamoto University) were supplied by Jackson Laboratory. The genotype of these mice was determined using genomic PCR analysis with the primers that are listed in Supplementary Table S1. The animal experiments were performed according to the Regulations for Animal Experiments and Related Activities of Tohoku University and the regulations of the Standards for Human Care and Use of Laboratory Animals of the University of Tsukuba.
Flow cytometry and cell sorting
For the cell surface marker analyses, single-cell suspensions of yolk sacs were prepared by passing the cells through a needle. Antibody-stained cells were also stained with propidium iodide to gate out dead cells and were analysed using a FACS. We used the FACSCalibur with CellQuest programme (Becton Dickinson). For the cell sorting analysis, single-cell suspensions were prepared by digesting embryonic tissues with Trypsin-EDTA (0.05%, Invitrogen) for 30 min at 37 °C. The GFP-positive cells were sorted using FACSVantage SE and FACSAria II (Becton Dickinson). The mean fluorescent intensity and the percentage of the normal distribution of the GFP+ and GFP− fractions were calculated. The phycoerythrin-conjugated anti-Ter119, allophycocyanin-conjugated anti-CD71 antibodies, allophycocyanin-conjugated anti-CD45 antibodies were obtained from BD Biosciences and used at 1:100 dilution.
The RNA samples were purified from dissected embryonic organs and FACS-sorted cells using the RNeasy kit (Qiagen). The total RNA was reverse transcribed using SenscriptRT (Qiagen). For the RT–qPCR analyses, Epo mRNA levels were measured using the ABI PRISM 7300 or StepOne real-time PCR systems (Applied Biosystems). Gapdh mRNA was used as an internal standard6,19. All primer sequences are listed in Supplementary Table S1.
The fluorescence of transgenic embryos was observed using a MZ16FA microscope (Leica) and a LMS510 confocal imaging system (Carl Zeiss). For the immunohistochemical analyses, the embryos were fixed in 4% paraformaldehyde for 15 min. Frozen sections (25 μm thickness) were collected from the fixed embryos after embedding them in blocks of OCT (Sakura Finetechnical). The following antibodies were used for the immunohistochemical analyses: anti-GFP rabbit polyclonal antibody (Medical & Biological Laboratories, 1:500 dilution), anti-CD31 rat monoclonal antibody (e-Bioscience, 1:100 dilution), anti-Sox2 rabbit polyclonal antibody (Abcam, 1:1000 dilution) and Alexa fluor 488- or 555-conjugated secondary antibodies (Molecular Probes, 1:500 dilution).
GFP-expressing yolk sacs were selected from E8.5 littermates that were obtained from the mating of Gata1-HRD-GFP transgenic male mice31 with wild-type female mice. Single-cell suspensions were prepared from the yolk sacs by incubating them in 0.05% Trypsin-EDTA (Invitrogen) for 5 min. Five thousand cells were incubated in 0.1 ml RPMI medium (Sigma) that was supplemented with 10% fetal bovine serum (Hyclone), 2-mercaptoethanol (0.1 mM) and antibiotics. The incubations were performed with or without human recombinant Epo (4 mU ml−1, Chugai Pharmaceutical) in 96-well round bottom plates in a multi-gas incubator (Astec) at 5% CO2 and 1% O2. GFP-negative embryos from the same litters were dissected as shown in Supplementary Fig. S2a and added to these yolk sac cell cultures. An anti-Epo antibody (10 μg ml−1, R&D Systems) was used to block Epo function in the culture medium. Following a 5-day incubation, the cells were harvested by pipetting and the GFP-expressing cells were analysed.
To measure Epo concentrations in mouse embryonic parts, mouse embryos were dissected as shown in Supplementary Fig. S2a–c, and the dissected parts from more than five embryos were gathered into a sampling tube. The pooled samples were lysed by pipetting after two freeze-thaw cycles and Epo amount was measured using a mouse Epo ELISA kit (R&D Systems). Total protein amount of the lysate was measured using the Bradford assay (Bio-Rad).
To measure the Epo secretion, the dissected organs (Supplementary Fig. S2a) from four embryos were pooled into 0.1 ml of RPMI medium (Sigma) that was supplemented with 10% fetal bovine serum (Hyclone). After 24-h incubation under normoxic or hypoxic (1% O2) conditions at 37 °C, the supernatants were measured the Epo concentrations using a mouse Epo ELISA Kit.
For ELISA of phosphorylated Stat5, a single-cell suspension of the yolk sac, which was prepared by pipetting, was fixed by 8% formaldehyde on the 96-well plate under a centrifuging condition (500g) for 20 min at room temperature. The relative amounts of phospho-Stat5 in each yolk sac were analysed using a rabbit anti-Stat5(Y699) antibody from cell-based ELISA system (R&D Systems) following the instruction manual.
How to cite this article: Suzuki, N. et al. Erythropoietin production in neuroepithelial and neural crest cells during primitive erythropoiesis. Nat. Commun. 4:2902 doi: 10.1038/ncomms3902 (2013).
We thank Drs Naoshi Obara (University of Tsukuba), Tadashi Nomura (Kyoto Prefectural University of Medicine), Takashi Moriguchi (Tohoku University) and Doug Engel (University of Michigan) for their help with the transgenic mouse analyses. We also thank Ms Chisa Sato, Yuko Kikuchi and Atsuko Konuma for their help, and Biomedical Research Core and Centre for Laboratory Animal Research of Tohoku University for supports. This work was supported in part by a research fund from Chugai Pharmaceutical Co. Ltd. (N.S., M.Y.), Grants-in-Aids from MEXT/JSPS KAKENHI (N.S., M.Y.), the NAITO foundation (M.Y.), the Astellas Foundation for Research on Metabolic Disorders (M.Y.), the Tokyo Biochemistry Society (N.S.) and the Takeda Science Foundation (N.S.).
Supplementary Figures S1-S6 and Supplementary Table S1