Recent discoveries of advanced fish-like stem-tetrapods (for example, Panderichthys and Tiktaalik) have greatly improved our knowledge of the fin-to-limb transition. However, a paucity of fossil data from primitive finned tetrapods prevents profound understanding of the acquisition sequence of tetrapod characters. Here we report a new stem-tetrapod (Tungsenia paradoxa gen. et sp. nov.) from the Lower Devonian (Pragian, ∼409 million years ago) of China, which extends the earliest record of tetrapods by some 10 million years. Sharing many primitive features with stem-lungfishes, the new taxon further fills in the morphological gap between tetrapods and lungfishes. The X-ray tomography study of the skull depicts the plesiomorphic condition of the brain in the tetrapods. The enlargement of the cerebral hemispheres and the possible presence of the pars tuberalis in this stem-tetrapod indicate that some important brain modifications related to terrestrial life had occurred at the beginning of the tetrapod evolution, much earlier than previously thought.
Living tetrapods, such as the frogs, turtles, birds and mammals, are a subgroup of the tetrapod lineage (tetrapod total group or tetrapodomorphs). The lineage also includes finned and limbed tetrapods that are more closely related to living tetrapods than to living lungfishes1,2,3. Previously, the undisputed earliest known stem-tetrapod was Kenichthys, a finned member from the late Emsian (∼399 million years ago (mya)) of Yunnan, China4,5. By comparison, the oldest fossil record of the lungfish lineage (dipnomorphs), which forms the immediate sister group of tetrapodomorphs, can be traced back to the early Lochkovian (∼415 mya)6. Thus, a ghost lineage of at least 16 million years existed for the tetrapod total group7,8.
Here, we describe a new finned stem-tetrapod, Tungsenia paradoxa gen. et sp. nov., from the Lower Devonian (Pragian, ∼409 mya) of Yunnan, China. The new taxon is ∼10 million years older than Kenichthys, and shifts the beginning of stem-tetrapods back to the Pragian. The parietal shield (holotype, V10687) and two lower jaws (V10688.1-2) were originally described as an indeterminate osteolepid9. However, these specimens were not fully prepared and their phylogenetic position was open to question. After the discovery of complementary specimens (V15132.1-22) from the same locality, we further prepared the original material to unveil the medial aspect of mandible and hitherto unrecognised aspects of the neurocranial anatomy.
The new material was recovered from a yellow sandstone layer of the Posongchong Formation, near the dam of the Qingmen Reservoir in the suburb of Zhaotong, northeastern Yunnan, South China (Fig. 1). The Posongchong fauna includes diverse galeaspid agnathans9,10,11,12, placoderms13,14, onychodonts, coelacanths and rhipidistians9,15,16,17,18 (Supplementary Table S1), as well as lingulids and plant remains15,19.
This clastic fish-bearing stratum was originally named as the ‘Cuifengshan Formation’, by comparsion to the Cuifengshan Group (previously the Cuifengshan Formation) in neighbouring Qujing district, Yunnan20,21. However, considering the lithology and faunal composition, as well as the overlying strata, the Devonian sediments underlying the marine Pojiao Formation in Zhaotong are more suggestive of the Posongchong Formation in Wenshan and Guannan, southeastern Yunnan than the Cuifengshan Group in Qujing. In this regard, the Posongchong Formation was proposed to represent the lowermost formation of the Devonian sequence in Zhaotong9,15,16,17,18,19.
Osteichthyes Huxley, 1880
Sarcopterygii Romer, 1955
Tetrapodomorpha Ahlberg, 1991
Tungsenia gen. nov.
Etymology. Generic name after Liu Tungsen for his pio neering contribution to Paleoichthyology in China.
Type species. T. paradoxa sp. nov.
Diagnosis. A small cosmine-covered stem-tetrapod char acterized by having a large orbital notch ∼40% of total parietal shield length, pineal foramen at the middle level of orbits, a large pair of fangs on the parasymphysial plate, short robust olfactory tracts, developed cerebral cavity, pineal and parapineal recesses not extending anteriorly, hypophysial fossa far posterior to the optic nerve root and paired tongue-like recesses at the front of the hypophysial fossa.
Tungsenia paradoxa sp. nov.
Etymology. Specific name from the Latin paradoxus, unexpected.
Holotype. IVPP V10687, a parietal shield.
Referred material. Skulls, V15132.1-6; lower jaws, V10688.1-2, V15132.7-20; cheek bone, V15132.22.
Type locality. Zhaotong, Yunnan Province, China.
Formation and age. Posongchong Formation (Pragian, Early Devonian).
Diagnosis. As for the generic diagnosis.
The parietal shield is about as wide as it is long (Fig. 2). In profile, the shield presents a protruding and slightly upturned snout, suggesting that the mouth was subterminal. The orbital notch, comprising ∼40% of total parietal shield length, is the largest among that of stem-tetrapods. The pineal foramen is anteriorly positioned, corresponding to the midpoint of the orbits.
Tungsenia resembles Kenichthys4,5 and basal dipnomorphs (for example, Youngolepis and Powichthys)22,23,24 in the medioventrally directed snout, the infraorbital sensory canal running along the suture between the premaxillary and neighbouring bones, the broad orbital tectum and the well-developed basipterygoid processes (Fig. 2a–g). The elongated, broad parasphenoid and the paired internasal pits (Fig. 2b; Supplementary Fig. S3b) are shared with primitive sarcopterygian Styloichthys and basal dipnomorphs8,22,24,25, but differing from the remainder of the stem-tetrapods4,26,27,28(Supplementary Fig. S4). A teardrop-shaped recess (Fig. 2c) is located anterodorsal to the optic foramen. A similar recess is also found in many finned stem-tetrapods, such as Gogonasus, Medoevia, Cladarosymblema and Litoptychus, and has been interpreted as the attachment area for eye muscle26,28,29,30,31.
Other features shared with stem-tetrapods include the opening for the pituitary vein at the base of the basipterygoid process and a flat parasymphysial dental plate1,30. A large pair of fangs on the parasymphysial plate (Fig. 2j; Supplementary Fig. S3c,e) is comparable to that in limbed stem-tetrapods (for example, Ichthyostega and Acanthostega)32, but absent in finned stem-tetrapods, suggesting that the parasymphysial fang pair has evolved in parallel within the tetrapod lineage. A compound cheek plate, comprising a fused squamosal+quadratojugal+preopercular (Fig. 3a), is similar to that in the dipnomorph Youngolepis and some finned stem-tetrapods (Supplementary Fig. S5a–c)33,34,35. As inferred from the anterior overlap area on the cheek plate, the postorbital bone was proportionally large as in the rhizodont Barameda36 (Supplementary Fig. S5d).
A reconstruction of the skull and endocast based on high-resolution computed tomography (HRCT) (Figs 2h and 4; Supplementary Movies 1 and 2) reveals an unexpected combination of brain features seen in Tungsenia. The short olfactory tracts and the anteriorly extending brain cavity recall the conditions in fossil sharks and placoderms37,38 (Supplementary Fig. S9). Besides, the brain and nerves exhibit a previously unrecognized mosaic of tetrapod and lungfish traits. The olfactory tracts of Tungsenia resemble those of basal dipnomorphs (for example, Porolepis and Glyptolepis)25 in anteriorly diverging with an angle up to 60°. Posteriorly, the space for the hemispheres (cerebral cavity) is swollen and enlarged, comparable to that in many other stem-tetrapods27,39. Although the enlargement of the hemispheres has independently evolved among different major groups such as cartilaginous fishes and ray-finned fishes, the evidence from Tungsenia suggests that the enlarged hemispheres in the tetrapodomorphs appeared during the incipient stage of their evolution (Fig. 5).
Immediately behind the cerebral cavity, the neuro-epiphysial recess presents laterally adjacent pineal and parapineal organs (Fig. 4a) as in basal dipnomorphs25,40. However, unlike other rhipidistians (the lungfish plus tetrapod lineages)41, these two organs do not extend forward or form canal-like structures. The mesencephalic portion is more than half of the length of the cranial cavity, which recalls the condition in placoderms38. Laterally, both trigeminal and profundus nerves emerge through foramina in the ethmosphenoid (Fig. 4a), like those of Youngolepis and Powichthys22,40. The hypophysial fossa (Fig. 4b), as in Youngolepis and Powichthys, is stout and triangular. However, the fossa is placed in a far more posterior position relative to the optic nerve root. A pair of tongue-like recesses at the front of the hypophysial fossa (Fig. 4b) may topologically correspond to the paired neurocranial structures housing the pars tuberalis (PT) in living urodeles (Supplementary Fig. S8). Incidentally, a paired tube-like structure at the front of the hypophysial fossa in the dipnomorph Glyptolepis was identified as the ‘pars tuberalis’ (PT)25,27. However, it differs from the condition in Tungsenia and living urodeles in connecting directly with the brain cavity25, and additional investigation of the ‘PT’ of Glyptolepis is required. The distal part of the hypophysial fossa of Tungsenia is connected with a complex of parallel canals for blood vessels, as in Youngolepis and Powichthys22,40. The hypophysial canal is funnel-shaped, extending posteriorly to set its opening on the parasphenoid far from the optic nerve exit (Fig. 4c; Supplementary Fig. S8a,b).
A phylogenetic analysis of 38 taxa, including 21 stem-tetrapods, shows that Tungsenia is at the most basal position of the tetrapod stem lineage (Fig. 6; Supplementary Figs S1 and S2). At least two unambiguous synapomorphies demonstrate the stem-tetrapod affinity of Tungsenia: the pituitary vein opening anteroventral to the basipterygoid process, and the flat parasymphysial plate of mandible.
The basal phylogenetic position, unique character combination and earlier occurrence of Tungsenia have wide implications for the study of the tetrapod ancestry. First, Tungsenia pushes back the fossil record of tetrapods by some 10 million years into the Pragian. As a result, the first appearance of the tetrapod total group has now been drawn far closer to the estimated time of the lungfish–tetrapod split7.
Second, Tungsenia displays a mixture of endocranial features previously found either in basal dipnomorphs (for example, paired internasal pits, broad parasphenoid and exits for trigeminal and profundus nerves in the parietal shield) or in tetrapodomorphs (for example, the position of the pituitary vein opening). It further fills in the morphological gap between tetrapods and lungfishes, and unveils the evolutionary pattern of character changes during the initial diversification of stem-tetrapods. Different from the mosaic cranial features, the mandible of Tungsenia displays undisputed stem-tetrapod features, suggesting that, at the early stage of the tetrapod evolution, changes in mandible were faster than changes in endocranium.
Last, the HRCT study of Tungsenia provides unique insights into the incipient stage of tetrapod brain evolution. For a long time, our knowledge of the brain evolution in stem-tetrapods was limited owing to a small selection of well-studied taxa27,38,39,42. Thus, the investigation of the brain in Tungsenia, the basalmost stem-tetrapod, is crucial for revealing the acquisition sequence of tetrapod brain features. The digital endocast of Tungsenia shows many plesiomorphies shared with stem-lungfishes and non-sarcopterygian taxa, such as placoderms and early sharks. Such arrangement indicates that the accelerated brain modifications (for example, developed olfactory bulbs, longitudinally positioned pineal and parapineal canals, and shorten mesencephalon) of stem-tetrapods had happened crownward of Tungsenia. On the other hand, the inferred enlarged hemispheres of Tungsenia indicate that the enlargement of the hemispheres had occurred at the beginning of the tetrapod evolution. In addition, although the homologous comparisons among the PT of living tetrapods, the ‘PT’ of Glyptolepis and the paired tongue-like recesses of Tungsenia still need additional investigations to test, the newly identified recesses in an early stem-tetrapod seem to provide a potential to recognize that the PT, a structure linked with some adaptation necessary for terrestrial living modes, had a deeper origin than previously considered.
A phylogenetic analysis was performed on a matrix of 263 characters scored for 38 taxa (see Supplementary Methods). All characters were treated as unordered, and weighted equally. The resulting data matrix was subjected to the parsimony analysis in PAUP* (version 4.0b10)43 using a heuristic search, with Guiyu, Psarolepis and Achoania (basal osteichthyans) specified as the outgroup.
The analysis generated five most parsimonious trees with 579 steps (Consistency index=0.5250; Homoplasy index=0.4750; Retention index=0.7255; and Rescaled consistency index=0.3809). All trees show Tungsenia as the most basal stem-tetrapod. The strict consensus tree (Supplementary Fig. S1a) highlights the poor phylogenetic resolution of the ‘Osteolepiformes’.
HRCT data were acquired at the Australian National University in 2007. Spatial resolution was set to 11.9 μm, (1024)3 16-bit voxels, 80 kV and 60 mA. Slice data derived from the scans were then analysed and manipulated using Drishti software. The three-dimensional reconstructions were created in the Mimics (v13.1) software. The images of the reconstructions were exported from Mimics and VG Studio Max (v2.0), and finalized in Adobe Photoshop.
This published work and the nomenclatural acts it contains have been registered in ZooBank, the proposed online registration system for the International Code of Zoological Nomenclature (ICZN). The ZooBank LSIDs (Life Science Identifiers) can be resolved and the associated information viewed through any standard web browser by appending the LSID to the prefix ‘http://zoobank.org/’. The LSID for this publication is: urn:lsid:zoobank.org:act:39677617-77C8-4144-800E-59C595E66DE8; urn:lsid:zoobank.org:pub:F80BD663-B04C-46E9-A245-1DCF0FB8383B.
How to cite this article: Lu, J. et al. The earliest known stem-tetrapod from the Lower Devonian of China. Nat. Commun. 3:1160 doi: 10.1038/ncomms2170 (2012).
Ahlberg P.E., Johanson Z. Osteolepiforms and the ancestry of tetrapods. Nature 395, 792–794 (1998)
Coates M.I., Ruta M., Friedman M. Ever since Owen: changing perspectives on the early evolution of tetrapods. Ann. Rev. Ecol. Evol. Syst. 39, 571–592 (2008)
Clack J.A. Gaining Ground—The Origin and Evolution of Tetrapods Indiana University Press (2002)
Zhu M., Ahlberg P.E. The origin of the internal nostril of tetrapods. Nature 432, 94–97 (2004)
Chang M.-M., Zhu M. A new Middle Devonian osteolepidid from Qujing, Yunnan. Mem. Assoc. Australas. Palaeontol. 15: 183–198 (1993)
Zhu M., Fan J.-H. Youngolepis from the Xishancun Formation (Early Lochkovian) of Qujing, China. Geobios M. S. 19: 293–299 (1995)
Müller J., Reisz R.R. Four well-constrained calibration points from the vertebrate fossil record for molecular clock estimates. BioEssays 27: 1069–1075 (2005)
Zhu M., Yu X.-B. A primitive fish close to the common ancestor of tetrapods and lungfish. Nature 418, 767–770 (2002)
Wang J.-Q., Fan J.-H., Zhu M. Early vertebrate fossils from the Early Devonian of Zhaotong District, northeastern Yunnan. Vertebr. PalAsiat. 34, 1–17 (1996)
Liu Y.-H. Lower Devonian agnathans of Yunnan and Sichuan. Vertebr. PalAsiat. 13, 202–216 (1975)
Pan J., Wang S.-T. New discoveries of polybranchiaspids from Yunnan Province. Vertebr. PalAsiat. 19: 113–121 (1981)
Wang J.-Q., Zhu M. Zhaotongaspis janvieri gen. et sp. nov., a galeaspid from Early Devonian of Zhaotong, northeastern Yunnan. Vertebr. PalAsiat. 32, 231–243 (1994)
Ji S.-A., Pan J. New Devonian petalichthyids (Placodermi) from eastern Yunnan, China. Professional Pap. Strat. Palaeontol. 27: 172–179 (1999)
Dupret V. A new wuttagoonaspid (Placodermi, Arthrodira) from the Lower Devonian of Yunnan (South China): origin, dispersal, and paleobiogeographic significance. J. Vertebr. Paleontol. 28: 12–20 (2008)
Zhu M., Janvier P. Un onychodontide (Vertebrata, Sarcopterygii) du Dévonien inférieur de Chine. Compt. Rend. Sci., Ser. II 319, 951–956 (1994)
Lu J., Zhu M. An Early Devonian (Pragian) sarcopterygian from Zhaotong, Yunnan, China. Vertebr. PalAsiat. 46: 161–170 (2008)
Lu J., Zhu M. An onychodont fish (Osteichthyes, Sarcopterygii) from the Early Devonian of China, and the evolution of the Onychodontiformes. Proc. R. Soc. B 277, 293–299 (2010)
Zhu M. et al. Earliest known coelacanth skull extends the range of anatomically modern coelacanths to the Early Devonian. Nat. Commun. 3, 772 (2012)
Liao W.-H., Xu H.-K., Wang C.-Y. In Symposium on the Devonian System of South China (ed. Inst. Geol. Min. Res.)193–213Geological Press (1978)
Xian S.-Y., Zhou X.-Y. In Symposium on the Devonian System of South China (ed. Inst. Geol. Min. Res.)176–183Geological Press (1978)
Yun Y. In Symposium on the Devonian System of South China (ed. Inst. Geol. Min. Res.)151–166Geological Press (1978)
Chang M.-M. The Braincase of Youngolepis, a Lower Devonian Crossopterygian from Yunnan, South-western China. Thesis, Stockholm Univ. (1982)
Jessen H.L. In Problèmes actuels de Paleontologie: Evolution des Vertébrés ed. Lehman J.P. 213–222Colloques Internationaux CNRS (1975)
Jessen H.L. Lower Devonian Porolepiformes from the Canadian Arctic with special reference to Powichthys thorsteinssoni Jessen. Palaeontogr. A 167: 180–214 (1980)
Jarvik E. Middle and Upper Devonian Porolepiformes from East Greenland with special reference to Glyptolepis groenlandica n. sp., and a discussion on the structure of the head in the Porolepiformes. Meddr. Grønland 187, 1–307 (1972)
Long J.A., Barwick R.E., Campbell K.S.W. Osteology and functional morphology of the osteolepiform fish Gogonasus andrewsae Long, 1985, from the Upper Devonian Gogo Formation, Western Australia. Recs. W. A. Mus 53: 1–89 (1997)
Jarvik E. Basic Structure and Evolution of Vertebrates. Vol. 1: (Academic Press (1980)
Lebedev O.A. Morphology of a new osteolepidid fish from Russia. Bull. Mus. Nat. Hist. Nat. C 17, 287–341 (1995)
Fox R.C., Campbell K.S.W., Barwick R.E., Long J.A. A new osteolepiform fish from the Lower Carboniferous Raymond Formation, Drummond Basin, Queensland. Mem. Queensl. Mus. 38: 97–221 (1995)
Coates M.I., Friedman M. In Morphology, Phylogeny and Paleobiogeography of Fossil Fishes eds Elliott D.K., Maisey J.G., Yu X.-B., Miao D.-S. 389–416Verlag Dr. Friedrich Pfei (2010)
Long J.A. A new osteolepidid fish from the Upper Devonian Gogo Formation, western Australia. Rec. W. A. Mus. 12, 361–377 (1985)
Ahlberg P.E., Clack J.A. Lower jaws, lower tetrapods—a review based on the Devonian genus Acanthostega. T. Roy. Soc. Edin. Earth Sci. 88, 11–46 (1998)
Chang M.-M., Yu X.-B. Reexamination of the relationship of Middle Devonian osteolepids—fossil characters and their interpretations. Am. Mus. Novit. 3189, 1–20 (1997)
Chang M.-M. InEarly Vertebrates and Related Problems of Evolutionary Biology. eds Chang M.-M., Liu Y.-H., Zhang G.-R. 355–378Science Press (1991)
Fan J.-H. A new species of Thursius from Wuding, Yunnan. Vertebr. PalAsiat. 30, 195–209 (1992)
Long J.A. A new rhizodontiform fish from the Early Carboniferous of Victoria, Australia, with remarks on the phylogenetic position of the group. J. Vertebr. Paleontol. 9: 1–17 (1989)
Maisey J.G. The braincase in Paleozoic symmoriiform and cladoselachian sharks. Bull. Am. Mus. Nat. Hist. 307, 1–122 (2007)
Stensiö E.A. The brain and the cranial nerves in fossil lower craniate vertebrates. Skr. Norske. VidenskAkad. Oslo, Mat.-Naturv. Kl. 13, 1–120 (1963)
Snitting D. A redescription of the anatomy of the Late Devonian Spodichthys buetleri Jarvik, 1985 (Sarcopterygii, Tetrapodomorpha) from East Greenland. J. Vertebr. Paleontol. 28, 637–655 (2008)
Clément G., Ahlberg P.E. In Morphology, Phylogeny and Paleobiogeography of Fossil Fishes eds Elliott D.K., Maisey J.G., Yu X.-B., Miao D.-S. 363–377Verlag Dr. Friedrich Pfeil (2010)
Ahlberg P.E. A re-examination of sarcopterygian interrelationships, with special reference to the Porolepiformes. Zool. J. Linn. Soc. 103, 241–287 (1991)
Romer A.S. The braincase of the Carboniferous crossopterygian Megalichthys nitidus. Bull. Mus. Comp. Zool. 82, 1–73 (1937)
Swofford D.L. PAUP*: Phylogenetic Analysis Using Parsimony (* and Other Methods), Version 4.0b 10 Sinauer Associates (2003))
Striedter G.F. Principles of Brain Evolution Sinauer Associates (2004)
Nieuwenhuys R. InThe Central Nervous System of Vertebrates. eds Nieuwenhuys R., Donkelaar H.J., Nicholson C. 273–326Springer (1998)
Niedźwiedzki G., Szrek P., Narkiewicz K., Narkiewicz M., Ahlberg P.E. Tetrapod trackways from the early Middle Devonian period of Poland. Nature 463, 43–48 (2010)
We thank M.-M. Chang, X.-B. Yu, P. Ahlberg, B. Choo and G. Young for discussions; X.-F. Lu and C.-H. Xiong for specimen preparation; J.-L. Huang for illustrations; and B. Choo for life restoration. This work was supported by the Major State Basic Research Projects (2012CB821902) of MST of China, the National Natural Science Foundation of China (40930208 and 41102010), the Chinese Academy of Sciences (KZCX2-YW-156), State Key Laboratory of Palaeobiology and Straigraphy, and the ARC Discovery grant (DP0772138).
The authors declare no competing financial interests.
Supplementary Figures S1-S9, Supplementary Table S1, Supplementary Methods and Supplementary References. (PDF 2248 kb)
The virtual braincase and endocast of specimen IVPP V10687 (holotype of Tungsenia paradoxa gen. et sp. nov.). (MOV 1952 kb)
HRCT slices of specimen IVPP V10687 (holotype of Tungsenia paradoxa gen. et sp. nov.) in horizontal section. (MOV 5965 kb)
About this article
Cite this article
Lu, J., Zhu, M., Long, J. et al. The earliest known stem-tetrapod from the Lower Devonian of China. Nat Commun 3, 1160 (2012). https://doi.org/10.1038/ncomms2170
A new onychodont (Osteichthyes; Sarcopterygii) from the Middle Devonian of Morocco and its bearing on early osteichthyan evolution
Journal of Systematic Palaeontology (2020)
Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences (2020)
Asia–Gondwana connections indicated by Devonian fishes from Australia: palaeogeographic considerations
Journal of Palaeogeography (2020)
New information on the giant Devonian lobe-finned fish Edenopteron from the New South Wales south coast
Australian Journal of Earth Sciences (2020)
Tristichopterids (Sarcopterygii, Tetrapodomorpha) from the Upper Devonian tetrapod-bearing locality of Strud (Belgium, upper Famennian), with phylogenetic and paleobiogeographic considerations
Journal of Vertebrate Paleontology (2020)