Fossil feathers, hairs and eyes are regularly preserved as carbonized traces comprised of masses of micrometre-sized bodies that are spherical, oblate or elongate in shape. For a long time, these minute structures were regarded as the remains of biofilms of keratinophilic bacteria, but recently they have been reinterpreted as melanosomes; that is, colour-bearing organelles. Resolving this fundamental difference in interpretation is crucial: if endogenous then the fossil microbodies would represent a significant advancement in the fields of palaeontology and evolutionary biology given, for example, the possibility to reconstruct integumentary colours and plumage colour patterns. It has previously been shown that certain trace elements occur in fossils as organometallic compounds, and hence may be used as biomarkers for melanin pigments. Here we expand this knowledge by demonstrating the presence of molecularly preserved melanin in intimate association with melanosome-like microbodies isolated from an argentinoid fish eye from the early Eocene of Denmark.
In vertebrate animals, melanins are complex, polymeric pigments located in a variety of tissues, including the skin, hair, feathers and eyes, where they serve a number of important biological functions, such as protection against short-wavelength light1,2. Additionally, they provide the integument and its appendages with the majority of black, grey, brown and reddish tones, thereby contributing to camouflage, thermoregulation and social signalling3. Melanins are synthesized and packaged in melanosomes; that is, lysosome-related organelles generated by melanocytes and pigment-epithelial cells4. Melanosomes are typically between 500 and 2000 nm in the long axis direction and they occur in a broad array of shapes, ranging from sub-spherical to distinctly ellipsoidal4. Whereas melanin granules are stored permanently in eye pigment cells, mature dermal melanosomes migrate from melanocytes to neighbouring keratinocytes (keratin-producing cells) for ultimate incorporation into developing feathers and hairs to create colour patterning3,4.
Putative fossil melanosomes have been described from feathers, hairs and vertebrate eyes dating to the Jurassic, and are preserved primarily as carbonaceous traces5,6,7,8,9,10,11,12,13,14,15,16,17, although replication by authigenic minerals also has been reported7,18. If indeed being the remains of ancient pigment organelles, then these microbodies would greatly improve our understanding of, for example, the evolutionary origin, function and colouration of feathers in extinct animals8,9,10,11,13,14,15,16,17. However, because both the shape and size of melanosomes correspond well with those of bacteria8,10,13, it is necessary to distinguish the two. Previous claims of melanosomes in multimillion-year-old animals have been based chiefly on structure8,9,10,11,16,17, although some trace elements that are present in fossil soft tissues rich in melanosome-like microbodies recently have been suggested to possess melanin affinity15. Nonetheless, because microorganisms are capable of adsorbing and concentrating trace metals19, a deeper understanding of the chemistry of the proposed fossil melanosomes is needed to avoid controversies and plausible alternative interpretations13,20.
Here we demonstrate that the organic content of melanosome-like microbodies isolated from a fossil fish eye is dominated by the pigment melanin. This result was obtained by time-of-flight secondary ion mass spectrometry (ToF-SIMS)—a powerful technique capable of simultaneous identification and mapping of molecules and chemical structures in biological samples at high spatial resolution21—combined with infrared (IR) microspectroscopy, transmission electron microscopy (TEM) and scanning electron microscopy (SEM).
Identification of microbodies in a fossil fish eye
The material examined, a virtually complete argentinoid fish (Museum Salling—Fur Museum; FUM-N-2050), was collected from the early Eocene (~54 Ma) Fur Formation of Denmark22,23, without application of preservatives (see Supplementary Methods online). The specimen is flattened but otherwise well preserved, comprising an almost complete and articulated skeleton with a distinct brownish pigmentation located firmly within the orbit (Fig. 1a,b). Under SEM, the dark matter showed masses of sub-spherical, oblate and prolate bodies, about 400–1500 nm long (Fig. 1c). Additionally, elemental mapping using EDX (energy-dispersive X-ray spectrometry) revealed that the eye contains more carbon (and slightly more sulphur) than do the surrounding bony tissues and sediments (Supplementary Fig. S1). Microbodies studied under TEM revealed a largely homogenous internal content consisting of dense matter (Supplementary Fig. S2).
Localization of melanin to the fossil fish eye
To analyse the molecular content of the melanosome-like bodies, samples of grains were removed from the eye (as well as from other parts of the fossil and surrounding sediments) using a sterile scalpel, and subjected to ToF-SIMS analysis. The resulting mass spectra, which are formed by secondary ions emitted from the sample surface when a focussed beam of high energy ions is scanned over it, provide spatially resolved molecular information and a detailed chemical fingerprint of the sample surface. A close agreement was observed between spectra obtained from the eye of FUM-N-2050 and that of a natural melanin standard, both with regard to the positions of the observed peaks and their intensity distributions (Fig. 1e; Supplementary Fig. S3). The striking spectral agreement between the fossil fish eye and the melanin standard strongly suggests that the former contains high concentrations of melanin. Furthermore, the signal intensity in terms of number of detected secondary ions per incident primary ion (that is, secondary ion (SI) yield) in the fish eye spectrum (Supplementary Table S1) is comparable to that of the melanin standard spectrum (the low counts in the former spectrum is a consequence of it representing only a small portion of the total analysis area, see caption to Fig. 1e), which is also consistent with melanin being a major molecular constituent of the analysed surface.
The spectrum from the eye of FUM-N-2050 presented in Fig. 1e was obtained from within the ~4 μm2 area enclosed by the purple line in Fig. 1d (which, according to a SEM image of the same area, contains almost exclusively melanosome-like microbodies). Moreover, an ion image showing the spatial signal intensity distribution of characteristic melanin peaks (selected from the melanin standard spectrum; Fig. 1e) superimposed onto the SEM image (Fig. 1d), clearly demonstrates that the signal intensity from the characteristic melanin peaks spatially correlates with the melanosome-like structures (see also Supplementary Figs S4, S5). ToF-SIMS spectra from other parts of FUM-N-2050, including the skull, body and surrounding sediments, were distinctively different from those obtained from the microbody-rich eye (Fig. 2a), to suggest dissimilar chemical compositions of primarily inorganic components, such as phosphates (skull and body) and silicates (body and sediments).
Although the data obtained at high spatial resolution demonstrate that the melanin-like spectra originate from the melanosome-like microbodies (Fig. 1d,e), high mass resolution spectra from the fossil fish eye showed peak positions virtually indistinguishable from those of the melanin standard (Table 1; Supplementary Fig. S3), thereby corroborating their assignments to melanin. Furthermore, all major peaks in the high mass resolution spectra from the natural melanin standard and fossil fish eye (as well as from a synthetic melanin standard; Supplementary Fig. S3) can be tentatively assigned to fragment ions that are consistent with the chemical structure of nitrogen-rich melanins (Fig. 3, Table 1)24.
These observations were corroborated by IR microspectroscopy consistent with previous infrared studies of fossil melanin14,15. The vibrational spectrum for the fossil microbodies is presented along with a spectrum for a natural melanin standard and other tissues and sediments of FUM-N-2050 in Fig. 2b. There are clear and significant similarities between the two spectra representing the fossil microbodies and the melanin standard, to suggest a similar molecular structure and composition25. In contrast, the spectra obtained from the skull, body and sediments are considerably different from the melanin standard, and instead they are consistent with calcite, apatite and quartz; that is, minerals expected to be found in these parts of the specimen (Fig. 2b).
The molecular analyses performed in this study demonstrate that the chemical composition of the fossil microbodies variably assigned to as bacterial biofilms5,6,12 or melanosomes8,9,10,11,14,15,16,17, at least in FUM-N-2050, is dominated by melanin or a molecular structure very similar to this pigment. Although microorganisms can synthesize melanins26, we argue against the possibility that the melanin-containing structures represent replacement bacteria because the pigment is highly concentrated and localized specifically to melanosome-like bodies in a tissue where melanin must have been a major constituent in life (cf. retinal melanosomes in an extant three-spined stickleback fish eye; Fig. 4). Additionally, it has previously been shown that melanosome-like bodies only occur in dark bands of fossil-banded feathers8, and that their organization and layering ultrastructure are identical to those of coloured feathers in extant birds9. Furthermore, it was recently demonstrated that certain trace elements, such as copper and zinc, are present in both ancient and modern melanosome-bearing tissues, and hence may act as biomarkers for melanin-derived compounds in fossils15. Finally, our ToF-SIMS analyses of various types of modern microbial mats (Supplementary Figs S6, S7) revealed chemical signatures that were significantly different from those of melanins, something that was particularly obvious in high-resolution mass spectra (Supplementary Fig. S7). The molecular specificity of the ToF-SIMS and IR microspectroscopic results was also tested by acquiring spectra of hemin chloride and chlorophyll a—two porphyrin-related compounds with molecular structures similar to that of melanin (Supplementary Fig. S8)—and comparing these spectra to those of the fossil fish eye and melanin standards. These compounds were chosen because chlorophylls and cytochromes (that is, heme derivates) are generally considered as the main biological precursors of so-called 'fossil porphyrins' (or 'geoporphyrins'), which are common in sediments containing organic matter27,28. Although the resulting mass spectra from melanin, hemin chloride and chlorophyll a have several peaks in common, their intensity distributions were distinctly different from one another (Supplementary Fig. S9). Importantly, whereas the two porphyrin-related compounds showed a number of peaks with very similar intensity distributions (which are probably related to the ring-structure of porphyrins), a close spectral agreement in the entire mass range up to m/z 160 was found only between the fossil fish eye and melanin standards. These results were corroborated by IR data that clearly discriminate between melanin and the two porphyrin-related compounds (Supplementary Figs S10, S11). Hence, we conclude that the microbodies examined herein are indeed the fossilized remains of colour-bearing organelles and that they contain high concentrations of the living organism's original chemistry; that is, components of melanin derived from the pigments of the eye. From our ToF-SIMS analyses of modern retinal melanosomes, it is also clear that other biomolecules, such as proteins and lipids, are essentially gone in the ancient pigment organelles. This suggests that the process of fossilization purifies melanin, whereas more labile organic molecules degrade and disappear. The astonishing stability of melanin, even over deep time, is likely a consequence of its biological role as an energy transducer. Protection against energetic photons (that is, blue and ultra-violet light), as well as quenching of free radicals, are possible because melanin can accommodate both optical and chemical energy and dissipate it as heat, thereby greatly reducing the rate of degradation29,30. Because the various physical properties of modern melanins likely are connected to different biological functions31,32, our discovery has vast potential to extend the utility of molecular structures over deep time, thereby opening a window, based on molecular data, for enhanced understanding of the life and behaviour of animals long extinct.
FUM-N-2050 was collected by one of us (B. P. Schultz) from the Fur Formation of Denmark, without application of preservatives. The fossil was wrapped in aluminium foil and kept isolated within a sealable plastic container until being examined. Fresh aluminium foil was used to cover all work areas, and surgical gloves and sterile scalpels were used in all handling and preparation. Treatment of modern reference samples was identical to that of the fossil structures for all analyses. All experiments were repeated to validate the results.
Scanning electron microscopy
Samples selected for SEM analysis were mounted on glass slides or aluminium blocks using double-sided tape. Initial screening was performed using a Hitachi S-3400N scanning electron microscope on uncoated samples under low vacuum, and the elemental composition was determined via elemental mapping using EDX analysis (1900 s scanning time at 15 kV, 62.0 μA and a working distance of 10 mm). Following ToF-SIMS analysis, the samples were sputter-coated with gold and re-examined using a Zeiss Supra 40VP FEG scanning electron microscope (2 kV, working distance 3–5 mm, Everhart–Thornley secondary electron detector).
Transmission electron microscopy
Microbodies were removed from the eye of FUM-N-2050 using a sterile scalpel and placed in pure alcohol. The alcohol was replaced with acetone, which in turn was stepwise substituted with epoxy resin (AGAR 100 Resin kit, R1031), thereby infiltrating the tissues. The epoxy was left to polymerize at 60 °C for 48 h. Infiltrated samples were first trimmed with a razor blade and then 2 μm thick sections were cut using a glass knife mounted on an ultrotome. Cut sections were stained with Azur-2 methylene blue and examined under a light microscope for a general overview. For the ultra-thin sectioning a diamond knife was used, cutting 50 nm thick slices that were applied to copper grids. The grids were treated with lead citrate and uranyl acetate for increased contrast and then inserted into a JEOL JEM-1230 transmission electron microscope. The microscope ran at 80 keV and sites of interest were photographed using a MultiScan 701 camera.
Time-of-flight secondary ion mass spectrometry
ToF-SIMS analyses in the static SIMS mode were performed in a ToF-SIMS IV instrument (IONTOF GmbH) using 25 keV Bi3+ primary ions and low-energy electron flooding for charge compensation. High mass resolution data were acquired in the bunched mode (m/Δm ~5000) at a spatial resolution of ~3–4 μm, whereas high-image resolution data were obtained without bunching (m/Δm ~300, spatial resolution ~0.2–0.5 μm); in both cases at 256×256 pixels. Because the positive ion spectra were found to show strong interference with the signal from the sedimentary matrix, only negative ion data are presented herein. The coordinates for all positions investigated were monitored to allow for subsequent SEM analysis of the same areas.
For ToF-SIMS analyses, fossil tissues and sediments were removed using a sterile scalpel and deposited on a substrate of double-sided tape. The synthetic melanin standard was analysed in its powder form, also after deposition on double-sided tape, whereas the Sepia melanin standard was first rinsed in deionized water to remove salts (mainly NaCl) and then deposited on a clean silicon wafer and allowed to air dry. The modern retinal melanosomes were deposited on a silicon wafer and air dried before analysis.
ToF-SIMS is a method designed for surface analysis, and it provides mass spectra from the outermost molecular layers (1–10 nm) of solid sample surfaces. During analysis, a focused beam of high-energy (primary) ions bombards the sample, thereby causing emission of molecules, molecular fragments and atoms (neutral and ionized) from its surface. The ionized fraction of the emitted particles is directed into a time-of-flight mass analyser to produce a mass spectrum. By scanning the primary ion beam over a preselected analysis area on the sample surface, separate mass spectra can be acquired from each raster point within the selected area (typically, 256×256 raster points and areas ranging in size from 50×50 to 500×500 μm2 are examined). The recorded data can be presented in various ways, including: ion images that show the spatial distribution of the signal intensity from selected ions over the analysed area (where pixel brightness reflects the signal intensity); mass spectra from the total analysed area; or mass spectra from selected regions within the analysed area.
Extensive fragmentation of the molecular species on primary ion bombardment was previously a problem; however, modern cluster primary ion sources (Bin+, C60+) reduce this fragmentation considerably, thereby enabling analysis of molecular species of up to around 2000 Da. For larger molecules, such as proteins and polymers, detailed chemical characterization is possible by using characteristic fragment ions, or, preferably (as in this work) patterns of peaks from characteristic fragment ions.
During mass analysis, the primary ions bombard the sample surface in short pulses, and the achievable mass resolution is determined by the shortest possible pulse duration. In contrast, the attainable image resolution is limited by the focus diameter of the primary ion beam. As both the mass resolution and image resolution cannot be at their maxima at the same time (mainly due to space-charge effects), the ToF-SIMS instrument is normally optimized either for maximum mass resolution (bunched mode) or for maximum image resolution (burst alignment mode). In the present contribution, data in the bunched mode were gathered at a mass resolution of m/Δm=5000 and a lateral resolution of 3–5 μm, whereas data in the burst alignment mode were acquired at a mass resolution of around m/Δm=300 and a lateral resolution down to about 300 nm. However, the lateral resolution also depends on the achievable signal per area unit, which is different for different compounds and monitored ions. Data from the two melanin standards were obtained in the bunched mode to use the high mass resolution for assignment of the peak ions (Table 1). For the fossil sample, the data presented herein were acquired both in the burst alignment mode (Fig. 1; Supplementary Figs S3–S5) and in the bunched mode (Table 1, Fig. 2a; Supplementary Figs S3, S6, S7, and S9). High image resolution was used to allow for reconstruction of mass spectra from small structures, such as individual melanosome-like microbodies in the eye of FUM-N-2050 (these data could then be correlated with microstructures imaged under SEM). The possibility to obtain mass spectra from well-defined, small-sized areas is important when the analyte is localized to specific parts of the surface, thereby minimizing contributions from other compounds that are present at higher concentrations in other regions of the sample surface. However, the sample from the fossil fish eye contained relatively large areas in which the spectra were dominated by melanin, thus allowing for acquisition of data also in the bunched mode (Table 1, Fig. 2a; Supplementary Figs S3, S6, S7, and S9).
ToF-SIMS is generally not used for absolute quantification, owing mainly to matrix effects leading to variations in signal intensities for different chemical environments of the analyte. However, relative quantification; that is, quantification of concentration ratios between different specific compounds, is possible at a semi-quantitative level by using relative sensitivity factors, which can be obtained by analysing standard mixture samples of known composition. To estimate the amount of analyte on the surface from a ToF-SIMS spectrum, it is therefore not the absolute signal intensity (that is, counts) that is primarily relevant but instead the analyte signal intensity relative to the signal intensity from other compounds in the spectrum. In the present work, the fossil fish eye spectra are clearly dominated by peaks characteristic of melanins (based on the spectra from the two melanin standards; Supplementary Fig. S3), whereas peaks that are not present in the melanin standard spectra provide much smaller contributions. Thus, it is possible to conclude that melanin constitutes a major component of the sampled area. Moreover, the low absolute intensities (that is, counts) of the fossil spectra are not a result of low amounts of melanin on the sample surface, but instead reflect the fact that these spectra were reconstructed from very small parts of the analysis areas from which the measurements were taken. Calculation of the number of secondary ions produced per incident primary ion (that is, the secondary ion yield) for selected peaks in the fossil fish eye spectra provides values very similar to those of the melanin standard (Supplementary Table S1); again consistent with high melanin concentrations in these areas.
Compared with other mass spectrometry techniques, such as MALDI-MS/MS or ESI-MS/MS, the main advantage of ToF-SIMS is that it allows for mass spectrometry analysis of solid sample surfaces at sub-micrometre spatial resolution without any pre-treatment of the samples. This means that ToF-SIMS is capable of molecular mapping and mass spectrometry analysis of very small structures (<1 μm) embedded in a surrounding matrix; capabilities that were critical when obtaining the data in the present study.
Typically, analysis is done by introducing the entire specimen into the instrument (subject to space limitations, which in our case are ~60×80×6 (height) mm) and navigating to the area of interest using built-in video cameras. In the present case, however, the fossil gave rise to an unacceptably high pressure in the instrument, rendering it necessary to remove small (~0.5 mm in diameter) samples for analysis.
It should also be pointed out that because only the outermost molecular layers of the sample surface are probed during ToF-SIMS analysis, potential contaminations must be carefully considered. Additionally, the choice of proper controls and/or standards is essential for meaningful comparisons. For further practical and methodological information about the use of ToF-SIMS for analysis of geological samples, the reader is referred to Thiel and Sjövall21.
Microbodies and other fossil tissues and sediments were removed from FUM-N-2050 using a sterile scalpel, suspended in deionized water, and then placed on sterile CaF2 spectrophotometric windows and left to air dry under a hood at room temperature. Likewise, melanin standard samples were dissolved in deionized water and then casted onto CaF2 spectrophotometric plates. IR microspectroscopy was performed at beamline 73, MAX-IV laboratory, Lund University. The set up combines a Hyperion 3000 microscope and a Bruker IFS66/v FTIR spectrometer. All measurements were recorded in off-line mode using a conventional thermal light source. The microscope was operated in transmission mode with a 170×170 μm aperture using a ×15 objective and a condenser along with a single element, 100×100 μm MCT detector. This arrangement gives a visible magnification of ×215 for the video camera in the microscope used to locate relevant structures in the samples.
How to cite this article: Lindgren, J., et al. Molecular preservation of the pigment melanin in fossil melanosomes. Nat. Commun. 3:824 doi: 10.1038/ncomms1819 (2012).
R. Wallén, C. Alwmark, C. Rassmusen, P. Ekström, C. Heim and T. Leefmann assisted during the laboratory work. This research was supported by grants from the Swedish Research Council (J.L., P.U., D.E.N.), Knut and Alice Wallenberg foundation (P.U.), VINNOVA Swedish Governmental Agency for Innovation Systems (P.S.), the German Research Foundation (DFG Research Unit 571, V.T.) and the Royal Physiographic Society in Lund (J.L.).
Supplementary Figures S1-S12, Supplementary Table S1, Supplementary Methods and Supplementary References.
About this article
Scientific Reports (2017)