WNT10A is the most commonly mutated gene in human non-syndromic selective agenesis of permanent teeth1,2 and WNT10A mutations are also associated with the ectodermal dysplasia syndromes Odonto-onycho-dermal dysplasia (OMIM #257980) and Schöpf–Schulz–Passarge syndrome (OMIM #224750)3. Patients with WNT10A mutations exhibit variable developmental dental defects including microdontia of primary teeth, defective root and molar cusp formation, and complete absence of secondary dentition2,3. Non-dental anomalies, such as palmoplantar keratoderma, thinning hair, sweating abnormalities, a smooth tongue surface and defective nail growth, appear beginning in adolescence or even later4,5, suggesting possible roles for WNT10A in epithelial regeneration. In line with this, genome-wide association studies identified an association between a WNT10A intronic single-nucleotide polymorphism (SNP) that correlates with lower WNT10A mRNA levels, and male pattern baldness6. Delineating the basis for these phenotypes and the molecular mechanisms of WNT10A action will be crucial in understanding the developmental and regenerative functions of WNT10A, and designing potential therapeutic approaches for affected individuals.

Here we describe a new human pedigree carrying a predicted loss-of-function mutation in WNT10A and delineate the functions and mechanisms of WNT10A signalling in dental development and adult epithelial renewal by analysing human patient tissue and loss-of-function mouse mutants. We demonstrate that Wnt-activated self-renewing stem cells are present in the adult tissues affected by WNT10A mutation, and identify WNT10A/β-catenin signalling as a broadly used mechanism controlling epithelial progenitor proliferation. In addition to proliferative defects, we unexpectedly identified a requirement for WNT10A/β-catenin signalling in permitting regionally restricted, suprabasal differentiation programmes in tongue filiform papillae and palmoplantar epidermis, explaining the smooth tongue and palmoplantar keratoderma phenotypes observed in human patients. We show that in differentiating suprabasal cells, but not basal progenitor cells, β-catenin complexes with KLF4, a suprabasally restricted transcription factor required for epidermal differentiation programmes7,8, allowing β-catenin to switch from pro-proliferative to pro-differentiation modes. Our data further suggest activation of the β-catenin pathway as a potential means for restoring normal epithelial functions in WNT10A patients.


Human pedigree with a novel loss-of-function WNT10A mutation

Here we report a 41-year-old woman of Indian descent who contacted our dermatology clinic complaining of thinning hair (Fig. 1a), onychodystrophy (Fig. 1b), palmoplantar scaling (Fig. 1c,d) and decreased palmoplantar sweating (Fig. 1e,f). The patient’s tongue surface was abnormally smooth (Fig. 1g,h). Taste testing did not reveal decreased sensitivity to salt, sweet and bitter tastes (Fig. 1i,j); however, her affective (like versus dislike) taste response was blunted compared with her affective response to odors. Her low ability to taste quinine was concordant with genotyping for a TAS2R19 allele associated with quinine sensitivity (heterozygous A:G for rs10772420)9 and homozygosity for the non-taster diplotype (AVI/AVI) for bitter receptor gene TAS2R38 (ref. 10). She had low alveolar bone density and a history of severe dental defects including small, conical primary teeth with taurodontism, and complete failure of secondary dentition (Fig. 1k).

Figure 1: Clinical features associated with human WNT10A mutation.
figure 1

(a) Thinning hair. (b) Nail dystrophy. (c,d) Fissures and scaling on palms and soles. (e,f) Starch-iodine sweat testing. Note brown grains on control palm indicating sweat production, and decreased sweating in patient (arrows). Insets show higher magnification of areas indicated by the lower arrow in each photograph. (g,h) Smooth tongue surface. (i) Taste testing. Patient data (red line) is similar to comparison group except for quinine and PTC1 (bitter). DB, denatonium benzoate (bitter). Higher y axis values indicate greater intensity (scale, 1–12). Patient was tested twice; 1=trial 1; 2=trial 2. (j) Taste quality assessment. NComp, number of comparison subjects (Ntotal=41) who gave same response as patient. (k) Oral X-ray. Note decreased alveolar bone density and tooth root and cusp defects. (l) Splice donor site mutation and predicted truncated protein. (m) qPCR with primers indicated in l confirms aberrant splicing.

Genetic testing ruled out mutation of the ectodermal dysplasia-associated genes EDA, EDAR and EDARRAD11. Instead, the patient was homozygous for a single nucleotide G>A transversion at position c.756+1 (c.756+1 G>A) of WNT10A, which mutates a conserved mRNA splice donor site for intron 3 (Fig. 1l). The proband’s younger brother was homozygous for the same mutation and had similar symptoms including conical primary teeth, failure to develop permanent teeth, alopecia and palmoplantar scaling. Both parents were heterozygous carriers, and a male second cousin on her paternal side also reported dental abnormalities.

qPCR of WNT10A transcripts isolated from the patient’s plucked scalp hairs revealed the presence of normally spliced exon 1 and exon 2 transcripts at levels comparable to those detected in a similarly aged control female of Indian descent. However, transcripts resulting from splicing of intron 3 were present at <10% of control levels (Fig. 1m). The predicted translation product is truncated after amino acid 252 (Gln), resulting in absence of 16 of the 24 conserved C-terminal cysteine residues necessary for disulfide bridge formation, Wnt protein secondary structure12 and binding to Frizzled receptors13. As human patients with a wide range of different WNT10A mutations including homozygous missense mutations and mutations predicted to truncate the protein at nine amino acids3 display overlapping phenotypes, these likely result from loss of WNT10A function.

Localization of Wnt signalling and Wnt10a expression

Wnt/β-catenin signalling stabilizes cytoplasmic β-catenin, allowing it to accumulate and enter the nucleus where it associates with TCF/LEF family DNA-binding factors, and activates target gene expression. Wnt/β-catenin signalling is active in embryonic ectodermal appendages and is required for their formation14. In adult life, Wnt/β-catenin signalling localizes to interfollicular epidermis, hair follicles (HFs), and tongue filiform papillae and taste buds (TBs)15,16,17. Immunofluorescence detection of nuclear β-catenin, and analysis of Wnt/β-catenin reporter expression in Axin2lacZ, Axin2-CreERT2/tdT(Axin2-tdT) and TCF/Lef-H2B-GFP (TL-GFP) mice16,18,19 revealed signalling in additional tissues that show defects in WNT10A patients, including sweat gland germs; adult sweat gland ducts, but not secretory cells; footpad epidermis; and basal and differentiated TB cells in adult fungiform and circumvallate taste papillae (Fig. 2a–h). In tongue filiform papillae, Axin2-tdT expression localized to basal cells and both anterior HOXC13− and posterior HOXC13+ differentiating cells (Fig. 2i–i), while TL-GFP was expressed in LEF1+ basal and HOXC13− differentiating cells but not in HOXC13+ cells (Fig. 2j–k), indicating differential sensitivity of these reporters to Wnt signalling. In addition to Wnt activity in HF matrix, pre-cortical and dermal papilla (DP) cells, we also detected Wnt reporter expression in the HF dermal sheath, isthmus and sebaceous gland peripheral cells (Fig. 2l–n).

Figure 2: Wnt/β-catenin signalling and generation of Wnt10a mutant mice.
figure 2

(ac) TL-GFP localizes to sweat gland (SG) germs at P1 (a), and KRT8+ SG luminal cells at P10 (b), but not adult SG secretory cells (c). (d) Axin2lacZ localizes to sweat ducts (SD) and footpad epidermis (FE), but not SG secretory cells in adult footpad. (e) Nuclear and cytoplasmic β-catenin localizes to basal (white arrow) and suprabasal (yellow arrow) cells in adult sweat ducts. (f) Nuclear β-catenin localizes to basal (white arrow) and differentiated (yellow arrow) adult fungiform TB cells. (gg″) TL-GFP localizes to KRT14+ basal (white arrows) and KRT14− differentiated (yellow arrows) TB cells. (hh″) tdT expression (pink) in p63+ basal (white arrows) and p63− differentiating (yellow arrows) cells in Axin2-CreERT2/tdT (Axin2-tdT) circumvallate papillae. (ii″) tdT expression in posterior HOXC13+ (yellow arrows), anterior HOXC13− differentiating (red arrows) and HOXC13− basal (white arrows) filiform papilla cells in Axin2-tdT mice. (jk″) TL-GFP localizes to anterior HOXC13− differentiating (jj″, red arrows) and LEF1+ basal (kk″, white arrows) but not posterior HOXC13+ differentiating (jj″, yellow arrows) filiform papilla cells. (l) TL-GFP localizes to matrix, pre-cortex and dermal sheath in P35 anagen HFs. (m,n) TL-GFP (m) and Axin2lacZ (n) localize to HF isthmus (yellow arrows) and sebaceous gland peripheral cells (white arrows) at P50 (telogen). (ot) Wnt10a expression (in situ hybridization, purple) in adult plantar epidermis (o); adult footpad epidermis (FE) and sweat ducts (SD) (p); neonatal (q) and P100 (rt) filiform and fungiform papillae in anterior (s) and posterior (t) dorsal tongue; and myoepithelial cells of adult SG (lower red arrow) (p). (uw) Generation of Wnt10a-floxed mice. (u) A conditional Wnt10a allele was generated by recombination using a cassette with loxP sites flanking exons 3–4. Correctly targeted ES cells were confirmed by Southern blotting of Sca1-digested genomic DNA (v); probe is indicated in u. (w) PCR-genotyping with primers P1+P2 confirmed germ-line transmission. Wnt10afl/fl mice were crossed with CMV-Cre mice to generate a null allele. PCR-genotyping with primers P1+P3 confirmed deletion of exons 3–4, encoding amino acids 126–528. Primer positions are indicated in u. Scale bar, 10 μm (gg″) or 25 μm (other panels).

Wnt10a expression coincides with β-catenin signalling in molar tooth development20,21, in embryonic anlagen for HFs and taste papillae, in adult interfollicular epidermis, and in HF epithelial cells and DP16,22,23,24. We detected Wnt10a expression in plantar and footpad epidermis at similar levels to those in haired skin epidermis, and in regenerating adult epithelia including filiform and fungiform papillae and sweat ducts (Fig. 2o–t). Wnt10a localized to sweat gland myoepithelial cells, but was not detectable in sweat gland mesenchyme (Fig. 2p).

WNT10A/β-catenin signalling in molar tooth development

To study the functions and mechanisms of action of WNT10A in vivo, we generated conditional Wnt10afl/fl mutant mice with loxP sites flanking exons 3 and 4, which encode 20 of the 24 conserved, functionally required cysteine residues (Fig. 2u–w). Wnt10afl/fl mice were crossed with CMV-Cre, Krt14-Cre or Krt5-rtTA tetO-Cre transgenic mice to generate null, constitutive epithelial, and doxycycline (dox)-inducible epithelial mutants. Approximately 50% of Wnt10a−/− mice developed loosely anchored ectopic molar M4 teeth (Supplementary Fig. 1a,b). Maxillary and mandibular molar teeth had flattened cusps, reduced size and defective root bifurcation and extension compared with littermate controls (Supplementary Fig. 1a,b and Fig. 3a–c), consistent with a previous report25. Cusp and size abnormalities were observed by E17.5 (Fig. 3d), indicating their morphogenetic origin, and mimicked the effects of Wnt/β-catenin inhibition after tooth initiation20. By 1 year of age, alveolar bone density was markedly decreased in Wnt10a−/− mice compared with controls, in line with human patient phenotypes (Fig. 1k), and molar teeth were frequently missing (Fig. 3b,c). Krt14-Cre Wnt10afl/fl mutants displayed molar cusp and root defects, but not decreased bone density (Fig. 3e,j), and a subset of these mice formed ectopic M4 molars. Thus, epithelial Wnt10a is required for normal tooth morphogenesis and suppression of ectopic molar formation, and mesenchymal Wnt10a maintains alveolar bone. β-catenin signalling in incisor region mesenchyme prevents ectopic incisor development by stimulating expression of Bmp4 and Shh, which then act to limit Wnt activity26. Wnt10a may be involved in a similar feedback mechanism to suppress ectopic molar formation by signalling to molar mesenchyme. In line with this possibility, Wnt10a−/− mandibles displayed reduced expression of Shh at E14.5 (Fig. 3f).

Figure 3: Tooth defects in Wnt10a mutant mice.
figure 3

(ac) Micro-CT analysis of mandibles (a,b) and maxillae (c) from control and Wnt10a−/− mice at the stages indicated. (d) Serial H&E-stained sections reveal smaller molar M1 size and blunted cusp development in E17.5 Wnt10a−/− mutant. (e) Micro-CT analysis of Krt14-Cre Wnt10afl/fl and control littermate mandibles at 12 months. (f) Whole-mount in situ hybridization of E14.5 control and Wnt10a−/− mandibles with Shh probe. (g,h) Analysis of whole mount (g) or frozen sections (h) of E17.5 Wnt10a−/− TL-GFP and control TL-GFP developing molars shows decreased GFP signal in mutant cusp precursors. (i) Immunofluorescence for KRT14 (green) and DLX3 (red) in P15 mandibular molar from control and Wnt10a−/− littermates. Dlx3 expression is reduced in the mutant. (j) Diagram summarizing Wnt10a mutant tooth phenotypes at 12 months of age. Scale bar, 50 μm (h), 250 μm (i) or 1 mm (all other panels).

TL-GFP expression was reduced in E17.5 Wnt10a−/− mutant molar cusps compared with controls (Fig. 3g,h), indicating that Wnt10a regulates cusp formation through the β-catenin pathway. Interactions between Hertwig’s epithelial root sheath, a proliferative structure that expresses Wnt10a (ref. 21), and adjacent mesenchymal cells control molar root size and shape. The molar root defects in Wnt10a mutants phenocopied those caused by deletion of the direct Wnt/β-catenin target gene Dlx3 in dental mesenchyme27,28. DLX3 expression was markedly reduced in mutant root-forming mesenchyme at P15 (Fig. 3i), indicating that Wnt10a promotes molar root formation by activating mesenchymal Dlx3 expression.

Wnt10a in embryonic development of non-dental epithelia

Primary and secondary HF placodes, taste papilla placodes and sweat gland germs developed normally in Wnt10a mutants (Fig. 4a–h). Constitutive epithelial β-catenin deletion in Krt14-Cre Ctnnb1fl/fl mice caused defective formation of tongue filiform papillae and the tongue barrier, and loss of expression of Pax9, a transcriptional factor critical for filiform papilla development and barrier establishment29 (Fig. 4m–t). By contrast, Wnt10a deletion did not grossly affect embryonic development of filiform or fungiform papillae (Fig. 4i–l). Thus, other Wnts may compensate for WNT10A in non-dental embryonic development.

Figure 4: Wnt10a mutation does not affect embryonic development of HFs or sweat glands or tongue papillae.
figure 4

(ad) Whole-mount in situ hybridization of control and Wnt10a mutant embryos at the indicated time points using DIG-labelled probe for β-catenin, an HF placode marker (purple signal), reveals that early stages of HF development are unaffected by constitutive epithelial (a,b) or global (c,d) deletion of Wnt10a. (e,f) TL-GFP expression in tongue whole mounts at E14.5 shows that fungiform taste papilla placodes and Wnt/β-catenin signalling (arrows) are not affected by global loss of Wnt10a. (gj) H&E staining at E18.5 reveals normal initiation of sweat gland (g,h, yellow arrows) and filiform papilla (i,j, red arrows) development in Wnt10a mutants. (k,l) P1.5 Wnt10a mutant tongues display normal fungiform and filiform papillae, assayed by SEM. (mp) Constitutive epithelial β-catenin deletion causes failure of filiform papilla formation at P0.5: H&E staining (m,n); SEM analysis (o,p). (q,r) Constitutive epithelial β-catenin deletion results in defective tongue barrier formation, revealed by dye penetration (dark blue staining), which is confined to fungiform papillae in controls (q, arrow) but is broadly apparent in mutants (r, arrow). (s,t) In situ hybridization for Pax9 reveals its decreased expression in epithelial β-catenin mutant dorsal tongue (purple/brown signal). N=3 mutants and n=3 control mice were analysed in all experiments. Scale bar, 25 μm (g,h), 40 μm (s,t), 50 μm (i,j,mp), 100 μm (k,l) or 200 μm (q,r).

Wnt10a mutant HFs show progressive defects in adult life

Adult mice with global or constitutive epithelial Wnt10a deletion displayed increasingly sparse hair with age. HFs undergo periodic cycles of growth (anagen), regression (catagen) and rest (telogen), driven by rarely proliferating epithelial stem cells in the permanent KRT15+ CD34+ bulge region, and rapidly proliferating progenitors in the adjacent KRT15+ CD34− secondary hair germ (SHG)30. Immunofluorescence for pan-hair shaft keratins produced a signal in mutant HFs, and cuticle structure appeared grossly normal by scanning electron microscope (SEM); however, mutant hair shafts were shorter and thinner than controls, with disorganized internal structures (Supplementary Fig. 2a–j). To investigate the mechanisms underlying these defects, we induced epithelial Wnt10a deletion at successive time points in K5-rtTA tetO-Cre Wnt10afl/fl mice. Wnt10a loss from P9 (embryonic anagen) caused premature HF regression, cessation of matrix cell proliferation and decreased cyclin D1 expression (Fig. 5a–b′ and Supplementary Fig. 2k,l). Deletion at P18 delayed initiation of anagen, indicated by histology and absent SHG proliferation (Fig. 5c–d′), and prevented timely TL-GFP activation and external hair growth (Fig. 5k–m). These phenotypes mimicked the effects of Wnt/β-catenin inhibition16. Mutant HFs eventually entered anagen by P29 (Fig. 5e,f), but proliferation and cyclin D1 expression remained lower than in controls (Fig. 5e′ and Supplementary Fig. 2m–p). Wnt10a deletion in full postnatal anagen slightly reduced proliferation but did not cause HF regression (Fig. 5g–i and Supplementary Fig. 2q,r), suggesting compensatory activity of other Wnts. Thus, epithelial WNT10A/β-catenin signalling maintains embryonic anagen and promotes anagen onset.

Figure 5: Wnt10a deletion causes altered hair cycle progression.
figure 5

(ah′) H&E stained sections (ah) and BrdU immunofluorescence (a′h′) of Krt5-rtTA tetO-Cre Wnt10fl/fl mutant and littermate control dorsal skin dox induced from P9, P18 or P25 and analysed at the stages indicated (ab′, n=3 controls, 3 mutants; cd′, n=6 controls, 6 mutants; ef′, n=4 controls, 4 mutants; gh′, n=5 controls, 5 mutants). (i) Quantification reveals statistically significantly reduced proliferation of Wnt10a mutant HF compared with controls. >20 control and >20 mutant HF were counted from n=4 mutants and 4 controls (P18-29) or 5 mutants and 5 controls (P25-35). Significance was calculated with two-tailed Student’s t-test. Error bars indicate s.e.m. (j) Accelerated catagen following Wnt10a deletion from P9 (photographed at P14 after hair clipping). (k) Delayed anagen entry following Wnt10a deletion from P20 (photographed at P26 after hair clipping). (l,m) Reduced TL-GFP expression in HFs (arrows) following Wnt10a deletion from P18. (n,o) Wnt10a mutant HFs are miniaturized and sebaceous glands (arrows) enlarged compared to controls at P180. (ps) Oil-red O (p,q) and FABP5 (r,s) staining reveal increased lipid in Wnt10a mutant HFs compared with controls (arrows). (tw) Bulge stem cell markers KRT15 and CD34 are retained in Wnt10a mutant HFs at P180. Scale bar, 25 μm (l,m,r,s), 50 μm (a′-h′,nq,tw) or 200 μm (ah).

By 6 months of age, Wnt10a mutant HFs became miniaturized with enlarged sebaceous glands and elevated lipid production (Fig. 5n–s). Dominant negative Lef1 also causes sebaceous gland expansion31, consistent with decreased Wnt/β-catenin signalling in Wnt10a mutant HFs. Despite HF miniaturization in Wnt10a mutants, CD34+ KRT15+ bulge stem cells were retained (Fig. 5t–w). Miniaturized HFs in human androgenetic alopecia similarly display enlarged sebaceous glands and bulge stem cell retention32. As data from genome-wide association studies indicate association of a WNT10A variant with androgenetic alopecia6, decreased WNT10A/β-catenin signalling may contribute to this condition.

In normal aged mice (18–34 months), HFs miniaturize via loss of stem cells due to COL17A1 proteolysis33. Miniaturized HFs of 6-month-old Wnt10a mutants expressed COL17A1 (Supplementary Fig. 2s,t), consistent with maintenance of stem cell markers and suggesting that miniaturization was not caused by accelerated aging. In line with this, levels of Axin2 expression are similar in young and aged HFs33.

WNT10A/β-catenin signalling in early postnatal appendages

Constitutive global or epithelial-specific Wnt10a deletion caused progressive defects in tongue papillae structure from P7 (Fig. 6a,b and Supplementary Fig. 3a–b′). TBs were miniaturized, and TL-GFP reporter activity was decreased in filiform papillae and TBs compared with controls (Supplementary Fig. 3c–h). Inducible epithelial β-catenin deletion in early postnatal life caused similar defects (Supplementary Fig. 3i,j). Sweat gland ducts failed to extend in Wnt10a−/− mutants (Fig. 6r,s), or following postnatal epithelial β-catenin deletion (Supplementary Fig. 3m,n), and starch-iodine tests revealed a functional inability to sweat (Supplementary Fig. 3k–l′). Thus, WNT10A/β-catenin signalling is required to complete postnatal oral appendage and sweat duct development. In line with this, our patient, and several other human WNT10A pedigrees5,34, display palmoplantar hypohidrosis. However, palmoplantar hyperhidrosis has also been described in some WNT10A patients5,35. We speculate that variable compensatory mechanisms, for instance upregulation of other Wnt genes during development, could account for these disparate findings. Approximately 20% of epithelial Wnt10a mutants also displayed defects in nail growth (Supplementary Fig. 3o,p), consistent with onychodystrophy in human patients (Fig. 1b).

Figure 6: WNT10A/β-catenin signalling is required for postnatal development and maintenance of epidermal appendages.
figure 6

(ad) SEM shows fungiform (FuP) and filiform (FiP) papilla defects in adult global (a,b) and inducible epithelial (c,d) Wnt10a mutants. (e,f) SEM reveals loss of TBs following inducible Wnt10a deletion in adult tongue epithelium. (gi) Decreased expression of TB markers KRT8 (red) and SOX2 (green) (g,h) and reduced percentage of KTR8+ TB cells (i) in sectioned circumvallate papillae following inducible Wnt10a deletion. KRT8+ and total DAPI+ cells were counted in 10 sections from 3 controls and 10 sections from 3 mutants. (jn″,o,p) Induced Wnt10a deletion at the stages indicated causes decreased basal cell proliferation in filiform (jk′), fungiform (mn″) and circumvallate (o,p) papillae. (l,q) Quantification of proliferation in filiform (l), and fungiform and circumvallate (q) papillae. FiP: BrdU+/KRT14+ and total KRT14+ cells counted in 10 fields at 20 × from 3 controls and the same for 3 mutants. Fungiform TBs: Ki67+/KRT14+ and total KRT14+ cells counted in 10 TBs from 3 control and 3 mutant (P9-14), 6 control and 6 mutant (P18-26) or 5 control and 5 mutant (P25-25) mice. Circumvallate TBs: Ki67+/KRT14+ and total KRT14+ cells counted in 30 TBs from 3 controls and 30 TBs from 3 mutants. (r,s) SEM reveals failure of postnatal sweat duct development in P16 Wnt10a−/− mutant footpad. (tw) Inducible Wnt10a deletion in adults prevents sweat duct maintenance (Nile blue staining) (t,u) and decreases sweating (starch-iodine staining, purple dots) (v,w). (xy′) Inducible Wnt10a deletion in early postnatal or adult life causes decreased sweat duct basal cell proliferation. (z) Quantification of sweat duct proliferation. Ki67+/KRT14+ or BrdU+/KRT14+ and total KRT14+ cells counted in 10 ducts from 3 controls and 10 ducts from 3 mutants (P9-14) or 10 ducts from 4 controls and 10 ducts from 4 mutants (P25-160). ≥3 control and 3 mutants used for other analyses. Significance was calculated with two-tailed t-test. Error bars indicate s.e.m. Dox induction periods are indicated; mice were analysed at the end of the induction period. Scale bar, 25 μm (jp,xy′), 50 μm (r,s), 100 μm (a,b,g,h, insets in c,d), 500 μm (c,d) or 2 mm (e,f).

WNT10A maintains adult oral appendages and sweat ducts

To determine whether WNT10A/β-catenin signalling is required for regeneration of adult non-hair bearing epithelia, we examined the effects of inducing epithelial Wnt10a or β-catenin deletion, or expression of the Wnt/β-catenin inhibitor DKK1 and its receptor Kremen1, in adult K5-rtTA tetO-Cre Wnt10afl/fl, K5-rtTA tetO-Cre Ctnnb1fl/fl and K5-rtTA tetO-Dkk1 K14-Krm1 mice16. In each case, SEM revealed progressively abnormal filiform and fungiform papilla structures, causing a flattened tongue surface (Fig. 6c,d and Supplementary Fig. 3q,r). SEM or whole-mount immunofluorescence for the TB marker KRT8 revealed decreased TB numbers in mutant fungiform and circumvallate papillae (Fig. 6e–i and Supplementary Fig. 3s). TBs contain Type I, II and III taste receptor cells, marked, respectively, by expression of ENTPD2, PLCβ2 and SNAP-25, and required for glial-like supporting function, and detection of sweet, umami, bitter and sour tastes. While forced β-catenin activation preferentially induces Type I fate36, Wnt10a or β-catenin deletion reduced marker expression for all three cell types (Supplementary Fig. 3s). However, we did not detect significant differences in the taste responses of adult mutants versus controls for sweet, sour, salt or bitter tastes, or for the irritant, capsaicin (Supplementary Fig. 4), indicating that, as in our human patient, residual taste function is sufficient to discriminate these compounds. Interestingly, Wnt10a−/− mutants had higher water intakes than controls following mild, but not more severe, water restriction. This could reflect increased dehydration, possibly caused by a slight epidermal barrier defect.

Inducible Wnt10a deletion or forced Dkk1 expression after sweat glands reached maturity at P20 caused sweat duct regression and impaired sweating ability compared with controls (Fig. 6t–w and Supplementary Fig. 3t–u′), revealing a previously unknown role for β-catenin signalling in sweat duct maintenance.

Stratified skin epidermis and tongue epithelium regenerate continuously from keratin 14 (KRT14)+ basal cells every 8–10 and 3–4 days, respectively37,38, while TB cells in fungiform and circumvallate papillae arise from KRT14+ SOX2+ basal cells and have slower turnover rates of up to 3 weeks39. Inducible Wnt10a deletion in either the early postnatal period, or in adult life, caused significantly decreased basal cell proliferation in filiform papillae and plantar epithelium (Fig. 6j–l and Supplementary Fig. 3v,w,z), similar to the effects of inducible β-catenin deletion16. Basal proliferation was also reduced in fungiform and circumvallate TBs (Fig. 6m–q).

Sweat gland ducts are composed of proliferating basal and non-proliferative suprabasal populations, both of which renew at least every 6 weeks40. Inducible Wnt10a or β-catenin deletion caused decreased sweat duct basal cell proliferation (Fig. 6x–z and Supplementary Fig. 3x–z). Thus, WNT10A/β-catenin signalling is required for progenitor cell proliferation and adult renewal in non-hairy epithelia, as well as for normal hair growth.

Axin2 marks self-renewing stem cells in adult epithelia

Wnt-activated self-renewing stem cells are present in filiform papillae, interfollicular epidermis and resting (telogen) HFs16,41,42. However, whether Wnt activity marks self-renewing stem cells in anagen HFs is unknown. The Wnt/β-catenin target Lgr5 marks stem cells in a subset of TBs in posterior tongue43, but it is unclear whether Wnt activity is a universal characteristic of TB stem cells. The related gene Lgr6 marks self-renewing stem cells for the sebaceous gland and nail44,45, but it is unknown whether Lrg6 is Wnt regulated at these sites, or whether Wnt-activated self-renewing cells are present in sweat gland ducts or dental epithelia. As epithelial progenitor cell proliferative defects contribute to WNT10A mutant phenotypes in these tissues we used lineage tracing to ask whether Wnt activity marks their stem cells.

To ensure that the time between labelling and long-term analysis was sufficient to ensure loss of initially labelled cells that were committed to terminal differentiation rather than self-renewal, we dox-induced R26-rtTA tetO-H2B-GFP mice from P14 to efficiently label histones in proliferating cells with H2B-GFP. Dox was withdrawn at P70 and tissues examined after 2 weeks or 3.5 months (P84 or P174). H2B-GFP label was retained in rarely cycling KRT15+HF bulge stem cells at P84 and P174, but by P174 was absent from the SHG, upper follicle and sebaceous gland, and from sweat ducts and fungiform and circumvallate TBs (Fig. 7a–f). Thus, with the exception of the HF bulge, epithelial cells in all these tissues turned over within 104 days.

Figure 7: Pulse-chase estimates of epithelial tissue turnover rates and lineage tracing of Axin2+ cells in anagen HFs.
figure 7

(af) Pulse-chase analysis of epithelial turnover times. (a) Labelling strategy: R26R-rtTA tetO-H2B-GFP mice were placed on doxcycline (dox) chow for 8 weeks (P14-P70) to induce expression of H2BGFP and its incorporation into the chromatin of dividing cells (Pulse). Mice were removed from dox treatment at P70 and analysed at successive time points following dox withdrawal (Chase). Label is gradually diluted out in cells that continue to proliferate. (b,c) Most HF epithelial cells, including sebaceous gland cells and some KRT15+ bulge stem cells, were H2BGFP positive at P70 (b). By P174, label had been lost from the epithelium, with the exception of KRT15+ bulge LRCs (c). (d,e) In fungiform (d) and circumvallate (e) taste papillae, epithelial cells including KRT14+ TB basal cells and KRT8+ differentiated TB cells were H2BGFP+ at P70, but lost label by P174 indicating that they turned over within 104 days. (f) In sweat ducts, KRT14+ basal cells and KRT6+ luminal cells were H2BGFP+ at P70, but had completely lost label by P174. (gv) Lineage tracing of Axin2-expressing cells in HFs. (g) Schematic of lineage-tracing strategy. (ht) Paraffin sectioned dorsal skin from AxinCreERT2/tdT R26RmTmG (hq,s) or AxinCreERT2/tdT R26RConfetti (r,t) mice tamoxifen treated at P20-21 and analysed at the time points indicated. DAPI-stained sections were co-stained with markers for bulge and SHG (KRT15), proliferation (Ki67), inner root sheath (IRS) (AE15), hair shaft (HS) precursors (AE13), dermal sheath (SMA), outer root sheath (ORS) (KRT14), isthmus (LRIG1), sebaceous gland (SG) (FAS, FABP) as indicated. (u,v) Whole-mounted tail skin epidermis from AxinCreERT2/tdT R26RConfetti mice induced at P28-29 and analysed at 11.5 months. At least three mice were analysed for each tracing condition; ≥20 labelled HFs were analysed for each mouse. Scale bar, 10 μm (bf) or 25 μm (ht).

Axin2lacZ and TL-GFP Wnt reporters are expressed in differentiated KRT8+ as well as basal TB cells. Lineage tracing in adult Krt8-CreERT2 R26REYFP R26R-EYFP mice tamoxifen treated for 2 days and examined after 4 days or 7 months revealed EYFP-labelled differentiated, but not basal, TB cells at 4 days, and complete loss of label by 7 months, indicating that KRT8+ cells are unable to self renew (Supplementary Fig. 5a,b).

Axin2 is a ubiquitous Wnt/β-catenin target gene that provides a reliable indicator of Wnt/β-catenin pathway activity42. To determine whether Wnt signalling marks self-renewing stem cells, we utilized Axin2-CreERT2/tdT mice16 crossed with R26REYFP, R26RmTmG or R26RConfetti Cre reporter lines (Fig. 7g). Tissues were examined shortly after Cre induction to reveal cells active for Wnt signalling, and after several cycles of epithelial renewal to identify self-renewing stem cells and their progeny. Un-induced Axin2-CreERT2/tdT R26REYFP mice displayed sporadic EYFP labelling in palatal rugae and tongue muscle, but not in skin or tongue epithelia (Supplementary Fig. 5c). We did not detect leakiness in any of these tissues when Axin2-CreERT2/tdT was used with R26RmTmG or R26RConfetti; however, as in any lineage tracing experiment, we cannot absolutely exclude that some clones resulted from leaky Cre activity.

In Axin2-CreERT2/tdT R26RmTmG mice induced in early anagen (P20-21) and examined 40 h after the first tamoxifen injection, mG+ cells were detected in the HF SHG, KRT15+ bulge, DP and dermal sheath (Fig. 7h–j). After 15 days (P35, full anagen), mG+ cells were present in both epithelial and dermal HF lineages (Fig. 7k–m). Cells in all regions of the permanent HF were labelled in telogen (Fig. 7n), and all lineages contained mG+ cells in the subsequent anagen (Fig. 7o–q). Similar results were obtained using the R26RConfetti reporter (Fig. 7r). Thus, self-renewing Axin2-expressing cells labelled in early anagen contribute to all epithelial and dermal HF components.

Sebaceous gland stem cells reside in the upper HF and sebaceous gland peripheral layer and are marked by LRIG1 and LGR6 (refs 44, 46). After long-term lineage tracing with Axin2-CreERT2/tdT R26RmTmG, the isthmus and an entire lobe of the sebaceous gland was labelled in some HFs that lacked labelling of the bulge and lower HF (Fig. 7s). Examination of Axin2-CreERT2/tdT R26RConfetti lineage-traced skin, which permits clonal analysis, confirmed this result (Fig. 7t–v). Thus, Axin2-expressing cells in the isthmus and/or sebaceous gland peripheral layer repopulate the sebaceous gland during homoeostasis.

Axin2-CreERT2/tdT R26REYFP fungiform and circumvallate papillae from mice induced at P20-P21 displayed EYFP expression in KRT14+ basal cells and KRT14− differentiated TB cells 40 h after Cre induction (Fig. 8a,c,e,g,i). After 6 or 9 months, KRT14+ basal cells remained labelled, indicating that they self-renew (Fig. 8b,d), and we also detected EYFP in differentiated Type I and II cells in fungiform and circumvallate papillae and Type III cells in circumvallate papillae (Fig. 8b,d,f,h,j). Similar data were obtained using the R26RmTmG reporter (Fig. 8k–n). Thus, self-renewing Axin2-expressing basal progenitors can produce all three taste cell types.

Figure 8: Lineage tracing of Axin2+ cells in taste papillae and sweat ducts and nails.
figure 8

(aj) Adult Axin2-CreERT2/tdT R26REYFP mice were tamoxifen treated at P60 and P61 and EYFP expression analysed in fungiform (a,b,e,f) and circumvallate (c,d,gj) papillae after 40 h, 6 months or 9 months as indicated. KRT14 marks basal cells (ad); SOX2 marks basal and Type I TB cells (b,d); PLCβ2 marks Type II TB cells (eh); SNAP-25 marks Type III TB cells (i,j). Yellow arrows indicate EYFP+ basal cells; red arrows indicate EYFP+ differentiated TB cells. Both basal and differentiated TB cells remain labelled over 6–9 months. (kn) Adult Axin2-CreERT2/tdT R26RmTmG mice were treated with tamoxifen on 2 successive days and mGFP expression analysed in cryosectioned circumvallate papillae at 40 h (k,m) and 4.5 months (l,n) as indicated. KRT14 marks basal cells (k,l); ENTP2 marks differentiated Type I TB cells (m,n). Both basal KRT14+ cells (yellow arrows) and differentiated KRT14− cells, including ENTP2+ Type I cells, (red arrows) were labelled at 40 h and maintained label after 4.5 months. (or) Sectioned sweat ducts (o,p) and nail (q,r) from AxinCreERT2/tdT R26RmTmG mice tamoxifen treated at P20-21 and analysed at the stages indicated. Yellow arrows indicate KRT14+ basal cells; red arrows indicate KRT6+ sweat duct suprabasal cells (o,p) or KRT14− differentiating nail plate cells (q,r). Insets in q are magnified images of boxed region; lower image in r is a higher magnification photomicrograph of the arrowed region in the upper image. At least three mice were analysed for each tracing condition; ≥10 labelled taste papillae or sweat gland ducts and ≥3 nails were analysed for each condition. Scale bar, 10 μm (an), 25 μm (o,p), 50 μm (insets in q), 100 μm (q; magnified region (lower image) in r) or 250 μm (upper image in r).

In Axin2-CreERT2/tdT R26RmTmG sweat gland ducts at 40 h after Cre induction, mG+ cells were present in both basal (KRT6−) and suprabasal (KRT6+) layers (Fig. 8o), and both populations remained labelled after 4.5 months (Fig. 8p). As we did not detect significant proliferation of suprabasal cells, these likely originate from self-renewing Axin2-expressing basal cells.

Terminally differentiated cells of the nail arise from self-renewing KRT14+ LGR6+ stem cells in the proximal nail matrix45,47. Consistent with Axin2lacZ expression in this region47, we observed mG+ KRT14+ proximal matrix cells (Fig. 8q, yellow arrows) as well as mG+ differentiating cells (Fig. 8q, red arrow) 4 days after induction of Axin2-CreERT2/tdT R26RmTmG mice. Clones of mG+ cells emanating from the KRT14+ proximal matrix and giving rise to the nail bed and nail plate persisted after 6 months (Fig. 8r, arrows). Thus, self-renewing Axin2-expressing basal cells contribute to nail growth.

Interestingly, we were unable to detect labelling of the epithelial incisor tooth cervical loop, the site of stem cells that generate enamel-secreting ameloblasts of the continuously growing incisor. This is consistent with absence of enamel defects in Wnt10a mutant incisors, and previous reports documenting lack of Wnt/β-catenin signalling in the cervical loop48,49. Thus, Axin2 promoter activity is not a universal characteristic of self-renewing epithelial stem cells.

WNT10A controls region-specific epithelial differentiation

Patients and mice with WNT10A mutations exhibit severe tongue and palmoplantar abnormalities that are highly region specific, and cannot entirely be explained by decreased progenitor cell proliferation. We therefore asked whether WNT10A loss also affects specialized tissue differentiation. Remarkably, we found that expression of the hard keratin genes Krt36 (Krt1-5) and Krt84 (Krt2-16) that specifically characterize tongue filiform papillae was reduced or absent in Wnt10a mutant tongue, or following inducible epithelial β-catenin deletion, even though rudimentary papilla structures were present and included differentiating cells (Fig. 9a–d). This result is consistent with co-expression of Axin2-tdT with HOXC13, a transcription factor required for Krt36 and Krt84 expression50 (Fig. 2i–i″). Nuclear β-catenin and TCF4 also localize to HOXC13+ cells, which are non-overlapping with LEF1+ proliferating progenitors (Supplementary Fig. 6a–d). Inducible epithelial Wnt10a or β-catenin deletion caused absence of nuclear, or all, β-catenin, respectively (Fig. 9e–h), and loss of LEF1 and HOXC13 expression (Fig. 9e′–m).

Figure 9: WNT10A/β-catenin signalling is required for region-specific differentiation.
figure 9

(ad) Filiform papillae are present in Wnt10a−/− and inducible β-catenin mutant dorsal tongue (yellow arrows), but horny structures and expression of hard keratins (in situ hybridization, purple signals) are decreased (red arrows). (el) Epithelial deletion of Wnt10a (ef″,i,j) or β-catenin (gh″,k,l) induced from P25, P110 or P15 as indicated causes decreased expression of nuclear β-catenin, LEF1 and HOXC13 (white arrows, LEF1+ proliferating cells; yellow arrows, HOXC13+ differentiating cells). (m) qPCR shows significantly decreased Hoxc13 levels in Wnt10a and β-catenin mutant tongue epithelium. (nr) IF and qPCR reveal reduced levels of KRT9 protein (nq) and mRNA (r) in Wnt10a−/− and inducible β-catenin mutant footpad epidermis. (sv″) Co-IF for KRT9 and KRT10 in plantar epidermis from patients homozygous for WNT10A c.756+1G>A (st″) or WNT10A c.391G>A (uv″) compared with similarly aged sex-matched controls. For qPCR, RNA levels were quantified in six control and six mutant (P40) or four control and four mutant (P20-100) samples with three technical replicates for each, and normalized to β-actin mRNA. Significance was calculated with two-tailed Student’s t-test. Error bars indicate s.e.m. Scale bar, 25 μm (el) or 50 μm (ad,nq,sv″).

Human WNT10A patients display skin scaling and cracking of skin in palmoplantar, but not other, skin regions. These defects overlap with the effects of mutation or deletion of KRT9, whose expression is confined to suprabasal palmoplantar epidermis in humans51 and footpad epidermis in mice52. KRT9 is the most highly differentially expressed gene in human palmoplantar versus dorsal hand or foot epidermis, and in vitro studies suggest that Wnt/β-catenin signalling enhances its expression53,54. Consistent with this, we observed nuclear-localized β-catenin and TCF3 in mouse footpad epidermis (Supplementary Figs 6e,f and 7r). LEF1 expression was undetectable in this tissue, and TCF1 and TCF4 were mainly associated with sweat ducts (Supplementary Fig. 6g–i). Global Wnt10a loss or inducible epithelial β-catenin deletion caused decreased KRT9 protein and mRNA levels (Fig. 9n–r). By contrast, the suprabasal keratin gene Krt10 and the terminal differentiation proteins filaggrin and involucrin, which locate to epidermis in all body regions, were unaffected by Wnt10a or β-catenin deletion (Supplementary Fig. 9j–r). Similarly, while KRT10 and loricrin expression was comparable in WNT10A patient and sex- and age-matched control plantar epidermis (Fig. 9s′–t″ and Supplementary Fig. 6s,t), KRT9 protein was decreased in our WNT10A c.756+1 G>A patient, and in an unrelated patient homozygous for a WNT10A c.391 G>A mutation4 (Fig. 9s–v″), and KRT9 mRNA levels were lower in patient plantar skin than in control (Supplementary Fig. 6u).

β-catenin complexes in differentiation and proliferation

Our surprising finding that WNT10A/β-catenin signalling is required for region-specific differentiation as well as progenitor proliferation suggested that β-catenin may complex with transcriptional co-activators that are specifically expressed in differentiating versus proliferating cells, allowing its localization to distinct sets of target genes. We therefore examined potential transcriptional partners that are differentially expressed in suprabasal versus basal epithelial cells. A strong candidate was KLF4, which localizes to suprabasal epidermis, but is low or absent in the basal layer, and is required for embryonic tongue filiform papillae differentiation7. KLF4 expression overlapped with nuclear β-catenin and HOXC13 in adult tongue filiform papillae (Fig. 10a and Supplementary Fig. 7a), but was unaffected by loss of either Wnt10a (Fig. 10a) or β-catenin, indicating that it is not regulated by WNT10A/β-catenin signalling. Inducible epithelial Klf4 deletion in adults caused defects in filiform papilla structure and loss of HOXC13, but did not affect LEF1 expression or basal proliferation (Supplementary Fig. 7b–e and Fig. 10b,c). Nuclear β-catenin remained detectable in LEF1-, as well as LEF1+, filiform papilla cells in Klf4 mutants (Fig. 10d); thus, nuclear β-catenin is insufficient for HOXC13 expression in the absence of KLF4. Consistent with this, mutation of epithelial β-catenin to a constitutively active form in Krt5-rtTA tetO-Cre Ctnnb1fl(Ex3)/+ mice enhanced HOXC13 levels in differentiating filiform papilla cells, but did not induce its ectopic expression in basal cells (Supplementary Fig. 7f–i).

Figure 10: β-catenin interacts differentially with TCF/LEF1 and KLF4 to control proliferation and specialized differentiation.
figure 10

(a) Nuclear β-catenin and KLF4 overlap in differentiating filiform papillae cells (yellow arrows). Nuclear β-catenin, but not KLF4, is depleted following inducible Wnt10a deletion. (bd) Inducible epithelial Klf4 deletion causes decreased HOXC13 (b, green) but does not affect LEF1 (b,d, pink), proliferation (Ki67) (c, pink) or nuclear β-catenin (d, green). (eh) PLA (pink signals) with adult dorsal tongue sections and anti-β-catenin and KLF4 (e), TCF4 and KLF4 (f), β-catenin and TCF4 (g), or β-catenin and LEF1 (h) reveals direct interactions of β-catenin, KLF4 and TCF4 in differentiating (yellow arrows) and β-catenin and LEF1 in proliferating (white arrows) cells. Signals were lacking following inducible Klf4 or β-catenin deletion (right panels). Asterisks indicate autofluorescence. (i) Overlap of nuclear β-catenin and KLF4 in suprabasal footpad epidermis. KLF4 is unaffected by inducible β-catenin deletion. (jl) Inducible epithelial Klf4 deletion causes decreased expression of KRT9 (j) but not KRT10 (k) or nuclear β-catenin (l). (mp) PLA in adult footpad with anti-TCF3 and KLF4 (m), β-catenin and KLF4 (n) or β-catenin and TCF3 (o,p) shows KLF4, β-catenin and TCF3 directly interact in suprabasal cells (yellow arrows); β-catenin and TCF3 interact in basal cells (white arrows). Signals are absent in tissues with inducible Klf4 (m) or β-catenin (n,o) deletion (right panels), and are enhanced by inducible stabilizing mutation of β-catenin (p; right panel shows single antibody control). (q) qPCR shows significant reduction of Krt9 but not Krt10 mRNA levels in P93 footpad epidermis following inducible epithelial Klf4 deletion. mRNA levels normalized to β-actin. (r) ChiP-qPCR with adult footpad epidermis shows specific enrichment for KLF4, TCF3 and β-catenin in a region containing conserved KLF4 and LEF/TCF-binding motifs, 16 kb downstream of Krt9 TSS. Samples from ≥3 mutant and ≥3 control mice analysed in all assays. For q,r, three technical replicates were additionally performed for each sample; significance calculated with two-tailed Student’s t-test; error bars indicate s.e.m. (s) Model showing distinct nuclear β-catenin complexes regulating proliferation versus differentiation in tongue and footpad epithelia. Scale bar, 25 μm (ai,mp) or 75 μm (jl).

These data suggested that KLF4, β-catenin and TCF4 might co-regulate differentiation genes in filiform papillae. To test whether β-catenin, KLF4 and TCF4 form a complex in differentiating filiform papilla cell nuclei, we used proximity ligation assay (PLA), which detects interacting epitopes that are separated by less than 30–40 nm (ref. 55). PLA with antibodies to β-catenin and KLF4, TCF4 and KLF4 or β-catenin and TCF4 produced signals in differentiating cell nuclei but not in progenitors (Fig. 10e–g, yellow arrows). Conversely, PLA for β-catenin and LEF1 produced positive signals in proliferating basal cell nuclei (Fig. 10h, white arrows). Signals were not detected in tissue lacking β-catenin or Klf4 (Fig. 10e–h and Supplementary Fig. 7j,k), or using only one antibody (Supplementary Fig. 7l,m), indicating specificity of the assay. β-catenin/LEF1 complexes formed in the absence of KLF4 (Supplementary Fig. 7n,o), and, interestingly, TCF4/KLF4 complex formation was unaffected by β-catenin deletion (Supplementary Fig. 7p,q).

To determine whether KLF4 plays a similar role in region-specific footpad epidermal differentiation, we examined its localization in this tissue. Immunofluorescence revealed KLF4 expression in suprabasal footpad epidermis where it co-localized with TCF3 (Supplementary Fig. 7r,s), and was unaffected by β-catenin deletion (Fig. 10i). Inducible epithelial Klf4 deletion in adults caused enhanced pigmentation and flaking of footpad skin (Supplementary Fig. 7t,u), a phenotype overlapping with the effects of loss of KRT9 (ref. 56). In line with this, KRT9 protein and mRNA expression were significantly reduced in Klf4 mutant footpad epidermis compared with controls, while Krt10 expression was unaffected (Fig. 10j,k,q). As in dorsal tongue epithelium, nuclear and cytoplasmic β-catenin localization was unaffected by Klf4 deletion (Fig. 10l). PLA revealed direct interactions of TCF3 and KLF4, and β-catenin and KLF4, in suprabasal footpad epidermal nuclei (Fig. 10m,n), and direct interactions of β-catenin and TCF3 in both basal and suprabasal cells (Fig. 10o). Gain-of-function mutation of epithelial β-catenin enhanced β-catenin/TCF3 interactions (Fig. 10p). A consensus TCF/LEF-binding motif conserved in dog, horse and human localizes 16,185 bp downstream of the mouse Krt9 transcription start site (TSS), close to a predicted KLF4-binding site. ChIP assays confirmed binding of KLF4, TCF3 and β-catenin to this region in footpad epidermis (Fig. 10r).

Our data support a model in which, in KLF4- basal cells, β-catenin promotes proliferation via interactions with LEF1 in filiform papillae and TCF3 in footpad epidermis. In suprabasal cells, which express KLF4 in a non-β-catenin-dependent manner, β-catenin instead complexes with KLF4 and TCF4 in filiform papillae, and with KLF4 and TCF3 in footpad epidermis, to activate specialized suprabasal differentiation programmes (Fig. 10s). The regional specificity of LEF1, TCF3 and TCF4 expression may underlie the distinct transcriptional programmes activated by WNT10A/β-catenin signalling in filiform papillae versus footpad epidermis.


Here we delineate the developmental and regenerative defects underlying ectodermal phenotypes in humans and mice carrying WNT10A mutations. We demonstrate that WNT10A/β-catenin signalling controls progenitor cell proliferation in a highly diverse set of epithelia characterized by distinct tissue organizations, differentiation pathways and cellular turnover rates. Using lineage tracing experiments with Axin2-CreERT2, we identified self-renewing Axin2-expressing cells in the tissues affected by loss of WNT10A function. While we cannot exclude that additional pathways regulate Axin2, its expression in skin epithelia is removed by β-catenin deletion42. Thus, our data suggest that Wnt-active self-renewing stem cells contribute to regeneration of Wnt10a-dependent tissues. However, Wnt signalling is not universally associated with epithelial regeneration, as we were unable to detect Axin2-expressing progenitors in rodent incisor epithelium. Unexpectedly, in addition to directing normal embryonic tooth morphogenesis and adult progenitor cell proliferation, we find that WNT10A is required for region-specific differentiation, explaining the smooth tongue and palmoplantar keratoderma phenotypes observed in patients with WNT10A mutations.

Using genetic mouse models, we show that long-term absence of WNT10A causes HF miniaturization and sebaceous gland enlargement, with retention of bulge stem cells. This phenomenon is also observed in human androgenetic alopecia, consistent with identification of a WNT10A variant associated with lower expression levels and male pattern baldness. Functional studies of the WNT10A variant may shed further light on the aetiology of this common condition. Conversely, WNT10A’s broad functions in epithelial proliferation suggest its possible requirement in skin squamous and basal cell tumours, which depend on β-catenin signalling57,58. In line with this, WNT10A overexpression in vitro promotes an invasive and self-renewing phenotype in oesophageal squamous cell carcinoma cells59.

Sebaceous gland stem cells reside in the HF isthmus and sebaceous gland peripheral layer44,46. We find that these regions express several independent Wnt reporters, and contain Axin2+ self-renewing stem cells that give rise to the sebaceous gland. Paradoxically, impaired Wnt/β-catenin signalling in Wnt10a mutants, and in mice expressing dominant negative LEF1 (ref. 31), causes sebaceous gland enlargement. Decreased signalling in the absence of Wnt10a may alter the balance between proliferation and differentiation of sebaceous gland stem cells. Alternatively, Axin2 may simply mark sebaceous gland stem cells rather than reflecting a cell autonomous requirement for Wnt signalling, and sebaceous gland enlargement could be caused by altered bulge cell fate. Further experiments will be required to distinguish between these models.

Although Wnt10a expression localizes to embryonic appendage anlagen, we find that its requirements in embryogenesis are largely restricted to developing teeth, where it is required for normal levels of β-catenin signalling and Shh expression, explaining the tooth size and cusp abnormalities observed in mutant mice and human patients. In parallel, reduced expression of the direct Wnt target gene Dlx3, which is required for root formation, explains the root defects. The key roles of WNT10A in molar cusp and root development suggest potential utility of this molecule in dental engineering strategies.

While microdontia and taurodontism are concordant between human patients and mouse mutants, patients with WNT10A mutations also display secondary tooth agenesis. Lack of this phenotype in mouse mutants is not surprising, as mice do not develop a secondary dentition. Interestingly, some Wnt10a mutant mice develop ectopic molar M4 teeth that are loosely anchored and preferentially lost, a phenotype that has not been described in human WNT10A patients. Careful examination of the dentition in very young, severely affected patients might similarly reveal ectopic formation of primary molars. Alternatively, differences in the mechanisms controlling patterning of dental development in humans and mice could explain the absence of ectopic primary molar formation in human patients.

The mechanisms underlying repression of Wnt signalling in quiescent stem cells and its subsequent activation as cells enter a proliferative phase have been well studied60. However, how this pathway is controlled as proliferating cells make the critical transition to differentiation is much less clear. Using footpad and tongue epithelia as relatively simple model systems, we find that inducible epithelial Klf4 deletion mimics region-specific differentiation, but not proliferative, defects seen in the absence of Wnt10a or epithelial β-catenin. Our data indicate that in basal cells, where KLF4 is low or absent, nuclear β-catenin complexes with LEF1 in filiform papillae and with TCF3 in footpad epidermis to control basal proliferation. By contrast, in differentiating cells, nuclear β-catenin directly associates with KLF4 and TCF4 in filiform papillae, and with TCF3 and KLF4 in footpad epidermis to regulate expression of region-specific differentiation genes. This mechanism may be generalizable to other specialized epithelia, such as HFs, TBs, sweat ducts and nails, that exhibit β-catenin signalling in differentiating as well as proliferating cells. In line with this, in addition to controlling HF progenitor cell proliferation16, Wnt/β-catenin signalling has been implicated in the regulation of hair keratin gene expression61,62, and we observed disorganized internal hair shaft structures in Wnt10a mutant mice.

While KLF4 is broadly expressed in suprabasal cells and plays general roles in epidermal differentiation8, we identified region-specific differences in the expression of LEF/TCF family members in filiform papillae versus footpad epidermis. These may contribute to the ability of β-catenin/KLF4/LEF/TCF complexes to direct region-specific differentiation programmes. Global analysis of the target genes activated by these distinct complexes will be a fascinating area for further study.

Our finding that KRT9 expression is regulated by WNT10A through the β-catenin pathway has important therapeutic implications for WNT10A patients. Aside from dental defects that require corrective surgery, palmoplantar fissuring is the most troubling clinical manifestation in these patients and results in significant discomfort. Given the known role of KRT9 in ensuring integrity of palmoplantar epidermal cells, it is likely that decreased KRT9 is an important contributor to this phenotype. Current treatments, including topical urea to soften the epidermis and steroids to reduce inflammation secondary to epidermal fragility, are non-specific and poorly effective4. Our data suggest topical application of appropriately formulated small molecule Wnt/β-catenin pathway activators as a potentially more effective approach to treat this condition by enhancing KRT9 levels in palmoplantar epidermis.


Human tissues

WNT10A patients provided informed consent for publication of photographs, taste testing and collection of skin samples. All analyses of human patients were carried out under protocols approved by the IRB of the University of Pennsylvania, Philadelphia, PA 191904, USA and St Thomas’ Hospital Ethics Committee, Westminster Bridge Rd, London SE1 7EH, UK. Normal controls were exempt de-identified discarded tissue provided by the University of Pennsylvania Skin Disease Research Center with IRB approval. Specimens were formalin-fixed, embedded in paraffin and sectioned at 5 μm.

Starch-iodine sweat testing

Iodine/alcohol (2 g iodine per 100 ml ethanol) solution was applied to human palm or to the plantar surface of a mouse rear paw with a brush. Once dry, the skin surface was painted with starch-oil suspension (100 g starch per 100 ml castor oil) and imaged after 2–3 min (mouse) or 20 min (human).

Human taste testing and analysis of bitter receptor genes

For taste test outcome measures, the patient’s ratings were compared with data from 41 women unselected for health complaints and born within 5 years of the patient. In the taste test, subjects rated six taste solutions twice for intensity (water, sucrose, sodium chloride, quinine, phenylthiocarbamide (PTC) and denatonium benzoate)63. Each of the two ratings is referred to as a trial, that is, trial 1 and trial 2. Subjects also indicated the taste quality descriptor, which best reflected the tasted solution, that is, water has little or no discernable flavour, sucrose is sweet, sodium chloride is salty and the other three compounds tested are perceived as bitter by most people. Genomic DNA was extracted from a saliva sample for genotyping for the bitter receptor gene for quinine sensitivity, TAS2R19 and PTC sensitivity receptor TAS2R38i using TaqMan SNP genotyping assay kits (Thermo Fisher Scientific, Waltham, MA).

Quantitative RT–PCR

For human samples, total RNA was extracted from paraffin sections using proteinase K digestion, phenol–chloroform extraction and ethanol precipitation. For mouse tissues, total RNA was extracted using the RNeasy plus kit (Qiagen, Valencia, CA). RNA was treated with Turbo DNA-free Kit (Thermo Fisher Scientific) to remove genomic DNA. Treated RNA was reverse-transcribed using SuperScript III First-Strand kit (Thermo Fisher Scientific). qPCR was performed using a StepOnePlus Real-Time PCR System with Power SYBR Green master mix (Thermo Fisher Scientific). Relative expression levels were standardized against β-actin, Gapdh or Krt10 as an internal control. At least three biological replicates were assayed in all experiments with mouse tissues. Three technical replicates were performed for each sample. Statistical significance was calculated using two-tailed Student’s t-test. For experiments with human patient and normal control samples, three technical replicates were performed, but statistical significance could not be calculated as only one human patient sample was available for RNA extraction. Primers are listed in Supplementary Table 1.

Experiments utilizing genetically modified mice

Mice were maintained on a mixed strain background and were genotyped by PCR of tail biopsy DNA. Analyses of the HF growth cycle were performed in male mice due to the variability of the growth cycle in female mice. Both male and female mice were used for other analyses, and no obvious sex differences were noted. Animals were not excluded from analyses, except in the case of brief-access taste-testing experiments (see below). Experiments were performed unblinded with the exception of quantification of proliferation, and analysis of PLAs, which were carried out by researchers who were not informed of the sample genotypes. Randomization was not used as mice were assigned to control or experimental groups according to their genotype. We utilized n=5 control and n=5 experimental mice wherever possible, providing 80% power at a two-sided significance level of 0.05 to detect a difference (effect size) of 2.0 s, where s is the s.d.; at a minimum we utilized n=3 control and n=3 experimental mice, providing 80% power at a two-sided significance level of 0.05 to detect a difference of 2.8 s. All experiments were performed under animal protocols approved by the University of Pennsylvania IACUC Committee according to University of Pennsylvania guidelines.

Mouse lines

Krt5-rtTA mice16 were provided by Dr Adam Glick, Pennsylvania State University. Krt14-Cre mice64, tetO-Dkk1 mice16 and Krt14-Krm1 mice16 were generated in the Millar laboratory. Axin2-CreERT2/tdT mice16 were generated in the Morrisey laboratory. Ctnnb1(Ex3)fl/+ mice65 were provided by Dr Makoto Taketo, Kyoto University. Klf4fl/fl mice66 were generated in the Kaestner laboratory. tetO-Cre, Ctnnb1fl/fl, Axin2LacZ, R26-M2rtTA (R26-rtTA), CMV-Cre, TCF/LEF:H2B-GFP (TL-GFP), Gt(ROSA)26Sortm4(ACTB-tdTomato,-EGFP)Luo/J (R26RmTmG), Gt(ROSA)26Sortm1(CAG-Brainbow2.1)Cle/J (R26RConfetti), Gt(ROSA)26Sortm1(EYFP)Cos/J (R26REYFP), tetO-H2B-GFP and Krt8-CreERT2mice were obtained from Jackson Laboratories (Bar Harbor, ME). Wnt10afl/fl mice were generated using a modified recombineering procedure67 to construct a gene-targeting vector with loxP sites flanking exons 3 and 4. 129X1/SvJ ES cell clones were screened by long-range PCR, confirmed by Southern blotting, and injected into mouse blastocysts to generate chimeric mice. Wnt10afl/fl mice were crossed with CMV-Cre mice (Jackson Laboratories) to generate global null mutants, and to Krt5-rtTA tetO-Cre or Krt14-Cre mice to obtain inducible Krt5-rtTA tetO-Cre Wnt10afl/fl or constitutive epidermal Krt14-Cre Wnt10afl/fl mutants. Krt5-rtTA tetO-Cre Wnt10afl/fl and Wnt10a−/− mice were crossed with TCF/LEF:H2B-GFP (TL-GFP, Jackson Laboratories) mice to monitor Wnt pathway activity. For dox-inducible Klf4, Wnt10a or β-catenin mutation, or forced expression of H2B-GFP or Dkk1, mice were placed on 6 g kg−1 dox chow (Bio-Serv, Flemington, NJ). For lineage tracing experiments, Axin2-CreERT2/tdT mice were crossed with Gt(ROSA)26Sortm4(ACTB-tdTomato,-EGFP)Luo/J, Gt(ROSA)26Sortm1(CAG-Brainbow2.1)Cle/J or Gt(ROSA)26Sortm1(EYFP)Cos/J Cre reporter alleles (Jackson Laboratories). Krt8-CreERT2 mice (Jackson Laboratories) were crossed with Gt(ROSA)26Sortm1(EYFP)Cos Cre reporter mice. Tamoxifen was administered by intraperitoneal injection at 0.2 mg g−1 per day for 1–3 days to induce Cre activity.

Micro-CT analysis

Micro-CT imaging was performed using an eXplore Locus SP micro-CT specimen scanner (GE Healthcare, London, Ontario). Mouse jaws were fixed in 4% paraformaldehyde (PFA), wrapped in cloth gauze and immersed in PBS for scanning. Scan parameters were as follows: 80 kVp per 80 μA X-ray tube voltage/current, 250 μm Al filter, 400 views, 0.5° increment, 1.7 s exposure, 4 averages and 1 h scan time. Images were reconstructed at a resolution of 16 μm isotropic voxels on the same intensity scale (Hounsfield units) to allow comparison of relative apparent bone density. Colour volume renderings and multi-planar reformatted slices were generated using OsiriX ( software, and maximum intensity projections were performed using FIJI (ImageJ, NIH) software.

Histology and immunofluorescence

Paraffin sectioned and cryosectioned tissue was subjected to haematoxylin and eosin staining or immunofluorescence. For immunofluorescence assays, tissues were fixed in 4% PFA, paraffin embedded and sectioned at 5 μm, or embedded in optimal cutting temperature embedding medium and cryosectioned at 10 μm. Paraffin sections were de-waxed through graded xylene solutions, microwaved in 10 mM sodium citrate and incubated with primary antibodies, followed by incubation with Alexa Fluor-labelled secondary antibodies (Thermo Fisher Scientific)16. For BrdU labelling, mice were injected with 50 μg BrdU g−1 body weight and killed after 1–2 h. Skin samples were fixed in 4% PFA, embedded in paraffin, de-waxed and incubated with anti-BrdU antibody (Rockland Immunochemicals, Limerick, PA, 600-401-C29, 1:100)16. For tail skin whole mounts, skin samples were incubated with Dispase II and separated epidermis was counterstained with Hoechst 33342 (Thermo Fisher Scientific) and imaged on a Leica TCS SP8 confocal microscope (Leica Microsystems, Buffalo Grove, IL). For analyses of proliferation in slides stained for Ki67 or BrdU, sections were counterstained with 4,6-diamidino-2-phenylindole (DAPI). Sectioned tongue and footpad tissues were subjected to co-immunofluorescence for KRT14 to identify basal cells.

Quantification and statistical analyses of immunostaining data

For quantification of KRT8-positive cells in circumvallate papillae, total DAPI-stained nuclei and KRT8-positive cells were counted in 10 sections of circumvallate papillae from n=3 mutant and 10 sections of circumvallate papillae from n=3 control mice, and the percentage of KRT8-positive cells per papilla was calculated. For quantification of proliferation in HFs, total DAPI-stained nuclei and BrdU-positive nuclei were counted in at least 20 control and 20 mutant HF bulbs from n=4 mutants and 4 controls (P18-29) or 5 mutants and 5 controls (P25-35). For filiform papillae and plantar epidermis, BrdU or Ki67-positive KRT14+ cells and total KRT14+ nuclei were counted in 10 fields (filiform papillae) or 15 fields (plantar epidermis) at × 20 magnification from three control mice and the same for three mutant mice. For fungiform TBs, Ki67-positive KRT14+ cells and total KRT14+ nuclei were counted in three control and three mutant (P9-14), six control and six mutant (P18-26) or five control and five mutant (P25-25) mice; a total of 10 TBs was counted for control and 10 for mutant at each stage. For circumvallate TBs, Ki67-positive KRT14+ cells and total KRT14+ nuclei were counted in 30 TBs from 3 control mice and 30 TBs from 3 mutant mice. For sweat ducts, Ki67 or BrdU-positive KRT14+ cells and total KRT14+ cells were counted in 10 ducts from 3 control mice and 10 ducts from 3 mutant mice at each stage (P9-14, P100-P160), or in 10 ducts from 4 control and 10 ducts from 4 mutant mice (P25-160). Significance was calculated with two-tailed t-test. For lineage tracing at least three mice were analysed for each tracing condition; ≥20 labelled HFs were analysed for each mouse; ≥10 labelled taste papillae or sweat gland ducts and ≥3 nails were analysed for each condition.


The following antibodies were used: mouse anti-β-catenin (Sigma-Aldrich Co., St. Louis, MO, C-7207, 1:1,000); rabbit anti-β-catenin (Novus Biologicals, Littleton, CO, NBP1-32239, 1:200); goat anti-β-catenin (R&D Systems, Minneapolis, MN, AF-1329, 1:100); rabbit anti-KLF4 (Cell Signaling Technology, Danvers, MA, 4038 S, 1:100); goat anti-KLF4 (R&D Systems, AF-3158, 1:50); rabbit anti-KRT 8 (Sigma-Aldrich Co., sab4501654, 1:200); mouse anti-KRT8 (Santa Cruz Biotechnology, Dallas, TX, sc-101459, 1:100); mouse anti-p63 (Santa Cruz Biotechnology, sc-8431, 1:100); rabbit anti-p63 (Cell Signaling Technology, 4892, 1:100); mouse anti-KRT14 (Abcam, Cambridge, UK, Ab7800-500, 1:200); rabbit anti-KRT14 (Covance, Princeton, NJ, 905301, 1:1,000); rabbit anti-KRT10 (Covance, PRB-159 P, 1:1,000); mouse anti-KRT15 (Vector Laboratories, Burlingame, CA, VP-C411, 1:100); rabbit anti-FAS (Abcam, ab22759, 1:200); goat anti-LRIG1 (Novus Biologicals, AF3688-SP, 1:100); mouse anti-hair cortex keratin (AE13) (Abcam, ab16113, 1:200); rabbit anti-KRT6 (Covance, PRB-169 P, 1:1,000); rabbit anti-COL17A1 (Abcam, Ab184996, 1:200); rabbit anti-filaggrin (Covance, PRB-417 P, 1:1,000); rabbit anti-loricrin (Covance, PRB-145 P, 1:1,000); rabbit anti-involucrin (Covance, PRB-140C, 1:1,000); rabbit anti-ENTPD2 (mN2-36 L, Centre Hospitalier Universitaire de Québec, 1:200); rabbit anti-PLCβ2 (Santa Cruz Biotechnology, sc-206, 1:200); rabbit anti-SNAP-25 (Sigma-Aldrich Co., S9684, 1:500); rabbit anti-Ki67 (Abcam, ab16667, 1:200); rabbit anti-LEF1 (Cell Signaling, 2286, 1:100); mouse anti-SMA (Sigma-Aldrich Co., a2547, 1:5,000); chicken anti-GFP (Cell Signaling, ab13970, 1:1,000); goat anti-FABP5 (R&D systems, BAF1476, 1:200); rabbit anti-BrdU (Rockland Immunochemicals, 600-401-C29, 1:100); mouse anti-HOXC13 (Abnova, Taipei, Taiwan, H00003229-M01, 1:100); rabbit anti-DLX3 (gift from Maria I. Morasso, 1:200); rabbit anti-mouse KRT9 (gift from Deena M Leslie Pedrioli, 1:200); mouse anti-human KRT9 (Thermo Fisher Scientific, MA1-35569, 1:10); rabbit anti-Cyclin D1 (Cell Signaling Technology, ab16663, 1:100); rabbit anti-SOX2 (Cell Signaling Technology, 4900, 1:100); rabbit anti-RFP (Rockland Immunochemicals, 600-401-379, 1:500); rat anti-CD34 (BD Biosciences, San Jose, CA, 553731, 1:40); rabbit anti-TCF3 (EMD Millipore, Billerica, MA, ABE414, 1:800); rabbit anti-TCF1 (Cell Signaling Technology, 2203, 1:100); and rabbit anti-TCF4 (Cell Signaling Technology, 2565, 1:100).

RNA in situ hybridization

For RNA in situ hybridization with tissue sections, tissues were fixed in 0.4% PFA overnight, embedded in paraffin or cryoprotected and embedded in optimal cutting temperature embedding medium and sectioned. In situ hybridization assays were carried out using antisense digoxigenin-labelled RNA probes for β-catenin, Shh, Wnt10a, Krt1-5, Krt2-16 and Pax9 (refs 16, 29, 68). Probe templates for β-catenin (nt 150–540, NM_007614), Wnt10a (nt 1295–2487, U61969), Krt1-5 (nt 374–724, X65506), Krt2-16 (nt 520–745, AY028607) and Pax9 (nt 1431–1643, NM_011041) were synthesized by PCR of embryonic mouse cDNA, with primers containing T7 RNA polymerase-binding sites. Shh hybridization probe was synthesized from a cDNA-containing plasmid23. After overnight hybridization, the slides were washed with saline sodium citrate buffer and maleic acid buffer and incubated with anti-digoxigenin alkaline phosphatase at 4 °C overnight. The signals were developed with BCIP-NBT or BM purple system (Roche, Basel, Switzerland). For whole-mount in situ hybridization, embryos were fixed in 4% PFA overnight and incubated with 1 μg digoxigenin-labelled riboprobes in 1 ml hybridization buffer at 70 °C. After overnight incubation, embryos were washed in saline sodium citrate and maleic acid buffers and incubated with anti-digoxigenin alkaline phosphatase at 4 °C overnight. After 48 h of washing with 0.1% Triton in PBS (PBST), the signals were detected by immersing embryos in BM purple solution (Roche).

Whole-mount dye exclusion assay and immunofluorescence

For dye exclusion assays, collected tissues were placed in PBS containing the following methanol concentrations for 2 min each: 0, 25, 50, 75, 100, 75, 50, 25 and 0%. Fixed tissues were immersed in 0.1% toluidine blue solution for 2 min, and washed in PBS69. For whole-mount immunofluorescence, mouse tongues were dissected and rinsed briefly in PBS. Excess muscle and ventral tissues were removed using a razor blade. The remaining dorsal tissues were flattened on a paper towel and placed in Dispase II (2 mg ml−1 in PBS) overnight at 4 °C. The following day, epidermal tissues were separated, washed briefly in PBS, fixed in 4% PFA for 60 min at 4 °C, washed in PBS, permeabilized in 1% Triton in PBS for 60 min, blocked in 1% Triton, 10% goat serum and Mouse On Mouse blocking reagent (Vector Laboratories, Burlingame, CA) in PBS for 2 h, and then incubated with primary antibody overnight at 4 °C. Samples were washed for 3 h with PBST, incubated with secondary antibody overnight at 4 °C, washed with PBST, mounted and imaged.

Oil Red O staining

For Oil Red O staining, cryosections were cut at 10 μm, fixed in 4% PFA, rinsed with 60% isopropanol and stained with Oil Red O working solution using an Oil Red O Stain Kit (American MasterTech, Lodi, CA) according to the manufacturer’s instructions. Slides were counterstained with haematoxylin.

SEM analysis

Samples were fixed overnight in 4% PFA, dehydrated in graded ethanols, incubated for 20 min in 50% hexamethyldisilazane (Sigma-Aldrich Co.) in ethanol followed by three changes of 100% hexamethyldisilazane, air-dried overnight, mounted on stubs and sputter coated with gold palladium. Specimens were observed and photographed using a Quanta 250 scanning electron microscope (FEI, Hillsboro, OR, USA) at 10 kV accelerating voltage.

Whole-mount Nile blue staining

Dissected mouse ventral paw skin was placed in 2 mg ml−1 Dispase II (Thermo Fisher Scientific) overnight at 4 °C. Epidermis was dissected with forceps and stained in 0.1% Nile blue solution for 2 min. Samples were washed with PBS, fixed in 4% PFA and imaged on a Leica MZ16F dissection microscope (Leica Microsystems, Buffalo Grove, IL).

Two-bottle preference tests and brief-access gustometer tests

We used two-bottle choice tests and brief-exposure tests, respectively, to assess preference and acceptance of taste solutions. For the two-bottle preference tests, cohorts of 8–14 Wnt10a+/+ and 9–16 Wnt10a−/− littermates received ascending concentration series for 48 h each of two sweet compounds (sucrose and saccharin), two bitter compounds (quinine hydrochloride (QHCl) and denatonium benzoate), two sour compounds (HCl and citric acid), NaCl and capsaicin.

We carried out brief-access tests on several groups of 7–14 Wnt10a+/+ and 7–16 Wnt10a−/− littermates. Mice were weighed daily for the duration of the experiment, immediately before their placement in an MS160-Mouse gustometer (DiLog Instruments, Inc., Tallahassee, FL). Each gustometer included a 14.5 × 30 × 15 cm test chamber with a motorized shutter to control taste solution access. Taste solutions were contained in bottles on a rack that was mechanically controlled to provide the mouse with access to any one of eight specific taste solutions. For each bottle, the drinking spout was connected with a high-frequency alternating current contact circuit. This permitted detection and recording of each lick of the spout70. Zero concentration and washout trials (see below) utilized deionized water. Reagent grade taste compounds (Sigma-Aldrich Co.) were dissolved in deionized water at room temperature.

To control for any instrument-specific variation, repeat tests on each mouse were always conducted with the same gustometer and equal numbers of wild-type and mutant mice were tested with each of our eight gustometers. Mice were trained to sample taste solutions during 5 s access periods by depriving them of water for 22.5 h, placing them for 25 min in a gustometer with the shutter open, returning them to their home cage and supplying them with water ad libitum for 1 h. This cycle was repeated for 2 more days, with the exception that in the two subsequent cycles, the access shutter was closed 5 s after each time the mouse started drinking and was then re-opened after 7.5 s. All tested mice were successfully entrained using these procedures.

We administered each of the eight compounds to the control and mutant mice in three test sessions over two cycles. Responses to sucrose, quinine hydrochloride, HCl and NaCl were assayed in the first cycle, and the remaining compounds were tested in the second cycle. One 25 min session was conducted per day, and tested only one compound. For the hedonically positive compounds sucrose and saccharin70, mice received free access to food and water for 24 h followed by 2 ml of water and 1 g of food, and were tested 24 h later. Mice then received unlimited access to food and water for 24 h before being prepared for the next test. Following testing with distasteful (hedonically negative) compounds, mice received unlimited water for 1 h before being deprived of water to prepare for the next session. For testing with hedonically positive compounds, the highest concentration was administered first to interest the mouse in accessing the drinking fluid. We then presented, in random order, once each of five different compound concentrations. For each measurement, the shutter was opened for 5 s, and the number of times the mouse licked the drinking spout was recorded. The shutter was then closed for 7.5 s, followed by presentation of the next taste solution. When testing hedonically negative compounds, we included additional one-second washout sessions with water between taste tests to cleanse the mouse’s palate of the unpleasant compound and encourage it to keep licking the spout.

For each taste compound, we carried out separate statistical analyses. We averaged the results of identical tests for each compound and concentration to calculate the mean number of licks for each animal. Mixed-design analyses of variance with factors of group (wild type or experimental) and concentration were carried out using the values for each individual animal. Mice that failed to respond during any presentation of a particular concentration of a taste compound were excluded from statistical analyses for that compound. To determine differences between groups of mutant and control mice in consumption of specific taste solution concentrations, and to assess differences in the response of each group to individual taste compound concentrations, we used post hoc least-significant difference tests (STATISTICA10, Stat Soft Inc.). P<0.05 was considered significant in all analyses.


The following primary antibodies were used: mouse anti-β-catenin (Sigma-Aldrich Co., C-7207, 1:1,000); rabbit anti-β-catenin (Novus Biologicals, NBP1-32239, 1:200); goat anti-β-catenin (R&D Systems, AF-1329, 1:100); rabbit anti-KLF4 (Cell Signaling Technology, 4038S, 1:100); goat anti-KLF4 (R&D systems, AF-3158, 1:50); rabbit anti-LEF1 (Cell Signaling Technology, 2286, 1:100); rabbit anti-TCF3 (EMD Millipore, ABE414, 1:800; Cell Signaling Technology, 2883, 1:100); and anti-TCF4 (Cell Signaling Technology, 2565, 1:100). A Duolink PLA kit (Olink Bioscience, Uppsala, Sweden) was used according to the manufacturer’s instructions with minor modifications. 4–6 μm frozen sections were fixed with 4% formaldehyde for 5 min, blocked in PBS/5% donkey serum/0.8% Triton X-100 for 2 h, incubated in primary antibodies overnight at 4 °C, washed in PBST, and incubated in PLA probe anti-goat plus or anti-mouse plus, and PLA probe anti-rabbit minus for 2 h. Ligation and amplification steps were performed following the manufacturer’s protocol. The slides were washed twice in washing buffer and once in PBS for 20 min each. Slides were dried and mounted using Duolink mounting medium and photographed using a Leica Microsystems DM5500B fluorescent microscope. All assays were repeated with at least three biological replicates.

ChIP assays

ChIP assays were performed using the Chromatin Immunoprecipitation kit (Cell Signaling Technology, Danvers, MA). Mouse tongue or footpad epidermal layers were separated following Dispase II treatment, washed with PBS and cross-linked with 1% formaldehyde for 20 min. For β-catenin ChIP, tissues were cross-linked with ethylene glycol-bis(succinimidyl succinate) (Thermo Fisher Scientific) at 5 mM final concentration, with addition of formaldehyde to 1% final concentration after 30 min of incubation. All steps were performed at 4 °C unless otherwise indicated. Tissue was pulverized under liquid nitrogen with a mortar and pestle and lysed in ChIP buffer. Chromatin was sonicated to 200–900 bp using an S220 Focused-ultrasonicator (Covaris, Woburn, MA). Thirty microgram chromatin were incubated overnight at 4 °C with 10 μl anti-β-catenin antibody (Cell Signaling Technology, 9587P), anti-KLF4 (R&D Systems, AF-1329), anti-TCF3 (Active Motif, 61125) or control IgG, followed by addition of Protein G Magnetic Beads. Beads were rinsed in washing buffer and DNA analysed by qPCR. At least three biological replicates were analysed in each experiment, and three technical replicates were performed for each biological sample. Primers are listed in Supplementary Table 1.

Data availability

The authors declare that the data supporting the findings of this study are either available within the paper and its Supplementary Information files, or are available from the corresponding author on reasonable request.

Additional information

How to cite this article: Xu, M. et al. WNT10A mutation causes ectodermal dysplasia by impairing progenitor cell proliferation and KLF4-mediated differentiation. Nat. Commun. 8, 15397 doi: 10.1038/ncomms15397 (2017).

Publisher’s note: Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.