It is well known that the parallel order of microtubules in the plant cell cortex defines the direction of cell expansion, yet it remains unclear how microtubule orientation is controlled, especially on a cell-wide basis. Here we show through 4D imaging and computational modelling that plant cell polyhedral geometry provides spatial input that determines array orientation and heterogeneity. Microtubules depolymerize when encountering sharp cell edges head-on, whereas those oriented parallel to those sharp edges remain. Edge-induced microtubule depolymerization, however, is overcome by the microtubule-associated protein CLASP, which accumulates at specific cell edges, enables microtubule growth around sharp edges and promotes formation of microtubule bundles that span adjacent cell faces. By computationally modelling dynamic 'microtubules on a cube' with edges differentially permissive to microtubule passage, we show that the CLASP-edge complex is a 'tuneable' microtubule organizer, with the inherent flexibility to generate the numerous cortical array patterns observed in nature.
Plant tissues contain cells that are polyhedral in shape. The sharp edges marking the boundaries between adjacent cell faces present an interesting challenge to relatively rigid microtubules (MTs), which cover much of the cell cortex. By organizing into parallel arrays, cortical MTs affect cell wall properties, promoting expansion at right angles to their predominant orientation. The parallel nature and orientation of cortical MT arrays in plant cells raise three tantalizing questions: First, how do MTs become aligned parallel to each other? Second, in the absence of clear spatial input from a central organizer (such as centrosomes), what determines whether an array will be oriented transverse or longitudinal relative to the cell axis? And finally, how is the orientation of cortical arrays coordinated between different cell faces1?
Live imaging studies over the past decade have clarified our understanding of how MTs form parallel arrays. Following the in vivo characterization of MT dynamic instability parameters by Shaw et al.2, several papers have focused on how interactions between MTs facilitate self-organization into large-scale MT arrays3,4,5. These self-organizational mechanisms include bundling of MTs on encounter at small contact angles6, MT catastrophe on steep angle collision with another MT6, MT severing at cross over points7, MT branch-and-release from pre-existing MTs8,9, co-parallel MT nucleation within bundles10,11, and MT-detachment-based bundle formation11. In addition to these small-scale self-organizational mechanisms, large-scale behaviours such as rotary movements of MT arrays12 and domains of homogeneous MT growth orientation12,13 have also been described. Recent computational modelling studies have supported these ideas by using empirically measured MT dynamic parameters to simulate self-organized, parallel arrays14,15,16.
How array orientation direction is determined, in the absence of a central organizer, is less clear. It has long been predicted and recently confirmed by imaging shoot apical meristems that MTs align according to major stress lines17, yet, a mechanism for such alignment remains to be identified. Mutations in genes encoding various MT-associated proteins and tubulins generate cortical arrays that are sometimes abnormally tilted from their typical transverse arrangement in elongating cells18,19, suggesting that modulation of intrinsic MT assembly dynamics by MT-associated proteins is involved. How the specific handedness of MT array tilt is achieved in these mutants, however, is unknown and computational modelling using the dynamic MT parameters measured in these mutants fails to recapitulate the phenotypes of these mutants16. Cytoplasmic streaming can flow-orient microtubules, especially when they are partially detached from the cortex11,20,21,22, but this myosin motor-dependent mechanism is likely to be only a minor contributor to overall MT orientation.
Elongating cells display distinct orientations of MTs on different cell faces, with transverse arrays typical along the growing longitudinal faces and radially arranged arrays along the non-expanding transverse faces1,23,24,25. It has been hypothesized that an asymmetric distribution of MT catastrophe factors at cell ends could contribute to the formation of transverse MT arrays on the longitudinal faces26. A non-biochemical mechanism has also been suggested by in vitro experiments of MT assembly in microfabricated chambers27, which demonstrated that when MT lengths exceed cell circumference, a longitudinal orientation is energetically preferred, as this orientation confers less bending on MTs. More recently, computer simulations of cortical MT arrays incorporating self-organizational mechanisms in the model predicted that catastrophe-inducing boundaries on two opposing cell faces are sufficient to form MT arrays with a net transverse orientation15,16,28.
Here we combine live cell imaging and computational modelling to demonstrate that by inducing MT catastrophe, cell edges influence cell-wide MT organization, and that the protein CLASP modulates this edge effect to generate array complexity during cell expansion and division.
CLASP localizes to cell edges
The nomenclature used in this article is as follows. Each cell is composed of faces and edges (Fig. 1a). Periclinal faces are parallel to the organ surface, and anticlinal faces are perpendicular to it. To distinguish the two types of anticlinal faces in roots, we use transverse (cross-walls), and radial (sidewalls). For edge nomenclature in roots, edges are named by their orientation with respect to the root axis: longitudinal, transverse, and radial. In leaf epidermal cells, the edges are termed periclinal or anticlinal.
To follow CLASP's distribution at physiologically relevant expression levels, we used the CLASP gene's endogenous promoter to drive expression of a GFP–CLASP fusion protein, which in the clasp-1 null mutant fully complements the clasp-1 phenotype (Supplementary Fig. S1). CLASP expression, as indicated by fluorescence intensity, was highest in regions of active cell division and cell expansion, particularly in root tips and the expanding leaf epidermis. Expanded, vacuolated cells, in which CLASP's distribution along MTs was previously studied29,30, contained comparatively little GFP–CLASP.
In newly formed cells of the root division zone, GFP–CLASP was enriched along the transverse and/or longitudinal edges in a stage of development-dependent manner, with a weaker intensity associated with MTs on the outer periclinal face (Fig. 1b,c). CLASP edge distribution was non-uniform, forming distinct domains that were persistent over tens of minutes, yet exhibited rapid turnover of CLASP molecules, as evidenced by GFP–CLASP's photobleach recovery in 10–20 seconds (Supplementary Fig. S2a–c). In recently formed root cells (5–10 min after phragmoplast disappearance), CLASP was enriched along the outer transverse edge (Fig. 1b,c). The signal intensity and immobility of GFP–CLASP was highest during this early stage. Edge distribution was particularly prominent in cells containing preprophase bands (PPBs), in which GFP–CLASP accumulated only at edges intersected by the band (Fig. 1b,c). CLASP levels gradually tapered off in the elongation zone, and GFP–CLASP became distributed along the longitudinal edges (Fig. 1b,c). In elongating root cells with smaller diameters (particularly lateral root cap cells), GFP–CLASP often covered entire radial faces (Fig. 1b,c). A mix of these GFP–CLASP distributions was found in the transition between the division and elongation zones.
In the polyhedral cells of the unexpanded leaf epidermis, GFP–CLASP accumulated soon after cell division at the outer edge of the newly formed cross-wall, as in roots (Fig. 1d–f; Supplementary Movie 1). Along older edges, GFP–CLASP formed patches of varying sizes, often with associated MT labelling along the outer periclinal face (Fig. 1d–f).
Coexpressing GFP–CLASP and Ubiquitin1 promoter-driven RFP–βTubulin6 (RFP–TUB6) identified MT bundles intersecting cell edges at CLASP edge domains and extending into the neighbouring face, forming transfacial bundles (TBs; Fig. 2; Supplementary Movie 2). Like GFP–CLASP, TBs were positionally persistent (mean persistence time 19.0±5.4 min, n=45 cells, n=79 TBs in root division zone cells), but contained dynamic MTs, as evidenced by observing MT plus-end growth with EB1b–GFP (Supplementary Fig. S2d,e). GFP–CLASP domains resemble arc-shaped elements that curve around the cell edge in association with TBs (Fig. 2a,b). TB-like structures have previously been observed in electron micrographs from root tip cells of the fern Azolla31.
CLASP edge domain distribution varied with cell type and age, being generally enriched at the edges intersected by MTs in the dominant orientation (Fig. 2c). The size and signal intensity of GFP–CLASP edge domains correlated with the size of the intersecting MT bundle: small GFP–CLASP spots associated with small TBs (arrowheads), moderate spots associated with moderate TBs (arrows), and the largest GFP–CLASP domains were at edge regions where multiple TBs converged (brackets; Fig. 2c). Partial Z-projections, such as the 3 μm maximum z-stacks shown in Figure 1c, do not show the complete population of edge-associated GFP–CLASP, as the GFP–CLASP signal was sometimes confined to fewer optical planes than the TBs, whose curved linear structures extended across the cell faces. To quantify the association of GFP–CLASP with the RFP–TUB6-labelled TBs, we therefore manually scrolled through merged-colour optical series (an example of one such z-stack is provided in Supplementary Movie 2).
In unexpanded leaf epidermal cells, GFP–CLASP accumulated in strong patches intersected by several TBs, most likely corresponding to the prominent bands of MT bundles associated with neck formation during epidermal cell interdigitation32,33 (Fig. 2c).
Transfacial bundle-CLASP intersections are specific to sharp edges
In seeking to understand the relationship between CLASP's distribution to particular cell edges and the formation of TBs, we compared the curvature of edges rich in GFP–CLASP fluorescence with those edges lacking it. In the root division zone, the transverse and radial edges of epidermal cells are consistently sharp (being derived from recent cell division), whereas longitudinal edges are rounded (Fig. 3a–c). In these cells, GFP–CLASP showed enrichment on the transverse edges, and was intersected by TBs in 96.4±0.3% of cases (Fig. 3d,e; n=42 cells). Along the semi-rounded longitudinal edges, GFP–CLASP was faint to non-detectable where TBs could be observed, being of similar intensity to that of the weak MT lattice labelling seen on the outer periclinal face, and roughly threefold less than that along the sharp transverse edges (Fig. 3f). The few instances of TBs crossing transverse edges without associated GFP–CLASP included the rounded edges at the site of cell separation along the outer perimeter of the transverse walls (Fig. 2c, circled region). Radial edges are, like transverse edges, very sharp, yet GFP–CLASP and TBs along radial edges were undetectable, thereby excluding a generalized preference for all sharp edges. GFP–CLASP signal intensity was also greatest along the recently formed sharp cell edges of leaf epidermal cells, in which edge curvature is variable around the perimeter of the outer periclinal face (Fig. 3g,h). Taken together, these data indicate an enrichment of CLASP at specific sharp edges, and, importantly, exclude the possibility that CLASP edge accumulation is merely a coincidental outcome of MT bundles bypassing edges in general.
Microtubules orient parallel to sharp edges lacking CLASP
CLASP's strong enrichment along sharp cell edges where TBs intersect suggests that CLASP acts to locally stabilize MTs in these edge regions. To test this possibility, we compared MT organization in clasp-1 null mutants and wild-type plants. As shown in Figure 4, clasp-1 mutants displayed a marked reduction in TBs in both root tips and young leaves. Importantly, TBs were absent at sharp cell edges but could still be observed at rounded edges. We therefore define TBs that cross sharp, CLASP-populated edges as CLASP-mediated transfacial bundles (CTBs).
In recently divided wild-type root division zone cells, CTBs intersecting the sharp transverse edges define a dominant longitudinal MT orientation or contribute to a mixed MT organization24 on the outer periclinal face (Fig. 4a). In contrast, MTs in clasp-1 root tips were consistently oriented parallel to the sharp transverse edges (Fig. 4a,b), resulting in a preponderance of transverse arrays (Fig. 4c). The lack of TBs at the recently formed cell edges in clasp-1 roots was also evident by the greatly diminished MT-specific fluorescence at the focal midplane in comparison to wild-type cells (Supplementary Fig. S3a–e).
In young leaf epidermal cells of clasp-1 mutants, the absence of CTBs was associated with an apparently random distribution of MTs at the periclinal face, with MTs only occasionally extending around the edges into the anticlinal faces (Fig. 4d). Taking advantage of the fact that the most recently divided leaf epidermal cells contain both sharp, newly-formed edges and rounded older edges, we confirmed that CTBs intersected at right angles the newly formed sharp edges in wild-type cells (Fig. 4e). By contrast, MTs in clasp-1 mutants were oriented parallel to these sharp edges but could extend onto the anticlinal face at the rounded edges (Fig. 4f). Thus, CLASP is required for CTBs to intersect the newly formed edges in both root and leaf epidermal cells.
Clasp-1 leaf epidermal cells exhibited premature outward bulging, which resulted in more rounded periclinal edges (Fig. 4d–f; Supplementary Fig. S4a). Similarly, in roots, transverse edges were more rounded in clasp-1 epidermal and lateral root cap cells compared with wild type (Supplementary Fig. S4b). CLASP is thus required to maintain sharp cell edges in leaf and root epidermal cells.
Sharp edges induce MT buckling and catastrophe
On the basis of the above correlation between edge curvature and MT orientation, we hypothesized that sharp cell edges present a physical barrier to MTs. MT depolymerization and buckling are known to occur in response to the axial compression resulting from polymerization against an obstruction7,34. Indeed, we observed that, in young wild-type leaf epidermal cells, MTs encountering the sharp periclinal cell edges underwent catastrophe at the point of edge encounter (Fig. 5a; Supplementary Movie 3). MTs encountering these edges often buckled before depolymerization, which is suggestive of a growth-impeding physical obstruction7,34 (Fig. 5b; Supplementary Movie 4). Sharp edge-induced MT buckling was more obvious in the clasp-1 mutant, perhaps due to the weakened cortical attachment of MTs, which allows greater lateral mobility11,34. (Fig. 5c; Supplementary Movie 5).
CLASP mitigates the barrier effect of sharp cell edges
On the basis of CLASP's co-localization with CTBs at cell edges and its requirement for CTB formation, we hypothesized that CLASP acts to locally stabilize the plus-ends of MTs encountering cell edges, allowing them to continue growth around the edge. To test this hypothesis, we first imaged young wild-type leaf epidermal cells and compared the frequency of catastrophe on edge encounter in regions occupied by CTBs (that is, CLASP edge domains) with regions lacking these bundles (CTB-free; as indicated in Fig. 6a). There was a striking difference in the behaviour of MTs in these two regions. MTs encountering CTB-free edge domains underwent catastrophe 84±2% of the time (n=100 MTs, 23 cells), whereas the catastrophe frequency at CTB edge domains was only 9.7±8.5% (n=72 MTs, 15 cells). Figure 6b shows an example of MT persistence on encountering a CTB edge domain (Supplementary Movie 6). In young clasp-1 leaf epidermal cells, which lack CTBs, the edge-induced MT catastrophe rate was 94.3±1.2% (n=106 MTs, 19 cells), which is mildly elevated from the 84% rate observed at CTB-free domains in wild-type cells. Several examples of edge-induced catastrophes from a clasp-1 leaf cell are shown in Figure 6c (Supplementary Movie 7).
In root cells, where we could more clearly co-visualize GFP–CLASP and RFP–TUB6, MTs encountering edge domains lacking GFP–CLASP were 13.8 fold more likely to undergo catastrophe compared with GFP–CLASP edge domains (Fig. 6d; Table 1; n=154 MTs, 27 cells).
Effect of edge curvature on edge catastrophe
Edge curvature-dependent catastrophe was also apparent in the older expanding cells (Table 1). In elongating root cells, MTs encountering the semi-rounded, longitudinal edges underwent catastrophe for 26.2±4.8% of cases, compared with the 98.2% rate seen at the sharp transverse edges (Fig. 6d; n=50 cells, 141 MTs). In expanded leaf epidermal cells (in which CLASP content is low), MTs encountering edges underwent catastrophe in 65.7±4.4% of the cases, compared with the 84% rate seen in unexpanded cells (Fig. 6d; n=28 cells, 172 MTs). The higher catastrophe rates at rounded edges in expanded leaf cells compared with rounded edges in root cells is consistent with the edges in expanded leaf epidermal cells being sharper than the longitudinal edges of root cells (radius of curvature 2.5 versus 7.2 μm; Table 1). Furthermore, subdividing leaf cell edges into sharp (<3 μm) and round (>3 μm) reveals greater edge catastrophe rates in the sharp class, which further correlates edge curvature and catastrophe rates (Table 1). Taken together, these data support a broad correlation between edge curvature and MT edge-induced catastrophe rates.
Computer modelling cell edge effects on MT organization
We next used computational simulations to test the hypothesis that MT organization can be controlled by modulating the ability of MTs to bypass the edges between cell faces. We simulated MTs migrating around the cortex using algorithms published previously15 and parameters measured in this study (Fig. 7) and previous ones38,39 (Supplementary Fig. S5; Methods). The simulations incorporated dynamic instability at the plus-end and continuous depolymerization at the minus-end, and MT–MT interactions through entrainment at low angles of collision and collision-induced catastrophe at high angles of collision. We approximated the cell as a cube and simulated the presence or absence of CLASP edge domains by modulating the ability of MTs to cross different edges. A MT encountering an edge undergoes edge-induced catastrophe with probability pcati, where i=(Longitudinal, Transverse, Radial). The alternative outcome is growth of the MT around the edge.
For values of edge-induced catastrophe probabilities, we used our experimentally obtained values (Table 1). Thus, for longitudinal edges, pcatlongitudinal=0.26. For radial and transverse edges, we use the probabilities of edge-induced catastrophe measured in leaf cell edges at CTB-containing and CTB-free domains (Fig. 7a) as a proxy for edges with or without CLASP, respectively. These values are rounded to the nearest 5% and shown in Supplementary Table S1.
Simulations in which MTs easily bypass longitudinal edges, but undergo frequent catastrophe at transverse edges result in an array for which the dominant direction is transverse to the elongation axis (Fig. 7a), in agreement with simulations in Allard et al.15. This simulation represents elongating cells, which have low CLASP levels and cells of the clasp-1 mutant, which establish transverse MT arrays soon after division. In these simulations, MT arrays on the transverse faces self-organize in independent, random directions and have fewer MTs per unit area.
Increasing the ability of MTs to grow around the transverse edges (modelling the observed localization and role of CLASP in recently divided cells) generated a large increase in longitudinally oriented MTs, resulting in a mixed array, containing both longitudinal and transverse MTs (Fig. 7b). This shows that decreasing the differential in MT edge pass-ability between edges can lead to less ordered MT arrays.
Simulating a cell in which only the middle third of the longitudinal edges allows MT passage resulted in a transverse band of MTs running around the middle of the cell, which is evocative of PPBs and early leaf epidermal cells, which have non-uniform bundling within individual faces (Fig. 7c). Further permutations are included in the Methods section.
How plant cells orient cortical MTs has remained enigmatic ever since 1963 when these cytoskeletal elements were first described40. Here we demonstrate, both by live imaging and computational modelling, that the intrinsic geometry of cells provides an external organizing cue that can bias the orientation of cortical MTs. Specifically, the sharp cell edges that are found in small boxy cell types, such as those in meristems and expanding leaves, present a physical barrier that, by impeding assembly of MTs growing into them, enriches for MTs running parallel to them.
Importantly, it is the differential pass-ability of cell edges that provides a spatial cue for orienting cortical MTs. This is clearly illustrated in root tip cells, which have sharp transverse edges at the newly formed cross walls that act as barriers to MTs, and rounded longitudinal edges (derived from more distant divisions) that are more passable to MTs. Plants lacking CLASP reveal the default MT response to this geometric polarity cue: MTs orient parallel to the transverse edges, resulting in transverse arrays. To generate the mixed arrays present at the outer periclinal face of recently divided wild-type root tip cells, it is necessary to provide further MT stabilization by CLASP protein accumulation at the transverse edges. This reduces the catastrophe frequency nearly tenfold to enable incoming longitudinal MTs to grow around these sharp edges and form CTBs. In agreement with these data, when MTs on adjacent anticlinal faces enter the shared periclinal face from two disparate orientations, a criss-cross pattern is generated1. The randomized distribution of MTs in clasp-1 leaf epidermal cells eventually corrects itself when edges become rounded enough to allow MT passage, and MTs even achieve a hyperparallel organization because of increased cortex detachment and MT interactions11. Thus, an inherent bias toward MT parallelism is driven by self-organizational mechanisms. Interestingly, edge-induced MT depolymerization is reminiscent of previous observations of collision-induced catastrophe on encounter of one MT with another at large encounter angles6.
Physical barriers that impede MT growth can increase the rate of MT catastrophe34,41, possibly by retarding MT growth while GTP hydrolysis continues, thereby depleting the GTP-cap15. Because curved MT growth requires extra bending energy in the MT lattice, curvature acts as a physical barrier that will locally increase the catastrophe frequency. This effect can be incorporated into the model by reducing the polymerization rate by an appropriate factor as outlined in the dimer-level model of Allard et al.15
Given this curvature-sensitive growth, MTs growing towards a particular edge have a probability of edge-induced catastrophe that depends on the edge's curvature and MT-edge encounter angle. At first glance, the probability of catastrophe might be expected to have an increasing dependence on both curvature and angle. The problem, however, is quite subtle. A shallow angle of incidence means the MT will encounter a lower curvature but will be sustained over a longer path length. Depending on the relationship between curvature-induced and instantaneous catastrophe rate, an edge's catastrophe probability could hypothetically increase or decrease with varying angle of incidence. As dependence on angle-of-incidence has not been quantified experimentally or theoretically, in the present work, we use population averages of all MTs encountering a particular edge.
CLASP has been reported to locally alter MT dynamics in yeast and animal cells by promoting MT rescue36,42. If this function is conserved in plants, CLASP could be counteracting the catastrophe-inducing influence of the edge's curvature. A schematic of CLASP-induced edge tolerance is shown in Supplementary Figure S6. In the present study, we have not investigated the mechanism of CLASP edge targeting, but future work will address this.
Stereotypical MTOCs, such as centrosomes in animal cells and spindle pole bodies in fungal cells, are discrete centres that act locally but influence cell-wide MT organization. By locally tethering MT minus ends, centrosomes ensure that MTs radiate from a central point, allowing plus-ends to interact with the cortex. We propose that the plant cell edge also fits the criteria of a MTOC: by locally inducing catastrophe or allowing passage of MT plus-ends at specific sites along the cell edges, cell-wide MT organization is generated. We also propose that CLASP works in concert with the cell edge to act as a 'tuneable MTOC'. By modulating the location and degree of catastrophe, CLASP is able to generate cell-wide ordering of MTs. The data suggest a molecular mechanism for the previous observation of MT foci at cell edges in the fern Azolla31,43.
CLASP also functions in elongating cells, as indicated by its association with transverse MTs in these cells and the significantly reduced density of MT populations in the clasp-1 mutant30. It is nonetheless not required for generating transverse order. Indeed, the precocious establishment of transverse MT arrays in clasp-1 and the reduction in CLASP protein levels as cells enter the root elongation zone suggest that CLASP-recruiting factors at sharp transverse edges are required to overcome a strong inherent bias toward transverse arrangement.
Given that GFP–CLASP edge domains are intersected by CTBs, it is possible these bundles provide protective tracks for incoming MTs, thereby indirectly allowing edge passage, instead of a direct CLASP-based stabilization. Indeed we observed many instances of MTs encountering TBs, becoming entrained with them, and continuing growth around the edge, consistent with dynamic turnover of MTs within bundles2,44. MT-bundle entrainment was also occasionally apparent in the case of TBs within mature leaf epidermal cells (where CLASP is low or absent). As documented in our current study, MTs encountering GFP–CLASP-free edges underwent frequent catastrophe, yet GFP–CLASP did not accumulate. In other cases, however, GFP–CLASP appearance at cell edges coincided with arrival of incoming MTs. Therefore, CLASP recruiting factors might reside at select edge domains, where, by complexing with a CLASP-coated MT (or possibly plus-end-associated CLASP), they can allow edge passage. This CLASP-based stabilization of select 'pioneer' MTs could also establish the initial MT tracks for extra MTs during CTB formation.
Leaf epidermal cells attain their distinctive interdigitated shape as a result of non-uniform MT bundling around the anticlinal edges32,33. This mechanism is thought to be distinct from that in other cell types, in which MTs attain a more uniform organization on all faces. On the basis of our data, however, we postulate that all cases of non-uniform MT bundling about the anticlinal faces (such as PPBs and tracheary element MT bands) are manifestations of a fundamental mechanism that is present in all young plant cells.
Plant materials and growth conditions
Arabidopsis thaliana Columbia ecotype plants were grown in continuous light conditions on vertical agar plates containing Hoagland's medium. Young expanding cotyledon cells were imaged at 3–4 days. Root tips were used for dividing and expanding root cells.
For the pCLASP:GFP–CLASP construct, DNA was amplified from 2,040 bp upstream up to the ATG start codon of the CLASP gene (At2g20190), and cloned into the HindIII/Sal1p sites of a modified pCAMBIA1300 vector containing smrsGFP followed by a 10×alanine linker, followed by the full coding sequence of the CLASP gene. Primers were fwd 5′-atttctttgcttccttctc-3′, and rev 5′-tttttaccaaaccaccgacgga-3′.
For pUBQ1:mRFP–TUB6, 2,322 bp upstream sequence from the Arabidopsis Ubiquitin 1 gene was cloned into the HindIII/Sal1p sites of a modified pCAMBIA1300 vector containing mRFP–TUB6. This reporter is far superior to previous 35S promoter driven RFP–TUB6 because it is expressed throughout the root and aerial tissues. Furthermore, its low expression in lateral root cap cells relative to the underlying tissues allows clear observation of epidermal division zone and elongation zone cells.
Immunofluorescence and root squashing
Immunofluorescence was performed as in Ambrose et al.30 Arabidopsis seedlings grown on vertical agar plates were fixed for 1 h (4% formaldehyde (freshly prepared from paraformaldehyde), 50 mM Pipes pH 6.9, 5 mM EGTA, 1 mM MgSO4, 1% glycerol), rinsed, and digested with cell-wall-degrading enzymes (0.5% cellulose, 0.05% pectolyase, 0.5% Triton X-100) for 15 min. Specimens were then treated with 3% bovine serum albumin for 1 h in a humidity chamber, rinsed, and detergent-extracted for 20 min in 0.5% Triton X-100 before incubation in fluorescein isothiocyanate-conjugated DMA1 anti-tubulin antibody (1:75 dilution; Sigma) for 1.5 h. Specimens were mounted in Citifluor AF1 anti-fade agent.
To illustrate the distribution of GFP–CLASP within individual cells, roots were fixed and squashed onto slides to separate cells. GFP–CLASP-expressing plants were fixed using a fixation regime that preserved GFP fluorescence. Subsequent to fixing, root tips were squashed onto poly-L-Lysine-coated slides to foster separation and adherence of cells.
Microscopy and image analysis
Images were acquired on a Zeiss Pascal scanning confocal microscope, or with a Perkin-Elmer spinning disk microscope. Images were processed using imageJ software (http://rsb.info.nih.gov/ij/), and figures were assembled using Corel Draw software. MT arrays were classified as transverse, longitudinal, or mixed relative to the long axis of the root on a cell by cell basis. If over 90% of visible MTs in the cell fit a given orientation, that orientation was assigned. Transverse MTs were oriented within 0–30° of the transverse axis, longitudinal MTs were 60–90°, and cells designated mixed contained populations of both directions in similar proportions, or an abundance of MTs in oblique orientations (30–60°).
For analysis of RFP–TUB6 in root tissues, we drove expression under the Ubiquitin 1 promoter, which, unlike the 35S promoter-driven RFP–TUB6, enabled the clear visualization of MTs in all root tissues.
We used a modified version of the simulation described in Allard et al.15 with kinetic parameters taken from wild type (WT) at 31 °C and interaction parameters including both entrainment and collision-induced catastrophe. We simulated uniform nucleation at random angles at a rate of 5 min−1 m−1. Instead of the two-dimensional geometry we described in Allard et al.15, we simulated on six faces of a cube. When the plus-end of a MT is incident on an edge, two outcomes are possible: with probability pi, the plus-end undergoes catastrophe; or, with probability (1- pi), the MT becomes split into two segments, with one segment on the connecting face at an equal angle relative to the edge. Here i is the class of edge (transverse, longitudinal or radial). Edge catastrophe probabilities for all simulations were taken from quantitative measurements performed in this study (Table 1), and are summarized in Supplementary Table S1. Snapshots were taken 120 min after initiation of assembly in an initially empty cube. Simulations were carried out on WestGrid (Compute/Calcul Canada).
Sensitivity of simulations
The simulations presented in Figure 6 use dynamic instability parameters measured from WT elongating cells at 21 °C reported in Kawamura and Wasteneys39 and a nucleation rate of 5 μm−2 min−1. This nucleation rate reproduces a density of MTs that closely approximates the density in observed cortical MT arrays. We obtained similar results using dynamic instability parameters from WT elongating cells at 31 °C (ref. 39), shown in Supplementary Figure S5a, and parameters from WT division phase cells reported in Vos et al.38 with a nucleation rate of 0.2 μm−2 min−1, shown in Supplementary Figure S5b. In the case of low nucleation rates, the MT pattern is the same but with lower MT density. These figures demonstrate that our results are robust to changes in nucleation rate and independent of whether the dynamic instability parameters are in the 'bounded' or 'unbounded' regime (for details see refs 15,45) because the WT at 21 °C parameters are in the unbounded regime. Note that for unbounded parameters, the mean length and number of MTs increase gradually as the simulation continues, whereas the array ordering, described by an order parameter14,15, saturates at a steady-state value. We also observe very similar MT patterns for the dynamic instability parameters described in Shaw et al.2 and Dixit and Cyr6 and nucleation rates ranging from 0.2 to 10 μm−2 min−1 (data not shown).
Sensitivity of simulations to changes in edge catastrophe rates
We determined that the upper limit of curvature that can still allow transverse arrays to form is an ∼60% catastrophe rate (Supplementary Fig. S7a). Catastrophe rates above this were unable to generate cell-wide order.
Simulating CLASP at transverse as well as radial edges (pcattransverse=0.1, and pcatradial=0.1) generated random arrays (Supplementary Fig. S7b).
How to cite this article: Ambrose, C. et al. A CLASP-modulated cell edge barrier mechanism drives cell-wide cortical microtubule organization in Arabidopsis. Nat. Commun. 2:430 doi: 10.1038/ncomms1444 (2011).
Flanders, D. J., Rawlins, D. J., Shaw, P. J. & Lloyd, C. W. Computer-Aided 3-D Reconstruction of Interphase Microtubules in Epidermal-Cells of Datura-Stramonium Reveals Principles of Array Assembly. Development 106, 531–541 (1989).
Shaw, S. L., Kamyar, R. & Ehrhardt, D. W. Sustained microtubule treadmilling in Arabidopsis cortical arrays. Science 300, 1715–1718 (2003).
Wasteneys, G. O. & Collings, D. A. C. The cytoskeleton and co-ordination of directional expansion in a multicellular context: in The Expanding Cell, Vol 5 (eds Verbelen, J.P. & Vissenberg, K.) 217–248 (Springer-Verlag, 2007).
Ehrhardt, D. W. Straighten up and fly right: microtubule dynamics and organization of non-centrosomal arrays in higher plants. Curr. Opin. Cell Biol. 20, 107–116 (2008).
Wasteneys, G. O. & Ambrose, J. C. Spatial organization of plant cortical microtubules: close encounters of the 2D kind. Trends Cell Biol. 19, 62–71 (2009).
Dixit, R. & Cyr, R. Encounters between dynamic cortical microtubules promote ordering of the cortical array through angle-dependent modifications of microtubule behavior. Plant Cell 16, 3274–3284 (2004).
Wightman, R. & Turner, S. R. Severing at sites of microtubule crossover contributes to microtubule alignment in cortical arrays. Plant J. 52, 742–751 (2007).
Wasteneys, G. O. & Williamson, R. E. Reassembly of Microtubules in Nitella-tasmanica - Assembly of Cortical Microtubules in Branching Clusters and Its Relevance to Steady-State Microtubule Assembly. J Cell Sci. 93, 705–714 (1989).
Murata, T. et al. Microtubule-dependent microtubule nucleation based on recruitment of gamma-tubulin in higher plants. Nat. Cell Biol. 7, 961–968 (2005).
Chan, J., Sambade, A., Calder, G. & Lloyd, C. Arabidopsis cortical microtubules are initiated along, as well as branching from, existing microtubules. Plant Cell 21, 2298–2306 (2009).
Ambrose, J. C. & Wasteneys, G. O. CLASP modulates microtubule-cortex interaction during self-organization of acentrosomal microtubules. Mol. Biol. Cell 19, 4730–4737 (2008).
Chan, J., Calder, G., Fox, S. & Lloyd, C. Cortical microtubule arrays undergo rotary movements in Arabidopsis hypocotyl epidermal cells. Nat. Cell Biol. 9, 171–175 (2007).
Dixit, R., Chang, E. & Cyr, R. Establishment of Polarity during Organization of the Acentrosomal Plant Cortical Microtubule Array. Mol. Biol. Cell 17, 1298–1305 (2006).
Tindemans, S. H., Hawkins, R. J. & Mulder, B. M. Survival of the aligned: ordering of the plant cortical microtubule array. Phys. Rev. Lett. 104, 058103 (2010).
Allard, J. F., Wasteneys, G. O. & Cytrynbaum, E. N. Mechanisms of Self-Organization of Cortical Microtubules in Plants Revealed by Computational Simulations. Mol. Biol. Cell 21, 278–286 (2010).
Eren, E. C., Dixit, R. & Gautam, N. A three-dimensional computer simulation model reveals the mechanisms for self-organization of plant cortical microtubules into oblique arrays. Mol. Biol. Cell 21, 2674–2684 (2010).
Hamant, O. & Traas, J. The mechanics behind plant development. New Phytol. 185, 369–385 (2010).
Furutani, I. et al. The SPIRAL genes are required for directional control of cell elongation in Aarabidopsis thaliana. Development 127, 4443–4453 (2000).
Abe, T., Thitamadee, S. & Hashimoto, T. Microtubule defects and cell morphogenesis in the lefty1lefty2 tubulin mutant of Arabidopsis thaliana. Plant Cell Physiol. 45, 211–220 (2004).
Foissner, I. & Wasteneys, G. O. Microtubules at wound sites of Nitella internodal cells passively co-align with actin bundles when exposed to hydrodynamic forces generated by cytoplasmic streaming. Planta 208, 480–490 (1999).
Sainsbury, F. et al. Developmental reorientation of transverse cortical microtubules to longitudinal directions: a role for actomyosin-based streaming and partial microtubule-membrane detachment. Plant J. 56, 116–131 (2008).
Andreeva, Z. et al. Phospholipase D family interactions with the cytoskeleton: isoform delta promotes plasma membrane anchoring of cortical microtubules. Funct. Plant Biol. 36, 600–612 (2009).
Korn, R. W. The Changing Shape of Plant Cells: Transformations During Cell Proliferation. Ann. Bot. 46, 649–666 (1980).
Collings, D. A. & Wasteneys, G. O. Actin microfilament and microtubule distribution patterns in the expanding root of Arabidopsis thaliana. Can. J. Bot./Rev. Can. Bot. 83, 579–590 (2005).
Wasteneys, G. O. & Collings, D. A. In The Plant Cytoskeleton in Cell Differentiation and Development, Vol 10 (ed. Hussey, P.J.) 83–115 (Blackwell, Oxford, 2004).
Ehrhardt, D. W. & Shaw, S. L. Microtubule dynamics and organization in the plant cortical array. Annu. Rev. Plant Biol. 57, 859–875 (2006).
Cosentino Lagomarsino, M. et al. Microtubule organization in three-dimensional confined geometries: Evaluating the role of elasticity through a combined in vitro and modeling approach. Biophys. J. 92, 1046–1057 (2007).
Baulin, V. A., Marques, C. M. & Thalmann, F. Collision induced spatial organization of microtubules. Biophys. Chem. 128, 231–244 (2007).
Kirik, V. et al. CLASP localizes in two discrete patterns on cortical microtubules and is required for cell morphogenesis and cell division in Arabidopsis. J. Cell Sci. 120, 4416–4425 (2007).
Ambrose, J. C., Shoji, T., Kotzer, A. M., Pighin, J. A. & Wasteneys, G. O. The Arabidopsis CLASP gene encodes a microtubule-associated protein involved in cell expansion and division. Plant Cell 19, 2763–2775 (2007).
Gunning, B. S. Spatial and temporal regulation of nucleating sites for arrays of cortical microtubules in root tip cells of the water fern Azolla pinnata. Eur. J. Cell Biol. 23, 53–65 (1980).
Fu, Y., Gu, Y., Zheng, Z. L., Wasteneys, G. & Yang, Z. B. Arabidopsis interdigitating cell growth requires two antagonistic pathways with opposing action on cell morphogenesis. Cell 120, 687–700 (2005).
Panteris, E. & Galatis, B. The morphogenesis of lobed plant cells in the mesophyll and epidermis: organization and distinct roles of cortical microtubules and actin filaments. New Phytol. 167, 721–732 (2005).
Janson, M. E., de Dood, M. E. & Dogterom, M. Dynamic instability of microtubules is regulated by force. J. Cell Biol. 161, 1029–1034 (2003).
Al-Bassam, J. et al. CLASP promotes microtubule rescue by recruiting tubulin dimers to the microtubule. Dev. Cell 19, 245–258 (2010).
Bratman, S. V. & Chang, F. Stabilization of overlapping microtubules by fission yeast CLASP. Dev. Cell 13, 812–827 (2007).
Sousa, A., Reis, R., Sampaio, P. & Sunkel, C. E. The Drosophila CLASP homologue, Mast/Orbit regulates the dynamic behaviour of interphase microtubules by promoting the pause state. Cell Motil Cytoskeleton 64, 605–620 (2007).
Vos, J. W., Dogterom, M. & Emons, A. M. C. Microtubules become more dynamic but not shorter during preprophase band formation: A possible 'search-and-capture' mechanism for microtubule translocation. Cell Motil Cytoskeleton 57, 246–258 (2004).
Kawamura, E. & Wasteneys, G. O. MOR1, the Arabidopsis thaliana homologue of Xenopus MAP215, promotes rapid growth and shrinkage, and suppresses the pausing of microtubules in vivo. J. Cell Sci. 121, 4114–4123 (2008).
Ledbetter, M. C. & Porter, K. R. A 'microtubule' in plant cell fine structure. J. Cell Biol. 19, 239–250 (1963).
Janson, M. E. & Dogterom, M. Scaling of microtubule force-velocity curves obtained at different tubulin concentrations. Phys. Rev. Lett. 92, 2723–2736 (2004).
Mimori-Kiyosue, Y. et al. CLASP1 and CLASP2 bind to EB1 and regulate microtubule plus-end dynamics at the cell cortex. J. Cell Biol. 168, 141–153 (2005).
Gunning, B. E. S., Hardham, A. R. & Hughes, J. E. Evidence for Initiation of Microtubules in Discrete Regions of Cell Cortex in Azolla Root-Tip Cells, and an Hypothesis on Development of Cortical Arrays of Microtubules. Planta 143, 161–179 (1978).
Shaw, S. L. & Lucas, J. Intrabundle microtubule dynamics in the Arabidopsis cortical array. Cytoskeleton 68, 56–67 (2011).
Dogterom, M. & Leibler, S. Physical Aspects of the Growth and Regulation of Microtubule Structures. Phys. Rev. Lett. 70, 1347–1350 (1993).
Funding for this work was obtained through NSERC Discovery grant 298264-2009 and CIHR Operating grant MOP-86675 to GOW, and NSERC Discovery Grant 298313-09 to ENC, and through the UBC Bioimaging Facility.
The authors declare no competing financial interests.
Supplementary Figures S1-S6 and Supplementary Table S1. (PDF 2331 kb)
Rotatable 3D reconstructions of unexpanded leaf epidermal cells. (MOV 21476 kb)
GFP-CLASP localization in a root tip. Maximum projection z-series showing pUBQ1RFPTUB6 (red) and pCLASPGFP-CLASP (green) in a root tip at the division zone, where the epidermal layer is still covered by the lateral root cap tissue. (MOV 2370 kb)
Microtubules undergo frequent catastrophe at CTB-free cell edges. Shown is a wild-type leaf epidermal cell expressing GFP-MBD. Dots track several plus ends. The scale bar represents 5 μm. (MOV 819 kb)
Microtubules buckling at cell edges. Shown is a wild-type leaf epidermal cell expressing GFP-TUB6. The scale bar represents 5 μm. (MOV 72 kb)
Microtubules buckling at cell edges in clasp-1. Shown is a clasp-1 leaf epidermal cell expressing GFP-MBD. The scale bar represents 5 μm. (MOV 325 kb)
Microtubule persistence upon CTB edge domain. Shown is a wild-type leaf epidermal cell expressing GFP-TUB6. The scale bar represents 5 μm. (MOV 173 kb)
Microtubules in clasp-1 undergo frequent catastrophe at all cell edges that lack CTBs. Shown is a clasp-1 leaf epidermal cell expressing GFP-MBD. Dots track several plus ends. The scale bar represents 5 μm. (MOV 718 kb)
About this article
Cite this article
Ambrose, C., Allard, J., Cytrynbaum, E. et al. A CLASP-modulated cell edge barrier mechanism drives cell-wide cortical microtubule organization in Arabidopsis. Nat Commun 2, 430 (2011). https://doi.org/10.1038/ncomms1444
This article is cited by
Nature Plants (2022)
Mechanical stress effects on transcriptional regulation of genes encoding microtubule- and actin-associated proteins
Physiology and Molecular Biology of Plants (2022)
BMC Genomics (2021)
Nature Plants (2021)
Nature Plants (2021)