The emergence of complex multicellularity (CM) represents a major transition in the history of life on Earth. Animals, land plants and fungi independently evolved CM. Despite fundamental differences in form, physiology and development, all CM organisms possess tissues with defined three-dimensional architecture and specialized cell types1,2,3. Studies focusing on sister groups to metazoans4,5,6,7,8,9,10,11,12 and land plants13,14,15,16,17 have been instrumental in defining early innovations associated with the transition to CM. These include diverse protein activities mediating cell-to-cell adhesion4,7,9,11, transcriptional regulation7,8,10,11,13,14,15, signalling pathways4,5,6,7,16,17 and spindle orientation12. These important advances notwithstanding, defining the molecular basis of CM remains a major challenge for cell, developmental and evolutionary biology.

In the fungi, CM is believed to have arisen twice: in the Pezizomycotina of the Ascomycota and the Agaricomycotina of the Basidiomycota3. Branching hyphal filaments in which cellular compartments are interconnected by perforate septa characterize these taxa. The life cycles of these fungi generally alternate between a haploid vegetative phase when hyphae form a loose network suited for invasive and foraging growth, and a sexual phase when hyphae aggregate and cells differentiate to produce multicellular fruiting bodies. This is a complex process orchestrated by multiple transcription factors and signalling pathways 18,19,20, indicating that CM has overlapping requirements in animals, plants and fungi.

Cytoplasmic bridges evolved independently in all eukaryotic CM taxa, suggesting that this form of intercellular communication is indispensable for CM21. Consistent with this idea, septal pore-associated organelles appear to be key innovations for fungal CM22. Open pores permit intercellular cooperation to promote rapid invasive tip growth. However, pores are sufficiently small to be gated to isolate adjacent cells. In the Pezizomycotina, this occurs through two distinct mechanisms: peroxisome-derived Woronin bodies plug the pore in response to cell lysis23, while cytoplasm-based disordered proteins aggregate to close the pore in the context of programmed cell death24, aging25 and developmental differentiation26. The Agaricomycotina evolved an alternative solution for pore gating. In this group, the endoplasmic reticulum-derived septal pore cap is associated with pore plugging and fruiting body development27. All these systems have a multigenic basis. Thus, the transition to fungal CM was accompanied by the evolution of elaborate pore-gating mechanisms22.

Many taxa within the fungi do not conform to a simple unicellular-multicellular dichotomy. Besides the CM Pezizomycotina and Agaricomycotina, close relatives of both groups show signs of significant complexity. In the Ascomycota, the Taphrinomycotina and the Saccharomycotina harbour unicellular Saccharomyces cerevisiae (budding yeast) and Schizosaccharomyces pombe (fission yeast), respectively. However, both groups also contain species having more complex forms. For example, Candida albicans (Saccharomycotina) and Schizosaccharomyces japonicus (Taphrinomycotina) can grow as yeast or hyphae28,29, and members of the genus Taphrina (Taphrinomycotina) form a tissue resembling the spore-forming hymenium of the Pezizomycotina30. The genus Neolecta31 is by far the most enigmatic in this group: it produces hyphae with perforate septa, Woronin body-like organelles and multicellular reproductive structures closely resembling those of the Pezizomycotina31,32. This initially led to its miss-classification as a genus within this group31. However, subsequent work has firmly placed Neolecta within the Taphrinomycotina32,33. Neolecta may, therefore, be a key species for investigating the evolution of fungal complexity.

In the present study, we sequence the Neolecta genome and employ comparative and functional genomics to identify candidate CM-associated genes. This group is enriched for functions related to diverse endomembrane organelles and their transport. Altogether, our data suggest that multicellularity is ancestral in the Ascomycota. Extensive parallel gene divergence during simplification of budding and fission yeasts, and constraint leading to CM suggest that shared aspects of cellular organization select for similarly configured organelle- and transport-related machineries.


Neolecta irregularis fruiting bodies

Neolecta species have not been successfully cultured in the lab. Therefore, we initiated this study by collecting Neolecta irregularis fruiting bodies in the wild and examining them by transmission electron microscopy (Fig. 1, Supplementary Fig. 1). Hyphae within fruiting bodies have septal pores that can be occluded by electron-dense structures similar to pore-associated structures observed in the Pezizomycotina. Some of these do not appear membrane-delimited, suggesting that they are cytoplasm-derived aggregates, while others are membrane-bound and similar in appearance to Woronin bodies (Fig. 1d). These data indicate that, like Neolecta vitellina34, Neolecta irregularis possesses pore-associated organelles resembling those found in the Pezizomycotina.

Figure 1: Multicellularity and septal pore gating in the fungi.
figure 1

(a) The phylogeny of representative fungal species with sequenced genomes. CM taxa are shown with grey background. Pe, Pezizomycotina. Ag, Agaricomycotina. Sa, Saccharomycotina. Ta, Taphrinomycotina. N. cra, Neurospora crassa. A. nid, Aspergillus nidulans. T. mel, Tuber melanosporum. S. cer, Saccharomyces cerevisiae. C. alb, Candida albicans. N. irr, Neolecta irregularis. S. com, Saitoella complicata. T. def, Taphrina deformans. S. pom, Schizosaccharomyces pombe. P. gra, Puccinia graminis. S. ros, Sporobolomyces roseus. U. may, Ustilago maydis. L. bic, Laccaria bicolor. C. cin, Coprinopsis cinerea. R. del, Rhizopus delemar. B. den, Batrachochytrium dendrobatidis. (b) A simplified representation of the hypha and pore-associated membranous organelles. The colours of these organelles correspond to the text colours of the group they represent. (c) A Neolecta fruiting body collected from Black Mountain, New Hampshire. Scale bar, 5 mm. (d) Septal pore associated organelles of N. irregularis. The left panel shows an electron dense structure, which is apparently not membrane-delimited. The middle panel shows a septum that has been plugged by a Woronin body-like organelle. The right panel shows a Woronin body-like organelle free in the cytoplasm. The arrows indicate the pore and arrowheads point to the lipid bilayer. Scale bar, 250 nm. This figure is complemented by Supplementary Fig. 1, which shows additional views of the Neolecta fruiting body.

The Neolecta irregularis genome

To investigate the genetic basis for CM in Neolecta, we sequenced genomic DNA and RNA from N. irregularis fruiting bodies. The 199-fold-coverage assembly spans 14.5 Mb with a N50 size of 16 Kb, and 44% GC content (Supplementary Table 1). The assembly is validated using the Core Eukaryotic Genes Mapping Approach35, and shown to have 96% completeness.

Bootstrapped maximum likelihood trees constructed from a concatenation of 110 conserved single-copy genes provide definitive support for previous studies’ placing Neolecta within the Taphrinomycotina33 (Supplementary Fig. 2). The Neolecta genome is predicted to contain 5,546 protein-coding genes, with 99.4% of these being supported by RNAseq data (Supplementary Table 1). CM fungi typically encode 10,000 genes, while yeast genomes generally encode between 5,000 and 6,000 genes36 (Fig. 2a). Thus, from the perspective of coding capacity, the Neolecta genome is atypical of CM fungi. We also examined the origins of gene families to estimate the degree of genetic innovation occurring upstream of various evolutionary transitions. Nodes leading to CM fungi show substantial gene family gain. By contrast, lineages leading to Neolecta and clades harbouring yeast species (Saccharomycotina and Taphrinomycotina) generally show a modest gain in gene family number and a substantial degree of loss (Fig. 2b). Despite low overall coding capacity, Neolecta harbours a significant expansion of a fungus-specific transcription factor subfamily (Supplementary Fig. 3). Fourteen members of this transcription factor subfamily appear to have arisen from lineage-specific duplication, and could account for some aspects of Neolecta’s CM.

Figure 2: Estimated protein coding capacity of selected fungal genomes.
figure 2

(a) The estimated number of genes is shown for selected members of the Ascomycota and Basidiomycota. A. fum, Aspergillus fumigatus. A. nig, Aspergillus niger. A. ory, Aspergillus oryzae. B. cin, Botrytis cinerea. C. gla, Candida glabrata. C. gui, Candida guilliermondii. C. lus, Candida lusitaniae. C. glo, Chaetomium globosum. C. imm, Coccidioides immitis. C. neo, Cryptococcus neoformans. D. han, Debaryomyces hansenii. F. gra, Fusarium graminearum. K. lac, Kluyveromyces lactis. M. gri, Magnaporthe grisea. N. hae, Nectria haematococca. P. pas, Pichia pastoris. P. sti, Pichia stipitis. S. cas, Saccharomyces castellii. S. klu, Saccharomyces kluyveri. S. scl, Sclerotinia sclerotiorum. S. nod, Stagonospora nodorum. T. ree, Trichoderma reesei. Y. lip, Yarrowia lipolytica. Other abbreviations are as indicated in the legend of Fig. 1. (b) Gains and losses of gene families at terminal taxa and internal nodes inferred using Dollo parsimony. Branch colour indicates the extent of net gain (green) or net loss (black) as defined in the legend.

Phylogenetic distribution of known CM-associated functions

Using a broad sample of fungal species, including representatives from major subphyla, we next examined the phylogenetic distribution of systems experimentally shown to be required for various aspects of fungal CM. The following paragraphs sequentially cover septal pore gating, hyphal fusion, environmental sensing and developmental patterning, and cell wall biogenesis.

Genes encoding structural and regulatory proteins associated with septal-pore gating are not observed in the Neolecta genome. These include the Woronin body matrix protein HEX23, its receptor WSC37, the Leashin tether38 and the regulator SPA-9 (ref. 24). Also absent in Neolecta are pore-occluding septal pore associated (SPA) proteins from the Pezizomycotina, and components of the septal pore cap of the Agaricomycotina (Fig. 3a). These data indicate that Neolecta is likely to have independently evolved its pore-associated organelles. This is further consistent with the presence of octahedral crystals within vacuoles (Supplementary Fig. 1d), which appear to play a role in pore gating34.

Figure 3: Distribution of proteins involved in septal pore gating and hyphal fusion.
figure 3

(a) Pezizomycotina- and Agaricomycotina-specific proteins associated with septal pore gating are absent in Neolecta. (b) A subset of Pezizomycotina proteins associated with hyphal fusion (HAM-11, HAM-5, HAM-8, SOFT, ADA-1) are not found in Neolecta. Protein sequences are named according to the model system in which they have been most extensively characterized. For aliases, refer to Supplementary Table 6. The PRO-41 homologue in Neolecta irregularis was manually identified by TBLASTN. PRO41 homologues in Batrachochytrium dendrobatidis, Homo sapiens, Monosiga brevicollis, Dictyostelium discoideum were manually added based on published data86. Filled squares denote presence, empty squares denote absence. M. bre, Monosiga brevicollis. H. sap, Homo sapiens. D. dis, Dictyostelium discoideum. A. tha, Arabidopsis thaliana. Other abbreviations are as indicated in the legends of Figs 1 and 2.

Hyphal fusion occurs between vegetative hyphae and is associated with fruiting body development39. Fusion requires ancient STRIPAK18 and MAP kinase complexes40, which both Neolecta and yeasts possess (Fig. 3b). However, a group of important Pezizomycotina-specific proteins (HAM-11, HAM-5, HAM-8, SOFT, ADA-1) are absent in Neolecta (Fig. 3b). The SOFT protein41, which localizes to the Woronin body in some species42 is among these, further corroborating the likely absence of this organelle in Neolecta. Neolecta also lacks a number of other proteins (HAM-7, PRO-1, HAM-9, GAT-1, PRO-44, RCO-1) with cell fusion related functions that are ancient in the fungi. Altogether, these data indicate that, as with septal pore gating, hyphal fusion is likely to have a distinct basis in Neolecta.

Environmental cues has a key role in determining developmental fate in CM fungi. White collar proteins are blue light receptors that act as transcription factors to control diverse processes including fruiting body formation43. Velvet family proteins are also light-regulated transcription factors that control the balance between sexual and asexual development, and coordinate development with secondary metabolism19. Both White collar and Velvet genes and their cofactors are mostly present in Neolecta and other CM fungal taxa, but absent in budding and fission yeast (Fig. 4a). This is also true for NADPH oxidases (NOX) which pattern tissues through reactive oxygen species and have been proposed to be important innovations for the evolution of multicellularity44. Phylogenetic trees constructed with these sequences largely reflect known evolutionary relationships, suggesting that they have been transmitted vertically during fungal evolution (Supplementary Fig. 4a–c). Altogether, these data indicate that regulation of developmental fate through these three ancient modules has been retained in Neolecta and CM taxa, but independently lost in the two yeast lineages. They further suggest an ancestral state of rudimentary multicellularity.

Figure 4: Distribution of proteins involved in signalling and hyphal morphogenesis.
figure 4

(a) Genes involved in light- and ROS-related signal transduction are mostly present in Neolecta and other CM taxa, and absent in budding and fission yeasts. (b) The fusion of chitin synthase and myosin motors (CHS-5 and CHS-7) occurred early in the fungal lineage. These sequences were retained in CM taxa and lost in the two yeast lineages. The septal pore associated protein SPA-10 arose before the divergence of Neolecta and Pezizomycotina. Protein sequences are named according to the model system in which they have been most extensively characterized. For aliases, refer to Supplementary Table 6. Filled squares denote presence, empty squares denote absence. (c) Wild type (WT) hyphae make multicellular precursors (arrows), which mature into fruiting bodies upon fertilization (inset, scale bar, 100μm). The spa-10 mutant (Δspa-10) is defective in this developmental pathway. Scale bar, 1 mm.

Chitin synthases (CHS) are important for cell wall synthesis in fungi. Among the seven reported classes, CHS-5 and CHS-7 result from domain shuffling that links an extracellular CHS domain to a cytoplasmic myosin motor domain45, providing an important innovation for hyphal morphogenesis. CHS-5 and CHS-7 are found in Neolecta and other CM fungal taxa, but absent in most yeasts (Fig. 4b). Again, phylogenetic trees constructed with these sequences suggest vertical transmission and independent losses from yeast genomes (Supplementary Fig. 4d). SPA-10 is another important function that regulates septum deposition24. It occurs exclusively in the Pezizomycotina and Neolecta, suggesting an origin that predates their divergence (Fig. 4b). The Neurospora Δspa-10 mutant is defective in fruiting body development (Fig. 4c), further linking it to CM. Altogether, these data suggest that Neolecta has retained ancestral mechanisms associated with hyphal morphogenesis and fruiting body development.

Computational search for complexity associated proteins

Data presented thus far indicate that Neolecta lacks Pezizomycotina genes associated with pore-gating and hyphal fusion. However, its genome encodes ancestral functions associated with environmental sensing and developmental patterning, which were lost in certain yeast lineages (Fig. 4a,b). This suggests that other CM-related genes can be discovered through their pattern of phylogenetic presence and rate of divergence. Towards this end, we used BLAST46 and HMMER47 to search for genes shared by the Pezizomycotina and Neolecta, which are either lost or show a higher degree of divergence in either budding or fission yeast (see Methods).

This search identified 1,050 genes. Remarkably, the majority of these are classified as absent (37%) or divergent (47%) in both yeast species (Supplementary Data 1). Over-represented functional categories are primarily related to endomembrane transport and organization (transport routes, substrate transport, peroxisome) and aerobic respiration (electron transport and redox-related enzymes) (Supplementary Table 2). The latter are likely to have been lost in yeasts during their independent transitions to a facultative anaerobic lifestyle. However, because of oxygen’s role in tissue patterning and secondary metabolism, a subset may also be related to CM. The genes associated with endomembrane systems and their organization include eleven dynein/dynactin motor complex48 components (Fig. 5 and Supplementary Fig. 5), all eight subunits of the exocyst vesicle targeting complex49, as well as other effectors of secretion and vacuolar protein sorting50 (Supplementary Fig. 6). In the majority of cases, these are lost or more highly divergent in both yeasts.

Figure 5: Conservation and divergence of dynein regulators.
figure 5

(a) Substitution rate analysis of dynein regulators. For the indicated proteins, the degree of sequence divergence compared with the Pezizomycotina is determined by substitution rate and indicated by the greyscale. A lighter shade indicates greater divergence from the Pezizomycotina. Red text indicates proteins identified by our search for CM-associated sequences. This figure is complemented by Supplementary Fig. 5, which shows substitution rate analysis of dynein complex components. (b) The cartoon depicts the structure the Dynactin complex. Components shown in red were identified as CM-associated. (c) Graphical representation of the p150Glued multiple sequence alignment. On the vertical axis, a positive score represents greater similarity between Neolecta and Pezizomycotina homologues while a negative score represents greater similarity between Neolecta and Saccharomycotina homologues (see Methods). The grey box indicates the range of score that could be generated by chance. The dotted line represents regions missing in yeast sequences. Red background indicates residues conserved in Neolecta and both reference groups. p150Glued domains are indicated on top of the plot based on the structure of mammalian p150Glued (ref. 87). (d) Systematic length variation in p150Glued. * indicates the regions that appear to have undergone significant contraction (Mann–Whitney U-test, P-values<10−3) in the two yeast-containing groups (highlighted with grey background). This figure is complemented by Supplementary Fig. 7a, which shows length distribution of contracted domains.

Of the seven identified dynein-associated components, two appear to have been lost in both yeast species (p25 and p62), and five show a higher degree of divergence in both (Fig. 5a,b). One of these, p150Glued, has a central role in regulating cargo, microtubule and dynein motor association48. To locate regions of sequence divergence, we devised a method for sequence alignment visualization (Fig. 5c). Neolecta p150Glued is more similar to Pezizomycotina orthologues over the entire length of the protein. By contrast, yeast sequences appear to have undergone domain contraction, and near complete loss of a basic domain involved in promoting motor processivity51 (Fig. 5c,d, Supplementary Fig. 7a). Deletion of the basic domain in the model CM fungi Neurospora crassa (Supplementary Fig. 7b–d) and Aspergillus nidulans52 results in a partial loss of function. By contrast, the reduced basic domain is dispensable for function in budding yeast53. Thus, budding and fission yeasts appear to have lost important domains for p150Glued function in the CM Ascomycota.

Our search also identified a significant number of peroxin (PEX) proteins involved in peroxisome biogenesis (Fig. 6a,b). A subset of these, PEX-33, PEX-26 and PEX-8, are not detected by similarity search in both budding and fission yeasts. However, likely functional homologues (Pex17p, Pex15p and Pex8p, respectively) have been identified in budding yeast54. These protein sequences have isolated regions of limited similarity to the Pezizomycotina sequences, and appear to be mostly restricted to members of the Saccharomycotina (Supplementary Fig. 8). Whether functional homologues exist in fission yeast remains unclear; nevertheless, these observations provide another striking case of overlapping genetic divergence in the two yeasts. Our search identified an additional nine peroxins that are detected in both yeasts. However, substitution rate analysis indicates greater divergence from the Pezizomycotina orthologues as compared with Neolecta (Fig. 6a). PEX-19 has a central role in peroxisome membrane biogenesis and was, therefore, examined in detail. PEX-19 binds peroxisome membrane proteins in the cytoplasm and delivers them to the peroxisome through an interaction with PEX-3 (ref. 55) (Fig. 6b). The PEX-3 binding segment (α-a) is highly conserved. However, sequence divergence is apparent in an amphipathic helix (α-1) required for substrate binding56,57 (Fig. 6c,d). To determine the functional significance of this divergence, we replaced Neurospora PEX-19 α-1 with the corresponding region from S. cerevisiae (Fig. 6d). This variant displays a partial loss-of-function as indicated by fewer peroxisomes and defects in matrix protein import (Fig. 6e,f). Interestingly, the PEX-19 chaperone function has been documented in metazoans58 and Neurospora57. However, in budding yeast, Pex19p has been associated with production of pre-peroxisomal vesicles at the endoplasmic reticulum59. Thus, despite a high degree of overall sequence conservation, PEX-19 appears to be functionally divergent in yeast as compared to CM-Ascomycota.

Figure 6: Conservation and divergence in peroxins.
figure 6

(a) Substitution rate analysis. For the indicated peroxins, the degree of sequence divergence compared with the Pezizomycotina is determined by substitution rate and indicated by the greyscale. A lighter shade indicates greater divergence from the Pezizomycotina. (b) The cartoon depicts the peroxisomal matrix (left panel) and membrane protein (right panel) import machinery. Red outline indicates proteins identified by the search for CM-associated sequences. The green colour denotes the lipid bilayer and hydrophobic transmembrane domain of PEX-19 substrates. (c) Graphical representation of the PEX-19 multiple sequence alignment. Amphipathic segments mediating PEX-3 binding (α-a) and chaperone activity (α-1) are indicated. (d) Alignment of α-1 segment in members of the Saccharomycotina (black), N. irregularis (blue), and members of the Pezizomycotina (orange). Numbers indicate the position of the last amino acid in the corresponding sequences. Red and blue background indicates residues with negatively and positively charged side chains, respectively. Different shades of green background indicate residue hydrophobicity88. (e) Defective peroxisome biogenesis in a Neurospora strain expressing PEX-19 with the α-1 segment from S. cerevisiae. The images show the matrix marker mCherry-PTS1 in the indicated strains. Scale bar, 10 μm. (f) Mean level of cytoplasmic mCherry-PTS1 in the indicated strains. Error bars, s.d. (n=10). Statistical significance of the difference in cytoplasmic mCherry-PTS1 levels is assessed by one-tailed t-test. ** indicates P value <10−3. The inset shows steady-state levels of PEX-19 as determined by western blotting (upper panel). The lower panel of the inset shows coomassie-stained bands, which serve as a loading control.

Functional characterization of CM-associated genes

To identify new CM-associated functions, we focused on a subset of genes identified by our search (See Methods for selection criteria, Supplementary Fig. 9a, Supplementary Data 1). Deletion strains of 147 genes were systematically examined in Neurospora. Seven of these have clear defects in hyphal growth and were selected for further investigation (Fig. 7a,b). Green fluorescent protein (GFP) tags at endogenous loci show that these proteins localize to distinct punctate compartments (Fig. 7c). This is consistent with the enrichment of predicted transmembrane domains (TMDs) within the overall group (Supplementary Fig. 9b) as well as these seven proteins (Fig. 7d). Four have potential homologues in animals and plants: ROGDI (NCU08091) encodes a human protein of unknown function whose mutation results in epilepsy and dementia60, Hyphal endomembrane protein-3 (HEP-3, NCU03590) is related to Alpha/gamma-adaptin-binding protein p34 of metazoans61, suggesting a role in clathrin-mediated protein sorting, and Vezatin (NCU09240) is involved in focal adhesions in animals62 and has recently been shown to have a role in hyphal polarity63. Finally, Mitochondria-1 (MIT-1, NCU02937) encodes a novel protein localized to mitochondria. The remaining genes encode novel fungus-specific proteins: HEP-1 (NCU03589) and HEP-2 (NCU06509) contain predicted TMDs and localize to distinct cytoplasmic puncta, and Spitzenkörper-1 (SPZ-1, NCU02049) is found at the hyphal tip where it co-localizes with markers of the Spitzenkörper vesicle supply center associated with hyphal growth and morphogenesis64.

Figure 7: Novel CM-associated proteins important for hyphal development.
figure 7

(a) Substitution rate analysis of novel CM-associated genes whose deletion mutants show growth defect. (b) Mean growth rate of wild-type and the indicated deletion strains. Error bars, s.d. (n=5). The significance of growth rate difference between the wild-type and mutants is assessed using one-tailed t-test. * indicates P value <10−2, ** indicates P value <10−3. (c) The localization of the indicated proteins shown by GFP fusion at their native chromosomal loci. The dotted line indicates cell outline. Scale bar, 10 μm. The inset shows the co-localization (merge) of SPZ-1 with the Spitzenkörper marker CHS-1. Inset scale bar, 5 μm. Images in the third column show MIT-1 co-localization with the mitochondrial marker, MitoTracker. (d) Position of predicted transmembrane domains and known domains in the indicated proteins.


The results presented here resolve Neolecta’s enigmatic relationship to the Pezizomycotina. The absence of important Pezizomycotina-specific gene families associated with pore gating and hyphal fusion indicates that Neolecta independently derived these functions (Fig. 3). By contrast, key genes controlling hyphal morphogenesis, environmental sensing and developmental patterning are present in Neolecta and the Pezizomycotina, but not in budding and fission yeasts (Fig. 4). Phylogenetic analyses support vertical transmission of these gene families (Supplementary Fig. 4). Altogether, these findings suggest that rudimentary CM is deeply rooted in the Ascomycota, and that budding and fission yeasts, as members of distinct monophyletic clades, are likely to be independently derived from a multicellular ancestor.

As a multicellular genus outside the CM Pezizomycotina (Fig. 1), Neolecta provides a key species for comparative genomics. By searching for gene families present in Neolecta and the Pezizomycotina, but absent or highly divergent in yeasts, we identified candidate genes associated with multicellularity (Supplementary Data 1). This group of 1,050 genes is enriched for functions related to diverse endomembrane organelles and their transport. These include a host of peroxisome-, dynein/dynactin- and secretion-associated functions, including all eight exocyst components (Figs 5 and 6, Supplementary Figs 5 and 6). We speculate that shared aspects of morphogenesis and development are two likely constraints on the evolution of these functions in the Pezizomycotina and Neolecta, while a transition to simplified cellular organization in budding and fission yeasts selected for extensive parallel gene loss and divergence. Remarkably, we also see evidence for convergence at the level of molecular structure. This is exemplified by the retention of p150Glued domains required for dynein motor processivity in CM fungi, and their loss or contraction in both yeasts (Fig. 5c,d). In the latter case, a diminished requirement for motor processivity is potentially related to the transition to smaller cell size. The link between peroxisomes and multicellularity (Fig. 6a) is consistent with their recognized role in Pezizomycotina sexual development65, as well as demonstrated functions in intercellular signalling66 and innate immunity67 in other CM taxa. How convergent loss of peroxins alters peroxisome function in yeasts remains unclear. However, all these genes act in matrix protein import, suggesting that their loss/divergence may relate to diminished diversity of imported proteins. This is supported by the 2-fold lower percentage of proteins bearing the peroxisomal targeting signal 1 (PTS1) in Ascomycota yeasts compared with the CM Pezizomycotina (Supplementary Fig. 10).

Our computational search allowed for genes to be lost in either budding or fission yeast. However, the overwhelming majority of recovered genes were lost or divergent in both (84%) (Supplementary Data 1). This finding suggests a profound degree of coding capacity convergence in these two yeast clades. This is likely to be the product of shared ecological, physiological and cellular selective pressures. Convergent simplification in the these yeasts is supported by previous work demonstrating convergent loss of Complex I of the mitochondrial respiratory chain68, and the parallel diversification of an ancestral transcription factor family69. Convergent phenotypic evolution with a similar genetic basis has been observed in a number of taxa. However, documented examples typically involve a limited number of genetic loci (reviewed in ref. 70). Our results show that effectors of endomembrane organization can be subject to massive convergence. This further implies that evolution can be predictable, even when targets of selection are complex and controlled by a large number of genetic loci. This finding has potentially far-reaching implications. Determining the underlying causes and generality of such predictability will require more work.

Haploid genetic model CM fungi such as Neurospora allow the combined use of comparative and functional genomics. This allowed us to identify previously uncharacterized genes that represent gains-of-function accompanying the transition to CM. Most of their gene products appear to be organelle-associated (Fig. 7). These include SPZ-1 (Spitzenkörper vesicle supply center), MIT-1 (mitochondria), HEP-3 (endosomes), HEP-1 and HEP-2 (uncharacterized compartments). Overall, these genes appear to have arisen throughout the evolutionary history of the lineage, predating the animal-fungi divergence, the radiation of the fungi and the Neolecta-Pezizomycotina divergence (Figs 4 and 7). Many of the protein functions underlying complexification in metazoans4,5,6,7,8,9,11,12 and land plants13,14,15,16,17,71 are present in their less complex relatives. Thus, in animals, plants and fungi, important CM-associated systems began to accumulate before the radiation of extant CM taxa.

Examination of extant taxa in animal and plant lineages generally suggests that progress towards increasingly complex forms is associated with the emergence of novel genes and gene family expansion4,5,6,7,8,9,10,11,12,13,14,15,16,17,71. However, because close relatives to CM groups can independently simplify11, inferring the nature of a common ancestor is challenging. The Neolecta genome points to a common multicellular ancestor in the Ascomycota. This is further consistent with the presence of many CM-associated genes in Neolecta’s close relative Taphrina, which displays significant developmental complexity30. Saitoella also possesses CM-associated genes. However, unlike Neolecta and Taphrina, Saitoella has only been reported to be a unicellular budding yeast33. This apparent incongruity could indicate that it is currently undergoing genome reduction. Alternatively, because Saitoella has received little attention, it may possess as-yet unrecognized complexity. In keeping with this scenario, we find that Saitoella can produce hypha-like cells under conditions of nitrogen starvation (Supplementary Fig. 11). This provides one basis for Saitoella’s gene content similarity to the CM groups. However, more work is required to understand Saitoella’s developmental complexity and function of its CM-associated genes.

Our computational search was designed to cast a wide net for complexity-related genes and its output is not meant to definitively identify genes associated with CM. As with Saitoella, other species outside of CM groups can possess genes identified by the search (for example, Candida albicans). Interestingly, the choanoflagellate and filasterean sister groups to animals do not meet the criteria of CM, yet possess many genes associated with metazoan CM7,11. The fungi present a spectrum of biological complexity whose genetic basis remains poorly understood, and many factors can contribute to the apparent presence or absence of a given gene. Thus, case-by-case experimental evidence is required to determine the function of a given gene in a given species.

Increasing endomembrane complexity appears to be a prerequisite for the emergence of organismal complexity. This is consistent with findings presented here (Fig. 7), as well as previous work showing that expansion of SNARE protein gene families accompanied the emergence of CM in green plants and metazoans72,73. Complex cellular architecture, diversified modes of cell–cell communication, and increased cell type diversity are all likely to be tied to this expansion. In the Pezizomycotina, the Spitzenkörper vesicle supply center contains concentric layers populated by distinct micro- and macro-vesicles64,74. This type of vesicle organization is not observed in hyphae of early diverging fungi74. The novel SPZ-1 protein can begin to account for this complexification. Cell polarity and secretory proteins shown to have a role in organizing the Pezizomycotina Spitzenkörper are all ancient64, suggesting that these are unlikely to fully account for this intricate organization. SPZ-1 executes an important function (Fig. 7b) and appears to have arisen before the divergence of Neolecta and the Pezizomycotina (Fig. 7a). Thus, SPZ-1 can begin to account for the gains-of-function required for Spitzenkörper complexification.

Understanding the emergence of biological complexity requires the identification of relevant genes combined with knowledge of the mechanistic role played by their protein products. The former task is commonly achieved by searching for systematic gene/domain gain and loss. Our approach complements this method by also allowing for the identification of sequence variation embedded in otherwise conserved genes. Mechanistic function is often inferred from sequence similarity to known domains. As demonstrated here, combining unbiased comparative genomics with functional characterization afforded by haploid genetics allows efficient identification of complexity-associated molecular machineries. This approach also has the potential to identify the mechanisms that fostered them.


Phylogenetic distribution of known developmental genes

Detailed methods on genome sequencing, assembly, annotation and phylogenetic analyses (including gene family gain-loss and expansion analyses and identification of dynein complex component orthologues) are described in the Supplementary Methods.

The presence of homologues to known developmental genes from other fungi was detected by BLAST46 and HMMER3 (ref. 47) (v3.1b1). HMM profiles were constructed from alignments of orthologues to characterized developmental genes in up to 22 fungal species representing Ascomycetes, Basidiomycetes, Mucoromycotina, Chytridiomycetes and Blastocladiomycetes. The HMM profiles were then used to search for homologues in the predicted proteomes of Neolecta and other fungi with the hmmscan function of HMMER3 (e-value=1e−5). Best hits were used for a BLAST search against the predicted Sordaria macrospora proteins (e-value=1e−5), and orthologues were considered as present if the protein encoded by the corresponding developmental gene from S. macrospora was the best hit in the reciprocal BLAST analysis.

Identification of candidate CM-associated genes

Protein products of genes common to the Pezizomycotina and Neolecta were identified using BLASTP46 (e-value=1e−3) with Neurospora sequences as queries. Sequences were considered if they were present in at least 7 out of 14 Pezizomycotina species included. HMM profiles of these sequences were constructed using Pezizomycotina homologues using HMMER3 (ref. 47), which were then used to search for homologues in 41 representative fungal, metazoan and plant proteomes (Supplementary Table 3). Sequences were selected for further analysis if they fit these criteria: −log10(e-value) of the best hit in S. cerevisiae and S. pombe must be lower than that of the best N. irregularis hit by at least 60, 40 or 20, when the best N. irregularis hit has −log10(e-value) in the range (200, +∞), [100,200], or [1,100), respectively (examples are shown in Supplementary Methods). Genes were selected for functional characterization if they encode a protein that is (1) present in N. irregularis and the Pezizomycotina, and (2) not detected in S. cerevisiae, S. pombe and non-fungal species using BLASTP (NCBI nr database, e-value=1e−3).

Computational analyses of candidate CM-associated genes

Functional enrichment analysis was performed using FungiFun75. TMDs in the Neurospora proteome and the set of candidate CM-associated proteins were predicted using TMpred76. The presence of PTS1 was predicted by searching for the signature C-terminal tripeptide [SAC][KRH]L77 in proteins of target proteomes (Supplementary Table 4). For substitution rate analysis, a multiple sequence alignment was built for each protein and its homologue using MUSCLE78. The alignment was then trimmed using trimAl (ref. 79) (-gt 0.8 -cons 0.5) and used to construct a maximum likelihood tree using PhyML80 with optimized tree topology, branch length and substitution rate. For each species x in the tree, the evolutionary distance between its protein sequence and the Pezizomycotina ancestral sequence was estimated by the score, (unit: substitutions/site), where d(x) denotes the branch length from species x to the Pezizomycotina root, p represents the number of Pezizomycotina species present in the tree. In words, s(x) was calculated as the difference between two measures: (1) the distance from species x to the Pezizomycotina root, and (2) the average distance from all extant Pezizomycotina sequences to the Pezizomycotina root. This score was used to determine the greyscale shown in Figs 5, 6, 7.

Graphical representation of multiple sequence alignment

Plots in Figs 5c and 6c were generated based on alignments of Pezizomycotina, N. irregularis, and Saccharomycotina homologues. For each position in the alignment, sum-of-pairs score of Neolecta-Pezizomycotina sequences (x) and sum-of-pairs score of Neolecta-Saccharomycotina sequences (y) were calculated following the BLOSUM62 substitution matrix81 and a gap penalty of 3. The Pezizomycotina-similarity score for that position was the difference (xy). A positive score indicates greater Neolecta-Pezizomycotina similarity. The scores were averaged by the Savitzky-Golay filter82 (window=41, 5th order polynomial), and plotted over the length of the Neolecta sequence. The insignificant range (grey region in the plot) was estimated by calculating the scores in the same way, for 1,000,000 randomly generated alignment columns, taking into account naturally occurring amino acid frequencies found in the BLOSUM62 matrix. A score was considered significant if it was higher than 95% of the scores resulting from those randomly generated.

Neurospora genetics

All Neurospora strains used in this study were backcrossed to wild-type strains FGSC465 or FGSC466 to obtain homokaryon mutants. Deletion mutants were obtained from the Fungal Genetics Stock Center’s arrayed mutant collection83. CM-associated genes with growth-defective deletion mutants were GFP-tagged in FGSC9719 or FGSC9720 background using Marker Fusion Tagging84. To express the p150Glued variant without the linker region, fusion polymerase chain reaction (PCR) was performed to join a DNA fragment encoding an HA-epitope tag and hygromycin B resistance protein to genomic DNA fragments flanking the linker region. The fusion PCR product was used to transform Neurospora strain FGSC9720. To express PEX-19 with S. cerevisiae α-1 and α-a, the region encoding these in Neurospora pex-19 genomic DNA were replaced with those from S. cerevisiae. The constructs were targeted to the his-3 locus85 using the pBM60 vector in a Δpex-19 background expressing mCherry-PTS1 (ref. 57). An HA-epitope tag was incorporated in both the variant and wild-type PEX-19 to detect their expression by western blot, using horseradish peroxidise-conjugated rat monoclonal anti-HA antibodies (Roche 12013819001, 1:2,500 dilution). Uncropped images of gels and blots, which were acquired using ChemiDoc Touch Imaging System, are shown in Supplementary Fig. 12. Strains, plasmids, and primers used to generate them are listed in Supplementary Table 5. For growth rate determination, conidia from strains of interest were inoculated on plates with Vogel’s N medium. After one day of growth, agar blocks of equal dimensions were cut 2 mm behind the colony’s growth front and placed inside race tubes fashioned from 25 ml disposable pipettes containing the same medium. The average growth rate per hour was calculated from the distance travelled by the colony’s growth front after 48 h.

Image acquisition and analysis

Images shown in Figs 6e and 7c were taken using a Leica SP8 inverted confocal microscope with the HCX PL APO 100 × /1.40 OIL objective and acquired by Leica Application Suite X. To measure the level of cytoplasmic mCherry-PTS1 signal and construct the graph shown in Fig. 6f, images of 10 growing hyphal tips randomly selected from each strain were obtained using fixed microscope settings. ImageJ ( was used to quantify the total and peroxisomal mCherry-PTS1 signals. The difference between these gives the cytoplasmic signal.

Code availability

Computer scripts used to generate and process data presented in this paper can be found at

Data availability

The Neolecta irregularis whole-genome shotgun project has been deposited at DDBJ/ENA/GenBank under the accession LXFE00000000. The assembly can be reached through NCBI ( using the accession no. LXFE01000000, BioProjectID 167926. The species tree shown in Supplementary Fig. 2 and the concatenated alignment used to generate it have been deposited at TreeBase ( Other data relevant to the findings presented here are available upon request.

Additional information

How to cite this article: Nguyen, T. A. et al. Innovation and constraint leading to complex multicellularity in the Ascomycota. Nat. Commun. 8, 14444 doi: 10.1038/ncomms14444 (2017).

Publisher’s note: Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.