Lasing at the nanometre scale promises strong light-matter interactions and ultrafast operation. Plasmonic resonances supported by metallic nanoparticles have extremely small mode volumes and high field enhancements, making them an ideal platform for studying nanoscale lasing. At visible frequencies, however, the applicability of plasmon resonances is limited due to strong ohmic and radiative losses. Intriguingly, plasmonic nanoparticle arrays support non-radiative dark modes that offer longer life-times but are inaccessible to far-field radiation. Here, we show lasing both in dark and bright modes of an array of silver nanoparticles combined with optically pumped dye molecules. Linewidths of 0.2 nm at visible wavelengths and room temperature are observed. Access to the dark modes is provided by a coherent out-coupling mechanism based on the finite size of the array. The results open a route to utilize all modes of plasmonic lattices, also the high-Q ones, for studies of strong light-matter interactions, condensation and photon fluids.
Plasmonic systems offer small mode volumes, ultrafast dynamics and nanoscale operation, which opens new prospects for light-matter interactions. Strong coupling between plasmonic modes and ensembles of emitters has been demonstrated1,2, and strong coupling even at the level of a few emitters has been reached at room temperature3,4. Gain assisted propagation of plasmon polaritons, spacing and lasing have been predicted5,6,7,8,9 and studied experimentally10,11,12,13,14,15,16,17,18,19,20,21,22,23,24, and the possibility of photon condensates has been proposed25. The fundamental tradeoff between the confinement of optical fields and losses26 render plasmonic systems inherently lossy. This motivates a search for hybrid modes where losses can be reduced by a narrow-linewidth component while still preserving the near-field characteristics of the plasmonic component.
Lattices of metal nanoparticles support modes called surface lattice resonances (SLRs) which are hybrids of localized nanoparticle surface plasmon resonances and diffracted orders (DOs) of the periodic structure27,28,29,30. The mode energies, losses and optical density of states can be tuned by lattice and particle geometry. The SLRs combine extreme optical confinement with the narrow linewidths inherent in the DO part of the hybrid. Indeed, strong coupling with organic molecules in such a system has been observed2,31,32. Infrared lasing at weak coupling regime has been realized in such lattices15,24, with linewidths of <1.3 nm (ref. 15). As the losses of an optical dipole scale as ω4, noble metals can suffer considerably higher losses at visible compared to IR. A key question has been whether similar nanoparticle structures could support lasing also at visible frequencies. Importantly, plasmonic lattices can also support so-called dark SLR modes, whose subradiant character results to significantly higher Q-values as compared with their radiant (bright) counterparts33. Thus plasmonic dark modes are promising candidates for realizing lasing, single-emitter strong coupling, and photon fluids at visible wavelengths. A central challenge is how to excite and couple out these inherently subradiant modes.
Here, we experimentally demonstrate lasing at the visible wavelengths in both bright and dark modes of the plasmonic lattice. A new concept to access the dark modes is introduced, which is based on a gradual, coherent build-up of dipole moments in a finite lattice.
Dark and bright modes of an infinite lattice
We fabricate and measure arrays of silver nanoparticles on glass, with interparticle spacings of 360–400 nm and array sizes of 100 × 100(μm)2, see Methods. Figure 1a–c shows the measurement setup, schematic and scanning electron micrograph of a sample. In Fig. 1d the measured dispersion E(kx) of a typical sample is shown, where kx is the in-plane momentum in the x-direction. Yellow features correspond to the bright modes that respond to the far-field radiation incident on the sample in the transmission measurement, while the location of the dark mode is indicated by a circle. Figure 1e,f shows the corresponding electric field and charge distributions found by Finite-Difference Time-Domain (FDTD) simulations for an infinite array. In Fig. 1e, a standing wave antinode at each particle location induces a large dipole moment and radiation to the far field, thus it is referred to as a bright mode. In Fig. 1f, however, the field gradient related to a field node induces a quadrupole moment into each particle resulting to zero net dipole moment and negligible far-field radiation, a feature of a dark mode. For both cases, the plasmonic component of the hybrid is evident from the strong near fields in the particle vicinity. A dark mode here specifically refers to one band-edge mode missing in the far field. There are other categories of dark modes in plasmonics systems which present a subradiant mode, especially in metamaterials with symmetry-breaking features34,35.
We combine the lattices with a 31 mM solution of Rhodamine 6G molecules. For concentrations of this order of magnitude, formation of aggregates is not significant36. Addition of the dye molecules modifies the refractive index surrounding the structure, shifting the SLR resonances slightly from Fig. 1. We excite the molecules with a 100 fs laser pulse (500 nm centre wavelength) and observe the emission, see Methods. Figure 2a–c shows the momentum and energy distribution of the sample emission with different pump fluencies. Below threshold, the emission closely follows the dispersion of the SLR mode (Fig. 2a). The emission spectra in Fig. 2d shows that at threshold, an intense and narrow emission peak at 2.185 eV is observed, and well above threshold a second peak appears at 2.178 eV. The momentum distributions of these two peaks are shown in Fig. 2b,c, respectively. For both peaks, characteristic signatures of lasing, such as rapid nonlinear increase of emission intensity, reduction of linewidth, and a blue shift of the emission are observed in response to increasing pump fluence, see Fig. 2e,f. Further, a high beam directionality with divergence of 0.3° is observed for both modes. The qualitative behaviour of lasing thresholds is well reproduced by an FDTD simulation with the dye molecules described as four-level systems (for details see Methods), as shown by Fig. 2g. The simulations show lasing at two separate energies, 2.169 and 2.142 eV. The higher energy mode has a lower lasing threshold, analogous to the experiments.
To further characterize the lasing, several control experiments were carried out. First, a sample with equal area and amount of nanoparticles but at random positions exhibits no lasing, ruling out random lasing37. FDTD simulations of our structures show that the near fields decay, in the z-direction perpendicular to the array, to 5% of the peak value within 100 nm. We deposited polymer poly(vinyl alcohol) (PVA) layers of various thicknesses on top of the array so that the gain medium was separated from the nanoparticles: for thickness of about 100 nm we observed lasing, but not for 500 nm (Supplementary Fig. 1; Supplementary Note 1). For phenomena reliant on strong coupling, the presence of the emitters extremely close to the nanoparticles is expected to be more essential than for our lasing which takes place in the weak coupling regime. As one more control, in contrast to ref. 23 where SLRs hybridize with waveguide modes, our samples exhibit no lasing when over 75% of particles are removed. For more information about the control experiments with 0, 50 and 75% of particles removed, see Supplementary Figs 2–4 and Supplementary Note 1.
Real space images
From Fig. 2d–f we note that the higher energy lasing mode has a lower threshold, higher emission intensity, and a slightly narrower linewidth compared with the lower energy peak. It could therefore be associated with the low loss dark mode. However, in case of an infinite array size, the dark mode should not radiate to the far field, see Fig. 1f. Curiously, the higher energy mode exhibits multiple peaks in k, whereas the lower energy lasing mode shows only a single peak at k=0, see Fig. 2c. A striking difference between the two cases is observed also in real space images of the lasing action. These far field microscope images correspond to the real space distribution of radiation from the sample but are not the same as the near-field distribution. Figure 3a,b shows that the lower energy mode lases in the middle of the array, while in the case of the upper energy mode the lasing light is predominantly visible at the edges. In Fig. 3c,d are shown multipolar scattering simulations, without a gain medium, of a finite 85 × 85 particle array under the y-polarized plane wave excitation (for details see Methods). In the simulations the particle polarizabilities include both dipolar and quadrupolar components. The real-space images in far field result from radiation emitted by the sample. The far field emission power is dominated by dipoles, thus the radiated far field intensities in Fig. 3a,b are proportional to the square of induced dipole moments. Notably, the phase of the dipole moment stays nearly constant across the array for the lower energy mode (Fig. 3e), whereas for the higher energy mode the phase undergoes an abrupt π-phase shift at the centre of the array (Fig. 3f). The amplitudes and phases of the quadrupolar moments for both modes are shown in Supplementary Fig. 5, and the related discussion can be found from Supplementary Note 2.
Finite size effects
We hypothesize that the higher energy mode is indeed the dark mode, and that its visibility, the peculiar beating pattern in k and the real space distribution of the lasing light are all consequences of gradual evolution of radiation fields in the array due to finite-size effects. Figure 4 shows schematically how finite size effects can lead to radiating dipoles near the edge of the array that are either in the same (bright mode) or opposite (dark mode) phase. Importantly, such a picture holds only if spatial coherence is preserved over the whole array. The profoundly different character of the two modes is manifested in their dipole moment distributions. According to the argument of Fig. 4, for the bright (dark) mode, the induced dipole moments maximize in the centre (edges) of the array. The dark mode in a finite lattice is thus a hybrid mode containing also features typical for a bright mode of an infinite lattice, such as dipoles, which makes it visible in the far field. The expected radiation in real space is strongest where the dipoles maximize. Indeed, in the real space images of the lasing action, the bright mode mainly emits from the centre of the array (Fig. 3a), whereas the dark mode radiates from the edges (Fig. 3b). Similar behaviour is visible in the simulations (Fig. 3c,d).
The different real-space distributions of the two lasing modes are expected to lead to distinct behaviour of the corresponding far-field momentum distribution. Analogous to single slit interference, the bright mode acts as a source with a constant phase and nearly equal amplitude, leading to an odd beating pattern in k (constructive interference at k=0). For the dark mode, radiation maximizes towards the edges, and thus a double slit analogy can be made. Due to the π-phase shift in the radiation fields across the array, an even beating pattern in k is expected (destructive interference at k=0). Indeed, in Fig. 2c, we observe a peak at k=0 for the lower energy mode and two peaks shifted away from k=0 for the higher energy, as expected for bright and dark modes, respectively.
As the ultimate test to our hypothesis, the even beating pattern in k for the dark mode should depend on the array size. This is exactly what we observe: as the array size is decreased, the spacing of the beating pattern maxima gradually increases (Fig. 5), depending linearly on the inverse of the array size, which is expected for small angles. The associated beating pattern in k shows that spatial coherence of the lasing action extends over the whole array for the system sizes (50–100 m) considered. From the lasing spectra for different array sizes (Fig. 5c) it is apparent that while smaller arrays have a higher pump threshold, the mode linewidth is not increased significantly. We have thus shown lasing in the dark mode which can be coupled out by a unique approach based on the finite size of the array.
In summary, we have demonstrated lasing at visible wavelengths both in dark and bright modes of a nanoparticle array. Even though plasmonic systems at visible wavelengths are lossy, we achieve remarkably narrow (0.2 nm) linewidths, an increase of four orders of magnitude in emission intensity above threshold, low beam divergence of 0.3°, and spatial coherence lengths of 100 μm. This achievement, together with earlier reaching of the strong coupling regime31,32, paves the way for studies of phenomena, which combine strong interactions with macroscopic mode population, for example thresholdless lasing, photon and polariton condensation, and photon fluids. The dark-mode out-coupling mechanism that we introduce is not simple scattering or leakage from sharp edges of the system, rather, it is gradual, coherent build-up of dipole moments and radiation intensity. This inspires ideas for the design of not only out-coupling schemes but also beam guiding, trap potentials, topologically non-trivial lattices and edge modes, for instance by gradually changing the pitch and by particle shapes supporting higher order multipoles.
Using electron beam lithography, rectangular arrays of cylindrical (nomimal diameter 60 nm, height 30 nm) silver nanoparticles were fabricated on a borosilicate substrate. The angle resolved transmission spectra were obtained by focusing light from a white LED onto a sample. A 10 × 0.3 NA objective focused onto the sample surface collected the transmitted light.
The image of the back focal plane of the objective was focused to the entrance slit of the spectrometer. Thus the transmitted (or emitted) light from the sample into a given angle is focused into a single position on the entrance slit. One axis of the two-dimensional (2D) CCD camera of the spectrometer can then be used to resolve the angle of the transmitted/emitted light, while the other axis is used to resolve the wavelength. The E(k) dispersions were subsequently calculated from the angle and wavelength resolved spectra as E=hc/λ and . Here k0=2π/λ and θ is the angle with respect to sample normal. The real space images were obtained by focusing the image plane of the same sample onto a separate 2-D CCD camera.
For lasing measurements, the gain medium was pumped with a femtosecond laser (45° incident angle, 500 nm centre wavelength, 100 fs pulse width, 1 kHz repetition rate). The gain medium consisted of 31 mM Rhodamine 6G in Benzyl Alcohol.
The beam divergence is obtained from the angle resolved lasing data (Fig. 2) by plotting the emission intensity as a function of in-plane k-vector at the lasing energy. From this crosscut, we can determine the full-width-half-maximum value of each individual lasing peak, ΔkFWHM. For small angles sin(θ)≈θ, and thus the divergence can finally be defined as (rad), where k0 is the free space wavenumber. The angular separation of the two peaks at dark mode energy (Fig. 5) can be calculated with the previous equation by replacing ΔkFWHM with peak separation Δk.
FDTD simulations were done using Lumerical's FDTD Solutions software. The nanoparticle was modelled as a 30 nm tall cylinder with a diameter of 60 nm. Tabulated material parameters for silver were used38. The background refractive index was set to 1.52. For the field profile simulations the simulation mesh was set to 0.6 nm over the volume of the nanoparticle. Ten dipole sources with random orientation, location, and phase excite the SLR modes with a 3.3 fs pulse at the beginning of the simulation. Field profiles were recorded after the simulation had ran for 700 fs to filter out the excitation pulse. An infinite array was considered in the simulations by choosing the x and y boundary conditions to be either asymmetric and symmetric (bright mode, Fig. 1e) or asymmetric and asymmetric (dark mode, Fig. 1f), respectively. This selection of boundary conditions allows to isolate the modes of interest, and control the polarization direction of the bright mode. As the structure has the same periodicity in the x and y, equivalent modes exist also in the perpendicular direction to the one shown in Fig. 1e,f.
The simulations with gain in FDTD were done using a similar model, except this time periodic boundary conditions were used for both x and y to allow both the bright and dark modes to exist simultaneously. The excitation of the modes is done by pumping the dye molecules with a 500 nm, 30 fs, 0.01–2.5 mJ cm−2 pulse normally incident on the structure. The dye is modelled as four-level systems, which are coupled to the electric fields in time domain, similar to ref. 39. After the pump pulse, the excitations in the dye molecules relax to the upper lasing state, and from there excite the bright and dark SLR modes through stimulated emission if the population inversion is sufficient to overcome the losses in the system, see Supplementary Figs 6 and 7 and Supplementary Note 3. For the parameters used to model the dye and for a more detailed description of the model, see Supplementary Fig. 8 and Supplementary Note 3. In addition to the FDTD modelling shown in the main text, we have used a neo-classical model with simplified description for the SLR modes to simulate the lasing action in a nanoparticle array40, see Supplementary Fig. 9 and Supplementary Note 4 for details.
Our theoretical calculations of the array response, see Fig. 3, are based on the multiple scattering T-matrix method41, which is a generalization of the often-used coupled dipole approximation, enabling to take into account multipole responses of a single nanoparticle up to an arbitrary multipolar order. We compute the electromagnetic response (T-matrix) of a single nanoparticle using scuff-em, an open-source implementation of the boundary-element method (http://github.com/homerreid/scuff-EM)42. The nanoparticle parameters are the same as in the FDTD simulations above. All the calculations are performed up to the quadrupole order. Figure 3c shows the magnitudes of the electric dipole moment in the y-direction among the nanoparticles when the array is excited by the y-polarized plane wave coming from the normal direction, at a frequency corresponding to the bright mode. Figure 3d depicts the same y-dipole response when the array is excited by two y-polarized plane waves with opposite incident angle, corresponding to the peaks of the observed k-space beating patterns. A brief explanation of the multiple scattering method and figures showing the quadrupole response among the nanoparticles are provided in Supplementary Fig. 5 and Supplementary Note 2.
The authors declare that relevant data supporting the findings of this study are available on request.
How to cite this article: Hakala, T. K. et al. Lasing in dark and bright modes of a finite-sized plasmonic lattice. Nat. Commun. 8, 13687 doi: 10.1038/ncomms13687 (2017).
Publisher's note: Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.
This work was supported by the Academy of Finland through its Centres of Excellence Programme (2012–2017) and under project nos. 263347, 284621 and 272490, and by the European Research Council (ERC-2013-AdG-340748-CODE). This article is based upon work from COST Action MP1403 Nanoscale Quantum Optics, supported by COST (European Cooperation in Science and Technology). Part of the research was performed at the Micronova Nanofabrication Centre, supported by Aalto University. Triton cluster at Aalto University was used for the computations. The authors thank M. Dridi for fruitful discussions.