It has recently been shown that electronic states in bulk gapless HgCdTe offer another realization of pseudo-relativistic three-dimensional particles in condensed matter systems. These single valley relativistic states, massless Kane fermions, cannot be described by any other relativistic particles. Furthermore, the HgCdTe band structure can be continuously tailored by modifying cadmium content or temperature. At critical concentration or temperature, the bandgap collapses as the system undergoes a semimetal-to-semiconductor topological phase transition between the inverted and normal alignments. Here, using far-infrared magneto-spectroscopy we explore the continuous evolution of band structure of bulk HgCdTe as temperature is tuned across the topological phase transition. We demonstrate that the rest mass of Kane fermions changes sign at critical temperature, whereas their velocity remains constant. The velocity universal value of (1.07±0.05) × 106 m s−1 remains valid in a broad range of temperatures and Cd concentrations, indicating a striking universality of the pseudo-relativistic description of the Kane fermions in HgCdTe.
In condensed matter systems, the interaction of electrons with a periodic crystal lattice potential can give rise to low-energy quasiparticles that mimic the relativistic dynamics of Dirac particles in high-energy physics. Perhaps the most spectacular demonstration of this concept was given ten years ago by the isolation of a monolayer of carbon atoms forming a graphene1 sheet. The electrons in graphene behave as two-dimensional (2D) massless fermions with gapless conical bands that obey the Dirac equation. Subsequently, further condensed matter analogues of high-energy relativistic fermions were demonstrated such as edge or surface states of 2D or three-dimesnional (3D) topological insulators2,3,4 and 3D Dirac semimetals with linear energy-momentum dispersion in all three momentum directions5,6,7.
Recently, another massless Dirac-like quasiparticle has been discovered in Hg1−xCdxTe at an inverted-to-normal band structure topological transition existing at the critical cadmium concentration8 xC≈0.17. These 3D massless Kane fermions are not equivalent to any other known relativistic particles. Similar to the pseudospin-1 Dirac–Weyl system9, their energy dispersion relation features cones crossed at the vertex by an additional flat band. The bandgap and the electronic dispersion in Hg1−xCdxTe can be tuned intrinsically by adjusting the chemical composition, or externally, by changing temperature10. The ability to control the properties of quasiparticles with relativistic behaviour in a tabletop condensed-matter experiment holds vast scientific and technological potential. However, the variation of the chemical composition in Hg1−xCdxTe crystals does not allow for fine-tuning of the bandgap in the vicinity of the phase transition due to inherent fluctuations of Cd concentration. Contrarily, a temperature-driven evolution of the band structure (see also Supplementary Note 1) provides a conceptually straightforward, yet very accurate and detailed probe of the relativistic properties of Kane fermions, while tuning the 3D Hg1−xCdxTe across the gapless state at the topological transition between a normal state and an inverted bandgap state. The appearance of a non-zero gap does not exclude relativistic properties of the Kane fermions in Hg1−xCdxTe, which is retained at energies significantly above the gap. The energy dispersion asymptotically tends to a linear behaviour, as it is for relativistic electrons at high energies. The cutoff energies for relativistic behaviour in the Hg1−xCdxTe compounds and in other 3D Dirac–Weyl semimetals are related to the presence of high-lying conduction bands and low-lying valence bands.
Here we conduct a systematic optical investigation of the dispersion of Kane fermions in Hg1−xCdxTe crystal as a function of temperature and magnetic field. From the experimental point of view, the use of temperature as a band structure tuning parameter in magneto-optical studies is challenging and demands ultimate quality samples. This is because the observation of well-defined optical resonances requires high carrier mobility, which degrades with increasing temperature due to the increase of scattering on phonons. Our bulk Hg1−xCdxTe samples were grown by molecular beam epitaxy. The Cd concentration was chosen to enable exploring the bandgap Eg(x, T) space across the semimetal-to-semiconductor phase transition using temperature for fine gap-at-will tuning. The sample A, x=0.175, is a standard narrow-gap semiconductor at any temperature. The sample B, x=0.155, is a semimetal at low temperatures with a negative bandgap corresponding to the inverted band order. As the temperature increases, the inverted bandgap closes as the system undergoes a semimetal-to-semiconductor phase transition at the critical temperature TC≈77 K followed by the opening of a gap in the normal state. Based on a simplified Kane model, we determine the Kane fermions velocity and rest mass. The rest mass experiences a change of sign at the critical temperature of topological phase transition. Our study reveals a universal velocity of 1.07 × 106 m s−1 in HgTe crystals. This further allows to determine the Kane fermion rest mass from all experimental results, past or future, close to the phase transition.
Band structure evolution with temperature
To describe the electronic structure near the centre of the Brillouin zone in Hg1−xCdxTe close to xC, we employ a simplified Kane model11,12 taking into account k·p interaction between the Γ6 and Γ8 bands, while neglecting the influence of the split-off Γ7 band. The corresponding (6 × 6) Hamiltonian formally resembles the one for relativistic 3D Dirac particles (see ‘Simplified Kane model’ in Methods). By neglecting small quadratic in momentum terms, the eigenvalues of this Hamiltonian can be presented in the form:
The first eigenvalue ξ=0 corresponds to the flat heavy-hole band. The two other eigenvalues describe the electron (ξ=+1) and light-hole (ξ=−1) conical bands separated by is a Heaviside step function, which equals to 1 for and to 0 if is negative. This representation of Kane fermions in Hg1−xCdxTe contains only two parameters, the rest -mass and the universal velocity , whereas the material properties are introduced through the Kane’s matrix element P and the Hg1−xCdxTe bandgap Eg.
The evolution of Kane fermions in Hg1−xCdxTe is illustrated in Fig. 1. If the rest mass is positive, the crystal is a typical narrow-gap semiconductor with the s-type Γ6 band lying above the p-type Γ8 bands, as schematically shown on Fig. 1a. On the other hand, if <0, the band order is inverted: the Γ6 band lies below the Γ8 bands. As the two Γ8 bands always touch each other at the Γ point of the Brillouin zone, the band structure is gapless and the crystal is a semimetal. The two distinct phases with different sign of the rest mass are not topologically equivalent, as characterized by a Z2 topological invariant13.
Experimentally, the dispersion of gapless or gapped 2D or 3D Dirac fermions can be conveniently probed through the magnetic field dependence of inter-Landau level transitions14,15,16,17,18,19,20. The application of a quantizing magnetic field B transforms the zero-field continuum of states into a set of unequally spaced Landau levels (LLs) with a distinct behaviour. In pristine gapless graphene, for example, the LLs have a simple structure given by14: , where ħ is the Planck constant and e is the electron charge. The integer LL index n labels electron- (n>0) and hole-like (n<0) states, and unconventional, zero-energy field-independent n=0 LL states. In graphene/boron-nitride heterostructures with zero crystallographic alignment angle, an intrinsic gap Δ opens up separating zeroth dispersionless LLs, En=0=±Δ/2. Other |n|>0 electron(hole)-like LLs shift up(down) by Δ/2 as well: (after ref. 17).
The LL spectrum of massive or massless fermions in Hg1−xCdxTe has a more complex form:
Here, the LL index n runs over positive integers n=1,2, …. for the states in the electron and light-hole bands (ξ=±1). For the zero energy, flat heavy-hole band (ξ=0), n runs over all non-negative integers, except 1: n=0, 2, 3…. The quantum number σ accounts for the Kramer’s degeneracy lifted by the magnetic field B=(0, 0, B). The corresponding splitting can be viewed as the Zeeman (spin) splitting of LLs: Eξ,n,↑(pz)−Eξ,n,↓(pz). The non-parabolicity of the bands implies a strong dependence of this spin-splitting on pz, B and on LL and band indices.
Temperature-induced bandgap opening in narrow gap HgCdTe
Besides the linear behaviour of the absorption coefficient at zero magnetic field measured in both samples (see Supplementary Fig. 1 and Supplementary Note 2), the presence of pseudo-relativistic 3D fermions with is established at 2 K in the sample A by -like dependence of optical transitions and a spin splitting of LLs seen in Fig. 2a. The fitting of the two main lines based on equation (2) shows that they are related to the inter-band transitions between the heavy-hole band remaining at zero energy (ξ=0) and the n=1 spin-up and spin-down LLs with ξ=1 (for details, see Supplementary Figs 2 and 3). The extracted bandgap value at 2 K equals =(5±2) meV. Magneto-optical results obtained at temperatures from 57 to 120 K are shown in Fig. 2b–d. The bandgap, visualized by intersect of the inter-band transitions with the energy axis (shown by white arrows), increases with temperature (see also Supplementary Fig. 4). In addition to inter-band transitions (Δξ=1), intra-band LLs transitions (Δξ=0) are also observed and fitted with equation (2).
Temperature-driven phase transition
Magneto-absorption of the sample B at different temperatures is presented in Fig. 3, in a -scale for the sake of clarity. It is seen that at low temperatures and low magnetic field values, the LLs transitions exhibit some discrepancies compared with a pure behaviour. Indeed, as shown in Fig. 1, the linear energy dispersion in conduction and valence bands arises in gapless samples only. However, even in the case of small negative (or positive) gap, the bands could be considered as parabolic in the vicinity of the Γ point. It corresponds to the small values of parameter , for non-zero rest mass values. At low magnetic fields, the band parabolicity results in a linear behaviour of the LLs transitions as a function of B. Therefore, only a precise behaviour down to the lowest applied magnetic fields implies a system with genuine massless particles. At temperatures below TC, the deviation from a pure behaviour is well reproduced by the theory and gives absolute values of the rest mass approaching to zero when temperature increases. As seen in equation (2), linear extrapolation of optical transitions in the square-root scale intersects the energy axis at , as represented by arrows in Fig. 3a,b. An accurate behaviour for all optical transitions is obtained as an evident proof of gap closing at 77 K (Fig. 3c, see also Supplementary Fig. 5). Above the critical temperature, the difference in energies of inter- and intra-band transitions in low magnetic fields becomes visible, as it is for the sample A, meaning that a positive gap between the Γ6 and Γ8 bands opens. This allows us claiming that at TC=77 K, a temperature-driven topological phase transition with pseudo-relativistic massless Kane fermions occurs. This fact is highlighted by the change of a sign of particle rest mass seen in Fig. 4a.
Universal velocity and rest mass description
The rest mass extracted from magneto-optical data and its dependence on temperature is compared with theoretical values using Supplementary equation (1)21 (in Supplementary Note 1). In the sample A, the rest mass is positive and increases in the whole range of temperatures, as it is shown in Fig. 4a. As discussed above, in the sample B the Kane fermion rest mass experiences a change of sign corresponding to the temperature-induced semimetal-to-semiconductor topological phase transition, which occurs at 77 K. Supplementary equation (1)21 (in Supplementary Note 1) describes very well the experimental rest mass curves for both samples and clearly reproduces the phase transition at 77 K in the sample B. The conic dispersion relation of the massless particles can be therefore realized for the specific range of crystal chemical composition and an according temperature—conditions that provide that the bulk bandgap is fully closed. Interestingly, the Kane fermion velocity is nearly constant over the whole range of temperatures for both samples with Cd contents of 0.155 and 0.175. The extracted value of −1 is in a very good agreement with the theoretical value defined by which equals to for the well-accepted value of EP=2m0P2/ħ2≈18.8 eV (ref. 22). Therefore, this universal value of allows for determination of the particle rest mass for bandgap values in the vicinity of the semimetal-to-semiconductor phase transition induced by temperature, Cd content or other external parameter (for example, pressure). Figure 4c shows the variation of the experimental bandgap energy obtained in this work (full blue and red points) and from previous studies21,23,24 (open symbols), as a function of the rest mass, using and the universal value of .
There are two points limiting the applicability of the simplified Kane model, considering the Γ6 and Γ8 band only, for actual HgCdTe crystals. The first one, already mentioned above, is related to the existence of other bands, considered as remote and not included in the model. The energy gap between the second and the lowest conduction bands in CdTe exceeds 4 eV, while the corresponding gap in HgTe is about 3 eV (ref. 25). Therefore, the cutoff energies for conduction bands in the simplified model should be lower than 3 eV. For the valence band, the cutoff energy is defined by the energy difference Δ≈1 eV between the split-off Γ7 band and the heavy-hole band. The second limitation is attributed to the flat heavy-hole band, characterized by an infinite effective mass in the model. To ignore the parabolic terms in the electron dispersion of the heavy-hole band, one has to consider sufficiently low energies E, such that the relativistic mass of the fermions should be significantly lower than the heavy-hole mass mhh. Assuming mhh≈0.5m0, where m0 is the free electron mass, we arrive at a cutoff energy of ∼3 eV for the flat band approximation, which exceeds Δ.
By using temperature as a fine-tuning external parameter we measured the bandgap energy of HgCdTe bulk crystals with well-chosen chemical composition in the vicinity of the semimetal-to-semiconductor phase transition. We clearly observed and accurately measured increasing of the bandgap with temperature in sample A. We also observed genuine massless Kane fermions at the critical temperature of 77 K in sample B. We used the simplified Kane model to determine the pseudo-relativistic Kane fermion parameters and as a function of temperature and Cd content. We observed a change of sign of accounting for the temperature-driven topological phase transition. Our results also reveal universal velocity in HgCdTe crystals allowing for the determination of the Kane fermion rest mass from all experimental results in the literature obtained in the vicinity of the phase transition.
We performed magneto-optical studies on two -oriented Hg1−xCdxTe layers, with different Cd concentrations, x=0.17 and 0.155. Both films were sufficiently thick (≈3.2 μm) to be considered as 3D materials and thin enough to be transparent in the far-infrared spectral range. The samples were grown by molecular beam epitaxy on semi-insulating GaAs substrates with relaxed CdTe buffers26. We used a special ultra-high vacuum multi-chamber molecular beam epitaxy set, which allows for the growth of very high-quality HgCdTe crystals monitored by in situ reflection high-energy electron diffraction and single wavelength ultra-fast ellipsometry (0.5 nm).
The magneto-optical transmission measurements were carried out by using a Fourier transform spectrometer coupled to a 16 T superconducting coil. The radiation of a Globar lamp is guided to a sample using oversized waveguides (light pipes). The intensity of the transmitted light is measured by a silicon bolometer. Both the magnet and the bolometer require cryogenic temperatures; therefore, most of reported up to today experiments were conducted at 4.2 K or lower temperatures. In this work, to perform a temperature tuning of the band structure, the standard magneto-optical configuration required important modifications. The bolometer was placed in a vacuum chamber separated from the sample chamber. To provide a wide spectral range for experiments, an indium-sealed cold diamond window ensures the optical coupling between the transmitted light and the bolometer. An additional superconducting coil around the bolometer compensates the spread field of the main coil, keeping the bolometer at zero magnetic field. This additional compensating superconducting coil also provides an additional screening of the bolometer. A Lambda plate coil—placed below the main magnet allows to obtain superfluid helium around the bolometer and keep the main coil at 4 K. Therefore, this modified experimental set-up allows to keep the coils in their superconducting state, the bolometer at its optimal temperature and to tune the sample chamber temperature in the 2–150 K range.
The magneto-optical spectra were measured in the Faraday configuration up to 16 T, with a spectral resolution of 0.5 meV. All the spectra were normalized by the sample transmission response at B=0 T.
Simplified Kane model
Relativistic fermions are usually described by the Dirac equation:
where pi (i=x, y, z) are the components of momentum operator, m and c are the rest mass and velocity of light, respectively. The matrices αi and β define the symmetry properties of the particles and have the form
in which σi are the Pauli matrices and I is a 2 × 2 unit matrix. As it is clearly seen from equation (3), if the rest mass of particles equals zero, their dispersion is described by twofold degenerate cone in energy-momentum space.
Current physics has proven the existence of several bulk condensed-matter materials, which are fairly well described by the above equation. At the same time, there are also other systems with relativistic-like charge carriers; nevertheless, they are described by different Hamiltonians. For Kane fermions, the corresponding Hamiltonian formally resembles the one for genuine 3D Dirac particles. However, we see that it has a form of a 6 × 6 matrix, which describes qualitatively a different system:
where , , , and where Uc, Jx, Jy, Jz are 3 × 3 matrices described as follows:
Here we deliberately present low-energy Hamiltonian, which describes the Kane fermions in a form similar to the Dirac equation, defining the rest mass and velocity of the Kane fermions. The matrices Jx, Jy, Jz arising in equation (5) do not satisfy the algebra of angular momentum 1; therefore, the Hamiltonian does not reduce to any well-known case of relativistic particles. However, the Kane fermions, with the Hamiltonian described by equation (5), share a number of properties with other relativistic particles.
The data that support the findings of this study are available from the corresponding authors on request.
How to cite this article: Teppe, F. et al. Temperature-driven massless Kane fermions in HgCdTe crystals. Nat. Commun. 7:12576 doi: 10.1038/ncomms12576 (2016).
We acknowledge M. Dyakonov, W. Zawadzki and A. Raymond for helpful discussions. This work was supported by the CNRS through LIA TeraMIR project, by the Languedoc-Roussillon region and the MIPS department of Montpellier University via the Terahertz platform, by European cooperation through the COST action MP1204, and the Era.Net-Rus Plus project ‘Terasens’. F.T. and S.S.K. acknowledge the support from the Physics Department (INP) of CNRS for post-doc prolongation program. This work was also supported by the Russian Academy of Sciences, the non-profit Dynasty foundation, the Russian Foundation for Basic Research (Grants 14-02-31588, 15-52-16017, 15-02-08274 and 16-02-00672), by Russian Ministry of Education and Science (grant numbers MК-6830.2015.2 and HIII-1214.2014.2) and by NTSIL. J.L., S.M., Z.J. and D.S. acknowledge the support from the U.S. Department of Energy (grant number DE-FG02-07ER46451) for infrared spectroscopy measurements at 4.2 K that were performed at the National High Magnetic Field Laboratory, which is supported by National Science Foundation (NSF) Cooperative Agreement Number DMR-1157490 and the State of Florida.
Supplementary Figures 1-5, Supplementary Notes 1-2 and Supplementary References
About this article
npj Quantum Materials (2017)