The development of chemical systems with switchable molecular spins could lead to the architecture of materials with controllable magnetic or spintronic properties. Here, we present conclusive evidence that the spin of an organometallic molecule coupled to a ferromagnetic substrate can be switched between magnetic off and on states by a chemical stimulus. This is achieved by nitric oxide (NO) functioning as an axial ligand of cobalt(II)tetraphenylporphyrin (CoTPP) ferromagnetically coupled to nickel thin-film (Ni(001)). On NO addition, the coordination sphere of Co2+ is modified and a NO–CoTPP nitrosyl complex is formed, which corresponds to an off state of the Co spin. Thermal dissociation of NO from the nitrosyl complex restores the on state of the Co spin. The NO-induced reversible off–on switching of surface-adsorbed molecular spins observed here is attributed to a spin trans effect.
Planar organometallic complexes with extended π-conjugation, for example, metalloporphyrins and metallophthalocyanines, have an indispensable role in controlling a wide range of functionalities: chemical reactivity (in biochemistry), optical absorbance (in dyes), optoelectronic conductance (in light harvesting chromophores), as well as the ability to function as electron donors or acceptors (in gas sensors and organic semiconductor devices)1. This degree of control is achieved by modifying the coordination of the central metal ion through interaction with its environment, for example, by an external chemical stimulus, as exemplified in nature by the regulation of Fe-porphyrin-to-oxygen affinity within the haemoglobin tetramer2,3. Recently, a similar effect has been implemented at surfaces in which the electronic surface-molecular interaction has been controlled by chemical stimuli4,5,6. Furthermore, metalloporphyrins containing unpaired spins have been shown to exhibit exchange coupling to magnetic substrates7,8,9,10,11,12. In view of spintronics13,14, which has been predominantly emerging for thin-film devices such as spin valves and transistors, it comprises a challenge to control single molecular spins within their specific environment at the spintronic interface. Notably, the molecular spin state for inorganic complexes/polymers in bulk can be controlled by external factors such as temperature, pressure and photon-induced excitation15,16,17,18.
Molecules containing unpaired spins and molecular magnets bearing several coupled magnetic atoms19 have recently received increasing attention. Unpaired electron spins in a molecule offer a wide range of options towards the tuning of their coupling with the environment. The structure and properties of such molecules can be initially architectured through synthesis and can be further modified by chemical reactions. X-ray magnetic circular dichroism (XMCD) spectroscopy20,21 allows for the highly sensitive determination of the magnetization of spin systems assembled at surfaces with elemental and chemical specificity. The XMCD technique has also been used to assess the magnetization of adsorbed metalloporphyrin spin systems with respect to ferromagnetic substrates7,8,9,10,11.
In this article, we demonstrate that the spin of a metalloporphyrin molecule, namely cobalt(II)tetraphenylporphyrin (CoTPP), is magnetically coupled to a ferromagnetic substrate (here nickel (Ni(001))) and can be controlled by nitric oxide (NO) functioning as a chemical stimulus. A reversible off–on switching process of the molecular spin, induced by NO, in the presence of the remanent magnetization of the Ni substrate is shown. Addition of NO supersedes the Co–Ni magnetoelectronic interaction by the formation of a NO–CoTPP nitrosyl complex22,23, which corresponds to the off state of the Co spin in CoTPP. Thermal dissociation of NO from the nitrosyl complex restores the initial Co–Ni magnetoelectronic interaction and leads to the on state of the Co spin in CoTPP. Thereby, this work provides an example of a chemical switch affecting the spin in surface-adsorbed molecules and presents a case for the spin trans effect in analogy to the well-established 'trans effect'22,23,24. Using stimuli to control single atomic25 and molecular spins at interfaces and determining their coupling with the environment is of eminent interest in the field of quantum information26.
Design of the magnetic interface
A cobalt-porphyrin, CoTPP (see Fig. 1a; top panel), has been chosen as a magnetic molecule characterized by one unpaired electron (S=½; magnetic moment M (static)=1.73 μB, M (effective)=1.92 μB)27. On the basis of its architecture and properties, this molecule is expected to be affected by the up or down magnetization of the ferromagnetic Ni substrate8. Atomically clean Ni substrates were prepared by deposition of thin films (~20 monolayers (MLs)) onto clean Cu(001) single crystals in ultrahigh vacuum. About 1 ML of CoTPP molecules was then evaporated onto the freshly prepared non-magnetized Ni(001) substrates kept at room temperature. On such prepared samples the magnetization of the different elemental species, that is, Co and Ni, has been determined by the element-specific XMCD technique20 (see Fig. 1a; bottom panel).
X-ray absorption spectra of circularly polarized synchrotron light with opposite helicities (μ+ and μ−) are presented in Figure 1b. They clearly show a difference in absorption, that is, magnetic circular dichroism, at L2 and L3 absorption edges of both Co (top) and Ni (bottom). In the dichroic spectra, both the magnetic molecule (Co; Fig. 1c; top left panel initial) and the substrate (Ni; Fig. 1c; bottom left panel initial) show a magnetization, as characterized by the two peaks at photon energies corresponding to the L2 and L3 edges. A ferromagnetic coupling between CoTPP molecules and the Ni substrate is clearly identified by the same sign of the L2 and L3 dichroic signals in the respective spectra. Such ferromagnetic coupling has also been observed for similar molecules with different central metal atoms on various substrates7,8,9. Following numerical calculations based on density functional theory, this coupling occurs by superexchange through nitrogen atoms of the porphyrin ring for these observations8,28,29.
To investigate the effect of a reaction with a chemical stimulus on the magnetization of CoTPP adsorbed on the Ni substrate, the CoTPP/Ni system was exposed to NO gas at room temperature. After the NO exposure, the initially well-detectable Co magnetization (Fig. 1c; initial) cannot be detected by XMCD anymore (Fig. 1c; '+NO). This behaviour is observed irrespective of the substrate magnetization and provides clear evidence that the magnetization of Co in CoTPP is switched off—an effect that goes far beyond earlier observations7,8,21 and allows for the switching of individual molecular spins. As expected for a thin film, the Ni substrate magnetization was only marginally affected by the NO adsorption. We assign the off state of the molecular spin to the pairing of the initially unpaired Co spin, with the unpaired spin supplied by NO in the formation of a NO–CoTPP complex22,23,30 as discussed further below.
To probe the reversibility of the process the sample temperature was temporarily increased to ~615 K, leading to the removal of NO from the NO–CoTPP complex. This implies the reactivation of the Co spin (S=½) and the regeneration of the ferromagnetic coupling between CoTPP and Ni as clearly reflected in the XMCD spectra (Fig. 1c; '−NO), that is, the Co spin system was switched on again. Consequently, the ferromagnetic coupling of Co magnetic moment to the Ni substrate magnetization is reestablished, as confirmed by the respective dichroic signals (Fig. 1c; '−NO).
X-ray photoelectron spectroscopy
To assess the influence of NO ligation on the chemical species involved and on the electronic interaction between CoTPP and Ni, we have employed X-ray photoelectron spectroscopy (XPS) and measured Co2p XP spectra at various stages of the experiment (Fig. 2a). For a monolayer of CoTPP on Ni, the Co2p3/2 XPS signal exhibits a multiplet spectral feature, on which the main peak was observed at ~778.2 eV resembling an outermost ()1-open-shell structure (compare CoTPP/Ag(111) system in Flechtner et al.6). Reaction with NO causes two major changes in the Co2p3/2 XPS signal. First, the multiplet spectral feature is replaced by a single peak, which is the expected behaviour for Co, assuming an outermost ()2-closed-shell electronic structure. Second, the main peak position shifts from ~778.2 to ~780.2 eV—the latter value also being observed for the main Co2p3/2 peak of CoTPP in multilayers (see Flechtner et al.6). This behaviour suggests the suppression of the Co–Ni interaction by the stronger NO–Co interaction and correlates the observed chemical shift in XPS to a downshift of the unoccupied spin level after bonding with NO. On thermal treatment of the NO–CoTPP–Ni system the multiplet feature of the Co2p3/2 XPS signal, characterized by the main peak at ~778.2 eV, is observed again, which proves the NO dissociation from the nitrosyl complex—consistent with an earlier report on the electronic coupling of the NO–CoTPP–Ag system6. Notably, in our system, both the electronic coupling and the ad-molecular magnetization respond simultaneously to NO addition and removal.
Scanning tunnelling microscopy
To further elucidate the nature of the chemical switching effect, it is necessary to study the adsorption geometry of the CoTPP molecules on Ni(001). Our scanning tunnelling microscopy (STM) data (Fig. 2b–d) show that the Ni(001) surface exhibits extended terraces that are virtually free of point defects and that CoTPP molecules adsorb spatially in a random distribution on the surface. This is due to a considerable surface-molecular interaction limiting the diffusion length during the deposition process, which then hinders the frequently observed self-assembly on metallic substrates31,32. This observation is in line with a recent report on the Mn-porphyrin/Co(001) system showing limited or no self-assembly11. High-resolution STM images of the CoTPP molecules on Ni(001) (Fig. 2d) reveal a planar orientation on the surface. A quasi-planar orientation has also been found by means of near-edge X-ray absorption fine structure spectroscopy for similar magnetic molecule–substrate interfaces, for example, Mn-porphyrin/Co(001), Fe-porphyrin/Co(001) and Fe-porphyrin/Ni(001)7,8. Density functional theory calculations have shown that magnetic exchange coupling requires the metalloporphyrin molecule: (i) in a planar orientation with the metal ion–4N moiety (see 'Co–4N' in Fig. 3a) on the surface and (ii) in a certain distance from the magnetic substrate8,28,29.
In our STM data, we observe some bright spots (Fig. 2c) that correspond to CoTPP molecules adsorbed on top of the first (incomplete) molecular layer. Molecules in the second layer do not have contact with the Ni substrate and reside comparably far above the surface. Thus, not every CoTPP molecule on our samples undergoes ferromagnetic exchange coupling with the Ni(001) substrate. However, XPS data (Fig. 2a) support that the vast majority of CoTPP molecules electronically interact with the Ni(001) substrate. Furthermore, in the STM overview of clean Ni(001) (cf. Fig. 2b), the small black square drawn within the dotted circle represents the corresponding size of one CoTPP molecule. From the molecular dimensions and the step density observed in the STM data, we estimate an upper limit of ~5 to 10% of the molecules (at a coverage of ~1ML CoTPP), which can reside at low-symmetry sites, for example, step edges. As a result, most of the CoTPP molecules are adsorbed at high-symmetry sites and in planar orientation (Fig. 2c and 2d) and are thereby expected to contribute to the magnetic interaction and to respond well to the spin switching events by NO adsorption/desorption, as observed in the XMCD data (see Fig. 1c).
On the basis of the XPS identification of the Co species and the STM observation of a predominantly planar orientation of the molecules, the NO-induced reversible switching between CoTPP and Ni can be attributed to the trans effect6,22,23,24. In analogy to the elegant postulate reported in Flechtner et al.6 describing the role of the trans effect in interfacial coordination chemistry, the NO ligand coordinating in trans position controls the coupling to a second ligand (Ni substrate) acting on the same metalloporphyrin (CoTPP). Bonding of NO with the Co ion presumably changes the 'Co–4N' planar geometry (see Fig. 3a) such that the Co ion is pulled out of the plane towards the NO, whereby the overlap with Ni orbitals is reduced—which assists the switching event. The 'trans effect is frequently used to control chemical reactivity or electron affinity through ligands22,23,24 and, as demonstrated here, simultaneously controls the chemical/electronic coupling and the spin state.
The magnetic properties, namely the Co magnetization during the switching process that depends on the Ni substrate magnetization direction, can be uniquely probed for this system by the element-specific XMCD technique. The quenching of the Co XMCD signal observed in our experiments is identified as a consequence of the pairing of the originally unpaired spin in the orbital on formation of the NO–CoTPP complex. This chemically stimulated process directly affects the Co spin system and the coupling to the substrate, as can be seen from the discussion of the molecular levels (Fig. 3b) involved: the highest occupied molecular orbital of the NO–CoTPP complex33,34,35 originates from the interaction of singly occupied molecular orbitals of CoTPP ()34,35 and NO (π*)23, as schematically shown in Figure 3a,b.
On heating the sample, NO dissociates from the NO–CoTPP complex, leaving the CoTPP molecule with an unpaired spin and reestablishing the magnetoelectronic association with the Ni substrate. The dichroic signal at ~778.5 eV (Fig. 1c; top right panel) and the Co XPS data (Fig. 2a; blue line) clearly indicate that the CoTPP molecules remain intact after the temperature-induced dissociation of NO. A scheme for the NO-induced reversible switching of the magnetic response of CoTPP coupled to a ferromagnetic Ni substrate is presented in Figure 3c. Two different mechanisms can be considered: (i) NO reacts with CoTPP from the top and forms the NO–CoTPP complex or (ii) the Ni substrate reacts with NO and consequently affects the CoTPP–Ni interaction. To provide decisive evidence towards mechanism (i) or (ii), we have performed two additional experiments. First, a bare Ni(001) surface was exposed to ~6,000 L (Langmuir) of NO and was subsequently annealed at ~615 K. The O1s (a) and N1s (b) XPS signals (see Fig. 4) remain essentially unchanged on annealing. The shoulder observed at higher binding energies before annealing is assigned to physisorbed species desorbing from the surface on annealing. On the basis of the earlier reported observation of NO dissociation on Ni(001), even at room temperature36, the two peaks are attributed to Ni–N and Ni–O species, which remain chemisorbed at the annealing temperatures used in our experiment.
In the second experiment, CoTPP (~1 ML) was deposited onto a Ni(001) surface preexposed to NO (~6,000 L). Subsequently, this system was annealed at ~615 K. Interestingly, the Co2p XPS data exhibited almost identical peak positions (Co2p3/2 ~780.2 eV) before and after this annealing procedure (see Fig. 5), which indicates that CoTPP remains electronically decoupled from the Ni substrate, that is, the preexposure of NO modifies the Ni(001) substrate such that no NO-induced reversibility can be observed in this temperature window. These results confirm that our experiments on the NO-induced switching are not significantly determined/affected by side reactions of NO on the bare fraction of the Ni substrate (<20%; see Fig. 2b), as the electronic and ferromagnetic exchange coupling between CoTPP and Ni is restored after annealing at ~615 K (see Figs 1c and 2a). Thus, the reported experiments are all in agreement with mechanism (i) and are consistent with the involvement of the trans effect. Note that the observation of ligand-induced spin switching of porphyrins is not restricted to ferromagnetic substrates, and we expect that this work can be extended to antiferromagnetic or diamagnetic (for example, Cu(100)) substrates as well, using sufficiently high external magnetic fields at low temperature, for example, 6 T and 8 K21. The trans effect, as used to control the site-specific affinity of porphyrins or phthalocyanines to chemical reactants, is used in this study to control the spin localized at a central metal ion, and thereby provides the case for a spin trans effect.
Because of the large body of knowledge about porphyrins and phthalocyanines1, and their variability established in coordination chemistry, the spin trans effect is expected to proceed beyond the case presented here. Spin switching systems on the basis of the presented architecture are expected to be demonstrated using other chemical stimuli (for example, CO), using modified molecular spin systems (for example, metallophthalocyanines), and also for the case of antiferromagnetic exchange coupling10,11. Considering the involvement of the chromophoric group in these molecules, the use of other stimuli such as light is foreseeable. By exploiting a pump-and-probe approach it might become possible to study spin dynamics in surface-supported chemical reactions using the XMCD technique20.
The reversible off–on switching of the electron spin in a surface-supported paramagnetic molecule presented here suggests further studies on organic spintronic interfaces in conjunction with transport measurements. In view of the rapidly advancing capabilities to induce events on the level of single atoms and molecules by scanning probe microscopy, it is anticipated that surface-supported magnetic molecules can be individually switched. The behaviour of such model systems, not only as isolated spin systems and in dependence of their coupling to the substrate/environment but also as elements of quantum-coupled systems, may provide a new basis for experimental insight into quantum behaviour at further increased complexity.
Sample preparation and characterization
All experiments were performed in ultrahigh vacuum. Cu(001) single crystals (MaTecK GmbH) were cleaned by repeated Ar+ sputtering/annealing cycles and the impurity level was monitored by recording C1s, O1s, N1s and Ni2p XPS signals. Ni (MaTecK GmbH) thin films (~20 MLs, ~3.5 nm) were deposited by means of electron-beam evaporation in a two-step procedure onto clean Cu(001) single crystals11. In the first step, ~10 MLs of Ni were evaporated on Cu(001) kept at room temperature, which provided a sufficient barrier to prevent the Cu atoms from diffusion across the Ni layers. After ~30 min of annealing at ~530 K, another ~10 MLs of Ni were deposited while keeping the sample at ~460 K to obtain atomically flat terraces. During these evaporation steps, the deposition rate was monitored by a quartz crystal microbalance. After deposition of ~20 MLs of Ni on Cu(001), the thin-film substrate was investigated by XPS and low-energy electron diffraction studies to assure that no contamination of the film occurred and that the growing film shows the fcc(001) structure11. CoTPP (Sigma-Aldrich) molecules were evaporated (~1 ML) onto a freshly prepared non-magnetized Ni(001) substrate kept at room temperature. The deposition rate was monitored by a quartz crystal microbalance and the molecular coverage on the surface was calibrated by combined XPS and STM measurements. STM images were taken in constant-current mode at room temperature with a Pt/Ir tip and the bias voltages were referred to the grounded sample. The prepared samples were transported to the surfaces/interfaces microscopy (SIM) beamline of the Swiss Light Source (SLS) using a vacuum suitcase (base pressure in the order of ~7.5×10−11 Torr), that is, without breaking the vacuum.
An external magnetic field of ~125 mT was applied perpendicular to the surface plane of the CoTPP/Ni(001) sample before the XMCD measurements to assure single-domain magnetization of the Ni film along the easy axis (out-of-plane)8. The L-edges absorption spectra for both Co and Ni were recorded at normal incidence in total electron yield mode without externally applied magnetic field, that is, in the remanent magnetization of the Ni substrate. The SLS-SIM beamline provides high brilliance X-ray light in the energy range of 130–2,000 eV from two elliptical twin undulators, which permit switching of the photon helicity optically within a few seconds37. All spectra were recorded at room temperature and normalized to the incident photon flux. The Ni magnetization was reproducibly reversed by inverting the externally applied magnetic field. XMCD data taken at the SLS-SIM beamline were complemented by XPS/STM measurements using the same sample preparation conditions.
NO dosing and heating
The CoTPP/Ni(001) system was exposed to ~6,000 L of NO (exposure time ~17 min) in the XMCD chamber at room temperature. The sample was subsequently heated to ~615 K to remove NO from the NO–CoTPP complex. Notably, our experiments suggest that cooling the sample to ~100 K reduces the required NO exposure to a considerable extent, whereas the off–on electronic switching events can still be consistently observed by the XPS measurements.
How to cite this article: Wäckerlin, C. et al. Controlling spins in adsorbed molecules by a chemical switch. Nat. Commun. 1:61 doi: 10.1038/ncomms1057 (2010).
We gratefully acknowledge financial supports from the Swiss National Science Foundation; National Center of Competence in Research, and Research Equipment Funding, Switzerland; and from the European Union through the Marie Curie Research Training Network PRAIRIES (MRTN-CT-2006-035810). N.B. thanks the Holcim Foundation for the Advancement of Scientific Research, Switzerland for a research scholarship. A part of this study has been conducted at the SLS-SIM beamline, Paul Scherrer Institut, Villigen, Switzerland. The authors thank Rolf Schelldorfer and Andrea Steger for technical support; Arantxa Fraile-Rodriguez for providing help during beamtimes at SLS; Harald Rossmann for assistance on XPS experiments; and Izabela Czekaj for the molecular scheme of CoTPP.
About this article
Nature Communications (2017)