The nature of inter-group relations among prehistoric hunter-gatherers remains disputed, with arguments in favour and against the existence of warfare before the development of sedentary societies1,2. Here we report on a case of inter-group violence towards a group of hunter-gatherers from Nataruk, west of Lake Turkana, which during the late Pleistocene/early Holocene period extended about 30 km beyond its present-day shore3. Ten of the twelve articulated skeletons found at Nataruk show evidence of having died violently at the edge of a lagoon, into which some of the bodies fell. The remains from Nataruk are unique, preserved by the particular conditions of the lagoon with no evidence of deliberate burial. They offer a rare glimpse into the life and death of past foraging people, and evidence that warfare was part of the repertoire of inter-group relations among prehistoric hunter-gatherers.
This is a preview of subscription content
Subscribe to Journal
Get full journal access for 1 year
only $3.90 per issue
All prices are NET prices.
VAT will be added later in the checkout.
Tax calculation will be finalised during checkout.
Get time limited or full article access on ReadCube.
All prices are NET prices.
Wrangham, R. W. & Glowacki, L. Intergroup aggression in chimpanzees and war in nomadic hunter-gatherers: evaluating the chimpanzee model. Hum. Nat. 23, 5–29 (2012)
Fry, D. P. & Söderberg, P. Lethal aggression in mobile forager bands and implications for the origins of war. Science 341, 270–273 (2013)
Garcin, Y. et al. Late Pleistocene–Holocene rise and collapse of Lake Suguta, northern Kenya Rift. Quat. Sci. Rev. 28, 911–925 (2009)
Wilson, M. L. & Wrangham, R. W. Intergroup relations in chimpanzees. Annu. Rev. Anthropol. 32, 363–392 (2003)
Wilson, M. L. et al. Lethal aggression in Pan is better explained by adaptive strategies than human impacts. Nature 513, 414–417 (2014)
Bowles, S. Did warfare among ancestral hunter-gatherers affect the evolution of human social behaviors? Science 324, 1293–1298 (2009)
Kelly, R. C. The evolution of lethal intergroup violence. Proc. Natl Acad. Sci. USA 102, 15294–15298 (2005)
Thorpe, I. J. N. inWarfare, Violence and Slavery in Prehistory (eds Parker Pearson, M. & Thorpe, I. J. N. ) 1–18 (British Archaeological Reports, 2005)
Burch, E. S. Alliance and Conflict: The World System of the Inupiaq Eskimos (Univ. Nebraska Press, 2005)
Ember, C. R. Myths about hunter-gatherers. Ethnology 17, 439–448 (1978)
Fry, D. P. Beyond War: The Human Potential for Peace. (Westview, 2007)
Goldschmidt, W. in The Social Dynamics of Peace and Conflict (eds Rubenstein, R. A. & Foster, M. L. ) 47–65 (Westview, 1988)
Hobhouse, L. T., Wheeler, G. C. & Ginsberg, M. The Material Culture and Social Institutions of the Simpler People (Chapman & Hall, 1915)
Leavitt, G. C. The frequency of warfare: an evolutionary perspective. Sociol. Inq. 47, 49–58 (1977)
Otterbein, K. F. How War Began (Texas A&M Univ. Press, 2004)
Radcliffe-Brown, A. R. The Andaman Islanders: A Study in Social Anthropology (Cambridge Univ. Press, 1922)
Schapera, I. The Khoisan peoples of South Africa (Routledge and Kegan Paul, 1930)
Wright, Q. A Study of War (Univ. Chicago Press, 1942)
Keely, L. H. War before Civilization (Oxford Univ. Press, 1996)
Wendorf, F. in The Prehistory of Nubia (ed. Wendorf, F. ) Vol. 2, 954–1040 (Southern Methodist Univ. Press, 1968)
Robbins, L. H. The Lothagam Site (Michigan State Univ., 1974)
Robbins, L. H. Lake Turkana archaeology: the Holocene. Ethnohistory 53, 71–93 (2006)
Beyin, A. Recent archaeological survey and excavation around the Greater Kalakol area, West Side of Lake Turkana: Preliminary Findings. Nyame Akuma 75, 40–50 (2011)
Robbins, L. H. Bone artefacts from the Lake Rudolf Basin, East Africa. Curr. Anthropol. 16, 632–633 (1975)
Barthelme, J. W. Fisher-Hunters and Neolithic Pastoralists in East Turkana, Kenya (British Archaeological Reports, 1985)
Forman, S. L., Wright, D. K. & Bloszies, C. Variations in water level for Lake Turkana in the past 8500 years near Mt. Porr, Kenya and the transition from the African Humid Period to Holocene aridity. Quat. Sci. Rev. 97, 84–101 (2014)
Angel, J. L., Phenice, T. W., Robbins, L. H. & Lynch, M. M. Late Stone Age Fishermen of Lothagam, Kenya (Michigan State Univ., 1980)
Sauer, N. J. in Forensic Osteology (ed. Reichs, K. J. ) 321–332 (Charles C. Thomas, 1998)
Smith, M. O. Beyond palisades: the nature and frequency of late prehistoric deliberate violent trauma in the Chickamauga reservoir of east Tennessee. Am. J. Phys. Anthropol. 121, 303–318 (2003)
Broadbent, B. H. & Golden, W. H. Bolton Standards of Dentofacial Developmental Growth (CV Mosby, 1975)
Smith, B. H. in Advances in Dental Anthropology (eds Kelley, M. A. & Larsen, C. S. ) 143–168 (Wiley-Liss, 1991)
Scheuer, L. & Black, S. M. Developmental Juvenile Osteology (Academic, 2000)
Bass, W. M. Human Osteology: A Laboratory and Field Manual (Missouri Archaeological Society, 1995)
Buikstra, J. E. & Ubelaker, D. H. Standards for Data Collection from Human Skeletal Remains (Arkansas Archaeological Survey, 1994)
Brooks, S. & Suchey, J. M. Skeletal age determination based on the os pubis: a comparison of the Acsádi-Nemeskéri and Suchey-Brooks methods. Hum. Evol. 5, 227–238 (1990)
Brothwell, D. R. Digging Up Bones (Oxford Univ. Press, 1981)
I˙s¸can, M. Y., Loth, S. R. & Wright, R. K. Metamorphosis at the sternal rib end: a new method to estimate age at death in white males. Am. J. Phys. Anthropol. 65, 147–156 (1984)
I˙s¸can, M. Y., Loth, S. R. & Wright, R. K. Age estimation from the rib by phase analysis: white females. J. Forensic Sci. 30, 853–863 (1985)
Brink, O., Vesterby, A. & Jensen, J. Pattern of injuries due to interpersonal violence. Injury 29, 705–709 (1998)
Jurmain, R. et al. Paleoepidemiological patterns of interpersonal aggression in a prehistoric central California population from CA-ALA-329. Am. J. Phys. Anthropol. 139, 462–473 (2009)
Kjaerulff, H. et al.The Copenhagen Study Group. Injuries due to deliberate violence in areas of Denmark. III. Lesions. Forensic Sci. 41, 169–180 (1989)
Martin, D. L. & Frayer, T. Troubled Times: Osteological and Anthropological Evidence of Violence (Gordon and Breach, 1997)
Shepherd, J. P., Shapland, M., Pearce, N. X. & Scully, C. Pattern, severity and aetiology of injuries in victims of assault. J. R. Soc. Med. 83, 75–78 (1990)
Quatrehomme, G. & I˙s¸can, M. Y. Postmortem skeletal lesions. Forensic Sci. Int. 89, 155–165 (1997)
Angel, J. L. Patterns of fracture from Neolithic to modern times. Anthropol. Kozlemenyek 18, 9–18 (1974)
Brickley, M. & Smith, M. Culturally determined patterns of violence: biological anthropological investigations at a historic urban cemetery. Am. Anthropol. 108, 163–177 (2006)
Fibiger, L., Ahlström, T., Bennike, P. & Schulting, R. J. Patterns of violence-related skull trauma in Neolithic southern Scandinavia. Am. J. Phys. Anthropol. 150, 190–202 (2013)
Levin, L. et al. Incidence and severity of maxillofacial injuries during the Second Lebanon War among Israeli soldiers and civilians. J. Oral Maxillofac. Surg. 66, 1630–1633 (2008)
Steadman, D. W. Warfare related trauma at Orendorf, a middle Mississippian site in west-central Illinois. Am. J. Phys. Anthropol. 136, 51–64 (2008)
Owsley, D. W., Berryman, H. E. & Bass, W. M. Demographic and osteological evidence for warfare at the Larson site, South Dakota. Plains Anthropological Memoirs 13, 119–131 (1977)
Walker, P. L. in Troubled Times: Violence and Warfare in the Past (eds Martin, D. & Frayer, D. W.) 145–180 (Gordon and Breach, 1997)
Berryman, H. E & Haun, S. J. Applying forensic techniques to interpret cranial fracture patterns in an archaeological specimen. Int. J. Osteoarchaeol. 6, 2–9 (1996)
Berryman, H. E. & Symes, S. A. in Forensic Osteology (ed. Reichs, K. J.) 333–352 (Charles C. Thomas, 1998)
Galloway, A. in Broken Bones: Anthropological Analysis of Blunt Force Trauma (ed. Galloway, A.) 81–112 (Charles C. Thomas, 1999)
Kimmerle, E. H. & Baraybar, J. P. Skeletal Trauma: Identification of Injuries Resulting from Human Rights Abuse and Armed Conflict (Taylor & Francis, 2008)
Knüsel, C. J. in Warfare, Violence and Slavery in Prehistory (eds Parker Pearson, M. & Thorpe, I. J. N. ) 49–65 (British Archaeological Reports, 2005)
Lovell, N. C. Trauma analysis in paleopathology. Am. J. Phys. Anthropol. 104, 139–170 (1997)
Ortner, D. in Skeletal Trauma: Identification of Injuries Resulting from Human Rights Abuse and Armed Conflict (eds Kimmerle, E. H. & Baraybar, J. P. ) 21–86 (CRC, 2008)
Passalacqua, N. V. & Fenton, T. W. in A Companion to Forensic Anthropology (ed. Dirkmat, D. C. ) 400–411 (Blackwell, 2012)
Roberts, C. in Human Paleopathology: Current Synthesis and Future Options (eds Ortner, D. & Aufderheide, A. C. ) 225–240 (Smithsonian Institution Press, 1991)
Rodríguez-Martín, C. in Forensic Anthropology and Medicine (eds Schmitt, A. et al.) 197–221 (Humana, 2006)
Wheatley, B. P. Perimortem or postmortem bone fractures? An experimental study of fracture patterns in deer femora. J. Forensic Sci. 53, 69–72 (2008)
Letourneux, C. & Petillon, J. Hunting lesions caused by osseous projectile points: experimental results and archaeological implications. J. Archaeol. Sci. 35, 2849–2862 (2008)
Fallon, S. J., Fifield, L. K. & Chappell, J. M. The next chapter in radiocarbon dating at the Australian National University: status report on the single stage accelerator mass spectrometry. Nucl. Instrum. Methods Phys. Res. B 268, 898–901 (2010)
Bronk Ramsey, C., Scott, E. M. & van der Plicht, J. Calibration for archaeological and environmental terrestrial samples in the time range 26–50 ka cal BP. Radiocarbon 55, 2021–2027 (2013)
Reimer, P. et al. IntCal13 and Marine13 radiocarbon age calibration curves 0–50,000 years cal BP. Radiocarbon 55, 1869–1887 (2013)
Bøtter-Jensen, L. Luminescence techniques: instrumentation and methods. Radiat. Meas. 27, 749–768 (1997)
Murray, A. S. & Wintle, A. G. Luminescence dating of quartz using an improved single-aliquot regenerative-dose protocol. Radiat. Meas. 32, 57–73 (2000)
Wintle, A. G. & Murray, A. S. A review of quartz optically stimulated luminescence characteristics and their relevance in single-aliquot regeneration dating protocols. Radiat. Meas. 41, 369–391 (2006)
Banerjee, D., Murray, A. S., Bøtter-Jensen, L. & Lang, A. Equivalent dose estimation using a single aliquot of polymineral fine grains. Radiat. Meas. 33, 73–94 (2001)
Wallinga, J., Murray, A. S. & Bøtter-Jensen, L. Measurement of the dose in quartz in the presence of feldspar contamination. Radiat. Prot. Dosim. 101, 367–370 (2002)
Hansen, V., Murray, A. S., Buylaert, J. P., Yeo, E. Y. & Thomsen, K. J. A new irradiated quartz for beta source calibration. Radiat. Measurem. 81, 123–127 (2015)
Duller, G. A. T. The Analyst software package for luminescence data: overview and recent improvements. Anc. TL 33, 35–42 (2015)
Galbraith, R. F., Roberts, R. G., Laslett, G. M., Yoshida, H. & Olley, J. M. Optical dating of single and multiple grains of quartz from Jinmium Rock Shelter, northern Australia: part I, experimental design and statistical methods. Archaeometry 41, 339–364 (1999)
Sutton, S. R. & Zimmermann, D. W. Thermoluminescence dating: radioactivity in quartz. Archaeometry 20, 67–69 (1978)
Mejdahl, V. Thermoluminescence dating: beta-dose attenuation in quartz grains. Archaeometry 21, 61–72 (1979)
Grün, R. & Fenton, C. Internal dose rates of quartz grains separated from fault gouge. Anc. TL 29, 26–28 (1990)
De Corte, F., Vandenberghe, D., Buylaert, J. P., Van den Haute, P. & Kucera, J. Relative and k0-standardized INAA to assess the internal (Th, U) radiation dose rate in the ‘quartz coarse-grain protocol’ for OSL dating of sediments: Unexpected observations. Nucl. Instrum. Methods Phys. Res. A 564, 743–751 (2006)
Vandenberghe, D., De Corte, F., Buylaert, J. P., Kucera, J. & Van den Haute, P. On the internal radioactivity in quartz. Radiat. Meas. 43, 771–775 (2008)
Rees-Jones, J. & Tite, M. S. Optical dating results for British archaeological sediments. Archaeometry 39, 177–187 (1997)
Guerin, G., Mercier, N. & Adamiec, G. Dose-rate conversion factors: update. Anc. TL 29, 5–8 (2011)
Zimmerman, D. W. Thermoluminescent dating using fine grains from pottery. Archaeometry 13, 29–52 (1971)
Prescott, J. R. & Hutton, J. T. Cosmic ray contributions to dose rates for luminescence and ESR dating: large depths and long-term time variations. Radiat. Meas. 23, 497–500 (1994)
Grün, R., Eggins, S., Kinsley, L., Mosely, H. & Sambridge, M. Laser ablation U-series analysis of fossil bones and teeth. Palaeogeogr. Palaeoclimatol. Palaeoecol. 416, 150–167 (2014)
Sambridge, M., Grün, R. & Eggins, S. U-series dating of bone in an open system: the diffusion-adsorption-decay model. Quat. Geochronol. 9, 42–53 (2012)
Dietze, M. et al. The abanico plot: visualizing chronometric data with individual standard errors. Quat. Geochronol. (in the press)
Kreutzer, S. et al. Introducing an R package for luminescence dating analysis. Anc. TL 30, 1–8 (2012)
R Development Core Team R. A Language and Environment for Statistical Computing. http://CRAN.R-project.org
We thank the Office of the President of Kenya, the Turkana Province government, and the National Museums of Kenya for permission to conduct research (NCST/5/002/R/419), the Turkana people of Locher Akwan, Lokwar Ankhaleso, Lotukumo, Eporon, and Natome for permission to work in their area and assistance, the Turkana Basin Institute for logistical and laboratory support, the British Institute in Eastern Africa, R. Leakey, M. Leakey, and L. Martin for support and advice, the staff at the TBI Turkwell facility, especially K. Onesmus Ngela, and the 2012 IN-AFRICA field team (E. Murungi, J. Oltimbao, J. Lokuruka, D. Lomuria, M. Lokinei, J. Ekeno, J. Erupe, J. Lopua, R. Ng’irotin, P. Amuk, P. Atadeit, M. Emusugut, F. Lowan, R. Ng’ichila, S. Eperon, P. Eperon, T. Echulum), especially P. Ebeya who found the site. We thank S. Black and C. Cunningham for advice on the foetal remains, Beta Analytic for advice and assistance, and F. Lahr for assistance with imaging and illustrations. Funding was provided by a European Research Council Advanced Award to M.M.L. (IN-AFRICA, ERC 295907), the Newby Trust, and the McDonald Institute for Archaeological Research, University of Cambridge.
The authors declare no competing financial interests.
The human remains from the site of Nataruk are curated for the National Museums of Kenya (KNM-WT 71251-71277) at the Turkwel Station of the Turkana Basin Institute, Kenya.
Extended data figures and tables
a, Geographical relation of the site of Nataruk to other similarly dated sites in the area and to the reconstructed palaeo-shorelines of Lake Turkana at different extents during the early Holocene transgression (440 m above sea level (a.s.l.), 430 m a.s.l., 420 m a.s.l.), on the basis of SRTM 90 m DEM (version 4.1) (source: CGIAR-CSI, http://srtm.csi.cgiar.org); background image: hillshade based on SRTM 90 m DEM (version 4.1) (source: CGIAR-CSI, http://srtm.csi.cgiar.org). b, Distribution of finds (human, animal and archaeological remains) at Nataruk; background image: ArcGIS Online Basemap - World Imagery (version 2 October, 2014) (source: Esri, DigitalGlobe, GeoEye, i-cubed, USDA, USGS, AEX, Getmapping, Aerogrid, IGN, IGP, swisstopo, and the GIS User Community).
a, b, View of the Nataruk site with exposed cranium of KNM-WT 71264 as was first found. c, KNM-WT 71264 after excavation. d, Geomorphological setting of the site of Nataruk, showing pattern of drainage and the small geological fault to the east; background image: ArcGIS Online Basemap - World Imagery (version 2 October, 2014) (source: Esri, DigitalGlobe, GeoEye, i-cubed, USDA, USGS, AEX, Getmapping, Aerogrid, IGN, IGP, swisstopo, and the GIS User Community). e, Elevation profile of the site of Nataruk showing the position of the ridge and northeast mounds. f, View of the lagoon carbonate nodules and shells. g, Example of human remains in the context of the lagoon sediments, illustrated by the left foot of KNM-WT 71255. Photographs by M.M.L.
a, Modelled date (bp) for the sediments above skeletons KNM-WT 71251 and 71260, and the shells associated with skeletons KNM-WT 71251, 71254, 71258, 71264, 71274 showing the age and probability distributions. Sample source and association with human remains to the left of individual plots, with the two younger sediment samples from the surface above skeletons at the top, and the shell samples in direct association with human remains below. b, Distribution of estimated uranium-series ages × uranium (p.p.m.) for samples 3487 and 3513 (both from skeleton KNM-WT 71264) and 3514 (KNM-WT 71265). c, Average apparent uranium-series age (error bars indicate 1σ standard deviation) and 234U/238U ratios of all samples analysed (n = 17) (further information in Extended Data Table 3 and Supplementary Table 8). d, Example of a natural OSL decay curve featuring the integrated signal (in red) and the background counts (in green) obtained from a multigrain quartz aliquot. e, Example of a sensitivity corrected dose–response curve for the natural (in red) and regenerative-dose signals using a double exponential fitting procedure. f, Abanico plot featuring the distribution of multigrain quartz equivalent dose measurements and their associated data precision and error scatter86. The plot combines a radial plot (bivariate plot on the left side) with a histogram and kernel density estimate curve (univariate plots on the right side) using the default function tool developed within the package ‘Luminescence’87 for the statistical programming language ‘R’88. The 2σ dispersion range is shown in grey and the red polygon characterizes the 1σ frequency distribution of the primary data.
a, Skeleton KNM-WT 71251; b, skeleton KNM-WT 71253. Displayed lesions on KNM-WT 71251 include an embedded projectile on the left parietal bone, a perforating lesion on the right parietal bone, and possible depressed fractures on the left and right knees. Displayed lesions on KNM-WT 71253 include radiating fractures on the frontal bone, and perforating lesions on the third (?) and seventh cervical vertebrae. Red boxes indicate enlarged images of particular lesions; red arrows point to the lesions described in Supplementary Information 3.3.1 and 3.3.2; red dotted line in KNM-WT 71251 delineates the depressed region on the anterior aspect of the left proximal tibia. Photographs and drawings by M.M.L.
a, Skeleton KNM-WT 71254; c, skeleton KNM-WT 71256; b, fetal remains found within the body cavity of KNM-WT 71255. Displayed lesions on KNM-WT 71254 include a perforating lesion on the frontal bone, and linear perforations on the mandible and the right trapezoid. Displayed lesions on KNM-WT 71256 include perforating lesions on cervical and thoracic vertebrae, and fractures on the second and third right metacarpals. Metacarpal images show four views of the element to illustrate the extent of the fractures; inset of second metacarpal shows palmar view of lesion, insets of third metacarpal show palmar (a) and dorsal-lateral (b) fractures. Red boxes indicate enlarged images of particular lesions; red arrows point to the lesions described in Supplementary Information 3.3.3 and 3.3.5. Further information on KNM-WT 71255 and fetal remains is given in Supplementary Information 3.3.4. Photographs and drawings by M.M.L.
a, Skeleton KNM-WT 71257; b, skeleton KNM-WT 71259. Displayed lesions on KNM-WT 71257 include depressed fractures on the left parietal and multiple radiating fractures across the skull, with the mandible unaffected. Displayed lesions on KNM-WT 71259 include three fractures to ribs, including on two consecutive ribs, and possible depressed fractures to the right knee. Red boxes indicate enlarged images of particular lesions in KNM-WT 71259, including the unnatural position of the left foot; red arrows point to the lesions described in Supplementary Information 3.3.6 and 3.3.8; red dotted line in KNM-WT 71259 delineates the depressed region on the anterior aspect of the right distal femur. Photographs and drawings by M.M.L.
a, Skeleton KNM-WT 71263; c, skeleton KNM-WT 71264; b, skeleton KNM-WT 71265. Displayed lesions on KNM-WT 71263 include a linear perforating lesion, with associated depressed fracture on the frontal bone, and a perforation on the right temporal bone. Displayed lesions on KNM-WT 71264 include depressed fractures on the frontal and left parietal bones, and multiple radiating fractures across the skull, as well as a healed (?) perforating lesion on the frontal bone. Displayed lesions on KNM-WT 71265 include a depressed fracture on the frontal bone. Red boxes indicate enlarged images of particular lesions; red arrows point to the lesions described in Supplementary Information 3.3.10, 3.3.11 and 3.3.12; red dotted line in KNM-WT 71265 delineates what would have been the natural profile of the bone. Photographs and drawings by M.M.L.
This file contains a Supplementary Discussion comprising: (1) description of the site, (2) description of the human remains, (3) description and discussion of the trauma, (4) description of the fauna, (5) description of the archaeology, and (6) description and discussion of the dated samples from Nataruk (see Contents on page 1 for more details). The file also contains Supplementary Tables 1-10 and additional references. (PDF 2905 kb)
This file, which rotates, contains a 3D image of the cranium KNM-WT 71264. The individual shown sustained multiple major trauma to the anterior and left portions of the cranium, which are depressed and fractured in relation to the surrounding bones, and caused a radiating fracture across the occipital bone and the fracture of the right temporal bone. The 3D image was obtained through a surface optical scanner (HDI Advance, LMI3D); 3D pdf made in Geomagic Studio 12.0 Software. (PDF 15922 kb)
About this article
Cite this article
Lahr, M., Rivera, F., Power, R. et al. Inter-group violence among early Holocene hunter-gatherers of West Turkana, Kenya. Nature 529, 394–398 (2016). https://doi.org/10.1038/nature16477
Skin Conductivity Responses to Images of War and Sports in Men and Women: An Evolutionary Perspective
Adaptive Human Behavior and Physiology (2022)
New insights on interpersonal violence in the Late Pleistocene based on the Nile valley cemetery of Jebel Sahaba
Scientific Reports (2021)
The Male Warrior Hypothesis: Testosterone-related Cooperation and Aggression in the Context of Intergroup Conflict
Scientific Reports (2020)
African Archaeological Review (2020)