Abstract
In principle, as has long been known, there are two ways by which the stigmas or styles of the flowers of self-incompatible species could discriminate between incompatible and compatible pollen, for either the growth of the former would be inhibited (the oppositional hypothesis) or that of the latter stimulated (the complementary hypothesis). In practice, however, the genetics of gametophytic systems all but rules out the second possibility, largely because of the number of alleles involved. Furthermore, nearly all of the more recent evidence concerning the behaviour of pollen on the stigma or style, both of the observational and the biochemical kind, is inconsistent with the complementary hypothesis. In a recent paper, however, Mulcahy and Mulcahy (1983) have argued that the oppositional hypothesis is unable to provide a satisfactory explanation of several more recent observations concerning gametophytic systems and have proposed a new, multigenic model that is based on the complementary hypothesis of discrimination. A review of the evidence regarded by the Mulcahys as inconsistent with the oppositional hypothesis reveals that this is either not relevant to the question of discrimination or has been misunderstood. Furthermore, the Mulcahys' model is inconsistent with the empirical evidence concerning multi-locus systems and is formally consistent with one-locus systems only if it is assumed that the constituent loci of the S-supergene are very tightly or completely linked, an assumption not made by the Mulcahys. Their perception of the evidence, therefore, is incomplete and their model ill-founded. Hence the Mulcahys' claim to have put forward a new model of gametophytic self-incompatibility which is consistent with the empirical evidence cannot be sustained.
Similar content being viewed by others
Article PDF
References
Bateson, W, and Gregory, R P. 1905. On the inheritance of heterostylism in Primula. Proc R Soc Lond B, 76, 581–586.
Brieger, F G, and Mangelsdorf, A J. 1926. Linkage between a flower color factor and self-sterility factors. Proc Nat Acad Sci (Wash), 12, 248–255.
Campbell, J M. 1977. Population genetics of self-incompatibility in Papaver rhoeas L Ph.D. thesis. University of Birmingham.
Campbell, J M, and Lawrence, M J. 1981a. The Population Genetics Of The Self-Incompatibility Polymorphism In Papaver Rhoeas. I. The Number And Distribution Of S-alleles In Families From Three Localities. Heredity, 46, 69–79.
Campbell, J M, and Lawrence, M J. 1981b. The Population Genetics Of The Self-Incompatibility Polymorphism In Papaver Rhoeas. II. The Number And Frequency Of S-alleles In A Natural Population (R106). Heredity, 46, 81–90.
Cornish, M A, Hayward, M D, and Lawrence, M J. 1979. Self-incompatibility in ryegrass. I. Genetic control in diploid Lolium perenne L. Heredity, 43, 95–106.
Cornish, M A, Hayward, M D, and Lawrence, M J. 1960. Self-Incompatibility In Ryegrass. III. The Joint Segregation Of S And Pgi-2 In Lolium Perenne. Heredity, 44, 55–62.
Denward, T. The Function Of The Incompatibility Alleles In Red Clover (Triolium Pratense L.). Hereditas, 49, 189–334.
East, E M, and Mangelsdorf, A J. 1925. A new interpretation of the hereditary behaviour of self-sterile plants. Proc Nat Acad Sci (Wash), 11, 166–171.
Emerson, S. 1938. The genetics of self-incompatibility in Oenothera organensis. Genetics, 23, 190–202.
Emerson, S. 1939. A preliminary survey of the Oenothera organensis population. Genetics, 24, 524–537.
Emerson, S. 1940. Growth of incompatible pollen tubes in Oenothera organensis. Bot Gaz, 101, 890–911.
Emerson, S. 1941. Linkage relationships of two gametophytic characters in Oenothera organensis. Genetics, 26, 469–473.
Esser, K. 1953. Genomverdopplung und Pollenschanchwachtum bei Heterostylen. Z indukt Abstamm-u Vererblehre, 85, 28–50.
Fearon, C H. Hayward, M D, and Lawrence, M J. 1983. Self-incompatibility in ryegrass. V. Genetic control, linkage and seed-set in diploid Lolium multiflorum Lam. Heredity, 50, 34–45.
Fearon, C H, Hayward, M D, and Lawrence, M J. 1984. Self-incompatibility in ryegrass. IX. Cross-compatibility and seed-set in autotetraploid Lolium perenne L. Heredity, 53, 423–434.
Fisher, R A, and Mather, K. 1943. The inheritance of style length in Lythrum salkana. Ann Engenics, 12, 1–23.
Van Gastel, A J G, and De Nettancourt, D. 1975. The generation of new incompatibility alleles. Incompatibility Newsletter, 6, 66–69.
Gerstel, D V. 1950. Self-incompatibility studies in Guayule. II. Inheritance. Genetics, 35, 482–506.
Hayman, D C. 1956. The genetical control of incompatibility in Phalaris coerulescsns Dest. Aust J Biol Sci, 9, 321–331.
Heslop-Harrison, J. 1983. Self-incompatibility: phenomenology and physiology. Proc R Soc Lond B, 218, 371–395.
Hoffman, F, and Lenzel, G. 1981. Self-compatibility in microspore-derived doubled-haploid rye lines and single grain selection for alkylresorcinol content. Theor Appl Genet, 60, 129–133.
Hughes, M B, and Babcock, E B. 1950. Self-incompatibility in Crépis foetida (L). subsp. rhoeadifolia (Bieb) Schinz et Keller. Genetics, 35, 570–588.
Labroche, P H, Poirier-Hamon, S, and Pernes, J. 1983. Inheritance of leaf peroxidase isozymes in Nicotiana alata and linkage with the S-incompatibility locus. Theor Appl Genet, 65, 163–170.
Lalouette, J A. 1967. Growth of pollen tubes exhibited by callose fluorochrome reaction. Grana palynol, 7, 601–603.
Larsen, K. 1975. Correlation between the quadruple heterozygous S-genotype Sa 1–2 Sb 3–4 Sc 5–6 Sd 7–8 and pseudo-compatibility in Beta vulgaris L. Incompatibility Newsletter, 5, 85–88.
Larsen, K. 1977a. Pseudo-compatibility in Beta vulgaris L. A quantitative character, dependent on the degree of 5-gene heterozygosity. Incompatibility Newsletter, 8, 48–51.
Larsen, K. 1977b. Self-Incompatibility In Beta Vulgaris L. I. Four Gametophytic, Complementary 5-Loci In Sugar Beet. Hereditas, 85, 227–248.
Larsen, K. 1978a. Four genes in one linkage group in Beta vulgaris L. Incompatibility Newletter, 9, 78–82.
Larsen, K. 1978b. Quantitative Modification Of The Compatibility Reaction In Beeta Vulgaris L. Incompatibility Newsletter, 9, 83–86.
Larsen, K. 1978c. Oligoallelism In The Multigenic Incompatibility System Of Beta Vulgaris L. Incompatibility Newletter, 10, 23–28.
Lawrence, M J. 1975. The genetics of self-incompatibility in Papaver rhoeas. Proc R Soc Lond B, 188, 275–285.
Lawrence, M J, Afzal, M, and Kenrick, J. 1978. The genetical control of self-incompatibility in Papaver rhoeas. Heredity, 40, 239–252.
Lawrence, M J, and O'Donnell, S. 1981. The population genetics of the self-incompatibility polymorphism in Papaver rhoeas. III. The number and freqeuncy of S-alleles in two further natural populations (R102 and R104). Heredity, 46, 53–61.
Levin, A A, Ritter, K, and Ellstrand, N C. 1979. Protein polymorphism in the narrow endemic Oenothera organensis. Evolution, 33, 534–542.
Lewis, D. 1943. The physiology of incompatibility in plants. II. Linum grandiflorum. Ann Botany NS, 7, 115–122.
Lewis, D. 1948. Structure of the incompatibility gene. I. Spontaneous mutation rate. Heredity, 2, 219–236.
Lewis, D. 1949. Structure of the incompatibility gene. II. Induced mutation rate. Heredity, 3, 339–355.
Lewis, D. 1951. Structure of the incompatibility gene. III. Types of spontaneous and induced mutation. Heredity, 5, 399–414.
Lewis, D. 1954. Comparative incompatibility in angiosperms and fungi. Adv in Genetics, 6, 235–285.
Lewis, D. 1960. Genetic control of specificity and activity of the S antigen in plants. Proc Roy Soc Lond B, 151, 468–477.
Linskens, H F, and Esser, K L. 1957. Uber eine spezifische Anfarbung der Pollenschlauche im Griffel und die Zahl der Kallosepfropfen nach Selbstdung und Fremdung. Naturwis, 44, 1–2.
Lundqvist, A. 1956. Self-incompatibility in rye. I. Genetic control in the diploid. Hereditas, 42, 293–348.
Lundqvist, A. 1958. Self-incompatibility in rye. IV. Factors related to self-seeding. Hereditas, 44, 193–256.
Martin, F W. 1959. Staining and observing pollen tubes in the style by means of fluorescence. Stain Technology, 34, 125–128.
Mulcahy, D L, and Mulcahy, G B. 1983. Gametophytic self-incompatibility reexamined. Science, 220, 1247–1251.
De Nettancourt, D. 1977. Incompatibility in Angiosperms. Springer Verlag, Berlin.
De Nettancourt, D, Ecochard, R, Perquin, M D G, Van De Drift, T, and Westerhof, M. 1971. The generation of new S-alleles at the incompatibility locus of Lycopersicum peruvianum Mill. Theor Appl Genet, 41, 120–129.
De Nettancourt, D, Devreux, M, Bozzini, A, Cresti, M, Pacini, E, and Sarfatti, G. 1973. Ultrastructural aspects of self-incompatibility mechanism in Lycopersicum peruvianum Mill. J Cell Scu, 12, 403–419.
De Nettancourt, D, Devreux, M, Carluccio, F, Laneri, V, Cresti, M, Pacini, E. Sarfatti, G, and Van Gastel, A J G. 1975. Facts and hypotheses on the origin of S mutations and on the function of the S gene in Nicotiana alata and Lycopersicum peruvianum. Proc Roy Soc Lond B, 188, 233–375.
O'Donnell, S. 1983. Population genetics of self incompatibility in Papaver rhoeas. L. Ph.D. thesis, University of Birmingham.
Osterbye, U. 1975. Self-incompatibility in Rannuculus acris L. I. Genetic interpretation and evolutionary aspects. Hereditas, 80, 91–112.
Prell, H. 1921. Das Problem der Unbefruchtbarkeit. Naturw Wschr NF, 20, 440–446.
Sree Ramulu, K. 1982a. Failure of obligate inbreeding to produce new S-alleles in Lycopersicum peruvianum Mill. Incompatibility Newsletter, 14, 103–110.
Sree Ramulu, K. 1982b. Genetic Instability At The S-Locus Of Lycopersicum Peruvianum Plants Regenerated From In Vitro Culture Of Anthers: Generation Of New S-Specificities And S-Allele Reversions. Heredity, 49, 319–330.
Thompson, K F, and Taylor, J P. 1965. Identical S alleles in different botanical varieties of Brassica oleracea. Nature, 208, 306–307.
Wright, S. 1939. The distribution of self-sterility alleles in population. Genetics, 24, 538–552.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Lawrence, M., Marshall, D., Curtis, V. et al. Gametophytic self-incompatibility re-examined: a reply. Heredity 54, 131–138 (1985). https://doi.org/10.1038/hdy.1985.17
Received:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1038/hdy.1985.17
This article is cited by
-
Do homomorphic and heteromorphic self-incompatibility systems have the same sporophytic mechanism?
Plant Systematics and Evolution (1986)
-
“Egg transformation” induced by irradiated pollen in Nicotiana: critical appraisal of Chyi and Sanford's observations
Theoretical and Applied Genetics (1986)
-
Gametophytic self-incompatibility or the more things change…
Heredity (1985)