NATURE BRIEFING

Daily Briefing: Both sides of the scalpel

Stephen Fry and his surgeon recount their experiences of treating Fry’s prostate cancer. Plus, allaying fears about open peer review, and exploring a hidden ocean in the Antarctic.

Search for this author in:

Hello Nature readers, would you like to get this Briefing in your inbox free every day? Sign up here.

Icebreaker and research ship FS Polarstern in the ice of the Weddell Sea, Antarctica

Icebreaker and research ship Polarstern, pictured here in the ice of the Weddell Sea, Antarctica, is set to explore an intriguing ecosystem.Credit: Picture Alliance/Photoshot

Antarctic voyage will explore ocean hidden for 100,000 years

In July 2017, a giant iceberg broke off from the Larsen C ice shelf east of the Antarctic Peninsula, revealing a large swathe of ocean that had lain in darkness beneath the ice for millennia. Now a 45-strong research team has set off aboard a German icebreaker to explore the newly exposed waters, in the hope that the sea bed might hold clues to the evolution and mobility of marine life and its response to climate change.

Nature | 3 min read

Trump’s science adviser wants industry to have a bigger role in funding research

Private funding of science is key to ushering in a “second golden era” of US science, according to newly minted US science adviser Kelvin Droegemeier. Droegemeier made the call during his first public address since taking office last month. He also emphasized the need to reduce unnecessary regulations and administration, but did not address climate change, environmental issues or other scientific topics that Trump has disparaged publicly.

Nature | 2 min read

Open peer review doesn’t put reviewers off

Posting peer reviews alongside published papers doesn’t dissuade potential reviewers, nor does it affect their recommendations about whether to accept the manuscript, according to a rare analysis. Some are concerned that the practice of ‘open peer review’ could compromise the peer-review process, but the analysis of more than 18,000 reviews from about 9,000 submissions seems to allay those fears — a result that surprised the study’s authors.

Nature | 3 min read

Reference: Nature Communications paper

Why hundreds of scientists formed a human chain around the Hungarian Academy of Sciences

Hungarian scientists are outraged by a government move to redirect money meant to fund operations at the nation’s science academy towards financing a government-led call for research proposals. The move effectively leaves scientists at the academy — which runs 15 independent research institutions and has more than 130 research groups in universities — competing against their own running costs. Hundreds of scientists and supporters turned out to protest against the decision, forming a human chain around the academy building as a gesture of protection.

Nature | 4 min read

FEATURES & OPINION

Both sides of the scalpel

In 2017, British actor and author Stephen Fry was diagnosed with prostate cancer after a routine medical examination. He went on to be successfully treated, a process that he and his surgeon recall in this unique jointly authored piece in Nature Reviews Urology.

Nature Reviews Urology | 23 min read

The confounding magnetic readings of Voyager 1

Space scientists thought that when the Voyager 1 spacecraft arrived in interstellar space, there’d be a telltale shift in the magnetic field. But six years after the craft became the first human-made object to enter interstellar space, we’re still waiting to see that shift.

Physics Today | 5 min read

Should a body of water be given rights normally granted to a person?

Residents in Toledo, Ohio, will be asked to vote on an unusual issue later this month: whether Lake Erie, the world’s 11th largest lake, has the legal right “to exist, flourish, and naturally evolve”. The lake system has encountered a number of environmental problems, from poisonous algal blooms and fertilizer-filled run-off to invasive fish species. If the lake wins legal rights, it means people might be able to sue polluters on its behalf.

New York Times | 5 min read

QUOTE OF THE DAY

“I would not trust a very large fraction of the discoveries that are currently being made using machine learning techniques applied to large data sets.”

Genevera Allen at Baylor College of Medicine and Rice University argues that scientists should question the accuracy of scientific discoveries made by artificial intelligence until computational systems can critique themselves. (Financial Times)

It’s a bit quiet in the office today, so lots of us are plugged in and listening to music while we work (one colleague has opted for the Dawson’s Creek soundtrack.) Drop us a line at briefing@nature.com and let us know what you listen to in the lab (aside from the Nature Podcast, of course).

Flora will be back in your inbox later this week. Until then, thanks for reading!

Anna Nagle, Chief Editor, Digital & Engagement

Nature Briefing

Sign up for the daily Nature Briefing email newsletter

Stay up to date with what matters in science and why, handpicked from Nature and other publications worldwide.

Sign Up