Smart polymers can sense and react to environmental conditions, and have been used in myriad technologies for decades1. Writing in Joule, Li et al.2 report that such polymers can be used to make smart windows that strongly modulate the amount of ultraviolet, visible and — most notably — near-infrared light that enters a building. Because these components of sunlight can generate heat, this regulation could reduce the monetary and energy costs associated with heating and cooling buildings.
Estimates show that about half of the energy used in a typical US home is for heating and cooling (see, go.nature.com/2c4ypx), making temperature control the most energy-consuming process in residential properties. It therefore follows that the heating and cooling of homes in the United States contributes more to greenhouse-gas emissions, and hence global warming, than any other process associated with household maintenance. The discovery and use of energy-efficient building materials, including windows, could thus have a profound impact for society.
A common approach to reduce heating and cooling demand in buildings is to open or close window coverings such as blinds and curtains. To begin to make this process less dependent on human intervention and hence more efficient, ‘electrochromic’ windows, which darken in response to the application of small electrical potentials, have been developed. Such windows are used on the Boeing 787 Dreamliner aeroplane, for example. The windows still require someone to decide when to darken them, but a simple feedback mechanism could be used to allow the windows to be darkened in response to room temperature.
Electrochromic windows are effective, but have several drawbacks3–5: they require the application of an electrical potential, are expensive to make, have inconsistent light-blocking efficiency and are unlikely to be durable in the long term. As a result, ‘thermo-chromic’ smart-window technologies that directly respond to the local temperature by changing their ability to allow sunlight into a space are highly desirable. Such technologies exist, but have limitations. For example, films of the thermochromic compound vanadium dioxide show promising sunlight-modulating properties, but are activated (darkened) at impractically high temperatures of up to 90 °C (ref. 6)6. Furthermore, the amount of light they allow through — their transmittance — in the inactivated, transparent state is relatively low, on the order of 50% (refs 6, 7)6,7.
Li and co-workers now report a useful advance in the development of thermochromic smart windows that depend on smart polymers for their function. The authors’ system consists simply of a thin layer of a concentrated solution of polymeric gel particles (known as microgels), trapped between two glass layers (Fig. 1). The resulting windows had an infrared transmittance of up to 81.6% in their inactivated transparent state, but a much lower transmittance of about 6% when activated — which represents an extremely high modulation of solar energy. In addition, the authors’ windows are activated at about 32 °C. This is a much more useful activation temperature than that of many other technologies, although similar activation temperatures have been reported for other systems based on smart polymers8.
The superior modulatory properties were achieved by paying close attention to the conditions used to synthesize the microgels. Li et al. developed conditions that allowed the generation of microgels that have an extremely uniform density of crosslinks between polymer chains, and a structure that allows the particles to swell greatly in water. The authors also fine-tuned the reactions to produce microgels that swell to a diameter of 1.4 micrometres at 25 °C. The resulting particles scatter very little light, and are highly transparent below temperatures of about 32 °C. Crucially, however, the microgels collapse and expel water at higher temperatures, whereupon they scatter light at wavelengths primarily dictated by their collapsed-state diameter and refractive index.
Smart windows need to scatter the near-infrared (NIR) wavelengths that are predominantly responsible for heating up spaces. The collapsed microgels in Li and colleagues’ windows have a diameter of 546 nm and a refractive index of about 1.4 at NIR wavelengths — which means that they scatter NIR wavelengths effectively. They also scatter shorter wavelengths in the ultraviolet and visible regions of the spectrum, which means that the activated windows are opaque to the human eye. Most importantly, when Li and co-workers exposed a chamber fitted with a microgel-based smart window to a solar simulator (a device that produces radiation that approximates sunlight), they observed that the temperature increase in the chamber was significantly reduced compared with the increase obtained when a standard double-pane window was fitted.
Li et al. also showed that the windows could be activated and inactivated at least 1,000 times with no noticeable systematic loss in performance, and are also seemingly un-affected by freezing. As an added benefit, visible light scattered by the windows could, in principle, be used to illuminate a room, reducing the need for interior lighting and thereby saving even more energy. Finally, the cost of generating the microgels should not prohibit the commercialization of the technology. Taken together, these properties suggest that Li and colleagues’ smart windows are suitable for real-world applications.
Nevertheless, there are some drawbacks to this technology. For example, the inability to darken the windows on demand means that they would be transparent at night when temperatures are cool, reducing privacy and, if used in bedrooms, potentially disrupting people’s sleep cycles. These issues can, of course, be addressed by using curtains, but this would be inconvenient at best. Moreover, because the activated windows are opaque, users would be unable to see out of them. The bottom line is that this technology is one option out of many, and will not be the perfect solution for all situations.
In my view, smart windows should allow users to choose whether infrared and/or visible light enters a room. For example, windows could actively and continuously prevent NIR sunlight from entering a space when activated by a user, but still allow visible light to enter, so that the room could be warmed and illuminated. If windows could self-regulate their behaviour in a user-defined manner, then the technology would be perfect. Some emerging smart-window technologies can also generate energy while modulating sunlight9, although much more development is needed to make them commercially viable. Finally, it should be noted that although energy-efficient windows can minimize the energy used by buildings, other energy-efficient building materials need to be developed in parallel. Together, they could have a tremendous impact on the world.
Nature 565, 438-439 (2019)