Geoscience society rescinds award to top seismologist after ethics investigation

The American Geophysical Union says it received a ‘conduct-related complaint’ against Thomas Jordan.

Search for this author in:

Thomas H. Jordan speaking into a microphone at a press conference in 2008.

Thomas Jordan has worked to develop tools for forecasting earthquake hazards.Credit: David McNew/Getty

The American Geophysical Union (AGU) has quietly reversed a decision it made in 2017 to award its highest honour, the William Bowie Medal, to seismologist Thomas Jordan. The action came after an AGU investigation determined that Jordan, the former director of the Southern California Earthquake Center in Los Angeles, had violated the AGU’s ethics policy — which he disputes.

“Last fall AGU received a formal ethics complaint regarding the 2017 named Bowie Medalist’s fitness for AGU’s highest honor,” chief executive Christine McEntee wrote in an e-mail to the AGU Council on 3 May. “This was a conduct-related complaint.” According to the e-mail, obtained by Nature, the AGU Ethics Committee investigated the complaint and recommended that the organization’s board of directors not award the medal to Jordan; the board agreed.

Jordan appealed against the decision, as allowed by the AGU ethics policy, but the board ultimately decided in late April not to give him the award.

“I respect AGU’s prerogative to award its honors to whomever it chooses, but I dispute the ethics allegations on which AGU acted in this particular case,” Jordan said in a statement to Nature.

Asked about the matter, McEntee noted that the AGU updated its ethics policy in September 2017 to broaden its definition of scientific misconduct and set standards for professional behaviour.

“Anything that’s harassment, bullying and discrimination, those kind of behaviours would be considered a violation of our policy,” she said. “This particular complaint was related to those behaviour characteristics that are in our policy.”

Jordan did not respond to specific questions about McEntee’s statements or the nature of the allegations against him.

Award announcement

Jordan, a professor of Earth sciences at the University of Southern California in Los Angeles, is known for his wide-ranging contributions to seismology, from studies of structures within the deep Earth to tools for forecasting earthquake hazards in California. From 2002 until September 2017, he directed the Southern California Earthquake Center in Los Angeles.

The AGU named Jordan as the Bowie Medal winner in a 20 July 2017 press release that also announced the winners of 21 other prizes. All, according to the press release, were to be handed out on 13 December in a ceremony at the AGU Fall Meeting in New Orleans, Louisiana. But Jordan did not receive the medal at the ceremony; a programme book handed out that night noted only that “the William Bowie Medal will not be presented at the 2017 Fall Meeting”.

McEntee said that the AGU had received the complaint against Jordan before the meeting, and decided not to present the medal in New Orleans because the ethics investigation was at an early stage.

The online version of the AGU’s July 2017 press release has been amended. It now lists an asterisk next to Jordan’s name, with an editor’s note that “the 2017 Bowie Medal was not awarded by the AGU Board”. The AGU has also removed Jordan’s name from its online list of Bowie Medal recipients.

According to the AGU, the Bowie Medal is awarded annually to a single recipient for “outstanding contributions for fundamental geophysics and for unselfish cooperation in research”.

Jordan is a member of the US National Academy of Sciences and a former president of the Seismological Society of America. He has received two major awards from the AGU: the James B. Macelwane Medal for early-career scientists in 1983, and the Inge Lehmann Medal for “outstanding contributions to the understanding of the structure, composition, and dynamics of the Earth’s mantle and core” in 2005.

doi: 10.1038/d41586-018-05171-4

Jeff Tollefson contributed reporting.

Nature Briefing

Sign up for the daily Nature Briefing email newsletter

Stay up to date with what matters in science and why, handpicked from Nature and other publications worldwide.

Sign Up