Global warming has reduced the amount of dissolved oxygen in the ocean by 2% since 19601. A major concern is that the rate of loss of dissolved oxygen has already increased by up to 20% in tropical waters, expanding the volume of regions called oxygen minimum zones (OMZs), where levels of dissolved oxygen are already very low2,3. The expansion of tropical OMZs threatens the survival of marine organisms that rely on dissolved oxygen for respiration, and affects the biogeochemical cycling of carbon and nitrogen, potentially amplifying global warming4. Writing in Global Biogeochemical Cycles, Fu et al.5 suggest that, in the long term, tropical OMZs might shrink after their initial expansion, reversing their impact on warming.
Although, overall, tropical oceans have lost dissolved oxygen in the past 50 years, observations indicate strong regional and temporal variations. For example, OMZs have clearly expanded since the 1970s in the equatorial Pacific and Atlantic oceans3,6, but a long-term reconstruction7 of the OMZ close to the Californian and Mexican coasts suggests that it had been shrinking for a century before it started to expand in the 1990s. In the Indian Ocean, the northern part of the OMZ is shrinking, whereas the southern part is expanding8.
Three competing processes control the levels of dissolved oxygen in the ocean. The first is the transfer of atmospheric oxygen to the surface ocean (which, in turn, is tied to oxygen solubility, the capacity of the water to hold on to dissolved oxygen). The second is ocean circulation (ventilation), which carries the oxygen-rich surface waters to the ocean interior. And, finally, there is the biological respiration of dissolved oxygen, the process by which microorganisms consume organic matter produced at the surface as it sinks to the deep ocean. OMZs develop in tropical intermediate waters (those at depths of 200−1,000 metres) because the physical supply of oxygen is low, but the biological demand for it is high.
As the ocean warms, the solubility of oxygen within it declines, and vertical stratification — the formation of distinct layers of water — increases, limiting the exchange of oxygen between surface and intermediate waters. Together, these changes reduce the supply of oxygen to the ocean interior and expand OMZs. Increased stratification also reduces the supply of nutrients to surface waters, limits biomass production9 and reduces the export of organic matter to the deep ocean. This biological effect lowers the demand for oxygen in underlying waters and reduces the volume of OMZs. In addition, local changes in ventilation in OMZs can act to shrink these zones5,10.
Globally, the direct effect of declining solubility explains half of the observed loss of oxygen in the upper 1,000 m of the ocean, and a combination of biological and ventilation effects accounts for the other half1. In tropical OMZs, however, the balance between these processes is more subtle and the relative contributions harder to tease out11. Numerical models of Earth systems can provide a mechanistic understanding of these past changes in oxygen and why they vary in space, and can inform us about changes to expect in the future.
Fu and colleagues used long-term simulations of the Earth system to reproduce the observed historical decline in dissolved-oxygen levels in the tropical ocean, and to project the evolution of OMZs between the twenty-first and twenty-third centuries (Fig. 1). In their model, the volume of OMZs initially expands, then levels off around the year 2150, and finally shrinks until 2300. The authors also introduce a modelling framework that can disentangle the contributions to this pattern that are made by solubility, ventilation and the reduction in biological export and respiration. In their model, the shift from OMZ expansion to contraction occurs when the biological effects become more prominent than the solubility effect, in 2150. Ventilation further tips this balance, as it switches from an initial slowdown that reinforces the expansion effect of solubility before 2150, to a reinvigoration that reinforces the OMZ contraction controlled by biological effects after 2150.
The findings suggest that about half of the OMZ expansion that occurred between 1900 and 2150 could be reversed by the year 2300. Moreover, the core of the OMZ (the region that has the lowest levels of dissolved oxygen) might contract to become smaller than it was in pre-industrial times, and could possibly act as a negative climate feedback that dampens global warming. The formation of a smaller OMZ core would certainly limit the production of nitrous oxide12, a powerful greenhouse gas, and limit the consumption of nitrate nutrients for respiration, which in turn could boost the efficiency of the ocean’s biological carbon sink13.
Fu and co-workers’ study highlights the extreme sensitivity of OMZs to biological and physical changes, and the difficulty of quantifying and anticipating these changes. Different Earth-system models currently project dramatically different changes in OMZ volume (ranging from −2% to +16% by 2100)14. So how much confidence can we have in OMZ projections?
In fact, Earth-system models agree on many aspects of future OMZs. Modelled changes in oxygen solubility are relatively well constrained and are tied to surface warming14,15. The reduction in biological export identified by Fu et al. is robustly produced by other models11,14, and most models also project a strengthening of the ventilation in tropical OMZs16. Uncertainties arise from the differences in the magnitude and timing of these changes. Simulated reductions in biological export by 2100 vary between 1% and 40%15, and changes in ventilation can vary by a factor of two between models16. These differences, even when small, can tip the balance of oxygen levels in OMZs, shifting them from expansion to contraction.
The challenge now is to constrain this subtle balance and the possible shifts in OMZ volume not only in time, as Fu et al. have done, but also between regions. For example, reduced biological export and consumption of oxygen is likely to have driven the OMZ contraction reported along the Californian and Mexican coasts7, whereas weakening ventilation probably underlies the OMZ expansion in the equatorial Pacific. Other factors, such as the supply of nutrients from anthropogenic aerosols, winds or ocean acidification, could also locally offset the effects of changes in solubility and stratification17. OMZ climate feedbacks — the reinforcing or dampening of climate change by OMZs — are tied to global OMZ volume, but establishing local OMZ responses will be crucial if we are to assess the impacts on ecosystems and ecosystem services, such as fisheries.
Nature 557, 314-315 (2018)