The cerebral cortex is essential for integration and processing of information that is required for most behaviors. The exquisitely precise laminar organization of the cerebral cortex arises during embryonic development when neurons migrate successively from ventricular zones to coalesce into specific cortical layers. While radial glia act as guide rails for projection neuron migration, pre-formed vascular networks provide support and guidance cues for GABAergic interneuron migration. This study provides novel conceptual and mechanistic insights into this paradigm of vascular-neuronal interactions, revealing new mechanisms of GABA and its receptor-mediated signaling via embryonic forebrain endothelial cells. With the use of two new endothelial cell specific conditional mouse models of the GABA pathway (Gabrb3ΔTie2-Cre and VgatΔTie2-Cre), we show that partial or complete loss of GABA release from endothelial cells during embryogenesis results in vascular defects and impairs long-distance migration and positioning of cortical interneurons. The downstream effects of perturbed endothelial cell-derived GABA signaling are critical, leading to lasting changes to cortical circuits and persistent behavioral deficits. Furthermore, we illustrate new mechanisms of activation of GABA signaling in forebrain endothelial cells that promotes their migration, angiogenesis and acquisition of blood-brain barrier properties. Our findings uncover and elucidate a novel endothelial GABA signaling pathway in the CNS that is distinct from the classical neuronal GABA signaling pathway and shed new light on the etiology and pathophysiology of neuropsychiatric diseases, such as autism spectrum disorders, epilepsy, anxiety, depression and schizophrenia.
Today, one in four people worldwide suffer every year from some form of neuropsychiatric illness. Drugs used in psychiatry usually act to ease symptoms with no cure, due to lack of mechanistic insights into how these diseases initiate. One factor known to exert extremely broad influence on brain development and network formation is gamma-aminobutyric acid (GABA). Abnormalities in GABAergic neurons and defects in cortical inhibition are implicated underlying the etiology of autism spectrum disorders (ASD), epilepsy, schizophrenia, anxiety and depression1,2,3,4,5,6. Given the significance of abnormal early brain development that leads to these serious neuropsychiatric conditions2,3,7, GABA-mediated signaling by neuronal progenitors/neurons during development has been extensively studied8,9,10. Brain development, however, is not limited to neuronal changes but is also supported by concomitant development of its vasculature. After establishment of the periventricular vascular gradient by embryonic day 1111, excitatory glutamatergic projection neurons and inhibitory GABAergic interneurons navigate along diverse courses from ventricular zones, radially and tangentially, to adopt final laminar positions and synchronize cortical microcircuits12,13,14. While radial glia were established as the substrate for radial neuronal migration in the early seventies15, our recent studies have shown that the developing vascular system exquisitely patterned amidst neurons is the substrate for GABAergic neuronal tangential migration16. These findings highlighted the autonomy of periventricular versus pial vascular networks and revealed that they are independently capable of guiding deep versus superficial GABAergic neuronal populations en route to the cortex. Not only is the periventricular vascular network acting as a physical substrate for the migration of large populations of deep GABAergic neurons in the embryonic telencephalon, but also it holds the key to several novel developmental mechanisms. Many genes traditionally believed to be confined to GABAergic neurons and their precursors were found to be enriched in forebrain periventricular endothelial cells when compared to pial endothelial cells or control endothelial cells prepared from midbrain and hindbrain16. These results suggested that telencephalic endothelial cells house a novel GABA signaling pathway that is distinct from the traditional neuronal GABA signaling pathway with new significance for brain development and neuropsychiatric disease.
Several mouse models with abnormal GABAA receptors and GABA function, which recapitulated defective behaviors similar to those seen in conditions like autism, epilepsy, schizophrenia, mood and anxiety disorders as well as human studies have been vital for understanding the pathobiology of these neurological and psychiatric illnesses1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8,9,10,17,18,19,20. However, all of the mouse models reported until now are systemic or region-specific knockouts of the GABAA receptor-GABA pathway2,8,9,17,18,19,20. With such models, it is impossible to establish a cause-effect relationship between neuronal and endothelial development.
To discover the significance of GABA-related gene expression specifically in endothelial cells during embryonic development, we designed strategies to selectively modulate components of the endothelial GABA signaling pathway in vivo. This approach markedly affected endothelial GABA release levels, disturbed periventricular angiogenesis and in turn impaired GABAergic neuronal tangential migration in the embryonic brain. Concurrent vascular dysfunction and GABA cell deficits persisted in the postnatal cerebral cortex and manifested as diverse neuropsychiatric behavioral symptoms. Our results highlight the importance of a novel GABA signaling pathway operating via forebrain endothelial cells that has an intricate and powerful control of cerebral cortex development leaving its lasting signature on behavioral outcomes. It shows for the first time how prenatal forebrain angiogenesis has the remarkable potential to modulate postnatal and adult behaviors.
Autonomous roles of endothelial GABAA receptors in telencephalic development
The earliest GABA expression in the embryonic cerebral cortex has been described on embryonic day 10 (E10) near the pial surface and it has been difficult to explain the diffuse GABA staining present throughout the neuroepithelium between E10 and E12, even before GABAergic interneurons arrive21. With the use of Tie2-GFP mice, we observed that GFP+ endothelial cells of the periventricular vessel gradient11 at E11 express GABA (Figure 1A). GABA expression was distinct and robust in periventricular vessels of the E12 dorsal telencephalon (Figure 1B) and cultured periventricular endothelial cells (Figure 1C)16. Additionally, we observed expression of several GABAA receptor subunits in periventricular endothelial cells with GABAA receptor β3 subunit (Gabrb3) showing enriched expression, in vitro and in vivo (Supplementary information, Figure S1A, Figure 1D, 1E)16. To discover the functional significance of endothelial GABAA receptors in vivo, we selectively deleted GABAA receptor β3 subunit from endothelial cells to generate Gabrb3 endothelial cell conditional knockout Gabrb3ΔTie2-Cre (also named Gabrb3ECKO) mice. While Gabrb3fl/fl endothelial cells robustly expressed GABRB3 (Figure 1F, Supplementary information, Figure S1B), endothelial cells of Gabrb3ECKO telencephalon did not express GABRB3 confirming its deletion (Figure 1G, Supplementary information, Figure S1C). Labeling with multiple markers of vessel components, isolectin B4 and CD31/PECAM-1 revealed reductions in vessel density and pattern formation in E13 Gabrb3ECKO telencephalon (Figure 1H-1J, Supplementary information, Figure S1D-S1I). The tangential stream of GABAergic neurons that migrate from basal to dorsal telencephalon, examined with GAD65/67 immunoreactivity, was reduced in Gabrb3ECKO telencephalon when compared to Gabrb3fl/fl telencephalon at E13 (Supplementary information, Figure S1J, S1K). Vascular reductions continued in E15 Gabrb3ECKO telencephalon (Supplementary information, Figure S2A-S2E). The rhombic vascular patterns in the ganglionic eminence (GE) that ensheath deep GABAergic neuronal populations in a tube-like form16 were well formed in E15 Gabrb3fl/fl telencephalon, but continued to be disrupted in Gabrb3ECKO telencephalon (Figure 1K), along with concurrent reduction in GAD65/67 immunoreactivity (Figure 1L-1N). In histological stainings, cortical lamination in E18 dorso-lateral Gabrb3ECKO telencephalon appeared normal (Figure 1O, 1P) but the medial telencephalon showed morphological defects (Figure 1P, 1R). While in Gabrb3fl/fl telencephalon, corpus callosum, hippocampal layer stratum oriens, triangular septal nucleus and ventral hippocampal commissure could be clearly visualized (Figure 1Q), these anatomical landmarks were perturbed in Gabrb3ECKO telencephalon (Figure 1R). Ventricular abnormalities (Figure 1S), reduced hippocampus (Figure 1S, 1T) and enlarged striatal compartments (Figure 1P) were frequently observed in Gabrb3ECKO telencephalon. Cortical vascular densities were reduced in E18 Gabrb3ECKO telencephalon when compared to Gabrb3fl/fl telencephalon (Figure 1U-1W, Supplementary information, Figure S2F, S2G). Significant changes in blood-brain barrier (BBB) properties were not observed in Gabrb3ECKO versus Gabrb3fl/fl telencephalon. Subtle changes in tight junction protein, claudin 5 expression (Supplementary information, Figure S2H, S2I) as well as dilated and abnormally stretched vessels were noticed by immunoglobulin G (IgG) staining in Gabrb3ECKO telencephalon, when compared to Gabrb3fl/fl telencephalon, but no IgG leakage was observed (Supplementary information, Figure S2J, S2K). Gabrb3ECKO mice were smaller in size than Gabrb3fl/fl mice at birth and during postnatal stages (Figure 1X, 1Y), but showed long-term survival into adulthood. This provided us with a unique opportunity for studying the consequences of developmental perturbations due to loss of endothelial Gabrb3 in the mature brain.
Postnatal consequences of selective loss of endothelial Gabrb3
The vascular and GABA cell deficit observed in the Gabrb3ECKO embryonic brain (Figure 1) was also reflected in Gabrb3ECKO adult brain (P90) (Figure 2A-2D). Significantly affected regions in Gabrb3ECKO adult brain were the cingulate cortex, motor cortex and somatosensory cortex, in which concurrent reductions in isolectin B4+ vessels and GABA+ interneurons were observed (Figure 2A-2D). In the piriform cortex of Gabrb3ECKO mice, vascular reduction was observed at the three bregma levels analyzed (Figure 2B), but GABAergic neurons were reduced significantly only at −1.5 bregma level (Figure 2D). We next used a combination of retro-orbital lectin perfusion and CD31 immunohistochemistry (IHC) techniques, and focused on the P90 cingulate cortex for further analysis of vasculature. Microvessel densities were significantly reduced in Gabrb3ECKO cortex in comparison with Gabrb3fl/fl cortex (Figure 2E). Additionally, vessel diameters were markedly increased in Gabrb3ECKO cortex indicative of morphological alterations when compared to controls (Figure 2F). The average lectin+ area per vessel was also increased in Gabrb3ECKO cortex (Figure 2G). Larger vessel diameters likely correlated with the increased perfusion and are indicative of functional changes in Gabrb3ECKO vessels. Enlarged vessels continued to be detected by IgG staining in Gabrb3ECKO cortex (Supplementary information, Figure S2L, S2M). The hippocampus of Gabrb3ECKO mice at P90 also showed a deficit in GABAergic neurons when compared to Gabrb3fl/fl mice (Figure 2H). The decreased number of interneurons in Gabrb3ECKO cortex was not due to apoptosis as confirmed by anti-active caspase-3 IHC (Supplementary information, Figure S2N, S2O).
We next questioned whether the vascular abnormalities and reduction of GABAergic neurons in Gabrb3ECKO cerebral cortex contributed to altered behavior. As a first indication of pathological behavior, 15% of the Gabrb3ECKO mice showed seizure-like symptoms from P14 onward. Common characteristics that overlap across many neuropsychiatric disease categories are impaired reciprocal social interactions, communication deficits and heightened anxiety. Therefore we performed behavioral tests to screen for stress, anxiety and sociability in Gabrb3ECKO mice. Mice are expert and flexible nest builders, so Gabrb3ECKO and Gabrb3fl/fl mice were housed individually in cages containing wood chip bedding and two nestlets (pressed cotton) or more naturalistic material like shredded paper strips. Gabrb3ECKO mice showed poor nest building behavior in both normal and enriched environments (Figure 2I-2K) as well as moderate to severe grooming (Figure 2L) indicative of impaired home cage social behavior and increased stress/anxiety22. Anxiety was also assessed with the classic light-dark avoidance test, which triggers a struggle between the desires to explore an unknown area versus dislike of a brightly lit open space22. Gabrb3fl/fl mice made several entries into the brightened space and spent equivalent times between the light and dark sides of the open field (Figure 2M-2O). On the other hand, Gabrb3ECKO mice showed an aversion to brightly lit open space and preferred the dark area (Figure 2M-2O).
We next performed the tail suspension test, a screening test for depression in which normal mice will struggle to face upward and climb to a solid surface. When the animal stops struggling and hangs immobile, it is considered to have 'given up'. Gabrb3ECKO mice showed longer periods of immobility than wild-type (WT) littermates in the tail suspension test that is characteristic of a depressive-like state (Figure 2P). We used the tube dominance test to assess cognition in Gabrb3ECKO mice, in particular social dominance through measurement of aggression. Both Gabrb3fl/fl and Gabrb3ECKO mice were released into opposite ends of a tube and evaluated for the winner who forced its opponent out of the tube. Gabrb3ECKO mice showed fewer wins in a tube dominance test in comparison to their WT littermates (Figure 2Q). To test for social communication, a three-chambered social approach task (Supplementary information, Figure S3) was used in which we scored time spent in a side chamber with a novel mouse versus time spent in a side chamber with a non-social novel object as a measure of sociability. While Gabrb3fl/fl mice showed preference for a stranger mouse over an inanimate object, Gabrb3ECKO mice showed no preference for the stranger mouse and spent approximately similar time investigating stranger and object signifying impaired sociability (Figure 2R). In the social novelty phase, when a new stranger mouse was introduced into the previously empty cylinder, Gabrb3fl/fl mice showed a marked preference for stranger 2 versus the now familiar stranger 1, while Gabrb3ECKO mice did not show a significant preference for stranger 2 versus stranger 1 indicative of decreased social motivation, memory and novelty exploration (Figure 2S). We confirmed that the abnormal social behavior was not due to an olfaction defect since Gabrb3ECKO mice performed slightly better than Gabrb3fl/fl mice in the buried food olfaction test (Figure 2T). Gabrb3ECKO mice did not show gender-specific differences in behavior in all of these behavioral assays (Figure 2I-2S). These results provided novel evidence that prenatal loss of a single GABAA receptor subunit from endothelial cells is sufficient to modulate postnatal behavior. It therefore became critical to gain mechanistic insights into endothelial GABAA receptor actions during embryonic brain development.
Mechanistic insights into endothelial GABAA receptor function and dysfunction
We first questioned whether embryonic forebrain endothelial cells possess functional GABAA receptors. WT periventricular endothelial cells showed higher expression of the cation-chloride cotransporter — NKCC1 versus KCC2 (Figure 3A), similar to embryonic neurons. We prepared pure cultures of periventricular endothelial cells from E15 CD1 embryonic telencephalon and tested if endothelial GABAA receptors were able to respond to the GABAA receptor agonist muscimol. We found that application of muscimol in whole-cell patch-clamp recording of periventricular endothelial cells at a holding potential of −70 mV, resulted in an inward current (Figure 3B). The muscimol induced inward current was blocked by application of the GABAA receptor antagonist bicuculline methiodide (BMI) (Figure 3C). This pharmacological profile provided evidence that periventricular endothelial cells have functional GABAA receptors that account for the GABA responses. Muscimol application induced no current response in Gabrb3ECKO periventricular endothelial cells (Figure 3D). Muscimol application induced inward currents in Gabrb3fl/fl and Gabrb3ECKO cortical neuronal cells that were blocked by BMI (Figure 3E, 3F). These results ascertained that there was no change in the GABAA receptor response in cortical neuronal cells and emphasized the specific loss of GABAA receptor function in endothelial cells. Furthermore, muscimol application produced an increase of intracellular calcium in Gabrb3fl/fl periventricular endothelial cells in calcium imaging assays, but no marked increase in intracellular calcium in Gabrb3ECKO periventricular endothelial cells (Figure 3G-3I). Calcium transients have been shown to tightly regulate proliferation in many cell types, including cells in the neocortex23,24. Ca2+ influx can influence advancement of progenitor cells through the cells cycle. Transitions of cells from G1 to S phase and progression through M phase have been reported to be highly calcium dependent25,26. Since GABAA receptor activation in Gabrb3fl/fl periventricular endothelial cells leads to an influx of Ca2+ that is likely to influence cell proliferation, we incubated Gabrb3fl/fl and Gabrb3ECKO periventricular endothelial cells isolated from E15 telencephalon in the presence of muscimol and the mitotic marker 5-bromo-2′-deoxyuridine (BrdU) to examine the impact on proliferation of these cells. Muscimol application significantly increased proliferation in Gabrb3fl/fl endothelial cells (Figure 3J, 3L). However, there was no discernible difference in Gabrb3ECKO endothelial cell proliferation before or after muscimol application (Figure 3K, 3L). Together, these results indicate that GABAA receptors in Gabrb3ECKO periventricular endothelial cells are dysfunctional and elucidate how activation of endothelial GABAA receptors modulates endothelial cell proliferation and angiogenesis.
Another interesting finding is that endothelial-specific deletion of Gabrb3 significantly decreased GABA expression in embryonic periventricular endothelial cells (Figure 3M, Supplementary information, Figure S4A, S4B). We observed robust GABA expression by IHC in control periventricular endothelial cells and this is illustrated at both low and high magnifications (Figure 3M, Supplementary information, Figure S4A). All Gabrb3ECKO endothelial cells, in sharp contrast showed a marked reduction in GABA expression (Figure 3M, Supplementary information, Figure S4B). Variability in GABA expression with respect to fold decrease was observed in the Gabrb3ECKO endothelial cell population and this was quantified (Supplementary information, Figure S4C). Next, we measured secreted GABA by ELISA from Gabrb3fl/fl and Gabrb3ECKO periventricular endothelial cells. As expected, there was a significant reduction in GABA secretion upon Gabrb3 knockout (Figure 3N). These data lay the foundation for a novel positive feedback signaling pathway in endothelial cells that functions via GABAA receptor-mediated GABA release. Since pial endothelial cells do not express GABRB316, they are unaffected by the deletion, and GABA secretion from these cells is unaffected (Supplementary information, Figure S4D). Thus the Gabrb3ECKO mouse is a model of partial loss of endothelial cell-secreted GABA in the embryonic telencephalon. Together these observations suggested that loss of functional endothelial GABAA receptors and partial loss of endothelial GABA can impair telencephalic angiogenesis and angiogenesis-guided GABAergic neuronal migration in vivo (Figure 3O) as observed in Figure 1. The consequences persist in the adult brain, reflecting as reduced vascular densities and reduction of cortical interneurons and manifest as multifaceted behavioral deficits common in many overlapping psychiatric disease symptoms (Figure 2).
The importance of endothelial cell-derived GABA for telencephalic development
Since partial loss of endothelial GABA during embryonic brain development resulted in long-term repercussions, we were curious as to the effect of complete loss of endothelial GABA release in vivo on brain development and postnatal behavior. We had detected both GAD1 and GAD2 expression in CNS endothelial cells16. Therefore, conditional deletion of GAD1 alone from endothelial cells will not be sufficient to deplete endothelial GABA due to presence of GAD2 and vice versa. We thus examined the expression of GATs, GABA transporters that can serve to store and release GABA. No GATs were present, but we found that slc32a1 (also named Vgat, vesicular GABA transporter) mRNA was highly enriched in periventricular endothelial cells16. We did not find glycine receptors, glycine, β-alanine or taurine expression in periventricular endothelial cells, suggesting that a GABA pathway is exclusively active in this cell type during early embryonic development. This suggested that GABA release from periventricular endothelial cells may be vesicular and deletion of endothelial Vgat is likely to have profound influence on adjusting the balance of GABA release and local GABA concentrations. Therefore, VGAT expression in both WT and Tie2-GFP telencephalic endothelial cells was first confirmed by IHC and found to be robustly expressed both in vitro (Figure 4A-4C) and in vivo (Figure 4D). Next, we used Tie2-cre mice and Vgat floxed mice to selectively delete Vgat from endothelial cells and generate Vgat endothelial cell conditional knockout VgatΔTie2-cre (also named VgatECKO) mice. VGAT expression was not detected specifically in VgatECKO endothelial cells (Figure 4E, Supplementary information, Figure S5A, S5B). No marked change or variability in GABA or GAD65/67 expression was observed in VgatECKO periventricular endothelial cells when compared to controls (Figure 4F, 4G). Then, we determined whether endothelial GABA secretion was affected in VgatECKO embryonic telencephalon by isolating VgatECKO periventricular endothelial cells and testing for GABA secretion by ELISA. We found that deleting Vgat from endothelial cells successfully abolished GABA secretion during embryonic stages from periventricular endothelial cells (Figure 4H). These experiments confirmed that VGAT is the primary GABA transporter in periventricular endothelial cells and that GABA release by these endothelial cells is executed through a vesicular mechanism. Telencephalic angiogenesis was more markedly affected in VgatECKO telencephalon when compared to Gabrb3ECKO telencephalon. Vascular densities were significantly reduced in E13 VgatECKO telencephalon (Fig 4I-4K). Reduction in vessel density and loss of normal periventricular vessel plexus formation continued in E15 VgatECKO telencephalon (Supplementary information, Figure S5C-S5G). Cortical vessel densities in E18 VgatECKO telencephalon were also significantly decreased (Supplementary information, Figure S5H-S5J).
Next, we performed a transwell migration assay to examine migration of VgatECKO endothelial cells labeled with Qdot nanocrystals versus controls. VgatECKO endothelial cells showed a significant reduction in migration when compared to Vgatfl/fl endothelial cells (Figure 4L, 4M). Tube formation assays27 showed that the angiogenic potential of VgatECKO periventricular endothelial cells was significantly affected (Figure 4N-4R). The tube network was quantified to measure the two parameters: number of junctions and number of tubules, both of which showed a significant reduction in VgatECKO endothelial cells when compared to controls (Figure 4P, 4Q). VgatECKO endothelial cells formed fewer polygons or 'honey comb' structures, which indicated the lack of organizing into complex structures. Furthermore, we quantified the angiogenic score using published methodology28 by taking into account the number of sprouting cells, connected cells and polygons. The angiogenic score of VgatECKO endothelial cells was significantly reduced versus Vgatfl/fl endothelial cells (Figure 4R).
Since vascular endothelial cells that advance in the telencephalon form a functional BBB during embryogenesis29, and extrinsic addition of GABA (5 μM) was able to increase expression of claudin 5 in WT periventricular endothelial cells (Supplementary information, Figure S5K, S5L), we tested the barrier properties in Vgatfl/fl and VgatECKO dorsal telencephalon in detail. Claudin 5 showed robust expression in E16 Vgatfl/fl cortical blood vessels (Figure 4S) but VgatECKO vessels showed a loss of tight junctions and reduced claudin 5 expression (Figure 4T). Another tight junction protein, ZO-1, was also reduced in VgatECKO endothelial cells versus control (Supplementary information, Figure S5M, S5N). We next checked for leakage of IgG using IHC, since IgGs are restricted to the insides of vessels. Contrary to controls (Figure 4U), IgG leakage and extravascular IgG staining was observed in the dorsal and medial telencephalon (developing hippocampus) of E17 VgatECKO mice (Figure 4V, 4W). To better determine barrier properties, E18 VgatECKO mice and littermate controls were given a trans-cardiac perfusion of biotinylated dextran. VgatECKO mice showed an increase in tracer staining in the dorsal telencephalon indicative of increased vascular permeability (Figure 4X, 4Y). Together, these results suggested an impairment of the BBB in VgatECKO mice. It illustrates the importance of endothelial cell-derived GABA for angiogenesis and formation of barrier properties in the embryonic telencephalon.
Endothelial GABA promotes long-distance GABAergic neuronal migration
By turning off endothelial GABA secretion during embryonic brain development, we were able to evaluate the significance of endothelial GABA for key events during brain development — neurogenesis and neuronal migration. No marked changes were seen in neuroepithelial cell proliferation in VgatECKO telencephalon as observed by the 2.0 h BrdU labeling index at early (E13) and late (E17) embryonic stages (Supplementary information, Figure S6). Since periventricular blood vessels have been shown to influence ventral telencephalic progenitors30, cell proliferation was further analyzed in the ventral telencephalon of E15 VgatECKO mice by examining interkinetic nuclear migration with phosphohistone 3 (PHH3), a specific marker for cells undergoing mitosis. There were no differences in the number of PHH3+ cells at the ventricular zone (VZ) of Vgatfl/fl versus VgatECKO ventral telencephalon. However, abnormal PHH3+ profiles were observed in the extra-VZ surface of VgatECKO ventral telencephalon, along with a small but significant increase in the number of PHH3+ cells (Supplementary information, Figure S7A-S7E). Ki67 labeling (a marker for all phases of the cell cycle: S, G2, M and G1) was increased at the extra-VZ surface of VgatECKO ventral telencephalon versus Vgatfl/fl ventral telencephalon (Supplementary information, Figure S7F, S7G). Some microtubule-associated protein 2 (MAP2) immunoreactive postmitotic neurons were observed within the neuroepithelium in the GE in the VgatECKO embryos, revealing evidence of impaired differentiation and perturbed neuronal migration (Supplementary information, Figure S7H, S7I). The GABAergic neurons in the VgatECKO telencephalon were significantly affected (Figure 5), while tyrosine hydroxylase+ neurons were not (Supplementary information, Figure S7J, S7K). The GABAergic neuronal tangential migratory profile, examined with GAD65/67 immunoreactivity was significantly reduced in E13 and E15 VgatECKO dorsal telencephalon when compared to Vgatfl/fl telencephalon (Figure 5A-5D). Since VgatECKO endothelial cells did not secrete GABA (Figure 4H), they were valuable for testing whether it was specifically endothelial cell-derived GABA that acted as a chemoattractant and provided directional cues to migrating neurons. Our experimental strategy was to seed either E15 WT periventricular endothelial cells, control endothelial cells (from WT midbrain and hindbrain combined) or VgatECKO periventricular endothelial cells (that do not secrete GABA) in a specific track spanning a 35 mm culture dish. WT GE-derived neurons from E15 GAD65-GFP telencephalon were plated at one end of the track (Figure 5E). GE neurons migrated robustly on a bed of WT periventricular endothelial cells from one end of the dish to the other (Figure 5F, 5G). The control (Figure 5F, 5G) confirmed that GE neuronal migration was specifically affected by periventricular endothelial cells. Most importantly, GE neurons failed to migrate long distance on VgatECKO periventricular endothelial cells that cannot secrete GABA (Figure 5F, 5G). Similar results were obtained when GE explants were cultured on Vgatfl/fl or VgatECKO periventricular endothelial cells (Figure 5H). Extrinsic addition of GABA (5 μM) was able to rescue GE neuronal migration on VgatECKO periventricular endothelial cells (Supplementary information, Figure S8) indicating the importance of the endothelial GABA source for neuronal migration. To test whether loss of endothelial GABA has consequences for GABA neuronal migration routes and distribution in vivo, we performed a BrdU birthdating study. We followed a single cohort of GE-derived interneurons by labeling cells born at E13 with a single BrdU pulse and analyzed their distribution in the E17 cortex. BrdU IHC by both fluorescence and DAB methods revealed several stalled BrdU+ cells in VgatECKO ventral telencephalon when compared to Vgatfl/fl telencephalon at both rostral and caudal levels indicative of abnormal GABAergic neuronal migration (Figure 5I-5L, Supplementary information, Figure S9). Double IHC for BrdU and LHX6 (a marker for migrating interneurons) highlighted layer-specific alterations in laminar targeting of GABAergic interneurons in VgatECKO developing neocortex (Figure 5M-5R). While LHX− BrdU+ cells were significantly reduced only in the cortical plate (CP) suggesting that laminar positioning of cortical projection neurons may also be affected in the VgatECKO telencephalon (Figure 5Q), LHX6+ BrdU+ cells were significantly decreased in the marginal zone, CP and subventricular zone (SVZ) of VgatECKO telencephalon indicative of perturbed GABAergic neuronal tangential migration and final distribution (Figure 5R). Together, these results signify that endothelial cell-secreted GABA is essential for long-distance GABAergic neuronal migration in the embryonic telencephalon.
Disturbances in radial neuronal migration in the absence of endothelial GABA
Earlier studies have shown that intermediate progenitors, the precursors of projection neurons in the developing neocortex are very closely associated with periventricular blood vessels and are influenced by vascular cues31. PHH3 labeling showed an increase in mitotic cells in the SVZ of E15 VgatECKO telencephalon, while no differences were observed in the ventricular border (Supplementary information, Figure S10A-S10D). The distribution of cells expressing the transcription factor Tbr2 that selectively marks intermediate progenitors, precursors of cortical projection neurons was next examined in the dorsal telencephalon. Tbr2-positive cells were predominant in the VZ/SVZ of Vgatfl/fl telencephalon, but ectopic increases in Tbr2-positive cells were observed in the intermediate zone (IZ) and CP of VgatECKO telencephalon (Supplementary information, Figure S10E-S10G). Spatial patterns of neuronal differentiation were examined by expression of MAP2 and cortical neuron population marker Tbr1, which marks CP and layer VI in WT embryos. MAP2-positive postmitotic neurons were detected within the SVZ in E15 VgatECKO telencephalon, revealing evidence of perturbed neuronal migration (Supplementary information, Figure S10H). Tbr1 immunoreactivity revealed a continuous uniform band of Tbr1-positive cells in the CP of E18 Vgatfl/fl embryos. On the other hand, abnormally positioned Tbr1-positive cells were detected trailing in the IZ of VgatECKO embryos (Supplementary information, Figure S10I, S10J). Together, these results indicate perturbations of radial neuronal migration in the absence of endothelial cell-secreted GABA during development.
Gene expression profiling of VgatECKO telencephalon predicts its postnatal phenotype
Our previous studies have implicated the importance of periventricular endothelial cells for a wide range of neuropsychiatric diseases16, therefore we questioned the significance of loss of the endothelial GABA source for global gene expression in the embryonic forebrain. We extracted RNA from Vgatfl/fl and VgatECKO whole telencephalon (E18), respectively; performed microarray hybridization on Mouse Gene 2.0 ST arrays (Affymetrix) and subsequent differential expression analysis. Two hundred and eighty six genes were differentially expressed (fold change cut off ≥ ± 50%) in VgatECKO versus Vgatfl/fl telencephalon of which the top 20 genes rated by significance have been depicted as a heat map (Figure 6A). Genes were further classified into three categories that are essential for embryonic forebrain development: angiogenesis (Figure 6B), neurogenesis (Figure 6C) and GABAergic neuronal development (Figure 6D). Top 20 differentially expressed genes in each category are shown. The gene expression profile revealed that loss of endothelial GABA has far reaching consequences for critical events during brain development and can modulate signaling events at the level of extracellular receptors, ion channels, transporters, intracellular signaling molecules as well as transcription factors (Figure 6A-6D). For instance, critical regulators of vascular morphogenesis and structure formation (Wasf2, Rasip1, Fmnl3 and Tbx4) were downregulated in VgatECKO telencephalon (Figure 6B). Genes involved in cell proliferation, cell adhesion and cytoskeletal organization pathways were altered in VgatECKO telencephalon (either significantly upregulated or downregulated) when compared to controls (Figure 6A-6D). Since Vgat (Slc32a1) had been deleted from endothelial cells, the heat map showed decreased expression of Slc32a1 in VgatECKO whole telencephalon as expected (Figure 6D). Gabrb3, on the other hand, was significantly upregulated in VgatECKO telencephalon (Figure 6D). Another interesting gene, Shank3, that is widely linked with ASD32,33 was significantly downregulated in VgatECKO telencephalon (Figure 6D).
What may be the signaling mechanisms perturbed by the loss of Vgat specifically in periventricular endothelial cells that contribute to the impaired telencephalic angiogenesis (Figure 4)? How does endothelial GABA interact with other signaling systems previously shown to regulate angiogenesis? To address these questions, we looked at three signaling pathways — VEGF signaling, Delta-Notch signaling and Wnt signaling, that are implicated in regulating diverse aspects of CNS angiogenesis. We examined expression of ligand/receptor combinations: vascular endothelial growth factor (isoform A; Vegfa) and its receptors Flk1 and Flt1, Dll4 and its receptor Notch1, Wnt signaling ligands (Wnt7a and Wnt7b) and receptor Frizzled6, specifically in periventricular endothelial cells, isolated from E15 Vgatfl/fl and VgatECKO telencephalons. There was a significant (P < 0.05) decrease in Vegfa, Flk1, Dll4, Wnt7b and Frizzled6 mRNA (but not Flt1, Notch1 and Wnt7a mRNA) in VgatECKO endothelial cells (Figure 6E). Since loss of endothelial Vgat altered the expression of molecules critical for telencephalic angiogenesis, our results suggest that other important angiogenesis signaling pathways may be either under direct control of or actively interacting with the endothelial GABA signaling pathway.
We next questioned whether the gene expression profile of VgatECKO embryonic telencephalon could be used to predict the postnatal phenotype of VgatECKO mice using the Comparative Toxicogenomic Database. When genes were classified according to disease categories, the genes expressed in VgatECKO telencephalon showed enrichment in neuropsychiatric disease categories like seizures, epilepsy, depression and autism (Figure 6F; Supplementary information, Figure S11). Several different types of epilepsies appeared in the list (Figure 6F). Epilepsy-related genes that were altered in VgatECKO telencephalon were isolated and grouped into specific categories, from the CTD database and from an elegant study34 describing the genetic landscape of early postnatal (infancy and childhood) epilepsies (Supplementary information, Table S1). Childhood epilepsies comprise many age-related epilepsy syndromes characterized by specific seizure types and neurological features and are a heterogeneous group of devastating disorders that cause developmental delays or regression34. Scatter plots depict the changes in epilepsy-related gene expression in VgatECKO telencephalon when compared to controls for all genes combined (Figure 6G), McTague only genes (Figure 6H) and genes isolated from the CTD database (Figure 6I). Specific genes that showed changes in expression in VgatECKO telencephalon, with respect to different groups of childhood epilepsies (isolated from34) have also been graphically illustrated (Figure 6J, Supplementary information, Figures S12, S13).
Postnatal phenotype of VgatECKO mice
No marked perturbation of cortical cytoarchitecture (e.g., heterotopias, dysplasia) was observed in VgatECKO telencephalon at late embryonic stage E18 (Figure 7A-7E). However, enlarged lateral ventricles were routinely seen (Figure 7B-7E), and abnormal cellularity in the CP was observed along the rostrocaudal axis (Figure 7B, 7D). Interestingly, the postnatal phenotype of VgatECKO mice turned out similar to the predictions offered by the prenatal gene expression signature. VgatECKO mice were smaller in size at birth than their floxed littermates (Figure 7F). VgatECKO mice started to show seizure-like activity between P7 and P14. Alterations in postnatal behavior were characterized by periods of quiescence, interrupted by tremors and a reduction in voluntary movement (Supplementary information, Movie S1). VgatECKO mice were fragile and died between P20 and P35. Since VgatECKO mice were unable to survive the surgical procedure for in vivo EEG recordings, we performed field potential recordings to measure the degree of hyperexcitability in hippocampal slices. VgatECKO slices displayed ictal-type discharges (Figure 7G, 7J), discontinuous interictal activity and spreading depression (SD), (Figure 7H, 7J) when compared to floxed controls that showed continuous interictal activity and no SD (Figure 7I, 7J). Control slices displayed ictal-type discharges with a significantly lower frequency than VgatECKO slices (Figure 7J). Furthermore, VgatECKO slices exclusively showed repetitive SDs (61.5% of slices), while control slices showed none (Figure 7J). VgatECKO slices showed no interictal discharges in 23% of the preparations, continuous interictal activity in another 23% and discontinuous interictal activity in 54% of the preparations (Figure 7K). On the other hand, controls showed discontinuous interictal activity in 20% of the preparations, and in 80% only continuous interictal activity (Figure 7K). The ictal type activity in VgatECKO slices is indicative of higher network excitability and epileptogenicity. Higher SD susceptibility has also been linked to higher epileptogenicity35. Furthermore, SD has been reported to trigger ictal-like activity in vitro (in rat brain slices)36, or enhance evoked activity37. Importantly, SD has also been shown to enhance excitability in human epileptic neocortex in vitro38. In conclusion, increased SD susceptibility is also a sign of increased excitability.
Developmental milestones of VgatECKO mice were significantly affected. Beginning on postnatal day 1 (PND 1), the mice were examined daily for acquisition of somatosensory reflexes and neurodevelopmental markers: surface righting, air righting, grasping and negative geotaxis. VgatECKO mice showed a deficit in surface righting and forelimb grasping (Figure 7L). Maternal scent preference, a test for social communication39 was conducted on PND 14 pups. While Vgatfl/fl mice spent significantly more time in the mother's bedding, indicative of social recognition of maternal scent when compared to the scent of a stranger female, VgatECKO mice showed significantly lower preference for maternal scent by comparison to the stranger's scent (Figure 7M). VgatECKO mice did not show signs of impaired movement capability in the maternal scent test. These data indicate that developmental milestones and social recognition are impaired in VgatECKO mice. Collectively, these results suggest that VgatECKO mice can serve as a model for infantile/childhood epilepsy or ASD.
Marked vascular and interneuron deficits in the VgatECKO cerebral cortex
Cortical regions — cingulate, motor, somatosensory and piriform cortex in the VgatECKO brain at P30 were more significantly affected than in the Gabrb3ECKO brain, and reductions in vessel density were observed at all of the bregma levels examined (Figure 8A, 8B). To evaluate the putative damage of the BBB at P30, we looked for a leakage of serum IgGs using IHC. No IgG leakage was observed in Vgatfl/fl somatosensory cortex while on the other hand, extra-vascular IgGs were detected in VgatECKO somatosensory cortex (Figure 8C). IgGs formed halos with a concentration gradient around VgatECKO microvessels (Figure 8D). Next we performed a double fluorescence labeling for IgG and isolectin B4 on P30 Vgatfl/fl and VgatECKO sections. While immunohistochemical localization of IgG and isolectin B4 was observed in Vgatfl/fl vessels (Figure 8E), IgG leakage along with neuronal uptake was observed in VgatECKO somatosensory cortex, 6 or 24 h after limbic status epilepticus (Figure 8F, 8G) indicative of a rapid BBB impairment.
Concurrent reductions in GABAergic interneurons was observed in cingulate, motor, somatosensory and piriform cortex (Figure 8H-8I). Layer-specific loss of GABAergic interneurons along with abnormal GABAergic (Figure 8H) and glutamatergic neuronal distribution (Supplementary information, Figure S14A, S14B) was marked in VgatECKO cerebral cortex, which is indicative of an asynchronous cortical circuitry. Activation of caspase 3 was insignificant in VgatECKO cortex, further demonstrating that the GABA cell deficits were not due to GABAergic neuronal cell death (Supplementary information, Figure S14C-S14E). We also tested whether specific subtypes of GABAergic interneurons were affected in VgatECKO cerebral cortex. Our results showed that while the calretinin population was not affected, somatostatin+ and NPY+ neurons were reduced, but the most significantly affected population was the parvalbumin+ neurons (Figure 8J). This is particularly interesting since parvalbumin+ neurons account for ∼50% of the GABAergic interneurons in the rodent cortex40. The parvalbumin subpopulation seems to be markedly affected in epilepsy and ASDs, possibly because these cells are less proficient at inhibiting pyramidal cells. In VgatECKO mice, similar to the GABAergic interneuron profile (Figure 8H), parvalbumin+ neurons also showed abnormal distribution and layer specific reductions in somatosensory cortex. Cells appeared to be stuck and clustered in lower layers (layer V) in VgatECKO cortex, while layers II/III showed the most significant reduction (Figure 8K-8M).
Parvalbumin+ interneuron class comprises of basket cells that focus on targeting the somata and proximal dendrites of pyramidal neurons and interneurons, and this gives them the unique advantage to regulate the gain of the integrated synaptic response. Large basket cells are classic basket cells with extensive axonal arborizations that can inhibit neurons in lower and upper layers and in neighboring and distant columns40. Golgi impregnation and morphological analysis showed differences in axonal arborizations of large basket cells in layer II/III from VgatECKO somatosensory cortex when compared to Vgatfl/fl cortex (Figure 8N-8Q, Supplementary information, Figure S15A, S15B). While Vgatfl/fl basket cells had long horizontally and vertically projecting axon collaterals that arborized on and around somata of target neurons, VgatECKO basket cells had shorter-range axon collaterals that failed to do so. There was a significant reduction in total dendritic lengths of basket cells (41%) in VgatECKO somatosensory cortex (Figure 8Q, 8R). VgatECKO basket cells also showed a reduction in the number of dendritic segments (37%) as compared to controls. By comparing the dendritic length versus branch order, VgatECKO basket cells showed a significant reduction in dendritic length in the middle portion, the 4th and 5th branch orders of the dendritic tree (Supplementary information, Figure S15C). To further investigate dentritic morphology of SS1 basket cells, Sholl analysis was performed in order to characterize the morphological changes in reference to a series of concentric circles (spheres in 3D) around the soma of the basket cell. Frequency of (dendritic) intersections at a 30-μm interval from the soma of basket cells between Vgatfl/fl and VgatECKO groups was determined. The VgatECKO group exhibited a significant reduction in the frequency of intersections in the middle portion (60-120 μm) of the dendritic field (Figure 8S). Also, VgatECKO basket cells showed a reduction of dendritic lengths in the middle portion (90-120 μm) of the dendritic field (Supplementary information, Figure S15D). These results illustrate significant alterations in the dendritic morphology of basket cells of VgatECKO somatosensory cortex. It signifies the importance of endothelial cell-derived GABA for normal formation and synchronization of the cortical microcircuitry.
Radial glia, which are cortical neural stem cells, cortical progenitors and migrating GABA neurons have all been reported to express functional GABAA and GABAB receptors early in development that respond to ambient GABA levels in many different ways to trigger several important events during cerebral cortex development. GABA has been well established as the first excitatory transmitter to become functional in the embryonic brain, acting as an epigenetic factor to control processes like neural progenitor proliferation, neuronal migration, dendritic maturation and synaptogenesis, and is a key player in building the cortical network8,9,10. Specifically, during the tangential neuronal migration process, neocortical GABAergic interneurons progressively acquire responsiveness to GABA; the paracrine actions of GABA acting on several receptor subtypes, being the key motility promoting signal. The functional expression of GABAA receptor subunits in tangentially migrating interneurons derived from the MGE has recently been characterized41. While early migrating interneurons express alpha 2 and alpha 3 subunits when they are at the corticostriate junction, they additionally upregulate alpha 1 and gamma 1-3 subunits as soon as they enter the developing cortex and the functional implications of this upregulation of multiple GABAA receptor isoforms with higher affinity to GABA in the migration process is not known41. Within the cortex, GABA's complexity increases and it has been reported to play contrasting roles on migrating neurons by acting as a 'GO' signal in lower layers and as a 'STOP' signal in upper cortical layers42. These multiple actions of GABA exerted at different developmental stages all appear to be mediated through a paracrine, diffuse, non-synaptic mode of action. However, current views of neocortical development have depicted this source of GABA during corticogenesis to be exclusively neuronal. And given its multiple roles in cerebral cortex development, GABA has been epitomized as a deeply interesting and versatile molecule.
We believe that the cell-type specific source that secretes GABA in the embryonic forebrain is the key to its versatility. Neuronal GABA seems to be sufficient to some degree for telencephalic neurogenesis in the absence of endothelial GABA. A previous study has demonstrated that GABA promotes VZ cell division while inhibiting SVZ cell divisions21. Our study also shows differences in cell proliferation in the absence of endothelial GABA in the VZ versus SVZ. The increase in cells undergoing mitosis in the SVZ of VgatECKO telencephalon suggests that endothelial GABA functions to inhibit cell proliferation here, while neuronal GABA is sufficient for VZ cell proliferation. Also, while possible paracrine roles of neuronal GABA on angiogenesis cannot be overlooked, it was clearly unable to rescue the vascular defects in the absence of endothelial GABA. Our results show that endothelial GABA is indispensable for angiogenesis and GABAergic neuronal tangential migration in the embryonic telencephalon. Neuronal GABA cannot compensate for these unique roles of endothelial GABA. Endothelial GABA may be a requisite for fostering neurovascular interactions in the long term. For instance, if GABA coming from neurons can contribute to GABAA receptor-mediated GABA release from endothelial cells, then it is possible that loss of this chemotactic signal during development due to stalled and abnormal neuronal migration as observed in VgatECKO telencephalon, may in turn have affected angiogenesis. Thus, the downstream cellular mechanism of endothelial GABA-mediated regulation is its key effect on neuronal migration that is highly concentration, time and location dependent.
Endothelial GABA closely influences key angiogenesis signaling pathways — VEGF, Delta-Notch and Wnt signaling, that play important roles in endothelial cell proliferation, migration, sprouting, vascular pattern formation and induction of BBB properties. The marked impairment of telencephalic angiogenesis that lead to BBB defects in VgatECKO mice may be due to direct links between endothelial GABA and BBB function, for instance, regulation of tight junction protein expression by GABA. Since our study has identified the relevant ligand/receptor pairs, it will facilitate future mechanistic studies linking endothelial GABA signaling with specific angiogenesis processes. The stalled GABAergic neuronal migration and accumulation in the ventral telencephalon due to absence of endothelial GABA also highlights the importance of endothelial versus neuronal GABA for subtype-specific contributions to the cerebral cortex. Parvalbumin+ neurons derive almost entirely from the MGE, whereas contributions from both MGE and CGE have been reported for somatostatin+, NPY+ and CR+ neurons43. The marked reduction of the parvalbumin+ population in VgatECKO mice highlights the important contribution of endothelial GABA for MGE-derived GABAergic neuronal migration. Interestingly, susceptibility of the parvalbumin population has been reported in neuropsychiatric diseases like schizophrenia, epilepsy and ASD2,44. Though GABAergic cell death was not significant in Gabrb3ECKO and VgatECKO brains, we cannot rule out possible contributions of reactive astrocytosis and microglial activation for some of the adult phenotypes.
Since development of the periventricular vascular gradient precedes neuronal migration during embryonic development11,16, we think that the mechanism of GABA release from periventricular endothelial cells is constitutive at first, then facilitated by GABA itself. GABA-mediated activation of endothelial GABAA receptors triggers an increase in intracellular Ca2+ that in turn induces endothelial cell proliferation. Endothelial GABAA receptor beta 3 subunit is not only essential for GABAA receptor functions, but also modulates GABA expression, resulting in lowered GABA levels in Gabrb3ECKO mice during embryonic development. This is of interest, since silencing GABAA receptor subunits alters GABA expression and release16 and correlations between lowered GABA levels and altered GABAA receptors have been reported in many neuropsychiatric disease scenarios1,45,46,47,48,49. In addition, our studies show that Vgat is the primary mechanism for GABA release from endothelial cells in the embryonic telencephalon, since loss of endothelial Vgat completely abolished endothelial GABA secretion. Our experiments thus point to a novel positive feedback of GABA release that is essential for telencephalic angiogenesis (Figure 9A). Since GABA itself promotes the developmental switch from excitatory during prenatal development to inhibitory at birth50,51,52, it would be interesting for future studies to dissect the specific roles of the endothelial GABA signaling pathway and novel mechanisms of action in the postnatal and adult brain.
Disturbances in vessel function, BBB and blood flow have repeatedly been observed in patients with epilepsy, ASDs, anxiety, depression and schizophrenia using old and new technologies53,54,55,56,57. However, these disturbances are usually linked to inflammation, changes in neural plasticity or seizure frequency. Our studies provide a direct cause for change in vessel function in psychiatric disorders that originates from intrinsic defects in vessels from the earliest developmental points. It illustrates the importance of a new endothelial GABA signaling pathway that molds neuronal development making lasting changes to cortical circuits and most importantly is sufficient to cause behavioral dysfunction. Our study also introduces the novel concept that variation in endothelial GABA levels during embryonic brain development can contribute to diversity in psychiatric disease symptoms.
We suggest re-consideration of current concepts that depict GABA signaling during brain development as predominantly neuronal (Figure 9B). The GABA balance in the embryonic telencephalon is maintained by both endothelial cells and neuronal cells (Figure 9C). Tipping the balance by either reducing or eliminating the endothelial GABA source can result in a spectrum of neuropsychiatric diseases such as autism, epilepsy, anxiety, depression or schizophrenia. These findings establish novel autonomous links between blood vessels and the origin of neuropsychiatric disease. Additionally, a role for modulation of vascular/endothelial GABAA receptors emerges as a contributing factor for neuropsychiatric disease origin. Many tranquilizers, sedatives, anesthetics and anti-epileptic drugs used in obstetric medicine modulate GABAA receptor-GABA function. Such treatments during pregnancy may cause problems in developing fetuses. Also, it is possible that altered GABAA receptor expression, altered NKCC1/KCC2 expression and altered chloride concentrations in telencephalic endothelial cells may have direct consequences for angiogenesis and neuronal migration. A 'GABA therapy' might hold significant promise in some cases for the prenatal treatment or prevention of neuropsychiatric diseases. The clinical applications of angiogenesis today benefits millions of patients with cancer, blinding eye diseases, stroke and neurodegeneration58; in a similar way we expect this study to open new doors and accelerate innovative angiogenesis-mediated therapies for neuropsychiatric diseases.
Materials and Methods
Timed pregnant CD1 mice were purchased from Charles River laboratories, MA. Colonies of GAD65-GFP and Tie2-GFP mice were maintained in our institutional animal facility. Tie2-cre mice, Gabrb3 floxed (Gabrb3fl/fl) mice and Vgat floxed (Vgatfl/fl) mice were obtained from Jackson Labs. The Tie2-cre transgene is known for uniform expression of cre-recombinase in endothelial cells during embryogenesis and adulthood59,60,61. To selectively delete Gabrb3 or Vgat in endothelial cells, Tie2-cre transgenic mice (males) were crossed to Gabrb3fl/fl mice (females) to generate Tie2-cre; Gabrb3fl/+ mice (males) or crossed to Vgatfl/fl mice (females) to generate Tie2-cre; Vgatfl/+ mice (males). These were further crossed with Gabrb3fl/fl mice (females) or Vgatfl/fl mice (females) to obtain the Gabrb3 and Vgat conditional knock-outs (Tie2-cre; Gabrb3fl/fl mice or Tie2-cre; Vgatfl/fl mice). The day of plug discovery was designated as embryonic day 0 (E0). Animal experiments were in full compliance with the NIH Guide for Care and Use of Laboratory Animals and were approved by the McLean Institutional Animal Care Committee.
Histology, immunohistochemistry and microscopic analysis
Paraffin IHC and fixed slice IHC was performed on embryonic brains, while frozen section IHC was used on postnatal brains. Briefly, for paraffin IHC — E13, E15 and E17 brains were fixed in zinc fixative (BD Biosciences Pharmingen) for 24 h and processed for paraffin histology. Histological stainings with hematoxylin (Vector Laboratories) and eosin (Sigma) were performed on 8 μm coronal sections. Lectin histochemistry (with biotinylated isolectin B4, 1:50, Sigma) as well as IHC was performed on 20 μm sections. Primary antibodies used for IHC were as follows: anti-CD31/PECAM-1 (1:50, BD Biosciences Pharmingen), anti-GAD65/67 (1:50, Millipore), anti-GABRB3 (1:50; Sigma), anti-VGAT (1:100, Synaptic Systems), anti-PHH3 (1:200, Millipore), anti-MAP2 (1:50, Sigma), anti-TBR1 and TBR2 (1:100, Abcam), anti-Ki67 (1:30, Sigma) and anti-TH (1:200, Millipore) followed by secondary detection with AlexaFluor conjugates (Invitrogen). DAPI (Vector Laboratories) was used to label nuclei. For slice preparations and IHC, brains from E13 and E15 embryos were collected and fixed in 4% paraformaldehyde at 4°C. Vibratome slices (50 μm) were prepared and incubated in anti-biotinylated isolectin B4 (1:40, Sigma) with 1% TritonX-100 at 4 οC overnight. After six washes in phosphate buffered saline (PBS), slices were incubated with secondary antibody (Alexa 594 streptavidin conjugate) for 6 h at 4 οC, washed and mounted. For frozen section IHC, P30 and P90 brains were removed, fixed in 4% PFA for 24 h, cryo-protected in sucrose gradient, embedded into frozen blocks; sectioned at 40 μm on a cryostat and immunostained with anti-isolectin B4 (1:50, Sigma), anti-GABA (1:400, Sigma), anti-calretinin (1:200; Swant), anti-somatostatin (1:2 000; Bachem), anti-NPY (1:1 000, Millipore), anti-parvalbumin (1:200, Immunostar), anti-caspase (1:200, Millipore) and anti-VGLUT1 (1:200, Synaptic Systems) antibodies. Twenty sections from each brain were used for IHC and histology experiments. Uniform penetration of antibodies or stains throughout the section was ascertained and quality of the staining in each digital section was examined. Only those sections which showed uniform labeling were included in further analysis. All low- and high-magnification images were obtained from an FSX100 microscope (Olympus).
A stereological point grid was superimposed on digital images of biotinylated isolectin-B4+ vessels using ImageJ software. The ratio between points falling on blood vessels and on brain tissue was calculated for each section, and average values were obtained for four specific cortical regions: cingulate, somatosensory and piriform (at bregma levels 1.5, 0.5 and −1.5), and motor (at bregma levels (1.5 and 0.5) using stereotaxic coordinates62.
Profiles of GABA+ immunoreactive cells were counted in the four areas of cortex: cingulate, somatosensory and piriform (at bregma levels 1.5, 0.5 and −1.5), and motor (at bregma levels (1.5, 0.5) using stereotaxic coordinates62. Profiles of GABA subtype immunoreactive cells were counted in the somatosensory cortex (at bregma level 0.5). For each area, cells in the strip of cortex from the pial surface to the white-gray matter interface was counted using ImageJ software and plotted. Details of sample size evaluation are provided in 'statistical analysis' and sample sizes are provided in figure legends.
Lectin perfusion and immunohistochemistry
Prior to killing and tissue harvest, animals were injected retroorbitally with 100 μl Fluorescein-labeled Lycopersicon Esculentum (Tomato) Lectin solution (Vector laboratories) over 2 min. About 5 min after completion of the lectin injection, whole mouse brains were harvested after intracardiac perfusion with 4% paraformaldehyde in PBS. Tissue was then fixed overnight in 4% paraformaldehyde/PBS, embedded in paraffin, and mounted on glass slides in 10-μm thick sections. Prior to IHC, tissue was deparaffinized and antigen retrieval was performed in a pH 9 solution (DAKO) at 96 °C. To prevent non-specific staining, sections were incubated with 5% normal donkey serum in PBS prior to incubation with an anti-CD31 mAb (1:20, Dianova), followed by secondary detection with a fluorescent antibody (Jackson ImmunoResearch). All image analyses were performed using ImageJ software. In brief, CD31-positive images were thresholded using an automatic ImageJ thresholding function, binary images generated, and CD31+ vessel ROIs (region of interests) generated. For MVD measurements, this number was correlated with the analyzed tissue area to compute micro vessel density. Vessel diameter was analyzed by selectively measuring the Feret's diameter in only elongated vessels. For lectin measurements63, the CD31 ROIs were overlayed over binary images from the lectin channel. The area percentage of the lectin positive area in each vessel ROI was measured and the average lectin area per vessel was plotted using the prism software.
Isolation and primary culture of endothelial cells
Embryonic brains were dissected under a stereo microscope and the telencephalon was removed. Pial membranes were peeled out and pooled (pial endothelial cells). The remaining telencephalon without pial membranes was pooled as well (periventricular endothelial cells). Mesencephalon and metencephalon were combined to prepare control endothelial cells. Purity of endothelial cell cultures was established with endothelial cell markers and determined to be 100%11,27. Isolation and culture of endothelial cells of the three sets were performed according to published methodology11,27.
Endothelial cell stainings, transwell assay, long-distance cell migration and chemoattraction assays
Periventricular endothelial cells were prepared from CD1 (wild type), Tie2-GFP, Gabrb3fl/fl, Gabrb3ECKO, Vgatfl/fl and VgatECKO embryos. Endothelial cells were labeled with the following primary antibodies: anti-biotinylated isolectin B4 (1:40, Sigma), anti-GABA (1:400, Sigma), anti-GABRB3 (1:200; Sigma), anti-VGAT (1:200, Millipore), anti-KCC2 (1:400, Sigma), anti-NKCC1 (1:400, Millipore), anti-GAD65/67 (1:400, Millipore) followed by secondary detection with AlexaFluor conjugates (Invitrogen). DAPI (Invitrogen) was used to label nuclei. Images were taken on an FSX100 microscope (Olympus). One million cells were examined for each IHC condition.
Transwell assay Endothelial cell migration was evaluated in 24-well transwell chambers (8-μm pore size; Corning, Lowell, MA, USA). The cells were labeled with Qdot nanocrystals (Thermo Fisher Scientific) and seeded into the upper chamber at 5 × 105 cells/well. The bottom chamber was filled with serum-supplemented endothelial cell culture medium to serve as a chemoattractant. Cells were incubated at 37 °C for 24 h in a humidified incubator containing 5% CO2. Cells that migrated through the membrane were fixed, imaged and the number of cells from five different fields (upper, lower, right, left and center) of view was quantified to get an average sum of cells that migrated through the membrane and quantified.
Long-distance cell migration assay In preparation for cell migration assays, square culture inserts (ibidi GmbH) were placed along the entire diameter of a 35 mm dish to create a long track. Cultures of endothelial cells were plated throughout the track while E15 GE-derived GAD65-GFP+ neurons were plated at one end of the track. Endothelial cells were labeled with cell trace marker (CellLight Plasma Membrane-RFP, BacMam 2.0, Invitrogen) to visualize endothelial cell morphologies during subsequent imaging. The co-culture was maintained for 24 h in FCS-DMEM (Invitrogen). The migration of neurons on endothelial cells from one end of the dish to the other spanning a distance of 3.5 cm was imaged and quantified.
Chemoattraction assay To prepare explants for chemoattraction assays, the GE region was micro-dissected from GAD65-GFP+ve brains and further trimmed into blocks of equal size, respectively. Individual explants were plated on Vgatfl/fl or VgatECKO periventricular endothelial cell cultures labeled with CellLight Plasma Membrane-RFP (Invitrogen). The co-culture was maintained for 24 h in FCS-DMEM (Invitrogen). The chemoattractive responses of GFP+ve cells from the explant toward endothelial cells in each experiment were imaged and analyzed.
Immunofluorescence for claudin 5 and IgG were performed on 40 μm cryo sections with anti-claudin 5 (1:200, Thermo Fisher), anti-mouse IgG antibody (1:200, Molecular Probes) and anti-ZO1 (1:400, Thermo Fisher), respectively. For double-fluorescence labeling for IgG and isolectin B4, cryo sections (10 μm) were first incubated with anti-biotinylated isolectin B4 antibody (1:100, Sigma) at room temperature for 1 h. Subsequently, they were incubated with secondary antibody, streptavidin-conjugated Alexa 488 at room temperature for 30 min. After being washed in PBS, they were then incubated with goat anti-mouse IgG antibody coupled to Alexa Fluor 594 (Molecular Probes) at a dilution of 1:200 for 30 min. Finally, they were examined in an FSX100 microscope. Trans-cardiac perfusion of E18 embryos was performed with 3 kDa biotinylated dextran (0.15 mg/ml, Invitrogen), tissue sections were stained with streptavidin Alexa 594 and fluorescence in tissue sections was quantified by ImageJ software. Perfusions and analysis was done blinded to genotype.
In vivo bromodeoxyuridine labeling
A single BrdU injection (50 μg/g) was administered to pregnant dams carrying E13 mice. Embryonic brains were removed at E17, immersed in zinc fixative (BD Biosciences Pharmingen) for 24 h, and processed for paraffin wax histology. BrdU IHC (fluorescence and DAB) was performed on coronal, 8 μm sections. Double labeling was performed with a mouse monoclonal antibody to BrdU (1:75, BD Biosciences Pharmingen) and a rabbit polyclonal antibody to LHX6 (1:100, Sigma).
Mice were housed in our animal facility with a 12 h light cycle with ad libitum access to food and water. Offspring stayed with their mothers until weaning at PND 21 after which males and females were separated. Before all behavioral testing, mice were acclimated to the testing room for 1 h. Behavioral assays were performed according to established protocols referenced here: nest building with nestlets64, nest building with shredded paper65, self-grooming66, light-dark box22, tail suspension test67, tube dominance test68, three chamber social interaction test69 and buried food test70. Both males and females were used for all behavioral assays. Developmental milestones and social recognition tests were conducted with several cohorts of pre-weanling pups. Experimenters scoring behaviors were blinded to the genotypes. Sample sizes for each assay are noted in figure legends.
Electrophysiological recordings, calcium imaging and BrdU assay
Cultured mouse E15 periventricular endothelial cells and cortical neuronal cells plated on 10 mm glass cover slips were placed inside a 35 mm culture dish with cover glass bottom (WPI FD35 FluoroDish) and continuously perfused with an extracellular solution at a rate of 2 ml/min. The extracellular solution contained 150 mM NaCl, 2.5 mM KCl, 2 mM CaCl2, 10 mM HEPES, 10 mM glucose, pH 7.3. Membrane currents were recorded by whole-cell configuration of the patch clamp technique using a List EPC7 amplifier (Medical System), at room temperature and at a holding potential of −70 mV. The intracellular solution used contained 140 mM potassium gluconate, 10 mM NaCl, 2 mM MgCl2, 10 mM HEPES, 1 mM EGTA, 4 mM Mg-ATP, 0.3 mM Na-GTP, pH 7.3. With this set of recording solutions, the chloride reversal potential (E-Cl−) was −61.8 mV at 24 °C. Data were filtered digitally at 2 KHz and acquired at 5 KHz by an Axon Instrument digitizer (Digidata 1322B) with pClamp 9 software using a Dell computer. Muscimol (Sigma) was applied with a puffer pipette (∼1 μm pore diameter) close to the cell (∼20 μm) by pressure ejection with a Picospritzer (General Valve). BMI (Sigma) was applied by bath perfusion. Drugs were kept at −20° as concentrated stock solutions and diluted on the day of the experiment.
For Ca2+ assays, E15 periventricular endothelial cells (1 million cells per assay) were incubated with Ca2+ indicator dye FluoForte AM according to manufacturer's instructions (Enzo Life Sciences), loaded into the chamber of an FSX100 microscope and imaged continuously before and after muscimol application. Fluorescence micrographs were digitalized and results were expressed as change in fluorescence over baseline fluorescence.
To test for cell proliferation, E15 periventricular endothelial cells (1 million cells per experiment) were incubated in the presence of the mitotic marker 5-bromo-2′-deoxyuridine (0.05% BrdU) for 1 h with or without muscimol to examine the impact on proliferation of these cells and processed for BrdU IHC.
Hippocampal slice recordings
Procedures for recordings were as described earlier71. In brief, mice were anesthetized with diethylether, and decapitated. The brain was gently removed and shortly immersed in ice-cold dissection solution (containing, in mM: 125 NaCl, 26 NaHCO3, 3 KCl, 1.25 NaH2PO4, 0.2 CaCl2, 5 MgCl2 and 13 glucose). All solutions were equilibrated with 5% CO2/95% O2 to yield a pH of 7.4. Horizontal slices of ventral hippocampus (400 μm) were cut on a vibratome (Leica) and stored in a chamber filled with artificial cerebrospinal fluid (ACSF) containing (in mM) 125 NaCl, 26 NaHCO3, 3 KCl, 1.25, NaH2PO4, 2.5 CaCl2, 1.3 MgCl2 and 13 glucose. Then, slices were gradually brought to room temperature and allowed to recover for at least 60 min before recording. Generally, 2-4 slices per animal were used. For electrophysiological recordings, slices were transferred to an interface recording chamber perfused with ACSF (at 32 °C). Field potential recordings were obtained from the stratum radiatum of CA1 subfield using glass micropipettes (1 MΩ) filled with ACSF (DC recording, filtered at 2 kHz using EXT 10C amplifier, npi, Tamm, Germany). Epileptiform activity was induced by replacing ACSF with a bath solution containing 6 mM KCl and 0 mM MgCl2 (the remainder was composed as above).
Gene expression profile analysis
RNA was extracted from E18 Vgatfl/fl and VgatECKO telencephalon using the PicoPure RNA Isolation Kit (Arcturus). RNA quality was determined and microarray hybridization was performed on Mouse Gene ST-2.0 gene chips (Affymetrix) at the Dana Farber Cancer Institute, Molecular Biology Core Facilities, Boston, MA, USA. For group comparison heat maps, expression levels were normalized with the SCAN method. Heat map visualization was conducted using Morpheus (Broad Institute, Boston, MA, USA) and ranked by t-test statistics. For gene network and CDT analysis, expression levels were normalized with the RMS method. The AltAnalyze pipeline was used to perform the Go-Elite analysis with 1.5-fold expression and 0.1 Fischer exact test as threshold parameters. CDT visualization was composed using Tableau 9.0 (Tableau, Seattle, WA, USA). MTRR CTD analysis and TPH1 CTD analysis were performed to classify genes according to disease categories. The analysis was performed according to established methodology: AltAnalyze72, SCAN73, RMS74 and CDT75.
RT was performed by using transcriptor first-strand cDNA Synthesis Kit (Roche Diagnostic). PCR reactions were run on an ABI Prism 7500 (Applied Biosystems) sequence detection system platform. Taqman primers with 6-carboxyfluorescein probe for VegfA, Flk1, Flt1, Notch1, Dll4, Wnt7a, Wnt7b and Frizzled6 were obtained from Applied Biosystems. The house keeping gene β2 microglobulin was used as a control. The relative gene expression among different samples and subsequent fold increase in periventricular versus pial endothelial cells was determined according to published methodology76.
Periventricular endothelial cells were prepared and seeded in 12 well culture plates at 0.1 × 106 cells/well. Supernatants from endothelial cell cultures were collected after 96 h and stored at −80 °C for ELISA. GABA concentrations were quantitatively determined by competitive ELISA according to manufacturer's protocol (GABA Research ELISA Kits, Labor Diagnostica Nord, Germany), and absorbance was measured using a multiplate microplate fluorescence reader (Molecular Devices, CA, USA) at 450 nm.
Golgi impregnation and morphological analysis
Vgatfl/fl and VgatECKO brains (P25) were shipped to Neurodigitech for Golgi impregnation. Serial coronal sections (120-μm thickness) were prepared that covered the anterior-to-posterior axis of the cerebral cortex. The somatosensory cortex was analyzed using stereology-based software (NeuroLucida, v10, Microbrightfield, VT), installed on a Dell PC workstation that controlled a Zeiss Axioplan 2 image microscope with an Optronics MicroFire CCD camera (1 600 × 1 200) with motorized X, Y and Z-focus for high-resolution image acquisition and digital quantitation.
For each experiment, we used samples collected from either 1 or 2 embryos of the same genotype or postnatal mice from a given litter. We used 4-10 litters of mice for each prenatal experiment and 3-10 litters of mice for each postnatal experiment. Thus, we used data from 8 to 10 individuals (n = 8 or 10) per prenatal condition and data from 6 to 10 individuals (n = 6, 8 or 10) per postnatal condition. For behavioral experiments, 8-16 litters of mice were used. Statistical significance of differences between groups was analyzed by either two-tailed Student's t-test (Prism; GraphPad software) or ANOVA and post hoc tests and has been noted in individual figure legends. Significance was reported at P < 0.05.
Competing Financial Interests
The authors declare no competing financial interests.
This work was supported by a National Alliance for Research on Schizophrenia and Depression (NARSAD) Independent Investigator Award from the Brain and Behavior Research Foundation (BBRF) to AV and grants from the National Institute of Mental Health (R01MH110438) and National Institute of Neurological Disorders and Stroke (R01NS073635) to AV. SS was supported by a NARSAD Young Investigator Award from BBRF. RKJ and JK's contributions were supported by grants from the National Cancer Institute (P01CA080124 and R35CA197743) to RKJ. JK was supported by fellowships from the German Research Foundation (DFG) and the Solidar-Immun Foundation.
Movie depicts movements of a VgatECKO mouse and a littermate control.
(Supplementary information is linked to the online version of the paper on the Cell Research website.)
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 Unported License. The images or other third party material in this article are included in the article's Creative Commons license, unless indicated otherwise in the credit line; if the material is not included under the Creative Commons license, users will need to obtain permission from the license holder to reproduce the material. To view a copy of this license, visit http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/