Cytokinin is a critical growth regulator for various aspects of plant growth and development. In Arabidopsis, cytokinin signaling is mediated by a two-component system-based phosphorelay that transmits a signal from the receptors, through histidine phosphotransfer proteins, to the downstream response regulators (ARRs). Of these ARRs, type-A ARR genes, whose transcription can be rapidly induced by cytokinin, act as negative regulators of cytokinin signaling. However, because of functional redundancy, the function of type-A ARR genes in plant growth and development is not well understood by analyzing loss-of-function mutants. In this study, we performed a comparative functional study on all ten type-A ARR genes by analyzing transgenic plants overexpressing these ARR genes fused to a MYC epitope tag. Overexpression of ARR genes results in a variety of cytokinin-associated phenotypes. Notably, overexpression of different ARR transgenes causes diverse phenotypes, even between phylogenetically closely-related gene pairs, such as within the ARR3-ARR4 and ARR5-ARR6 pairs. We found that the accumulation of a subset of ARR proteins (ARR3, ARR5, ARR7, ARR16 and ARR17; possibly ARR8 and ARR15) is increased by MG132, a specific proteasomal inhibitor, indicating that stability of these proteins is regulated by proteasomal degradation. Moreover, similar to that of previously characterized ARR5, ARR6 and ARR7, stability of ARR16 and ARR17, possibly including ARR8 and ARR15, is regulated by cytokinin. These results suggest that type-A ARR proteins are regulated by a combinatorial mechanism involving both the cytokinin and proteasome pathways, thereby executing distinctive functions in plant growth and development.
Cytokinin is a classical phytohormone that plays important roles in many aspects of plant growth and development. Cytokinin regulates embryo and seed development, stem-cell specification, shoot and root development, flowering time, leaf senescence and the circadian clock. Generally, it is believed that cytokinin acts to stimulate cell division and cell differentiation 1, 2. In Arabidopsis thaliana, genetic and biochemical studies have defined major components of the cytokinin signaling pathway. According to our current understanding, cytokinin signaling is transduced through a phosphorelay based on a two-component system (TCS). In Arabidopsis, the TCS mainly consists of Histidine Kinases (AHKs), Histidine Phosphotransfer Proteins (AHPs) and Response Regulators (ARRs) 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8. Three AHKs, AHK2, 3 and 4, have been characterized as cytokinin receptors, of which AHK4 has also been known as CYTOKININ RESPONSE 1 (CRE1) or WOODEN LEG (WOL) 9, 10, 11, 12, 13, 14. In the presence of cytokinin, the receptors are autophosphorylated at a conserved His residue and then transfer the phosphoryl group to a conserved Asp residue 12, 15. This phosphoryl group is subsequently transferred to a conserved His residue of AHP proteins, which consist of five members named AHP1 through AHP5. Upon phosphorylation, AHPs are rapidly shuttled from the cytoplasm into the nucleus, where ARR proteins are activated upon receiving a phosphoryl group from AHPs 16, 17, 18, 19. When type-B ARRs, a class of MYB-type transcription factors, receive the phosphoryl group from AHPs, they activate expression of downstream type-A ARR genes. Type-A ARRs, in turn, act to repress the activity of type-B ARRs by a negative feedback mechanism 4, 5, 18, 20.
In the Arabidopsis genome, 24 ARR genes have been identified, which were mainly classified into two groups based on their expression patterns, structures and possible functions of the encoded proteins 21, 22, 23, 24, 25. Type-B ARRs, including ARR1, 2, 10∼14, 18∼21 and 23, contain a receiver domain and a long C-terminal extension carrying a DNA-binding domain named GARP 23, 24, 26. Mutations in single type-B ARR genes do not show apparent phenotype, whereas multiple mutants show reduced sensitivities to cytokinin and a variety of developmental defects, suggesting that this group of transcription factor genes functions redundantly 27, 28, 29, 30. Moreover, overexpression of a dominant transcriptional repressor ARR1-SRDK results in the suppression of most, if not all, activities of type-B ARR genes, which consequently causes a cytokinin-deficiency phenotype 31. Similarly, induced ubiquitous expression of the dominant transcriptional repressor ARR10-EAR in early embryogenesis causes defective pattern formation 32. Conversely, overexpression of several type-B ARR genes results in typical cytokinin responses 20, 33, 34. These observations indicate that type-B ARR genes function as positive regulators of cytokinin signaling.
Type-A ARR proteins, including 10 typical members (ARR3∼9, 15∼17) and 2 atypical members (ARR22 and 24), contain a receiver domain at the N-terminal region and a short variable extension at the C-terminal region 23, 24. Typical type-A ARR genes are primary responsive genes in cytokinin signaling, and their expression can be rapidly induced by cytokinin in the absence of de novo protein synthesis 35, 36. A major function of type-A ARR proteins is to act as negative regulators of cytokinin signaling by repressing type-B ARRs via unknown mechanisms. In addition, type-A ARR genes have also been shown to play multiple roles in plant growth and development. For example, ARR3, ARR4 and ARR9 are involved in the regulation of the circadian rhythm 37, 38, 39. ARR4 acts as a molecular node integrating light and cytokinin signaling by interacting with red light receptor phytochrome B 40. ARR5, ARR6, ARR7 and ARR15 are repressed by WUSCHEL to control meristem development 41. ARR7 and ARR15 are also shown to be positively regulated by auxin and play a role in root stem-cell niche specification 32. However, little is known about the biochemical mechanism of the type-A ARR protein activity.
A challenge in genetic studies on ARR has been encountered by functional redundancy among those genes. Most, if not all, mutations in single type-A ARR genes do not cause obvious abnormalities and altered responses to cytokinin. In a remarkable effort, Kieber and coworkers 42 have generated multiple mutants of type-A ARR genes, most of which, including a hextuple mutant (arr3, 4, 5, 6, 8, 9), exhibited only minor differences compared with wild-type plants under normal growth conditions. As an alternative approach, analysis of the gain-of-function phenotype has yielded valuable information on the function of type-A ARR genes. Overexpression of several type-A ARR genes causes reduced sensitivity to cytokinin in root elongation and shoot formation assays or an early flowering phenotype 43, 44, 45, 46. Interestingly, several type-A ARR proteins have been found to be stabilized by cytokinin in a phosphorelay-dependent manner, thus uncovering an additional regulatory mechanism of cytokinin signaling 46. In this study, we performed a genome-wide analysis of all type-A ARR genes by the generation and characterization of transgenic Arabidopsis plants overexpressing individual type-A ARR genes. We found that the type-A ARR genes show distinctive functions in plant growth and development, and that stability of some type-A ARR proteins is likely regulated by cytokinin and proteasome machinery. These results provide new insight into the regulatory mechanism of cytokinin signaling.
Generation of transgenic Arabidopsis plants overexpressing type-A ARR genes
To facilitate functional analysis, we have generated transgenic plants overexpressing type-A ARR genes (ARR3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 15, 16 and 17). cDNA fragments containing respective coding sequences of individual ARR genes were obtained by reverse transcription (RT)-PCR, in which the stop codons were removed during PCR. The cDNA fragments were fused in-frame to a 6 X MYC epitope tag, and the ARR-MYC fusion genes were placed under the control of a CaMV 35S promoter. The resulting constructs were transformed into wild-type (Columbia-0, Col-0) plants. For each construct, at least five independent transgenic lines were initially analyzed in the T2 generation, and then at least two representative lines (homozygous T3 or T4 plants) were used in all experiments described below. Representative results obtained from one set of transgenic lines are presented in this report and a part of results obtained from an independent set of transgenic lines are included in the Supplementary Data. In these transgenic lines, respective transgenes showed a variety of expression levels as revealed by RT-PCR (Figure 1A). For conciseness, hereafter we refer to these transgenic lines as ARR-overexpression or ARR-OX lines.
Distinctive phenotypes of type-A ARR-OX transgenic plants
Under normal growth conditions, ARR-OX transgenic plants showed a variety of phenotypes. The primary root length of ARR3-OX, ARR4-OX, ARR5-OX, ARR16-OX and ARR17-OX plants was significantly longer than that of wild type (P < 0.01), and other transgenic plants showed a marginal phenotype (Figures 1B and 1C; Supplementary information, Figure S1A). In these transgenic lines, ARR3-OX, ARR16-OX and ARR17-OX showed relatively stronger phenotype in primary root growth, with root length over 30% (ARR3-OX) and 20% (ARR16-OX and ARR17-OX) longer than that of wild-type plants (Figure 1C).
Overexpression of type-A ARR genes substantially affected lateral root development, as most ARR-OX plants (except ARR4-OX, ARR5-OX and ARR7-OX) had more lateral roots than wild-type plants (P < 0.01) (Figure 2). Again, the ARR3-OX transgenic plants showed the strongest phenotype with 60% more lateral roots than wild-type plants (Figure 2). ARR16-OX and ARR17-OX also had substantially more lateral roots (∼40%) than wild-type plants (Figure 2). Notably, whereas ARR4-OX and ARR5-OX showed a similar phenotype as wild-type plants in lateral root development, both transgenic lines however had longer primary roots (Figures 1C and 2). Collectively, these results suggest that type-A ARR genes have overlapped functions in root development, but may employ distinctive mechanisms to regulate development of primary roots and lateral roots.
Most ARR-OX plants, except ARR5-OX and ARR15-OX, flowered earlier than wild type when grown under continuous white light (P < 0.01) (Figure 3 and Supplementary information, Figure S2). Similar observations were made in the previous studies on ARR4-OX, ARR8-OX and ARR7-OX transgenic plants 43, 45. In contrast to their dominant roles in root development, ARR3-OX and ARR16-OX transgenics showed a moderate phenotype in the flowering time. Instead, ARR4-OX and ARR7-OX, which showed a weak or a wild-type-like phenotype in root development (see above), had a more profound effect on the control of the flowering time. Among all the tested transgenics, ARR4-OX plants showed the strongest early flowering phenotype (Figure 3 and Supplementary information, Figure S2), consistent with its role in the regulation of light signaling 37, 38, 40. The ARR17-OX transgenic plants showed relatively strong phenotype in both root development and the flowering time (Figures 1B, 2 and 3). Therefore, as summarized in Table 1, the function of type-A ARR genes is partially overlapped and, on the other hand, also shows a gene-specific pattern during plant growth and development (see Discussion).
Type-A ARR-OX transgenic plants show reduced sensitivity to cytokinin in root growth
We examined the sensitivity of ARR-OX transgenic plants to cytokinin in several assays, focusing on the regulatory roles of these response regulators in cytokinin-mediated growth and development. External application of cytokinin inhibits primary root elongation. When treated with cytokinin, all ARR-OX transgenic plants had longer primary roots than wild-type plants (Figure 1D and Supplementary information, Figure S1B). Under our assay conditions, treatment with 0.05 and 5 μM benzyladenine (BA) caused more than 50% and 85% inhibition of primary root elongation in wild-type plants, respectively (Figure 4 and Supplementary information, Figure S3). Primary root elongation of ARR-OX transgenic plants showed reduced sensitivity to cytokinin at varying degrees (Figures 1D and 4; Supplementary information, Figure S3). In the presence of 0.05 μM BA, the root length of all the transgenic lines was longer than that of wild type (Figure 1D; P < 0.01). When treated with different concentrations of cytokinin, ARR3-OX, ARR5-OX, ARR6-OX and ARR16-OX transgenic plants had longer primary roots than other ARR-OX transgenic lines (Figure 4 and Supplementary information, Figure S3). Of these four lines, ARR5-OX showed the strongest phenotype, although it had a relatively weak phenotype under normal growth conditions, especially in lateral root development and the flowering time (Figures 2 and 3).
Cytokinin has been known to regulate root xylem development by promoting protoxylem differentiation 47, 48. However, no significant effects on root xylem development were observed in all tested ARR-OX transgenic plants in the absence or the presence of cytokinin (see Supplementary information, Figure S4 for examples). Moreover, an arr3, 4, 5, 6, 8, 9 hextuple mutant 42 did not show detectable abnormalities in root xylem development in the absence or the presence of cytokinin (Supplementary information, Figure S4).
Cytokinin-induced shoot regeneration capacity is compromised in type-A ARR-OX transgenic plants
In vitro shoot formation is a highly specific assay for the cytokinin response 12, 49. We tested the response of hypocotyl explants derived from ARR-OX plants to cytokinin in a shoot regeneration assay. Compared with that of wild type, hypocotyl explants of ARR3-OX, ARR5-OX, ARR6-OX, ARR16-OX and ARR17-OX transgenics were nearly insensitive to cytokinin (2-isopentenyladenine (iPA)), incapable of forming green calli or shoots even under relatively high concentrations of iPA (15 μM) (Figure 5 and Supplementary information, Figure S5). Under the assay condition, ARR15-OX explants showed slightly reduced sensitivity to iPA, whereas other ARR-OX explants (4, 7, 8 and 9) displayed a similar response to iPA as wild type (Figure 5 and Supplementary information, Figure S5).
Dark-induced leaf senescence in type-A ARR-OX plants
Cytokinin is able to delay senescence of detached leaves in the dark. We performed a dark-induced leaf senescence assay of ARR-OX transgenic plants to evaluate possible roles of these genes in cytokinin-regulated leaf senescence. In the absence or the presence of cytokinin, leaves collected from most ARR-OX transgenic plants showed a phenotype similar to that of wild type (ARR3-OX, ARR4-OX and ARR9-OX) or a marginally altered phenotype (ARR5-OX, ARR6-OX, ARR7-OX, ARR8-OX, ARR15-OX and ARR17-OX) (Figure 6A). However, ARR16-OX leaves displayed an early senescence phenotype, and had a substantially reduced response to cytokinin in the dark-induced leaf senescence assay (Figure 6A). To quantitatively analyze the senescence phenotype of ARR16-OX leaves, we measured the chlorophyll level in wild-type and the transgenic leaves (Figure 6B). ARR16-OX leaves contained a slightly lower level of chlorophylls than that of wild type. The dark treatment caused a more rapid loss of chlorophylls in ARR16-OX leaves. When treated with cytokinin, whereas wild-type leaves retained chlorophylls at a similar level as the untreated leaves, ARR16-OX leaves showed substantially reduced response to cytokinin (Figure 6B). This result suggests that ARR16 may be involved in the regulation of cytokinin-controlled leaf senescence.
Analysis of type-A ARR-MYC proteins in transgenic plants
Expression of type-A ARR genes has been shown to be rapidly induced by cytokinin which does not require de novo protein synthesis 35, 36. Constitutive expression of type-A ARR genes by a 35S promoter therefore allows the study of possible posttranslational regulation of ARR proteins. We analyzed individual ARR-MYC proteins by western blot using an anti-MYC monoclonal antibody. Compared with the relatively constant level of mRNA as revealed by RT-PCR (see Figure 1A), ARR-MYC protein levels substantially varied in different transgenic plants, implying the involvement of possible translational or posttranslational controls (see below).
In most cases, we have been able to detect single protein bands that were specific to related transgenic plants and approximately correlated to the predicted molecular weights (MW). In ARR4-OX transgenic lines, however, a protein band with an apparent MW over 50 kD, instead of the predicted MW of ∼37 kD, was specifically detected (Supplementary information, Figure S6). A similar observation has also been made in a previous study (see Figure 2B, 46). Because no other specific band was detected in ARR4-OX transgenic plants, we followed To et al. 46 to presume the ∼50-kD band as ARR4-MYC. In addition, we noticed that two protein bands were reproducibly detected in multiple ARR8-OX, ARR15-OX and ARR17-OX transgenic lines (Figure 7 and Supplementary information, Figure S7). Both bands appeared to be specific to the respective transgenic lines, because similar bands were not detected by the anti-MYC monoclonal antibody in wild-type and other transgenic plants. The lower bands in the ARR8-MYC and ARR15 blots appeared to be correlated to the predicted MW of the respective fusion proteins (approximately 34 and 31 kD, respectively). We speculate that some of these bands may be caused by posttranslational modifications of these proteins, albeit the precise biochemical mechanism of the possible modifications remains to be elucidated.
The accumulation of type-A ARR-MYC proteins is regulated by cytokinin and the proteasome pathway
We found that cytokinin was able to increase the accumulation of ARR8-MYC, ARR15-MYC, ARR16-MYC and ARR17-MYC fusion proteins (Figure 7 and Supplementary information, Figure S7). Stability of ARR5-MYC, ARR6-MYC and ARR7-MYC proteins was also increased by cytokinin, consistent with the observation in a previous study 46. The elevated protein level stimulated by cytokinin in these transgenic lines could be caused by an increased translation rate or increased protein stability, or by a combination of both effects. To distinguish these possibilities, we treated the transgenic plants with the protein synthesis inhibitor cycloheximide (CHX) in the absence or the presence of cytokinin. The CHX treatment significantly reduced the accumulation of ARR8-MYC, ARR15-MYC, ARR16-MYC and ARR17-MYC proteins, indicating that stability of these proteins is regulated. In the presence of CHX, the reduced protein level of ARR16-MYC and ARR17-MYC could be partially rescued by cytokinin (Figure 7 and Supplementary information, Figure S7; lanes CHX vs lanes CHX+BA). These results suggest that cytokinin is capable of stabilizing ARR16-MYC and ARR17-MYC proteins.
ARR8-MYC and ARR15-MYC proteins showed a complicated pattern. In the presence of CHX, the reduced level of the lower bands of ARR8-MYC and ARR15-MYC (see above for explanation) could not be rescued by cytokinin. However, the accumulation of upper bands appeared to be increased upon cytokinin treatment (Figure 7 and Supplementary information, Figure S7; lanes CHX vs lanes CHX+BA). This result suggests that cytokinin may partially stabilize ARR8-MYC and ARR15-MYC proteins.
ARR3-MYC protein did not appear to be regulated by cytokinin (Figure 7 and Supplementary information, Figure S7), showing a phenotype similar to that of ARR4-MYC and ARR9-MYC. Moreover, the ARR3-MYC level was not significantly altered by CHX, indicating that the protein has a relatively longer half-life.
To ask if stability of ARR-MYC proteins is also regulated by the proteasome pathway, we treated the transgenic plants with MG132, a specific proteasomal inhibitor, in the absence or the presence of CHX. We found that ARR3-MYC, ARR5-MYC, ARR7-MYC, ARR16-MYC and ARR17-MYC proteins could be stabilized by MG132, suggesting that stability of these proteins is subjected to regulation by the proteasome pathway (Figure 7 and Supplementary information, Figure S7). Similar to that of the cytokinin treatment, lower bands of ARR8-MYC and ARR15-MYC did not appear to be affected by MG132. However, the upper bands of these two proteins were substantially upregulated by MG132 (Figure 7 and Supplementary information, Figure S7). Levels of ARR4-MYC, ARR6-MYC and ARR9-MYC proteins were only marginally altered by MG132, suggesting that these three proteins may not be significantly regulated by the proteasome pathway. Collectively, these results suggest that stability of ARR proteins is regulated by distinctive mechanisms involving cytokinin regulation and/or proteasomal degradation or both.
Phenotypes of type-A ARR-OX transgenic plants and stability regulation of ARR-MYC proteins are summarized in Table 1.
In Arabidopsis, cytokinin signaling is mediated by a TCS consisting of AHKs, AHPs and ARRs. As an output of the signaling pathway, ARR proteins are the main effectors, by which cytokinin executes its various functions during plant growth and development. Owing to functional redundancy, it is technically difficult to study the function of type-A ARR genes by using loss-of-function mutants 27, 28, 42. In fact, our current understanding of the type-A ARR functions was largely obtained from overexpression studies of several type-A ARR genes 18, 43, 44, 45, 46. In this study, we performed a genome-wide comparative analysis on the function of all type-A ARR genes, aimed at gaining comprehensive and new insights into their functions and regulatory mechanisms.
Redundant and diverse functions of type-A ARR genes in plant growth and development
Most key components in the cytokinin signaling pathway function redundantly, and this redundancy is particularly apparent in genes encoding for receptors, phosphotransfer proteins and response regulators. However, these components also appear to function distinctively in plant growth and development. It has been proposed that different receptors or receptor combinations contribute to distinctive aspects of plant growth and development 11. For instance, CRE1/WOL/AHK4 is predominantly involved in root xylem specification 47, 48, whereas AHK3 plays an important role in the regulation of leaf senescence 50. Likewise, type-A ARR genes may also have overlapped yet distinctive functions in a gene-specific manner to regulate different aspects of plant growth and development. In agreement with this notion, it has been shown that individual or combinations of type-A ARR genes play distinctive roles in the regulation of red light signaling, the circadian clock, meristem development and stem-cell specification (see Introduction for detailed references).
The gene-specific action mode of the functionally redundant type-A ARR genes perhaps could be best exemplified by ARR3 and ARR4. These two genes encode two structurally closely-related proteins that function redundantly to regulate the circadian period in a cytokinin-independent manner 37. ARR4 physically interacts with phytochrome B to regulate red light signaling 40, and possibly circadian clock oscillation as well 38. However, whereas ARR4-OX shows a marginally altered response to cytokinin, ARR3-OX displays substantially reduced response to this phytohormone. Intriguingly, neither cytokinin nor MG132 appears to be able to affect the ARR4-MYC protein level, whereas MG132 can substantially increase the ARR3-MYC protein level (see also below). Collectively, these observations indicate that ARR3 and ARR4, function redundantly in the activity associated with circadian clock oscillation, but execute different functions in other aspects of plant growth and development, which is consistent with the possible involvement of distinctive regulatory mechanisms. A similar pattern can also be noticed for ARR5 and ARR6, which fall into the same phylogenetic branch 51. Overexpression of these two genes, however, causes nearly opposite phenotypes in primary root growth, lateral root development and the flowering time, as well as in the regulation of protein levels by the proteasome pathway (Table 1). These results provide an additional example of diverse functions and regulatory mechanisms of type-A ARR proteins.
It is interesting to note that ARR16, in addition to its role in root growth and shoot regeneration, also affects leaf senescence. It appears that overexpression of ARR16 displays a phenotype stronger than any other type-A ARR-OX transgenics thus far analyzed, suggestive of its important roles in plant growth and development. Despite the relatively strong phenotype of ARR16-OX, an arr16 loss-of-function mutant does not have detectable phenotype under normal growth conditions and shows a normal response to cytokinin (Ren and Zuo, unpublished data), providing an additional line of evidence of functional redundancy of type-A ARR genes.
A major physiological role of cytokinin is to regulate root xylem development. Mutations in AHK, AHP and type-B ARR genes cause reduced protoxylem differentiation 16, 28, 29, 30, 47, 48. However, we could not observe detectable abnormalities in root xylem development in all ARR-OX transgenic lines that were grown in the absence or the presence of cytokinin. One possibility is that overexpression of type-A ARR genes under our experimental conditions is unable to attenuate cytokinin signaling to a sufficiently low level, at which root xylem differentiation may be affected. Alternatively, root xylem development is less sensitive to the intracellular concentrations of individual type-A ARR proteins, owing to functional redundancy or buffering capacity of this family of proteins. This view is supported by the observation that an arr3, 4, 5, 6, 8, 9 hextuple mutant did not show abnormal development of root xylem, although other developmental defects were detectable in the mutant.
Regulation of stability of type-A ARR proteins by cytokinin and proteasome machinery
The discovery of type-A ARR genes was based on their cytokinin-inducibility in the absence of de novo protein synthesis 35, 36. Considering the complexity of cytokinin signaling, it is reasonable to predict additional mechanisms involved in the regulation of the activity of this class of proteins. Recent studies demonstrated that cytokinin is indeed able to stabilize a subset of type-A ARR proteins, including ARR5, ARR6 and ARR7 46. Similarly, we found that stability of other type-A proteins, including ARR16 and ARR17 (possibly ARR8 and ARR15), is also regulated by cytokinin. More importantly, our results revealed an additional mechanism involved in the regulation of ARR proteins. The accumulation of several ARR-MYC proteins can be substantially increased by MG132 in the absence or the presence of de novo protein synthesis, suggesting involvement of the proteasomal degradation in the regulation of these proteins.
It has been noticed that the overall design and action of cytokinin signaling are similar to that of auxin signaling 42, 51. In the auxin signaling pathway, AUX/IAA proteins, encoded by auxin-inducible genes, act to repress the activity of a class of transcription factors, termed as auxin response factors (ARFs). Auxin induces the degradation of the AUX/IAA repressors, thereby derepressing ARFs and consequently activating the signaling pathway 52. Analogously, type-A ARRs repress the activity of type-B ARRs, also a class of transcription factors, and the repression is relieved by cytokinin 4, 18, 51, 53. An attractive model is that type-A ARR proteins, similar to AUX/IAA proteins, are subjected to the regulation by proteasomal degradation, and destruction of the repressive type-A ARR proteins thus leads to the activation of type-B ARRs 42, 51. Consistent with this model, mutations in COP10/FUS9/CIN4 and RPN12, which encode subunits of the 26S proteasome, lead to insensitivity to cytokinin 54, 55, and the reporter activity of an ARR7-luciferase fusion gene is enhanced by MG132 in transiently transformed protoplasts 56. The observation that the accumulation of a subset of type-A ARR proteins is increased by MG132 provides a line of supporting evidence that cytokinin signaling is regulated by a mechanism involving proteasomal degradation of certain type-A ARRs, which may act to derepress type-B ARRs.
It is worthwhile to note that, as implicated from its role in the regulation of red light signaling, the accumulation of ARR4 is induced by white light and red light, but repressed by far-red light in a phytochrome B-dependent manner 40. Thus, it appears that stability of type-A ARR proteins is regulated by diverse mechanisms, involving at least the cytokinin, light and proteasome pathways. These regulatory mechanisms are further complicated by different combinations of the cytokinin and MG132 actions on type-A ARR proteins. As summarized in Table 1, six type-A ARR proteins (ARR5, ARR7, ARR8, ARR15, ARR16 and ARR17) appears to be regulated by both cytokinin and proteasomal degradation. Moreover, whereas ARR3 and ARR6 are sensitive to MG132 and cytokinin, respectively, ARR4 and ARR9 show no response to either reagent. This combinatorial regulatory mechanism likely plays an important role in the control of the ARR activity. Obviously, unraveling the biochemical natures of these regulatory mechanisms, in particular, identification and characterization of E3 ligases specific to type-A ARR proteins, will be crucial toward a better understanding of cytokinin signaling, as well as its roles in plant growth and development.
Materials and Methods
Plant materials and growth conditions
Unless specified, the Columbia-0 (Col-0) accession of Arabidopsis was used in this study. The arr3,4,5,6,8,9 mutant was kindly provided by Dr Joe Kieber 42. Unless otherwise indicated, plants were grown under continuous white light at 22 °C in soil or on Murashige-Skoog (MS) 57 medium (1/2 MS salts, 1% sucrose and 0.8% agar).
Plasmid construction and generation of transgenic lines
Total RNA prepared from different tissues of wild-type plants was used as templates to synthesize the first strand of cDNA using oligo-dT as a primer. The reaction was used to PCR-amplify cDNA sequences corresponding to the coding region (lacking stop codons) of type-A ARR genes using PWO DNA polymerase (Roche Diagnostics Hong Kong, Hong Kong, China), and the resulting PCR fragments were cloned into a pGEM-T easy vector (Promega, Madison, WI, USA). All primers used in PCR are listed in Supplementary information, Table S1. After confirmation by DNA sequencing, the ARR fragments were cloned into the XhoI and EcoRI (or EcoRV) sties of a pSK-c-MYC vector, which contained six copies of a MYC epitope followed by an in-frame stop codon. The ARR-MYC fusion genes were then cloned into the XhoI and SpeI sites of a pBA-0 vector under the control of the CaMV 35S promoter carrying a bialaphos-resistance selectable gene. The resulting constructs were transformed into Agrobacterium tumefaciens strain GV3101, which was then used for the transformation of plants (Col-0) by the floral dip method as described 58.
RNA preparation and RT-PCR
Total RNA was extracted from 10-day-old seedlings with the TRIZol reagent (Invitrogen) according to the manufacturer's instructions. RT-PCR was carried out as previously described 59. The reaction was cycled 24-26 times at 94 °C for 30 s, 58 °C for 30 s and 72 °C for 1 min.
Analysis of cytokinin responses
For root elongation inhibition assay, Arabidopsis seedlings were grown vertically on 1/2 MS agar supplemented with appropriate concentrations of BA or dimethyl sulfoxide. Root length was measured 8 days post germination. The flowering time was measured by counting the rosette leaf numbers at bolting. The shoot formation assay 59 and the dark-induced leaf senescence assay 60 were performed as previously described.
Western blot analysis
Seedlings (2-week-old) were infiltrated in liquid 1/2 MS medium supplemented with, alone or in different combinations (see Figure legends), 200 μM CHX, 50 μM MG132 or 5 μM BA. After the treatment, samples were immediately frozen in liquid nitrogen until the use.
Plant materials were ground in liquid nitrogen into fine powder, and then extracted in 50 mM Tris (pH 7.5), 150 mM NaCl, 10 mM MgCl2, 1× complete protease inhibitors (Roche), 0.1% Nonidet P-40 and 0.5% β-mercaptoethanol. After centrifugation in a microcentrifuge for 10 min, the supernants were mixed with equal volume of loading buffer (250 mM Tris, pH 6.8, 10% SDS, 0.5% bromophenol blue, 50% glycerol and 5% β-mercaptoethanol). After boiling for 5 min, the sample was separated by 12% SDS-PAGE and then transferred onto a Westran Clear Signal polyvinylidene difluoride membrane (Whatman). ARR-MYC fusion proteins were detected with an anti-MYC monoclonal antibody (Santa Cruz, CA, USA) as a primary antibody and goat anti-mouse IgG conjugated with the horseradish peroxidase as a secondary antibody. The signal was detected using the SuperSignal Western Femto Maximun Sensitivity Substrate kit (Pierce Biotechnology), following the manufactures' instructions. Membranes stained by Ponceau S were used as loading controls.
( Supplementary information is linked to the online version of the paper on the Cell Research website.)
Davies PJ . Plant Hormones: Biosythesis, Signal Transduction, Action! 3rd Edition. Dordrecht, The Netherlands: Kluwer Academic Press, 2004.
Mok DW, Mok MC . Cytokinin metabolism and action. Annu Rev Plant Physiol Plant Mol Biol 2001; 52:89–118.
Hwang I, Chen H-C, Sheen J . Two-component signal transduction pathways in Arabidopsis. Plant Physiol 2002; 129:500–515.
Kakimoto T . Perception and signal transduction of cytokinins. Annu Rev Plant Biol 2003; 54:605–627.
To JPC, Kieber JJ . Cytokinin signaling: two-components and more. Trends Plant Sci 2008; 13:85–92.
Heyl A, Schmülling T . Cytokinin signal perception and transduction. Curr Opin Plant Biol 2003; 6:480–488.
Haberer G, Kieber JJ . Cytokinins. New insights into a classic phytohormone. Plant Physiol 2002; 128:354–362.
Müller B, Sheen J . Advances in cytokinin signaling. Science 2007; 318:68–69.
Higuchi M, Pischke MS, Mähönen AP, et al. In planta functions of the Arabidopsis cytokinin receptor family. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 2004; 101:8821–8826.
Nishimura C, Ohashi Y, Sato S, et al. Histidine kinase homologs that act as cytokinin receptors possess overlapping functions in the regulation of shoot and root growth in Arabidopsis. Plant Cell 2004; 16:1365–1377.
Riefler M, Novak O, Strnad M, Schmülling T . Arabidopsis cytokinin receptor mutants reveal functions in shoot growth, leaf senescence, seed size, germination, root development, and cytokinin metabolism. Plant Cell 2006; 18:40–54.
Inoue T, Higuchi M, Hashimoto Y, et al. Identification of CRE1 as a cytokinin receptor from Arabidopsis. Nature 2001; 409:1060–1063.
Suzuki T, Miwa K, Ishikawa K, et al. The Arabidopsis sensor His-kinase, AHK4, can respond to cytokinins. Plant Cell Physiol 2001; 42:107–113.
Yamada H, Suzuki T, Terada K, et al. The Arabidopsis AHK4 histidine kinase is a cytokinin-binding receptor that transduces cytokinin signals across the membrane. Plant Cell Physiol 2001; 42:1017–1023.
Mähönen AP, Higuchi M, Törmäkangas K, et al. Cytokinins regulate a bidirectional phosphorelay network in Arabidopsis. Curr Biol 2006; 16:1116–1122.
Hutchison CE, Li J, Argueso C, et al. The Arabidopsis histidine phosphotransfer proteins are redundant positive regulators of cytokinin signaling. Plant Cell 2006; 18:3073–3087.
Suzuki T, Sakurai K, Imamura A, et al. Compilation and characterization of histidine-containing phosphotransmitters implicated in His-to-Asp phosphorelay in plants: AHP signal transducers of Arabidopsis thaliana. Biosci Biotechnol Biochem 2000; 64:2486–2489.
Hwang I, Sheen J . Two-component circuitry in Arabidopsis cytokinin signal transduction. Nature 2001; 413:383–389.
Suzuki T, Imamura A, Ueguchi C, Mizuno T . Histidine-containing phosphotransfer (HPt) signal transducers implicated in His-to-Asp phosphorelay in Arabidopsis. Plant Cell Physiol 1998; 39:1258–1268.
Sakai H, Honma T, Aoyama T, et al. ARR1, a transcription factor for genes immediately responsive to cytokinins. Science 2001; 294:1519–1521.
Nakamura A, Kakimoto T, Imamura A, et al. Biochemical characterization of a putative cytokinin-responsive His-kinase, CKI1, from Arabidopsis thaliana. Biosci Biotechnol Biochem 1999; 63:1627–1630.
Kiba T, Aoki K, Sakakibara H, Mizuno T . Arabidopsis Response Regulator, ARR22, ectopic expression of which results in phenotypes similar to the wol cytokinin-receptor mutant. Plant Cell Physiol 2004; 45:1063–1077.
D'Agostino IB, Deruere J, Kieber JJ . Characterization of the response of the Arabidopsis response regulator gene family to cytokinin. Plant Physiol 2000; 124:1706–1717.
D'Agostino IB, Kieber JJ . Phosphorelay signal transduction: the emerging family of plant response regulators. Trends Biochem Sci 1999; 24:452–456.
Mason MG, Li J, Mathews DE, Kieber JJ, Schaller GE . Type-B response regulators display overlapping expression patterns in Arabidopsis. Plant Physiol 2004; 135:927–937.
Sakai H, Aoyama T, Oka A . Arabidopsis ARR1 and ARR2 response regulators operate as transcriptional activators. Plant J 2000; 24:703–711.
Mason MG, Mathews DE, Argyros DA, et al. Multiple type-B response regulators mediate cytokinin signal transduction in Arabidopsis. Plant Cell 2005; 17:3007–3018.
Yokoyama A, Yamashino T, Amano Y, et al. Type-B ARR transcription factors, ARR10 and ARR12, are implicated in cytokinin-mediated regulation of protoxylem differentiation in roots of Arabidopsis thaliana. Plant Cell Physiol 2007; 48:84–96.
Ishida K, Yamashino T, Yokoyama A, Mizuno T . Three type-B response regulators, ARR1, ARR10 and ARR12, play essential but redundant roles in cytokinin signal transduction throughout the life cycle of Arabidopsis thaliana. Plant Cell Physiol 2008; 49:47–57.
Argyros RD, Mathews DE, Chiang YH, et al. Type B response regulators of Arabidopsis play key roles in cytokinin signaling and plant development. Plant Cell 2008; 20:2102–2116.
Heyl A, Ramireddy E, Brenner WG, et al. The transcriptional repressor ARR1-SRDX suppresses pleiotropic cytokinin activities in Arabidopsis. Plant Physiol 2008; 147:1380–1395.
Müller B, Sheen J . Cytokinin and auxin interaction in root stem-cell specification during early embryogenesis. Nature 2008; 453:1094–1097.
Tajima Y, Imamura A, Kiba T, et al. Comparative studies on the type-B response regulators revealing their distinctive properties in the His-to-Asp phosphorelay signal transduction of Arabidopsis thaliana. Plant Cell Physiol 2004; 45:28–39.
Imamura A, Kiba T, Tajima Y, Yamashino T, Mizuno T . In vivo and in vitro characterization of the ARR11 response regulator implicated in the His-to-Asp phosphorelay signal transduction in Arabidopsis thaliana. Plant Cell Physiol 2003; 44:122–131.
Brandstatter I, Kieber JJ . Two genes with similarity to bacterial response regulators are rapidly and specifically induced by cytokinin in Arabidopsis. Plant Cell 1998; 10:1009–1019.
Imamura A, Hanaki N, Umeda H, et al. Response regulators implicated in His-to-Asp phosphotransfer signaling in Arabidopsis. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 1998; 95:2691–2696.
Salome PA, To JPC, Kieber JJ, McClung CR . Arabidopsis response regulators ARR3 and ARR4 play cytokinin-independent roles in the control of circadian period. Plant Cell 2006; 18:55–69.
Zheng B, Deng Y, Mu J, et al. Cytokinin affects circadian-clock oscillation in a phytochrome B- and Arabidopsis Response Regulator 4-dependent manner. Physiol Plant 2006; 127:277–292.
Ishida K, Yamashino T, Mizuno T . Expression of the cytokinin-induced type-A response regulator gene ARR9 is regulated by the circadian clock in Arabidopsis thaliana. Biosci Biotechnol Biochem 2008; 72:3025–3029.
Sweere U, Eichenberg K, Lohrmann J, et al. Interaction of the response regulator ARR4 with phytochrome B in modulating red light signaling. Science 2001; 294:1108–1111.
Leibfried A, To JP, Busch W, et al. WUSCHEL controls meristem function by direct regulation of cytokinin-inducible response regulators. Nature 2005; 438:1172–1175.
To JPC, Haberer G, Ferreira FJ, et al. Type-A Arabidopsis response regulators are partially redundant negative regulators of cytokinin signaling. Plant Cell 2004; 16:658–671.
Lee DJ, Park JY, Ku SJ, et al. Genome-wide expression profiling of ARABIDOPSIS RESPONSE REGULATOR 7 (ARR7) overexpression in cytokinin response. Mol Genet Genomics 2007; 277:115–137.
Kiba T, Yamada H, Sato S, et al. The type-A response regulator, ARR15, acts as a negative regulator in the cytokinin-mediated signal transduction in Arabidopsis thaliana. Plant Cell Physiol 2003; 44:868–874.
Osakabe Y, Miyata S, Urao T, et al. Overexpression of Arabidopsis response regulators, ARR4/ATRR1/IBC7 and ARR8/ATRR3, alters cytokinin responses differentially in the shoot and in callus formation. Biochem Biophys Res Commun 2002; 293:806–815.
To JPC, Deruere J, Maxwell BB, et al. Cytokinin regulates type-A Arabidopsis response regulator activity and protein stability via two-component phosphorelay. Plant Cell 2007; 19:3901–3914.
Mähönen AP, Bonke M, Kauppinen L, et al. A novel two-component hybrid molecule regulates vascular morphogenesis of the Arabidopsis root. Genes Dev 2000; 14:2938–2943.
Mähönen AP, Bishopp A, Higuchi M, et al. Cytokinin signaling and its inhibitor AHP6 regulate cell fate during vascular development. Science 2006; 311:94–98.
Kakimoto T . CKI1, a histidine kinase homolog implicated in cytokinin signal transduction. Science 1996; 274:982–985.
Kim HJ, Ryu H, Hong SH, et al. Cytokinin-mediated control of leaf longevity by AHK3 through phosphorylation of ARR2 in Arabidopsis. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 2006; 103:814–819.
Hutchison CE, Kieber JJ . Cytokinin signaling in Arabidopsis. Plant Cell 2002; 14:S47–S59.
Reed JW . Roles and activities of AUX/IAA proteins in Arabidopsis. Trends Plant Sci 2001; 6:420–425.
Ferreira FJ, Kieber JJ . Cytokinin signaling. Curr Opin Plant Biol 2005; 8:518–525.
Smalle J, Kurepa J, Yang P, et al. Cytokinin growth responses in Arabidopsis involve the 26S proteasome subunit RPN12. Plant Cell 2002; 14:17–32.
Vogel JP, Schuerman P, Woeste K, Brandstatter I, Kieber JJ . Isolation and characterization of Arabidopsis mutants defective in the induction of ethylene biosynthesis by cytokinin. Genetics 1998; 149:417–427.
Lee DJ, Kim S, Ha YM, Kim J . Phosphorylation of Arabidopsis response regulator 7 (ARR7) at the putative phospho-accepting site is required for ARR7 to act as a negative regulator of cytokinin signaling. Planta 2008; 227:577–587.
Murashige T, Skoog F . A revised medium for rapid growth and bioassays with tobacco tissue culture. Physiol Plant 1962; 15:473–497.
Clough SJ, Bent AF . Floral dip: a simplified method for Agrobacterium-mediated transformation of Arabidopsis thaliana. Plant J 1998; 16:735–743.
Sun J, Niu QW, Tarkowski P, et al. The Arabidopsis AtIPT8/PGA22 gene encodes an isopentenyl transferase that is involved in de novo cytokinin biosynthesis. Plant Physiol 2003; 131:167–176.
Feng H, Chen Q, Feng J, et al. Functional characterization of the Arabidopsis eukaryotic translation initiation factor 5A-2 that plays a crucial role in plant growth and development by regulating cell division, cell growth, and cell death. Plant Physiol 2007; 144:1531–1545.
We thank Dr Joe Kieber (University of North Carolina, USA) and the Arabidopsis Biological Resource Center (Ohio State University) for providing seeds. We thank Dr Shuhua Yang (China Agricultural University) for critically reading the manuscript. This work was supported by grants from the National Natural Science Foundation of China (90817107), the Ministry of Science and Technology of China (2007CB948203) and Chinese Academy of Sciences (KSCX2-YW-N-015).
Primary root length of type-A ARR-OX transgenic plants. (PDF 77 kb)
The flowering phenotype of the type-A ARR-OX plants. (PDF 62 kb)
Reduced cytokinin sensitivity of type-A ARR-OX plants in the inhibition of primary root elongation. (PDF 81 kb)
Root xylem development in ARR-OX and arr3,4,5,6,8,9 mutant plants. (PDF 98 kb)
In vitro shoot formation of type-A ARR-OX hypocotyl explants. (PDF 98 kb)
Analysis of A RR4-MYC and AR R5-MYC proteins. (PDF 72 kb)
Stability of ARR-MYC proteins is regulated by cytokinin and MG132. (PDF 142 kb)
Primers used in this study (PDF 26 kb)
About this article
Cite this article
Ren, B., Liang, Y., Deng, Y. et al. Genome-wide comparative analysis of type-A Arabidopsis response regulator genes by overexpression studies reveals their diverse roles and regulatory mechanisms in cytokinin signaling. Cell Res 19, 1178–1190 (2009). https://doi.org/10.1038/cr.2009.88
- protein stability
- type-A ARR
Transcriptome analysis revealed the regulation of gibberellin and the establishment of photosynthetic system promote rapid seed germination and early growth of seedling in pearl millet
Biotechnology for Biofuels (2021)
Plant Cell Reports (2021)
Plant Methods (2020)
Integrating transcriptomic and metabolomic analysis of hormone pathways in Acer rubrum during developmental leaf senescence
BMC Plant Biology (2020)
Cell Research (2019)