Abstract
In December 2006, the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) sponsored a 2-day workshop on “Interpretation of Epidemiologic Studies of Multipollutant Exposure and Health Effects” in Chapel Hill, NC. The final session at this workshop was devoted to assessing the biological plausibility of epidemiological findings with regard to criteria air pollutants. The presentations and the panel contributions of this last session primarily focused on controlled exposure studies and led to wide-ranging discussions, some of which were provocative. The panel summary provides some guidance to future evaluations of the biological plausibility of the epidemiological reports on criteria pollutants and is intended to stimulate thinking, without drawing any definitive conclusions. This paper does not approach, nor was it intended to approach, the more formal analytical approach such as that used in EPA's development of its Science Assessment Document for the criteria pollutants.
This is a preview of subscription content, access via your institution
Access options
Subscribe to this journal
Receive 6 print issues and online access
$259.00 per year
only $43.17 per issue
Rent or buy this article
Prices vary by article type
from$1.95
to$39.95
Prices may be subject to local taxes which are calculated during checkout
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Adams W.C. Comparison of chamber 6.6-h exposures to 0.04–0.08 ppm ozone via square-wave and triangular profiles on pulmonary responses. Inhal Toxicol 2006a: 18: 127–136.
Adams W.C. Human pulmonary responses with 30-min time intervals of exercise and rest when exposed for 8 h to 0.12 ppm ozone via square-wave and acute triangular profiles. Inhal Toxicol 2006b: 18: 413–422.
Anderson K.R., Avol E.L., Edwards S.A., Shamoo D.A., Peng R-C, Linn W.S., and Hackney J.D. Controlled exposure of volunteers to respirable carbon and sulfuric acid aerosols. J Air Waste Manage Assoc 1992: 42: 770–776.
Avissar N.E., Reed C.K., Cox C., Frampton M.W., and Finkelstein J.N. Ozone, but not NO2, exposures decreases glutathione peroxidases in epithelial lining fluid of human lung. Am J Resp Crit Care Med 2000: 162: 1342–1347.
Ballinger C.A., Cueto R., Squadrito G., Connor L.M., Coffin J.J., Velsor L.W., Pryor W.A., and Postlethwait E.M. Antioxidant-mediated augmentation of ozone-induced membrane oxidation. Free Radic Biol Med 2005: 38: 515–526.
Balmes J.R., Aris R.M., Chen L.L., Scannell C., Tager I.B., Finkbeiner W., Christian D., Kelly T., Hearne P.Q., Ferrando R., and Welch B. Effects of Ozone on Normal and Potentially Sensitive Human Subjects. Part I: Airway Inflammation and Responsiveness to Ozone in Normal and Asthmatic Subjects, Health Effects Institute, Cambridge, MA, 1997 Research report no. 78; pp 1–37, 81-99.
Balmes J.R., Chen L.L., Scannell C., Tager I., Christian D., Hearne P.Q., Kelly T., and Aris R.M. Ozone-induced decrements in FEV1 and FVC do not correlate with measures of inflammation. Am J Respir Crit Care Med 1996: 153: 904–909.
Brown J.S., Wilson W.E., and Grant L.D. Dosimetric comparison of particle deposition and retention in rats and humans. Inhal Toxicol 2005: 17: 355–385.
Connor L.M., Ballinger C.A., Albrecht T.A., and Postlethwait E.M. Interfacial phospholipid monolayers inhibit ozone absorption and reduced cytotoxicity in vitro. Am J Physiol Lung Cell Mol Physiol 2004: 286: L1169–L1178.
El-Fawal H.A., McGovern T., and Schlesinger RB Nonspecific bronchial responsiveness assessed in vitro following acute inhalation exposure to ozone and ozone/sulfuric acid mixtures. Exp Lung Res 1995: 21 (1): 129–139.
Foster W.M., Silver J.A., and Groth M.L. Exposure to ozone alters regional function and particle dosimetry in the human lung. J Appl Physiol 1993: 75: 1938–1945.
Gardner D.E., Miller F.J., Illing J.W., and Kirtz J.M. Increased infectivity with exposure to ozone and sulfuric acid. Toxicol Lett 1977: 1 (2): 59–64.
Gilliland F.D., Li Y.F., Gong Jr H., and Diaz-Sanchez D. Glutathione S-transferases M1 and P1 prevent aggravation of allergic responses by secondhand smoke. Am J Respir Crit Care Med 2006: 174 (12): 1335–1341.
Grievink L., Zijlstra A.G., and Brunekreef B. intervention trial on modulation of ozone effects on pulmonary function by antioxidant supplements. Am J Epidemiol 1999: 15: 306–314.
Harkema J.R., Keeler G., Wagner J., Morishita M., Timm E., Hotchkiss J., Marsik F., Dvonch T., Kaminski N., and Barr E. Effects of concentrated ambient particles on normal and hypersecretory airways in rats. Res Rep Health Eff Inst 2004: 120: 1–79.
Hazucha M.J., Folinsbee L.J., and Bromberg P.A. Distribution and reproducibility of spirometric response to ozone by gender and age. J Appl Physiol 2003: 95: 1917–1925.
Hazucha M.J., Folinsbee LJ, and Seal Jr E Effects of steady-state and variable ozone concentration profiles on pulmonary function. Am Rev Respir Dis 1992: 146: 1487–1493.
Holz O., Jörres R.A., Timm P., Mücke M., Richter K., Koschyk S., and Magnussen H. Ozone-induced airway inflammatory changes differ between individuals and are reproducible. Am J Respir Crit Care Med 1999: 159: 776–784.
Holz O., Tal-Singer R., Kanniess F., Simpson K.J., Gibson A., Vessey R.S., Janicki S., Magnussen H., Jörres R.A., and Richter K. Validation of the human ozone challenge model as a tool for assessing anti-inflammatory drugs in early development. J Clin Pharmacol 2005: 45: 498–503.
Horstman D.H., Ball B.A., Brown J., Gerrity T., and Folinsbee L.J. Comparison of pulmonary responses of asthmatic and nonasthmatic subjects performing light exercise while exposed to a low level of ozone. Toxicol Ind Health 1995: 11: 369–385.
Hwang J.S., Nadziejko C., and Chen L.C. Effects of subchronic exposures to concentrated ambient particles (CAPs) in mice. III. Acute and chronic effects of CAPs on heart rate, heart-rate fluctuation, and body temperature. Inhal Toxicol 2005: 17 (4–5): 199–207.
Jenkins H.S., Devalia J.L., Mister R.L., Bevan A.M., Rusznak C., and Davies R.J. The effect of exposure to ozone and nitrogen dioxide on the airway response of atopic asthmatics to inhaled allergen. Am J Respir Crit Care Med 1999: 60: 33–39.
Kleinman M.T., and Phalen R.F. Toxicological interactions in the respiratory system after inhalation of ozone and sulfuric acid aerosol mixtures. Inhal Toxicol 2006: 18: 295–303.
Lippmann M., Gordon T., and Chen L.C. Effects of subchronic exposures to concentrated ambient particles in mice. IX. Integral assessment and human health implications of subchronic exposures of mice to CAPs. Inhal Toxicol 2005: 17 (4–5): 255–261.
Madden M.C., Richards J., Dailey L.A., Hatch G., and Ghio A.J. Effect of ozone on diesel exhaust particle toxicity in rat lung. Toxicol Appl Pharmacol 2000: 168: 140–148.
Martin-Gallan P., Carrascosa A., Gossinye M., and Dominguez C. Estimation of lipoperoxidative damage and antioxidant status in diabetic children: relationship with individual antioxidants. Free Radic Res 2005: 39: 933–942.
McDonnell W.F. Individual variability in human lung function responses to ozone exposure. Environ Toxicol Pharmacol 1996: 2: 171–175.
McDonnell W.F., Stewart P.W., and Smith M.V. The temporal dynamics of ozone-induced FEV1 changes in humans: an exposure–response model. Inhal Toxicol 2007: 19 (6): 483–494.
Meng Z. Oxidative damage of sulfur dioxide on various organs of mice: sulfur dioxide is a systemic oxidative damage agent. Inhal Toxicol 2003: 15: 181–195.
Miller F.J., Schlosser P.M., and Janszen D.B. Haber's rule: a special case in a family of curves relating concentration and duration of exposure to a fixed level of response for a given endpoint. Toxicology 2000: 149: 21–34.
Morishita M., Keeler G., Wagner J., Marsik F., Timm E., Dvonch J., and Harkema J. Pulmonary retention of particulate matter is associated with airway inflammation in allergic rats exposed to air pollution in urban Detroit. Inhal Toxicol 2004: 16 (10): 663–674.
Mudway I.S., Behndig A.F., Helleday R., Pourazar J., Frew A.J., Kelly F.J., and Blomberg A. Vitamin supplementation does not protect against symptoms in ozone-responsive subjects. Free Radic Biol Med 2006: 40 (10): 1702–1712.
O'Neill C.A., van der Vliet A., Eiserich J.P., Last J.A., Halliwell B., and Cross C.E. Oxidative damage by ozone and nitrogen dioxide: synergistic toxicity in vivo but no evidence of synergistic oxidative damage in an extracellular fluid. Biochem Soc Symp 1995: 61: 139–152.
Pryor W.A. Can Vitamin E protect humans against the pathological effects of ozone in smog? Am J Clin Nutr 1991: 53: 702–722.
Romieu I., Sienra-Monge J.J., Ramírez-Aguilar M., Moreno-Macias H., Reyes-Ruiz N.I., Estela del Rio-Navarro B., Hernández-Avila M., and London S.J. Genetic polymorphism of GSTM1 and antioxidant supplementation influence lung function in relation to ozone exposure in asthmatic children in Mexico City. Thorax 2004: 59: 8–10.
Rusznak C., Devalia J.L., and Davies R.J. Airway response of asthmatic subjects to inhaled allergen after exposure to pollutants. Thorax 1996: 51: 1105–1108.
Slade R., Crissman K., Norwood J., and Hatch G. Comparison of antioxidant substances in bronchoalveolar lavage cells and fluid form humans, guinea pigs, and rats. Exp Lung Res 1993: 19: 469–484.
Stenfors N., Pourazar J., Blomberg A., Krishna M.T., Mudway I., Helleday R., Kelly F.J., Frew A.J., and Sandström T. Effect of ozone on bronchial mucosal inflammation in asthmatic and healthy subjects. Respir Med 2002: 96: 352–358.
Trenga C.A., Koenig J.Q., and William P.V. Dietary antioxidants ozone-induced bronchial hyperresponsiveness in adults with asthma. Arch Environ Health 2001: 56: 242–249.
Ultman J.S., Ben-Jebria A., and Arnold S.F. Uptake Distribution of Ozone in Human Lungs: Intersubject Variability in Physiologic Response. Health Effects Institute, Boston, MA, 2004. research report no. 125 Available: http://www.healtheffects.org/Pubs/Ultman.pdf [29 July, 2005].
U.S. Environmental Protection Agency. Long-term effects of air pollutants in canine species. EPA-600/8-80-014 1980.
U.S. Environmental Protection Agency. Air quality criteria for oxides of nitrogen. EPA/600/8 91/049cF 1993.
U.S. Environmental Protection Agency. Supplement to the Second Addendum (1986) to air quality criteria for particulate matter and sulfur oxides (1982): assessment of new findings on sulfur dioxide and acute exposure health effects in asthmatic individuals. EPA 600/FP-93/002 1994.
U.S. Environmental Protection Agency. Air quality criteria for particulate matter. EPA/600/P-99/002aF-bF 2004.
U.S. Environmental Protection Agency. Air quality criteria for ozone and related photochemical oxidants. EPA/600/R-05/004aF-cF 2006.
Velsor L.W., Ballinger C.A., Patel J., and Postlethwait E.M. Influence of epithelial lining fluid lipids on NO2-induced membrane oxidation and nitration. Free Radic Biol Med 2003: 34: 720–733.
Wang J., Wang S., Manzer R., McConville G., and Mason R.J. Ozone induces oxidative stress in rat alveolar type II and type I-like cells. Free Radic Biol Med 2006: 40: 1914–1928.
Wellenius G.A., Batalha J.R.F., Diaz E.A., Lawrence J., Coull B.A., Katz T., Verrier R.L., and Godleski J.J. Cardiac effects of carbon monoxide and ambient particles in a rat model of myocardial infarction. Toxicol Sci 2004: 80: 367–376.
Xia T., Kovochich M., and Nel A. The role of reactive oxygen species and oxidative stress in mediating particulate mater injury. Clin Occup Environ Med 2006: 5: 817–836.
Acknowledgements
This work was funded, in part, by the U.S. EPA under purchase order EP07C000038.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Brown, J., Graham, J., Chen, L. et al. Panel discussion review: session four — assessing biological plausibility of epidemiological findings in air pollution research. J Expo Sci Environ Epidemiol 17 (Suppl 2), S97–S105 (2007). https://doi.org/10.1038/sj.jes.7500632
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1038/sj.jes.7500632
Keywords
This article is cited by
-
Using community level strategies to reduce asthma attacks triggered by outdoor air pollution: a case crossover analysis
Environmental Health (2014)
-
Statistical strategies for constructing health risk models with multiple pollutants and their interactions: possible choices and comparisons
Environmental Health (2013)